The Validation and Development of An Integrated Landfill Gas Risk Assessment Model: Gassim
The Validation and Development of An Integrated Landfill Gas Risk Assessment Model: Gassim
The Validation and Development of An Integrated Landfill Gas Risk Assessment Model: Gassim
SUMMARY: The emissions of bulk and trace gases from landfills created either directly from
waste decomposition or from the combustion of landfill gas (LFG) during flaring and/or gas
utilisation, have the potential to impact the global atmosphere, the local environment and expose
humans to potential health risks. The European Directives on Landfill and on Integrated
Pollution Prevention and Control have been incorporated into UK regulations, and GasSim has
been developed for the Environment Agency of England and Wales (the Agency) as a risk
assessment tool to aid in the evaluation of these impacts, and help landfill operators comply with
the new regulations and guidance. GasSim assesses the likelihood of these processes and the
magnitude of the impacts and considers the uncertainty in processes and parameters, using a
Monte Carlo Simulation, in a reproducible manner.
1. INTRODUCTION
There have been a number of drivers behind the development of GasSim. First was the need to
substantiate and quantify the potential human exposure from living near and working on
landfills. Recent research (Elliott et al, 2001; Vrijheid et al, 2002) has indicated a statistical (but
not necessarily causal) relationship between an adverse effect on human health, e.g. birth defects,
and landfill emissions. Second was the need for a management tool to help the UK meet the
Kyoto requirement to reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases to the environment. Methane is
the second most important anthropogenic greenhouse gas, after carbon dioxide, and is emitted
from landfills in significant quantities. Thirdly, the regulatory regime was changing, and a
consistent and auditable approach to LFG management was required.
There are three European Union (EU) Directives, which apply to the generation and
management of landfill gas:
• the European Union Waste Framework Directive (EC, 1991), which requires that waste is
recovered or disposed without using methods that could endanger human health or harm the
environment;
• the Landfill Directive (EC, 1999), which requires waste operators to control the accumulation
and migration of LFG, to collect and flare or utilise LFG from landfills receiving
biodegradable waste, and minimise damage or deterioration of the environment; and
Proceedings Sardinia 2003, Ninth International Waste Management and Landfill Symposium
S. Margherita di Pula, Cagliari, Italy; 6 - 10 October 2003
2003 by CISA, Environmental Sanitary Engineering Centre, Italy
• the Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC) Directive (EC, 1996), which requires
preventative measures are taken against pollution through flaring and utilisation.
These directives, which have been implemented into UK regulations, cover the design,
construction, operation and maintenance of the LFG management systems and require:
• gas management systems to control the migration and release of LFG;
• minimising the contribution to global warming;
• management of odour; and
• reporting of releases of named pollutants (the Pollution Inventory). This requires either
measurement or modelling of gas generation, surface emissions, and combustion plant
emissions, including tracking and reporting the changes to these emissions through time.
The guidance developed for the industry by the Environment Agency (Environment Agency,
2002a), to guide the management of LFG under the new regulations, adopts a risk based
approach coupled with the concept of BAT (best available techniques) (Environment Agency,
2002b), to minimise the impact on:
• health from trace components and combustion products;
• the local environment by odour and vegetation stress; and
• global atmosphere by ozone depletion and global warming.
The risk of these processes occurring has previously been assessed using a mixture of
experience, calculations and computer models. GasSim has therefore been developed to support
the risk assessors’ experience by providing a standard methodology and LFG generation and
emissions management tool for the Environment Agency, landfill operators, gas utilisation plant
operators and consultants.
In order to quantitatively evaluate the risks of these processes and the magnitude of the
impacts, GasSim considers the uncertainty in input parameters using a Monte Carlo Simulation.
Allowing Parameter uncertainty (and to some extent model uncertainty) to be dealt with by
specifying a range of values for each input parameter rather than a single number, using
probability density functions (PDFs). GasSim is designed to aid LFG risk assessment, by
enabling LFG generation, emissions, migration/dispersion and impact/exposure to be assessed in
a reproducible manner by those familiar with the subject. GasSim was developed from the
Environment Agency’s HELGA research model (Gregory et al., 1999).
2. CONCEPTUAL MODEL
The conceptual model (Figure 1) has a modular structure. Each module incorporates the effects
of additional processes. Progression to successive modules is only necessary if this information
is required, e.g. LFG generation and emissions can be determined without proceeding through
subsequent modules to optimise time and data collection constraints. Time dependency is built
into all modules.
GasSim is divided into 5 main modules (or assessment stages), described in detail below:
• gas generation (the source term);
• gas emissions (fugitive surface and lateral emissions, and combustion plant emissions);
• environmental transport through atmospheric dispersion;
• environmental transport through terrestrial lateral migration; and
• human exposure and other environmental impacts.
Figure 1. The GasSim Conceptual Model.
2.2 Emissions
Emissions from a landfill are normally, but not always, controlled by engineering measures, e.g.
the installation of engineered barriers (cap and liner) and gas collection system. The gas
collected can then be flared or utilised. The GasSim model assumes that any LFG generated and
not collected will be emitted through the landfill cap or lateral liner at a steady state. The
emissions from engines and/or flares are determined from the quantity of gas combusted and:
• the concentration of the species in LFG and/or the combustion emissions; or
• the concentration of a parent species, which reacts to form the emitted species, in LFG; or
• the monitored concentration of the emissions.
GasSim is a steady state model that assumes that all the gas generated is emitted by some
pathway or another. This gas will be either collected and used by flares and/or engines or lost
through fugitive surface or lateral emissions. Surface emissions are determined by combining
the fugitive emissions from the completed (capped) and operational (uncapped) areas. This
differentiation is made since GasSim assumes that gas generated from the uncapped area is
emitted directly through the surface, without methane oxidation. It is assumed the open surface
of the waste will be far more permeable that the sides of the landfill, which may or may not be
engineered. The surface emissions from the uncapped areas are calculated using the percentage
of the uncapped area and the gas generation rate. For the engineered surfaces, the proportion of
emissions lost laterally through the side liner, compared to the proportion lost through the capped
surface is calculated and partitioned using the permeability, thickness and unsaturated surface
area of the most impervious layers of each. GasSim assumes that gas movement is via plug flow
and that both the cap and liner are homogenous and isotropic, even though in practice poor
cap/liner construction and maintenance can result in cracks and micro-fractures. Although these
may be locally important, their net effect on the emissions will be averaged out across the site.
GasSim also allows the option to reduce the emissions of methane through the cap by
biological methane oxidation by simulating the quantity of emission that pass though that cap
(and are subject to oxidative processes) compared to that which passes unoxidised through
fissures. The model allows the use of the IPCC methodology (IPCC 1996a, 1996b), or a user
defined approach where the emissions through the cap are reduced by a user defined or default
percentage if a sufficiently oxidative thickness of soil is present above the cap, and the flux is
less than the methane oxidising capacity of the microbial population. The amount of fissuring of
the cap can be specifically modelled.
GasSim simulates the surface and lateral emission of trace gases using the concentration of
the species per m3 of LFG and the LFG emission rate, by proportioning the quantity of trace gas
generated along the same lines as the as the bulk gases.
2.4.5 Exposure
Exposure to humans is determined for a number of set scenarios:
• Residential with plant uptake;
• Residential without plant uptake;
• Allotments;
• Commercial & Industrial; and
• Worker exposure.
Each of these exposure scenarios has a defined number of exposure pathways, exposure
algorithms, and exposure factors based on a member of the critical group, and each contaminant
considered has a contaminant specific set of physico-chemical properties associated with it.
GasSim primarily undertakes this exposure assessment following the approach used in the
CLEA model (Environment Agency and DEFRA, 2002), with some minor modifications.
3. MODEL VALIDATION
In order for any model to be used with confidence, it is essential that it can represent reality.
Therefore a series of verification and validation trials were undertaken. Verification comprised
comparison of the GasSim source term against other gas production models (HELGA: Gregory
et al., 1999, and LandGem: Pelt et al, 1998). When it was shown that GasSim produced good
replication of the outputs from these models, it was time to compare GasSim forecasts with other
landfills where data had been collected by different means (validation).
Observed
range
The bulk LFG surface emissions module predicts that the average net surface emissions after
allowing for LFG collection and biological methane oxidation for this unnamed UK landfill lies
between 10-1 mg.m2.s-1 and 10-3 mg.m2.s-1, for both scenarios. The values are slightly higher
than those reported in the HELGA framework. However, these values are within the range
observed for similar sites reported in the HELGA framework (10-4 – 1 mg.m2.s-1) depending on
the methodology used to determine the emissions (Gregory et al. 1999).
GasSim does overestimate the emissions of VOCs at this site. The 5th percentile of the GasSim
emissions forecasts occur at a similar order of magnitude as the maximum observed emissions.
This is believed to be due to differences between the conceptual models in GasSim and the
processes taking place at Green Valley. GasSim does not simulate compositional changes in
VOCs in the soil cap by microbiological and other processes, as discussed by Bogner et al.
(1997) whilst Bogner et al (1997) have limited data from high emission point sources, e.g.
fissures.
The GasSim model was designed to allow the risks from LFG to be assessed during both at the
planning, operational and post operational stages of a landfill stages to serve a number of
purposes:
• to aid decision making;
• to manage the environmental impact on local receptors, by allowing the optimisation of
different capping designs and flare/gas engine combinations; and
• to perform quantitative assessment of the exposure impact to humans, vegetation, the global
atmosphere, and the extent of odour releases.
The landfill can be simulated using a limited amount of site-specific data, with uncertainties in
the data sets modelled using PDFs and Monte Carlo simulation. Generic data are provided,
which cover information that individual site operators are unlikely to have, e.g. for trace gas
concentrations, destruction efficiencies of flares and gas engines, and composition of different
waste streams.
The verification trails have demonstrated that the GasSim model produces results that agree
with other models, namely LandGem and the equations used in HELGA framework. The initial
validation trails are encouraging with the source and emissions modules simulating gas
production in accordance with reality.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
GasSim was developed by Golder Associates and Land Quality Management Ltd for The
Environment Agency of England and Wales. This paper is produced with permission. The views
expressed in this paper are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the Agency.
This paper also helps us celebrate the life of Gary Attenborough (20 April 1971 – 28 October
2002). Four months after the release of GasSim, Gary suffered a fatal heart attack at the age of
31. Gary was a key technical contributor, and all who knew him and worked with him knew the
drive and enthusiasm he put into his work. He remains in our memories.
REFERENCES
Bognor J., Spokas K., Niemann M., Neimann L., and Baker J., (1997) Emissions of non-methane
organic compounds at the Illinois (USA) landfill site: preliminary field measurements.
Proceedings Sardinia 97, Sixth International Landfill Symposium, CISA, Cagliari, 127 – 138.
Christophersen, M., and Kjeldsen, P. (2001) Lateral gas transport in soil adjacent to an old
landfill: factors governing gas migration. Waste Management and Research, 19, 144 – 159.
EC, 1991, Council Directive 75/442/EEC on waste, as amended by Council Directive
91/156/EEC concerning The Framework Directive on Waste. Official Journal of the European
Communities.
EC, 1996. “Council Directive 96/61/EC of 24 September 1996 concerning Integrated Pollution
Prevention and Control”. Official Journal of the European Communities.
EC, 1999. “Council Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the landfill of waste”. Official
Journal of the European Communities.
Elliott P., Morris S., Briggs D., de Hoogh C., Hurt C., Jensen T.K., Maitland I., Lewin A.,
Richardson S., Wakefield J., and Jarup L., 2001. Birth outcomes and selected cancers in
populations living near landfill sites. Report to Department of Health by the Small Area
Health Statistics Unit, Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, Imperial College,
London.
Environment Agency, 2002a, The Management of Landfill Gas. Environment Agency, draft for
consultation, November 2002.
Environment Agency, 2002b, Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC).
Environmental Assessment and Appraisal of BAT. Horizontal Guidance Note IPPC H1.
Environment Agency, draft 3.1 for consultation, July 2002.
Environment Agency, 2002c, LandSim, Landfill Performance Simulation by Monte Carlo
Simulation. Environment Agency R&D Publication 120.
Environment Agency and DEFRA, 2002, The contaminated land exposure assessment model
(CLEA): Technical basis and algorithms. Environment Agency R&D Publication CLR10.
Gregory R.G., Revans A.J., Hill M.D., Meadows M.P., Paul L. and Ferguson C.C., 1999,
A framework to assess the risks to human health and the environment from landfill gas.
Environment Agency Technical Report P271.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 1996a. Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines for National
Greenhouse Gas Inventories: Reference Manual, Chapter 6.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 1996b. IPCC Expert Group on Waste, Topical
Workshop on Carbon Conversion and Methane Oxidation in Solid Waste Disposal Sites,
Argonne National Laboratory, Chicago, USA, 25 October 1996.
NRPB, 1995. Methodology for assessing the radiological consequences of routine releases of
radionuclides to the environment, Report EUR 15760, Luxembourg, European Commission.
Pelt R., White C., Blackard A., Bass R. L., and Burklin C., and Heaton R. E., 1998, User's
Manual Landfill Gas Emissions Model, USEPA Contract 68-D1-0117, EPA.
Scott, P.E., Crozier, F., Birch, C., and Leach, A. (1998). Investigations into odour problems at
Nant-y-Gwyddon landfill, South East Wales. Entec Report 97194 to the Environment Agency.
Vrijheid M., Dolk H., Armstrong B., Abramsky L., Bianchi F., Fazarinc I., Garne E., Ide R.,
Nelen V., Robert E., Scott J.E.S., Stone D. and Tenconi R. (2002). Chromosomal congenital
anomalies and residence near hazardous waste landfill sites. The Lancet, 359, 320-322.
Williams, G.M., Ward G., and Noy D.H. (1999). Dynamics of landfill gas migration in
unconsolidated sands. Waste Management and Research 17, 327 – 342.