Student Name:: Page 1 Should Be Completed by The Student or Committee Chairman Prior To Distribution To Committee
Student Name:: Page 1 Should Be Completed by The Student or Committee Chairman Prior To Distribution To Committee
Student Name:: Page 1 Should Be Completed by The Student or Committee Chairman Prior To Distribution To Committee
Circle One: Master’s Thesis Proposal Master’s Thesis Defense Dissertation Proposal Dissertation Defense
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
At the conclusion of the presentation/defense, each committee member should fill out the response sheet. For each attribute which a committee member feels is
somewhat or very deficient, a short explanation should be provided. Confidential Comment sections at the bottom of the rubric are provided for explanations of
the reasoning behind the overall evaluation of the examinee’s performance if desired. Completed forms are to be treated as confidential and are to be turned in to
the Director of Graduate Studies, not the student.
A summary of written comments from the committee members WILL be provided to the student by the chair of the examining committee. A verbal summary of
the overall evaluation of the student’s performance WILL also be provided to the student by that individual.
All examination documents (rubrics and written comments) must be completed regardless of the outcome of the presentation or defense.
A copy of the completed forms (both rubrics and written comments) must be sent to the Director of Graduate Studies within 48 hours of the conclusion of the
Page 1
EXAMPLE: Adopted from University of Maryland – College Park, 2013 Rubric for PhD Milestones
Student Name:
Page 2
EXAMPLE: Adopted from University of Maryland – College Park, 2013 Rubric for PhD Milestones
Student Name:
Page 3
EXAMPLE: Adopted from University of Maryland – College Park, 2013 Rubric for PhD Milestones
Student Name:
Summary of written comments from ALL committee members for student concerning performance on proposal presentation / defense:
Page 4
EXAMPLE: Adopted from University of Maryland – College Park, 2013 Rubric for PhD Milestones