A Simple Structure of Zero-Voltage Switching Zero Current Switching Buck Converter
A Simple Structure of Zero-Voltage Switching Zero Current Switching Buck Converter
A Simple Structure of Zero-Voltage Switching Zero Current Switching Buck Converter
http://dx.doi.org/10.6113/JPE.2015.15.6.1480
JPE 15-6-7 ISSN(Print): 1598-2092 / ISSN(Online): 2093-4718
Abstract
In this paper, a revolutionary buck converter is proposed with soft-switching technology, which is realized by a coupled inductor.
Both zero-voltage switching (ZVS) of main switch and zero-current switching (ZCS) of freewheeling diode are achieved at turn on
and turn off without using any auxiliary circuits by the resonance between the parasitic capacitor and the coupled inductor.
Furthermore, the peak voltages of the main switch and the peak current of the freewheeling diode are significantly reduced by the
coupled inductor. As a result, the proposed converter has the advantages of simple circuit, convenient control, low consumption and
so on. The detailed operation principles and steady-state analysis of the proposed ZVS-ZCS buck converter are presented, and
detailed power loss analysis and some simulation results are also included. Finally, experimental results based on a 200-W prototype
are provided to verify the theory and design of the proposed converter.
Key words: Buck converter, Coupled inductor, Soft switching, Zero-current switching (ZCS), Zero-voltage switching (ZVS)
1482 Journal of Power Electronics, Vol. 15, No. 6, November 2015
condition, and the current of the coupled inductor L1 reaches di1 di2
maximum value, i.e., iS = i1 = I1max. At the same time, the u L1 L1 dt M dt (4)
freewheeling diode D1 turns on automatically under a ZCS di di
u L 2 L2 2 M 1
condition. After t0, the coupled inductor L1 discharges, and i1 dt dt .
starts decreasing from I1max, while the coupled inductor L2, By substituting (4) into (3), the slopes of i1 and i2 are
parasitic capacitor Cr charge, i2, and uCr increase from zero. At derived as follows:
t1, iS drops to zero, and i1 and i2 are equal to It1.The voltage
di1 di2 Vo (5)
across Cr reaches steady value, and the charging is completed. k
According to Magnetism Chain Conservation Theorem, this
dt dt L1 L2 2M .
process can have The slope of the filter inductor current of the conventional
L1I1max L1 L2 2M I t1 (1) buck converter in this interval is equal to
A Simple Structure of ... 1483
interval. At t2, i1 and i2 are equal to zero. It provides a uL1 Vin Vo . (16)
necessary condition for the freewheeling diode D1 turned off
Then, the slope of i1 can be obtained as follows:
under a ZCS condition. After t2, the parasitic capacitor Cr
Vin Vo L1
discharges through coupled inductor L1, and i1 changes its di1
k (17)
direction and is equal to iS. At t3, i1 reaches negative maximum dt .
value. Then, i1 starts to decline negatively until the voltage uCr
At the same time, the voltage uL2 across coupled inductor L2
drops to zero at t4.
can be derived as follows:
Let us make an assumption that the output capacitor C1 is
Vin Vo .
di1 M
large enough, or the output voltage Vo is constant. Based on uL2 M (18)
KCL and KVL, we can obtain dt L1
According to KVL, the voltage uD1 of the freewheeling
iS i1
(9) diode can be written as follows:
Vin uCr uL1 Vo .
The current equation of coupled inductor L1 and the voltage
uD1 uL2 uL1 Vo
M
Vin Vo Vin . (19)
L1
equation of parasitic capacitor Cr can be expressed as follows: 5) Mode 5 [t5-t6, Fig. 3(e)]: The switch S1 is turned on, and
duCr the current i1 is negative in this interval. Before t5, the current
iS C r dt i1 flows through anti-parallel diode DS, and the voltage uCr of
(10)
the parasitic capacitor Cr is equal to zero. Therefore, a ZVS
u L di1
condition of the switch S1 turned on can be obtained at t5.
L1 1
dt .
After t5, it is the same as Mode 4, except that i1 flows through
Combining (9) and (10), the following resonant equation switch S1. The current i1 decreases negatively with the
can be written as follows:
slope Vin Vo L1 until it reaches zero at t6.
d 2uCr
L1Cr uCr Vin Vo (11) 6) Mode 6 [t6-t0, Fig. 3(f)]: The switch S1 is turned on, and
dt 2 . the current i1 is positive in this interval. At t6, the current i1
The initial conditions of the resonant circuit at t2 are i1 = 0, changes its direction. After t6, this mode is the same as Mode 4
L2 M and Mode 5, except that the current i1 is positive. Then, i1
and uCr Vin Vo . Some assumptions are increases linearly with the slope Vin Vo L1 until switch S1
L1 L2 2M
turns off at t0. At the end of this mode, the next operating cycle
made in this interval as follows:
begins.
0 1 L1Cr (12)
1484 Journal of Power Electronics, Vol. 15, No. 6, November 2015
TABLE I
RELATED SPECIFICATIONS OF THE PROPOSED CONVERTER
Parameters Values
Input voltage Vin 48V
Output voltage Vo 32V
Output power Po 200W
Switching period TS 20μs
Couple inductor L1 5μH
Couple inductor L2 5μH
Fig. 4. ZVS condition analyses particularly.
parasitic capacitor Cr 440nF
However, to obtain ZVS conditions of the switch S1, the filter capacitor C1 220μF
switch S1 must be turned on between t4 and t6, as shown in Fig.
4.
completed, and the voltage conversion ratio MD and turn ratio
According to the voltage across parasitic capacitor Cr in
N are constant, it can be chosen a large resonant capacitor Cr
equation (15), t4 can be obtained as follows:
to increase ΔT. But at the same time, the current i1 at t3 is
1 1 Vin Vo
-U0/Z0, which also increases. As a matter of fact, we expect to
t4 cos t2 (23)
0 U0
.
decrease the value of i1 at t3. Hence, the volume of Cr must be
appropriate. The specific values and others parameter values
Then, we can obtain are shown in Table I.
U 0 V V
It4 sin cos1 in o
Z0 U0 IV. SIMULATION ANALYSIS
1
U 0 Vin Vo
2 2 A. Soft Switching Waveforms of Simulation
(24)
Z0 To illustrate the operation of the proposed ZVS-ZCS buck
.
converter, it has been accomplished through a simulation with
where It4 is the current iS at t4.
Multisim software. Using the parameters in Table I, the
Consequently, ΔT that is between t4 and t6 can be derived as
soft-switching waveforms are obtained, in which the turn ratio
follows:
N is equal to 1, as shown in Fig. 5.
2
1 U0 The resonant circuit, which consists of the coupled inductor
T 1 (25) L1 and parasitic capacitor Cr, provides a necessary condition
0 Vin Vo . for switch S1 turned on under a ZVS condition. Furthermore,
the ZVS condition of switch S1 turned off is obtained by the
B. Design of the Proposed Circuits
parasitic capacitor Cr, as shown in Fig. 5(a). Since the
As presented in formula (22), the coupled inductor L1 must proposed converter works under DCM, the current i2 is equal
be chosen a small one to satisfy it. However, to achieve ZVS to zero at the freewheeling diode D1 both turned on and turned
better, it demands ΔT as long as possible. off. Therefore, the ZCS conditions of the freewheeling diode
The voltage conversion ratio MD is the ratio of the output to D1 that is turned on and turned off are achieved, as shown in
the input voltage of the converter, and can be obtained under Fig. 5(b). The voltage uL1 and current i1 of coupled inductor L1
DCM as follows: are supplied in Fig. 5(c).
M D Vo Vin
B. Analysis of Power Losses
2
(26) The power losses of the proposed ZVS-ZCS buck converter
2 1 N 1 N 1 N 4 K D
2 2 2
can be divided into three segments, i.e., switch losses, diode
.
losses, and others. When the turn ratio N is equal to 1, power
Thus, the equation (25) can be simplified as follows:
losses at different output power are shown in Fig. 6. As we can
2
1 MD see in the figure, the main factors that affect the total
T 1 (27) efficiency of the proposed converter are the switch and diode
0 1 M D 1 N . losses.
As we can see in equation (27), the ΔT is closely related to As shown in Fig. 5(a), the switch losses are closely related
ω0, i.e., the coupled inductor L1 and resonant capacitor Cr. to the voltage uCr, i.e., the switch losses will decrease as the
Therefore, when the design of the coupled inductor L1 is voltage uCr declines and when the switch S1 turns off. The
A Simple Structure of ... 1485
NM D
uCr_N 1 (29)
1 N .
Similarly, Fig. 5(b) shows that the diode losses will reduce
as the current i2 declines at freewheeling diode D1 turned on
moment. The maximum value I1max of the current i1 at t0 can be
derived under hard-switching conditions as follows:
I1 max DTS Vin Vo L1 (30)
.
(a) Therefore, the current i2 of coupled inductor L2 at t1 in
equation (2) can be simplified as follows:
Vin Vo
I t1 DT . (31)
1 N 2 L1 S
Normalized Current It1_N is defined as
1 MD
I t1 _ N D. (32)
1 N 2
The contours of uCr_N and It1_N are shown in Fig. 7(a) and
(b) (b), respectively, in which K is constant value. The x axis
represents the duty cycle D, and the y axis represents the turn
ratio N. As shown in Fig. 7, the increase of duty cycle D
results in a decrease of uCr_N. However, It1_N increases first,
then decreases, while uCr_N and It1_N will both decrease as the
turn ratio N increases. In Fig. 8, the switch losses and
freewheeling diode losses are presented with different turn
ratio N at diverse output power, respectively. Both the switch
losses and freewheeling diode losses can be decreased by
increasing the turn ratio N. Hence, the total power losses can
(c) be decreased by increasing the turn ratio N, i.e., the overall
Fig. 5. The soft switching waveforms of simulation. (a) ZVS efficiency of the proposed converter can be improved this
conditions of switch S1 (magnification: voltage is 0.5 and current way.
is 1). (b) ZCS conditions of freewheeling diode D1 (magnification:
voltage is 0.2 and current is 1). (c) The voltage and current of C. Evaluation of Output Voltage
coupled inductor L1 (magnification: voltage is 0.833 and current
The ripple of output voltage Vo, an important index to
is 1).
evaluate the performance of proposed buck converter, is
affected by the slopes of i1 and i2 when the freewheeling diode
D1 turns on. The equation (5) can be simplified as follows:
Vo
k (33)
1 N 2 L1
In any case, the value of coupled inductor L1 is so small that
the current i1 can be negative. Hence, the ripple of output
voltage also closely associates with the current i1. At t3, the
negative maximum of the current i1 is
L1 M Vo Vo
I t3 (34)
Fig. 6. Power losses of the proposed converter. L1 L2 2 M Z 0 1 N Z 0
voltage of parasitic capacitor Cr in equation (8) can be According to the couple of equations above, when the
simplified as follows: coupled inductor L1, parasitic capacitor Cr, and output voltage
1 Vo are constant, |k| and |It3| will both decrease as turn ratio N
uCr Vin Vo (28) increases. That is to say, the ripple of Vo can be decreased by
11 N .
increasing turn ratio N. In Table II, the ripples of Vo are
The normalized parameter uCr_N is presented at different turn ratio N by simulation.
1486 Journal of Power Electronics, Vol. 15, No. 6, November 2015
(a) (b)
Fig. 7. Contour graphs of the proposed converter. (a) uCr_N contour graph. (b) It1_N contour graph.
(a) (b)
Fig. 8. Switch and freewheeling diode losses of the proposed converter. (a) Switch losses. (b) Freewheeling diode losses.
TABLE II
RIPPLE OF OUTPUT VOLTAGE AT DIFFERENT TURN RATIO
Turn ratio N Ripple of Vo /mV
1 301
2 215
3 173
4 156
A Simple Structure of ... 1487
(a) (b) (c)
Fig. 11. Experimental waveforms at light load. (a) ZVS conditions of switch S1 (current iS: 5A/div. and voltage uCr: 20V/div.). (b) ZCS
conditions of freewheeling diode D1 (current i2: 2A/div. and voltage uD1: 20V/div.). (c) The voltage and current of coupled inductor L1
(current i1: 5A/div. and voltage uL1: 20V/div.).
(a) (b) (c)
Fig. 12. The experimental waveforms at full load. (a) ZVS conditions of switch S1 (current iS: 10A/div. and voltage uCr: 20V/div.). (b)
ZCS conditions of freewheeling diode D1 (current i2: 10A/div. and voltage uD1: 20V/div.). (c) The voltage and current of coupled
inductor L1 (current i1: 10A/div. and voltage uL1: 10V/div.).
B. Efficiency
The efficiency curves of the buck converters are shown in
Fig. 13. As we can observe in the figure, the overall efficiency
values of the proposed buck converter are relatively high with
respect to those of the rest buck converters. Moreover, the
efficiency reaches 97.3% at full load. The figure also shows
that even at light load (about 10% of the full power) the
measured efficiency is as high as 91%.
Fig. 13. Measured efficiency.
1488 Journal of Power Electronics, Vol. 15, No. 6, November 2015
[1] M. Jabbari, “Unified analysis of switched-resonator Xinxin Wei was born in Henan, China. He
converters,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., Vol. 26, No. 5, pp. received his B.S. degree in Electronics
1364-1376, May 2011. Engineering from Zhongyuan University of
[2] I. Aksoy, H. Bodur and A. F. Bakan, “A new Technology, Zhengzhou, China in 2013. He is
ZVT-ZCT-PWM DC-DC converter,” IEEE Trans. Power currently a postgraduate student in the School
Electron., Vol. 25, No. 8, pp. 2093-2105, Aug. 2011. of Electronics Engineering, Chongqing
[3] M. Jabbari and H. Farzanehfard, “New resonant University. His research interest area is power
step-down/up converters,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., electronics in general, especially the analysis
Vol. 25, No. 1, pp. 249-256, Jan. 2010. and design of switching power converters, high-frequency power
[4] E. Adib and H. Farzanehfard, “Family of zero-current conversion and soft-switching converters.
transition PWM converters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., Vol.
55, No. 8, pp. 3055-3063, Aug. 2008. Ciyong Luo was born in Anhui in 1973. He
[5] S. Urgun, “Zero-voltage transition-zero-current transition received his B.S and M.S degrees in
pulse width modulation DC-DC buck converter with Automatic Control and Ph.D. degree in
zero-voltage switching zero-current switching auxiliary Electronics Engineering from Chongqing
circuit,” IET Power Electron., Vol. 5, No. 5, pp. 627-634, University, Chongqing, China, in 1995, 1998,
and 2005, respectively. From January 2011 to
May 2012.
January 2012, he was with the Department of
[6] M. Ilic and D. Maksimovic, “Interleaved
Automatic Control and Systems Engineering,
zero-current-transition buck converter,” IEEE Trans. Ind. University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, as a Visiting Scholar. He is
Appl., Vol. 43, No.6, pp. 1619-1627, Nov. 2007. currently an Associate Professor in the School of Electrical
[7] A. Emrani and H. Farzanehfard, “Zero-current switching Engineering, Chongqing University. His research interests include
resonant buck converters with small inductors,” IET Power the modeling, design, and control of power converters,
Electron., Vol. 5, No. 6, pp. 710-718, Jul. 2012. soft-switching power converters, the modeling and analysis of the
[8] S. Pattnaik, A. K. Panda and K. K. Mahapatra, “Efficiency dynamical behavior of switching DC-DC converters, and
Improvement of Synchronous Buck Converter by Passive power-factor correction circuits.
Auxiliary Circuit,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., Vol. 46, No. 6,
pp. 2511-2517, Nov. 2010. Hang Nan was born in Hubei in 1989. He
[9] P. Das and G. Moschopoulos, “A comparative study of received his B.S. degree in electrical
zero-current transition PWM converters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. engineering from Hubei University of
Electron., Vol. 54, No. 3, pp. 1319-1328, Mar. 2007. Technology, Wuhan, China in 2013. He is
[10] M. R. Amini and H. Farzanehfard, “Switched resonator currently a postgraduate student in the School
DC/DC converter with a single switch and small inductors,” of Electronics Engineering Chongqing
IET Power Electron., Vol. 7, No. 6, pp. 1331-1339, Jan. University. His research interests include the
2014. modulation methods of switching power
[11] C.-Y. Chiang and C.-L. Chen, “Zero-voltage-switching converters, power electronics, and especially, DC-DC converters.
control for a PWM buck converter under DCM/CCM
Yinghao Wang was born in Hebei in 1989.
boundary,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., Vol. 24, No. 9, pp.
He received his B.S. degree in electrical
2120-2126, Sep. 2009. engineering from Chongqing University,
[12] W. Yu, J.-S. Lai, and S.-Y. Park, “An improved zero-voltage Chongqing, China in 2013. He is currently a
switching inverter using two coupled magnetics in one postgraduate student in the School of
resonant pole,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., Vol. 25, No. 4, Electronics Engineering Chongqing
pp. 952-961, Apr. 2010. University. His research interests include the
[13] H.-L. Do, “Zero-voltage-switching synchronous buck modulation methods of switching power
converter with a coupled inductor,” IEEE Trans. Ind. converters, and the modeling and analysis of the dynamical
Electron., Vol. 58, No. 8, pp. 3440- 3447, Aug. 2011. behavior of switching DC-DC converters.