Alexopoulos, Stefanos - Initiation of Adults in Greece Today. Challenges and Suggestions (Orientalia Et Occidentalia, 2008) (Art.)
Alexopoulos, Stefanos - Initiation of Adults in Greece Today. Challenges and Suggestions (Orientalia Et Occidentalia, 2008) (Art.)
Alexopoulos, Stefanos - Initiation of Adults in Greece Today. Challenges and Suggestions (Orientalia Et Occidentalia, 2008) (Art.)
KNKL6CTX
INSTITUTI STUDDS SPlRlTUKLITKTIS
oRjeNTXLiuM occipeHTXLiuMQue PRoveneNDis
NOMIN6 P. MICHX6LIS LX CKO XPPGLLKTI
Editor:
Simon MARINCAK
SVATE TAJOMSTVA
NA KRESTANSKOM
VYCHODE
SUBOR STUDII
KOSICE
2008
Stefanos Alexopoulos
in the Greek society, and also believe that the Church will help them
do so. Finally, there are those who want to be baptized because they
want to marry with a Greek Orthodox in the Church.
I have to point out here that I will limit the scope of this presenta
tion to those who have not received a Christian baptism,3 and as a re
sult need to go through the whole process of Initiation, as they reflect
the majority of those that approach the Church and express their will
to become members of the Church.
3 On the issue of the acceptance of converts into the Orthodox Church in Byzantine and cur
rent practice, see the following studies: Μ. Arranz, "Les Sacraments de 1'ancien Euchologe
constantinopolitan (1): Etude preliminaire des sources," OCP 48 (1982) 284-335; idem, "Les
Sacraments de 1'ancien Euchologe constantinopolitan (2): lere partie-admission dans 1'Eglise
des convertis des heresies ou d'autres religions non-chretiennes" OCP 49 (1983) 42-90. Chry
sostomos, Metropolitan of Myra, "Response to Thomas Hopko: 'Tasks Facing the Ortho
dox'," Orthodox Perspectives on Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry (G. Limouris, Μ. Vaporis eds.)
Faith and Order Paper 128 (Brookline 1985) 149-158. J. Erickson, "The Reception of Non
Orthodox into the Orthodox Church," Diakonia 19 (1984-1985) 68-86; idem, "Divergencies in
Pastoral Praxis in the Reception of Converts," Orthodox Perspectives on Pastoral Praxis (T.
Stylianopoulos ed.) (Brookline 1988) 150-177; idem, "The Reception of Non-Orthodox into
the Orthodox Church: Contemporary Practice," St. Vladimir's Theological Quarterly 41 (1997)
1-17. T. Hopko, "Tasks Facing the Orthodox in the 'Reception' Process of BEM," Orthodox
Perspectives on Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry (G. Limouris, Μ. Vaporis eds.) Faith and Or
der Paper 128 (Brookline 1985) 135-147., Bishop P. L'Huillier, "The Reception of Roman
Catholics into Orthodoxy: Historical Variations and Norms," St. Vladimir's Theological Quar
terly 24 (1980) 75-82. J. Klentos, "Rebaptizing Converts in the Orthodox Church: Old Perspec
tives on a New Problem," Studia Liturgica 29 (1999) 216-234. G. Metallinos, I Confess One Bap
tism: Interpretation and Application of Canon VII of the Second Ecumenical Council by the Kolly-
vades and Constantine Oikonomos (Transl. Priestmonk Seraphim) (Mount Athos: St Paul's
Monastery 1994). Theodoros Giagos, "To Baptisma kai o Tropos Apodochis ton Airetikon kai
ton Schismatikon," To Baptisma: Praktika A' Panelliniou Leitourgikou Symposion (Athens 2003)
153-183. Orthodox-Roman Catholic Consultation in North America. "Statement on Baptism
and Sacramental Economy" (June 1999). Archimandrite A. Pogodin, "On the Question of the
Order of Reception of Persons into the Orthodox Church Coming to Her from Other Chris
tian Churches," Vestnik Russkogo Khristianskogo Dvizheniya [Messenger of the Russian Chris
tian Movement] 173 (1-1996) 174 (II-1996/I-1997). English translation available at:
http:/ /www.holy-trinity.org/ecclesiology/pogodin-reception. R. Stephanopoulos (ed.),
Guidelines for Orthodox Christians in Ecumenical Relations. Second Edition (New York 1973) 18-
19. F. Thomson, "Economy: An Examination of the Various Theories of Economy Held
Within the Orthodox Church," Journal of Theological Studies 16 (1965) 368-420. Μ. Thurian
(ed.), Churches Respond to BEM. 5 Vols. (Geneva 1986-1988) v. 1,122-129; vol. 2,5-29; vol. 3,1-
25; vol. 4,1-6; vol. 5,1-3.
INITIATION OF ADULTS IN GREECE TODAY 147
that the bishop accept the candidate's application (Plate 2). The bishop
then replies, usually accepting the application, assigns a catechist for
the candidate, and notes that the candidate should be baptized after
the catechism is completed (Plate 3). The catechist is usually the priest
who sent the letter accompanying the candidate's application. Now, if
there is a language barrier, then the priest is responsible for finding a
translator and books in the language of the candidate.
The catechesis then starts. It varies in length, depending on the
background of the candidate, his discipline and willingness to study
and learn, and the frequency of meetings. Usually the catechesis takes
place within private study meetings, once or twice a week. What ma
terial and what method is used depends entirely upon the
priest/catechist. The minimum duration for a catechesis is six months.
There is no ritual associated either with beginning or the process of
catechesis.
After the priest/catechist has judged that the candidate is ready to
receive baptism, he usually arranges for the baptism to take place on
any given day, and after the baptism is completed he fills in a baptis
mal certificate stating that so and so has been baptized and is a mem
ber of the Church (Plate 4).
When looking at the baptism proper of an adult, we observe that it
follows the rites of initiation as adapted to the rise and establishment
of infant baptism. In these rites, the whole process of initiation which
would last months, even years, is compressed into one service. All the
rites associated with the process of catechesis are performed all at
once before the Baptism proper, and the post-baptismal rites are per
formed immediately after the Baptism proper. In addition, Baptism
proper is not celebrated within the context of a Eucharistic Liturgy,
but independently and privately.
If we briefly look at the outline of the baptismal service, as it is
celebrated today, and compare it with the process of initiation in
Byzantium as presented in the documents reflecting the practice of the
Great Church of Constantinople in the tenth century, we will observe
that the whole process has been preserved in present practice. How
ever, it has lost its capacity to mark the various stages of the catechu-
menate; it has lost its intimate connection with the Eucharistic assem
bly and celebration; and it has lost its continuation in the post-
baptismal mystagogy.
As mentioned above, the whole process of catechesis is a series of
classes, devoid of any ritual signpost of its beginning, its process, and
its nearing completion. The liturgical elements of the process of cate
chesis are all piled one on top of the other right before baptism
proper:
148 STEFANOS ALEXOPOULOS
These ritual elements, stacked one on top of the other, and com
pleted today within ten or fifteen minutes, once marked the whole
process of the catechumenate. Important documents reflecting the
practice of the Great Church in the tenth century allow us to recon
struct the catechumenate in the cathedral practice of Constantinople.9
According to the cathedral practice of Constantinople, the admission
of a candidate to the catechumenate was marked by the Prayer for the
Making of a Catechumen (item 1 above). During the period of his or
her catechesis exorcisms were read over him (item 2 above). The cate
chumenate was not a private affair; it was a collective catechumenate
and an ecclesial event, as the petitions and prayer for the Catechu
mens in the Divine Liturgy (and the Liturgy of the Hours) demon
strate.10
In the final phase of the catechumenate, a select group among the
catechumens deemed ready was prepare^ for Baptism. Hence their
various names in the Christian tradition: electi, competences, or illumi-
nandi in the Western Liturgical tradition, photizomenoi in the Byzantine
liturgical tradition. This final phase was initiated on the third Sunday
of Lent, the Sunday of the Exaltation of the Cross, a liturgical high
4 S. Parenti, E. Velkovska (eds.), L'Eucologio Barberini gr. 336 (Rome 2000’) 119, #114; hence
cited as Barberini gr. 336.
5 Barberini gr. 336,120-122, #115-117.
6 Barberini gr. 336,122-123, #118.
? Barberini gr. 336,124, #119.1-10.
8 Barberini gr. 336,124, #119.11.
9 These documents are the earliest Euchologion Barberini gr. 336 dating to the end of the
eighth century, M. Arranz, L'Eucologio Constantinopolitano Angli Intzi del Secolo XI (Rome
1996); J. Mateos, Le Typikon de la Grande fglise (OCA 165-166) (Rome 1962-1963); H. Brak-
mann, "Der griechische Text des Konstantinopler prosphonetikon ton katechoumenon," OCP 52
(1986) 211-213; G. Engberg, C. Hoeg, G. Zuntz (eds.), Prophetologium (MMB, Lectionaria)
(Copenhagen 1939-1981).
10 Barberini gr. 336, 119-122, #114-117; Arranz, L'Eucologio Constantinopolitano, 172-173; M.
Arranz, "Les Sacraments de 1'ancien Euchologe constantinopolitain" 1:1-10, OCP 48 (1982)
284-335; 49 (1983) 42-90, 284-302; 50 (1984) 43-64, 372-397; 51 (1985) 60-86; 52 (1986) 145-178;
53 (1987) 59-106; 55 (1989) 33-62,317-338, here (1984) 52-60; S. Parenti, "Christian Initiation in
the East," Handbook for Liturgical Studies IV: Sacraments and Sacramentals (A. Chupungco ed.)
(Collegeville 2000) 29-48, here 35.
INITIATION OF ADULTS IN GREECE TODAY 149
11 J. Mateos, Le Typikon de la Grande Eglise (OCA 165-166) (Rome 1962-1963) here 11:38. M.
Arranz, "Les Sacraments" (1984) 47-49. Apparently this text was also read on the previous
Sunday, as a rubric in the provisions for the Second Sunday of Lent in the Typikon of the
Great Chinch indicates. See J. Mateos, Le Typikon, 11:30. For a French translation of the Greek
text from Dresden A 104, see J. Mateos, Le Typikon, 11:31 note 2. For the Greek text, see H.
Brakmann, "Der griechische Text des Konstantinopler prosphonetikon ton katechoumenon,"
OCP 52 (1986) 211-213, here 212.
12 On the three-week distance between the enrollment of the photizomenoi and Lazarus Satur
day, see T. Talley, The Origins of the Liturgical Year (Collegeville 19862) 189-214; M. Johnson,
"Preparation for Pascha? Lent in Christian Antiquity," Passover and Easter. The Symbolic
Structuring of Sacred Seasons (P. Bradshaw, L. Hoffman eds.) Two Liturgical Traditions 6
(Notre Dame 1999) 36-54; idem, "From Three Weeks to Forty Days: Baptismal Preparation
and the Origins of Lent," idem, Living Water, Sealing Spirit (Collegeville 1995) 118-136.
13 S. Alexopoulos, The Presanctified Liturgy in the Byzantine Rite: A Comparative Analysis of its
Origins, Evolution, and Structural Units. Doctoral Dissertation (Notre Dame 2004) 242. This
dissertation is being prepared for publication.
14 Ibid., 230-244.
15 L'Eucologio Barberini, 122-123, #118; Arranz, L'Eucologio Constantinopolitano 178; M. Arranz,
"Les Sacraments" (1984) 60-61.
16 Barberini gr. 336,124, #119; M. Arranz, L'Eucologio Constantinopolitano, 181.
150 STEFANOS ALEXOPOULOS
From this brief sketch we can observe, I believe, how the present
catechetical process has lost its ritual power and has been condensed
to a short service held immediately prior to the Baptismal proper.
Baptism proper has maintained its structural unity, although it is
now not celebrated within the context of a Divine Liturgy. The ele
ments of the service are:
Enarxis
1. Litany of Peace [Private Prayer of Celebrant read during the
litany]
2. Blessing of the Baptismal Waters
3. Blessing of the Oil of Gladness
4. Anointing of Font
5. Anointing of the Candidate
6. Triple Immersion with Passive formula
7. Ps31.1
8. Prayer of Chrism and anointing with Chrism
9. Clothing with White Garment
10. Gal. 3:27
11. Romans 6:3-11
12. Matthew 28:16-20
13. Prayers of Ablution
14. Prayer of Tonsure
Dismissal
Items (1) to (9), the Baptismal proper, reflect both the current and
the Byzantine practice. The only difference is that in the Byzantine
practice these would take place in the Baptistery, while the commu
nity, gathered for the Eucharist, would listen to a series of readings,
waiting for the baptisms to be completed, while today the baptism is
celebrated privately and not in the context of a Eucharistic liturgy.
Item (10) acts as a transition. In current practice the newly baptized
processes around the font three times, standing opposite the priest
who in the meantime censes. In the practice of the Great Church, item
(10) was chanted when the newly baptized were chrismated, and then
Ps. 31.1 was chanted as they left the Baptistery and entered the
Church, joining the Eucharistic assembly and participating for the first
time in the Eucharistic celebration.23 In current practice, on the other
hand, the newly baptized will have to wait until the first Divine Lit
urgy to be celebrated after his or her Baptism to receive communion!
Items (11) and (12), the readings, are remnants of the Divine Lit
urgy, while items (13) and (14) are part of the rites that would take
place after baptism: The ablution would take place on the eighth day,
following a week of daily communion and mystagogy,24 and the ton-
sure, a rite for children originally independent from Baptism, would
take place when the baptized would have his or her hair cut.25 Today
they are also compressed, attached to the end of the Baptismal proper,
concluding Baptism, and the rite of tonsure is administered to adults
too.
Evaluation - Challenges
From this summary that I have presented, it is obvious, I believe,
that the Initiation of Adults in current Greek practice is problematic.
In brief, we can observe the following: The ritual elements of the
whole period of catechesis are compressed to a ten to fifteen minute
service before Baptism proper, Baptism itself has lost is connection
with the Eucharistic celebration, turning Baptism into a private enter
prise, and the rites of the eighth day lose their meaning by being at
tached to the end of the baptismal service.
Although Byzantine liturgy has maintained the structural frame
work within which the Initiation rites of an adult could be restored,
nothing is done to that measure. In other words:
1. Baptisms of adults are not held on the baptismal days that are
in place in the Byzantine liturgical tradition: Holy Saturday,
Christmas eve, Epiphany eve, Saturday of Lazarus, and Pente
cost.
2. Baptisms almost never take place within the context of the Di
vine Liturgy.
3. Sometimes fonts for adults are not available!
4. The local bishop does not have an active role in the process.
5. Although Great Lent offers the structure for the catechetical
process, such as the petitions for the catechumens and
photizomenoi (after 4th week) in the Presanctified, with the
Old Testament Readings, with the vesperal Liturgy of Basil on
Holy Saturday, it is not employed at all. In general, although
Great Lent, Holy Week, and Easter are the natural locus for
24 See, for example, Canon 66 of the Council of Trullo. P. Trempelas, Mikron Euchologion vol
ume A (Athens 1950) 310, 371-377, critical apparatus; Barberini gr. 336, 131-132, # 126; Μ.
Arranz, L'Eucologio Constanttnopolitano, 194-195; Μ. Arranz, "Les Sacraments" (1989) 39-42.
25 Barberini gr. 336, 198, 200, # 208, 209, 212; P. Trempelas, Mikron Euchologion, 378-382. See
also Μ. Arranz, L'Eucologio Constantinopolitano, 196-197; Μ. Arranz, "Les Sacraments" (1989)
48-54.
INITIATION OF ADULTS IN GREECE TODAY 153
Suggestions
Great Lent provides us with an already existing structure within
and around which we can re-establish an active catechumenate, thus
also restoring meaning to elements of Lent that now make no sense to
the non-specialists (e.g. petitions of the photizomenoi from fourth
week of Lent on, the series of readings at vesperal Basil on Holy Sat
urday). More concretely, I would suggest:
1. Establish set days during the year when new catechumens are
enrolled in the presence of the local bishop, who meets with
them, and reads over them the prayer of the making of cate
chumen.
2. The bishop will have an active role in the catechesis by meet
ing with the catechumens and reading over them the exor
cisms.
3. On the Third Sunday of Lent (Sunday of the Adoration of the
Cross) a formal announcement is made regarding those who
enter the final stage of the catechumenate and become
photizomenoi. The petitions for the photizomenoi be restored
on Sundays too.
4. On Holy Friday the bishop gathers all the photizomenoi
where the renunciation of the devil and acceptance of Christ is
made, and the bishop reads over them the invitation to Bap
tism.
5. Each diocese should make sure it has a font designed for
adults.
6. Baptism is restored and takes place during the readings of ves
peral Liturgy of Basil on Holy Saturday, and is celebrated by
the bishop.
7. Mystagogy on Bright Week is also restored.
8. On the parish level, the existing structure (petitions for cate
chumens and photizomenoi) will regain their meaning and
thus the community will be made part of the process.
Your Beatitude,
λίακαρκιίαιιτ,
I respectfully take the honour to request that You
Εύοεβάοτωι; lagjlriνω τήν τιμήν να ιιαμακαλέο« "Υμάς
Approve my petition and undertake all procedures necessary
όπως ε»<ιρκο<»ύμι:νος έγκρίνηιβ καί διαιάξηα·. ιά δίχινια
for my becoming a member of the Eastern Orthodox Church,
διά τήν npootaoiv μοιι ri'’, ιάι; uifcu; τής ΧΙρΟοΒόξου Ά ναιολικής Έκκλιιοίας
My present religious affiliation is
Τιιγχάνω ιό Ηρήοκπιμα
And I desire, of my own free will and with no compulsion or force
καί ίπιΟιιμώ άλως άβιάοτως καί αύιοπροιιιρίιωι;
to become a member of the Orthodox Christian Faith,
νά (ιοιιαοΟώ ιήν θρΒόίίοζον Χριοπανικήν ιΰοιην.
Most respectfully,
Μετά οιβαομοΰ. Ό ’Εφημνριας
Plate 1
156 STEFANOS ALEXOPOULOS
ΓΙρό<;
Τόν Μιικαριώιαιο ν
Άρχικηιοκοπον Αθηνών
κ<ιί ιιάοηι; ΈλμιΙΙιχ;
κ.κ ΧΡΙΣΤΟΔΟΥΛΟΝ
Έν ΛΟήνακ;
M<IK(tpiftHUlE.
Plate 2
INITIATION OF ADULTS IN GREECE TODAY 157
6ΛΛΗΝΙΚΗ ΛΗΜΟΚΡΚΓΙΚ
I6RK. ΚΡΧΙΘΠΙΟΚΟΠΗ ΚΘΗΝ(ΟΝ
πρόζ
Τόν Αίδεοιμ. Πρεσβύτερον
η. Στέφανον ΆΠεξόπουλον
Έ...ν..χ.ςι.ίι.θ_.α
του εις τήν ‘Ορθόδοξον ημών Εκκλησίαν’, όρίζομεν ύμός. όπως κατηχήοητε αυτόν
2000 Έγκυκλίω Σημειώματι ημών. ώς καί άπαντα τά ύπό τών Νόμων του Κράτους
προβλεηόμενα.
0 ΓΡΑΜΜΑΤΕΥΣ
Plate 3
158 STEFANOS ALEXOPOULOS
HIXFOIIOIHTIKON
.... .jrhbnhmmmmhimiihB'...................
Hit; IliOlGIOlV xopqyi.ltoi «> nopov IVO XpI(OipiWI[| ÖllOII Μ
XttMtviipi .......
Plate 4
42 - Agios Georgios: Pantokratoros
40 - Agios Georgios: Holy Week and Easter
44 - Agios Georgios: Adult baptistery