Power Quality Analysing: Content
Power Quality Analysing: Content
Power Quality Analysing: Content
Content
1. Introduction........................................................................................................................... 2
2. Application areas for power quality monitoring......................................................................... 2
3. Benefits of power quality analysing ......................................................................................... 2
Interferences and failure detection.............................................................................................. 2
Advanced power resources management and predictive diagnostics............................................ 2
Input power quality evaluation according to EN 50160 ................................................................. 3
4. Most frequent power quality problems and possible solutions ................................................... 3
Low cos ϕ. ................................................................................................................................. 3
High content of harmonic components ........................................................................................ 3
Consequences of high current harmonics ............................................................................... 4
Preventive and corrective actions ........................................................................................... 4
Supply voltage variations ........................................................................................................... 4
Consequences of voltage variations ....................................................................................... 5
Possible solutions ................................................................................................................. 5
5. Various situations and troubleshooting.................................................................................... 5
Resonant state between power supply transformer and the capacitor bank ................................... 5
Flickers caused by welding machines ......................................................................................... 6
Loose bus bar........................................................................................................................... 6
Overheating of a neutral conductor ............................................................................................. 6
EN50160 compliance testing...................................................................................................... 7
6. Return of investment ............................................................................................................. 7
Reduction of a peak consumption (peak power) .......................................................................... 7
Improving cosϕ and power factor (PF) ........................................................................................ 8
Filtering harmonic currents......................................................................................................... 8
Installing uninterruptible power supplies (UPS)............................................................................ 8
7. Technical background ........................................................................................................... 9
What is measured at Power Quality Analysing?........................................................................... 9
Calculated parameters............................................................................................................... 9
Simultaneous measurements and TRMS ...................................................................................10
Types of measurements in Power Quality Assessment ...............................................................10
8. What type of instrument will I need for my purpose? ...............................................................10
Number of inputs......................................................................................................................10
Sampling frequency..................................................................................................................10
True RMS ................................................................................................................................11
Scope and Meter function .........................................................................................................11
Harmonic components and their direction ..................................................................................11
EN50160 Autotest ....................................................................................................................11
Special tools ............................................................................................................................11
Energy………...........................................................................................................................11
Accessories .............................................................................................................................11
PC Evaluation software package...............................................................................................12
Remote control of the instrument ...............................................................................................12
9. Evaluation of the results with Metrel’ instruments....................................................................12
Periodics measurement ............................................................................................................12
EN 50160 Auto report ...............................................................................................................13
Waveforms ..............................................................................................................................13
Transients................................................................................................................................13
Fast Logging ............................................................................................................................14
10. The most frequent terms in power quality analysing............................................................14
-1-
1. Introduction
There are quite a few reasons for measuring and analysing power quality nowadays.
Potential interactions between end use equipment and electric distribution system,
external electromagnetic interferences, resonant states between electrical circuits
and some other factors call for a need to be analysed in order that harmful
consequences can be omitted or prevented.
§ Manufacturing plants
§ Banks
§ Hospitals
§ Telecommunication companies
§ IT and Data centres
§ Education and other Public Services
§ Power distribution
§ Power generation
§ Quality of service,
§ Competitiveness of services and products
§ Time management
-2-
Input power quality evaluation according to EN 50160
Transients, voltage variations and supply interruptions often come from the supply
network and influence operations of internal electrical systems. Loss of data, shorter
life span of the electronic equipment, increased rejection level on production lines
etc. are consequences of bad quality power supply.
Supply voltage quality can be assessed in accordance with relevant “Power Quality”
standards (example: EN 50160).
Advanced Power Quality Analysers will produce “Quality compliance” report which
can be used for further negotiations with electro-distribution company if necessary.
Improper selection of cosϕ correction equipment can cause a risk of resonant states
with other elements of a supply network and/or harmful switching transients.
-3-
Computers, printers and other small office IT equipment. High 3 rd, a bit lower 5 th, 7th,
11th and 13th current harmonics are typical for such loads.
Variable frequency drives (VFD’s). High harmonic components like 5 th, 7th, 11th, 13th,
17th and 19th order.
3rd, 6th, 9th, 12th Harmonics cause high current in a neutral conductor in 3-phase, 4-
wire systems.
Dips or sags that describe temporary drops of the voltage under the nominal level.
Duration is usually measured in seconds or sometimes in minutes.
Voltage swell is occurrence when the voltage level rises above the nominal level.
Duration period is also measured in seconds or minutes.
-4-
Voltage transients. These are short lasting events with a duration measured in milli-
or microseconds. They usually appear as a consequence of external electromagnetic
interferences (atmospheric electric discharges, switching manoeuvres).
Longer power supply interruptions that can be categorised as unexpected or
foreseeable.
Possible solutions
• Installing UPS systems. These will compensate voltage variations to a certain
extent. UPS systems are frequently used as a back-up power supply system in
IT, Data and Telecom environments. Possible drawback of installing UPS
systems is that they may generate harmonics.
• Over-voltage protection devices can considerably reduce fatal consequences
of over-voltage transients corresponding. They will protect expensive and
high-availability systems.
• Analysing internal electrical inventory and their influences on the voltage
variations.
• Assessing the input power quality on the connection point in order to prove
that supplied voltage complies with relevant standards.
There are some typical situations that deserve power quality analysing. Here are
some examples.
-5-
Flickers caused by welding machines
Flickers occur frequently as a consequence of supply voltage variations or as an
influence of larger internal loads on the voltage level.
An example of internal cause for flickers is spot welding machine. Welding cycle is
usually only several periods long. Shape of the welding current (waveform, duration)
depends on how the triggering elements (triacs, diodes) are set.
Magnitude and length of the welding current can affect supply voltage level, which
further reflects as the illumination intensity variation.
Scope of the analysis is to find out possible interactions between temporary current
increases that are followed with voltage dips.
To avoid flickers a welding cycle has to be adjusted slightly (different triggering
settings, shorter welding period). Increased power of the supply transformer is
usually better long-term solution although it is quite expensive.
-6-
Possible solutions can go in a direction of increasing a neutral conductor’s diameter,
filtering current harmonics to the acceptable level or perhaps splitting existing circuit
into several smaller circuits with separate neutral conductors.
- Voltage
- Magnitude
- Wave form
- Symmetry of the three phase voltages
These characteristics vary during the normal operation of a supply system due to
changes of load, disturbances generated by certain equipment and the occurrence of
faults that are mainly caused by external events.
Variation of observed parameters can exceed allowed limits on a small number of
occasions.
If the number of violations and their size is out of, within EN50160 specified, limits the
consumers are entitled to complain against bad power quality to their electro-
distribution company.
Advanced Power Quality Analysers enable EN50160 compliance testing without
requiring a special knowledge from the user.
6. Return of investment
Reliable Power Quality Analyser is an essential tool that helps the users to:
Improvements of the power quality are often conditioned with a certain investment.
Therefore it is always necessary to compare potential financial burden of the
improvement with possible gains.
Experiences have shown that savings on electricity cost between 5-20% can be
achieved if proper actions are executed. Investment costs usually return within 1 to 3
years time.
-7-
Technical measures base around applying current limiters or more sophisticated PLC
(Programmable Logic Controllers) devices that are both man-independent systems.
Such systems will keep the power peak under adjusted limit all the time. However,
PLC’s can be programmed in a way that production process parameters will not be
essentially influenced.
-8-
7. Technical background
Systematic approach and correct interpretation of the measuring results are two of
the things that count the most in power quality analysing.
Selecting the right solution greatly depends on analysing possible interactions
between various signals and parameters that are measured simultaneously.
Sampling rate
During the measurement selected analogue input current and voltage signals are
sampled at a certain rate, converted into a digital form and stored inside the
instrument’s memory. Faster the sampling rate the more accurate the end results.
Calculated parameters
Some parameters are calculated from the basic input signals (current, voltage).
-9-
Simultaneous measurements and TRMS
Simultaneous sampling on all input signals is essential that possible interactions
between various parameters can be determined.
Long-term measurements
The duration of long-term measurements (frequently called Periodic measurements
or Periodics) is usually between several days or even up to several weeks long.
Purpose of such measurements is to observe consumption dynamics of larger loads /
consumers or controlling the quality of supplied voltage according to relevant
standard (EN 50160 for example).
Special measurements
Short lasting events like transients, direction of harmonics require that a complete
signal is captured.
Observed parameters are peak magnitudes, time of occurrence and rise / fall rates.
Measurement can be started when triggering conditions are fulfilled and last from
several periods up to several minutes.
Compared with Periodic measurements where the IP is relatively long, Special
measurements consume considerably more instrument’s memory as a complete
picture of the event has to be drawn.
It is not unusual that both type of the measurements have to be performed in order
that a complete and effective troubleshooting is made.
Number of inputs
At least three independent current and three independent voltage inputs are needed
for analysing on 3-phase systems. It is necessary that both voltage and current are
measured simultaneously in order to capture possible interactions between different
parameters. For example a direction of harmonics cannot be determined without
simultaneous sampling of current and voltage.
Sampling frequency
The higher it is, the more accurate the results are. Sampling rate declares the highest
order of a harmonic component the instrument can still measure and is of paramount
importance for capturing short lasting transients. Usual sampling frequencies are
from 6400 Hz upwards.
- 10 -
True RMS
Non-linear loads distort signals. Measurement of distorted signals can only be made
by True RMS method.
EN50160 Autotest
Many users wonder whether their input voltage comply with the relevant standards. It
is simple to check all necessary parameters and compare their values with allowed
limits by performing EN 50160 Autotest.
Special tools
Short lasting events like Transients, Motor’s start-ups (Fast Logging) and Waveforms
have to be measured when profound power quality assessment is performed.
A complete signal (or more signals) will be captured and drawn in order that a
complete event is analysed and possible interactions with other parameters can be
determined.
Energy
Electric energy consumption measurement is essential when performing cost-
reduction analysis. Based on this measurement daily or weekly consumption
diagrams can be produced.
Accessories
Power Quality Analyser usually cannot be connected directly on the analysed
system. Measuring transducers are used for this purpose.
Current inputs receive input signals from current clamps or current transformers.
Voltage inputs can be fed directly or via voltage transformers.
In case the transducers are incorporated in the measuring circuit corresponding
calculation constants have to be applied that correct results are generated.
- 11 -
PC Evaluation software package
PC evaluation software is essential part of every Power Quality Analyser.
After a recording is accomplished measuring results have to be downloaded on a PC
for further analysing.
PC evaluation software enables making various reports that show different relations
between analysed signals either in a table or in a diagram.
Programme suite can also report results in a statistical form with additional
information on average, minimum and maximum values within the observed period.
Periodics measurement
Application areas:
- General Power Quality assessment,
- Power Factor correction,
- Harmonics filtering,
- Power Peak reduction,
- Power Breaks Capturing
Possible corrective solutions:
- PF correction equipment,
- Filters,
- UPS,
- Power conditioners
Suitable Metrel Power Quality Analyser:
- Power Harmonics Analyser MI2092
- Power Quality Analyser MI2192
- Power Quality Analyser Plus MI2292
- 12 -
EN 50160 Auto report
Application areas:
- Assessment of supply voltage quality at end users
- Assessment of voltage quality in electro distribution
- Assessment of voltage quality in electrical generation systems
Possible corrective solutions:
- Dealing with customer’s complaints,
- UPS,
- Ferro-resonant transformers,
- Backup generators,
- Power conditioners
Suitable Metrel Power Quality Analyser:
- Power Quality Analyser MI2192
- Power Quality Analyser Plus MI2292
Voltscanner MI 2130 (1-phase only)
-
Waveforms
Application areas:
- Analysing of influences of motor start-ups,
- Analysing of load variations,
- Analysing of non-linear loads
- Analysing of determination of harmonics direction
Possible corrective solutions:
- Voltage regulators,
- Power conditioners,
- UPS,
- Ferro-resonant transformers,
- Filters
Suitable Metrel Power Quality Analyser:
- Power Quality Analyser MI2192
- Power Quality Analyser Plus MI2292
-
Transients
Application areas:
- Analysis of oscillatory transients caused by lightning,
- Analysis of electrostatic discharges,
- Analysis of switching manoeuvres
Possible corrective solutions:
- UPS,
- Overvoltage protection devices,
- Power conditioners
Suitable Metrel Power Quality Analyser:
- Power Quality Analyser MI2192
- Power Quality Analyser Plus MI2292
- 13 -
Fast Logging
Application areas:
- Analysing of influences of motor start-ups
- Analysing of load variations
Possible corrective solutions:
- UPS,
- Voltage regulators,
- Power conditioners
Suitable Metrel Power Quality Analyser:
- Power Quality Analyser MI2192
- Power Quality Analyser Plus MI2292
The list of common terms that are encountered when dealing with power quality is
long. Here is a short explanation of the most frequent ones.
Supply interruptions
A condition in which the voltage at the supply terminals drops under 1% of the
declared voltage. There are two kinds of interruptions:
Pre-arranged. This is when the consumers are informed beforehand and can plan
their activities accordingly and minimize negative effects of the interruption.
Accidental interruptions. These are further classified as long (longer than three
minutes) and short-term (shorter than three minutes) interruptions.
Flicker
Voltage fluctuation causes changes of the luminance of lamps that can create the
visual phenomenon called flicker. Above a certain threshold flicker becomes
annoying. The annoyance grows very rapidly with the amplitude of the fluctuation. At
certain repetition rates even small amplitudes can be annoying.
There are two types of flickers.
Short-term flicker (Pst) is measured over a period of ten minutes.
Long-term flicker (Plt) is calculated from a sequence of 12 P st – values over a two-
hour interval.
- 14 -
Harmonic components
A sinusoidal current /voltage with a frequency equal to an integer multiple of the
fundamental frequency of the supply voltage.
Harmonic components can be evaluated individually by their relative amplitude
related to the fundamental voltage / current or globally, by the total harmonic
distortion factor THD.
Mainly customer’s non-linear loads connected to all voltage levels of the supply
system cause harmonic components. Harmonic currents flowing trough the system
impedance rise to harmonic voltages. Harmonic currents and system impedances
and thus the harmonic voltages at the supply terminals vary in time.
Voltage unbalance
Appears in three – phase systems. A condition in which the RMS values of the phase
voltages or the phase angles between consecutive phases are not equal.
Interharmonic voltage
A sinusoidal voltage with a frequency between the harmonics, i.e. the frequency is
not an integer multiple of the fundamental.
Interharmonic voltages at closely adjacent frequencies can appear at the same time
forming a wide band spectrum.
- 15 -