An Empirical Study On Recruitment and Selection Process With Reference To Private Universities in Uttarakhand
An Empirical Study On Recruitment and Selection Process With Reference To Private Universities in Uttarakhand
An Empirical Study On Recruitment and Selection Process With Reference To Private Universities in Uttarakhand
Roma Tripathi*
*Assistant Professor, School of Management, IMS Unison University, Dehradun (Uttarakhand), India
Email: [email protected]
Contact No: 7895907326
Abstract
This study throws light upon various sources of recruitment and selection processes in selected
private universities. The main purpose of the study is to identify the probable area of
improvement for the next generation to make recruitment and selection practices more efficient.
The recruitment and selection process is the foremost pillar of success in any organization.
Thus, every business must seek to improve the quality of its workforce. To get the best human
resource, an efficient and well planned strategy is required at the workplace. Nowadays,
technical advances are being made in the field of human resource with time and slowly the
traditional sources of human resource are being replaced by new and technically enhanced
sources and methods of recruitment and selection processes. Therefore, recruitment process in
an organization must be effective to attract the best talent. The primary data for this study has
been collected through a structured questionnaire and convenience sampling method was used.
The sample size was 150. Limitations and scope for future work have also been discussed in the
study. This study provides several theoretical and managerial implications to the practitioners
for the next generation. The inferences depict that many private universities make use of social
media platforms like Facebook, LinkedIn, Glassdoor, Skype (Video conferencing) etc. as a
recruiting tool and it has become a valuable instrument for employers in the hiring process as
well as jobseekers. It is via all these social media maneuvers that recruiters are able to manifold
the probability of identifying suitable recruits by reaching out to a bigger pool of potential
applicants. In this paper, an attempt has been made to understand the advancing recruitment and
selection (staffing) process in the private universities and offer a recommendation for the same.
In the modern world, explicit social media avenues and social networking sites have enabled
people to cooperate in ways which was not witnessed by the previous generations. Faculty and
staff at a university are able to broadcast information about upcoming events, deadlines, or
opportunities for their colleagues and followers to participate in. Without ever needing a
physical presence, the whole university community can communicate with one another.
Today, private university campuses’ career and placement offices use social recruiting
since social media is familiar to and often embraced by students and graduates as a job
searching medium. According to Mr. Manoj Biswas, HR lead, Accenture India, (2012),
“opposed to popular opinion, social media is a platform where an employer can seek candidates,
irrespective of the nature of the job.” Recruiting through social networking websites is more
economical as compared to conventional forms of hiring that include placement consultants,
posting advertisements in different forms of media and participation in job fairs, and waiting for
potential candidates to appear before them.
Recruitment and selection is one of the foremost parts of human resource
management. It is conducted to get the right person for the right place at the right time at an
organization. Recently there has been a significant increase in the use of internet to recruit and
select people (Hopkins and Markham, 2003). Various research evidences show that online
recruitments have become an easy way to save cost and valuable time of firms (Hart, Doherty &
Ellis Chadwick, 2000). If observed through a human resource lens, effective plans of action that
are used in recruitment and selection processes are of primary importance, since recruitment and
selection strategies are the main methods of filtering extraordinary talent from the existing pool
of applicants.
Retention of employees is governed by better recruitment and it is a process of
bringing people and organization together to meet their common goals. Manpower planning and
recruitment not only involves strategies, but it also blends together many thought processes and
multifaceted challenges.
Education is the only service through which a person’s life can be reformed. In case of
universities they provide higher levels of education to the student which is one kind of service.
So, it plays a crucial role in a student’s life. A university can’t give quality education to its
students without an efficient and effective workforce. An effective and efficient workforce has
to be secured by the university through successful recruitment and selection processes.
Recruitment is closely followed by a selection process of the candidates where they are
screened for choosing the most suitable person for vacant positions. It is usually through various
interviews and tests. Selection is perceived as a negative process as it involves rejection of the
unsuitable candidates. Selection results into the establishment of contract of service between the
employer and the selected employee. So, this process needs to be very robust.
Srikrishna (2012) investigates and shows that how social networking sites have become
an integral part of our lives. It has helped not only to build personalized online connections but
also helped us in enhancing our employer branding quotient. Not just friendships but
professional relationships on a wider canvas have become easy to cultivate. From the viewpoint
of the employer, social media has become a great stage to communicate their valued suggestions
as an employer quite effectively because it becomes a tool for masses.
“Social media platforms have emerged as a very important element in building the
employer brand. From building rich talent pools and communities, connecting with potential
employees, to finding effective ways to interact with ‘passive’ candidates, social media is doing
all this and more. The sheer speed and interconnections of these platforms augments the
bandwidth of reach in terms of potential candidates,”
Social media also helps to overcome various shortcomings of candidates on their
personal fronts. For instance, any candidate who is shy to present him or her in front of the
panel right away can overcome his personal shortcomings via social media. Shyness may not be
a desirable trait or attribute that is expected from a potential candidate, but through social media
this personal boundary can be leaped over.
The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 discusses relevant
literature to identify the various advancing sources of staffing and selection process in the
private universities in Uttarakhand. Section 3 describes the methodology. Section 4 discusses
the results and analysis part of this paper. Section 5 discusses the conclusions of the study.
Finally, limitations and scope for future work are presented in Section 6.
2. Literature Review
According to Samuel and Nyarko (2014), there has been a transformation in the delivery
of transactional HRM from an approach which is “labor intensive” to one which is “technology-
intensive” whereby a large quantity of transactional activities are now delivered using a wide
variety of softwares rather than by HR administrators.
As per Wolmer (2012), a survey conducted by the Society for Human Resource
Management (SHRM), states that a large number of companies make use of social networking
sites, such as Facebook for recruiting and contacting potential applicants. He explains that the
use of Facebook as a recruitment tool goes beyond creating a Facebook page, keeping it up to
date and occasionally interacting with its visitors.
According to Penttila (2009), many cases have come across where candidate have
accounted fake details and information to get the job. This is one of the disadvantages of using
social sites for recruitment and selection process. For hiring managers and even for the
candidates, social media has now become the real time search engine because it is cost saving
and time saving as well. The significant feature for hiring managers through social media is that
you can get all the correct information of the candidate through his/her website profile. One of
the most important reasons for candidates to use the websites is that it is low cost or free to join.
Hunt (2010) discussed a Career Builder survey that found an increase in employer usage
of social media for recruitment purposes. Within these results, 35 percent of employers reported
using social media to promote their organization, 21 percent to recruit or research potential
employees, and 18 percent to increase their company brand. He pointed out that candidates in
today’s market expected their employers of choice to be online.
According to Vicknair et al., (2010), the positive aspect of hiring via social media
practice is the additional information and skills that can be demonstrated by a candidate that
simply cannot be replicated through paper and pen. Candidates have been offered jobs due to
their social networking profiles that reflected well-roundness, creativity, display of awards, and
just looking like the correct fit.
As discussed by Private University, management should look into this (HR practices)
matter because high faculty turnover not only incur financial loss for academic institutions but it
also affects the goodwill of the university through disrupting smooth operations of quality
education. And, in the long run, it may be a big obstacle for recruiting and retaining good
faculty, which in turn, will raise the question of survival of the institution. Good human
resource practices fulfill the psychological contract between employer and employees
(Hellriegel, Slocum and Woodman 1995).
From the view point of Faruqui and Islam (2005), It is widely believed that for a service
industry good human resource practices are must (as compared to manufacturing industry),
because people are the most important asset in the service industry to gain competitive
advantage. In fact, without introducing appropriate human resource management practices in the
organization, survival of the organization would be under a big exclamatory sign!
As Vaishali and Shruti (2013) examined in their research paper that the social media
platforms are an effective recruitment tool with a more direct and focused approach in today’s
technologically vibrant age.
The growth of social media makes recruiters change their perceptions of methods and
practical ways of looking for new candidates for jobs. Traditionally, CVs sent by mail or by
recommendation or faxed are now giving ground to social media recruiting. Social network
offers a powerful tool for recruiters to reach a pool of qualified candidates that they might not
otherwise be able to reach. Instead of merely searching for passive candidates via search engine,
it uses social networking and multimedia.
As per Rynes and Barber (1990), in most of the literature the recruitment and selection
are being treated separately while as recruitment and selection are interrelated and
interdependent that has influence to each other. The right selection becomes very difficult if the
recruitment process will not be effective to bring enough pool or applications for any specific
job (Carless, 2007).
Abel (2011) explores that the social networking sites which have become the daily use
sites, are used by organization for broad casting their job posting and job seekers use it for job
searching.
The literature says that employers are doing the traditional method of recruiting rather
than the modern technologies (Schmidt, 1998). On the web, the life cycle of a vacancy is longer
and allows the display of the duration of the advertisement. One of the differences between
social media recruitment and old fashion recruitment has to do with the life cycle of the vacancy
(Valvis, 2005). The consumptions of these sites are constantly developing. Facebook’s rapid
replacement of MySpace shows us how quickly these transformations can occur (Reiners and
Alexander, 2013).
2. Objectives
1. To study the various roles of social media platforms in the recruitment and selection
process.
2. To identify the probable areas of improvement to make recruitment and selection
procedure more effective for next generation.
3. Research Methodology
A questionnaire was developed on the basis of prior literature review and experts’ opinion.
Experts were having more than five years of experience in his/her field. Questionnaire consists
of ten dimensions of recruitment and selection process in private universities. After that data
was collected through questionnaire and convenience sampling method was used. The
questionnaire was carefully designed by considering the parameters of the study. The sample
size was 150 from various levels in three private universities and to different departments. The
private universities chosen were some of the reputed ones in the city of Dehradun, India. The
questionnaire was filled by the employees and based on that data was collected and conclusions
were drawn.
4. Analysis and results
Transfers
Many companies adopt transfer as a process of recruitment. This concept is followed by the
employers to fulfill the required position where there is scarcity of manpower.
Employee recommendation
In this method employees are asked to recommend people for jobs. Since the employee is
having knowledge of the working conditions within the company he will suggest people who
can adjust to the situation.
Screening of CV’s by
HR Recruiter
Is CV relevant?
Reject CV and maintain the NO
same in databank
YES
Is CV suitable?
NO
YES
Organise Interview
Conduct Interview
Preliminary Round by HR
Second Round by concerned
HOD
Is offer accepted?
NO Reject the Candidate
YES
Issue
1. Offer Letter
2. Medical Letter
Is Candidate Medically
fit?
NO
YES
Facebook
Facebook is now the most visited place on the web. Facebook‟s ad network offers recruiters a
unique opportunity to target job advertisements to Facebook users by keyword, education,
location, and even age. Facebook Fan Page can serve as a recruiting and sourcing tool just like a
company blog or opportunities to directly engage and educate target candidate market.
LinkedIn is one of the social networking sites in India which are used by many professionals.
LinkedIn is considered as reality check for the candidates. LinkedIn has become a new way of
virtually shaking hands. It’s a pre-meet, meet. Networking is crucial and social media plays a
big role in that. LinkedIn is best used as a social proofing when connecting with others that you
know, know of, or would like to know. It can use it as a resume builder and verifier. It is also a
good place to post your own content as further proof affirmation to your expertise and fit for
any recruiter or hiring manager. It is still evolving in terms of culture, etiquette, use, etc. It’s
becoming one of the biggest business to business platforms.
Every social media has a different feel, style, and culture. For twitter, it is best to keep things
very positive and constructive. Twitter is a place to connect, share ideas, construct solutions
together. The feeling of cooperation and collaboration over intra-group competition is vital to
successful engagement on Twitter. Social media should not be used as a replacement for
traditional recruitment strategy, but rather as an extension and enhancement.
Glassdoor is a website where employees and former employees anonymously review companies
and their management. Staying true to its own name, Glassdoor actually shows the organization
from the inside to the candidate, as if the candidate himself is looking into the organization
through a door made of glass. Employees also mention questions asked in the interview for the
reader who might be applying for a similar post at the same organization.
It was observed that out of all the sources, the website portal sources were adopted the most
(50%) by the University to recruit candidates (See Figure 2).
20% 20%
10% 10%
t l In r k g)
m
en orta ed doo boo cin
se P k s ce n
rti sit
e Lin Gl
as Fa fe
re
e
d v eb Co
n
rA W o
pe de
p a (Vi
ews yp
e
N Sk
l k In er or g) +
orta b oo ed itt do cin gle
k w s o
ep Fa
ce Lin T as re
n
Go
sit Gl fe
eb co
n
W o
e
id
e (V
yp
Sk
3% 5% 2%
te m lic
y st ke
t
ida or o r co ar
nd tr yN ny
p
we m
f ca us pa Lo o ur
eo In
d m lab
yp Co e
ct th
cifi to
pe ess
r s cc
g fo ofa
okin Ea
se
Lo
Today, social media is emerging as a tool that more recruiters rely on in the hiring
process. Networks such as LinkedIn, Facebook, Twitter, Periscope and Glassdoor can provide
recruiters with an array of information about potential candidates, as well as new avenues for
reaching passive candidates and advertising the company’s current openings. E-recruitment is
the University’s staff recruitment system. There is no doubt that social media has improved the
recruitment process by making it more open and democratic; increasing the visible talent pool
from which to engage and recruit. It is changing the way we do business today.
Despite a growth in the use of the internet to find applicants, many human resource (HR)
professionals continue to primarily reply and rely on personal contacts and networking to find
top talent. Employee recruitment across levels has become more demanding as the market for
qualified job applicants is shrinking. Giving advertisements in newspapers and internet based
job boards is expensive and is a constant challenge to target the narrowly defined candidate
types through mass advertising. This is when social networking becomes an emerging and an
exciting imperative. On the basis of analysis, inferences depicts that many universities still
follow traditional methods of recruitment which is now has lost popularity these days. In
smaller cities, local media like classified newspapers are still used to reach out to the public.
A company has to recognize the potential for social recruiting. Posting and sharing job
openings through social media is more likely to deliver results than a single description on a job
board, so using social media in recruiting results in better ROI than that of traditional recruiting
as the benefits far exceed its cost. Using social networks gives recruiters a competitive
advantage over other talent competitors who aren’t using social media recruiting.
From the above literature, it is concluded that as compared to the traditional methods of
recruiting sources like referrals, recommendation, press advertisement and so on, social media
or social networking approaches can enhance, sort and expand the recruiting market which can
benefit at large.
The main motive of paper is to identify the probable area of improvement for the next
generation to make recruitment and selection more efficient. On the basis of analysis and
answers received from the existing employees the following suggestions are suggested:
Due to lack of time and a busy schedule, it is found that the company website is not updated on
a regular basis. As a result of this, even the positions that have been closed long back appear in
the open vacancies. Candidates keep calling for the vacancies which have already been filled.
The IT personnel should be taken into consideration by the HR department. Further, the
candidate should be informed about the final result on the same day, or at the earliest, so that
qualified candidates do not shift to any other job.
Delay occurs when the candidates are called for an interview in the midst of a tight schedule.
Sometimes it happens that on the dates of the interview, the candidate might not turn up, owing
to existing work schedules. This delay occurs due to hectic schedule of the candidates. Instead
of calling for a face to face session, they can conduct telephonic or video conferencing chats as
an interview. So, by adopting new ways of resourcing, greater efficiency can be ensured.
In the broader perspective, Universities must keep the recruitment and selection on top priority
basis, as this is a real base for the social and economic development of any society and country.
Job posting is the very beginning of the recruiting process and needs to explain the open
position well in order to attract the best candidates and to retain them. Instead of just listing the
needed education, experience and training, it should also include the day-to-day activities of the
position. Social media is considered as supplement to traditional hiring strategies, not a
replacement for them. 70% of hiring managers say they’ve successfully hired with social and
now 89% of companies plan to recruit on social media.
With the help of social networking sites, candidates can see and prepare themselves for
the interview after getting to know who they will be competing with the job arena.
Periscope
Periscope allows you to set up a live video stream from your phone anywhere you can connect,
and give others access to that live stream. Many companies have been using it for prospective
candidates, and recruiters are catching on to it as well. Social media platforms are cost-effective
recruitment tools with a more direct and focused approach in today’s technologically vibrant
age. It is used to share your company culture with potential applicants by broadcasting company
events or a live video stream of your workplace. It only works on phones with iOS or Android
installed, and must also pair with Twitter.
Introducing an App
Introducing an app like a website portal for a vacant position will help the candidates to track
their application for which positions they have applied. They can easily get the access on
updated new job vacancies and they can also refer to the HR policy with their terms and
conditions. Introducing an app can also be a source of marketing for the University. It will
benefit not only the human resource recruiter but also to the placement offices that are using this
app for their students’ career and placement.
References
1. Hopkins, B and Markham, J. (2003). E-HR: using intranets to improve the effectiveness
of your people. Gower Publishing, Ltd.
2. Hart, C., Doherty, N and Ellis-Chadwick, F. (2000). Retailer adoption of the Internet
Implications for retail marketing. European Journal of Marketing, 34(8), pp. 954-974.
3. Sharmin, S. (2015). Recruitment and selection process in the public and private
universities of Dhaka city in Bangladesh: A comparative study. International journal of
management and business studies, 5(3), pp. 31-37.
4. Lal, V. and Aggarwal, S. (2013). Analyzing the effect of social media on recruitment.
International journal of management and social sciences research, 2(9), pp. 37-41.
5. Recruiting through social media. (2012, September 12). Retrieved from
http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-features/tp-opportunities/recruiting-through-
social-media/article3886953.ece
6. Ofori, D. and Aryeetey, M. (2011). Recruitment and selection practices in small and
medium enterprises. International Journal of Business Administration, 2(3), pp. 45-60.
7. Samuel, O. A. and Nyarko, K. (2014). Leveraging information technology (IT) in
recruitment and selection processes – A comparative study. International journal of
network and communication research, 2(1), pp. 16-44.
8. Wolmer, F. (2012). The impact of social media in the recruitment process: An
employer’s perspective. Master of Science in management.
9. Penttila, C. (2009, July 01). Entrepreneur. Retrieved from www.entrepreneur.com:
http:\\www.entrepreneur.com/article/202466
10. Srikrishna, N. P. (2012, Sept 05). The Hindu. Retrieved from www.thehindu.com:
http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-features/tp-opportunities/social-media-plays-
a-crucial-role-in-recruitment/article3860317.ece
11. Information Resource Management Association (2016). Social media and networking:
concepts, methodologies, tools, and applications. USA: Information science reference.
Retrieved from https://books.google.co.in/books?
id=IYkfCgAAQBAJ&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false
12. Vicknair, J., Elkersh, D., Yancey, K., and Budden, M. (2010). The use of social
networking sites as a recruiting tool for employers. American Journal of Business
Education, 3 (11), pp. 7-12.
13. Faruqui, G.A. and S. Islam. 2005. Evaluation of Faculty’s Job Satisfaction in Private
Universities. Journal of Business Studies, 1(2), pp. 67-82.
14. Hellriegel, D., W.J Slocum., and W.R. Woodman. 1995. Organizational Behavior. St.
Paul: West Publishing Company
15. Bennett.L.”Making Labor Law in Australia: Industrial Relation, Politics and Law:
Sydney, 1994.
16. Lal, V. and Aggarwal, S. (2013). Analyzing the effect of social media on Recruitment.
International journal of management and social science research, 2(9), pp. 37-41.
17. Rynes, S.L. and Barber, A.E. (1990) Applicant Attraction Strategies: An organizational
perspective. Academy of Management Review, 15, pp. 286–310.
18. Carless, S. A. (2007). Graduate recruitment and selection in Australia. International
Journal of Selection and Assessment, 15(2), pp. 153-166.
19. Abel, S. (2011, May 12). The role of social networking sites in recruitment: Results of a
quantitative study among German companies. Retrieved from essay.utwente.nl:
http://essay.utwente.nl/61154/1Msc_S_Abel.pdf
20. Schmidt F. The validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology:
Practical and theoretical implications of 85 years of research findings. Psychological
Bulletin 1998; pp. 262-274.
21. Valvis, M. (2005), Personnel Management: Changes and company’s action programs,
Propomdos: Athens.
22. Tyson, S. and Selbie, D. (2004).People processing systems and human resource strategy.
International Journal of Human Resource Development and Management, 4(2), pp. 117-
127.
23. Ben, (2016, May 31). Fresh perspectives: a conversation on social media and the job
market. Retrieved from https://updocmedia.com/socialmedia-and-jobmarket/
24. Betterteam, (2016, Oct, 04). 15 social recruiting tips proven to attract the best talent.
Retrieved from https://www.betterteam.com/blog/social-recruiting-tips.
25. Johansson, A. (2016, May 11). How social media has changed the way that we engage
consumers. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.in/entry/how-social-media-has-
changed-the-way-that-we-engage-consumers_b_9874242.