Assessment of Sustainable Tourism Development in Mt. Pamitinan

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 78

ASSESSMENT OF SUSTAINABLE

TOURISM DEVELOPMENT
IN MT. PAMITINAN

A Research
Presented to the Faculty of
Tourism and Hospitality Management
STI College Cubao

In Partial Fulfilment
of the Requirements of the Degree
Bachelor of Science in Tourism Management

John Cyrus B. Corrales


Mariah Christianne P. Reotutar
Zuzanne S. Segismar
Jasmin Denise B. Sta. Cruz

January 18, 2022

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao i


ENDORSEMENT FORM FOR FINAL DEFENSE

TITLE OF RESEARCH: Assessment of Sustainable Tourism Development in Mt.

Pamitinan

NAME OF PROPONENTS:

In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements


for the degree Bachelor of Science in Tourism Management
has been examined and is recommended for Final Defense.

ENDORSED BY:
Athena Y. Jacinto
Research Adviser

APPROVED FOR FINAL DEFENSE:


Nicka G. Romero

Research Coordinator

NOTED BY:

Kenneth Bryann Aliser

Program Head

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao ii


January 18, 2022

APPROVAL SHEET

This research entitled: Assessment of Sustainable Tourism Development in Mt. Pamitinan


prepared and submitted by John Cyrus B. Corrales, Mariah Christianne P. Reotutar,
Zuzanne S. Segismar. Jasmin Denise B. Sta. Cruz, in partial fulfillment of the Bachelor of
Science degree requirements in Tourism Management, has been examined and is recommended
for acceptance and approval.

Athena Y. Jacinto
Research Adviser

Accepted and approved by the Research Panel


in Partial Fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
Bachelor of Science in Tourism Management

<Panelist’s Given Name MI. Family Name> <Panelist’s Given Name MI. Family
Name>
Panel Member Panel Member

<Panelist’s Given Name MI. Family Name>


Lead Panelist

NOTED BY:

Jose Danilo Jabon


Academic Head

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao iii


January 18, 2022

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The researchers would like to thank the following:

Mrs. Nicka G. Romero, Research Coordinator, for her valuable remarks and ideas for the study's

enrichment, as well as for giving us a long period of time to go through with this paper.

Ms. Athena Y. Jacinto, Thesis Adviser, for her unwavering support and encouragement during

this study, who gave her love and care to the researchers. The authors are very thankful for

having such a good adviser like you.

Mr. Jerome P. Dumlao, Statistician, for sharing his knowledge and assisted with data analysis,

and statistical computations for the study.

Research Panelists, for their brilliant thoughts and critique.

To the Parents and/or Guardian of the Researchers, for their support in whatever endeavors the

researchers have and just being a constant support-system through thick and thin.

Friends and inspirations, for being the light in the dark during difficulties and struggles.

Tourists, Locals, and the LGU of Rizal, for lending some of their precious time in giving their

responses to the survey.

Above all, to the Almighty God, whose infinite wisdom provided us with the courage to

overcome adversity and finish the study successfully. All praise to the Most Gracious!

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao iv


ABSTRACT

Title of Research: Assessment of Sustainable Tourism Development in Mt. Pamitinan

Researchers: John Cyrus B. Corrales, Mariah Christianne P. Reotutar, Zuzanne S.

Segismar, and Jasmin Denise B. Sta. Cruz

Degree: Bachelor of Science in Tourism Management

Date of Completion: May 2022

The tourism industry in the Philippines has been considered as one of the main engines for a
robust and sustainable economic growth. Ecotourism is becoming increasingly popular due of its
long-term viability. This paper discusses the sustainable tourism development in Mt. Pamitinan
focused on three concepts: Social, Economic, and Environmental. The three pillars of sustainable
tourism development are the most prevalent names for these three components. The researchers
believe that these three pillars are critical in assessing the sustainable tourism development in
Mt. Pamitinan. The variables used by the LGU of Rizal to analyze growth in Mt. Pamitinan and
their future intentions for the site are also discussed in this study. Tourism is deemed to be a
well-established sector in the Philippines that contributes to the country’s inclusive economic
growth. The sustained united efforts of all in the execution of all offered strategies would
undoubtedly strengthen Mt. Pamitinan’s sustainable tourism development.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao v


TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page

Title Page i
Endorsement Form for Final Defense ii
Approval Sheet iii
Acknowledgements iv
Abstract v
Table of Contents vi
List of Tables vii
List of Figures viii
Chapter I: Introduction 1
Background of the Study 2
Research Questions 3
Significance of the Study 4
Scope and Limitations
6
Chapter II: Review of Related Literature 7
Chapter III: Theoretical/Conceptual Framework 20
Chapter IV: Research Methodology 23
Chapter V: Presentation and Discussion of Findings 26
Chapter VI: Conclusions and Recommendations 51
References 54
Appendices 56

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao vi


LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
1 Profile of Respondents According to Age 26
2 Profile of Respondents According to Gender 27
3 Profile of Respondents According to Type of Respondent 28
4 Profile of Respondents According to Location 28
5 Perception of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism Development 29
According to Social Pillar
6 Perception of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism Development 30
According to Economic Pillar
7 Perception of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism Development 32
According to Environmental Pillar
8 Grand Mean of Perceptions of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism 34
Development According to the Three Pillars
9 Applicable Factors that Rizal LGUs Use to Assess Development in Mt. 35
Pamitinan
10 Planned Activities of Rizal LGUs for the Development of Mt. Pamitinan 37

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao vii


LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
1 Study’s Conceptual Framework 21

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao viii


FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao ix
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION

The UN Environment Program and the UN World Tourism Organization describe

sustainable tourism as “tourism that addresses the requirements of tourists, the industry, the

environment, and host communities while taking full account of its present and future economic,

social, and environmental implications.” Furthermore, they state that sustainable tourism “refers

to the environmental, economic, and socio-cultural aspects of tourism development, and that a

suitable balance must be established between these three dimensions to ensure its long-term

sustainability” (UNEP & UNWTO, 2005: 11-12. Making Tourism More Sustainable – A Guide

for Policy Makers).

When people think about sustainable tourism, they usually think of how it affects the

environment. However, it also considers the current and future economic, social, and

environmental effects of its operations. There is a lot to consider in order to properly integrate

sustainability into tourism, from laws and regulations to local people and visitor demand. As a

result, it is critical to consider sustainable tourism not just from the standpoint of the tourism

operator, but also from the perspective of the individual tourist. To guarantee that sustainable

tourism thrives, every gear in the machine must function properly.

There are several significant advantages to committing to sustainable tourism, the three

primary overarching points being: protecting the environment, economic benefits for the

location, and support for local communities. Not only that, but sustainable tourism has the added

benefit of promoting sustainable mobility, which means that activities may continue and are

more long term. Supporting the environment is critical to tourism’s long-term viability. When

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 1


giving an experience to visitors, concerns like waste, pollution, and the usage of non-organic

items, as well as over tourism, must be considered.

Local communities benefit from this sort of tourism as well, since being included in the

decision-making process for tourist development guarantees that they are protected from

inflation, their culture is preserved, and they profit from the income streams that tourism brings

to the region. It has the potential to help the region develop and remain safe in the tourism

industry. It is obvious that this then becomes a positive cycle, with advantages for all parties

involved.

Background of the Study

It is obvious that tourism’s long-term viability depends on its capacity to be sustainable.

Over-tourism has been a problem in certain regions, where a large number of visitors visit one

location, necessitating the construction of more accommodations and activities. As a result,

natural areas and resources are redirected for tourists, putting local species at risk and forcing

communities to compete for few resources. As a result, sustainable tourism is critical for the

industry’s development to continue and prosper. Sustainable tourism has been on the rise, with

the United Nations declaring 2017 the International Year of Sustainable Tourism for

Development. Today, as the coronavirus continues to postpone tourist, the benefits of reduced

tourism are becoming evident.

In connection with this, the researchers decided to search for a place that will greatly

benefit from this kind of tourism. And upon reviewing various locations, the researchers wound

up upon Mt. Pamitinan, the mountain of folklore and freedom. It is said that it is at the foot of

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 2


Mt. Pamitinan that the Katipunan Supremo himself, Andres Bonifacio, tore cedulas and cried out

“Viva La Independencia Filipinas!” as early as 1985. This just shows that other than the

picturesque and wonderful scenery that the mountain offers, it also has a historical significance.

Mt. Pamitinan is a fantastic day-hiking destination due to its accessibility to Manilla (it is

only two hours away) and the variety of activities offered there. Like Mt. Manalmon, one may go

spelunking in Pamitinan Cave and the so-called Bat Cave while still having time to climb Mt.

Binacayan, a peak that is about the same height. Mt. Pamitinan is only 426 meters above sea

level; therefore, it is merely a short trek. The challenge, on the other hand, comes from

bouldering and scrambling among the trail’s jagged limestone outcrops. Gloves, as well as a

positive attitude, are required for certain pseudo-rock climbing.

For a variety of reasons, the researchers chose Mt. Pamitinan as the location or topic of

their study. The first is that, despite the fact that Mt. Pamitinan is easily accessible and provides a

variety of eco-friendly activities, only a small percentage of the population is aware of it,

implying that it has to be promoted more. Second, when it comes to development, Mt. Pamitinan

is still not at its peak. Despite the fact that it is currently operational and a popular tourist

destination due to the stunning views it provides, the researchers feel that the area could be

improved further, therefore the assessment of sustainable tourism development in Mt. Pamitinan.

Research Questions

This study aims to assess the sustainable tourism development in Mt. Pamitinan.

Specifically, this study seeks answers to the following questions:

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 3


1. What is the demographic profile of the respondents in terms of:

1.1 Age

1.2 Gender

1.3 Location

1.4 Type of Respondent?

2. What is the perception of the respondents towards sustainable tourism development

according to the three pillars:

2.1 Social

2.2 Economic

2.3 Environmental?

3. What are the factors that the Local Government Unit of Rizal uses to assess the

development of Mt. Pamitinan?

4. What plans does the Local Government Unit of Rizal has in store for the development of

Mt. Pamitinan?

Significance of the Study

The results of the study may benefit the following:

The Researchers. For aspiring tourism professionals such as researchers, being a rookie in

this field is a difficulty. As a result, this will be a tool that will lead and steer them in identifying

trustworthy, dependable, and crucial aspects that are recognized as vital facts for gaining a better

knowledge of the subject. Indeed, this research will be a significant source of information for

them in their future studies.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 4


The Tourists. It is important to state that not all tourists are aware of sustainable

development that have a significant impact on the performance of a tourist attraction. This study

will act as a source and guide for them in the future if they want assistance or information about

tourism locations.

The Provincial Tourism Department of Rizal. Assessing the sustainable tourism

evelopment to further promote Mt. Pamitinan will be of benefit to the provincial tourism

department of Rizal. Through this study, and through the practical realization of the possible

results, the rise and improvement of Mt. Pamitinan as a tourist attraction will encourage more

tourists to visit the place.

The Tourism Industry. This study will also assist the tourist sector because the possible

improvement brought by the assessment of sustainable tourism destinations in Mt. Pamitinan

might serve as a springboard for improving other tourism attractions around the country. As a

result, if tourism takes off, the economy will reap significant benefits.

The Business Investors. Business investor will likely benefit from this study as they will

have a broader knowledge or an enlightenment about how significant sustainable developments

are when it comes to tourism. Hence, will help them in their decision-making of investments

towards this sector.

The Tourism Students. This research might be used as a study guide or a resource for

tourism students. This article will provide students with a concept or understanding of how to

market tourist attractions, particularly in less developed areas.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 5


Future Researchers. The result of this study can be utilized by other researchers in

understanding the importance of sustainable tourism development in developing tourist

attractions.

Scope and Limitations

This study covered the assessment of sustainable tourism development in Mt. Pamitinan

on the following components: social, economic, and environmental. For this study, the

respondents were those who have been to or have heard about Mt. Pamitinan. Tourists of any

kind were potential respondents, whether they are business tourists, food tourists, adventure

tourists, eco tourists, event visitors, religious tourists, leisure tourists, or medical tourists, as long

as they are familiar with Mt. Pamitinan. As a result, the responders were mostly residents of

Rizal, where Mt. Pamitinan is located, as well as the Local Government Unit (LGU) of Rizal,

which have the authority and more in-depth information about the current development of Mt.

Pamitinan.

The primary aim of this study is to assess the sustainable tourism development in Mt.

Pamitinan. Data gathering was limited to answers generated in a researcher-developed

questionnaire, which was administered to four-hundred and five (405) respondents.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 6


CHAPTER II

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This chapter presents the review of related literature that serve as a basis for this study.

Local Literature

Ecotourism in the Philippines

The Philippines is a fortunate country. Its biodiverse flora and animals serve as a virtual

canvas for a variety of picture-perfect scenes scattered over its 7,107 islands. People from all

over the globe are drawn to the country’s bounty, but they also fall in love with practically all of

the islands they visit, experiencing nature at its best.

The Philippines has struggled as a developing country over the past century. Poverty, a

lack of education and health care, and rampant corruption all led to the deterioration of

Philippine society. Ecotourism became a national endeavor to repair the economy and promote

the welfare of the local people (Olsen,n.d.). Local government authorities have been urged to

embrace and promote related activities in their constituencies as knowledge of ecotourism’s

potential as an alternative method for economic growth has grown.

The Philippines’ tourist business is now divided into three (3) categories: ecotourism,

agritourism, and scientific tourism, with ecotourism receiving the most attention. Ecotourism

promotes the country’s natural resources, whereas agritourism promotes farms and agricultural

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 7


goods. Science tourism has recently gained popularity as a means of showcasing the results of

scientific research and activities from research and development (R&D) institutes across regions.

Redefining Sustainable Tourism in COVID-19

Tourism has developed as an important source of economic growth and development in

many nations throughout the world. However, in the wake of the COVID-19 epidemic, tourism

has been identified as one of the hardest-hit industries (United Nation World Tourism

Organization [UNWTO], 2020). In 2019, tourism accounted for around 10.3% of worldwide

GDP, 6.8% of total exports, and 1 in every 10 employment (330 million jobs) in the global

economy (World Travel and Tourism Council, 2019). Tourism has become equally vital to

emerging economies such as the Philippines, which has included it in its development plan

(Philippine Development Plan 2017-2022). The industry’s overall contribution to GDP was

predicted to be 12.7 percent in 2019. In terms of employment, the tourist industry employs

around 5.7 million people, or 14 out of every 100 Filipinos in the same year (Ilarina, 2020).

Together with remittances from abroad Filipino workers and the business process outsourcing–

information technology industry, it has become an economic pillar of development in the

services sector (Villegas, 2018).

While the industry’s performance has remained unblemished throughout time, experts

stress the importance of growing destinations in a sustainable way—that is, promoting

sustainable tourism (ST). Its importance has grown even more obvious in the middle of the

coronavirus pandemic. Since the introduction of pandemic-prevention measures, such as travel

bans, community quarantines, temporary and/or partial airline shutdowns, and establishment

closures, tourism has experienced significant losses (Organization for Economic Cooperation

and Development, 2020). Travel limitations in the Philippines are predicted to result in a loss of

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 8


revenue. Approximately USD 9.3 billion in foreign currency flows are at stake, putting up to

50,000 employments at risk. Losses in tourism, as a key contributor to the country’s economic

growth, are equivalent to a slowdown. (PricewaterhouseCoopers Philippines [PwC Philippines],

2020) in the national economy.

Developing a Sustainable National Tourism Industry

Through a comparative analysis of the tourist development strategies of Thailand and the

Philippines, Rodolfo (2003) investigated the role of national government in facilitating or

constraining the sustained expansion of the national tourism sector. His research found that the

economic sustainability of tourism is the key driver of both nations’ tourism industries when the

three basic principles of sustainable development were applied to the national tourist industries

of Thailand and the Philippines.

As a result, it’s not surprising that the two nations’ national tourist organizations (NTOs)

have a lot in common when it comes to policy goals. Both nations, for example, have made

concrete initiatives toward achieving long-term tourist growth. Both countries have national

ecotourism strategies in place. In 2001, Thailand created a National Sustainable Tourism Plan,

which currently acts as a guide for the country’s regional provinces and towns. Similarly, the

Philippines’ Tourism Master Plan is dedicated to long-term growth.

Both countries place a strong emphasis on developing local tourism sectors. In addition to

their usual concentration on foreign visitor arrivals, they are now focusing on domestic tourism

as well. However, Rodolfo points out that in the Philippines, some national regulations may

jeopardize the industry’s economic viability by restricting the spread of company operations.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 9


Limited access between major East Asian markets and the Philippines is an example of this.

Regulation has also increased the expenses of doing business in the Philippines for foreign

carriers, which are deemed greater than those of other Asian destinations.

Stakeholder Roles in Sustainable Tourism Development

The Department of Tourism’s aim for Philippine tourism by 2010 is one that

would promote the country as a “top Asian destination,” which will be a job-creating and

revenue-generating business. By 2010, the Department of Transportation hopes to have 5 million

visitors. At least 8.3 million jobs and $17 billion in income are estimated to be created if this

goal is met. The Department of Transportation envisions a tourist industry that is “on a

sustainable growth path that safeguards our land, culture, and people via the development of

tourism” (Gordon 2001). The Department of Transportation is well aware of the magnitude of

the task. As a result, it has called for collaboration between the government (including local

governments) and the corporate sector in order to achieve its aim.

The DOT appears to regard the function of the national tourist body as supporting a

tourism-friendly environment. Former tourism secretary Richard Gordon identified the “three

A’s” of Philippine tourism: attraction, assurance, and accountability during his tenure. He

believes that the DOT, local governments, and the business sector should work together to

achieve these three goals. However, the Department of Transportation’s strategic goals, which

were made public at a series of Travel Industry Congresses (TRICON), appear to be focused

only on two A’s: attraction and assurance. According to the Department of Transportation’s

strategic plans for marketing, planning and development, and tourist standards, most of the

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 10


department’s attention and resources would be focused on raising awareness and recruiting

important market groups. It would also focus on policymaking and enabling access infrastructure

and support services for key destinations (e.g., motorways, airports, police, and sanitation

services). All of this was done to reassure visitors and investors that the nation was quiet and

orderly, and that they could anticipate excellent service.

Political Economy and Sustainable Tourism in the Philippines

Political economy believes that the study of politics and economics are inextricably

linked, or that power and riches are inextricably linked (Underhill, 1991). The political and

economic sides of the tourist business are addressed separately in the literature. There has been a

noticeable lack of research that use a political economics approach to analyzing tourist

development (Bianchi, 2018). Concerns and difficulties suggesting that political economy is

swallowed by the social sciences, including economics, are one possible explanation for the lack

of relationship between tourist research and political economy (Bianchi, 2018). Studies and

recent occurrences, however, have demonstrated the necessity to address this by addressing the

threat of ST via a range of perspectives and methodologies (Ritchie & Jiang, 2019; Zenker &

Kock, 2020).

The use of layers of analysis complements this method. The levels of analysis offer a

theoretical framework for comprehending certain occurrences. The influence is the focus of the

first level of analysis. Individual preferences and behaviors, as well as internal politics, all have a

role in the country’s pursuit of ST. The government’s and domestic institutions’ roles

are highlighted at the second level of study. Finally, the third level of analysis highlights

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 11


the role of the international environment and international institutions (Underhill, 1991). By

distinguishing factors from the individual, state, and international levels, it provides a holistic

and comprehensive analysis of the subject matter.

Foreign Literature

Climate Change, Tourism, and Social Justice

Both global and domestic tourism are intricately interwoven, posing major dangers to

local residents’ livelihood alternatives. They also have a significant influence on carbon

emissions and, as a result, global warming. The national capital’s complicity and the new middle

class’s conspicuous consumerism do not receive appropriate attention in most conversations,

despite the fact that it is a politically and economically significant issue to be reckoned with.

Local movements against exploitative tourism, in our perspective, will need to respond

intelligently to the new phenomena (Sreekumar, 2008).

The localized impact of climate change, in particular how local populations will be

influenced and, in the case of major catastrophes, how they will cope with the challenge of social

and economic rebuilding, is also less contested. Furthermore, capturing the precise links of

global-local climate change interconnections is difficult.

Tourism is an industry that has a wide range of effects on the lives of ordinary people.

Initially, the tourist sector sought to portray itself as a victim of climate change. The main source

of concern was the potential danger of climate change to tourism locations’ long-term viability.

However, later study and reflection correctly emphasized the importance of sending markets in

exacerbating tourism’s detrimental effects on climate change. Citizens and manufacturers in

Northern nations have been scrutinized by the developing world for their disproportionate

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 12


contribution to CO2 emissions at home and abroad, ever since the climate change debate began

to gain traction.

Sustainable Tourism Development and Competitiveness

Travel has become an inextricable element of people’s life. A desire for travel is

unaffected by global issues or the fear of terrorism. In the year 2019, around 1.4 billion people

traveled throughout the world (UNWTO, 2019). However, tourism, like any other economic

sector, not only benefits states economically, but it also causes severe issues such as excessive

energy consumption and increased negative environmental repercussions, such as climate

change. Also, as a result of tourism and travel expansions, environment is being ruined, tourist

locations are suffering from heavy tourist flows, and local people’s quality of life is

deteriorating. To reduce harmful tourist effects, the United Nations Globe Tourism Organization

(UNWTO) declared 2017 the Year of Sustainable Tourism and asked the entire world to travel

while adhering to sustainable tourism principles and supporting local communities (UNWTO,

2017).

According to research (UNWTO, 2017), the modern economy is marked by strong

competitiveness in all areas of business, including tourism. Organizations are required to boost

corporate efficiency, use cutting-edge technology, seek out competitive advantages in products

and services, compete for more market share, and retain the finest experts in order to survive.

When future development is difficult without attracting investment resources, the author

(Smagurauskien, 2009) highlights that organizational management faces a dilemma.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 13


Investment gives a company a competitive edge as well as a potent growth indicator.

According to Smagurauskien (2009), all EU and major global states encourage business growth

in some form or another, with a special focus on the country’s small and medium businesses,

which are considered to create the country’s economic foundation and ensure its stability.

Financial assistance to small and medium-sized businesses is a crucial policy tool for small and

medium-sized businesses.

Sustainable Development of Tourism Destinations

For many nations, tourism has become the primary source of revenue and a means of

survival. As a result, tourism competitiveness issues are closely linked to addressing sustainable

development targets of tourist destinations and providing green tourism services that do not have

a negative impact on the environment, ensure resource savings, and protect the natural

environment, and are based on innovations in green service development. In the event that tourist

flows increase, new companies that provide accommodation, catering, and transportation are

being established. “Strengthening public economic and cultural integration determine the

development of regional tourism, which is inextricably linked to the impact on the economy,

socio-cultural environment, and nature,” writes Zilinskas (2011). “Due to the increasing tourism

demand, municipalities foster tourism, expecting to receive revenue from tourism, to create new

workplaces, and to encourage the development of business service.”

However, mastering the fundamentals of tourist management and implementing

innovations in this sector is required in order to grow a firm. “Tourism management is a difficult

process – it is directly and indirectly tied to numerous sectors (accommodation, catering,

transportation, connections, insurance, etc.) that are designed not only for visitors, but also for

the satisfaction of local people’ needs,” writes Paulauskien (2013). So yet, no efficient

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 14


administration of a tourist industry at the national, regional, or local municipal levels has been

established.” “It is one of the most challenging challenges, solved in practice, that tourist policy

makers face in nations of various economic development levels,” the author says.

The Sustainability Debate

The World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) famously defined

sustainable development as “development that meets the needs of the present without

jeopardizing future generations’ ability to meet their own needs” (WCED, 1987), but many

authors have since developed their own definitions and taken differing positions on the term.

Attempts have been made to classify these notions, resulting in concepts of weak versus strong,

light green versus dark green and techno/anthropocentric versus eco-centric, with the former in

each case taking the view that natural capital may be replaced with human-made capital, whereas

the latter deems natural and human-made capital as incompatible (Haughton and Hunter 1994).

There are common themes that can be combined to provide some ‘principles’ for

sustainable development within this range of definitions and approaches, based on the underlying

notion that future generations should be compensated for reductions in the endowment of

resources caused by current generations’ actions (Pearce et al., 1989). These concepts of futurity,

equity, and environment, according to Haughton and Hunter (1994), must underpin the process

of sustainable development, so that principles of inter- and intra-generational equity, as well as

trans-frontier responsibility, are at the forefront of sustainable development policy.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 15


Sustainability is increasingly being linked to systems thinking (see Bell and Morse, 2003;

Kelly and Baker, 2002; Bakkes, 1997), in which sustainability is viewed as a framework for

change management. Systems thinking emphasizes thinking about cause and effect as well as

inter-relationships between elements (following Senge et al., 1994 in Kelly and Baker, 2002).

Sustainable Tourism Development and Economic Growth

On a global and local level, tourism is a rapidly increasing and economically essential

business. It has essential economic, social, and cultural significance, as well as real potential for

long-term, inclusive growth. The importance of this industry is such that, before to the

introduction of COVID-19, the number of tourist journeys made each year had surpassed the

global population. In 2019, international visitor arrivals surpassed 1.5 billion, an increase of 3.8

percent over the previous year. Similarly, this amount is predicted to climb, with 1.8 billion

foreign tourists expected by 2030, albeit this figure may be changed depending on the impact of

the COVID-19 pandemic (Gomez, 2021). Tourism has established itself as a vital engine of

economic growth after six decades of continuous expansion. In this regard, it’s worth noting that

the travel and tourism industry grew by 3.5 percent in 2019, outpacing the world economy’s 2.5

percent growth for the ninth year in a row. From a different viewpoint, the industry directly

provides 4.4 percent of GDP, 6.9 percent of employment, and 21.5 percent of service exports in

nations that are members of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development

(OECD).

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 16


COVID-19’s negative consequences, on the other hand, are not confined to the loss of

human lives; they also encompass short- and long-term social, economic, and political

consequences. With ramifications for international tourism, a longer and more intensive COVID-

19 is predicted to lower global growth to 1.5 percent in 2020, which is half of the projected

growth rate before 2020. According to the International Monetary Fund, the COVID-19

epidemic could spark a worldwide recession in 2020 that might be worse than the one caused by

the global financial crisis of 2008–2009. Similarly, the COVID-19 epidemic will have substantial

ramifications for worldwide tourism, with significant implications for numerous countries’

economic development and prosperity.

Culture and Heritage in Sustainable Tourism Development

Culture is a very hard concept. It has long been a prominent topic in academic study, and

it has been researched in a variety of domains. Yaprak (2008) uses the idea of culture at the

national or societal level to illustrate the 'values, beliefs, conventions, and behavioral patterns of

a national group,' as described by Leung, Bhagat, Buchan, Erez, and Gibson (2005).

The adoption of sustainable tourism practices is influenced by a wide range of elements,

including social, cultural, and economic concerns at each level of the tourist sector (Day & Cai,

2012). Individual attitudes, which are frequently impacted by culture, play a significant role in

understanding the viewpoints of residents and other stakeholders on sustainable tourism (Chen &

Jim, 2010; Liu, Ouyang, & Miao, 2010). As an example, the Chinese have a 'harmony approach

characterized by respect for environment and love for people' (Wang & Heikki, 2009).

Furthermore, cultural and heritage objectives are reflected in China's methods to sustainable

development in cities and villages (Zhao, Wang, Fu, Wang, & Zhang, 2011).

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 17


The Brief Review of Sustainable Tourism

Since the late 1980s, sustainable tourism development has received substantial attention

in various scientific studies, notably in tourism studies, and has been one of the most rapidly

increasing fields of tourist studies study. According to Buckley (2012), the phrase "sustainable

tourism" was coined about two decades ago. During the first decade, basic frameworks from

tourism, economics, and environmental management backgrounds were examined. Sharpley

(2000), Gossling (2002), Liu (2003), Saarinen (2006), Lane (2009b), and Liu (2003) were among

those who reconceptualized and critiqued the second decade (2013). According to Bramwell and

Lane, the two most important pioneers of these concepts in the tourism industry, sustainable

tourism emerged in part as a negative and reactive concept in response to numerous tourism

issues, such as environmental damage and serious impacts on society and traditional cultures

(Bramwell & Lane, 1993). Tourism development has gradually come to be considered as a

solution capable of bringing about good change through the concepts of sustainable tourism.

Sustainable tourism has played an essential role in discovering strategies to achieve beneficial

outcomes, as have established regulatory and development control techniques (Bramwell &

Lane, 2012).

Sustainability and sustainable development are defined in a variety of ways. The most

well-known definition of sustainable development is "development that fulfills the demands of

the present without jeopardizing future generations' ability to satisfy their own needs" (WCED,

1987). This formulation indicates the interdependence of economic progress, environmental

conservation, and social fairness, with one part encouraging the others. According to the World

Tourism Organization (WTO), sustainable development is defined as follows:

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 18


Sustainable tourism development satisfies the demands of current visitors and host places

while also safeguarding and expanding future prospects. It is envisioned that it will lead to the

management of all resources in such a way that economic, social, and aesthetic requirements

may be met while preserving cultural integrity, critical ecological processes, biological variety,

and life support systems.

The precise definition of' sustainability' is highlighted by Liu (2013), which implies the

significant role of states in preparing a steady progress in life conditions for future generations;'

sustainable development' is more process-oriented and associated with managed changes that

cause improvements in conditions for those involved in such development; and' sustainable

tourism' is defined as all types of tourism that are compatible with or contribute to sustainable

development. 'Sustainable tourism' necessitates both the long-term expansion of tourism's

contribution to the economy and society, as well as the long-term use of resources and the

environment, all of which will be acquired via a thorough knowledge and effective management

of tourism demand (Liu, 2013). Tourism development, according to Liu (1994), is a dynamic

process of aligning tourism resources to the wants and preferences of present or future tourists.

Eco-system and Eco-tourism

Ecotourism is one of the world's fastest growing tourism industries (WTO, 2003).

Ecotourism is frequently seen as a sort of nature-based tourism and has piqued the interest of

travelers as an alternative type of tourism. According to Ayala (1995), ecotourism is "tourism

that allows for the pleasure and knowledge of a destination's nature and culture while creating

economic advantages and actively supporting environmental protection." Ecotourism

management has several obstacles, including building a viable and environmentally sustainable

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 19


enterprise while also providing a gratifying experience for guests and raising living conditions in

the host community (Lim & McAleer, 2005).

The rise of the tourist sector, particularly in developing nations, has been poorly planned

and foreseen, resulting in the deterioration, depletion, and, in some cases, entire loss of key

economy-supporting natural resources (Baker, 1997; Obua & Harding, 1997; Shackley, 1996).

As a result, emphasizing sustainability is reasonable since it leads to ecologically sensitive tourist

development and the conservation of natural resources from the negative environmental

consequences of tourism.

CHAPTER III

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK /CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK

This chapter presents the theoretical framework and the conceptual framework of the

study that the researchers utilized in pursuing the aim of assessing the sustainable tourism

development in Mt. Pamitinan.

Theoretical Framework

This study was anchored on the theory of sustainable tourism development. In the

tourism industry, sustainable development entails two major considerations: preserving the

natural environment, resources, and biodiversity, as well as preserving live cultural heritage and

customs. The state, companies, and local communities should work together to establish

sustainable tourist development initiatives. The tactics must be centered on maximizing potential

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 20


good outcomes while avoiding or reducing potential negative consequences. Impact monitoring

and assessment systems, as well as performance indicators, must be established. Tourism is

demonstrated to contribute to producing foreign exchange revenues, providing jobs and income,

and increasing domestic consumption when it grows as a result of a professionally developed and

managed strategy.

It also benefits the host communities’ social and cultural growth. Smaller and emerging

nations that specialize in tourism enjoy better economic development than countries that do not

have a substantial tourism industry, according to studies. The contribution of tourism to national

economies may be precisely and simply assessed using modern economic and statistical

methodologies, which can be used as an indicator in analyzing the impact and impacts of tourist

expansion.

Sustainable tourism is known to have three pillars: social justice, economic growth, and

environmental integrity. The belief that everyone deserves equal economic, political, and social

rights is known as social justice. As a result, one of the objectives of sustainable tourism is to

achieve equity and to be future proof. Economic growth, on the other hand, is the goal of most

types of tourism, and it ensures that tourism will assist the country’s economy thrive. Finally,

environmental integrity, which is synonymous with sustainable tourism, encompasses a wide

range of notions that characterize a healthy natural system capable of supporting critical

activities.

The three pillars are the variables that was analyzed in conjunction with the study

because the above-mentioned pillars are crucial when it comes to measuring the sustainable

tourism development in Mt. Pamitinan.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 21


Conceptual Framework

This research attempts to assess the sustainable tourism development in Mt. Pamitinan, as

well as some of the elements that have a significant impact on its development. This study was

implemented using the Input-Process-Output (IPO) paradigm. As shown in Figure 1, the variable

of this study is reflected in the stated model.

INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT

 Participating  Data collection of the The proposed guideline to

respondents (Locals respondents’ profile. further develop the

and LGU of Rizal)  Administering sustainable tourism at Mt.

 Demographic Profile questionnaires. Pamitinan.

 Perception of  Organization of

sustainable tourism respondents’

development in terms responses.

of:  Statistical Analysis of

 Social data.

 Economic

 Environmental

Figure 1 – Study’s Conceptual Framework

The study used the IPO model as a basis for assessing the sustainable tourism

development in Mt. Pamitinan with the input being the participating respondents and their

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 22


demographic profile, their perception of sustainable tourism development based on social,

economic, and environmental components.

Data collection of the respondents’ profile, administering questionnaires, organization of

respondents’ responses, and the statistical analysis of the data are all part of the process.

The study’s output is the creation of guidelines based on the findings.

Chapter IV

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This chapter discusses the necessary procedures, tools, and method necessary to gather

the required data that will answer the problem of this study. Specifically, this covers the research

design, the respondents of the study, the data gathering instruments, and data gathering

procedures.

Research Design

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 23


The descriptive research approach was used in this study. According to Nassaji (2015),

descriptive research entails gathering data in order to test a hypothesis or answer questions about

respondents’ status. It is a type of study that determines and describes how observations are

made.

To identify and explain the demographic features of the respondents, as well as their

perceptions on sustainable tourism development in terms of social, economic, and environmental

components, a descriptive study approach using a survey was used.

Participants of the Study

The study had the tourists, locals, and the LGU of Rizal as the respondents of the study.

According to the 2020 census, Rizal has a population of 3,330,143. Since it is impossible

to cover all of these potential respondents, the researcher decided to employ a stratified

sampling. Since there are three categories of respondents: tourists, locals of Rizal, and the LGU

of the same province, the researcher divided the three categories according to their group. Since

there are a total of four-hundred and five (405) respondents, 50.5% will came from the locals of

Rizal, 43.8% came from the tourists, and 5.4% came from the LGU. Hence, there were 205

locals, 178 tourists, and 22 respondents from the Local Government Unit.

From here on, the random sampling technique was employed.

Data Gathering Instrument

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 24


In this study, a survey questionnaire was employed. There were four (4) sections to the

survey questionnaire. The demographic profile of the respondents is the first part. The second

section focused on the respondents’ perceptions of Mt. Pamitinan’s development in terms of the

three pillars of sustainable tourism development: social, economic, and environmental. The

Likert scale was used to measure perception. The third section is about the factors that the LGU

of Rizal uses in assessing the development of Mt. Pamitinan. The fourth part is about the plans of

the LGU of Rizal in the further development of Mt. Pamitinan. The third and fourth section was

only answered by the LGU respondents. The survey took no longer than fifteen (15) minutes to

complete. The identities of the respondents were kept anonymous.

The questionnaires were proofread and checked to ensure that all of the information

needed to assess Mt. Pamitinan’s sustainable tourism development is collected. It was also pre-

tested on friends and acquainted locals of Rizal to ensure clarity and that the study’s research

topics are addressed.

Data Gathering Procedure

This study is being suggested during a pandemic, when people’s movements and

gatherings are restricted because of quarantine restrictions. As a result, the researcher used online

questionnaires to gather data. A formal letter was sent to the respondents notifying them of the

survey’s purpose. A permission letter was also sent to the STI College Cubao administration,

notifying them of the survey’s conduct.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 25


Google forms was utilized for the online survey. The form was formally emailed to the

respondents who have been chosen.

The anonymity of the respondents was protected by the researcher by not collecting their

names or publishing any information about their responses that may indicate their identity. The

survey took place at a time that is convenient for the respondents. Before each survey is

completed, the researcher explained its purpose and how it will be used to tackle a specific

problem. The participants were then asked if they still want to participate.

Statistical Treatment of Data

After the participation period has ended, statistical analysis was performed on variables

selected from the survey to establish areas of importance and to answer the study’s research

objectives.

The demographic profile was be analyzed using descriptive statistics in the form of a

frequency and percentage table. The respondents’ perceptions on Mt. Pamitinan’s development

and the three pillars of sustainable tourism development was evaluated using descriptive

statistics such as mean and standard deviation. The t-test was used to generate inferences,

conclusions, and recommendations based on the results.

CHAPTER V

PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION OF FINDINGS

The aim of this research was to assess the sustainable tourism development in Mt.

Pamitinan. The three pillars of sustainable tourism, namely social justice, economic

development, and environmental integrity were taken into account in this study and served as the

foundation for analyzing the sustainable tourist development in Mt. Pamitinan.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 26


In chapter 4, we reviewed the questionnaire that was created as a tool to validate the

components of the three pillars. The questionnaire's objective was not only to collect data for this

thesis, but also to identify areas of the subject for future research.

This chapter contains a full discussion of the findings of the data collected via

questionnaires in order to address the study questions stated in Chapter 1. The sample profile is

summarized in the first section of this chapter, and the remainder of the sections are the results,

which are presented separately for each study topic. It should be noted that some of the questions

are essentially theoretical in nature and have been treated as such. When additional queries

required empirical proof, relevant tables and diagrams were employed to summarize the findings.

Demographic profile of the respondents according to age, gender, location.

Table 1

Profile of Respondents According to Age

f %
15-20 years old 149 36.79%
21-30 years old 180 44.44%
31-40 years old 33 8.15%
41-50 years old 24 5.93%
Above 50 years old 19 4.69%
Total 405 100%

Table 1 above shows the profile of the respondents according to age. The results showed

that 180 respondents or 44.44% belonged to the 21-30 years old age bracket. 149 (36.79%) were

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 27


in the 15-20 years old bracket. The 31-40 age bracket had 33 (8.15%) respondents while the 41-

50 years old had 24 (5.93%). 19 respondents or 4.69% were above 50 years old.

This table shows that most of the respondents, which are the people who have heard or

been to Mt. Pamitinan are the tourists, local residents, or LGU ages from 21-30 years old.

Table 2

Profile of Respondents According to Gender

f %
Male 178 43.95%
Female 193 47.65%
LGBTQIA+ 14 3.46%
Prefer Not To Say 20 4.94%
Total 405 100%

Table 2 reveals the profile of the respondents according to gender. Of the 405

respondents, 193 or 47.65% were female and that 178 or 43.95% were classified as males. There

were 20 or 4.94% who Preferred Not to Say what their gender was. Finally, 14 or 3.46% reported

that they were members of the LGBTQIA+ community. Based on this table, we can conclude

that most respondents are female.

Table 3

Profile of Respondents According to Type of Respondent

f %
Locals 205 50.62%
Tourists 178 43.95%
Local Government Unit of Rizal 22 5.43%
Total 405 100%

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 28


Table 3 reveals the profile of the respondents according to the type of respondent. Of the

405 respondents, 205 or 50.62% were locals and 178 or 43.95% were classified as males. There

were 22 or 5.43% who were Local Government Units of the province of Rizal. This table shows

that among three types of respondents, most respondents came from the locals of Rizal, followed

by the tourists, and then the LGU.

Table 4

Profile of Respondents According to Location

f %
Angono 4 0.99%
Antipolo 24 5.93%
Baras 2 0.49%
Binangonan 7 1.73%
Cainta 11 2.72%
Cardona 3 0.74%
Jala-jala 2 0.49%
Morong 2 0.49%
Others 82 20.25%
Pasig 40 9.88%
Real 11 2.72%
Rodriguez 161 39.75%
San Mateo 31 7.65%
Tanay 6 1.48%
Taytay 17 4.20%
Teresa 2 0.49%
Total 405 100%

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 29


Table 4 presents the profile of the respondents according to Location. 161 of the

respondents or 39.75% disclosed that they were from Rodriguez. 82 or 20.25% reported that they

came from other places. 40 of the respondents or 9.88% said that they were residing in Pasig. 31

or 7.65% mentioned that they came from San Mateo. 24 of the respondents or 5.93% hailed from

Antipolo while 17 or 4.20% were from Taytay. Meanwhile, Cainta and Real had 11 or 2.72%

respondents each. Binangonan had 7 (1.73%) respondents, Tanay with 6 (1.48%), Agono listed 4

(.99%), and Cardona reportedly had 3 (0.74%) respondents. Baras, Jala-jala, Morong, and Teresa

each had 2 (0.49%) respondents.

B. Perceptions of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism Development According


to the Three Pillars

Table A1

Perceptions of Tourists Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Social Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
promoting the culture of the 4.0787 Somewhat Agree
people in Rizal.
2. Mt. Pamitinan ensures a satisfying
and rewarding experience for the 4.1966 Somewhat Agree
tourists.
3. Mt. Pamitinan have a positive
impact on preserving the culture in 4.0281 Somewhat Agree
Rizal.
4. Mt. Pamitinan enlightens the
tourists or potential tourists
3.9157 Somewhat Agree
regarding the cultural and
historical heritage of the site
5. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
improving the quality of life for 4.1124 Somewhat Agree
the local community
6. Mt. Pamitinan supports local 3.9494 Somewhat Agree

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 30


projects for the betterment of the
local community
7. Mt. Pamitinan provides the local
community with long-term 3.9157 Somewhat Agree
promotional benefits.
8. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the
development of the local 4.0730 Somewhat Agree
community.
9. Mt. Pamitinan promotes positive
3.9438 Somewhat Agree
changes in values and customs.
10. Mt. Pamitinan increases demand
3.9438 Somewhat Agree
for historical and cultural exhibits.

Grand Mean 4.0157 Somewhat Agree

Table A2

Perceptions of Local Residents Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Social Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
promoting the culture of the 4.2927 Strongly Agree
people in Rizal.
2. Mt. Pamitinan ensures a satisfying
and rewarding experience for the 4.4000 Strongly Agree
tourists.
3. Mt. Pamitinan have a positive
impact on preserving the culture in 4.2780 Strongly Agree
Rizal.
4. Mt. Pamitinan enlightens the
tourists or potential tourists
4.2390 Strongly Agree
regarding the cultural and
historical heritage of the site
5. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
improving the quality of life for 4.2390 Strongly Agree
the local community
6. Mt. Pamitinan supports local
projects for the betterment of the 4.2244 Strongly Agree
local community
7. Mt. Pamitinan provides the local
community with long-term 4.1415 Somewhat Agree
promotional benefits.
8. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the 4.2439 Strongly Agree

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 31


development of the local
community.
9. Mt. Pamitinan promotes positive
4.1220 Somewhat Agree
changes in values and customs.
10. Mt. Pamitinan increases demand
3.9902 Somewhat Agree
for historical and cultural exhibits.

Grand Mean 4.2171 Strongly Agree

Table A3

Perceptions of Local Government Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Social Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
promoting the culture of the 4.5909 Strongly Agree
people in Rizal.
2. Mt. Pamitinan ensures a satisfying
and rewarding experience for the 4.5000 Strongly Agree
tourists.
3. Mt. Pamitinan have a positive
impact on preserving the culture in 4.4394 Strongly Agree
Rizal.
4. Mt. Pamitinan enlightens the
tourists or potential tourists
4.3939 Strongly Agree
regarding the cultural and
historical heritage of the site
5. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
improving the quality of life for 4.4091 Strongly Agree
the local community
6. Mt. Pamitinan supports local
projects for the betterment of the 4.4091 Strongly Agree
local community
7. Mt. Pamitinan provides the local
community with long-term 4.4697 Strongly Agree
promotional benefits.
8. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the
development of the local 4.3939 Strongly Agree
community.
9. Mt. Pamitinan promotes positive
4.4242 Strongly Agree
changes in values and customs.
10. Mt. Pamitinan increases demand
4.3788 Strongly Agree
for historical and cultural exhibits.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 32


Grand Mean 4.4409 Strongly Agree

Table 5

Perceptions of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Social Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
promoting the culture of the 4.2247 Strongly Agree
people in Rizal.
2. Mt. Pamitinan ensures a satisfying
and rewarding experience for the 4.3185 Strongly Agree
tourists.
3. Mt. Pamitinan have a positive
impact on preserving the culture Somewhat
4.1778
Agree
in Rizal.
4. Mt. Pamitinan enlightens the
tourists or potential tourists Somewhat
4.1111
regarding the cultural and Agree
historical heritage of the site
5. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in
improving the quality of life for Somewhat
4.1901
Agree
the local community
6. Mt. Pamitinan supports local
projects for the betterment of the Somewhat
4.1086
Agree
local community
7. Mt. Pamitinan provides the local
community with long-term Somewhat
4.0642
promotional benefits. Agree

8. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the


development of the local Somewhat
4.1753
community. Agree

9. Mt. Pamitinan promotes positive Somewhat


changes in values and customs. 4.0642
Agree

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 33


10. Mt. Pamitinan increases demand
Somewhat
for historical and cultural exhibits. 3.9877
Agree

Grand Mean 4.1422 Somewhat Agree

Table 5 discloses the perceptions of the respondents towards sustainable tourism

development according to the Social Pillar. Highest mean of 4.3185, verbally translated as

Strongly Agree was produced by the perception that Mt. Pamitinan ensures a satisfying and

rewarding experience for the tourists. The perception that Mt. Pamitinan contributes in

promoting the culture of the people in Rizal received the second highest mean of 4.2247 or

Strongly Agree. Third highest mean of 4.1901 or Somewhat Agree was garnered by the

perception that Mt. Pamitinan contributes in improving the quality of life for the local

community.

The perception that Mt. Pamitinan have a positive impact on preserving the culture in

Rizal had a mean of 4.1778, with a verbal interpretation of Somewhat Agree. The perception that

Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the development of the local community had a mean of 4.1753 or

Somewhat Agree. The perception that Mt. Pamitinan enlightens the tourists or potential tourists

regarding the cultural and historical heritage of the site received a mean of 4.111 or Somewhat

Agree. The perception that Mt. Pamitinan supports local projects for the betterment of the local

community got a mean of 4.1086 or Somewhat Agree.

The perceptions with the lowest mean were: Mt. Pamitinan provides the local community

with long-term promotional benefits which had 4.0642, Somewhat Agree; Mt. Pamitinan

promotes positive changes in values and customs with 4.0642 or Somewhat Agree; and, Mt.

Pamitinan increases demand for historical and cultural exhibits with 3.9877, Somewhat Agree.

Grand mean for this aspect is 4.1422, verbally translated as Somewhat Agree.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 34


Table B1

Perceptions of Tourists Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Economic Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan plays a significant
role in enhancing the economy in 4.0506 Somewhat Agree
Rizal through tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan supports the local
economy by creating more
4.0618 Somewhat Agree
opportunities in terms of
generating an income.
3. The growth and/or development of
Mt. Pamitinan helps in improving 4.1180 Somewhat Agree
Rizal’s economy.
4. Mt. Pamitinan promotes the
selling of local products such as
souvenirs to the tourists to support 3.9326 Somewhat Agree
the small business owners in
Rizal.
5. Mt. Pamitinan helps to generate
more local jobs, helping to
3.8933 Somewhat Agree
decrease the unemployment rate in
Rizal.
6. Mt. Pamitinan sources their
supplies locally to support the 3.8876 Somewhat Agree
local economy.
7. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the
betterment of income and standard 3.9157 Somewhat Agree
of living of the local community.
8. Mt. Pamitinan creates new
business opportunities for the
locals and external investors that 3.9157 Somewhat Agree
will provide more employment for
the locals.
9. Mt. Pamitinan helps in increasing
3.8933 Somewhat Agree
tax revenues.
Grand Mean 3.9632 Somewhat Agree

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 35


Table B2

Perceptions of Local Residents Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Economic Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan plays a significant
role in enhancing the economy in 4.2976 Strongly Agree
Rizal through tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan supports the local
economy by creating more
4.1024 Somewhat Agree
opportunities in terms of
generating an income.
3. The growth and/or development of
Mt. Pamitinan helps in improving 4.1805 Somewhat Agree
Rizal’s economy.
4. Mt. Pamitinan promotes the
selling of local products such as
souvenirs to the tourists to support 4.1220 Somewhat Agree
the small business owners in
Rizal.
5. Mt. Pamitinan helps to generate
more local jobs, helping to
4.0878 Somewhat Agree
decrease the unemployment rate in
Rizal.
6. Mt. Pamitinan sources their
supplies locally to support the 4.0732 Somewhat Agree
local economy.
7. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the
betterment of income and standard 4.1122 Somewhat Agree
of living of the local community.
8. Mt. Pamitinan creates new
business opportunities for the
locals and external investors that 4.1024 Somewhat Agree
will provide more employment for
the locals.
9. Mt. Pamitinan helps in increasing
4.0000 Somewhat Agree
tax revenues.
Grand Mean 4.1198 Somewhat Agree

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 36


Table B3

Perceptions of Local Government Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Economic Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan plays a significant
role in enhancing the economy in 4.4545 Strongly Agree
Rizal through tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan supports the local
economy by creating more
4.4242 Strongly Agree
opportunities in terms of
generating an income.
3. The growth and/or development of
Mt. Pamitinan helps in improving 4.4545 Strongly Agree
Rizal’s economy.
4. Mt. Pamitinan promotes the
selling of local products such as
souvenirs to the tourists to support 4.3788 Strongly Agree
the small business owners in
Rizal.
5. Mt. Pamitinan helps to generate
more local jobs, helping to
4.4242 Strongly Agree
decrease the unemployment rate in
Rizal.
6. Mt. Pamitinan sources their
supplies locally to support the 4.4242 Strongly Agree
local economy.
7. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the
betterment of income and standard 4.3939 Strongly Agree
of living of the local community.
8. Mt. Pamitinan creates new
business opportunities for the
locals and external investors that 4.4091 Strongly Agree
will provide more employment for
the locals.
9. Mt. Pamitinan helps in increasing
4.3485 Strongly Agree
tax revenues.

Grand Mean 4.4125 Strongly Agree

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 37


Table 6

Perceptions of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Economic Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan plays a significant
role in enhancing the economy in Somewhat
4.1975
Agree
Rizal through tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan supports the local
economy by creating more Somewhat
4.0988
opportunities in terms of Agree
generating an income.
3. The growth and/or development
of Mt. Pamitinan helps in Somewhat
4.1728
Agree
improving Rizal’s economy.
4. Mt. Pamitinan promotes the
selling of local products such as
souvenirs to the tourists to support Somewhat
4.0519
Agree
the small business owners in
Rizal.
5. Mt. Pamitinan helps to generate
more local jobs, helping to Somewhat
4.0222
decrease the unemployment rate Agree
in Rizal.
6. Mt. Pamitinan sources their
supplies locally to support the Somewhat
4.0049
local economy. Agree

7. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the


betterment of income and Somewhat
standard of living of the local 4.0469
Agree
community.

8. Mt. Pamitinan creates new 4.0395 Somewhat


business opportunities for the Agree
locals and external investors that
will provide more employment for

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 38


the locals.

9. Mt. Pamitinan helps in increasing Somewhat


tax revenues. 3.9654
Agree

Grand Mean 4.0667 Somewhat Agree

Table 6 reveals the perceptions of the respondents towards sustainable tourism

development according to the Economic Pillar. The perception with the highest mean of 4.1975

verbally interpreted as Somewhat Agree was that Mt. Pamitinan plays a significant role in

enhancing the economy in Rizal through tourism. The perception that the growth and/or

development of Mt. Pamitinan helps in improving Rizal’s economy had the second highest mean

of 4.1728 or Somewhat Agree. Third highest mean was produced by the perception that Mt.

Pamitinan supports the local economy by creating more opportunities in terms of generating an

income.

The perception that Mt. Pamitinan promotes the selling of local products such as

souvenirs to the tourists to support the small business owners in Rizal received a mean of 4.0519

or Somewhat Agree. The perception that Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the betterment of income

and standard of living of the local community had a mean of 4.0469, Somewhat Agree. More so,

the perception that Mt. Pamitinan creates new business opportunities for the locals and external

investors that will provide more employment for the locals gained a mean of 4.0395 or

Somewhat Agree.

The three lowest means were received by the following perceptions: Mt. Pamitinan helps

to generate more local jobs, helping to decrease the unemployment rate in Rizal with 4.0222 or

Somewhat Agree; Mt. Pamitinan sources their supplies locally to support the local economy with

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 39


a mean of 4.0049 or Somewhat Agree; and Mt. Pamitinan helps in increasing tax revenues with

the lowest mean of 3.0654 or Somewhat Agree.

Grand mean for this aspect is 4.0667, verbally translated as Somewhat Agree.

Table C1

Perceptions of Tourists Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Environmental Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan offers the
guarantee of quality and
4.1348 Somewhat Agree
respect for the environment
through sustainable tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan minimizes the
generation of waste with its
environmental-friendly 4.0449 Somewhat Agree
protocols to manage natural
areas.
3. Mt. Pamitinan encourages the
tourists to conserve and be
more eco-friendly while
3.9831 Somewhat Agree
travelling through the policies
they implement in line with
sustainable tourism.
4. Mt. Pamitinan puts efforts in
maintaining and enhancing its 3.9326 Somewhat Agree
natural and cultural heritage.
5. The activities in Mt.
Pamitinan assures the
3.9326 Somewhat Agree
preservation of the quality of
the natural environment.
6. Mt. Pamitinan provides the
staff and tourists with
information, tips, and training 3.9719 Somewhat Agree
on how to be more
environmentally responsible.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 40


7. Mt. Pamitinan raises
awareness on environmental 3.9045 Somewhat Agree
issues.
8. Mt. Pamitinan promotes long-
3.9213 Somewhat Agree
term conservation of the area.
9. Mt. Pamitinan protects the
3.9775 Somewhat Agree
natural environment.
10. Mt. Pamitinan prevents
3.9719 Somewhat Agree
further ecological decline.
Grand Mean 3.9775 Somewhat Agree

Table C2

Perceptions of Local Residents Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Environmental Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan offers the
guarantee of quality and
4.3366 Strongly Agree
respect for the environment
through sustainable tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan minimizes the
generation of waste with its
environmental-friendly 4.2341 Strongly Agree
protocols to manage natural
areas.
3. Mt. Pamitinan encourages the
tourists to conserve and be
more eco-friendly while
4.2732 Strongly Agree
travelling through the policies
they implement in line with
sustainable tourism.
4. Mt. Pamitinan puts efforts in
maintaining and enhancing its 4.1463 Somewhat Agree
natural and cultural heritage.
5. The activities in Mt.
Pamitinan assures the
4.2000 Somewhat Agree
preservation of the quality of
the natural environment.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 41


6. Mt. Pamitinan provides the
staff and tourists with
information, tips, and training 4.2000 Somewhat Agree
on how to be more
environmentally responsible.
7. Mt. Pamitinan raises
awareness on environmental 4.1902 Somewhat Agree
issues.
8. Mt. Pamitinan promotes long-
4.3100 Strongly Agree
term conservation of the area.
9. Mt. Pamitinan protects the
4.4488 Strongly Agree
natural environment.
10. Mt. Pamitinan prevents
4.1268 Somewhat Agree
further ecological decline.
Grand Mean 4.2468 Strongly Agree

Table C3

Perceptions of Local Government Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Environmental Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan offers the
guarantee of quality and
4.4394 Strongly Agree
respect for the environment
through sustainable tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan minimizes the
generation of waste with its
environmental-friendly 4.3636 Strongly Agree
protocols to manage natural
areas.
3. Mt. Pamitinan encourages the
tourists to conserve and be
more eco-friendly while
4.4242 Strongly Agree
travelling through the policies
they implement in line with
sustainable tourism.
4. Mt. Pamitinan puts efforts in 4.3636 Strongly Agree
maintaining and enhancing its

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 42


natural and cultural heritage.
5. The activities in Mt.
Pamitinan assures the
4.3788 Strongly Agree
preservation of the quality of
the natural environment.
6. Mt. Pamitinan provides the
staff and tourists with
information, tips, and training 4.4242 Strongly Agree
on how to be more
environmentally responsible.
7. Mt. Pamitinan raises
awareness on environmental 4.4545 Strongly Agree
issues.
8. Mt. Pamitinan promotes long-
4.4545 Strongly Agree
term conservation of the area.
9. Mt. Pamitinan protects the
4.3864 Strongly Agree
natural environment.
10. Mt. Pamitinan prevents
4.3636 Strongly Agree
further ecological decline.
Grand Mean 4.4053 Strongly Agree

Table 7

Perceptions of Respondents Towards Sustainable Tourism


Development According to Environmental Pillar

Verbal
Mean
Interpretation
1. Mt. Pamitinan offers the
guarantee of quality and respect
4.2593 Strongly Agree
for the environment through
sustainable tourism.
2. Mt. Pamitinan minimizes the
generation of waste with its Somewhat
4.1531
environmental-friendly protocols Agree
to manage natural areas.
3. Mt. Pamitinan encourages the 4.1580 Somewhat
tourists to conserve and be more Agree
eco-friendly while travelling
through the policies they
implement in line with sustainable

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 43


tourism.
4. Mt. Pamitinan puts efforts in
maintaining and enhancing its Somewhat
4.0617
Agree
natural and cultural heritage.
5. The activities in Mt. Pamitinan
assures the preservation of the Somewhat
4.0963
quality of the natural Agree
environment.
6. Mt. Pamitinan provides the staff
and tourists with information, tips, Somewhat
4.1062
and training on how to be more Agree
environmentally responsible.
7. Mt. Pamitinan raises awareness
Somewhat
on environmental issues. 4.0741
Agree
8. Mt. Pamitinan promotes long-
Somewhat
term conservation of the area. 4.1556
Agree
9. Mt. Pamitinan protects the natural
4.2395 Strongly Agree
environment.
10. Mt. Pamitinan prevents further Somewhat
4.0716
ecological decline. Agree
Grand Mean 4.1375 Somewhat Agree

Table 7 presents the perceptions of the respondents towards sustainable tourism

development according to the environmental pillar. The perception that Mt. Pamitinan offers the

guarantee of quality and respect for the environment through sustainable tourism received the

highest mean of 4.2593, verbally interpreted as Strongly Agree. This was followed by the

perception that Mt. Pamitinan protects the natural environment which garnered the second

highest mean of 4.2395 or Strongly Agree. Third highest mean of 4.1580 or Somewhat Agree

was earned by the perception that Mt. Pamitinan encourages the tourists to conserve and be more

eco-friendly while travelling through the policies they implement in line with sustainable

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 44


tourism. This was followed by the perception that Mt. Pamitinan promotes long-term

conservation of the area with 4.1556 or Somewhat Agree.

The perception that Mt. Pamitinan minimizes the generation of waste with its

environmental-friendly protocols to manage natural areas had a mean of 4.1531 with verbal

interpretation of Somewhat Agree. The perception that Mt. Pamitinan provides the staff and

tourists with information, tips, and training on how to be more environmentally responsible came

in next with a mean of 4.1062 or Somewhat Agree. The perception that the activities in Mt.

Pamitinan assures the preservation of the quality of the natural environment received a mean of

4.0963, Somewhat Agree.

The three lowest means belonged to the following perceptions: Mt. Pamitinan raises

awareness on environmental issues with 4.0741 or Somewhat Agree; Mt. Pamitinan prevents

further ecological decline with 4.0716, Somewhat Agree; and Mt. Pamitinan puts efforts in

maintaining and enhancing its natural and cultural heritage with 4.0617 or Somewhat Agree.

Grand mean for this aspect was 4.1375, verbally interpreted as Somewhat Agree.

Table 8

Grand Mean of Perceptions of Respondents Towards Sustainable


Tourism Development According to the Three Pillars

Grand Verbal
Mean Interpretation
Social Pillar 4.1422 Somewhat Agree
Economic Pillar 4.0667 Somewhat Agree

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 45


Environmental Pillar 4.1375 Somewhat Agree

Table 8 presents the Grand Mean of all the perceptions of the respondents towards

sustainable tourism development according to the Three Pillars. The highest grand mean among

the three belonged to the Social Pillar which is 4.1422 with a verbal interpretation of Somewhat

Agree. Second highest grand mean of 4.1375 belonged to the Environmental Pillar described as

Somewhat Agree. Finally, the Economic Pillar had a grand mean of 4.0667, Somewhat Agree.

The tables under the perception of respondents (tourists, local respondents, and the LGU

of Rizal) towards the three pillars of sustainable tourism development (social, economic, and

environmental) in Mt. Pamitinan showed that while there are still a lot to improve when it comes

to these three components as the basis of sustainable tourism development in Mt. Pamitinan, the

tables also showed that Mt. Pamitinan is indeed on the right track when it comes to sustainable

tourism development. The tables showed us that based on the perception of the respondents, Mt.

Pamitinan is indeed social, economic, and environmentally responsible.

Table 9

Applicable Factors That Rizal LGUs Use to


Assess Development in Mt. Pamitinan

f % Rank
1. Competitiveness of
10 9.90% 2
Destination

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 46


2. Quality of Destination 9 8.92% 3
3. Satisfaction of the Tourists 8 7.92% 4
4. Annual Occupancy Level 4 3.96% 7
5. Impact on the Economy of the
6 5.94% 6
Province
6. Impact on the Future
10 9.90% 2
Development of the Province
7. Stability and Increase in
7 6.93% 5
Employment
8. Loyalty of Customers 6 5.94% 6
9. Emotional Experience of
12 11.88% 1
Tourists
10. Sustainability of the Image 8 7.92% 4
11. Development of Roads and
Infrastructure in the Vicinity 10 9.90% 2
of the Site
12. The Impact of the Marketing
Strategies to the Target 10 9.90% 2
Customers
13. Others 1 0.99% 8
Total 101 100%

Table 9 shows the applicable factors that Local Government Units in the province of

Rizal used to assess development in Mt. Pamitinan. Of the 101 LGU respondents who

participated in the research, 12 or 11.88% revealed that they assessed development in the area

through the Emotional Experience of Tourists. 10 LGUs or 9.90% said that their yardstick was

the Competitiveness of the Destination. Another 10 (9.90%) said that the Impact of the Future

Development of the Province was their measure. 10 (9.90%) more mentioned that Development

of Roads and Infrastructure in the Vicinity of the Site accounted for development. Still another

10 (9.90%) believed that the Impact of the Marketing Strategies to the Target Customers was

proof enough of development. 9 LGUs or 8.92% disclosed that the Quality of the Destination

showed that development was present. 8 (7.92%) LGUs revealed that the Satisfaction of Tourists

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 47


who visit the place was proof enough of development. Another 8 or 7.92% said that they see

development in the Sustainability of the Image of Mt. Pamitinan. 7 (6.93%) of those who

participated believed that there was development because there was Stability and Increase in

Employment. Loyalty of Customers was the factor that 6 (5.94%) LGUs believed proved the

proved the site was experiencing development. Another 6 or 5.94% LGUs said that the Impact

on the Economy of the Province showed there indeed was development. Finally, 4 LGUs or

3.96% of the 101, held that they assessed development in Mt. Pamitinan through and Annual

Occupancy Level.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 48


Table 10

Planned Activities of Rizal LGUs for the


Development of Mt. Pamitinan

f % Rank
Improve Road Accessibility to Mt. Pamitinan 14 10.00% 1
Construct plans for the building of infrastructures like souvenir
12 8.57% 2
shops, food establishments, and emergency shelters.
Strengthen safety and security measures by installing CCTV
7 5.00% 5
cameras.
Spread COVID-19 awareness to promote safe travelling. 8 5.71% 4
Improve the accommodation for tourists by making sure it’s
sustainable and can accommodate a justifiable number of 9 6.43% 3
tourists.
Provide more activities for the tourists to make their visit more
worthwhile and to use as a promotion strategy as well for the 9 6.43% 3
site.
Devise strategies to improve the marketing strategy of Mt.
7 5.00% 5
Pamitinan to attract more tourists to the site.
Take advantage of new initiatives from the local government
and hospitality sector and adopt it to further develop Mt. 8 5.71% 4
Pamitinan.
Tailor the offers to different visitor groups, like families or
7 5.00% 5
couples.
Minimize the environmental impact of any activities offered in
7 5.00% 5
Mt. Pamitinan.
Create a new generation of tourism strategies that favors
6 4.29% 6
sustainability.
Strengthen the guidelines and protocols in regards with
promoting sustainability to make sure that the tourists will 12 8.57% 2
strictly follow.
Partner with local organizations with the same advocacy as Mt.
7 5.00% 5
Pamitinan. (e.g., sustainability and environmental advocacies.)
Provide a more sustainable and environmental-friendly
8 5.71% 4
marketing strategy.
Partner with local business owners to promote local products. 6 4.29% 6
Provide more job opportunities to the locals of Rizal. 6 4.29% 6
Design a management system for sustainable development 7 5.00% 5

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 49


initiatives.
Total 140 100%

Table 10 presents the planned activities of the Rizal Province Local Government Units

for the development of Mt. Pamitinan. The table reveals, in certain terms, how many LGUs

shared common visions on what to do in order to further develop the site. From this table, it can

be gleaned that 14 LGUs or 10% of the 140 which participated in this research planned to

Improve Road Accessibility to Mt. Pamitinan. 12 LGUs (8.57%) wanted to construct plans for

the building of infrastructures like souvenir shops, food establishments, and emergency shelters.

Another 12 (8.57%) wanted to strengthen the guidelines and protocols with regards to promoting

sustainability to make sure that the tourists will strictly follow. For 9 (6.43%) of the LGUs, the

plan was to Improve the accommodation for tourists by making sure it is sustainable and can

accommodate a justifiable number of tourists. Another 9 (6.43%) LGUs planned to Provide more

activities for the tourists to make their visit more worthwhile and to use as a promotion strategy

as well for the site.

Eight (8) or 5.71% of the LGUs intended to Spread COVID-19 awareness to promote

safe travelling. Another 8 (5.71%) proposed to Take advantage of new initiatives from the local

government and hospitality sector and adopt it to further develop Mt. Pamitinan. Still, 8 (5.71%)

more LGUs planned to Provide a more sustainable and environmental-friendly marketing

strategy.

Going down the list of planned activities, there were seven (7) LGUs or 5.00% of the

total who participated intended to Strengthen safety and security measures by installing CCTV

cameras. Another 7 (5.00%) wanted to Devise strategies to improve the marketing strategy of

Mt. Pamitinan to attract more tourists to the site. More so, 7 (5.00%) LGUs planned to Tailor the

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 50


offers to different visitor groups, like families or couples. Still 7 (5.00%) more LGUs proposed

to Minimize the environmental impact of any activities offered in Mt. Pamitinan.

Six (6) or 4.29% LGUs wanted to Create a new generation of tourism strategies that

favors sustainability. Also, 6 (4.29%) more wanted to Partner with local business owners to

promote local products. Finally, the last 6 (4.29%) participating LGUs intended to Provide more

job opportunities to the locals of Rizal.

Likert Scale

Numerical Rating Value Scale Range Verbal Interpretation


5 4.21 – 5.00 Strongly Agree
4 3.41 – 4.20 Somewhat Agree
3 2.61 – 3.40 Neither Agree nor Disagree
2 1.81 – 2.60 Somewhat Disagree
1 1.00 – 1.80 Strongly Disagree

The tables above showed the findings of the study according to the survey questionnaires

distributed online. This is where the conclusions and recommendations of the study will be

derived from which can be found in chapter 6.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 51


CHAPTER VI

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

The conclusion drawn from the findings of this study on the assessment of sustainable

tourism in Mt. Pamitinan is discussed in this chapter. The study’s goal, research questions, and

results were used to draw conclusions. The implications of these results, as well as the

suggestions that come from them, will be discussed. The results and goal of the study were used

to make the recommendations.

Conclusions

It is true that Mt. Pamitinan is more sustainable than other tourist attractions in Rizal, yet

it is not surprising that it still needs to be improved. The social, economic, and environmental

aspects of Mt. Pamitinan’s sustainable tourism development was considered first and foremost.

When it comes to sustainable tourism, these three components are seen to be important.

Respondents highly believe that Mt. Pamitinan contributes to fostering the culture of the people

in Rizal and assures a fulfilling and rewarding experience for visitors, according to the survey.

This demonstrates that Mt. Pamitinan considers the promotion of culture as well as the ability to

function well in order to delight tourists. The social pillar, on the other hand, is not limited to

these two elements. Many variables or sectors, particularly the improvement of the local

community’s quality of life, should be given more attention. The social pillar is primarily

concerned with improving the community and assisting locals. Based on the study’s findings, the

studies claim that Mt. Pamitinan is definitely doing its part, however, more can still be done.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 52


When it comes to the economic pillar, the study discovered that Mt. Pamitinan

contributes to the improvement of Rizal’s economy by creating jobs for residents, resulting in

greater income opportunities. As a result, the unemployment rate in Rizal lowers as more jobs

are created. The most essential economic element of tourism-related activities is that they

contribute to three high-priority goals for developing countries: revenue production,

employment, and foreign-exchange earnings. Mt. Pamitinan does contribute to the economy of

Rizal, according to the study’s findings. However, because the tourist destination is not well-

known on a national level, it is apparent that Mt. Pamitinan’s economic potential has not been

fully realized.

The last pillar is the environmental. The survey showed that Mt. Pamitinan offers the

guarantee of quality and respect for the environment through sustainable tourism. This means

that Mt. Pamitinan protects the natural environment. As a tourist attraction that showcases nature

itself, Mt. Pamitinan has to give importance to the environment, in which they do. However, just

like the two other pillars, Mt. Pamitinan has not yet perfected sustainable tourism when it comes

to the environmental pillar. The study showed that while Mt. Pamitinan is considered to be very

environmental-friendly, the regulations and protocols when it comes to preserving the

environment should be more strictly implemented to minimize the generation of waste in the area

brought by the tourists.

When it comes to the LGU of Rizal, the factors that they consider in assessing the

development in Mt. Pamitinan is the emotional experience of the tourists, the competitiveness of

the destination, the development of roads and infrastructure in the vicinity of the site, the impact

of the marketing strategies to the target customers, and the quality of the destination itself. Their

future plans include the improvement of road accessibility to Mt. Pamitinan and the construction

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 53


of plans for the building of infrastructures like souvenir shops, food establishments, and

emergency shelters. The LGU of Rizal also plans to improve the accommodation for tourists by

making sure it is sustainable and can accommodate a justifiable number of tourists and provide

more activities for the tourists to make their visit more worthwhile and to use it as a promotion

strategy as well for the site.

Recommendations

 Through development, education, and training programs, promote tourism development

in accordance with the natural and cultural environment at the national, regional, and

community levels.

 Organize tourist strategy plans that support ecologically and economically sound, as well

as socially sustainable growth.

 Encourage and facilitate full involvement by including local communities in the creation

of programs aimed at developing awareness for the development and promotion of

sustainable tourism at all levels of society.

 In order to ensure sustainable growth, create environmental effects analysis for the design

of tourism projects.

 Work with the Rizal Local Government Unit to leverage tourist profits to help reduce

poverty and create more jobs in the community.

 Be a cost-effective and long-term solution for utilizing natural resources.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 54


 Utilize non-exploitative marketing tactics that respect people, communities, and

destinations’ surroundings, demolish stereotypes, and integrate sustainable tourism

concepts while developing new marketing methods for ‘green’ tourist marketing.

References

“Boosting Sustainable Tourism Development and Capacity of Tourism SMEs through


Transnational Cooperation and Knowledge Transfer.” (n.d.). Retrieved January 11, 2022,
from https://tourisme-project.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/D2.1-Literature-Review-on-
Sustainable-Tourism.pdf
Alampay, R. and C. Libosada. 2003. Development of a classification framework on ecotourism
initiatives in the Philippines. PASCN Discussion Paper 2003-04 Makati City: Philippine
APEC Study Center Network.
Angelevska-Najdeska, K., & Rakicevik, G. (2012). Planning of Sustainable Tourism
Development. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 44, 210–220.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2012.05.022
Anil, K., Singh, Punit, K., & Dwivedi. (2011). Sustainable Tourism Development through
Ecotourism: A conceptual Approach Sustainable Tourism Development through
Ecotourism: A conceptual Approach. http://www.thaavan.com/download.php?
download_file=uploadfile/8.+THAVAN+IJREB+Vol-01+Issue+01+Oct-Dec-2011.pdf
Benedicto, R. (2005). The Challenge of Sustainable Tourism Development in the Philippines.
ResearchGate; unknown.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/306257124_The_Challenge_of_Sustainable_Tou
rism_Development_in_the_Philippines
Jasrotia, S. S., Kamila, M. K., & Patel, V. K. (2021). Impact of Sustainable Tourism on Tourist’s
Satisfaction: Evidence from India. Business Perspectives and Research,
227853372110439. https://doi.org/10.1177/22785337211043960
Katerina Angelevska-Najdeska, & Rakicevik, G. (2012). Planning of Sustainable Tourism
Development. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 44.
https://cyberleninka.org/article/n/1050910
León-Gómez, A.; Ruiz-Palomo, D.; Fernández-Gámez, M.A.; García-Revilla, M.R. Sustainable
Tourism Development and Economic Growth: Bibliometric Review and Analysis.
Sustainability 2021, 13, 2270. https://doi.org/ 10.3390/su13042270
Liu, Z. (2003). Sustainable Tourism Development: A Critique. Journal of Sustainable
Tourism, 11(6), 459–475. https://doi.org/10.1080/09669580308667216
López-Sanz, J. M., Penelas-Leguía, A., Gutiérrez-Rodríguez, P., & Cuesta-Valiño, P. (2021).
Rural Tourism and the Sustainable Development Goals. A Study of the Variables That
Most Influence the Behavior of the Tourist. Frontiers in Psychology, 12.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.722973
Nugraheni, A. I. P., Priyambodo, T. K., Sutikno, B., & Kusworo, H. A. (2019). DEFINING
SOCIAL SUSTAINABILITY AND SOCIALLY CONSCIOUS TOURIST IN

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 55


SUSTAINABLE TOURISM DEVELOPMENT. Journal of Business on Hospitality and
Tourism, 5(2), 264. https://doi.org/10.22334/jbhost.v5i2.172
Salman, A., Jaafar, M., & Mohamad, D. (2020). A comprehensive review of the role of
Ecotourism in sustainable tourism development. E-Review of Tourism Research, 18(2),
215–233. https://journals.tdl.org/ertr/index.php/ertr/article/view/482
Sørensen, F., & Grindsted, T. S. (2021). Sustainability approaches and nature tourism
development. Annals of Tourism Research, 91, 103307.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2021.103307
Sustainable tourism: a comprehensive literature review on frameworks and applications. (2015).
Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1331677X.2014.995895
Venugopalan, T. (2021). Sustainable Tourism Development In India: An Exploratory Research
On Sustainability Of Delhi Tourism. Archives of Business Research, 9(4), 198–217.
https://doi.org/10.14738/abr.94.10043
World Tourism Organization. International Tourism and COVID-19. 2020. Available online:
https://www.unwto.org/international-tourism-and-covid-19
VU, D. V., TRAN, G. N., NGUYEN, H. T. T., & NGUYEN, C. V. (2020). Factors Affecting
Sustainable Tourism Development in Ba Ria-Vung Tau, Vietnam. The Journal of Asian
Finance, Economics and Business, 7(9), 561–572.
https://doi.org/10.13106/jafeb.2020.vol7.no9.561

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 56


APPENDIX A. GANTT CHART

APPENDIX B. ACTUAL RESEARCH EXPENSES

Quantity Specifics Approximate Cost Actual Cost


1 Statistician Php 3,000.00 Php 3,000.00
1 Transportation Cost Php 2,500.00 Php 2,500.00
1 Research Equipment and Php 1,750.00 Php 1,750.00
Supply
4 Fees for internet connectivity Php 1,999.00 Php 7,996.00
and data connections
3 Subscriptions for paid Php 500.00 Php 1,500.00

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 57


publications

APPENDIX C. QUESTIONNAIRE

STI COLLEGE CUBAO


Assessment of Sustainable Tourism Development in Mt. Pamitinan
(Survey Questionnaire)
Date Accomplished: ____________ Survey No:
________
A. Respondent’s Profile

1. Name (Optional):
2. Age:
3. Gender:
4. What type of respondent are you?
___ Tourist
___ Local Resident
___ LGU of Rizal
5. Location: (Note: This only applies to the local residents of Rizal. If you’re not from
Rizal, kindly choose “others”.)
___ Antipolo
___ Taytay
___ Binangonan
___ Cainta
___ Tanay
___ Angono
___ Morong
___San Mateo
___ Teresa
___ Baras
___ Pililla
___ Rodriguez
___ Jala-jala
___ Cardona
___ Pasig
___ Real
___ Others

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 58


B. Perception on the Three Pillars of Sustainable Tourism Development

Please rate your perception of each statement under the identified three pillars of sustainable tourism
development.

The rate significance varies from 1 – 5 wherein:

1 = Strongly Disagree
2= Somewhat Disagree
3= Neither Agree nor Disagree
4= Somewhat Agree
5 = Strongly Agree
Social

1. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in promoting the culture of the people in Rizal.

1 2 3 4 5

2. Mt. Pamitinan ensures a satisfying and rewarding experience for the tourists.

1 2 3 4 5

3. Mt. Pamitinan have a positive impact on preserving the culture in Rizal.

1 2 3 4 5

4. Mt. Pamitinan enlightens the tourists or potential tourists regarding the cultural and historical
heritage of the site.

1 2 3 4 5

5. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in improving the quality of life for the local community

1 2 3 4 5

6. Mt. Pamitinan supports local projects for the betterment of the local community.

1 2 3 4 5

7. Mt. Pamitinan provides the local community with long-term promotional benefits.

1 2 3 4 5

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 59


8. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the development of the local community.

1 2 3 4 5

9. Mt. Pamitinan promotes positive changes in values and customs.

1 2 3 4 5

10. Mt. Pamitinan increases demand for historical and cultural exhibits.

1 2 3 4 5
Economic

1. Mt. Pamitinan plays a significant role in enhancing the economy in Rizal through tourism.

1 2 3 4 5

2. Mt. Pamitinan supports the local economy by creating more opportunities in terms of
generating an income.

1 2 3 4 5

3. The growth and/or development of Mt. Pamitinan helps in improving Rizal’s economy.

1 2 3 4 5

4. Mt. Pamitinan promotes the selling of local products such as souvenirs to the tourists to support
the small business owners in Rizal.

1 2 3 4 5

5. Mt. Pamitinan helps to generate more local jobs, helping to decrease the unemployment rate in
Rizal.

1 2 3 4 5

6. Mt. Pamitinan sources their supplies locally to support the local economy.

1 2 3 4 5

7. Mt. Pamitinan contributes in the betterment of income and standard of living of the local
community.

1 2 3 4 5

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 60


8. Mt. Pamitinan creates new business opportunities for the locals and external investors that will
provide more employment for the locals.

1 2 3 4 5

9. Mt. Pamitinan helps in increasing tax revenues.

1 2 3 4 5

Environmental

1. Mt. Pamitinan offers the guarantee of quality and respect for the environment through
sustainable tourism.

1 2 3 4 5

2. Mt. Pamitinan minimizes the generation of waste with its environmental-friendly protocols to
manage natural areas.

1 2 3 4 5

3. Mt. Pamitinan encourages the tourists to conserve and be more eco-friendly while travelling
through the policies they implement in line with sustainable tourism.

1 2 3 4 5

4. Mt. Pamitinan puts efforts in maintaining and enhancing its natural and cultural heritage.

1 2 3 4 5

5. The activities in Mt. Pamitinan assures the preservation of the quality of the natural
environment.

1 2 3 4 5

6. Mt. Pamitinan provides the staff and tourists with information, tips, and training on how to be
more environmentally responsible.

1 2 3 4 5

7. Mt. Pamitinan raises awareness on environmental issues.

1 2 3 4 5

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 61


8. Mt. Pamitinan promotes long-term conservation of the area.

1 2 3 4 5

9. Mt. Pamitinan protects the natural environment.

1 2 3 4 5

10. Mt. Pamitinan prevents further ecological decline.

1 2 3 4 5

C. The factors that the LGU of Rizal uses to assess the development in Mt. Pamitinan.

This part of the questionnaire will only be answered by the respondents coming
from the LGU of Rizal. This section will be used to know the factors that the LGU of
Rizal uses to assess the development in Mt. Pamitinan.

Out of the list, pick the factors used for assessing development that is applicable
to Mt. Pamitinan.
____ Competitiveness of Destination
____ Quality of Destination
____ Satisfaction of the Tourists
____ Annual Occupancy Level
____ Impact on the Economy of the Province
____ Impact on the Future Development of the Province
____ Stability and Increase in Employment
____ Loyalty of Customers
____ Emotional Experience of Tourists
____ Sustainability of the Image
____ Development of roads and infrastructures in the vicinity of the site.
____ The impact of the marketing strategies to the target customers.

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 62


____ Others (kindly type down your answer)

D. The Plans of the LGU of Rizal for the development of Mt. Pamitinan.
This section will also only be answered by the LGU of Rizal. This section will be
utilized to know the future or current plans of the LGU of Rizal for the development of
Mt. Pamitinan.

Out of the lists, choose the future plans of the LGU of Rizal for the further
development of Mt. Pamitinan. (If you’re not from the LGU of Rizal, kindly skip this
section.)

___ Improve road accessibility in Mt. Pamitinan.


___ Construct plans for the building of infrastructures like souvenir shops, food
establishments, and emergency shelters.
___ Strengthen safety and security measures by installing CCTV cameras.
___ Spread COVID-19 awareness to promote safe travelling.
___ Improve the accommodation for tourists by making sure it’s sustainable and can
accommodate a justifiable number of tourists.
___ Provide more activities for the tourists to make their visit more worthwhile and to
use as a promotion strategy as well for the site.
___ Devise strategies to improve the marketing strategy of Mt. Pamitinan to attract
more tourists to the site.
___ Take advantage of new initiatives from the local government and hospitality
sector and adopt it to further develop Mt. Pamitinan.
___ Tailor the offers to different visitor groups, like families or couples.
___ Minimize the environmental impact of any activities offered in Mt. Pamitinan.
___ Create a new generation of tourism strategies that favors sustainability.
___ Strengthen the guidelines and protocols in regards with promoting sustainability
to make sure that the tourists will strictly follow.
___ Partner with local organizations with the same advocacy as Mt. Pamitinan. (e.g.,
sustainability and environmental advocacies.)
___ Provide a more sustainable and environmental-friendly marketing strategy.
___ Partner with local business owners to promote local products.
___ Provide more job opportunities to the locals of Rizal.
___ Design a management system for sustainable development initiatives.
___ Others (kindly type down your answer)

Thank you and God bless!

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 63


APPENDIX D. LGU DOCUMENTS

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 64


FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 65
FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 66
FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 67
Prepared by:
John Cyrus B. Corrales
Mariah Christianne P. Reotutar
Zuzanne S. Segismar
Jasmin Denise B. Sta. Cruz

Noted by:
Jessica B. Corrales
Lyn P. Reotutar
Jackson D.P. Segismar
Sharon B. Sta. Cruz

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 68


Approved by:
Athena Y. Jacinto Nicka G. Romero

FT-CRD-113-00 | STI College Cubao 69

You might also like