Yoga Critical
Yoga Critical
Yoga Critical
YOGA
INTRODUCTION
*57 .
II
158
is called absence of cognition, yet it is a mental modification because
after sleep a person says ‘I slept sound and knew nothing’ and therefore
there must be some mental modification to support this absence of
knowledge. Smfti is the recollection of past experience through the
impressions left behind.
In fact the Purusa is the eternally pure and transcendental conscious
ness. It is the Chitta with the reflection of the Purusa in it or the Purusa
as reflected in the Chitta, which is the phenomenal ego or Jïva, which
is subject to birth and death and transmigration and to all painful or
pleasurable experiences, and which imagines itself as the agent and the
enjoyer. There are five kinds of sufferings (klesha) to which it is subject.
These are: (i) ignorance (avidyâ), (2) egoism (asmitä), (3) attachment
(räga), (4) aversion (dvesa), and (5) clinging to life and instinctive fear
of death (abhinivesha). The bondage of the self is due to its wrong
identification with the mental modifications and liberation, therefore,
means the end of this wrong identification through proper discrimina
tion between Purusa and Prakrti and the consequent cessation of
the mental modifications. It is the aim of Yoga to bring about this
result.
There are five levels of mental life (chittabhümi). The differences in
the levels are due to the predominance of the different gunas. The lowest
level is called Ksipta or restless, because the mind here is restless due
to the excess of rajas and is tossed about like a shuttlecock between
different sense-objects. The second is called Müdha or torpid. The mind
here has the predominance of tamas and tends towards ignorance, sleep
and lethargy. The third is called Viksipta or distracted. Here sattva
predominates, but rajas also asserts itself at times.1 The fourth is called
Ekägra or concentrated. The mind here is entirely dominated by sattva,
and rajas and tamas are subdued. The mind becomes concentrated on
the object of meditation. The fifth and the highest level is called Nirud-
dha or restricted. Here the mental modifications are arrested, though
their latent impressions remain. The first three levels are not at all
conducive to Yogic life. Only the last two are.
I ll
ASTÄNGA YOGA
y o g a advocates control over the body, the senses and the mind. It
does not want to kill the body; on the other hand, it recommends its
perfection. A sound mind needs a sound body. Sensual attachment and
1 Viksipta here does not mean 'extrem ely restless* (visheçena kfiptab) as its name sug
gests, but 'better than kçipta' (kçiptâd vishi$tab), because in kçipta rajas predominates
w hile in viksipta sattva predominates.
159
passions distract the body as well as the mind. They must be conquered.
T o overcome them, Yoga gives us the Eightfold Path of Discipline
(Astänga Yoga):
160
passions distract the body as well as the mind. They must be conquered.
T o overcome them, Yoga gives us the Eightfold Path of Discipline
(Astänga Yoga):
160
IV
GOD
in God seems to be practical, but the later Yogins have taken also a
theoretical interest in Him and have tried to prove His existence as a
necessary philosophical speculation. Patanjali defines God as a special
kind of Purusa who is always free from pains, actions, effects and
impressions.1 He is eternally free and was never bound nor has any
possibility of being bound. He is above the law of Karma. He is omnis
cient and omnipotent and omnipresent. He is perfection incarnate. He is
purest knowledge. He is the teacher of the rsis (sa pürvesämapi guruh)
and the teacher of the Veda. ‘Aum’ is His symbol. Devotion to God is
one of the surest means of obtaining concentration. The proofs advanced
for His existence are: (a) The Veda tell’s us that God exists; (ò) the law
of continuity tells us that there must be the highest limit of knowledge
and perfection which is God; (c) God is responsible for the association
and dissociation of Purusa and Prakrti; (d) devotion to God is the
surest way of obtaining concentration and thereby liberation.
But God of Yoga is not the creator, preserver or destroyer of this
world. He is only a special Purusa. He does not reward or punish the
souls. Innumerable Purusas and Prakrti, all eternals and absolutes, are
there to limit Him. He cannot grant liberation. He can only remove the
obstacles in the upward progress of the devotees. Directly He has
nothing to do with the bondage and the liberation of the Purusas.
Ignorance binds and discrimination between Prakrti and Purusa
liberates. The end of human life is not the union with God, but only
the separation of Purusa from Prakrti. Such a conception of God is
certainly unsatisfactory.
The Yoga system of Patanjali should not be confused with magic and
tantra and self-hypnotization. It is a great system of spiritual discipline
and has found favour with all schools of Indian Philosophy except the
Chärväka. It is founded on the metaphysics of Sänkhya and gives us
a practical path of purification and self-control in order to realize the
true nature of man.
162