Determination of Specific Energy: 1 Scope
Determination of Specific Energy: 1 Scope
(2001)
1
The definitions of gross and net heat of combustion are based on BS 526 or ASTM D2382, Sec. 3, 'Definitions of the
Calorific Value of Fuel'.
2
Users of this method desiring to calculate )H°k298 for a pure compound should note that corrections must be applied
to the value of Qg for buoyancy of air, heat capacities of reaction components, reduction to a constant-pressure process,
and deviations of the reaction from the thermodynamic standard state. See, for example, E. J. Prosen, 'Experimental
Thermochemistry', F. D. Rossini, editor, Interscience Publishers, 1956, pp. 129-148. Reliable values for heats of
combustion of pure compounds are given in National Bureau of Standards Circular C-461, 'Selected Values of Properties
of Hydrocarbons' (US Government Printing Office, Washington DC, 1947, and in F. D. Rossini et al., 'Selected Values
of Physical and Thermodynamic Properties of Hydrocarbons and Related Compounds', Carnegie Press, Pittsburgh, Pa.,
1953. These compilations were prepared by F. D. Rossini et al. as part of American Petroleum Institute Research Project
44. In any comparison of measurements on pure compounds with those cited in these compilations, the user of this
method should realise that impurities of various kinds, including water and foreign hydrocarbons, may cause significant
effects on the values obtained from particular samples of material.
12.1
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
4.3 Calorimeter vessel, metal vessel polished on 5.1 Water, unless otherwise indicated,
the outside, preferably at least 75 mm higher than references to water shall be understood to mean
the bomb, preferably of such cross-sectional area distilled or demineralised reagent water.
that 2 litres of water just covers the bomb.
5.2 Oxygen, under pressure in cylinders, free
4.3.1 Stirrer, a mechanical device for stirring the from combustible material.
water in the calorimeter vessel at a uniform rate.
The stirring shall be thorough, but not so rapid as to 5.3 Ignition wire, 0,1±0,03 mm dia. platinum
cause appreciable heating of the water. Continuous wire. The same diameter and length of wire should
stirring of the water in the calorimeter vessel of the be used in the calibration and determination.
isothermal jacketed apparatus for 10 min after
thermal equilibrium has been established shall not 5.4 Firing cotton (if required), a strand of wick
cause an increase in temperature of more than as specified for use with ASTM D1266—IP 107,
0,01°C. With the adiabatic jacketed apparatus dried at 100 to 105 °C and stored over silica gel
continuous stirring of the water in the calorimeter until required. The heat of combustion of each batch
vessel for 10 min after thermal equilibrium has been of firing cotton must be determined.
established shall not cause an increase in
temperature of more than 0,002 °C. The portion of 5.5 Sodium hydroxide solution, approx. 0,1 N,
the stirrer immersed in the calorimeter vessel shall accurately standardized.
be connected to the outside portion with material of
low heat conductivity. 5.6 Benzoic acid, powder or pellet form, of
thermochemical standard of purity and of a heat of
4.3.2 Water jacket, a double walled metal vessel combustion certified by the National Physical
containing water, fitted with a lid and leaving an air Laboratory or the National Bureau of Standards.
gap of preferably 10 mm all around the calorimetric Powdered material shall be compressed into pellets.
vessel.
5.7 Cellulose adhesive tape, plain transparent
4.3.2.1 The isothermal jacket shall be arranged so cellulose film of width not less than 25 mm and
as to remain at a uniform temperature (maximum thickness 0,05 to 0,075 mm. Use only
variation 0,05 °C) during the test. cellulose-based film. The heat of combustion of
each batch of tape must be determined.
4.3.2.2 Adiabatic calorimeters shall be capable of
circulating water continuously through both jacket 5.8 Indicator, the following alternatives may be
and lid. The system shall be fitted with heating and used:
cooling devices such that the temperature of the
jacket water is rapidly adjusted to that of the water 5.8.1 Methyl purple solution, aqueous solution
in the calorimeter vessel with a sensitivity containing approximately 0,1% active constituent,
sufficiently good to satisfy the requirements of or
9.5.2.
5.8.2 Methyl red solution, 60% alcohol-aqueous
4.4 Fuel cup, a range of fuel cups that may be solution containing approximately 0,1% indicator.
used is illustrated in Annex A2.
6 Safety precautions
4.5 Ignition system, conforming to the
specifications given in Annex A5. 6.1 The weight of sample shall be such that the
heat developed during the combustion shall in no
4.6 Thermometers, conforming to the case exceed 90 J/ml bomb capacity; and the total
specifications given in Annex A3. weight of sample, together with any combustible
12.2
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
material such as cellulose tape, shall be calculated nearest 0,1 mg to find the weight of benzoic acid.
in advance, so that the given limit is not exceeded. Pipette 1 ml of water into the bomb (to saturate the
oxygen used for combustion with water vapour).
6.2 Provision must be made to ensure that the Place the fuel cup in the circular ring support
oxygen filling pressure does not exceed the safety attached to the terminals of the bomb.
limit (see Annex A4 concerning oxygen charging
equipment). 8.1.1.1 Attach a measured length of ignition wire
(approx. 100 mm, see Section 5.3) across the bomb
The operator shall not go near the calorimeter until terminals so as to form a U-shape loop and arranged
at least 20 sec have elapsed from the time of firing. so that the central portion of the loop is in contact
with the benzoic acid; or
6.3 The bomb must be completely submerged in
water during firing and the charge must not be 8.1.1.2 Attach a measured length of ignition wire
ignited if there is any evidence of gas leakage. Also, (approx. 100 mm, see Section 5.3) across the bomb
do not fire the bomb if it has been accidentally terminals under light tension. Weigh a suitable
over-charged with oxygen to a pressure greater than length of dry firing cotton and tie it at the centre of
40 bar (39,5 atm, 580 lb/in2). the ignition wire. Insert the free end of the firing
cotton into the crucible so that it is in contact with
6.4 Because of the risk of explosion, it is the benzoic acid.
strongly recommended that the firing point and the
oxygen cylinder be situated outside the room or 8.1.2 Close the bomb securely.
safety enclosure containing the calorimeter, but in
any case firing shall be by remote control in order to 8.1.3 Admit oxygen slowly to a gauge pressure of
minimize the risk of injury to the operator (see 30 bar (29,6 atm, 430 psig).
Annex A5 concerning Ignition Systems).
8.1.4 Determine the effective heat capacity of the
7 Sample bomb by making not less than 5 combustions of the
certified benzoic acid using the standard quantity of
7.1 Take samples of liquid fuels of flash point water. The standard quantity of water is such that
less than 38 °C directly into a container of not less the cover of the bomb (but not terminals) is
than 200 ml capacity, fill the container as immersed and the effective heat capacity of the
completely as possible and close immediately after system is approx. 10 500 joules/°C. If necessary,
taking the sample. Store samples in a refrigerator at make preliminary combustions of benzoic acid to
below 4 °C until required. The fuel shall be establish the correct weight of water. Once
transferred to the fuel cup at a temperature as near established this shall be the standard quantity of
as possible to the storage temperature. water, weighed to within 0,5 g, to be used in all
subsequent determinations.
7.2 If results are required on a dry basis,
determine the water content independently and 8.1.5 When using isothermal apparatus follow the
correct the result accordingly. details of procedure described in 9.4 and 9.6. When
using adiabatic apparatus follow the details of
8 Standardisation procedure described in 9.5 and 9.6. Calculate the
effective heat capacity as described in 10.1 to 10.4.
8.1 Determination of effective heat capacity,
energy equivalent or water equivalent, using 9 Procedure
tweezers, place in the weighed fuel cup (Type 2 or
3 of Annex A2 Fig. 4) the approximate weight of For liquid fuels of flash point below 38 °C proceed
benzoic acid derived from the relation: as in 9.1.1 or 9.1.2 and continue the determination
as in 9.4, 9.6, and 9.7 when using isothermal
m = 90 x Bomb capacity to ml apparatus or as in 9.5, 9.6, and 9.7 when using
26 500 adiabatic apparatus. For liquid fuels of flash point
above 38 °C proceed as in 9.2.1 or 9.2.2 and
where m is the approx. weight of benzoic acid, in g. continue the determination as in 9.4, 9.6, and 9.7
when using isothermal apparatus or as in 9.5, 9.6,
8.1.1 Weigh the fuel cup and its contents to the and 9.7 when using adiabatic apparatus.
12.3
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
9.1 Liquid fuels of flash point less than 38 °C the nearest 0,1 mg. Charge the fuel cup by lifting
the lip of the sealing tape and introducing the
9.1.1 Fuel cup type 1 or 4 Annex A2 Fig. 4, weigh required weight [Note 1] of liquid fuel with a
the fuel cup to 0,1 mg. Cover the cup with the hypodermic syringe. Replace the tape to seal the
cellulose adhesive tape, trim around the edge with fuel cup, allow the temperature to reach equilibrium
a razor blade, and seal tightly. Puncture the tape (Section 7.1) and weigh the fuel cup and its
with a large needle to make an opening somewhat contents to the nearest 0,1 mg. Pipette 1 ml of
larger than the diameter of the hypodermic syringe water into the bomb. Place the fuel cup in the
needle. Place a 4 x 12 mm strip of tape, creased in circular ring support attached to the terminals of the
the middle and sealed along one side, in the centre bomb. Attach a measured length of ignition wire
of the tape disk to give a flap arrangement which (see Section 5.3) across the bomb terminals under
will cover the hole when finally sealed down, as light tension. Tie the free end of the firing cotton to
shown in Fig. 1, Type 4. Weigh the cup and tape, the centre of the ignition wire and with a pin make
and remove from the balance with forceps. Add the about six small holes in the tape sealing the mouth
required weight [Note 1] of sample with a of the fuel cup. Immediately close the bomb
hypodermic syringe through the hole in the tape. securely.
Seal the flap down over the hole by pressing lightly
with a metal spatula. Allow the temperature to 9.2 Liquid fuels of flash point greater than 38°C
reach equilibrium (7.1) and reweigh the cup, tape, [Note 2]
and sample. Care must be taken throughout the
weighing and filling operation to avoid contacting 9.2.1 Fuel cup type 2, 3, or 4 of Annex A2 Fig. 4,
the tape or cup with bare fingers. Place the cup in place the required weight [Note 1] of liquid fuel in
the curved electrode and attach a measured length the weighed fuel cup. Weigh the fuel cup and its
of ignition wire (see 3.3) across the bomb terminals contents to the nearest 0,1 mg. Pipette 1 ml of
such that the central portion of the loop presses water into the bomb. Place the fuel cup in the
down on the centre of the tape disk. Pipette 1 ml of circular ring support attached to the terminals of the
water into the bomb and immediately close the bomb. Attach a length of ignition wire across the
bomb securely: or, alternatively bomb terminals under light tension. Weigh a suitable
length of dry firing cotton and tie it at the centre of
9.1.2 Fuel cup type 1 or 4 of Annex A2 Fig. 4, the ignition wire. Dip the free end of the firing
weigh the fuel cup to the nearest 0,1 mg. Cover the cotton into the contents of the fuel cup and
fuel cup top with two pieces of cellulose adhesive immediately close the bomb securely; or,
tape, such that they slightly overlap as shown in alternatively
Fig. 1, Type 1. Fix one end of a weighed length of
firing cotton into the overlap, the other end being 9.2.2 Fuel cup type 2, 3, or 4 of Annex A2 Fig. 4,
free for attachment to the ignition wire. Weigh the place the required weight [Note 1] of sample in the
fuel cup and the attached tape and firing cotton to weighed fuel cup. Weigh the cup and sample to
12.4
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
0,1 mg. Place the cup in the curved electrode and 9.4.3 At the end of the sixth minute fire the
arrange the fuse wire so that the central portion of charge by closing the firing circuit for not longer
the loop just dips into the contents of the cup. than 2 sec. CAUTION: see 6.2.
Pipette 1 ml of water into the bomb. Immediately
close the bomb securely. DO NOT GO NEAR THE BOMB UNTIL AT LEAST 20 SECONDS
HAVE ELAPSED FROM THE TIME OF FIRING
NOTE 1 - The weight of the sample shall be controlled
such that: 9.4.4 Record the temperatures at 45, 60, 75, 90,
and 105 sec after the time of firing. By interpolation
M = 90 x Bomb capacity in ml between these readings the time at which the
Qg temperature rise reached 60% of its final value will
later be found [Note 5].
where
M is the required weight of sample in g; 9.4.5 After the rapid rise period (about 4 to 5 min)
Qg is approx. heat of combustion of the record the temperature at 1 min intervals on each
sample in J/g. completed min after the time of firing. Continue
these readings until the difference between
NOTE 2 - Liquid luck having flash point in the range 38 to
successive readings has been constant for 5 min
60 °C may tend to lose a small proportion of their more
volatile components on exposure to the atmosphere.
[Note 5]. From this series determine the time at the
Weigh the sample into the fuel cup and seal immediately beginning of the period in which the rate of
in the bomb whilst avoiding exposure to draughts. temperature change with time is constant.
Determine also the rate of change of temperature
9.3 Admit oxygen slowly to a gauge pressure of with time.
30 bar (29,6 atm, 430 psig).
9.4.6 The temperature rise shall be between
9.4 Isothermal jacket calorimeters 2,5 and 3,5 °C and the final temperature shall not
be more than 1 °C (and preferably not more than
Fill the water jacket with water at a temperature 0,5 °C) above that of the jacket.
within 3 °C of room temperature and ensure that it
remains constant throughout. Fill the calorimeter NOTE 3 - Temperatures should be read to 0,001 °C. This
vessel with the standard quantity of water (see will not be possible during the rapid period, and the most
accurate readings which are practicable at this time
8.1.4) weighed to within 0,5 g. The initial
should be recorded. Mercury-in-glass thermometers shall
temperature of the bomb and calorimeter shall be: be tapped lightly before reading, particularly when the
temperature is falling, to prevent errors caused by sticking
(i) in the range 15 to 32 °C; of the mercury. A convenient method of effecting this is
(ii) above the dew point; to mount a small buzzer directly on top of the
(iii) approx. 2,5 °C below the temperature of thermometer. and operate it for a few moments before
the water jacket and preferably within 2 °C each reading. Use an eyepiece to facilitate thermometer
of the temperature of standardisation (see reading.
Note 9).
NOTE 4 - The rate of temperature Change with time shall
be considered constant if the variation in the rate does
9.4.1 Place the prepared bomb, CAUTION: see
not exceed 0,001 °C/min. the rate of change of
Section 6, in the calorimeter vessel, check that
temperature shall be calculated as the mean of the
there is no leakage of oxygen, confirm that the firing relevant recordings.
leads are dead, and make the appropriate electrical
connexions. Put the covers in position, arrange the NOTE 5 - When the approx. heat of combustion of the
thermometer and stirrer so that they do not touch fuel is known to within 1 500 joule/g, the expected
the bomb or vessel, and start the stirrer. temperature rise may be determined from the relation:
12.5
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
Calculate the temperature at the 60% point by the bomb and release the pressure uniformly at such
adding to the temperature at the time of firing, 60% a rate that the operation takes at least 1 min. Open
of the expected temperature rise. Start an additional the bomb and examine the inside for traces of
stopwatch at the time of the first reading of the unburned oil or soot; if either is found discard the
series of temperature recordings made before firing. determination [Note 7].
Stop the stopwatch when the calculated 60%
temperature rise is attained and record the time. 9.6.1 Rinse out the interior of the bomb, including
the fuel cup, with a fine jet of distilled water, and
9.5 Adiabatic calorimeters collect the washings, which shall not exceed a
volume of 350 ml, in a beaker. Add a few drops of
Fill the calorimeter vessel with the standard quantity indicator and titrate with the sodium hydroxide
of water, weighed to within 0,5 g (see 8.1.4), the solution to determine the quantity of nitric and
temperature of which shall be within the range of sulphuric acids formed in the combustion.
15 to 32 °C, shall be above the dew point and
preferably within 2 °C of the temperature of NOTE 6 - If a constant temperature is not obtained within
standardisation (see Note 9). Ensure that the jacket 15 min of firing the apparatus should be considered
is filled with water at a temperature close to, and suspect.
preferably equal to or slightly below, that of the
calorimeter vessel. Place the prepared bomb in the NOTE 7 - The combustion of highly leaded fuels may
cause appreciable corrosion inside a stainless steel bomb,
calorimeter vessel, check that there is no leakage of
but this is not to be taken as a reason for rejecting the
oxygen, confirm that the firing leads are dead and test result.
make the appropriate electrical connexions. Place
the covers in position, arrange the stirrer, 9.7 When the sulphur content of the sample is
thermometer, and temperature regulating device in unknown, filter the neutralised washings through a
position so that they do not touch the bomb or medium texture filter paper such as a Whatman No.
calorimeter walls. Switch on the calorimeter stirrer, 40, and determine the sulphur content as prescribed
jacket stirrer, heaters, and cooling coil and run the in ASTM D129–IP 61.
apparatus for 5 min to attain equilibrium.
12.6
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
r1 is the rate at which the temperature NOTE 9 - The term DT is an approximation which is
was rising during the 6 min period applied to adjust the effective heat capacity of the system
before firing, in °C/min; at the mean temperature, T, of the determination to the
r2 is the rate at which the temperature reference temperature of 25 °C, and is only necessary
when the mean temperature of the bomb standardisation
was rising during the 5 mm period
and the determination differ by more than 3 °C. It is
after time c in °C min. If the calculated as follows:
temperature was falling, r2 is
negative and the quantity [– r2(c – ⎛ MB ⎞
b)] is positive. DT = α M w − β ⎜ M s + ⎟ J / deg C
⎝ 4 ⎠
10.3 Temperature rise in adiabatic jacket
where
calorimeter Mw is the weight of water in the system, in
kg;
Using data obtained as prescribed in 9.5 and 10.1, Ms is the weight of stainless steel in the
compute the temperature rise, )t in an adiabatic system, in kg;
jacket calorimeter as follows: MB is the weight of bronze and brass in the
system, in kg.
)t = tf – ta
The values " and $ are obtained from the graph in Fig.2.
The mean temperature T in °C is given by the relation
where
)t is the corrected temperature rise, in
Ta + t f
°C; t=
ta is the temperature at time of firing, 2
in °C;
tf is the final maximum recorded where
temperature, in °C. ta is the temperature at the time of firing
in °C;
tf is the final maximum recorded
10.4 Effective heat capacity of the calorimeter temperature in °C.
Calculate the effective heat capacity of the Plot the calculated values of DT in J/°C against values of
calorimeter, W in joules/°C as follows: T between 15 and 35 °C.
[QB + 12
. (25 − t f )]m + e1 + e2 10.5 Gross heat of combustion
W= − DT
Δt
[Notes 8 and 9] Calculate the gross heat of combustion at constant
volume and at 25 °C, in J/g from the equation:
where
QB is the certified calorific value of the Δ t × (W + DT ) − e1 − e2 − e3 − e4
Qg =
benzoic acid in J/g (see 5.6); M
m is the weight of benzoic acid, in g;
)t is the corrected temperature rise, where
°C; W is the effective heat capacity of the
e1 is the correction for the heat of system at 25 °C, in J/°C;
formation of acids in DT is the correction at the mean
J (1 ml 0,1 N NaOH = 5,9 J); temperature, T, obtained from the
e2 is the correction for heat of data plotted as described in Note 9,
combustion of firing cotton in J (if in J/°C (apply this correction in
used) (heat of combustion of batch whole numbers);
x weight of cotton); )t is the corrected temperature rise, in
DT is the correction for test °C;
temperature variation [see Note 9] e1 is the correction for the heat of
in J/°C. (Apply this correction in formation of acids, in joules (1 ml
whole numbers.) 0,1 N NaOH = 5,9 J);
e2 is the correction for firing cotton (if
NOTE 8 - The term [QB +1,2(25 – tf)] relates the certified used) in joules (heat of combustion
heat of combustion of benzoic acid at 25 °C to the final of batch x weight of cotton used);
temperature of the calorimeter.
12.7
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
12.8
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
Aeronautics, Tech. Note 996, June 1945, and J. A. considered suspect if they differ by more than:
Cogliano and R. S. Jessup, 'Relationship between Net
Heat of Combustion and Aniline Gravity Product of 276 J/g (119 BtuIT/lb, 66 calIT/g)
Aircraft Fuels', National Bureau of Standards Report
2348, March 1953.
11.2 Reproducibility
10.7 To obtain the gross or net heat of
The results submitted by each of two laboratories
combustion in calIT/g or BtuIT/lb divide Qg or Qn by
should not be considered suspect unless the two
the appropriate factor given in Section 3.
results differ by more than:
10.8 Report the result as the Gross or Net Heat of
773 J/g (332 BtuIT/lb, 185 calIT/g)
Combustion to the nearest 20 J/g, or to the nearest
10 BtuIT/lb or to the nearest 5 calIT/g.
11.2.1 The precision estimates have been derived
by statistical analysis of inter-laboratory test
11 Precision results and were first published in 1971.
The following criteria should be used for judging the 11.2.2 In the light of a cooperative programme
acceptability of results (95% confidence). carried out by the ASTM/IP, it is apparent that this
method should be carried out by experienced
11.1 Repeatability operators. Under these circumstances a greatly
improved precision can be expected.
Duplicate results by the same operator should be
12.9
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
ANNEX A
12.10
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
Figure 3: Typical bomb for heat of combustion (for values of labelled dimensions see Table 1)
The material from which the bomb cap and body are For a bomb designed to the minimum dimensions
made shall, in addition, be certified to have passed and dimensional ratios given in Table 1, the material
a suitable test for resistance to intercrystalline shall have the following mechanical properties:
corrosion. If steel is used it shall be subject to the
ring test and 90° bend test, described in BS 1501-6 Tensile strength not less than 525 MN/m2.
and BS 970. Elongation at break not less than 25%.
The appropriate British Standards for suitable Aluminium bronze to BS 2872 Grade CA 103 and
materials are listed below: BS 2874 Grade CA 103 have been proved by
experience to be suitable.
BS 1501-6 Steels for use in the chemical,
petroleum, and allied industries. The appropriate British Standards are listed below:
BS 970 Wrought steels in the form of bars,
billets and forgings, up to 152,5 BS 2872: 1969 Copper and copper alloys.
mm ruling section, for automobile Forging stock and forgings.
and general engineering purposes. BS 2874: 1969 Copper and copper alloys.
BS 1503-845 Grade B for Ti for forgings. Rods and sections (other
BS 1506-845 For bars. than forging stock).
12.11
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
A1.7.3 The name of the testing body, the test A4 Oxygen charging equipment
pressure to which the bomb was subjected, and the
date on which the pressure test was made. A4.1 The valves, gauges, filling tube and fittings
used in the oxygen charging system must meet
A1.7.4 A certificate to the effect that a prototype industry safety codes and must be rated for use at
closure ring made of material corresponding to that input pressures up to 206 bar (3 000 psig) and
used in the manufacture of production closure rings discharge pressures up to 55 bar (800 psig).
has withstood a total load (W) as defined below, Separate gauges should be provided to show the
applied in such a way as to simulate operating supply pressure and the bomb pressure. The bomb
conditions without undergoing a permanent change gauge should be not less than 75 mm in diameter
of shape at any point greater than 0,05 mm, where: and preferably graduated from 0 to 55 bar (atm) in
12.12
SPECIFIC ENERGY OF LIQUID FUELS, IP 12
1 bar (atm) sub-divisions. Both gauges must be from a stepdown transformer connected to an
absolutely oil-free and must never be tested in a alternating current line or from a storage battery.
hydraulic system containing oil. The charging The firing voltage must not exceed 24 volts and
equipment should include either a pressure reducing should be held to the lowest practicable level
valve which will limit the discharge pressure to a recommended by the manufacturer. An ammeter or
maximum of 40 bar (600 psig) or a relief valve set a pilot light may be used in the circuit to indicate
to discharge at 40 bar (600 psig) in case the bomb where current is flowing, and the circuit must be
should accidentally be overcharged. Means should controlled by a double-pole, momentary contact
also be provided for releasing the residual pressure switch which remains normally open, except when
in the filling tube after the bomb valve has been held closed by the operator.
closed.
The switch shall be held in the closed position for
A5 Ignition system not more than 2 sec.
12.13