Long Term Auditory Follow Up of Preterm Infants After Neonatal Hearing Screening
Long Term Auditory Follow Up of Preterm Infants After Neonatal Hearing Screening
Long Term Auditory Follow Up of Preterm Infants After Neonatal Hearing Screening
net/publication/335429802
CITATION READS
1 364
4 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Michel Ruben Benard on 27 August 2019.
HSOA Journal of
Neonatology and Clinical Pediatrics
Research Article
Netherlands
2
Pento Speech and Hearing Center Zwolle, Audiologist in Zwolle, Abbreviations
The Netherlands
SNHL - Sensori Neural Hearing Loss
3
Department of Child Health, TNO, Leiden, The Netherlands
CHL - Conductive Hearing Loss
Abstract ANSD - Auditory Neuropathy Spectrum Disorder
PTA - Post Term Age
Background
TOST - Two One-Sided Tests
Since introduction of neonatal Automated Auditory Brainstem Re-
AABR - Automated Auditory Brainstem Response
sponse (AABR) hearing screening in Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
(NICU) graduates, Hearing Loss (HL) is established during the first ABR - Auditory Brainstem Response
few months of age. The diagnostic Auditory Brainstem Response NICU - Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
(ABR) is used as the gold standard in establishing HL after birth. Aim
of this study was to investigate the predictive value of better ear ABR
HL - Hearing Loss
findings at three months Post Term Age (PTA) in preterm infants with VRA - Visual Reinforcement Audiometry
bilateral Sensori Neural (SNHL) or Conductive Hearing Loss (CHL). IVH - Intra Ventricular Hemorrhage
In Preterms with bilateral Auditory Neuropathy Spectrum Disorder
(ANSD) the predictive value of Visual Reinforcement Audiometry
NEC - Necrotising Entero Colitis
(VRA) was investigated.
Introduction
Methods
When Hearing Loss (HL) is diagnosed in the neonatal period it
Outcome data of graduates of a level III NICU, who didn’t pass is essential that interventions are started as early as possible. This
AABR neonatal hearing screening between 2004-2016 were ana-
enables early habilitation, including guidance of parents and fitting
lyzed retrospectively. At follow-up type and hearing level of gradu-
ates with bilateral HL was established. Hearing level was investigat-
of hearing aids, cochlear implants or bone-conduction devices at an
ed at the age of two years using VRA and at four and eight years of early age. This can help the child with normal speech and language
age using play-audiometry. The Two One-Sided Tests equivalence acquisitionwhich leads to improved school achievement, self-esteem
procedure for paired means was applied with the magnitude of the and psychosocial adaption [1,2].
region of similarity equal to 10dB.
A two-step Automated Auditory Brainstem Response (AABR)
Results neonatal hearing screening program was gradually introduced in all
In all 32 cases ABR at three months PTA correctly predicted the Neonatal Intensive Care Units (NICU) in the Netherlands between
final type of HL. In 8 SNHL children initial ABR was equivalent with 1998 and 2001 as a first step towards nation-wide neonatal hearing
the four and eight year’s play-audiometry (p<0.05). In eight SNHL screening [3]. After repetitive referral, audiological diagnostic tests
and 15 ANSD children,VRA levels didn’t reflect significantly play-au- were performed at a Speech and Hearing center to establish neonatal
diometry levels. Almost all cases (89%, N=8/9) with non-syndromic
HL as soon as possible,with in three months Post Term Age (PTA).
CHL recovered properly.
This correction for gestational age is extremely relevant, especially in
*Corresponding author: KS de Graaff-Korf, Department of Neonatology, Isala NICU graduates with an extremely low gestational age. Besides the
Women and Children’s Hospital, The Netherlands, E-mail: [email protected] fact that the stage of the ontogenetic development is related to the du-
Citation: de Graaff-Korf KS, Benard MR, van Dommelen P, van Straaten HLM ration of pregnancy it is reported in literature that the ongoing process
(2019) Long-Term Auditory Follow-Up of Preterm Infants after Neonatal Hearing of myelination of the auditory pathway may be delayed or deviant in
Screening. J Neonatol Clin Pediatr 6: 034. infants who are born prematurely [4-6]. Therefore, we want to inves-
Received: July 11, 2019; Accepted: July 23, 2019; Published: July 30, 2019 tigate the predictive value of the initial diagnostic ABR findings in the
better ear at three months PTA versus the Visual Reinforcement Au-
Copyright: © 2019 de Graaff-Korf KS, et al. This is an open-access article dis- diometry (VRA) results at two years and the play-audiometry results
tributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which at four and eight years of age, with regard to the type and severity of
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided
the original author and source are credited. bilateral HL.
Citation: de Graaff-Korf KS, Benard MR, van Dommelen P, van Straaten HLM (2019) Long-Term Auditory Follow-Up of Preterm Infants after Neonatal Hearing
Screening. J Neonatol Clin Pediatr 6: 034.
• Page 2 of 5 •
Methods for paired means was applied with the magnitude of the region of sim-
ilarity equal to 10dB. The null hypothesis was that the differences in
Outcome data from graduates of a single center level III NICU who mean dB levels for the different tests were not equal. P-values <0.05
did not pass AABR neonatal hearing screening between 2004-2016 were considered significant.
were retrospectively analyzed. Although the NICU hearing screening
program was established in 2001, it is only since 2004 that all the pro- Within the group of patients with etiologically temporary conduc-
cedures and measurement protocols are standardized and well doc- tive HL we defined the ABR level to be predictive if at least 75% have
umented. Auditory retesting was performed at approximately three normal hearing (<35dB) on the play-audiometry (at four and eight
months PTA in two dedicated referral Audiological Centers (Pento years).
Speech and Hearing Centres Zwolle and Hengelo, the Netherlands).
This included an extensive diagnostic ABR, Oto-Acoustic Emissions Results
(OAE) and impedance audiometry, to diagnose the severity and type A total of 62 NICU graduates failed neonatal AABR screening of
of HL. During follow-up VRA and play-audiometry were used to in- which 59 (N꞊59/62) bilaterally and three (N꞊3/62) unilaterally (Figure
vestigate possible progression of HL. The quality and timing of this 1). All three graduates with unilateral AABR failure had no HL at
program is guaranteed by the central regulation and registration of diagnostic testing.
data at the Department of Child Health, TNO, Leiden, The Nether-
lands [7]. For this study, auditory follow-up data were collected from Long term follow-up data were available for 34 (N꞊34/59) new-
NICU graduates with established bilateral HL at approximately three borns with diagnosed bilateral HL at a PTA of three months. In 14
months PTA. The data included the results of impedance audiome- (N=14/59) no HL was diagnosed and in 11 (N꞊11/59) the follow-up
try, OAE, diagnostic ABR, VRA at two years, and play-audiometry dataset was in complete due to referral to Speech and Hearing Centers
at four and eight years of age. Informed consent (oral) was obtained outside the region.
from the parents or legal guardians of all participating patients. This
The type and severity of bilateral HL could be diagnosed in 34
study was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of the Isala
NICU graduates: Nine (N꞊9/34) had CHL, eight (N꞊8/34) had SNHL,
Hospital, Zwolle, The Netherlands (reference number 190508).
15 (N꞊15/34) had ANSD and two (N꞊2/34) had a combination of
Types of hearing loss ANSD and SNHL.
For this study, a distinction is made between Conductive Hear- In this study the last two patients with combined HL were not in-
ing Loss (CHL), Sensori Neural Hearing Loss (SNHL) and Auditory cluded in the results, leaving follow-up data of 32 infants for analysis
Neuropathy Spectrum Disorder (ANSD). (Table 1).
• Page 3 of 5 •
In NICU graduates with SNHL the initial ABR and not the VRA
was significantly accurate in predicting the severity of HL at four and
eight years of age.
• Page 4 of 5 •
which declined with an increased postconceptional age referring to 2. Marciano E, Laria C, Malesci R, Iadicicco P, Landolfi E, et al. (2013) New-
a maturational delay in the auditory pathway [4]. The study of Sleif- born hearing screening in the Campania region (Italy): Early language and
er, et al., confirms these findings with an inverse correlation between perceptual outcomes of infants with permanent hearing loss. Acta Otorhi-
nolaryngol Ital l33: 414-417.
gestational age and ABR interpeak latencies I-III, I-V and III-V with
gestational age [5]. Jiang, et al., also found that the maturation in cen- 3. van Straaten H, Tibosch C, Dorrepaal C, Dekker F, Kok J (2001) Effica-
tral regions of the brainstem is faster compared to the peripheral re- cy of automated auditory brainstem response hearing screening in very
preterm newborns. J Pediatr1 38: 674-678.
gions in preterm infants [6]. Other studies also showed that in preterm
infants, <28 weeks of gestation, there is an improvement in HL up 4. Coenraad S, Hoeve LJ, Goedegebure A (2001) Incidence and clinical value
until the age of 40 weeks post-term, suggestive of maturational prob- of prolonged I-V interval in NICU infants after failing neonatal hearing
lems of the auditory pathway [17]. The study of Vohr, et al., supports screening. EurArch Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 268: 501-505.
this data [18].They observed that even in the absence of brain injury 5. Sleifer P, da Costa S, Cóser P, Goldani M, Dornelles C, et al. (2007) Audi-
there are alterations in maturation and vulnerability of the brain as a tory brainstem response in premature and full-term children.Int J PediatrO-
consequence of premature birth leading to structural changes within torhinolaryngol 71: 1449-1456.
the brain. For these reasons follow-up data in this study were related 6. Jiang Z, Brosi D, Wu Y, Wilkinson A (2009) Relative maturation of periph-
to the PTA of three months which seems to be proper in the SNHL eral and central regions of the human brainstem from preterm to term and
(very) preterm newborns. the influence of preterm birth. Pediatr Res 65: 657-662.
The play-audiometry results at four and eight years of age reflect 7. van Dommelen P, van Straaten H, Verkerk P, Dutch NICU Neonatal Hear-
ing Screening Working Group (2011) Ten-year quality assurance of the
the most objective stage of HL in the child. The less severe hearing nationwide hearing screening programme in Dutch neonatal intensive care
level thresholds at VRA in comparison with play-audiometry levels in units. Acta Paediatr 100: 1097-10103.
the ANSD group may raise questions.The subjective character of the
8. van Zanten G (2008) Audiologische diagnostiek. In: van Straaten H, Meu-
interpretation of the VRA test might possibly bean explanation for the wese-Jongejeugd J (eds.) Werkboek Neonatale gehoorscreening. Werk-
different results between VRA and play-audiometry hearing levels. boek Neonatale Gehoorscreening, The Netherlands.
Another explanation could be a more progressive character or a more
heterogeneous course of ANSD in NICU graduates. Robertson et al. 9. Hoekstra (2009) Spelaudiometrie. In: LamoreB,Prijs P, Franck V (eds.).
Audiologieboek, The Netherlands.
concluded earlier in 2002 that NICU graduates with severe respirato-
ry failure frequently developed late-onset progressive ANSD without 10. Bovo R, Trevisi P, Ghiselli S, Benatti A, Martini A (2015) Is very early
a clear explanation for this phenomenon [19]. One can also argue that hearing assessment always reliable in selecting patients for cochlear im-
plants? A case series study. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 79: 725-731.
the more positive results of VRA are partly consequence of the altered
or delayed maturation of the brain [5,6]. This study does not support 11. Psarommatis I, Florou V, Fragkos M, Douniadakis E, Kontrogiannis A
an ongoing deterioration reflected by stable play-audiometry levels (2011) Reversible auditory brainstem responses screening failures in high
between four and eight years of age in children with ANSD. Gard- risk neonates. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 268: 189-196.
ner-Berry, et al., followed twelve infants with ANSD until the age of 12. Yoon PJ, Price M, Gallagher K, Fleisher BE, Messner AH (2003) The
two years. They found that a reliable VRA was difficult to obtain and need for long-term audiologic follow-up of Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
resulted in a time delay in further audiological management [15]. (NICU) graduates. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 67: 353-357.
13. Ching TY, Day J, Dillon H, Gardner-Berry K, Hou S, et al. (2013) Impact
Limitation of this study is the limited number of included new- of the presence of Auditory Neuropathy Spectrum Disorder (ANSD) on
borns. We realize there was no sufficient statistical power to detect outcomes of children at three years of age. Int J Audiol 52: 55-64.
a lack of difference. Though, the initial results were encouraging for
extending this study. 14. Martínez-Cruz CF, García Alonso-Themann P, Poblano A, Ochoa-López
JM (2012) Hearing loss, auditory neuropathy, and neurological co-mor-
We conclude that the preliminary findings in this study suggests bidity in children with birthweight<750 g. Arch Med Res 43: 457-463.
that in NICU graduates ABR of the better ear at three months PTA 15. Gardner-Berry K, Purdy SC, Ching TY, Dillon H (2015) The audiological
reliably predicts the type and severity of HL at four and eight years of journey and early outcomes of twelve infants with auditory neuropathy
age in children with SNHL. In the group of children with ANSD VRA spectrum disorder from birth to two years of age. Int J Audiol 54: 524-535.
levels were lower and not predictive for the severity of HL at four and 16. American Academy of Pediatrics, Joint Committee on Infant Hearing
eight years of age with play-audiometry. These initial results warrant (2007) Year 2007 position statement: Principles and guidelines for early
more future research in a larger study group to substantiate reliable hearing detection and intervention programs. Pediatrics 120: 898-921.
predictions with greater precision of the severity of HL in relation to 17. Hof JR, Stokroos RJ, Wix E, Chenault M, Gelders E, et al. (2013) Audi-
the initial findings at the young age in very preterm NICU graduates tory maturation in premature infants: A potential pitfall for early cochlear
to support early intervention and adequately rehabilitation. implantation. Laryngoscope1 23: 2013-2018.
18. Vohr B (2014) Speech and language outcomes of very preterm infants.
References Semin Fetal Neonatal Med 19: 78-83.
19. Robertson CM, Tyebkhan JM, Hagler ME, Cheung PY, Peliowski A, et al.
1. Dettman SJ, Dowell RC, Choo D, Arnott W, Abrahams Y, et al. (2016)
(2002) Late-onset, Progressive Sensori Neural Hearing Loss after Severe
Long-term communication outcomes for children receiving cochlear im-
Neonatal Respiratory Failure. Otol Neurotol 23: 353-356.
plants younger than 12 months: A multicenter study. Otol Neurotol l37:
82-95.
Herald Scholarly Open Access, 2561 Cornelia Rd, #205, Herndon, VA 20171, USA.
Tel: +1 202-499-9679; E-mail: [email protected]
http://www.heraldopenaccess.us/
View publication stats