Converted 110401
Converted 110401
Converted 110401
No Business can ever exist unless it has three resources to support it i.e.
Man, Money and Machines.
Along with looking for value addition from employees, “giving back” to
them is also quite essential as it develops a feeling of belongingness
towards the company.
To this end and intent, companies offer various employee benefit schemes
with pre-determined objectives .
OBJECTIVES OF EMPLOYEE BENEFIT SCHEMES?
To retain the key employees and reduce the attrition rate of the Company.
Grants of Options.
Acceptance of Grant
Exercise of Options
Employee Coverage
Type of plan
The key attributes
to be established Route of the Scheme
for designing a
stock-based Period of Vesting
benefit plan are:
Vesting Conditions
Exercise Period
COVERAGE OF EMPLOYEES
Defined under Regulation 2(i) of SEBI (Share Based Employee Benefits and Sweat Equity)
Regulations, 2021
“Employee” Means
an employee* as designated by the company, who is exclusively working in India or outside India; or
a director of the company, whether a whole time director or not, including a non-executive director who
is not a promoter or member of the promoter group, but excluding an independent director; or
an employee as defined in sub-clauses (i) or (ii), of a group company including subsidiary or its
associate** company, in India or outside India, or of a holding company of the company
a director who, either himself or through his relative or through any body corporate, directly or indirectly,
holds more than ten per cent of the outstanding equity shares of the company.
• *“Permanent Employee of the Company "has been covered as per Companies Act, 2013.
• To motivate ESOPs in Startups, Government has even allowed to offer ESOPs to Promoters & Directors holding more than 10% of the
outstanding Equity Share capital of the company – for a period of 10 (Ten) years from the date of Incorporation or Registration.
• ** Associate Company has been omitted under Companies Act, 2013 vide Notification dated 18.03.2015.
TYPES OF EMPLOYEE BENEFIT
SCHEME
Employee Stock
Options
Restricted Stock
Types of Employee Units
Stock Benefit
Schemes
Stock Appreciation
Rights (Equity)
Stock Appreciation
Rights
Cash Based Plan
(Cash)/Phantom
Stock
EMPLOYEE STOCK OPTION PLAN (ESOP)
• It is right offered by a Company to its
Employees to purchase equity shares of it
company at a discounted price.
VIEW TO BE CONSIDERED:
• As per market practice ESOP is an integral compensation tool for retaining and employing human
resource.
• ESOP is a repetitive practice intended to continuously appraise and incentivize the employees.
06/05/2023
RESTRICTED STOCK UNIT SCHEME (RSU)
• Under RSUs an Employee is awarded with the shares subject to fulfillment of certain
underlying conditions.
• Under this scheme, full rights may be conditional and predicated on the occurrence
of certain events e.g. continued employment and/or achievement of certain business
measures.
Performance Based:
RSU’s are granted with an objective to motivate an employee for achieving a pre-
determined performance target linked with:
• individual performance; or
• organizational performance; or
• combination of both
RESTRICTED STOCK UNITS (RSU)
VIEW TO BE CONSIDERED:
• Higher value to employee- Unlike ESOPs, the exercise price of which is based on
the market value of the shares, the exercise price of RSUs is the par value of the
shares.
• Lower Dilution- RSUs are granted to only selected employees aligned towards
specific tangible goal.
• Granting RSUs is a selective practice, as a tool to give target driven incentive to the
employees.
Settled in Cash:
Appreciation amounting to the difference between Exercise Value and Base
value (less applicable taxes) is directly transferred to the bank account of an
employee or through such other modes as prescribed.
Settled in Equity:
Appreciation amounting to the difference between Exercise Value and Base
value (less applicable taxes) is converted into Equity shares which are then
allotted the employee.
STOCK APPRECIATION RIGHTS (SAR)
VIEW TO BE CONSIDERED:
• Low Dilution Risk- Since the benefit is based on the incremental value the shares
allotted are less and in case of cash settlement there is no dilution
The principle message conveyed to the employees is that, if they stay long
enough till vesting, they stand to gain significantly through increase in
company’s market value
EMPLOYEE STOCK PURCHASE SCHEME (ESPS)
• Employee Stock Purchase Schemes allow Employee to purchase Company’s shares at
a discount from Fair Market Value.
The terms of the Plan determines the tenure and price for possession of the Company’s
shares by the Employees.
• ESPS is being framed by banks for offering shares as a part of public holding.
VIEW TO BE CONSIDERED:
• ESPS is a reward plan intended to appraise and incentivize the employees for their
past contributions
• Ascertained Benefit- the shares are allotted immediately so the benefit received is well
ascertained
The principle message conveyed to the employees is that they are also
considered as business owners based on their proven performance.
TYPES OF PLAN AS PER CURRENT
MARKET PRACTICES
Direct
Route Trust
Route
Now, the Companies can make changes in the route of the Scheme (i.e. Direct Route to Trust
Route or Vice-Versa) subject to the Shareholders approval.
DIRECT ROUTE
Direct
Route
Employe
Company 2 Direct Issue of Shares
e
3 Issue of options
ACQUISITION OF SHARES BY TRUST
Trust can acquire shares by:
06/05/2023
VESTING CONDITIONS
The employee earns the right to convert option to shares during the
vesting during subject to certain vesting conditions
Graded Vesting:
• Graded vesting is the process by which employees is vested with the benefits over
time in specified intervals.
• Certain portion of the options granted vest with each completed year of service
during the vesting period.
• Cliff Vesting means that the employees become immediately 100 percent vested
upon completion of specified period of service.
• If the employee leaves the organization before that specified time, the options
granted would be forfeited and lapse.
PRICING CRITERIA FOR EXERCISE PRICE
To exercise an option, the employee pays an exercise price to the
company and receives shares for each option exercised.
Base Price
Companies are free to decide the Exercise price, discount / premium over it
however, the Exercise price shall never go below the Par Value of Shares.
EXERCISE PERIOD
Exercise Period means the time period after vesting within which an
employee should exercise his right to apply for shares against the vested
option in pursuance of the Plan
The exercise period may be Time Based or Event Based:
Time Based
• Under this the options can be exercised after completion of the specified period
after vesting of options.
• The exercise may be done immediately upon vesting or after completion a certain
time period, in whole or in part during the exercise period.
• No specific time period has been prescribed under the law for Exercise of
Options/ Units / Offer etc.
Event Based
• In case of unlisted companies since the shares are not traded on stock exchange
the company may find practically difficulty in providing exit to the employees
upon exercise.
• The company may provide exercise option to the employee on occurrence of
certain specified exit events.
ALLOTMENT OF SHARES
Allotment means issuance of shares to the employee by Company against
the number of options exercised under the Scheme.
Direct Route:
• Upon valid exercise of options by the employee, allotment of new shares will
be made by the company directly to the employees, upon receipt of exercise
price and applicable taxes and other charges if any, in the name of the
Company.
• The said allotment is made by the Company subject to the applicable laws.
• The Company shall intimate the employee about such allotment.
• After such allotment, the employee shall become a member of the Company.
Trust Route:
• When the Trust acquires shares through fresh subscription from the company,
i.e direct allotment of shares is made to the Trust.
• Upon valid exercise of options by the employee, the Trust shall transfer the
shares to the employees, upon receipt of exercise price in the name of the Trust
and Taxes payable in the name of the Company.
• Under secondary acquisition , no fresh allotment of shares is involved.
SALE/EXIT OF SHARES
Sale of shares can be freely done by employee in the market .
• The employee can freely sell their shares on occurrence of any liquidity
events.
Shares can be
directly sold in the
Following may be considered as liquidity events:
Market.
• Acquisition by any company, person, entity or group of a controlling stake
in the Company.
• The successful listing of the Company’s share on a recognized stock market
• In case of private equity investment in the Company
• In case of Investments by NRIs and VCs
• Investment by High Net Worth Individuals
• Merger, de-merger, spin-off, acquisition, consolidation, amalgamation, sale
of business, dissolution or other reorganization of the Company in which
the Shares are converted into or exchanged for Cash
• Sale, lease or exchange of all or substantially all of the assets or undertaking
of the Company
• Any liquidity event created by the management of the Company itself.
PROCEDURE FOR ISSUANCE
LISTED COMPANY
• Drafting of the Scheme
Step
1
Step • Hold General Meeting of the Shareholders for approval of the Scheme.
3
• Obtain In-principal application to the Stock Exchange(s) for seeking their approval for the
Step issuance of the equity Shares under Employee Stock Option Scheme for Listed Company.
4
Step • Issue of grant and vesting letters to the employees from time to time .
6
• Hold a Board Meeting at the suitable interval during the exercise period for allotment of
Step
7 shares on options exercised by the Employees in accordance with the exercise forms received.
Step • Listing application to be filed by the Listed company with the Stock Exchange(s) to get the
8 shares so allotted listed (in case of direct allotment) and Dispatch of letter of allotment.
PROCEDURE FOR ISSUANCE
UNLISTED COMPANY
• Drafting of the Scheme
Step 1
• Hold a Board Meeting for making grants to employees identified by the Board of Directors
Step 4 on who are eligible to participate in the scheme.
• Issue of grant and vesting letters to the employees from time to time .
Step 6
• Hold a Board Meeting at the suitable interval during the exercise period for allotment of
Step 7 shares on options exercised by the Employees in accordance with the exercise forms
received.
TAX TREATMENT
In the hands of
Employee
*“Permanent Employee of the Company “ & Employees or Director of Subsidiary or Holding company in
India or outside India has been covered as per Companies Act, 2013.
REGULATORY ASPECTS-IN TERMS OF
ISSUANCE
Unlisted Listed
Company Company
Further, the sweat equity shares shall not exceed 25% of the paid-up
equity capital of the issuing company at any point in time.
1. Exception for Start-ups-They can issue sweat equity shares of up to 50% of the paid-up capital
within 10 years from the date of its registration or incorporation.
2. The maximum quantum of Sweat Equity Shares shall not exceed fifteen percent of the existing paid
up equity share capital in a year or shares of the issue value of rupees five crore, whichever is higher.
(issuance of sweat equity shares in the Company shall not exceed twenty five percent, of the paid up
equity capital of the Company at any time.
QUANTUM OF SWEAT EQUITY-LISTED
Maximum: Further, the sweat equity shares shall not exceed 25% of the
paid-up equity capital of the issuing company at any point in time.
Acquisition of Sweat Equity Issue shall be subject to the provisions of SEBI (SAST) Regulations
2017 , SEBI (ICDR) Regulation 2018, Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, Securities
Contracts (Regulation) Rules, 1957.
PRICING OF SWEAT EQUITY
Frequently Infrequently
Traded Traded
*FREQUENTLY TRADED SHARES means shares, in which the traded turnover on any stock exchange during 240 trading days
preceding the relevant date, is at least 10% of total number of shares of such class of shares.
LOCK IN PERIOD- SWEAT EQUITY
18 Months
Promoters from Trading Date of For a period
Approval Date Allotment of 3 years
Equity Shares
Allotted
6 Months from
Public Trading
Approval Date
SWEAT EQUITY-CEILING ON MANAGERIAL
REMUNERATION
IF THE SWEAT EQUITY The amount of sweat equity shares issued shall
SHARES ARE ISSUED be treated as part of managerial Remuneration, if
PURSUANT the following conditions are fulfilled:—
TO
ACQUISITION OF VALUE a) the sweat equity shares are issued to any director or
WHICH DOES NOT TAKE manager; and
FORM OF AN ASSET
a) they are issued for consideration other than cash, which
does not take the form of an asset which can be carried to
the balance sheet of the company.
IF THE SWEAT EQUITY • The value of the asset, as determined by the valuation
SHARES ISSUED PURSUANT report, shall be carried in the balance sheet as per the
TO Accounting Standards.
ACQUISITION OF AN ASSET
• Here no part of consideration shall form part of managerial
remuneration.
PROCEDURE FOR ISSUANCE
LISTED COMPANY
Convening of Board Meeting for approval of Sweat Equity Issue
• File a copy of special resolution with ROC within 30 days of the passing of resolution
in Form MGT-14.
Step 4
• Hold a meeting of the Board within a period of not more than 12 months from the
date of passing of the special resolution: To consider the allotment of sweat equity
Step 5 shares and issue of allotment letters and share certificates
TAXATION ASPECTS
(FOR EMPLOYEES)
STAGES TAX TREATMENT
Allotment of shares
Taxed as perquisite in the hands of Employees which is computed as the difference
between the Fair Market Value of the share on the date of allotment and the
*Lock-in period in case of Listed Company shall be as per SEBI (SBEB &SE) Regulations, 2021
Mohini Varshneya Anshuma Dev
Partner & Head – ESOP Assistant Manager– ESOP
Services & Services &
Insider Laws Insider Laws
M: + 91 9971673332 M: + 917014628406
T: +91 1140622231 T: +91 1140622244
[email protected] [email protected]
www.corporateprofessionals.com www.corporateprofessionals.com