Asuncion v. Salvado
Asuncion v. Salvado
Asuncion v. Salvado
DECISION
PER CURIAM : p
FROM: Respondent
Date: February 4, 2014
Time: 11:09 a.m.
Honestly, sobra2 n pakiusap at pagpapaliwanag na gnawa ko mairaos
lng ang decisyn na syang kaisa isang depensa na pde panghawakkan
ng nanay mo para madismis kaso nya! Naintindihan ko sitwasyn nyo
pero dapat intindihn nyo rn stwasyon ko! Kung gusto nyong
ma2lungan kayo, magtiwala at makipag2lungan dn kayo . . . hope u
understand 59
FROM: Complainant
Date: February 4, 2014
Time: 11:09 a.m.
Kung 18 nyo ibibigay yang mga papel na yan wala ng pag gagamitan
nyan dahil 20 ang hearing ng mother ko ipapadala pa yan sa
switzerland. Hindi pwede yung ganun paki gawan ng paraan nag
hirap mag hanap ng pera panay txt kayo sa akin inipit din nyo ako
kaya gumawa ako ng paraan tapos 18 nyo ibibigay anu mangyayare
sa nanay ko dun sa hearing nya! 60
FROM: Respondent
Date: February 4, 2014
Time: 11:44 a.m.
Wag mo ako mamanduhan tila s Recto ginagawa dokmento! Sobra2
na follow up ko s inyo dhl sbi ko gagahulin tayo pag pinatagal pa! Ano
gnawa nyo? Gusto nyo magkaraon ng 2nay at maayos n defense pero
d nyo naman pinaglalaanan ng priodad! Kung nuon nyo p bnuo pera,
tagal n sna tapos kaso ng nanay mo! At wala ka karapatan na
magmando n ibigay ang mga dokumento n d pa byad ang lahat!
Maliwanag ang usaping iyan! Saka d kailangang isakripisyo ang ibang
commitments ko s pagantay s inyo n ideliver ang pyment dhl
responsibilidad nyo yn! I hav hundreds of pending cases also! Ikaw at
nanay mo kausap ko d2 kaya d kailngang humarap kung kani kanino!
At ito intindhn mo, nadelay ang proceso dahil s kakulangan nyo s
budget. d ako nagkulang s paalala s inyo kht nagmumukha n akong
tanga! Umayos ka ng salita kung gusto may patutunguhan pa ang
usaping ito! Kayo nan ga nagkulang kayo pa ang may ganang
magsalita ng ganyan! 61
FROM: Respondent
Date: February 4, 2014
Time: 12:24 a.m.
eto ang BDO current account ng exec secretary ko # 402 800 136-9
name Hazel Sarabia Boado. Pede nyo deposit nalang d2 pera
Ma Vesta s Aquino rcbc act no 9007004692 or s acct n to 62
(Underscoring omitted.)
Respondent argues that the records are bereft of any proof which
would show that the messages originated from a phone number registered
in his name. For him, the text messages are inadmissible for failure to satisfy
the requirements under the Rules on Electronic Evidence. 63
SO ORDERED.
Gesmundo, C.J., Leonen, Caguioa, Hernando, Lazaro-Javier, Inting,
Zalameda, M.V. Lopez, Gaerlan, Rosario, J.Y. Lopez, Dimaampao, Marquez,
Kho, Jr. and Singh, JJ., concur.
Footnotes
1. See Salaysay ng Reklamo, rollo, pp. 2-5.
4. Id. at 2.
5. Id. at 6.
6. Id. at 10.
7. Id. at 11.
8. Id. at 12.
9. Id. at 27.
10. Id. at 3.
11. Id.
18. Id.
19. Id. at 24.
43. Atty. Yumul-Espina v. Atty. Tabaquero, 795 Phil. 653, 659 (2016), citing
Ventura v. Samson , 699 Phil. 404 (2012).
44. See Cristobal v. Atty. Renta, 743 Phil. 145 (2014); Gaviola v. Atty. Salcedo, 472
Phil. 624 (2004); Bernaldez v. Atty. Anquilo-Garcia , supra note 37; Ventura v.
Atty. Samson, 699 Phil. 404 (2012).
45. Respondent quoted portions of Commissioner Buted's Report and
Recommendation in his Motion for Reconsideration; rollo, pp. 46-47.
46. Id.
47. Id. at 40-41. See also id. at 24-A, 26-A, 32-A, 34-A, 40-41.
48. Sec. 69, Rule 120, Rules of Court.
50. See Koh v. Court of Appeals, 160-A Phil. 1034, 1042 (1975), citing Uytengsu v.
Republic, 95 Phil. 890 (1954).
51. See Lapitan v. Atty. Salgado , A.C. No. 12452, February 18, 2020.
53. Ylaya v. Atty. Gacott, 702 Phil. 390, 404-405 (2013), citing A.Z. Arnaiz Realty,
Inc. v. Office of the President, 638 Phil. 481, 491 (2010).
54. Rollo, pp. 13-21.
59. Id.
82. Rodco Consultancy and Maritime Services Corp. v. Atty. Concepcion, supra
CD Technologies Asia, Inc. © 2023 cdasiaonline.com
note 72.
84. Id. at 334. See also Bataan Shipyard and Engineering Co., Inc. v. Consunji , A.C.
No. 11439, January 4, 2022; Bayonla v. Reyes, 676 Phil. 500 (2011);
Adrimisin v. Javier, 532 Phil. 639 (2006); Rollon v. Naraval , 493 Phil. 24
(2005); and Ramos v. Imbang , 557 Phil. 507 (2007).