01 Introduction To Philosophy of Research
01 Introduction To Philosophy of Research
01 Introduction To Philosophy of Research
"The great virtue of philosophy is that it teaches not what to think, but how
to think. It is the study of meaning of the principles underlying conduct,
thought and knowledge”
Goal of philosophy: Improved quality of life
Hence, philosophy is a way of transforming oneself for the better
It provides a framework for life and our action
It can be useful in solving educational problems
What is Philosophy?
knowledge,
values,
reason,
mind, and
language
Definitions
Analytical function
Logical function
Theoretical function
Thinking function
Knowledge function
Research function
Philosophical Approaches
1. Philosophy is a set of views or beliefs about life and the universe, which
are often held uncritically
We refer to this meaning as the informal sense of philosophy or “having” a
philosophy
Usually when a person says “my philosophy is,” he or she is referring to an
informal personal attitude to whatever topic is being discussed.
Nature of Philosophy
5. Philosophy is a group of ever lasting problems that interest people and for
which philosophers always have sought answers
Philosophy presses its inquiry into the deepest problems of human existence
Many questions, however, have been answered only tentatively, and many
problems remain unsolved
What is truth?
What is the distinction between right and wrong?
What is life and why am I here?
Why is there anything at all?
Importance of Philosophy
Scope of metaphysics
Metaphysics is the science of being as being
Metaphysics is the science of immaterial being: Spiritual
Metaphysics is the science of the most abstract conceptions
Metaphysics is the science of the principles
Metaphysics is the science of the most universal conception
2. Epistemology
Definitions of Epistemology
American Encyclopedia It is systematic philosophical investigation of
human knowledge
Britannica Encyclopedia Epistemology is the study about nature of
knowledge and uses of knowledge
International Education Encyclopedia Epistemology is theory of
knowledge, it is valuable and natural
2. Epistemology
The Rationalists Human reason alone can discover the basic principles
of the universe
The Empiricists All knowledge is ultimately derived from experience
and, thus, that our knowledge is limited to what can be experienced
It should be clear that there is a necessary relation between metaphysics
and epistemology
Conversely, our theory of knowledge depends on our understanding of
ourselves in relation to the whole of reality
3. Axiology/Value Theory
Aesthetics, and
Ethics
The study of values in human behavior or the study of moral problems
e.g.,
Ethics
It concerns itself with the question of morality
What is right and what is wrong in human relations?
It seek to identify, within the range of human conduct, the motives, desires,
and intentions as well as overt acts themselves
3. Axiology/Value Theory
Aesthetics
Concerns the theory of art and beauty
The study of value in the arts
The inquiry into feelings, judgments, or standards of beauty and related
concepts
Questions of art and beauty are considered to be part of the realm of values
because many philosophical problems in aesthetics involve critical judgments
3. Axiology/Value Theory
Aesthetics
Philosophy of art is concerned with judgments of sense, taste, and emotion
E.g., Is art an intellectual or representational activity?
Does art represent sensible objects or ideal objects?
Is artistic value objective?
Is it merely coincidental that many forms in architecture and painting seem to
illustrate mathematical principles?
Are there standards of taste?
Is there a clear distinction between art and reality?
3. Axiology/Value Theory
Aesthetics
There are wide differences of opinion as to what objects call forth the
aesthetic response, and what beauty really is
Our concepts of beauty may differ not because of the nature of beauty itself
Therefore, if we cannot perceive beauty in objects that others find beautiful,
it may be wise to withhold judgment until we are capable ourselves of making
a competent analysis of the aesthetic experience
3. Axiology/Value Theory
Ethics is concerned with what is good for individuals and society and is also
described as moral philosophy.
The term is derived from the Greek word ethos which can mean custom, habit,
character or disposition(nature, outlook)
Ethics covers the following dilemmas:
How to live a good life?
Our rights and responsibilities
The language of right and wrong
Moral decisions - what is good and bad?
Meaning of Ethics
Rules are the means and whenever there are means, there must be an
end or goal as well
If Right is the mean of conduct, then the question arises that what should
be its end
Ethics as a science is not concerned with particular good of the
individuals; on the contrary it is concerned with the supreme goal or the
ultimate end with reference to which the entire life of individual is
directed – the ‘Summum Bonum’.
Moral Philosophy
One of the big questions in moral philosophy is whether or not there are
unchanging moral rules that apply in all cultures and at all times
The moral philosophy involves systematizing, defending, and
recommending concepts of right and wrong behavior
Ethical theories are divided into three general subject areas:
Metaethics
Normative ethics
Applied ethics
Moral Philosophy
Metaethics
It investigates where our ethical principles come from, and what they mean
Are they merely social inventions?
Do they involve more than expressions of our individual emotions?
Normative ethics
It takes on a more practical task, which is to arrive at moral standards that
regulate right and wrong conduct
This may involve articulating the good habits that we should acquire, the
duties that we should follow, or the consequences of our behavior on others
Moral Philosophy
Applied ethics
It involves examining specific controversial issues, such as:
Abortion
Iinfanticide
Animal rights
Environmental concerns
Homosexuality
Nuclear war
Moral Values
Truth
Non-violence
Kindness
Equality
Happiness
Friendship
Peace
Patience
Meaning of Moral Judgment
The moral judgement is the judgement which deals with the moral value or
quality of an action
It is a judgement of value and it evaluates the rightness or wrongness of our
actions
When we analyse a moral judgement then we find that it contains
a) a subject which will judge
b) an object whose action will be judged
c) a standard in conformity to which the action of the subject will be judged, and
d) a power of judging the action as required
Meaning of Moral Judgment
If the voluntary actions have conformity with the standard or the ideal,
then the moral judgment will express it as the right action
If the action has conflict with the standard or norms, then the moral
judgment will express it as wrong
So, moral judgment involves comparison of voluntary acts with the moral
standard
Meaning of Moral Judgment
Curiosity and the self-driven efforts to satisfy the curiosity lie at the root of
research
It involves systematic and creative investigations in any domain of
knowledge
These can be related to
Either philosophy or matter
Or anything in this Universe that can be perceived by our senses
The Philosophy of Research
Research has…
Owner/s
who learn about the new discovery when the owner communicates the new
information/knowledge to the larger group
The Philosophy of Research
1. Problem-solving
It enhances the ability to evaluate and resolve problems
It helps to analyze concepts, definitions, arguments, and problems
It contributes towards the capacity to
Organize ideas and issues
Deal with questions of value, and
Extract what is essential from masses of information
Why is Philosophy Important in Research?
1. Problem-solving
It helps both to
Distinguish fine differences between views and
Discover common ground between opposing positions
It can help to synthesize a variety of views or perspectives into a coherent
understanding
Why is Philosophy Important in Research?
Descriptive writing
Research Philosophy
Knowingly or unknowingly a researcher will be making numerous
assumptions while embarking on research
These assumptions help a researcher to design the research questions,
choose appropriate methods, and influence the interpretation of findings
These assumptions altogether form the research philosophy of the study
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
These assumptions are of three types:
Ontological assumptions
Epistemological assumptions
Axiological assumptions
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
Ontological assumptions
Assumptions regarding
Research Philosophy
Epistemological assumptions
Assumptions associated with
human knowledge or
What forms valid knowledge or
Whether it can be known, and
How a researcher can get it and transfer it
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
Axiological assumptions
These are assumptions about
The level of influence of the researcher’s values on the research process or
What is essential and valuable in the research
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
According to Saunders et al. (2019), there are five research philosophies:
Positivism
Critical realism
Interpretivism
Postmodernism; and
Pragmatism
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
Positivism
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
Critical realism
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
Interpretivism
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
Postmodernism
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Philosophy
Pragmatism
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Approach
According to Saunders et al. (2012), there are three research approaches:
Induction
Deduction, and
Abduction
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Approach
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Approach
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Approach
Inductive approach to research
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Approach
Deductive approach to research
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Approach
Abductive approach to research
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Design
It is the overall plan of a research project which involves three distinct but
interrelated aspects
They are: methodological choice, research strategy and time horizon
Sanders et al. (2019) classified research designs into three types:
Qualitative research design
Quantitative research design
Mixed methods research design
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Design
Qualitative research design
Peeling the Research Onion
Research Design
Quantitative research design
Peeling the Research Onion
Methodological Choices
Methodological Choice involves the selection and use of a quantitative,
qualitative, or mixed methods research design
Mono method: A single data collection technique is utilized, followed by
corresponding qualitative or quantitative analysis procedures
Multiple method design: More than one data collection techniques and analysis
procedures are employed
Mixed-method approach: It utilizes both qualitative and quantitative data
collection techniques and analysis procedures
Peeling the Research Onion
Methodological Choices
According to Saunders et al. (2019), mixed method research can be classified
into three ways which are as follows:
Concurrent mixed methods research
Here a researcher collects both qualitative and quantitative data and analyses them in
a single phase study.
Sequential mixed methods research
Here a researcher collects and analyses data in two phases, which can further be
divided into two forms:
Peeling the Research Onion
Methodological Choices
According to Saunders et al. (2019), mixed method research can be classified
into three ways which are as follows:
Sequential exploratory research design
where a researcher collects and analyses qualitative data in the first phase, followed
by quantitative data collection and analysis in the second phase;
Sequential explanatory research design
Here a researcher collects and analyses quantitative data in the first phase followed
by qualitative data collection and analysis in the second phase.
Peeling the Research Onion
Methodological Choices
According to Saunders et al. (2019), mixed method research can be classified
into three ways which are as follows:
Sequential multi-phase
In this a researcher collects and analyses data in more than two phases, in sequence.
For example, qualitative followed by quantitative and then qualitative.
Peeling the Research Onion
Time Horizon
Research can be grouped into two types based on time
Longitudinal or successive independent samples
The longitudinal study refers to the study of a phenomenon or a population over a
period of time
Cross-sectional
Ethical considerations
https://www.aesanetwork.org/research-onion-a-systematic-approach-to-
designing-research-methodology/