Malaina Fed With Cassava Peel
Malaina Fed With Cassava Peel
Malaina Fed With Cassava Peel
arborea LEAVES AND CASSAVA PEEL FED TO WEST AFRICAN DWARF (WAD)
SHEEP.
1
ABSTRACT
Inadequate forage in quality and quantity during the dry season is the major constraint in
ruminant production in Nigeria, and this negatively influences the performance of these animals.
In an effort to surmount this limitation, Gmelina arborea leaves (GML) and cassava peel (CsP)
were ensiled at different proportions to evaluate the physio-chemical quality, intake and growth
response by West African dwarf (WAD) goats fed the diets. The varying proportions of GML
and CsP were mixed as follows; 100GAL, 75GAL+25CP, 50GAL+50CP, 25GAL+75CP and
100CP. The mixtures were ensiled for 21 days. Sixteen West African dwarf (WAD) goats aged
7-8 months weighing between 8.45- 8.48kg housed in individual pens were used to determine
feed intake, growth rate and feed conversion ratio for 90 days. Completely randomized design
was adopted for the study. Silages with CsP had pleasant smell and pH range of 3.7-4.7 while the
silage without CsP had non-pleasant smell with pH of 9.5. The pH and temperature reduced with
increasing level of cassava peel while the smell, texture and appearance improved with
2
CERTIFICATION
This project entitled "Voluntary intake and nutrient digestibility of ensiled Gmelina arborea
and cassava peel fed to WAD Sheep" by ODEDEYI BLESSING OLUFUNKE with the matric
number 163507 supports the laid down principles of the degree of Bachelor of Technology
___________________________ ________________
Supervisor
________________________ _________________
Head of Department
3
DECLARATION
I thus declare that this project has been written by me and is a record of my own research
work. All citations and sources are clearly acknowledged by means of references.
_______________________ _________________
4
DEDICATION
This is dedicated to Almighty God the One who is the brain behind my success and to my
loving and caring parents and pastor for their support so far.
5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My acknowledgement goes to my Father, the maker of the universe and all there is for his Love
and faithfulness, for helping me leap over this wall. Thank you Jesus, thank you Holy Spirit for
being my helper.
My utmost appreciation goes to my supervisor, Dr. (Mrs) R.T. Binuomote for her guidance,
correction and support shown during the period of the research. I also appreciate the efforts of
the H.O.D of the department of Animal Production and Health (APH); Dr. T.A Rafiu and all
My sincere appreciation goes to my loving family, my parents- Pastor and Deaconess Ronke
Odedeyi for their sacrifice, prayers, encouragement, financial support throughout my stay in
school, you’ve been the best parents in the world. My dear sister- Kemisola Odedeyi and
handsome brother, you are not counted out in the story line of my academics. God Almighty
Evangelism Church.
Profound gratitude also goes to my friends and project mates- Adepeju, Olufemi, Precious,
Dorcas, Deborah, Daniel, Bashirat, Ifeoluwa and others for their cooperation and support who all
To everyone who is part of my success story, a heartfelt gratitude and may you reap much more.
6
CHAPTER ONE
1.1. Introduction
Ruminant animals play an important role in the economic development of Nigeria in terms
of feeding the steadily growing population and providing the investible resources for national
development (Bolaji et al., 2016). The most commonly reared ruminants in Nigeria include
cattle, sheep and goat. Sheep is one of the most important small ruminant livestock species that
produces a good source of meat and milk for human consumption. It represents about 30% of
ruminant livestock in Africa and the largest group of small ruminant livestock in Nigeria
(FAOSTAT, 2011). About 85% of rural households and small time business people keep sheep
(FDLPCS, 2007). The West African dwarf sheep is the most common and an indigenous breed in
the West and Central African countries (Chiejina & Behnke, 2011). Most sheep are reared on
free range and trek for long distance in search of feed especially during the dry season which
may have adverse effect on their performance. Feed accounts for 60–70% of total cost of
livestock production and it’s inadequacy in quality and quantity could lead to a situation of low
nutritional status, poor weight gain, poor reproductive ability, poor production, poor health
condition and poor conversion ratio (Fajemisin et al., 2015). It therefore, becomes important to
supply adequate feed in quantity and quality for optimal performance by livestock. The
attainment of sustainable livestock production largely depends on the availability, quality and
quantity of feed Ibhaze et al., (2015). Scarcity and poor quality of forage is usually experienced
during the dry season, this renders these animals undernourished for a significant part of the
year. The excess forage produced by the perennial species in the rainy season must be conserved
and should be considered a potential forage resource for feed in the dry season. Ruminant owners
raise their animals on natural grasses, which are intrinsically poor in nutritive value, low in
7
digestibility and scarce during the dry season (Babayemi et al., 2009). The animals are therefore
In Nigeria, seasonal variations and lack of forage are the main factors affecting ruminant
productivity since animals lose weight quickly after gaining it during the lush season, which can
result in death and cause significant financial losses to farmers, Kimathi et al. (2021). Ruminants
gain weight during the wet season, which corresponds to the period of adequate pasture growth
and abundant feed supply. However during the dry season most of the weight gained during the
wet season is lost due to inadequate forage supply from pasture, thus a seasonal pattern of weight
gain interrupted by weight loss during the dry season is formed. The resultant effect is that
ruminants in these parts take a longer period to reach market weight or maturity than ruminants
in other parts of the world (Lamidi & Ologbose 2014). Conservation of forage as hay or silage is
the major technique used in developed countries to address the deficit in forage supply to
ruminants during periods of insufficient pasture growth. However, the prevailing climatic
conditions in southern Nigeria during the period of excess herbage production (high precipitation
and humidity) are not conducive for successful haymaking. Silage making is not so attractive to
the small farmer due to the high labour demand and machinery required to harvest, chop and
store sufficient quantities of herbage to carry ruminant stock through the dry season. This,
coupled with the low nutritive value of conserved tropical forage does not justify the cost of its
production.
West African Dwarf (WAD) sheep, a native breed of sheep reared in the humid zone of
Nigeria are fed with grasses and agricultural by-products which affect the growth rate,
physiological responses and performance of the WAD sheep Aye, (2014). The end result is the
persistence shortage in the supply of animal protein in people’s diet which is inimical to growth,
8
performance, intelligence and defence against avoidable diseases. WAD sheep are adjudged to
be vigorous, fertile, resistance to climatic stress and are tolerant of irregular supply of feeds.
WAD sheep are mainly kept as a minor farm enterprise by most small holder farmers in South-
Western Nigeria. They play important socio-economic and cultural roles in the lives of these
farmers due to their use as means of storing wealth in times of agricultural plenty; provision of
cash reserves for emergencies; and the guarantee of a degree of food security in times of crop
failure. WAD sheep are highly adaptable to a broad range of environments, can live on crop by-
products without grain supplementation ( Haimanot et al., 2021) are trypanotolerant (Geerts et al.
2009), have rapid growth (Zhuoyi et al.,2021 and are rich in genetic variation (Ameer et al.,
2022). Also, sheep is the most productive ruminant in Nigeria that can increase the animal
protein intake. They are versatile creatures that can produce skin, milk, meat, and manure. Their
reputation for short gestation interval, early maturity, easy management, remarkable capacity to
convert roughages into meat and milk, unique ability to adapt and maintain itself in harsh
environments, low cost of production, ability to trek long distances in search of feed, high
dressing percentage, ability to adapt to a wide range of climatic conditions, high meat quality and
their small body sizes make them indispensable livestock in Nigeria and beyond. The meat is
routinely tolerated and consumed in Nigeria since there is no religious taboo against it and there
1.2. Justification
Feed availability has been a major factor limiting the expansion of ruminant production in
Nigeria. Forages are usually the primary and most economic source of nutrients for ruminants
9
where they serve to meet their daily nutritional requirements. As forage mature, palatability and
digestibility declines. They become dry and less digestible during dry season resulting in reduced
feed intake and weight loss of animals. The dry season is this a critical period for ruminant
animals as it is characterized by shortage of feed, that is, reduction in quality and quantity of
forages. Utilization of by-products as silage during this critical period of feed shortage will go a
Silage making has a great potential to solve seasonal shortage of feed for ruminants in
Nigeria by preserving excess forage produced during the wet season for use at the dry period. A
judicious use of locally available feed resources like crop residents and agro-industrial by
products can improve the nutrition of these animals and boost livestock productivity in these
parts.
This study was connected to evaluate the voluntary intake and nutrient digestibility of ensiled
Gmelina arborea and cassava peel fed to West African Dwarf (WAD) Sheep.
o To determine the digestibility of the various nutrients of ensiled Gmelina arborea and
cassava peel.
o To evaluate the silage characteristics of ensiled Gmelina arborea with varying level of
cassava peel.
o To observe the nitrogen balance of West African Dwarf (WAD) Sheep fed ensiled
10
CHAPTER TWO
ancient Indian system of medicine. The roots, leaves, flowers, fruits and bark are used for
treating different ailments in traditional medicine. The literature suggests use of the plant in
treatment of scorpion sting, snake-bites, and diabetes. The plant is anthelmintic and used for
treating hallucinations, excess thirst, piles, abdominal pains, burning sensations, and fever.
Gmelina arborea is a cheap non-conventional feed resource for ruminants in Nigeria. It is a fast
growing deciduous Multi-Purpose plant of high nutritive value reaching up to 40m tall and
140cm in diameter and grows in climates with mean annual 0 rainfall temperatures of 21-28 oC
Vijendra and Achlesh, (2022). The leaves are very high in protein and it a suitable source of
energy. The leaves are available all year round ensuring availability of feed to animals during the
dry season. The best climatic condition for the cultivation of Gmelina arborea is fertile soils,
various rainfall. The tree has long maturation period so it is best plantation for forest upgrading.
Gmelina arborea planted in the presence of chlorophyll is outer bark of this plant. Gmelina
arborea is yellow to cream in colour and calorific value approximately 4800 Kcal per kg. The
11
2.2. Cassava peel
Cassava peel is a waste product produced from the peeling of fresh cassava roots before
processing into various products in Nigeria. It consist about 5-15% of the whole root when
peeled mechanically; Aro et al. (2010) and 20-35% with hand peeling; Olanbiwoninu and
Odunfa, (2012). The meal contains about 3.5% crude protein but is high in carbohydrates, crude
fibre, minerals and hydrogen cyanide (HCN); Olorunnisomo, Ewuola and Lawal, (2012).
Various processing methods of cassava peel including soaking in water and retting, sun-drying,
parboiling, ensiling and enzyme supplementation. However, the innovative processing of cassava
peels by grating, pressing, sieving and drying developed by International Livestock Research
Institute (ILRI, 2015) to produce high quality cassava peel (HQCP) fine mash has reduced the
drying period thereby improving the quality and quantity of the product. The HQCP method also
reduced the HCN content in cassava peel and affects the nutrients; increased fiber content; Okike
et al. (2015). Toxicity of HCN to ruminants is not common because of its microbial
detoxification in the rumen. This is because when cyanogenic glucoside is exposed to linamarase
enzyme extraruminally during cassava processing, HCN is released and can be detoxified in the
rumen but when unprocessed cassava peels are fed to ruminants, microbial fermentation may
rather enhance HCN formation in the rumen thereby increasing the level of toxicity Llewellyn,
(2014).
They WAD sheep is predominant breed of the Humid tropics from Southern West African
through Central Africa. This breed is a small bodied, compact breed which may be all white,
12
black or brown. Its variation in colour and patchy distribution makes it difficult to distinguish it
clearly from the Yankassa adult males. Its weight approximately 37Kg, but ewes have mature
Sheep is an example of small ruminant in Nigeria that are increasingly becoming source of
animal protein. Sheep provide almost 30% of the meat consumed and around 16% of the milk
produced. In Nigeria, sheep play a significant socioeconomic role in the life of the people: they
are slaughtered during ceremonies and festivals, and generation income to farmers.
Sheep requires energy for growth which could be gotten from pasture (forages, range and
browse), hays, silage, by-product and grain. Some of the grasses in forage specie are;
Andropogon gayanus (Gamba grass), Brachiaria brizantha (Signal grass), Chloris gayana
(Rhodes grass), Cynodon dactylon (Bahama grass), Digitaria decumbens (Pangola grass),
Melinis minutiflora (Molassess grass), Panicum maximum (Guinea grass) and lots more. The
following are the browse plants which can be fed to sheep; Gliricidia sepium (Gliricidia
maculata), Leucaena leucocephala (Leucaena glauca). These forages can be further processed
into hay (by drying) or silage; both methods could be regarded as conversation of forage crops.
Aside energy, sheep also require protein which can be gotten from legume-forage. Cajanus cajan
purpureus (Lablab or hyachnth bean); all these are some of the legumes which can be fed to
sheep. Other nutritional requirements are; minerals, salt, vitamins and water.
13
2.4. Digestion in Sheep.
Ruminants generally have a competing stomach which contains the rumen, reticulum,
omasum and abomasums Kendall, (2019). The rumen allows the animal to consume plants
material and retain it long enough to allow bacteria, protozoa and fungi to break down and digest
the material. The plant material is consumed, regurgitated and re-chew and swallowed. Nutrients
are required from body maintenance, physically activity, growth, milk production, reproduction
It is necessary to feed ruminants with forage of good quality so as not to affect the ruminant
and as well to achieve farmer’s aim of keeping the animals. Since the quality of forage directly
impacts the production success, there are many ways to test forage. The first term to be
understood is dry matter (DM). When forage is harvested by machine, the amount above the
leftover stubble can be dried, since 70-90% of the herbage is water, and weighed to determine
the amount of dry matter, usually referred to per acre. Testing can be done on representative
samples. But if the forage is consumed by grazing animals there are still other ways to test for
quality. Forage quality can be determined by many ways but the three main methods are
discussed below:
o Organoleptic Observation
o Chemical Composition
14
Organoleptic observation means using the sense organs (eyes, nose, taste, ears, touch) to
evaluate the quality of the forage. This method is practical because it can be easily done, requires
no special equipment, and is readily applied. It is the simplest method but it provides the least
information. Organoleptic observation can be useful in some ways but cannot determine
chemical composition. Visually, high-quality forage should show leafiness, vivid color, little
foreign material, an appropriate stage of maturity, and no molds. The smell should be fresh and
in the case of silage sweet; a specific odor that you can learn to recognize. Livestock use their
sense of smell in selection. Some producers can even taste the right flavors, especially in good
silage. Touch can also be used to check for the right consistency. Good hay should not be too
manager to more accurately determine how much forage and supplement are needed for a
particular animal and production goal. It can answer how nutritious forage is and allows for
better rationing. But the results are only valid to the extent that the sample represents the forage
being considered.
Historically from about the mid-1800's, forage quality has been measured in the
laboratory by proximate analysis which looks at the crude fiber (CF), ether extract, nitrogen-free
extract, crude protein (CP), and ash. The ash is the residue after burning or combustion and
indicates the mineral content. The CP is determined by analyzing for nitrogen (N) by a method
invested by Kjeldahl F.A.O,(2016). True protein is made up of amino acids with approximately
16% nitrogen so 100% divided by 16% = 6.25 which is used to multiply the nitrogen in a sample
to estimate the amount of protein within. Ether extract is the total compounds that can be
extracted with hot diethyl ether. Crude fiber is the organic matter insoluble in weak acid and
15
weak alkali. Nitrogen-free extract is the amount left when subtracting all the four components
Another way of determining forage quality is with feed trials and animal performance. Are
animals gaining weight, producing more milk, successfully reproducing, and living longer? All
of these take time to determine but can be measurements of successful feeding systems. The
laboratory methods can be costly and require proper sampling but are faster and more specific.
Sometimes ruminants are fistulated to determine exactly what is being consumed or excreted.
Fistulated ruminants have an opening into their stomach. Comparing what is within the ruminant
and later what is excreted can lead to better understanding of nutrition. But this type of
evaluation is unpleasant and not as easily extrapolated to small ruminants like sheep and goats.
16
CHAPTER THREE
The research was carried out at Sheep and Goat unit, Ladoke Akintola University of
Technology (LAUTECH) Teaching and Research farm, Ogbomoso, Nigeria. While the ensiling
process was done at silage room beside poultry house, near Faculty of Agricultural Science,
Gmelina arborea was obtained from the University vicinity. The collected leaves were
pruned for easy collection of the leaves. The harvested leaves were weighed so as to determine
the expected amount of leaves for making silage; and left for wilting which lasted for about 12
hours. Fresh cassava peel was gotten from Garri Processing Unit at the Campus premises.
The leaves and peels were milled to reduce the particle size for easy compacting into the
silo. The milled leaves and cassava peels were manually compacted into the silos lined with
polythene nylon. Each layer of the ingredients; Gmelina arborea leaves and cassava peel were
manually compacted in the silo (with heavy stones and sand bags) to displace air. Then, the
polythene sheet was then used to cover the material and pressed down with the sand bags and
stones. The silage was then left to ferment for minimum of 21days, before opening for feeding to
animals.
17
3.4. Pen preparation, experimental animals and their management.
The pen was cleaned, washed with detergent and fumigated with morigad against
infections. The surrounding was cleared and the fence was adjusted where necessary. Fifteen
(15) active West African Dwarf yearling Sheep were purchased from local markets and kept in a
prepared, sanitized pen. Their initial weights were taken and recorded as they were brought into
the farm. They were acclimatized for 2-3 weeks. The acclimatization of the animals was to
familiarize the animals with the forages and the environment. During this period, the animals
were fed with Gmelina arborea leaves, dried cassava peel and concentrate. The animals were
reared under intensive system of management using the design of Completely Randomized
Design (CRD). Three animals were placed on a treatment (silage): thus, fifteen animals for five
treatments.
Fifteen (15) active West African Dwarf Sheep were used for a digestibility study. Three
rams were assigned to a treatment. The animals were transferred into the metabolic cages that
allowed for separate collection of faeces and urine. They were in the cage for 14days during
which daily feed left over and fecal production were evaluated. Three animals received a given
diet twice daily. The animals were allowed to acclimatize for the first 7days in the cages, after
which data on feed offered, left over, fecal output and urine were collected and weighed daily.
Sub-samples of the diets were taken and oven dried at 60 oC for 24 hours to determine dry matter
content. About 10% of the urine collected daily was preserved with 20ml of tetraoxosulphate
(VI) acid (H2SO4) and ice block for each animal. The essence of the acid is to prevent nitrogen
18
3.6. Statistical Analysis
Data generated were subjected to one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) using SAS
(2001) and significant differences were separated using Duncan’s multiple range test of the same
package.
CHAPTER FOUR
19
REFERENCE
leucocephala and Gliricidia sepium as protein supplements for small ruminants in South-
Western Nigeria. Ph.D Thesis Ekiti State University, Ado-Ekiti. 2014; 201.
o Amata, I. A. (2014). The use of non-conventional feed resources (ncfr) for livestock
feeding in the tropics: a review. Journal of Global Biosciences. Vol. 3. No. 2: 604-614.
o Aro S.O, Aletor V.A, Tewe O.O, & Agbede J.O. (2010). Nutritional potentials of
cassava tuber wastes: A case study of a cassava starch processing factory in south-
West African Dwarf (WAD) sheep. Agriculture and Biology Journal of North America,
peels together with Albizia saman pods. In: Animal Agriculture and the global food
challenges. Proceedings of the 34th Annual Conference of the Nigerian Society for
Animal Production held at University of Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria, pp. 544–546.
growth performance of West African Dwarf goats fed with elephant grass or different
proportions of plantain and mango peels. International Journal of Plant and Animal
20
o Chiejina, S. N., & Behnke, J. M. (2011). The unique resistance and resilience of the
Vectors, 4, 12.
100596-5.03341-2
Yankasa sheep fed Panicum maximum substituted with varying levels of Gmelina
production held at NAPRI/Ahmadu bello university, Zaria, Nigeria. March 19th 2015. Pp
589-592.
o FDLPCS. (2007). Federal Department of Livestock and Pest Control Services. FDLPCS
o Geerts, S., Osaer, S., Goossens, B. and Faye, D. (2009). Trypanotolerance in small
o Ibhaze, G. A., Alade, C. T., Fajemisin, A. N., Olorunnisomo. O.A. Adewumi, M.K.,
Ekeocha, A.H., Tona, G. O. 2015. Quality and preference of Gmelina arborea leaves
and cassava peel silage as off season feed for West African dwarf goats. Proceedings of
the 20th Annual Conference of Animal Science Association of Nigeria 6-10, 2015,
Ibadan. Pp 688-692.
o International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI, 2015): Scaling the use of cassava
21
o Kendall C. Swanson (2019). Small intestinal anatomy, physiology and digestion in
ruminants. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100596-5.22638-3
o Lamidi A. A., Ologbose F. I., 2014. Dry season feeds and feeding: a threat to sustainable
14(1):17-30.
https://s3.wp.wsu.edu/uploads/sites/2071/2014/01/prussic-Acid-Poisoning-in-
small-scale producers and households to process wet cassava peels into high quality
http://www.developmentbookshelf.com/doi/abs/10.3362/20461887,2015.005.
o Olorunnisomo, O.A., Ewuola, E.O. & Lawal, T.T. (2012). Intake and blood
metabolites in red Sokoto goats fed elephant grass and cassava peel silage. Journal of
o Statistical Analysis Systems. 2001. SAS/STAT Guide for Personal Computer. Version
o 8 Steele M.A., Malmuthuge N. and Guan L.L. (2015). Dietary factors influencing the
o Vijendra Shah, Achlesh Daverey, (2022). Environmental Technology & Innovation 18,
100774, 2020.
22
23