Blue Ocean Strategy
Blue Ocean Strategy
Blue Ocean Strategy
Introduction
• The turnaround of Cirque du Soleil
– Circus business in long term decline.
– Alternative forms of entertainment available
– Children preferred playstations
– Animal rights
– Decreasing audiences
– Increasing costs
– Profitability increased by a factor of 22 in 10 years
Continued
• Created uncontested market space
• Made competition irrelevant
• Pulled in non-customers
The Difference
Red Oceans Blue Oceans
• Known market space • Not in existence today
• Industry boundaries defined • Unknown
• Competitive rules • Untouched by competition
understood • Demand is created
• Try to outperform rivals • Completely new industries
• Grab a share of demand – eBay with auctions
• Created within red ocean
– Cirque du Soleil
Blue & Red Oceans
• Which industries were unknown 100 years back
• What about 30 years
• What about 5 years
– Blue oceans will remain the engines of growth
• Prospects in red oceans are shrinking
• Technological advances have improved productivity
• Trade barriers are being overcome
• Niches and monopolies disappearing
• Supply is overtaking demand
• Population on decline in many developed economies
Paradox of strategy
• Linked to competition
• Roots in military strategy
• Driven to outperform rivals
Towards Blue Ocean Strategy
• Not about technology innovation
– Not a defining feature
– Ford’s assembly line was already in existence
– Linking technology to what buyers value is critical
Examples
Examples
Key takeaways
• Incumbents not at a disadvantage
• Created within their businesses
• New markets are not found in distant waters
– Need to study strategic moves or set of
managerial action and decision involved in making
a business offering
– Compaq – acquired by HP
– Remarkable work done in PC servers
• Blue Ocean creates brand equity.
Continued….
Defining characteristic
• Differentiation and low cost simultaneously.
– Fun and thrill of circus with the artistic appeal of
theatre
– Clowns, tents and acrobatic acts
– Theatre performance with a theme and story line
– Broadway based
– Driving down costs and driving up value
Continued
• In red oceans, industry structural conditions are
given and firms compete
– Environmental determinism
• Market boundaries and industries reconstructed
by the actions and beliefs of industry players
• Barriers to imitation
• Attract customers – scale economies (walmart)
• Network externalities (eBay)
Continued
• Imitation requires a whole slew of changes
– Is it so simple to imitate Southwest’s low cost
strategy
• Conflict with existing brand image
– Body Shop shuns top models
– Imitation is difficult for traditional brands like
Estee Lauder
Red Ocean Traps
• Market creating strategies as customer
oriented approaches
– Is the customer really the King?
– Focus on non customers. Why no patronage?
– Why did Sony’s PRS not capture market in 2006?
– Kindle sold out within 6 hours of release
Red Ocean Traps
• Treating Market Creating Strategies as Niche
Strategies
– Uncovering a niche is not the same thing as
identifying a new market space
– Song launched by Delta Airlines for Women
– Strive towards desegmenting the market
Red Ocean Traps
• Confusing Technology Innovation with
Market-Creating Strategies
– Yellow Tail opened a new market without any
bleeding-edge technologies.
– So did the coffee chain Starbucks
– Segway Personal Transporter
Red Ocean Traps
• Equating Creative Destruction with Market
Creation
– Does Market creation always involve destruction?
– Grameen bank and work in microfinance
• It is not differentiation
– Breaks the value cost trade off
– BMW C1
Blue Ocean strategy & Value curve