Aliki Kosyfologou, Women's Status in A Struggling Greek Economy. The Terrifying Fall of A Society's Progress
Aliki Kosyfologou, Women's Status in A Struggling Greek Economy. The Terrifying Fall of A Society's Progress
Aliki Kosyfologou, Women's Status in A Struggling Greek Economy. The Terrifying Fall of A Society's Progress
Ιntroduction 3
References 23
Biography 26
Introduction 3
I
n the March 2019 issue of the IMF’s quarterly publication Finance &
Development, Christine Lagarde, the president of the European Central
Bank and former managing director of the IMF, characterises the em-
powerment of women status in the economy as “a global imperative”.1
However, this loud expression of commitment to the achievement of an
inclusive and gender-equitable global economy contradicts the rather un-
doubtedly negative impact of the IMF’s global financial policy on the fu-
ture of gender equality. Gender remains a crucial factor for an individual’s
status in the economy in both developing and developed economies.
The structural adjustments imposed by austerity policies across Eu-
rope, Asia, Africa and South America have resulted in unemployment, the
shrinking and privatisation of the welfare sector and, in many cases, dein-
dustrialisation.2 In this context, women and especially poor women bear
the disproportionate burden of the neoliberal deficit-centred economic
policies. According to the International Labour Organisation’s (ILO) World
Employment Social Outlook, “working women are more likely than men to
be unemployed in large places in the world”3 and “working poverty is wide- AUSTERITY, GENDER INEQUALITY AND FEMINISM
spread among both women and men”.4
In Greece, a country severely traumatised by the IMF’s lending
policies, the employment crisis and the devaluation of labour have been
major setbacks for the country’s development. As stated by the United
5 “Currently, Greece has one of the lowest rates of women’s employment in the
European Union and is the lowest ranking country in the Gender Equality Index for EU countries.
The situation for marginalized groups, such as migrant and Roma women, is even worse.” Office
of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, “Greece must put gender equality at the heart of
economic and social recovery, say UN independent experts,” Geneva/Athens, April 2019, https://
www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=24480.
6 It is important to note that Greece has not yet submitted a comprehensive-level
review regarding the progress made in the implementation of the Beijing Declaration and
Platform for Action directives and goals.
7 This study was a part of the RLS project“When the belt can’t get any tighter: Mapping
the impacts of austerity on women’s lives across Europe” (2018), https://www.rosalux.de/en/
news/id/38926/when-the-belt-cant-get-any-tighter-1/. Some of the findings of the “austerity
studies” were presented and discussed on the commission on the status of women (csw63) in
2019 at an official side event organized by the RLS NYC. A podcast of the discussion is available at
http://www.rosalux-nyc.org/rls-nyc-at-the-commission-on-the-status-of-women-csw63/.
1 5
13 Hellenic Statistical Authority. “Risk of poverty.” Income and Living Conditions (EU-
SILC) 2018, 21 June 2019, https://www.statistics.gr/en/statistics/-/publication/SFA10/2018.
14 Ibid., 4
15 Ibid., 5.
16 Dimitris Ziomas, Nikolaos Bouzas, Antoinetta Capella and Danai Konstantinidou,
In-work Poverty: Greece (Brussels: European Social Policy Network, 2019), p. 7, https://
ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=89&furtherNews=yes&langId=en&newsId=9378.
17 Ibid., 8.
18 Hellenic Statistical Authority, “Labour Force Survey: October 2019,” 9 January
2010, https://www.statistics.gr/documents/20181/a8c68f77-761f-f9f8-e474-02b610ef63a1.
19 International Labour Office, World Employment Social Outlook: Trends 2019 (Geneva:
ILO, 2019), p. 49, https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---dgreports/---dcomm/---
publ/documents/publication/wcms_670542.pdf.
the Gender Equality Index 2019, Greece and Italy share the lowest em-
7
ployment rate for women (31%), while Greek women have poor access
to financing.20
20 “Greece last in gender equality 2017, report finds,” Ekathimerini, 15 October 2019,
http://www.ekathimerini.com/245538/article/ekathimerini/news/greece-last-in-eu-in-
gender-equality-in-2017-report-finds.
21 Eurostat, “Gender pay gap statistics: the unadjusted gender pay gap, 2017 (the
difference between average gross hourly of male and female employees as % of male gross
earnings),” February 2019, https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/
Gender_pay_gap_statistics.
22 European Federation of Public Service Unions, The Gender Pay Gap in Public
Services, Brussels, 2013, 5, https://www.epsu.org/sites/default/files/article/files/Gender_
pay_gap_FINAL_report.pdf.
23 Maria Karamessini and Franciscos Kountentakis, “Labour Market Flows and
Unemployment Dynamics by Sex in Greece During the Crisis,” Revue de l’OFCE, no. 133 (2014):
215–39.
24 Nikolaj Nielsen, “Greek migrant hotspot now EU’s worst right issue,” 7 November
2019, EUobserver, https://euobserver.com/migration/146541.
en’s rights researcher at Human Rights Watch, states “just going to the
8
bathroom feels too risky for women and girls in Moria … Their lives are
defined by fear, and that won’t change unless the Greek government
addresses the pervasive dangers they face.”25 Inevitably, these poor liv-
ing conditions and the continuous abuse of refugee women’s rights is
the main cause of their social marginalisation.26 In this regard, very lit-
tle or almost zero progress has been made in the process of integrating
refugee and asylum seekers women in the labour market.
25 Human Rights Watch, “Greece: camp conditions endanger women and girls.
Asylum seekers lack access to food, water, health care,” 4 December 2019, https://www.hrw.
org/news/2019/12/04/greece-camp-conditions-endanger-women-girls.
26 “The abuse of refugee women’s rights is one of the basic underlying root causes
of their marginalization and violence in their countries of asylum.” Pearl K. Atuhaire and
Sylvia Kaye, “Through the Lens of Forced Displacement: Refugee Women’s Rights as Human
Rights,” International Journal of Business, Human and Social Sciences 10, no. 2 (2016): 454.
27 Ibid.
28 Aggelos Tsakanikas, Ioannis Giotopoulos, Sofia Stavraki, Evangelia Valavanioti,
Annual Entrepreneurship Report, 2016–2017: Early Stage Entrepreneurship Rates Decrease, Athens:
Foundation for Economic and Industrial Research, November 2017, 4.
crease in rural family incomes and rural women’s social status.29 How-
9
ever, in the context of the ongoing social crisis, due to bureaucracy,
lack of training in new technologies and traditional structures – many
of them operate as closed family businesses. As a result, small-scale
production cooperatives have not emerged as major alternatives to fe-
male unemployment in rural areas.
39 Sustainable goal 8, Decent work and economic growth for all, https://www.
un.org/sustainabledevelopment/economic-growth/.
40 European Commission, “Trafficking in Domestic Work in Greece: A Demand-side
Approach,” European Policy Brief, June 2016. 1, https://ec.europa.eu/research/social-sciences/
pdf/policy_briefs/demandat_policybrief_greece_dangeli.pdf.
41 Ibid., 2
CONVENTION ON THE
BEIJING DECLARATION AND PLATFORM 2030 SUSTAINABLE
FOR
ELIMINATION OF ALL FORMS
DEVELOPMENT AGENDA
14
OF DISCRIMINATION AGAINST
ACTION
WOMEN
12. Women and the economy Article 14. Governments Goal 8. Promote sustained, inclusive
Strategic objectives should undertake to eliminate and sustainable economic growth
discrimination against women full and productive employment and
F1. Promote women’s economic rights in rural areas so that they may decent work for all.
and independence, including access participate in and benefit from
to employment, appropriate working rural development. (GR) The youth unemployment
conditions and control over economic
rate reached 35.6% in October
resources. (GR) The highest rate of 2019.
women’s unemployment Greece also has one of the
(GR) Unemployment is gendered in in rural areas in the EU can highest unemployment rates of
Greece. Women’s unemployment be found in rural areas in people with disabilities in the EU
rate is still considerably higher Greece.42 (approx. 37.2%).
than that of men (20.2% in October Although women are the In the domestic care sector,
2019). backbone of the rural uninsured work is prevalent (see
economy in Greece, they section 2.2).
still face many hardships
and have poor access to
decent income. Many of
them work as contributing
workers in informal
employment (38%). On
the other hand, the
legal context promoting
the founding of women
cooperatives since the
1980s has contributed
to the increase in rural
family income and the
empowerment of many
women living and working
in rural areas (women
head farms or agritourism
cooperatives)
However, due to the
peculiarities of this form of
female entrepreneurship
that emerged in rural
Greece (family business
type), it is difficult to AUSTERITY, GENDER INEQUALITY AND FEMINISM
define their role in a rural
venture (for example, they
can be named as head
farmers or owners of 51%
of a rural business but do
not actually undertake
managerial tasks).43
F2. Facilitate women’s equal access to re- Article 11. Women have an Goal 9. Build resilient infrastructure,
sources, employment, markets, and trade. equal right to work with promote inclusive and sustainable
men, which includes pay, industrialisation and foster innovation.
(GR) Law 1414/1984 “applies promotions, training, health,
the principle of sex equality in and safety. (GR) After the crisis “crash” in the
employment relations, abolishes construction sector in Greece –
all forms of discrimination against (GR) The gender-pay-gap which was considered to be the
women and differentiation between rate in Greece is 12.5%. pillar of the country’s economic
male and female jobs”.44 development – tourism, shipping,
Healthcare and social food and beverages have emerged
The business sector in Greece is security: access to as the major industrial sectors.
gender segregated. Despite the high social insurance and
levels of integration of women in healthcare is connected In terms of contribution towards
the business sector, women are still to paid employment. the GDP, agriculture accounts for
underrepresented in administrative Therefore, with the 3.4%, industry 20.8% and services
boards and in the field of decision prevalence of precarious 75.8%.47
making (approx. 11.3% women are forms of employment,
members of administrative boards many women and men Employment in the tourism sector
and only 3.4% are chairwomen).45 have become long-term hit record numbers in August 2019
uninsured. (10.6% of the total workforce in
Gender parity legislation regulates Greece was engaged in tourism-
the participation of women in the Consequently, precarious related jobs).48
administrative boards of public female employees are
organisations. often deprived of access The majority of the jobs offered
to social insurance and in tourism are seasonal and
Also, new “substantive gender healthcare. precarious. Despite the existing
equality” legislation was introduced labour legislation, a huge number of
in 2019 by the former government, labour rights violations take place
according to which: every year, including the severe
exploitation of migrant workers.
“Public and private enterprises are
encouraged to draft and implement In 2018 Greece’s labour inspection
‘equality plans’ with specific targets, body “imposed fines worth over
strategies and practices and the two million euros to businesses
General Secretariat for Gender active in the tourism sector
Equality of the Ministry of Interior for violating the labour law”.49
can award ‘equality labels’ to them Examples of very common
as a reward for their engagement in violations in this formal and
favour of equal treatment and equal informal employment market are
opportunities for their male and continuous overtime work and the AUSTERITY, GENDER INEQUALITY AND FEMINISM
female employees.”46 seven-day working week.
Analysis
and recommendations
b. A feminist-activist approach
We could convincingly argue that “it’s the neoliberalism, stupid!,” to
paraphrase the famous quote.48 And of course, neoliberalism is to
blame for the structural class, gender and racial inequality and the
exploitation of human labour and natural resources. Yet, the materi-
al background of poverty and gender injustice is acknowledged by the
abovementioned institutional texts and many other international in-
stitutions, such as the World Bank and International Monetary Fund.
However, the “adoption” of social justice notions in these docu-
ments has very little “material” impact on the content of global policies
imposed and implemented by these institutions. It also partially ex-
plains the chasm that lies between the written word and reality. Struc-
tural gender inequality impedes the realisation of the visionary goals
described in the abovementioned international texts. The radical ideas
remain unfulfilled because of a lack of political strategising and, main-
ly, of political will. Despite the noteworthy engagement of the institu-
tional discourses with equality, gender parity and sustainability, global
AUSTERITY, GENDER INEQUALITY AND FEMINISM
politics remains a field of military competition as well as the exploita-
tion of natural assets and of human labour.
49 Τhe profile of the “Greek boomer” has its own peculiarities since she or he
grew up in the post-civil war Greek society and also experienced a seven-year dictatorship;
however, it could be said the “boomers” enjoyed some of the “privileges” of the uneven
economic development of the Greek 1960s and 1970s, for example, massive access to third-
level education and permanent employment.
50 Marine Moulineux refers to an international trend: “The world of young
feminists is, however, one marked by a high degree of insecurity: the liberal reforms that
have transformed labour markets and conditions, while removing many former securities
and welfare supports that their parents enjoyed if they worked in formal employment.”
Marine Moulineux, “The New Feminist Activism, 1970–2019: Intergenerational Perspectives,”
background paper prepared for UN Women Expert Group Meeting, 25–26 September 2019.
https://www.unwomen.org/en/csw/csw64-2020/preparations/expert-group-meeting.
struggles against the prevailing austerity regime. Nevertheless, no re-
21
versal of the uneven labour status in Greece can be achieved without
the restructuring of the “tired” and bureaucratised Greek tertiary trade
union movement, that has failed to address the needs and express the
demands of a large part of the workforce in both the private and public
sectors.
Neoliberalism impedes the realisation of gender justice in all
major sectors in the domestic sphere, in the economy and in politics.
The slogan “You are burning our future”, which is one of the most popu-
lar mottos in the protests against climate change and global warmth,
sounds realistic in a terrifying way, while the majority begins to ac-
knowledge that the mere “supremacy of finance”51 lies behind the cur-
rent global social and environmental crises. Likewise, the references
to social equity and sustainability in the official documents reflect at-
tempts to manipulate and institutionalise the movements and their
demands, which must be accompanied by strong commitments to
change the political regime. Partial reform measures are insufficient
and have failed to address the human impact of population displace-
ments due to war, political prosecution, climate change, the jump in
unemployment and of the abolition of social welfare in many countries.
Therefore, the chasms between reality and the documents could
be better explained if the internal contradiction of the policies of de-
velopment is readdressed. The radical feminist criticism of the 1990s of
the policies of gender development focused on the persistent consen-
AUSTERITY, GENDER INEQUALITY AND FEMINISM
sus-seeking52 to build policies that partially alleviate gender inequali-
ties. Eventually, this consensus and “mainstreaming” served the de-
radicalisation of feminist discourse, while ignoring the political back-
ground of gender injustice. Empowerment, as a common reference in
policy documents, is perceived as an individual cause, whereas eman-
cipation describes the true complexities and the social background of
the struggles against patriarchy.
The new “face” of neoliberalism activates strategies to mitigate
51 The term “financial supremacy” was introduced Marina Durano and Nicole
Bidegain Ponte, “A Feminist Perspective on the Follow-Up Process for Financing for
Development,” Development 59, nos. 32–39 (2016).
52 Andrea Corwell, Jasmine Gideon and Calpana Wilson, “Introduction: Reclaiming
Feminism: Gender and Neoliberalism.” IDS Bulletin 39, no. 6 (December 2008), 7.
the impact of the implemented policies while isolating all cores of so-
22
cial struggles through state repression and international supervisory
mechanisms. This “new social consensus” emerges as a horrifying ver-
sion of the postwar New Deal, establishing an uneven and rigid system
of power relations.
To that end, leftists and feminists should not – again – abandon
the idea of social transformation, which can only be achieved through
collective resistance and political organisation. Acknowledging the
distance between institutional documents and reality is one thing, the
building of grassroots alliances and synergies challenging the domi-
nant system of political power is another. And it is hugely important.
International Labour Office. World Employment Social Outlook: Trends for Women.
Geneva: ILO, 2018. https://www.ilo.org/global/research/global-reports/
weso/trends-for-women2018/WCMS_619577/lang--en/index.htm.
International Labour Office. World Employment Social Outlook: Trends 2019. Gene-
va: ILO, 2019. https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---dgreports/-
--dcomm/---publ/documents/publication/wcms_670542.pdf.
Kampouris, Nick. “Employment in tourism sector hits record numbers in
Greece.” Greek Reporter, 30 August 2019. https://greece.greekreporter.
com/2019/08/30/employment-in-tourism-sector-hits-record-numbers-
in-greece/.
Karamessini, Maria, and Franciscos Kountentakis, “Labour Market Flows and
Unemployment Dynamics by Sex in Greece During the Crisis.” Revue de
l’OFCE, no. 133 (2014): 215–239.
Karamessini, Maria. “Structural Crisis and Adjustment in Greece: Social Regres-
sion and the Challenge to Gender Equality.” In The Economic Crisis and the 25
Future of Gender Equality, ed. Maria Karamessini and Jill Rubbery, 165–85.
New York: Routledge, 2015.
Lagarde, Christine. “A global imperative: Empowering women is critical for the
world’s economy and people.” Finance & Development 56 (March 2019): 5.
Lassithiotaki, Aikaterini, and Argiro Roubakou. “Rural Women Cooperatives at
Greece: A Retrospective Study.” Open Journal of Business and Management 2,
no. 2 (2014): 127–37. doi:10.4236/ojbm.2014.22016.
Moulineux, Marine. “The New Feminist Activism, 1970–2019: Intergenerational
Perspectives.” Background paper prepared for UN Women Expert Group
Meeting, 25-26 September 2019. https://www.unwomen.org/en/csw/
csw64-2020/preparations/expert-group-meeting.
NGO Committee on the Status of Women/New York. “NGO guidance for parallel
reports: twenty-fifth anniversary of the fourth world conference on women
and the Bejing Declaration and platform for action.” New York, 2019.
Nielsen, Nikolaj. “Greek migrant hotspot now EU’s worst right issue.” EUobserver,
7 November 2019. https://euobserver.com/migration/146541.
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. “Greece must put gender
equality at the heart of economic and social recovery, say UN independ-
ent experts.” Geneva/Athens, April 2019. https://www.ohchr.org/EN/
NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=24480.
Papada, Lefkothea, and Dimitris Kaliambakos. “Measuring Energy Poverty in
Greece.” Energy Policy 94 (July 2016): 157–65.
Theodoropoulos, Dimitris, Argyris Kyridis, Christos Zagkos and Zoe Konstanti-
nidou. “‘Brain Drain’ Phenomenon in Greece: Young Greek Scientists on
their Way to Immigration, in an Era of ‘Crisis’: Attitudes, Opinions and Be-
liefs towards the Prospect of Migration.” Journal of Education and Human
Development 3, no. 4 (December 2014): 229–48.
AUSTERITY, GENDER INEQUALITY AND FEMINISM
Toussaint, Eric. “Banks are responsible for the crisis in Greece: debts from Greece
are odious.” Committee for the Abolition of Illegitimate Debt, 9 January
2017. http://www.cadtm.org/Banks-are-responsible-for-the
Tsakanikas, Aggelos, Ioannis Giotopoulos, Sofia Stavraki and Evangelia Valava-
nioti. Annual Entrepreneurship Report, 2016–2017: Early Stage Entrepreneur-
ship Rates Decrease. Athens: Foundation for Economic and Industrial Re-
search, 2017.
UN Women. Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action: Beijing+5 Political Dec-
laration and Outcome. United Nations: New York, 2014.
Ziomas, Dimitris, Nikolaos Bouzas, Antoinetta Capella and Danai Konstanti-
nidou. In-work Poverty: Greece. Brussels: European Social Policy Network,
2019. https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=89&furtherNews=yes
&langId=en&newsId=9378.
Biography 26
AUTHOR
Aliki Kosyfologou
PUBLISHER
Rosa-Luxemburg-Stiftung, Franz-Mehring-Platz 1, 10243 Berlin, Germany
COPY EDITING
Damian Mac Con Uladh
LAYOUT / GRAPHIC
Erifili Arapoglou
This publication was financed by the German Federal Foreign Office. This publication or parts of it
can be used by others for free as long as they provide a proper reference to the original publication.
The content of this publication does not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the Rosa-Luxem-
burg-Stiftung. Responsibility for the information and views expressed therein lies with the authors.