The Case For Blue Hydrogen
The Case For Blue Hydrogen
The Case For Blue Hydrogen
Blue Hydrogen
UK Hydrogen and Fuel Cell
Association Position Paper
The UK oil & gas industry has contributed greatly to the UK’s
economy, both in terms of tax revenues and employment –
blue hydrogen provides a route to ensure similar levels of
support for communities as we transition towards Net Zero.
Blue hydrogen is essential to the UK’s transition to low carbon energy as part of the 2050 net
zero targets. The potential for low carbon hydrogen is particularly high in industrial processes
and in hard to abate sectors, especially heavy-duty vehicles, shipping, heating, aviation and
energy storage.
The UK is well placed to take advantage of the opportunities from low carbon blue hydrogen
given the existing, historic large-scale production of natural gas, and the Government’s
commitment to the technology as part of the energy transition, including the investment in
carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS) across four industrial clusters.
But if we are to maximise the potential of blue hydrogen in the UK, we need clearer direction
and support from Government including:
Low carbon hydrogen standards need to be set and implemented for the carbon
content of hydrogen, maximising the contribution to emissions reduction. In order to
help make hydrogen the fuel of the future, it is critical that emissions standards are both
standardised and trusted - a crucial step towards achieving the net zero targets.
To enable low carbon hydrogen production at scale and across all colours, Government will
need to provide business models and targeted support mechanisms, complementary to
carbon pricing to facilitate the transition away from fossil fuels.
Clarity and greater certainty around the support available for blue hydrogen projects will
drive innovation and investment. Confirmation on the way forward for hydrogen blending
into the gas grid and the implementation of certification schemes are two examples of
where clear direction from Government will be key.
Ambitious targets for blue hydrogen production equivalent to those for green hydrogen
are also critical - with an emphasis on the need to grow all types of low carbon hydrogen to
scale. This is crucial to incentivising investment in the UK hydrogen sector and aligning to
the various hydrogen needs for different sectors and end users.
Given the potential for the UK to be a world leading producer of hydrogen, the Government
should develop an industry wide plan for international co-operation, including boosting
hydrogen exports and imports. There is also huge scope for exporting technologies,
products and services.
Finally, there is a need for support to enable the transition from the traditional roles for oil
and gas, with blue hydrogen playing an important role in the ‘just transition’. This offers a
route to securing workers’ employment and leveraging skills from a legacy sector into a new
energy sector - across hundreds of thousands of jobs1 as we transition to Net Zero.
1 https://www.heraldscotland.com/business_hq/17856099.north-sea-supply-chain-job-numbers-increase-first-time-years/
Background
There is little doubt that low carbon
hydrogen2 is an essential component of We define “Blue hydrogen” as the
the future net zero economy, particularly process of converting natural gas
to decarbonise hard to abate sectors, such to hydrogen and CO2, with the CO2
as high temperature industrial processes, being sent to geological storage sites.
heavy duty transport, aviation, shipping, non- Currently there is no internationally
electrified train lines, heating, dispatchable accepted definition of what counts as
power and energy storage.3 blue hydrogen, but in the UK all projects
are setting a high bar with >95%
In the near-term, blue hydrogen will be the
CO2 removal from the process being
fastest way to deploy large volumes of low
considered a minimum.
carbon hydrogen and will pave the way for
the ramp up of green hydrogen production in It is possible for bio-methane to be
the longer term – including opening up new converted in the same process which,
distribution systems that can be utilised when coupled with CCUS, will lead to
for all types of hydrogen across the range negative emissions.
of applications. The UK HFCA supports the
UK Government’s strategy of a twin-track or
technology agnostic approach, recognising that both blue and green hydrogen will play a key
role in achieving our ambitious decarbonisation goals.
Today, the majority of hydrogen manufactured globally is from the conversion of natural
gas to hydrogen, with the resulting CO2 - amounting to ~3% of global industrial sector CO2
emissions4 - being emitted into atmosphere; this is known as grey hydrogen. Most current
hydrogen production is either integrated into a large process, for example in the manufacture
of ammonia or methanol, or is supplied to refineries to improve the quality of liquid fuels.
There is therefore not currently a large merchant market for hydrogen. The key role for low
carbon hydrogen going forward, as an energy vector, brings with it not only many opportunities
– particularly in our transition to ‘net zero’ – but also challenges that need to be overcome if it
is to reach its potential.
As mentioned earlier, there are multiple sectors where low carbon hydrogen will be vital for
decarbonisation. Many of the initial projects are focused around industrial clusters, where
blue hydrogen can be produced and service multiple sectors. This cluster approach allows the
critical CCUS infrastructure to be shared with other industrial producers and users of CO2,
2 Low-carbon hydrogen is hydrogen that is made in a way that creates little to no greenhouse gas emissions.
3 See Annex B for more details areas where hydrogen can play a key role in decarbonisation.
4 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267623573_Assessment_of_CO2_capture_options_from_various_points_in_
steam_methane_reforming_for_hydrogen_production
1 Acorn
Through the Acorn Hydrogen project, North Sea
natural gas would be reformed into clean hydrogen,
with CO2 emissions safely mitigated through the
Acorn CCS infrastructure. Hydrogen would be used
in transport applications, and in the gas grid to
decarbonise heating in homes and industries.
2 HyNet 1
However, it should be clear that this is not an exhaustive list and there are a number of other
projects that are under consideration. Some of these are considering transporting CO2 by ship to
a CO2 store, so it should not be seen as only CCUS clusters that can host blue hydrogen plants.
5 https://www.theccc.org.uk/publication/sixth-carbon-budget/
6 https://www.irena.org/newsroom/pressreleases/2021/Mar/Fast-Track-Energy-Transitions--to-Win-the-Race-to-Zero
7 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/911268/poten-
tial-of-bioenergy-with-carbon-capture.pdf
1 2 3
8 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/972520/north-sea-
transition-deal_A_FINAL.pdf
There has been significant support from Government for both hydrogen production and
CCUS over recent years, with hundreds of millions of pounds invested in engineering studies.
However, this is insignificant when compared to the investment that will be required from
Government and the private sector to deploy low carbon hydrogen at the level needed. The next
critical step is to deploy technology at scale and ensure that demand grows in tandem.
For all colours of hydrogen, the business models to support deployment will be key and the
sooner that Government can move to contracting the first projects the better. The UK has the
opportunity to lead in this area. In contrast to new industries, such as off-shore wind, where
we have deployed large quantities of wind turbines, but import most of the high value items,
with blue hydrogen we also have the potential to develop a strong robust UK supply chain if
the sector is supported correctly. We have a good basis to build from here, not only in terms
of getting early projects deployed as soon as possible, but also the breadth of existing supply
chain capability, including carbon capture, the design of sorbents and system design at
various scales.
Having the policy landscape with the correct signals for cross-party support of hydrogen will
attract investment into the UK in a sector in which many countries will compete. We only have
to look at the announcements from multiple EU countries to see that hydrogen will be an area
receiving large investment over the next few years and the route to maximising value to the UK
is by attracting investment for manufacturing in the UK of high value items. We should not try
to manufacture everything in the UK, but with targeted investment and clear growth ambitions
we can make sure that we do not leak value out of the UK.
The UK has world-leading projects and, with speed of deployment, these will be the first plants
producing blue hydrogen at scale. There will be a lot to learn from these initial projects that will
inform the future roadmap and allow us to prove the use of hydrogen in multiple sectors.
The UK Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Association (UK HFCA) aims to ensure that hydrogen and fuel
cell solutions can realise the many benefits offered across economic growth, energy security,
carbon reduction and beyond. Through the breadth, expertise and diversity of our membership,
we work to trigger the policy changes necessary for the UK to fully deliver the opportunities
offered by emerging clean energy solutions and their associated supply chain requirements.
We promote and represent our members’ interests across the hydrogen and fuel cells space,
and work to make the UK the best possible place for hydrogen and fuel cells across the full
range of applications and opportunities.
Our members include the leading UK hydrogen and fuel cell players, as well as companies with
wider energy interests, supply chain businesses, and materials and components suppliers, as
well as service providers and universities.
9 https://www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-enshrines-new-target-in-law-to-slash-emissions-by-78-by-2035
10 Impact Assessment for the sixth carbon budget: legislation.gov.uk
11 ARUP, 2019 speech at the World Energy Council
12 DUKES, 2019, page 5 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/
file/820277/DUKES_2019_Press_Notice_GOV.UK.pdf