Salgado 2016
Salgado 2016
Salgado 2016
DOI: 10.1111/and.12655
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
KEYWORDS
dihydrotestosterone, male infertility, protodioscin, semen quality, Tribulus terrestris
concentration, motility, morphology and viability; Turek, 2012). 2 | MATERIALS AND METHODS
These parameters may be affected by many factors, including
certain medications, chemotherapy, pollution, toxic products and 2.1 | Study population and data collection
smoking, as well as excessive alcohol consumption (du Plessis,
Sixty-five male patients (n = 65) were enrolled in this clinical study for
Agarwal, & Sabanegh, 2014).
a total duration of 12 consecutive weeks. The study was conducted
There are a variety of plants thought to improve sexual perfor-
at Instituto de Pesquisa Aluisio Calil Mathias, a private assisted repro-
mance and male fertility. Among them are the members of the genus
duction centre in Brazil. Patients were evaluated on days 0, 1, 7, 14,
Tribulus of the Zygophyllaceae family, which comprises about 20
28, 56 and 84 (total of seven appointments).
species of shrubs or herbs that grow in subtropical areas around the
The inclusion criteria for patient selection were as follows:
world (Hegnauer, 1973). Tribulus terrestris (TT), T. cistoides and T. ala-
18–50 years of age with no hormonal disorders or chronic diseas-
tus have been extensively used as male sexual stimulants (El-Tantawy,
es, diagnosed with infertility (no pregnancies and/or diagnosed with
Temraz, & El-Gindi, 2007). Moreover, TT has been used as tonic, aph-
altered sperm parameters; according to World Health Organization,
rodisiac, palliative, astringent, stomachic, antihypertensive, diuretic
2000). The exclusion criteria were as follows: patients who used ana-
and urinary disinfectant; the fruit of the herb is also used to treat sex-
bolic steroids, patients with hepatic abnormalities as determined by
ual dysfunction (review, Chhatre, Nesari, Somani, Kanchan, & Sathaye,
elevated liver enzymes on blood sample evaluation and patients par-
2014).
ticipating in any other clinical study. All patients included in the trial
There are some data to support a positive effect of oral TT
read and signed an informed consent form. For recording of data, sub-
administration on male sexual function (Tomova et al., 1978). Oral
jects were identified using 3-digit sequential numbers. This study was
administration of TT extract increased erectile function in rabbit
approved by Ethics Committee of the University of São Paulo.
penile tissue (Adaikan, Gauthaman, Prasad, & Ng, 2000). In old-
All participating men underwent an initial evaluation (Day 0) then
er rats, oral TT extract increased sexual activity, increased serum
started treatment with TT extract in the form of a commercially pre-
testosterone and increased epididymal sperm numbers, in a dose-
pared pill (Androsten® [Herbarium Laboratório Botânico Ltda., Brazil]).
dependent manner (Singh, Nair, & Gupta, 2012). Administration
Each pill contained 250 mg of extract, including 37.5 mg (15%) of ste-
of TT increased both testosterone and dihydrotestosterone (DHT)
roidal saponins (protodioscin), according to the manufacturer. Starting
concentrations in rats, rabbits and rhesus monkeys (Gauthaman &
on Day 1, the men were instructed to take one pill orally every 8 hr,
Ganesan, 2008). Considering its various phytochemical components,
thus providing 112.5 mg of protodioscin per day.
majorly present are furostanol glycosides, such as protodioscin and
protogracillin, of which protodioscin is the most abundant saponin
(Kostova & Dinchev, 2005). It is suggested that a major role of this
2.2 | Parameters evaluated
steroidal saponin is to induce the reduction in testosterone into the
potent dihydrotestosterone (DHT), which occurs by the action of Safety was evaluated on days 0 and 84 of the treatment. The follow-
the enzyme 5-alpha reductase (review, Chhatre et al., 2014). In men, ing exams were performed: complete blood count, fasting glycemia,
protodioscin appeared to increase serum dehydroepiandrostenedi- liver function tests (transaminases, gamma-glutamyl transferase, alka-
one (DHEA) concentrations and increase erectile function, when line phosphatase and total bilirubin), urea, creatinine and uric acid. No
values were compared before and after administration (Adimoelja significant differences were found; however, when any of these tests
& Adaikan, 1997). was altered at the onset of treatment, the patient was not included
However, other studies showed little effect of TT extract. in the study.
Frydrychová et al. (2011) fed boars with a preparation containing At each visit, participants were evaluated for weight, body fat
extracts of three herbs, including TT, for 10 weeks. All boars had index and lean muscle mass, the latter two both by dual-energy
normal semen parameters at the onset of treatment. The treated X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA). DEXA scanners use an X-ray tube that
group had low libido; libido returned to control levels after 10 weeks scans the entire body. DEXA measures bone density, fat mass and
of treatment. There was no significant effect of treatment on sperm lean mass separately, with a high degree of accuracy (St-Onge et al.,
parameters. 2004).
Two other studies were conducted to analyse the effects of TT Blood samples from participants were collected in serum-
extract in athletes; however, there was no effect of oral administra- separation tubes on days 0, 28 and 84. The samples were allowed
tion of TT extract on lean muscle mass gain or body strength enhance- to clot at room temperature and then were centrifuged for 10 min;
ment in men during physical training (Antonio, Uelmen, Rodruiguez, & after centrifugation, serum was isolated, frozen and stored at −20°C.
Earnest, 2000; Rogerson et al., 2007). Blood serum concentrations of free testosterone, FSH, LH and pro-
The aim of the present trial was to evaluate whether treatment lactin were evaluated by chemiluminescence immunoassays (ADVIA
with daily oral administration of TT extract in men having male fac- Centaur XPT Immunoassay System – Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics
tor infertility significantly affects semen quality and the androgen- Inc., USA), according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Analytical
related physiological parameters of lean muscle mass and body fat measurement ranges are 10–1,500 ng dl−1 (testosterone), 0.2–
index. 200 mIU ml−1 (FSH), 0.2–150 mIU ml−1 (LH) and 0.2–250 ng ml−1
Salgado et al. | 3
distribution was determined using the Shapiro–Wilk test. In normally were significant increases in liquefaction time (p = .01), sperm concen-
distributed measures (DEXA evaluation), values on Day 0 and Day 84 tration (p = .007) and sperm motility (p < .001) between days 0 and 84.
were compared within patient using paired t test. When normal distri-
bution was rejected, nonparametric tests were used: Friedman test was
used to test the difference between several related samples (hormone 4 | DISCUSSION
levels on days 0, 28 and 84); Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney test was used
to compare two independent samples (Semen parameters on days 0 The results of this study suggest that treatment with TT can increase
and 84). Values of p ≤ .05 were considered statistically significant. serum DHT concentrations and improve sperm count and motility, but
g, grams.
Bold Values: Significant differences in the percentage of body fat and in lean muscle mass between days 0 and 84 of treatment.
a
Descriptive level of probability of the Student paired t test.
4 | Salgado et al.
DHEA (ng ml−1) 0 58 4.39 2.40 0.60 14.73 2.68 4.10 5.80
28 58 7.73 23.51 0.60 183.00 3.43 4.20 5.80 .426
84 58 12.43 59.03 1.10 454.00 3.38 4.30 5.58
DHT (pg ml−1) 0 58 469.49 319.26 26.00 1,905.00 359.50 455.00 586.23
28 58 561.38 297.91 0.60 1,891.00 395.25 481.00 712.00 .023
84 58 596.82 283.71 6.90 1,705.00 458.75 499.35 758.90
FSH (mUI ml−1) 0 60 8.27 5.02 1.17 22.62 4.83 6.74 10.40
28 60 8.34 5.14 1.33 25.18 4.72 6.74 11.28 .278
84 60 8.28 5.06 1.35 24.27 4.85 6.94 10.36
LH (mUI ml−1) 0 60 5.08 2.26 1.01 10.64 3.24 4.72 6.68
28 60 5.08 2.42 1.95 13.11 3.08 4.77 6.24 .971
84 60 5.35 3.32 1.66 24.73 3.51 4.59 6.50
Free testos terone 0 51 333.10 128.95 152.20 775.89 245.40 312.81 385.02
(ng dl−1) 28 51 318.94 103.82 107.09 543.93 242.92 303.59 379.65 .114
84 51 360.62 91.23 177.58 508.00 282.90 366.80 440.85
Prolactin (ng ml−1) 0 61 17.53 78.60 2.66 621.00 5.17 7.17 9.06
28 61 7.60 4.49 1.05 29.75 5.27 6.43 8.36 .916
84 61 7.67 3.08 2.63 17.23 5.44 7.18 9.35
Bold Values: Significant differences in DHT levels when comparing the beginning and the end of treatment.
a
Descriptive level of probability of the nonparametric Friedman test.
Bold Values: Significant differences in sperm concentration and motility, as well as liquefaction time between days 0 and 84 of treatment.
a
Descriptive level of probability of the nonparametric Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney test.
not sperm morphology, in men with reduced sperm quality in a clinical In that trial, there was also a significant increase in free testoster-
ART program. These findings increase the support for investigation one levels and a positive impact on erectile function after 3 months
of TT as a possible intervention in male factor infertility and serve as of treatment with the same dose of TT extract as was used in our
a basis for future case-controlled studies to evaluate the effect of TT study. Gauthaman and Ganesan (2008) showed an increase in serum
supplementation on both sperm parameters and pregnancy rates after testosterone and DHT in primates. They stated that “The rise in the
either ART or natural conception. level of DHT was proportionate to the increase observed with testos-
The effect of TT on DHT concentrations is in agreement with terone. Since DHT is the reduced form of testosterone, the observed
a recent clinical trial, again comparing parameters before and after increase could probably be due to a primary increase in testosterone
treatment, with 30 male patients suffering from partial androgen level.” DHT has two or three times greater androgen receptor affinity
deficiency (Roaiah, El Khayat, GamalEl Din, & Abd El Salam, 2015). than testosterone and acts in the development of male secondary
Salgado et al. | 5
sex characteristics, as well as prostate and sexual function (Amory Amory, J. K., Anawalt, B. D., Matsumoto, A. M., Page, S. T., Bremner, W. J.,
et al., 2008). Wang, C., … Clark, R. V. (2008). The effect of 5alpha-reductase inhibi-
tion with dutasteride and finasteride on bone mineral density, serum
A recent review of the literature concluded that there is support
lipoproteins, hemoglobin, prostate specific antigen and sexual function
for a positive effect of TT on libido and erectile function, but that it in healthy young men. Journal of Urology, 179, 2333–2338.
is inconclusive whether these effects are due to androgen-enhancing Antonio, L., Uelmen, J., Rodruiguez, R., & Earnest, C. (2000). The effects
properties (Neychev & Mitev, 2016). of Tribulus terrestris on body composition and exercise performance in
resistance-trained males. International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Ex-
Arsyad (1996) reported a similar increase in sperm concentration
ercise Metabolism, 10, 208–215.
and motility after treatment of oligozoospermic men with an unspec- Arsyad, K. M. (1996). Effect of protodioscin on the quantity and quality of
ified amount of commercially prepared protodioscin. An increase in sperms from male with moderate idiopathic oligozoospermia. Medika,
sperm concentration, but not motility, was reported in a clinical trial 8, 614–618.
Chhatre, S., Nesari, T., Somani, G., Kanchan, D., & Sathaye, S. (2014). Phy-
in oligozoospermic men (Moeloek, Adimoelja, Tanojo, & Pangkahila,
topharmacological overview of Tribulus terrestris. Pharmacognosy Re-
1994); pregnancies were achieved for 8/36 men in the TT treatment views, 8, 45–51.
group, vs. 0/9 in the control group. Treatment with TT extract may DeKretser, D. M., & Baker, H. W. (1999). Infertility in men: Recent advances
improve sperm parameters in men with oligozoospermia by reversing and continuing controversies. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Me-
tabolism, 84, 3443–3450.
the negative effects of environmental toxins. Kumari and Singh (2015)
Duncan, M. W., & Thompason, H. S. (2007). Proteomics of semen and its
found that a dose of 200 mg kg−1 of TT fruit extract prevented testic-
constituents. Proteomics Clinical Applications, 1, 861–875.
ular damage induced by metronidazole treatment in mice. Similarly, El-Tantawy, W. H., Temraz, A., & El-Gindi, O. D. (2007). Free serum testos-
Rajendar et al. (2011) found that TT exerted a protective effect on terone level in male rats treated with Tribulus alatus extracts. Interna-
cadmium-induced testicular damage in rats, which appeared to be tional Brazilian Journal of Urology, 33, 554–558.
Frydrychová, S., Opletal, L., Macáková, K., Lustyková, A., Rozkot, M., & Li-
related to inhibition of peroxidation in testicular tissue. It has been
penský, J. (2011). Effects of herbal preparation on libido and semen
hypothesised that TT enhances sperm count by increasing testoster- quality in boars. Reproduction in Domestic Animals, 46, 573–578.
one levels via a prior increase in GnRH levels, which in turn stimu- Gauthaman, K., & Ganesan, A. P. (2008). The hormonal effects of Tribulus
lates the production of LH and FSH (Antonio et al., 2000); however, terrestris and its role in the management of male erectile dysfunction
an evaluation using primates, rabbit and rat. Phytomedicine, 15, 44–54.
we found no indication of any changes in these gonadotropins in our
Hegnauer, R. (1973). Chemataxonomie der Pflanzen, vol. 6 (p. 707). Basel:
study. Birkhauser-Verlag.
Lean muscle mass gain and body fat were evaluated, as chang- Kostova, I., & Dinchev, D. (2005). Saponins in Tribulus terrestris – chemistry
es in these parameters may be expected with increased androgen and bioactivity. Phytochemistry Reviews, 4, 111–137.
Kumari, M., & Singh, P. (2015). Tribulus terrestris ameliorates metronidazole-
levels. In 66% of the patients, DEXA evaluation demonstrated signif-
induced spermatogenic inhibition and testicular oxidative stress in
icant decreases in the percentage of body fat and increases in fat- the laboratory mouse. Indian Journal of Pharmacology, 47, 304–310.
free mass between days 0 and 84. Similar changes were not found Moeloek, N., Adimoelja, A., Tanojo, T., & Pangkahila, W. (1994). Trilas of
in a report on effects of a TT extract in trained athletes (Rogerson Tribulus terrestris on oligozoospermia. Proceedings of the VIth Nation-
al Congress and IIIrd International Symposium on New Perspectives on
et al., 2007).
Andrology in Human Reproduction. National Congress of Indonesian
In conclusion, the present clinical findings imply a possible thera- Association of Andrology (PANDI) in Manado, Indonesia.
peutic use of Tribulus terrestris extract in men presenting altered semen Neychev, V., & Mitev, V. (2016). Pro-sexual and androgen enhancing effects
parameters and/or infertility in a human ART program. Prospective of Tribulus Terrestris L.: Fact or fiction. Journal of Ethnopharmacology,
179, 345–355. pii: S0378-8741(15)30305-6.
randomised controlled studies are needed to determine whether TT
du Plessis, S. S., Agarwal, A., & Sabanegh, E. S. Jr (2014). Male infertility:
is effective in improving sperm parameters and inducing gain in lean
A complete guide to lifestyle and environmental factors. New York, NY:
muscle mass in this population of men. Springer Science + Business Media.
Rajendar, B., Bharavi, K., Rao, G. S., Kishore, P. V., Kumar, P. R., Kumar, C.
S., & Patel, T. P. (2011). Protective effect of an aphrodisiac herb Tribulus
ACKNOWLE DG E MEN TS terrestris Linn on cadmium-induced testicular damage. Indian Journal of
Pharmacology, 43, 568–573.
The authors wish to acknowledge the invaluable contribution of Roaiah, M. F., El Khayat, Y. I., GamalEl Din, S. F., & Abd El Salam, M. A. (2015).
Herbarium Laboratório Botânico, for supplying the TT extract Pilot study on the effect of botanical medicine (Tribulus terrestris) on se-
preparation. rum testosterone level and erectile function in aging males with partial
androgen deficiency (PADAM). Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy, 7, 1–5.
Rogerson, S., Riches, C. J., Jennings, C., Weatherby, R. P., Meir, R. A., & Mar-
REFERENCES shall-Gradisnik, S. M. (2007). The effect of five weeks of Tribulus terres-
tris supplementation on muscle strength and body composition during
Adaikan, P. G., Gauthaman, K., Prasad, R. N., & Ng, S. C. (2000). Proerec- preseason training in elite rugby league players. Journal of Strength and
tile pharmacological effects of Tribulus terrestris extract on the rabbit Conditioning Research, 21, 348–353.
corpus cavernosum. Annals of the Academy of Medicine, Singapore, 29, Singh, S., Nair, V., & Gupta, Y. K. (2012). Evaluation of the aphrodisiac activ-
22–26. ity of Tribulus terrestris Linn. in sexually sluggish male albino rats. Journal
Adimoelja, A., & Adaikan, P. G. (1997). Protodioscin from herbal plant Tribu- of Pharmacology & Pharmacotherapeutics, 3, 43–47.
lus terrestris L. improves the male sexual functions, probably via DHEA. St-Onge, M. P., Wang, J., Shen, W., Wang, Z., Allison, D. B., Heshka, S., …
International Journal of Impotence Research, 9, 1–15. Heymsfield, S. B. (2004). Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry-measured
6 | Salgado et al.
lean soft tissue mass: Differing relation to body cell mass across the World Health Organization (WHO). (2000). Manual for standard investi-
adult life span. Journals of Gerontology. Series A, Biological Sciences and gation and diagnosis of the infertile couple. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge
Medical Sciences, 59, 796–800. University Press.
Tomova, M., Gyulemetova, R., & Zarkova, S. (1978). An agent for stimula- Zegers-Hochschild, F., Adamson, G. D., de Mouzon, J., Ishihara, O., Man-
tion of sexual function. Bulg Patent, 27584, A61K35. sour, R., Nygren, K., … World Health Organization. (2009). Interna-
Turek, P. J. (2012). Male reproduction physiology. In A. Wein (Ed.), Camp- tional Committee for Monitoring Assisted Reproductive Technology
bell-Walsh urology, Vol. 1 (pp. 591–615). Philadelphia, PA: Elsevi- (ICMART) and the World Health Organization (WHO) revised glossary
er-Saunders. of ART terminology. Fertility and Sterility, 92, 1520–1524.