04 Isomerism
04 Isomerism
One of several species (or molecular entities) that have the same atomic composition
(molecular formula)but different line formulae or different stereo chemical formulae and
hence different physical and / or chemical properties is called isomer. The phenomenon
of existence of two or more compounds possessing the same molecular formula but
different properties is called isomerism.
Types of Isomerism
The isomerism is of two main types
a) Constitutional isomerism (formerly structural isomerism)
b) Stereo isomerism
a) Constitutional isomerism
The isomerism between structures differing in constitution and described by different
line formulae is called constitutional isomerism.
b) Stereo isomerism
Isomerism due to difference in the spatial arrangement of atoms without any
difference in connectivity or bond multiplicity between the isomers is called Stereo
isomerism.
The stereo isomerism is of three types
i) Geometrical isomerism
ii) Optical isomerism
iii) Conformational isomerism
Isomers
Constitutional Stereoisomers
(Structural isomers)
Conformational Configurational
Geometrical Optical
CONSTITUTIONAL ISOMERISM
Constitutional Structural isomerism can be further sub-divided as
I) Skeletal (or) Chain isomerism II) Position isomerism
III) Functional isomerism IV) Metamerism
V) Ring chain isomerism VI) Tautomerism
The first three members of the alkane family CH4 , C2H6 and C3H8 do not exhibit chain
isomerism.
Ex: 1. C 4 H10 2. C5 H12
3. C 8 H10
Ethylbenzene 1,2-dimethylbenzen
Chain Isomers 2 3 5 9 18 35 75
2)
3)
2-methylpentane 3-methylpentane
118 ISOMERISM
4)
3) Alcohols ethers
Cyclic alcohol
5) Acids esters
ISOMERISM 119
6) Cyanide isocyanide
CH3 — CH2 — CN CH3 — CH2 — NC
IV) Metamerism
The compounds having same molecular formula but different number of carbon atoms
(or alkyl groups) on either side of the functional group are called metamers and this
phenomenon is called metamerism.
A and B
2) are metamers
A and C
B and C are not metamers but positional isomers since number of carbon
atoms are same on either side.
120 ISOMERISM
3)
Both are metamers since nature of alkyl groups is changed.
Ex: 1) 2)
3)
Learn the skills:
1. Write the total number of structural isomers for molecular formulae C4H8?
Ans.
Ans. i)
ii)
4. How many cyclic compounds are possible with formula C 6 H12 and draw the structure?
ISOMERISM 121
Ans. 12
5. How many substituted cyclohexanes are possible for the formula C 9 H18 and draw the
structure?
Ans. 12
Questions:
1. How many unsubstituted bicyclic compounds are possible with formula C 8 H14 ? Ans. 8.
2. How many chloro derivatives are possible for ethane? Ans. 2.
3. How many isomers possible for C7 H9N containing at least one benzene ring? Ans. 5.
4. How many mono bromo derivatives are possible for 2-methyl pentane? Ans. 5.
Tautomerism (Kryptomerism/Desmotropism)
The phenomenon of two (or) more structurally distinct compounds that are in rapid
equilibrium is called tautomerism. Isomers of the general form
GYX Z Y XZG
where the isomers called tautomers are readily interconvertible.
If G is hydrogen it is called prototropy.
Tautomers differ both physically and chemically and can be “isolated”.
Diad System (1, 2–shift)
1. Keto-enol 2. Nitro-acinitro
Simple esters don’t exhibit tautomerism due to lack of sufficient acidity to -hydrogen.
_______________________________________________________________________________________
Higher Systems
1, 5 – shift
1, 7 - shift
Valence Tautomerism
Tautomerism in which single and/or double bonds are rapidly formed and ruptured without
migration of atoms (or) groups.
ISOMERISM 123
II) Aromaticity
Introduction of aromaticity stabilizes the enol to a larger extent than keto form which
makes phenols to exist almost 100% in enol form (resonance energy of benzene is
36 kcal/mol)
Ex: 1)
2)
3)
III) Bridge head
In a non-zero bridged bicycle compound, bridged head carbon cannot have a double
bond if the ring size is less than 8-carbons (Bredt’s rule).
Ex:
IV) Rings
Simple cyclic ketones have higher enol content than simple acyclic ketones.
Cyclic ketones have restricted rotation of their bonds and hence adding a double bond
does not make much difference to the entropy of system.
In case of acyclic ketones, there will be appreciable decrease in entropy due to
restricted rotation caused about C = C in the enol form.
Ex:
V) Steric relief
ISOMERISM 125
Dimesityl acetaldehyde on moving from keto to enol form enjoys a steric relief of 10°
32' (theoretically) between two mesityl groups. This results in a very high enol
content.
Ex:
i)
ii)
In (i), the dipoles of carbonyl groups align “anti” to each other to minimize the
repulsion between partial charges on oxygen.
The rigidity of the ring does not permit such an alignment, in the (ii). Thus it has no
other option but to enolise and stabilise via chelation.
Polar protic solvents solvate keto form forming hydrogen bonds with carbonyl oxygen,
hence increase in polarity of solvents shifts the equilibrium towards keto form.
Gaseous phase – 92 %
n – hexane solvent – 92 %
Liquid phase – 76 %
CH3CN – 58 %
H 2O – 15 %
IX) Effect of temperature
High temperature shift the equilibrium towards keto form.
Questions:
5. Which of the following show tautomerism?
A) CH3 COOH B) CH3COCl C) CH3COOEt
D) E) CH3CONH2
6. Arrange in order of enol content.
A) HCO3 CH B) CH3CO3 CH C) i Pr CO3 CH3 D) t BuCO3 CH
Ans. A>B>C>D
Mechanism of enolisation
Mechanism
Ex: 1)
2)
Learn the skills:
6.
Ans. Mechanism
CONFORMATIONAL ISOMERISM
Conformations are different spatial arrangements of atoms (or) groups in a molecule that are
interconvertible by free rotation about single bond (or) flipping of rings.
Rotamers/conformers are conformations corresponding to minimum potential energy.
Conformers cannot be isolated as they convert rapidly but are detected spectroscopically.
They do not differ in physical properties and chemical properties.
Specific conformations are made use while proposing certain reaction mechanism.
128 ISOMERISM
For conformers to exist there must be two polyvalent atoms connected by single bond.
Ex: Ethane.
As there is a carbon-carbon single bond, rotation about the bond results in many
spatial arrangements called conformations.
Saw Horse Projection
Newmann Projections
In Newman projections the observer looks at the C—C bond head on. The three lines
emanating from the center of the circle represent the bonds coming from the front carbon,
with respect to the observer.
Newmann representation
Staggered Eclipsed
Dihedral Angle (Torsional Angle)
The angle of torsion, which is a dihedral angle, is the angle between the X—C—C and the
C—C—Y planes, as shown
1) Conformations of Ethane
The conformation in which torsional angle is 0° (or) 120° (or) 240° is called as Eclipsed
conformation.
Eclipsed Eclipsed
2) The conformation in which the torsional angle is 60° (or) 180° (or) 300° is called as
staggered conformation.
Staggered Staggered
3) Any conformation other than Staggered and Eclipsed are called Skew conformations.
There are infinite numbers of conformations possible for ethane.
The most stable conformation of ethane is the staggered conformation and the least
stable is eclipsed conformation.
The energy difference between the most stable conformation and the least stable
conformation is 12 kJ.
The low stability of eclipsed form is attributed to torsional strain.
At ordinary temperatures enough rotational energy is present for the ethane molecule
rapidly to rotate, though it still spends most of its time at or near the energy
minimum. Groups larger than hydrogen cause larger barriers. When the barriers are
large enough, as in the case of suitably substituted biphenyls, rotation at room
temperature is completely prevented and only configurational isomerism is exhibited.
Torsional Strain
It is the repulsion between electron clouds of bonds on adjacent atoms. It is maximum when
= 0 and is minimum (or) zero in staggered form.
Conformations of Butane
n-butane is treated as 1,2-disubstituted ethane for which there are four extremes a fully
staggered conformation called anti, trans, or antiperiplanar another staggered conformation
called gauche or synclinal and two types of eclipsed conformations called synperiplanar and
anticlinal.
130 ISOMERISM
Energy diagram
The fully eclipsed is the least stable form due to van der Waals strain (steric repulsion) in
additional to torsional strain)
If the electron clouds of the pair of atoms (or) group of atoms (such as methyl group) are too
close to each other, then there is a destabilization due to the electrostatic repulsion of the
electron clouds called van der Waals strain.
In syn conformation (eclipsed) the distance between the methyl groups (210 pm) is less than
the sum of van der Waals radii of two hydrogen atoms (240 pm).
Repulsion between two methyl groups in gauche conformation is called “Gauche repulsion”.
Potential energy barrier between least and most stable conformation of butane is 25 kJ/mol.
Gauche form is more stable than anti form due to hydrogen bond.
ISOMERISM 131
Generalization
1, 2-dihalo ethanes
Conformational equilibrium in 1, 2-dihalo ethanes shift from prefentially anti in the chloro,
bromo and iodo compounds, to “gauche” for the diflouride.
Conformation in Propanal
All the conformations so far discussed have involved rotation about sp3 sp3 bonds. Many
studies were also made of compounds with sp3 sp2 bonds. For example, propanal (or any
similar molecule) has four extreme conformations, two of which are called eclipsing and the
other two bisecting. For propanal the eclipsing conformations have lower energy than the other two,
with ‘P’ favored over ‘Q’ by ~1kcal mol
1
4 kJ mol .
1
P Q
CONFORMATIONS OF CYCLOALKANES
Baeyer’s strain theory
Baeyer assumed cycloalkanes as planar molecules and calculated the deviation of C—C—C (bond
angle) from original tetrahedral bond angle.
According to him lesser the deviation from the original angle, more is the stability.
Expected bond angles 10928 ' 10928 ' 10928 ' 10928 '
Assuming planar
structure bond angle 60 90 108 120
Deviation 4928' 1928 ' 128 ' 1052'
Angle strain 2444' 944' 44 ' 526'
Expected stability order
132 ISOMERISM
1
Angle strain = 109°28' — bond angle assuming planar
2
Heat of combustion and stability
For isomeric hydrocarbons, stability is inversely proportional to heat of combustion.
The C—C—C bond angle is 111° which makes it almost free from angle strain.
ISOMERISM 133
Boat is de-stabilised by van der Waals strain involving two flag pole hydrogens which
are at a distance of 180 pm.
Also there is a torsional strain between the eclipsed bonds of four carbon atoms.
Boat is less stable than chair form by 27 kJ/mol.
III) Twist boat conformation
The torsional and van der Waals strain are reduced by rotation by C—C bonds to give
skew boat (or) twist boat conformation on which it is slightly more stable than boat
form.
Substituted cycloalkanes
I) Mono substituted cyclohexane
Ex: Methyl cyclohexane
Reason
As the size of the substituent increases, the preference of equitorial position increases.
Me < Et < iPr < t-Br
F < Cl < Br < I
Ex: 1, 2-dimethylcyclohexane
Cis isomer
Trans isomer
2) 1, 3-disubstituted
Configuration - Cis (aa/ee)
Configuration-Trans (ae)
Ex: 1, 3-dimethylcyclohexane
Cis isomer
Twist boat is more stable compared to chair form as both t-butyl bulky groups occupy
equatorial position in twist boat form.
Cyclobutane
Has lesser angle strain than cyclo propane and minimizes the torsional strain by adopting a
“puckered” conformation.
In case of 1,3-dimethyl cyclobutane, Cis-1, 3-dimethyl cyclobutane is more stable than trans-
1, 3-dimethyl cyclobutane.
Cyclopentane
In planar structure, angle strain is negligible but torsional strain exists. There are two non-
planar conformations with lesser torsional strain namely (“half chair” and “envelope form”
both have same energy).
Envelope Half-chair
GEOMETRICAL ISOMERISM
Geometrical isomerism is exhibited by a wide variety of compounds and they may be
classified into three groups
I) Compounds containing a double bond: C C, C N, N N .
II) Compounds containing a cyclic structure — homocyclic, heterocyclic and fused ring
systems.
III) Compounds which may exhibit geometrical isomerism due to restricted rotation about
a single bond.
Geometrical isomers cannot be inter converted without breakage of bond and they have
different physical and chemical properties. These compounds do not rotate plane polarized
unless they also happen to be chiral.
When W = Y, isomer (i) is called cis and isomer (ii) is called trans.
There is no easy way to apply this method when the four groups are different. The
newer method which can be applied to all cases is based on the Cahn-Ingold-Prelog
system the two groups at each carbon are ranked by the sequence rules. Then the
isomer with the two higher ranking groups on the same side of the double bond is
called Z isomer (for the German word zusammen meaning together); the other is E (for
entgegen meaning opposite) The Z isomer is not necessarily the one that would be
called Cis.
Ex:
Ex:
5) A bond pair gets higher priority over lone pair.
ISOMERISM 137
Ex:
6) cis gets higher priority over trans
Ex:
7) If the group cannot be regarded as cis (or) trans then E gets higher priority over Z.
8) If like priorities are on the same side of the axis of the double bond it is given a
configuration ‘Z’.
9) If like priorities are on opposite side of the axis of double bond, it is given a
configuration ‘E’.
Ex:
In the case of other double bond such as C N,N N or even C S only two or three
groups are connected to the double-bond atoms. In case of imines, oximes and other
C N compounds, if W = Y.
Azo compounds
In azo compounds, regardless nature of W and Y, if W and Y are same side it is ‘syn’ isomer
and if W and Y are opposite side then it is ‘anti’ isomer.
E and Z system also can be used.
138 ISOMERISM
Ex: 1)
2)
3)
Spiranes having even number of rings do not show geometrical isomerism, but
spiranes with odd number of rings exhibits geometrical isomerism
Ex:
I) Cyclo propane
II) Cyclobutane
ISOMERISM 139
III) Cyclopentane
IV) Cyclohexane
1,2-disubstituted
1,3-disubstituted 1,4-disubstituted
V) Cycloalkenes
All cyclo alkenes having less than 8 carbons atoms don’t show geometrical isomerism.
140 ISOMERISM
Cis form is more stable than trans form because in trans form there is trans-annular
repulsion between hydrogens.
Stability order
Decaline
Due to steric repulsion the outer rings will be in the same plane and inner will be
perpendicular to others.
2)
ISOMERISM 141
3)
PPL is made up of two circularly polarized beams one propagating clockwise and the other
anti-clockwise.
Polarizer
Crystal used in (or) to polarize unpolarized light.
Ex: 1) Nicol prism which is made up of calcite crystal.
2) Tourmaline Prism.
Specific Rotation []
The amount of rotation ‘’ is not a constant for a given enantiomer it depends on the length
of the sample vessel, the temperature, the solvent and concentration (for solutions), the
pressure (for gasses), and the wavelength of light. Of course, rotations determined for the
same compound under the same conditions are identical. The length of the vessel and the
concentration or pressure determine the number of molecules in the path of the beam and
is linear with this. Therefore, a number is defined, called the specific rotation [], which is
ISOMERISM 143
for solutions for pure compounds
lc ld
Where is the observed rotation, l is the cell length in decimeters, c is the concentration in
grams per millilitre and d is the density in the same units. The specific rotation is usually
given along with the temperature and wavelength, in this manner: T .
ELEMENTS OF SYMMETRY
For optical activity, although the ultimate criterion is, of course, nonsuperposability on the
mirror image (chirality), other tests may be used that are simpler to apply. One such test is
the presence of elements of symmetry.
I) Axis of symmetry (Cn)
360
A molecule is said to have n-fold axis of symmetry in a rotation of along an axis
n
gives the same representation in space.
Ex:
effected across a plane at right angles to the axis, an new object is obtained that is
indistinguishable from the original one. This is also called “improper axis of
symmetry”.
Condition for molecule to be optically active
For a molecule to be optically active it should be dissymmetric i.e., it should not have
i) Centre of symmetry
ii) Plane of symmetry
iii) Alternating axis of symmetry
An old but commonly used word to describe the condition for optical activity is asymmetric.
It is commonly used for carbon atoms connected for four different substituents.
Enantiomer
One of a pair of molecular entities which are mirror images of each other and non-
superposable is called enantiomer.
Ex:
H3C CH CH C2H5
| |
OH Cl
Enantiomers have identical physical and chemical properties except in two important
aspects.
1. They rotate the plane of plane polarized light in opposite directions, though in equal
amounts. Because they differ in this property they are often called optical antipodes.
2. They react at different rates with other chiral compounds. These rates may be so close
together that the distinction is practically useless, or they may be so far apart that one
enantiomer undergoes the reaction at a convenient rate while the other does not react
at all. This is the reason that many compounds are biologically active while their
enantiomers are not. Enantiomers react at the same rate with achiral compounds.
In general, it may be said that enantiomers have identical properties in a symmetrical
environment, but their properties may differ in an unsymmetrical environment.
Racemic mixture/recemate/form
Mixtures of equal amounts of enantomers are optically inactive since the equal and opposite
rotations cancel out. Such mixtures are called racemic mixture or recemate.
Diastereomers
Two non-superposable configurational units that correspond to the same constitutional unit
and if they are not mirror images are called diastereomers.
They have different physical as well as chemical properties they can be separated by
fractional distillation (or) crystallization and chromatography.
Ex: 1
ISOMERISM 145
Meso compound
Meso compound is the compound with chiral centres but is optically inactive due to
symmetry in it.
It is a term for achiral member(s) of a set of diastereo isomers which also includes one or
more chiral members.
Ex:
Optical activity has been detected even in cases such as 1-butanol-1-d, where one
group is hydrogen and another deuterium.
normally results. However, the preparation of an optically active sulfone (i) in which
one oxygen is 16 O and the other 18 O illustrates the point that slight differences in
groups are all that is necessary. This has been taken even further with the preparation
of the ester (ii), both enantiomers of which have been prepared. Optically active chiral
phosphates (iii) have similarly been made.
would be expected to be chiral and thus resolvable. Many attempts have been made to
resolve such compounds, but until 1968 all of them failed because of pyramidal
inversion, which is a rapid oscillation of the molecule into its enantiomer. For
ammonia there are 2 1011 inversions every second. The inversion is less rapid in
substituted ammonias (amines, amides etc.). Two types of nitrogen atom invert
particularly slowly,
1) A nitrogen atom in a three-membered ring
2) A nitrogen atom connected to another atom bearing an unshared pair.
Even in such compounds, however, for many years pyramidal inversion proven too
rapid to permit isolation of separate isomers. This goal was accomplished only when
compounds were synthesized in which both features are combined: a nitrogen atom in
a three-membered ring connected to an atom containing an unshared pair.
Ex: The two isomers of 1-chloro-2-methyaziridine were separated and do not interconvert
at room temperature.
In suitable cases this barrier for inversion can result in compounds that are optically active
solely because of a chiral tervalent nitrogen atom.
Ex: The following compound has been resolved into its separate enantiomers. In this case
too, the nitrogen is connected to an atom with an unshared pair.
ISOMERISM 147
Phosphorus inverts more slowly and arsenic still more slowly. Non bridgehead phosphorus,
arsenic, and antimony compounds have also been resolved.
Ex:
Sulfur exhibits pyramidal bonding in sulfoxides, sulfinic esters, sulfonium salts and sulfites.
These compounds have been resolved.
Ex:
Biphenyls
Biphenyls with bulky groups at ortho positions face large steric repulsions which force both
the rings perpendicular to each other, this hinders (or) greatly lowers the free rotation about
the C – C bond connecting the rings and makes molecules dissymmetric. Isomers that can be
separated only because rotation about single bonds is prevented or greatly slowed are called
atropisomers.
Ex:
Similarly if t-butyl and mesityl groups are present even H-atom forces it out of plane.
Allenes
In allenes, the central carbon is sp bonded. The remaining two p-orbitals are perpendicular
to each other and each overlaps with the p-orbital of one adjacent carbon atom, forcing the
two remaining bonds of each carbon into perpendicular planes.
148 ISOMERISM
Like biphenyls, allenes are chiral only if both sides are unsymmetrically substituted.
These cases are completely different from the cis–trans isomerism of compounds with one
double bond. In the latter cases, the four groups are all in one plane, the isomers are not
enantiomers, and neither is chiral, while in allenes the groups are in two perpendicular
planes and the isomers are a pair of optically active enantiomers.
When three, five, or any odd number of cumulative double bonds exist, orbital overlap causes
the four groups to occupy one plane and cis–trans isomerism is observed. When four, six, or
any even number of cumulative double bonds exist, the situation is analogous to that in the
allenes and optical activity is possible.
Among other types of compounds that contain the system illustrated in the below examples
are similarly chiral, if both sides are dissymmetric are spiranes and compounds with
exocyclic double bonds.
3) It is also permissible to keep any one group fixed and to rotate the other three
clockwise or counter-clockwise (because this can be done with models).
ISOMERISM 149
However, the interchange of any two groups results in the conversion of an enantiomer
into its mirror image (this applies to models as well as to the Fischer projections).
With these restrictions Fischer projections may be used instead of models to test
whether a molecule containing asymmetric carbons is superposable on its mirror
image. However, there are no such conventions for molecules whose chirality arises
from anything other than chiral atoms; when such molecules are examined on paper,
three-dimensional pictures must be used. With models or three-dimensional pictures
there are no restrictions about the plane of the paper.
Note: Fischer projection represents eclipsed conformation of the molecules.
Ex:
1 2 3 Clockwise direction
Least priority group is away from observer so configuration is R.
If the molecule is in Fischer projection the following rules are used.
If lowest priority group is in vertical line
123 Clockwise R.
Anti-clockwise S.
If lowest priority group is in horizontal line
123 Clockwise S.
Anti-clockwise R.
Ex:
D(+) glyceraldehyde
To assign configuration of their carbohydrates their Fischer projection is drawn with the
longest C-chain in vertical line and the most oxidised one at the top (aldehyde or ketone). If
OH group at the farthest chiral centre form CHO or C = O group is at the right, it is given
configuration ‘D’, if it is left ‘L’ configuration.
Similarly when amino acids are drawn in Fischer projection —COOH group up and the alkyl
residue down. If NH2 group is on the right it is given D-configuration or else L.
1) Cyclopropane
Optically active
When a = b the cis isomer is optically inactive due to plane of symmetry whereas
trans isomer is optically active.
2) Cyclobutane
1, 2 - disubstituted
1, 3 - disubstituted
3) Cyclopentane
1,2-disubstituted
1,3-disubstituted
If a = b cis isomer is optically inactive not due to plane of symmetry but to a rapid
interconversion of the molecule and its mirror image.
1,3-disubstituted
1,4-disubstituted
1,4-disubstituted cis and trans isomer of cyclo hexanes are optically inactive
irrespective of nature of the substitutions.
Enantiomeric excess (Optical purity)
If the value of [] for the pure material
max
is known, the purity of the sample can be
determined by measuring its rotation. For example, if max is +80° and our (+) enantiomer
contains 20 % of the (–) isomer, [] for the sample will be +48°.
observed
Optical purity 100
max Pure enantiomers
Assuming a linear relationship between [] and concentration, which is true for most cases,
the optical purity is equal to the percent excess of one enantiomer over the other
RESOLUTION
Resolution is the process whereby a recemic modification is separated into its two
enantiomers.
Method of resolution
1) Mechanical separation
This method is also known as spontaneous resolution by crystallization, and was
introduced by Pasteur (1848). It depends on the crystallization of the two forms
separately, which are then separated by hand. The method is applicable only for
recemic mixtures where the crystal forms of the enantiomers are themselves
enantiomerphous. Pasteur separated sodium ammonium recemate in this way. The
transition temperature of sodium ammonium recemate is 28 °C; above this
154 ISOMERISM
temperature the recemic compound crystallizes out, and below this temperature the
recemic mixure. Now Pasteur crystallized his sodium ammonium recemate from a
concentrated solution at room temperature, which must have been below
28 °C, since, had the temperature been above this, he would have obtained the
recemic compound, which cannot be separated mechanically. Actually, Staedel (1878)
failed to repeat Pasteur’s separation since he worked at a temperature above 28 °C.
Asymmetric induction
Introduction of chiracity center in an achiral compound.
ISOMERISM 155
Enantiotropic hydrogens
Ha , Hb – enantiotropic hydrogens.
Diastereobropic hydrogens
H, Hb – diastereotropic hydrogens.
Prochiral centre
Atom which turns chiral during reaction.
Ex: