Historical View

www.anatomy.org.tr
Received: May 7, 2015; Accepted: August 7, 2015
doi:10.2399/ana.15.003

Herophilos, the great anatomist of antiquity*

Rafael Romero Reverón*

Human Anatomy Department, J.M. Vargas School of Medicine, Universidad Central de Venezuela, Caracas, Venezuela

Abstract
Herophilos (ca. 330 to ca. 260 B.C.) was a Greek physician and precursor in learning and teaching of human anatomy through
systematic anatomical dissections who made extraordinary anatomical discoveries. He developed the theory of using the pulse as
a form of diagnosis and introduced the use of experimental method to medicine.
Keywords: dissection; Herophilos, human anatomy
Anatomy 2015;9(2):108–111 ©2015 Turkish Society of Anatomy and Clinical Anatomy (TSACA)

Introduction known about Herophilos’ life. From secondary sources,

The city of Alexandria, Egypt, was the world center of such as the physician Galen, the writer Celsus and the
learning and scholarship in the 3rd century B.C. It was theologian Tertullian in the 2nd century A.D.,
founded by Alexander the Great in 332 B.C. and estab- Herophilos and his works are known. About 250 years
lished by the mighty Ptolemaio Pharoahs. This city was after the death of Herophilos, Celsus and later
home to many prominent philosophers and medical prac- Tertullian blamed him to have performed vivisection on
titioners of that time.[1] condemned criminals awarded to Herophilos by the
rulers of Alexandria, but such accusations remain specu-
Although there are very few historical documents, it
lative.[2,4,5]
may fairly be stated that the Alexandrian physicians were
the first in the medical tradition to perform systematic dis-
Background
sections of human cadavers.
Aristotle dissected animals in the 4th century B.C., and
The knowledge of human anatomy (from the Greek
there were also dissections by other Greek physicians in
word (anatomē), which means dissection) con-
previous centuries and later on by Galen in the 2nd cen-
stitutes an essential pillar in the broad and complex field of
tury, but Herophilos’ work drew widespread praise.
medicine. Among the main contributions in the field of
learning and teaching of human anatomical dissections, It is believed that Herophilos was born in Chalcedon,
those made by Herophilos of the school of anatomy in currently Kadikoy, a settlement on Bosphorus, Turkey,
Alexandria stand out.[2] The cultural, social, intellectual and about the year 335 B.C.[6,7] His name comes from the
political conditions of Alexandria in the third century B.C. ancient Greek word , later sometimes Latinized
provided Herophilos with opportunities to dissect human as Herophilus.
cadavers. He was thus able to make an unprecedented We have no knowledge of his childhood. He was
number of anatomical discoveries and accompany them trained as a physician with Praxagoras and Crisipus of
with precise descriptions (Figure 1).[3] Cnido, physicians and anatomists who taught in the
The objective of this paper is to make a review of medical school of Greek island of Cos. After his medical
Herophilos’ contribution to of human anatomy. Little is training, Herophilos went to live in Alexandria, where he

*Numerary Member of the Venezuelan Society of the History of Medicine; Member of the International Society of the History of Medicine, Member of the American
Association of the History of Medicine; Medical Doctor, Specialist in Orthopedic Trauma Surgery at the Centro Médico Docente La Trinidad and Urológico San
Román, Caracas, Venezuela
 Herophilos, the great anatomist of antiquity 109

learned and practiced human anatomy dissection and

medicine.[8]
Systematic dissections of human cadavers started in
Alexandria in the third century B.C. and for about 30 years
of Herophilos' life, the prohibition on human dissections
was removed, initiating this medical practice. He and
some of his colleagues and disciples had the exclusive
opportunity to perform human dissections, a procedure
that was not tolerable anywhere else at the time.[9] After
this period, human dissection was banned and not permit-
ted again for about 1,800 years until it began to be prac-
ticed again during the 14th century A.D. Herophilos was
among the first physicians to perform anatomical dissec-
tions in public, dissected more than 600 human cadavers
and being among the first to compare human and animal
morphology. His dissections provided unprecedented
knowledge of how the human body and its organs
worked.[2,7] He created terms to systematically describe the Figure 1. Herophilos (ca. 330 to ca. 260 B.C.) from How human
experimentation worksworks?[3]
objects of study, as opposed to the use of "natural names",
named them for the first time and established anatomical
nomenclature so that there was some uniformity for study
and description.
damage to motor nerves produced paralysis.[12] Herophilos
His anatomical discoveries of the nervous system named the styloid process of the skull.[13]
Herophilos made outstanding anatomical discoveries in His anatomical discoveries on the digestive system
human cadavers: for example, he distinguished the brain
from the cerebellum, and described the brain as the seat of Herophilos studied the liver extensively and described and
intelligence,[10] contrary to the beliefs of his contempo- named the duodenum, the ileum and colon, performed the
raries. first research of the pancreas.[14] He described the sub-
mandibular glands and the parotid gland and he also
He recognized and studied the internal surface of the
described and gave his name to the hyoid bone.[15,16]
skull and the cranial sutures. Herophilos described the
Herophilos knew the vessels of the mesentery, and showed
lower brainstem and spinal cord as one structure he
that they did not go to vena portae. Herophilos also noted
referred to as “spinal marrow”, and also identified and
the existence of the lymphatic system but did not rule o›ut
described several brain structures, some of which still have
its function.
his name, such as the concavity on the internal surface of
the occipital bone, in which lodges the posterior confluent
His anatomical discoveries on the
of the cranial venous sinuses, known as the Herophilos’
cardiovascular system
press (torcular Herophili).[11] The three membranes of the
brain were also recognized by Herophilos and designated Herophilos established the distinction between arteries
as “chorioid” because they resembled the chorionic enve- and veins and confirmed that the arteries had thicker walls
lope surrounding the fetus. On the vision system, than the veins[6,12] and maintained the idea that arteries car-
Herophilos explored the optic nerve and described the ried blood rather than air.[16,17] He described the pulmonary
sclerotic ring, the retina, and the choroid coat.[2,7] He stud- artery which he denominated arterious vein and also
ied the encephalon by dissecting human cadavers and car- described the pulmonary vein.[18] His mentor Praxagoras’
rying out investigations with animals, describing the misconception that the pulse was not associated with the
choroid plexus, the meninges, and the fourth ventricle. He heart beat was refuted by Herophilos,[19] who pointed out
discovered that nerves originated in the brain, was the first the importance of the pulse, establishing the synchronici-
to distinguish nerves from tendons and observed the dif- ty of pulse and heart beats. He sustained that the pulse was
ference between the motor and sensory nerves.[1,11] not a natural faculty of the arteries, but was derived from
Herophilos also described at least six cranial nerves and the heart, and differentiated the pulse as not simply quan-
named them the optic, oculomotor, trigeminal, facial, titative but also qualitative of palpitations, tremors and
auditory and hypoglossal nerves, and pointed out that spasms which are muscular in origin.[9,17.18] He was the first

Anatomy • Volume 9 / Issue 2 / August 2015

110 Romero RR

to point out that the pulse could be used as an indicator of Herophilos, prognosis was derived from the symptoms,
disease, believing that artery pulsations were involuntary, and for this reason, symptoms should be clearly recog-
as a result of the dilatation and contraction of arteries due nized. Herophilos acquired great prestige, both as a
to impulses sent by the heart. He observed the pulse of the practitioner and as a teacher of human anatomy. He con-
arteries and developed measuring standards, using a water sidered there were limits to medical activity, arguing that
clock and made important contributions to medicine by an accomplished physician can differentiate what is pos-
developing the theory of diagnosing through the pulse.[19] sible from what is not possible. It is attributed to
Herophilos is considered for his researches as one of the Herophilos to have said “When health is absent, wisdom
precursors of cardiology. He described the anatomy of the cannot reveal itself, art cannot manifest, strength cannot fight,
heart valves.[20] He also described the respiratory move- wealth becomes useless, and intelligence cannot be applied”.[2,7,8]
ments. Herophilos is thought to be one of the founders of the
scientific method. He had introduced the experimental
His anatomical discoveries on the method to medicine, for he considered it essential to
reproductive system found knowledge on empirical bases. For that, he was
On the male reproductive system, Herophilos described criticized by Galen for whom the experimental method
the epididymis, the prostate gland, and identified the vari- contradicted rationality.
ous parts of the spermatic duct.[6] He recognized that the
testicles produced spermatozoa. On the female reproduc- Discussion
tive system, Herophilos described the ovaries, the uterine Herophilos was a precursor in the learning and teach-
tubes, and the uterus,[21] showing that the latter was ing of human anatomy through systematic dissections of
attached by the broad ligament and thus not mobile in the human cadavers that is why he is considered the ‘Father of
body as had been previously thought. He described the Human Anatomy.[6,21,22] It appears that he wrote three trea-
phases and duration of pregnancy as well as causes for dif- tises devoted to anatomy, one to midwifery, two each to
ficult childbirth. Herophilos also described and explained the study of the pulse and to therapeutics, one to ophthal-
the causes of uterus prolapsus and rightly held that only the mology and one to dietetics.[1,7] None of his works have
cervix, and not the entire uterus, can protrude. He was also been preserved, they disappeared with the destruction of
interested in the relationship between menstruation and the library of Alexandria.[15,23]
general health. His teachings and research were complemented and
enhanced by his disciple Erasistratus,[12,24,25] but after
Herophilos’ medical practice Herophilos’ death, about the year 280 B.C, his followers
In the field of medical treatments, Herophilos was a spon- got caught up for centuries in unfriendly and needless
sor of Plato’s dogmatic doctrine, which gave preference to polemics, with the following decline in the medical appli-
reason above experience, classifying all diseases based on cation of his teachings and research in the field of human
the theory of the accumulation of humors and maintained anatomy studies.[7,17,26]
the ancient doctrine of the four humors as the basis for
treatment.[7,8] Herophilos revised the humor theory of
Hippocrates. In his own theory, he argued against the References
notion that the veins were filled with a blend of blood, 1. Pearce J. The neuroanatomy of Herophilus. Eur Neurol 2013;69:
292–5.
water and air; rather he showed, through his dissections
2. Magner L. A history of medicine. 2nd ed. Boca Raton: Taylor and
that it was pure blood in the veins. Thus, he used blood-
Francis; 2005. p. 106–13.
letting and purging to evacuate the unwanted humors.[8]
3. How human experimentation works? http://holykaw.alltop.com/
To Herophilos, an imbalance of the four humors triggered how-human-experimentation-works
all diseases. 4. Scarborough J. Celsus on human vivisection at Ptolemaic Alexandria.
The cardiocentric thesis enjoyed great success well Clio Med 1976;11:25–38.
beyond Aristotles and Praxagoras, and among others 5. Sinha DN. Ancient human cadaveric dissection. Personal commu-
nique. National Journal of Clinical Anatomy 2015;4:53-7.
Greek physicians and philosophers,[10] but Herophilos
6. Bay NS, Bay BH. Greek anatomist Herophilus: the father of anato-
rejected cardiocentric thesis and returned to
my. Anat Cell Biol 2010;43:280-3.
Hippocraticencephalocentrism supported in his anatom-
7. Sigerist HE. A History of medicine. Vol. II. Early Greek, Hindu, and
ical research on the configuration and function of the Persian Medicine 1961. New York: Oxford University Press. p. 262-
brain.[21] He was also one of the first doctors who recom- 6.
mended the habits of proper diet and exercise.[7,17] For 8. Dobson J. Herophilus of Alexandria. Proc R Soc Med 1925;18:19-32.

Anatomy • Volume 9 / Issue 2 / August 2015

 Herophilos, the great anatomist of antiquity 111

9. Moon K, Filis AK, Cohen AR. The birth and evolution of neuro- 18. Harris CRS. The heart and the vascular system in ancient Greek
science through cadaveric dissection. Neurosurgery 2010;67:799- medicine: from Alcmaeon to Galen. Oxford: Clarendon Press;
809. 1973.
10. Crivellato E, Ribatti D. Soul, mind, brain: Greek philosophy and the 19. Khan IA, Daya SK, Gowda RM. Evolution of the theory of circula-
birth of neuroscience. Brain Res Bull 2007;71:327-36. tion. Int J Cardiol 2005;98:519–21.
11. Tubbs RS, Oakes WJ. 2002. Letter to the Editor. Neuroanatomy 20. Buzzi A, Doisenbant AR. Evolución histórica de la medicina. Buenos
2002;1:14. Aires: Editorial Médica Panamericana; 2008. p. 110-1.
12. Reverón RR. Herophilus and Erasistratus, pioneers of human 21. Mavrodi A, Paraskevas G. Morphology of the heart associated with
anatomical dissection. Vesalius 2014;20:55-8. its function as conceived by ancient Greeks. Int J Cardiol 2014;172:
13. Persaud TVN. Early history of human anatomy: from antiquity to 23-8.
the beginning of the modern era. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas; 22. Loukas M, Hanna M, Alsaiegh N, Shoja MM, Tubbs RS. Clinical
1984. anatomy as practiced by ancient Egyptians. Clin Anat 2011;24:409–
14. Acar F, Naderi S, Guvencer M, Ture U, Arda M. Herophilus of 15.
Chalcedeon: pioneer in neuroscience. Neurosurgery 2005;56:861-7. 23. Imai M. Herophilus of Chalcedon and the Hippocratic tradition in
15. Strkalj G, Chorn D. Herophilus of Chalcedon and the practice of early Alexandrian medicine. Hist Sci (Tokyo) 2011;21:103–22.
dissection in Hellenistic Alexandria. S Afr Med J 2008;98:86-9. 24. Smith CU. The triune brain in antiquity: Plato, Aristotle,
16. Potter P. Herophilus of Chalcedon: an assessment of his place in the Erasistratus. J Hist Neurosci 2010;19:1–14.
history of anatomy. Bull Hist Med 1976;50:45-60. 25. Wiltse LL, Pait TG. Herophilus of Alexandria (325-255 B. C.). The
17. von Staden H. Herophilus: the art of medicine in early Alexandria: father of anatomy. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 1998;23:1904–14.
edition, translation, and essays. Cambridge: Cambridge University 26. Wills A. Herophilus, Erasistratus, and the birth of neuroscience.
Press; 1989. Lancet 354:1719–20.

Online available at: Rafael Romero Reverón, MD

www.anatomy.org.tr Human Anatomy Department, J.M. Vargas School of Medicine,
doi:10.2399/ana.15.003 Universidad Central de Venezuela,
QR code:
Caracas, Venezuela
e-mail: [email protected]; [email protected]
Conflict of interest statement: No conflicts declared.

This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported (CC BY-NC-
ND3.0) Licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/) which permits unrestricted noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Please cite this article as: Romero RR. Herophilos, the great anatomist of antiquity. Anatomy
2015;9(2):108–111.

Anatomy • Volume 9 / Issue 2 / August 2015