Unit 1 1
Unit 1 1
Unit 1 1
CONTENTS
Part-1 : State in Ancient India : .......................... 1–2Q to 1–4Q
Evolutionary Theory,
Force theory, Mystical
Theory, Contract Theory,
Stages of State Formation
in Ancient India
PART-1
State in Ancient India : Evolutionary Theory, Force Theory, Mystical
Theory, Contract theory, Stages of state formation in ancient India.
Questions-Answers
Que 1.1. Give an account into the origin and evolution of the
state in ancient India.
OR
Write a short note on : Evolutionary theory.
OR
Write a short note on : Force theory.
OR
Write a short note on : Mystical theory.
OR
Write a short note on : Contract theory.
Answer
1. To look into the origin and evolution of the state has been one of the
greatest issues in political science.
2. Ancient Indian thinkers like Bhisma, Narada, Brihaspati, Kautilya,
Kamandaka also have looked at the problem.
3. On the basis of the writings of these thinkers we can detect following 4
important theories regarding the origin of the state in ancient India :
A. Evolutionary theory :
1. This is the oldest theory of the origin of the state in India and has been
mentioned in the Atharva Veda.
2. According to this theory the state is the result of evolutionary progress
and it didn’t originate at a fixed time.
3. On the basis of Atharva Veda several stages of the evolution of the state
can be traced.
4. According to Atharva Veda the earliest phase of human life was the
stage of vairajya or stateless state. It was a state of complete anarchy.
5. Subsequently, with the emergence of agriculture, stable life became
possible.
Indian Tradition, Culture & Society 1–3 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
6. To fulfill the needs of agricultural society the family emerged and the
head of the family became the first wielder of authority.
7. Further, the need of co-operation in the different realms of society led
to the emergence of sabha and samiti.
8. With the emergence of sabha and samiti organised political life began
which finally culminated in the emergence of the state.
B. Force theory :
1. Though ancient Indian political thinkers did not propound force theory
in a systematic way, force was considered to be an important factor in
the evolution of the state in India.
2. Earliest Aryan clans fought among themselves for pet animals (especially
for the cow), pastureland, settlements and sources of drinking water.
3. Only a strong and able warrior could lead the clan in such wars. So he
was given special status and the members of clan started obeying him.
4. This tendency continued in the days of peace also and subsequently the
leader became king.
C. Mystical theory :
1. This was the most popular theory of origin of the state in ancient India.
2. Kingship was given divine sanction and the king was considered not to
be the representative of God but himself a God.
3. It appears first in the epics and the law books of Manu, the king was
exalted far above ordinary mortals, through the magical powers of the
great royal sacrifices.
4. The magical power which pervaded the king at his consecration was
restored and strengthened in the course of his reign by further rites,
such as the ceremonial rejuvenation of the Vajapeya and the horse-
sacrifice (Asvamedha).
5. The viewpoint which supports the theory of divine origin of state in
ancient India has been widely criticised by Western as well as Indian
scholars.
D. Contract theory :
1. Contract theory is the most extensively discussed theory of the origin of
the state in ancient India.
2. The reference to contract theory can be seen in the Buddhist and
brahmanical texts and Arthashastra of Kautilya.
3. Many scholars accept only the Buddhist sources as the authentic source
of contract theory.
4. According to them the brahmanical texts have a mixture of contract and
divine origin whereas Buddhist sources give a clear cut account of
contract theory.
Society State & Polity in India 1–4 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
Answer
1. Six main stages in the history of ancient Indian polity can be identified.
2. The earliest stage was that of tribal military democracy in which tribal
assemblies, which had some place for women were mainly pre-occupied
with war. The age of Rig Veda was primarily a period of assemblies.
3. The second stage saw the break-up of the tribal polity under the stress
of constant conflicts between the rajanyakshatriya and the ordinary
businessman called the vis. The chiefs were helped by the priesthood
called the brahmins. This stage saw the beginning of taxes and classes or
varnas which came to be firmly established in the third stage.
4. The third stage was marked by the formation of the full-fledged
state. There arose large territorial monarchies of Kosala and Magadha
and tribal oligarchies in North-Western India and at the foot of the
Himalayas. For the first time large standing armies and organised
machinery were used for the collection of land revenue.
5. The fourth or the Maurya phase saw bureaucratic centralisation
based on the expanding economic activities of the state. The state with
the help of its bureaucracy controlled various aspects of the life of its
subjects.
6. The fifth stage was marked by the process of decentralised
administration in which towns, feudatories and military elements came
to the forefront in both the Deccan and North India. This was partly
neutralised by the emphasis on the divinity of the king.
7. The last stage, identical with the Gupta period, may be called the
period of proto-feudal polity. Land grants now played an important
part in the formation of the political structure and those made by the
Gupta feudatories conferred fiscal and administrative privileges on
priestly beneficiaries.
Indian Tradition, Culture & Society 1–5 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
PART-2
Kingship, Council of Ministers, Administration, Political Ideals in
Ancient India, Conditions’ of the Welfare of Societies, the
Seven Limbs of the State.
Questions-Answers
Answer
1. The king was the most important figure in the body politic.
2. In the Saptanga theory of the state, developed by Kautilya the king has
been described as the head or the most important organ of the state.
3. The king’s functions involved the protection not only of his kingdom
against external aggression, but also of life, property and traditional
custom against internal foes.
4. He protected the purity of class and caste by ensuring that those who
challenged the system were excommunicated.
5. He protected the family system by punishing adultery and ensuring the
fair inheritance of family property. He protected widows and orphans by
making them his wards.
6. He protected the rich against the poor by suppressing robbery, and he
protected the poor against the rich by punishing extortion and oppression.
7. Religion was protected by liberal grants to learned brahmins and temples
and frequently to heterodox sects also.
8. The ideal set before the king was one of energetic beneficence.
9. The Arthashastra puts forward the kingly duty in simple and forceful
language, setting an ideal which few ancient civilizations can boast of.
10. The ideal before the king in ancient India was that of being a chakravarti
meaning a king who ruled over the united vast territory of the Indian
subcontinent.
11. With the Mauryas this possibility was substantially realised, and was
incorporated into the Buddhist tradition and blended with later Vedic
imperialist ideas, then taken over by orthodox Hinduism.
Society State & Polity in India 1–6 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
12. The concept of the universal emperor was also known to the Jainas, and
in the epics numerous kings of legend, such as Yudhisthira and Rama,
are said to have been digvijayins or conquerors of all the four quarters.
13. The universal emperor was a divinely ordained figure with a special
place in the cosmic scheme, and as such was exalted to semi-divine
status.
Answer
1. Ministers or council of advisors have been regarded by ancient Indian
political thinkers as a very vital organ of the body politic.
2. The Ministerial Council was the chief administrative authority in the
kingdom. The king was supposed not to do anything without the consent
of the council.
3. Only men who possessed wisdom, purity of purpose, bravery and loyalty
were appointed as ministers. These ministers were no yes-men but
known for their integrity, leadership qualities and concern for the welfare
of the kingdom.
4. The size of this mantriparishad or council of ministers varied in the
figures ranging from seven to thirty-seven.
5. The body was divided into two parts mantrina and mantriparishad.
6. Mantriparishad was the large body resembling a modern council of
ministers. It consisted of all the ministers.
7. Mantrina was a smaller body or a core organisation within the
mantriparishad largely resembling the modern cabinet.
8. It included the few most important ministers like the purohita (priest),
senapati (supreme commander of army) and yuvaraja (the crown prince).
9. During the Mauryan period, the council’s purpose was primarily to advise
the king, and not to govern, but it was no mere rubber stamping body.
10. In fact, the council often exerted great powers. It might transact business
in the king’s absence.
Answer
1. With the advent of the Mauryas on the political stage of India,
bureaucracy developed as a well organised, hierarchical, cadre-based
administrative system.
2. This establishment of a large and complex bureaucracy was a
remarkable feature of the Mauryan government.
Indian Tradition, Culture & Society 1–7 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
Answer
1. Though India had no formal political philosophy, the science of
statecraft was much cultivated and a number of important textbooks
on this topic have survived.
2. In ancient India the political science was known by several terms like
the Rajadharma, Rajyasastra, Dandniti, Nitisastra and Arthasastra.
3. Monarchy was the normal form of the state and the science of politics
and government was therefore naturally called Rajadharma (duties of
the king) or Rajyasastra (science of the state).
4. Dandaniti explain that the ultimate sanction behind the state is force.
If it is not used, the alternative is the law of the jungle (matsyanyaya).
5. It is Danda (physical force or physical punishment) which rules over all
the subjects, it is Danda which protects them; when all else are sleeping,
Danda keeps awake; law is nothing but Danda itself. But it should be
wielded with discretion.
6. In Nitishastra, the term Niti is derived from the root ni meaning to
lead; Niti therefore means proper guidance or direction.
7. It was held that this would become possible by following ethical course
of conduct. Therefore one connotation of the term Nitishastra was the
science of ethics.
8. Thus it can be said that in the early stages of the development of the
science of polity, it was known as Rajadharma; Dandaniti became a
more popular term later and Arthasastra was suggested as an
alternative to it.
9. In course of time, however, the word Rajniti-sastra, abridged into
Nitisastra and became most popular.
Society State & Polity in India 1–8 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
10. From the Gupta period and the Middle Ages a number of political texts
survive, the most important of which are the Nitisara of Kamandaka,
the Nitivakyamrta of Somadeva Suri, and the Nitisaraattributed to the
ancient sage Shukra, but evidently of later medieval origin.
11. Besides these sources, there is a tremendous amount of Brahmin,
Jaina and Buddhist literature which deals on occasions with the politics
of the time.
Answer
1. According to the Hindu thought the purpose of government was not to
legislate, but only to administer the eternal law (sanatana dharma).
2. Buddha adapted the list of following conditions of the welfare of
republics to the circumstances of the Buddhist order :
i. Call frequent public assemblies.
ii. Meet in concord, conclude meetings in concord, and carry out
policies in concord.
iii. Make no laws not already promulgated, and set aside nothing
enacted in the past.
iv. Respect, esteem, reverence, and support the elders, and look on it
as a duty to heed their words.
v. No women or girls should be held by force or abducted.
vi. Respect, esteem, reverence, and support the shrines, whether in
town or country, and do not neglect the proper offerings and rites
laid down and practised in the past.
vii. Give due protection, deference, and support to the perfected beings
among them so that such perfected beings may come to the land
from afar and live comfortably.
Answer
Kautilya’s saptanga (seven organs) theory of state illustrates a novel dimension
of state power that dialectically engages artha and dharma respectively.
Kautilya enumerated seven prakritis or essential organs of the state. They
are as follow :
Indian Tradition, Culture & Society 1–9 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
PART-3
Society in Ancient India, Purusartha, Varnashrama System,
Ashrama or the Stages of Life, Marriage, Understanding Gender
as a Social Category, the Representation of Women in Historical
Traditions, Challenges Faced by Women, Four-class
Classification, Slavery.
Questions-Answers
Answer
1. Society in ancient India had several distinguishing features. It was
arranged in the form of four varnas.
Indian Tradition, Culture & Society 1–11 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
2. The life of individual was divided into four stages or ashramas. There
were rules regarding marriage, family etc.
3. The purpose of life was to attain four goals called purusarthas.
4. The concept of purusarthas is the fundamental principle of Indian social
ethics.
5. The word purusartha means “attainments” or “life purposes”.
6. The aim of every person is to attain the four noble ends or purusartha.
These four purusarthas are :
A. Dharma :
1. Dharma or the principle of righteousness is considered to be the supreme
of the purusarthas.
2. Dharma is derived from the Sanskrit root dhr, which connotes to sustain,
support or uphold. Dharma has a wide range of meaning.
3. It is the essential foundation of something or of things in general, and
thus signifies ‘truth’.
4. It is that which is established, customary, proper and therefore, means
‘traditional’ or ceremonial.
5. It is one’s duty, responsibility, imperative and thereby ‘moral obligation’.
6. It is that which is right, virtuous, meritorious, and accordingly ethical.
7. It is that which is required, precepted, or permitted through religious
authority, and thus legal.
8. Hence, dharma in ancient India was a code of conduct for members of
the society.
B. Artha :
1. Artha is the second purusartha.
2. The term artha refers to worldly prosperity or wealth. It includes all the
material means of life.
3. Kautilya maintains that wealth is the basis of human requirements and
that social well-being depends ultimately on material prosperity.
4. Indian thinkers had recognised the pursuit of wealth as a legitimate
human aspiration. But artha must be acquired by right means.
C. Kama :
1. Kama means worldly pleasures or sensual pleasures.
2. It refers to some of the innate desires and urges in human beings.
3. In the narrow sense kama means sexual pleasure but in the wider
sense it involves sexual, emotional and aesthetic life all together.
Society State & Polity in India 1–12 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
D. Moksha :
1. It is the ultimate purusartha.
2. Moksha means salvation or liberation from the cycle of birth and death.
3. It is the summum bonum of human existence.
Answer
Answer
3. The individual pursues wealth (artha) and pleasure (kama) within the
limits of the moral law (dharma).
C. Vanaprasthasharma or the Stage of Retirement from Active
Life :
1. After discharging all the duties and obligations as a householder, the
individual enters into the Vanaprastha stage.
2. It consists of the third quarter of person’s life.
3. In this phase, after retiring from active life, the individual dedicates
himself to a life of spiritual contemplation.
4. He leaves his home and goes to the forest to become a hermit.
D. Sanyasashrama or the Stage of Renunciation :
1. This is the last stage of life.
2. Now the individual leaves his hermitage and becomes a homeless
wanderer (sanyasin) with all his earthly ties broken.
3. The sanyasin aspires and acts to attain liberation only.
Answer
Answer
10. All these ideas emerged between 5th century BCE and 5th century CE,
and were explored in the following centuries.
11. Ancient Indian gender studies were designed to appreciate the diversity
of nature, as well as to identify those who could become monks, outgrow
sexual desire and liberate themselves from all karma.
Answer
Answer
C. The learned : The learned, such as the philosopher, the physician, the
arithmetician, the geometrician, the astronomer, who resemble water.
From their pen and their wisdom, a river rises in the drought of the
world, and the garden of the creation receives from their irrigating
powers, a peculiar freshness.
D. Husbandmen and labourers : Husbandmen and labourers, who
may be compared to earth. By their exertions, the staple of life is
brought to perfection, and strength and happiness flow from their
work.
3. It is obligatory for a king to put each of these in its proper place, and by
uniting personal ability with due respect for others, to cause the world
to flourish.
Answer
1. The term that is most often used to refer to a slave in ancient Indian
texts is dasa.
2. This term may have been derived from the word “das” which means to
finish or terminate something.
3. It was associated with slaves because their work was to finish various
jobs.
4. During the Rig Vedic Period, the word dasa did not have the same
connotation. However, the term was used to denote a slave by the Later
Vedic Age.
5. Slaves were considered to be some form of objects and there were
instances where they were listed as gift items.
6. Their work was primarily associated with domestic chores but they
could also be used as helpers for agriculture.
7. Since they were normally equated with other objects that were used
communally, they could have also been viewed as property of the whole
tribe.
8. Slaves are believed to have held a lower position than even the Shudras.
9. In the Mauryan Empire slavery was a well-established and accepted
institution.
10. It had approximately eight or nine categories of slaves.
Society State & Polity in India 1–18 Q (NCC-Sem-5 & 6)
11. Slaves brought from another country, children of women slaves, slaves
who were purchased, prisoners of war, slaves who were inherited, slaves
received as presents, those who sold themselves as slaves, those who
were mortgaged and criminals whose punishment for their offence was
to serve as a slave.
12. Debts continued to remain one of the reasons behind slavery.
13. Complexities in the types of slaves only grew with the Gupta Period.
There were fifteen types of slaves present.
14. However, the slaves were not exploited and there were chances for a
slave to get manumission.