Call To Order Pledge of Allegiance Invocation.: December 10, 2008
Call To Order Pledge of Allegiance Invocation.: December 10, 2008
Call To Order Pledge of Allegiance Invocation.: December 10, 2008
Also present:
oooooOooooo
CALL TO ORDER
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
INVOCATION.
oooooOooooo
APPROVAL OF MINUTES.
oooooOooooo
oooooOooooo
TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT.
The Board heard Mr. Komara’s report on the activities of the Transportation
Department including the following:
• North Main Street (Route 42) and Mt. Crawford Avenue (Route 1310) in
Bridgewater – traffic signal is working
• Bergton Road (Route 820) – digging shell which is a good winter job
• Kerns Road (Route 731) – replacing bridge with a new box culvert
• Peake Mountain Road (Route 612) – fixing bridge
• Cutting brush and preparing for inclement weather
------
Mr. Komara requested the Board approve adding two roads in the Cloverdale
Subdivision to the Virginia Department of Transportation’s secondary system of state
highways.
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, the streets described below are shown on plats recorded in the
Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of Rockingham County, and
------
that he would like to put “old fashioned” chevrons through the curve, but will ask the
traffic engineer for other recommendations. Supervisor Breeden noted there has been
another accident at that location and asked if the speed limits can be altered since this
is an industrial road. Mr. Komara said the speed limits can be changed and he will
look into this.
Supervisor Eberly noted there is a dangerous curve on Green Hill Road going
into Singers Glen, where there may be enough shoulder to widen the pavement. Mr.
Komara will determine if the road can be widened without environmentally impacting
an old ice house at the curve.
oooooOooooo
oooooOooooo
Supervisor Cuevas stated that while the County is certainly concerned with the
protection of the watersheds, it is also important to protect the rights of the general
public to use the forest. He is concerned that some groups may be trying to create
additional wilderness-designated areas, which the County has previously noted it does
not support. He noted some parts of the original resolution contradict recreational uses
of the forest. He wants to make sure that the definition of “disturbing ground” is one
in which all parties can agree.
December 10, 2008 (4)
Supervisor Kyger commended Mr. Burge and the Forest Service on their land
management practices. He explained that a well-managed forest is beneficial because
the County relies somewhat on funds from timber sales and taxes from those sales. He
stated it is both his personal philosophy and the Board’s philosophy that the Forest be
accessible for many uses.
Supervisor Kyger stated the County’s silence regarding the resolution may be
perceived by the Forest Service as approval of practices the County does not approve.
Since a large portion of the watersheds involve the County, he thinks it is important for
the County to make a statement.
Supervisor Cuevas agreed that no action may be viewed as not caring about the
issue, which may be worse than adopting the resolution. Since the Board is
comfortable with the wording of the revised resolution, Supervisor Cuevas said he
would like it to reflect the County’s position, rather than duplicate resolutions
approved by other jurisdictions.
Carroll Dickenson from the Shenandoah Valley Sportsman’s Alliance said the
Virginia Sportsman’s Alliance was very concerned about the original resolution.
While clean water matters seem appealing, he said the original resolution looked like a
precursor to the Wilderness Act which will limit usage and projects such as wind
turbines in the National Forest. He said many people use the George Washington
National Forest (70% visit to see wildlife and 30% use wilderness-designated areas).
WHEREAS, the U.S. Forest Service is in the process of revising its 1993 Land
and Resource Management Plan for the George Washington National Forest; and
WHEREAS, one of the six goals identified in the U.S. Forest Services’ agency-
wide strategic plan is to “Improve watershed condition”; and
WHEREAS, the availability of clean, safe drinking water is one of the primary
benefits that the George Washington National Forest provides to the communities that
surround it; and
WHEREAS, the watersheds of surface waters that flow from the George
Washington National Forest, such as the North River and the North and South Forks of
the Shenandoah River, also provide a source for drinking water to residents in the
communities of Bridgewater, Broadway, Elkton and Harrisonburg and surrounding
Rockingham County; and
• The U.S. Forest Service identify the watersheds serving the Switzer Lake
reservoir and the surface water resources within the George Washington
National Forest that feed the North River and South and North Forks of the
Shenandoah River;
• The U.S. Forest Service establish management objectives that support the
health of the drinking watershed and which encourage conditions within the
watershed that maintain, protect and enhance drinking water quality;
December 10, 2008 (6)
• The U.S. Forest Service continue to permit ground disturbing activities in these
areas; however, such activities shall be properly managed and controlled by the
Forest Service to protect the health of the watershed;
• The U.S. Forest Service communicate in a timely manner with the localities
that obtain drinking water from sources within the George Washington
National Forest to ensure that the drinking watersheds are managed effectively,
appropriately and for the public good;
• The U.S. Forest Service shall work with local communities, agencies and the
larger public to establish policies and develop management plans for the
drinking watersheds to properly maintain, protect and enhance drinking water
quality.
------
oooooOooooo
approved support for their half of funding with a moral obligation to back the
financing, Mr. Campbell said.
RESOLUTION
IN REGARD TO
SHENANDOAH VALLEY REGIONAL AIRPORT COMMISSION
WHEREAS, the Commission shall issue the Local Obligation to finance the
Project (including an interim financing therefor, if required), pursuant to the terms and
conditions of the Financing Agreement and as otherwise may be necessary or
convenient in connection with requirements by Virginia Resources Authority (“VRA”)
for long-term financing of the Project under the Virginia Airport Revolving Fund (or
any other applicable financing program administered or otherwise offered from time to
time by VRA).
WHEREAS, the Commission desires that the governing bodies of the Member
Localities approve the incurrence of indebtedness by the Commission in connection
with the Project, subject to the determination of the final terms and provisions therefor
(all such undertakings by the Commission, including any interim financing therefor, if
necessary, being collectively referenced herein as the “Loan”).
4. The Chairman and Vice Chairman of the Board, and the County
Administrator, any one or more of whom may act, and such officers, employees, and
agents of the County as any of them may designate, are each authorized and directed to
take all such further actions and to execute and deliver any and all instruments,
certificates and other documents (including but not limited to the Support Agreement)
in order to carry out the purposes hereof and in furtherance, otherwise, of the financing
by the Commission of the Project (including an interim financing therefor, if required).
SUPPORT AGREEMENT 1
1This form of Support Agreement has been drafted for the long‐term financing of the Project to be provided
by Virginia Resources Authority (VRA). Therefore, appropriate changes would be needed in the event the
Commission also shall require a short‐term loan for the Project in anticipation of its receipt of such long‐
term monies from VRA.
December 10, 2008 (9)
RECITALS
WHEREAS, the Commission shall issue the Local Obligation to finance the
Project pursuant to the terms and conditions of the Financing Agreement and as
otherwise may be required by VRA under the Virginia Airport Revolving Fund (or any
other applicable financing program administered or otherwise offered by VRA); and
WHEREAS, all other remaining Member Localities also have duly adopted
resolutions in support of the Project; and
AGREEMENT
2. The Commission shall use its best efforts to issue the Local Obligation
and use the proceeds thereof to pay the costs of the Project in accordance with the
terms of the Financing Agreement. The Commission shall construct and place the
Project in operation at the earliest practical date.
December 10, 2008 (10)
Augusta - 50%
Rockingham - 50%
4. No later than March 15 of each year, beginning March 15, 2009, the
Commission shall notify the Augusta Board and the Rockingham Board of their
respective Proportional Share of the amount, if any, by which the Commission
reasonably expects its revenues to be insufficient to pay (i) the debt service obligations
under the Financing Agreement and the Local Obligation, (ii) the operation and
maintenance expenses for SVRA, in full, as and when due, and (iii) any other
payments due and owing by the Commission under the Financing Agreement (the
“Additional Payments”) in full, as and when due, during the fiscal year of Augusta and
Rockingham, respectively, each beginning the following July 1 (such aggregate
deficiency amount of the Commission’s revenues being referenced herein as the
“Annual Deficiency Amount”).
If the Augusta Board shall fail to make such appropriation, the County
Administrator shall add the amount of such requested appropriation to the Proportional
December 10, 2008 (11)
Share reported to Augusta by its County Administrator for the next fiscal year.
Likewise, if the Rockingham Board shall fail to make such appropriation, the County
Administrator shall add the amount of such requested appropriation to the Proportional
Share reported to Rockingham by its County Administrator for the next fiscal year.
7. The Augusta Board and the Rockingham Board each hereby undertake
a non-binding obligation to appropriate their respective Proportional Share as may be
requested from time to time pursuant to Sections 5 and 6 above, to the fullest degree
and in such manner as is consistent with the Constitution and laws of the
Commonwealth of Virginia.
The Augusta Board and the Rockingham Board, each while recognizing
that it is not empowered to make any binding commitment to make such appropriations
in future fiscal years, hereby states its intent to make such appropriations in future
fiscal years, and hereby recommends that future Boards of Supervisors of Augusta and
Rockingham, respectively, do likewise.
Any party hereto may designate any other address for notices or
requests by giving notice.
10. It is the intent of the parties hereto that this Support Agreement shall be
governed by the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia.
11. This Support Agreement shall remain in full force and effect until the
Local Obligation and all other amounts payable by the Commission, if any, under any
authorizing resolution and any other documentation in connection with the Project and
the Local Obligation, including but not limited to the Financing Agreement, have been
paid, in full.
oooooOooooo
The Board received and reviewed Administrator Paxton’s staff report dated
December 5, 2008.
------
Supervisor Kyger indicated some organizations will be very happy with this
program but a few will be hesitant to proceed. He said EMS calls are a rapidly-
growing part of the budget and localities that bill for services have noted reduced
demand. Supervisor Kyger stated this needs to be examined as a regional program
because if Augusta County adopts the program and Rockingham County does not, it
would be difficult on Rockingham County agencies providing services in Augusta
County. A regional RFP may leverage a better proposal and may lead to a regional
management approach, Supervisor Kyger said.
Since the County receives heavy support from garages that maintain fire trucks
and citizens who donate money on a regular basis, Supervisor Eberly said the County
needs to ensure this program does not discourage donations.
Supervisor Breeden said he hopes this program will allow volunteers to spend
more time running calls rather than fundraising.
Supervisor Kyger stated money paid for insurance premiums rather than tax
dollars will supplement EMS calls.
Supervisor Eberly stated volunteers can provide more economical service to the
County.
Administrator Paxton explained that the Board does not need to determine
whether they are in favor of this program at this time. Board action is required to
move forward with an RFP to obtain additional information about third party billing
for EMS calls so the Board can decide whether to pursue billing for emergency
services.
Supervisor Kyger noted that many agencies currently bill for services. He
anticipates that in the next five years 80-90% of Virginia emergency service agencies
will bill for their services. West Virginia and North Carolina already bill for
emergency services by state legislative action. He said the results of the RFP will
provide information regarding how the system works. Supervisor Kyger does not
anticipate competition between agencies due to the use of central dispatch.
Supervisor Eberly would like to have flexibility for the agencies to decide
whether to charge nuisance callers.
Supervisor Cuevas stated the issue was complex. The next step has to be an
educational process to understand how this billing program works. He said fire and
rescue are indispensible community services.
Supervisor Breeden asked that Chief Symons make sure the volunteer agencies
know the Board is soliciting for an RFP and is not moving to a pay-for-service system
at this time.
Supervisor Kyger reported that a fire department in his district requested 24-
hour, 7-day a week coverage and is looking for ways to raise money to provide this
service.
------
oooooOooooo
oooooOooooo
oooooOooooo
oooooOooooo
oooooOooooo
The Board received and reviewed Mr. Heidt’s staff report dated December 10,
2008, which stated the following:
oooooOooooo
The Board received and reviewed Mr. Vaughn’s staff report dated December
10, 2008, which included a commercial zoning districts ordinance revision to the
Zoning Ordinance, a summary of special-use permit and rezoning requests, and a
Comprehensive Plan Amendment.
oooooOooooo
The Board received and reviewed Mr. O’Byrne’s staff report dated December
4, 2008, which included updates on Phase 2 of the Perceptive Software/Image Now
content management software implementation, Windows XP desktop operating system
December 10, 2008 (15)
conversions, Windows server migration, remote access software, e-mail archiving, and
Intranet portal development.
oooooOooooo
The Board received and reviewed Chief Symons staff report dated December 1,
2008, which included personnel issues and a summary of the activities of the Training,
Prevention, and Public Education divisions, the Assistant Chief of Administration/
Emergency Medical Officer and Assistant Chief of Operations.
oooooOooooo
The Board received and reviewed Mr. Eberly’s staff report dated December 5,
2008, which included personnel issues, facilities maintenance, and recreation
programs.
oooooOooooo
APPOINTMENTS.
------
oooooOooooo
RABIES CLINIC.
oooooOooooo
December 10, 2008 (16)
Registrar Douglas Geib reported that the 2008 general election was successful
with 77% of registered County voters participating. This was not a significant increase
as the County has historically had an active voter turnout. The number of absentee
voters (2,236) was substantially higher than other presidential elections and Mr. Geib
expects that number will continue to grow. He reported that five of the largest
precincts used electronic pollbooks for the first time, which went well after some early
morning glitches were resolved. 219 election officers covered 29 precincts and four
additional employees were hired during the last several weeks prior to the election.
The cost for the election was $66,243.07 or $1.98 per voter.
In the future, Mr. Geib would like to increase the use of electronic pollbooks
and expand the County’s voting website.
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
ELECTORS FOR
PRESIDENT AND VICE PRESIDENT
OF THE UNITED STATES
Democratic Party for Electors for Barack Obama, President and Joe Biden, Vice President
Republican Party for Electors for John McCain, President and Sarah Palin, Vice President
Independent Green Party for Electors for Chuck Baldwin, President and Darrell L. Castle, Vice President
Craig E. Ennis Sherman D. Witcher Glenda Gail Parker David William Gillis, Jr.
D. C. Amarasinghe Joseph L. LeBlanc George R. Wood Carey C. Campbell
William K. Grogan Brian Taylor Harlan Fred Wahlert Mario T. Palmiotto
Albert P. Burckard, Jr.
Libertarian Party for Electors for Bob Barr, President and Wayne A. Root, Vice President
Green Party for Electors for Cynthia McKinney, President and Rosa Clemente, Vice President
Independent for Electors for Ralph Nader, President and Matt Gonzalez, Vice President
Ashley Elizabeth Slaff Jeffrey C. Mitchell Henry A. Perretta Michael Joseph Smith
Adrienne Nicole Cottle Raymond W. Fary Matthew Lee Alley Dena May Cottle
Nicholas William Johnson Michael Lee Ogilvie Daniel J. Christakos Rickey Ray Johnson
Erick W. Brucker
WRITE-INS CERTIFICATION
Electors for President and Vice President
Rockingham
; COUNTY CITY November 4, 2008 General Election
1. Invalid Write-Ins 65
2. Valid Write-Ins 0
3. Total Write-Ins 65
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
MEMBER
UNITED STATES SENATE
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
cast in the County of Rockingham_________, Virginia,
at the November 4, 2008 General Election, for:
MEMBER
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
6TH District
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
COMMISSIONER OF REVENUE
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
cast in the Town of Bridgewater in the County of Rockingham , Virginia,
at the November 4, 2008 General Election, for:
MAYOR
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
MEMBER
TOWN COUNCIL
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
cast in the Town of Dayton in the County of Rockingham , Virginia,
at the November 4, 2008 General Election, for:
MAYOR
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
L. J. Purcell 413
MEMBER
TOWN COUNCIL
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
cast in the Town of Elkton in the County of Rockingham , Virginia,
at the November 4, 2008 General Election, for:
MAYOR
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
MEMBER
TOWN COUNCIL
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
WRITE-INS CERTIFICATION
1. Invalid Write-Ins 31
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
MAYOR
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
MEMBER
TOWN COUNCIL
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
MAYOR
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
MEMBER
TOWN COUNCIL
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
cast in the Town of Timberville in the County of Rockingham , Virginia,
at the November 4, 2008 General Election, for:
MAYOR
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
MEMBER
TOWN COUNCIL
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
NAMES OF CANDIDATES AS PRINTED ON BALLOT (IN FIGURES)
ABSTRACT OF VOTES
TOTAL VOTES
RECEIVED
(IN FIGURES)
YES 15,079
NO 17,122
oooooOooooo
COMMITTEE REPORTS.
The Board heard the following committee reports from staff and Board
members:
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
Supervisor Eberly asked Board members to let the Deputy Clerks know if they
plan to attend the Chamber of Commerce Banquet on January 7, 2009.
FINANCE
Revenue Adjustment:
General Fund
E911 Communications
A transfer of $1,817,999 from the E911 Fund to the General Fund which represents the
fund reserve of the E911 Fund at June 30, 2008. This request was made because the
E911 Fund was no longer a special revenue fund and the activity was absorbed by the
General Fund.
-----
Supervisor Cuevas reported that the Clerk of the Court requested money be
refunded to the State for the unused portion of a grant.
Reimbursement of funds to the Library of Virginia that were received on May 26,
2004. The funds were for a reformatting grant, but the Library of Virginia will have
this reformatting done in-house.
PUBLIC WORKS
of a CAT 301.8C Mini Hydraulic Excavator for $30,600 from Carter Machinery
through the NJPA nationwide contract with the understanding that final authorization
of this purchase and a grant fund reimbursement commitment will be obtained from
USDA prior to placing the order.
SOCIAL SERVICES
Supervisor Breeden reported that the Saturday with Santa Christmas gift
program was expanded to 800 children (150 more than last year).
Supervisor Kyger noted that he met with the Governor’s Assistant Suzette
Denslow and Virginia Municipal League representatives regarding pending additional
budget cuts by the Governor. He, Supervisor Cuevas and Administrator Paxton helped
the two groups draft resolutions regarding budget cuts. The projected budget cuts over
the bi-annium are $3.5 billion ($1 billion during the current year). He further indicated
state and local obligations will be handled differently in the future. There will be
major cuts in K-12 education, the Sheriff’s department, public safety money and for
Constitutional Officers.
Administrator Paxton stated he and Supervisor Kyger will attend the National
Association of Counties (NACo) Legislative Meeting in Washington, DC in March.
He asked that other Board members who would like to attend inform him as soon as
possible.
oooooOooooo
oooooOooooo
At 7:00 p.m., Chairman Floyd opened the meeting and informed the public that
the following amendment to the Comprehensive Plan was withdrawn.
CP08-01 Valley Engineering, Surveying, and Planning, Inc., 3231 Peoples Drive,
Harrisonburg, to amend the Comprehensive Plan’s Conceptual Land
Use Plan map regarding tax parcels 124-(A)- L121, L98, and L119 and
125-(3)- L2. The amendment proposes redesignating a 283-acre area;
located north and south of Osceola Springs Road, east and west of
Pleasant Valley Road, and west of Spaders Church Road; from
Industrial and Agricultural Reserve to Community Residential.
oooooOooooo
December 10, 2008 (26)
At 7:01 p.m., Chairman Floyd declared the meeting open for a public hearing
on the following rezoning request which Ms. Henderson reviewed.
Paula Figgatt from Shenandoah Mobile Company stated this tower will provide
cell phone coverage through the Massanutten area, particularly the water park. The
stealth flagpole will be 80 feet tall.
-----
At 7:05 p.m., Chairman Floyd closed the public hearing and called the regular
meeting to order.
-----
oooooOooooo
At 7:06 p.m., Chairman Floyd declared the meeting open for a public hearing
on the following special-use permit applications. Ms. Stultz reviewed each request.
Bill Rogers from Solaya explained that Solaya, Inc. is working in cooperation
with a group of landowners who are requesting the tower be put up to measure wind
speed and direction. After one year, when data is obtained, the tower will be removed
from the site.
December 10, 2008 (27)
Chris Bolgiano, the Fulks Run Ruritan Club reporter for the North Fork Journal,
expressed concern that this wind turbine is a step toward a full industrial wind
installation. Ms. Bolgiano stated the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service is opposed to wind
turbines due to their effect on wildlife. She pointed out that Highland County spent
five years discussing a wind proposal with similar issues. She hopes the Board will
familiarize themselves with the Virginia State Corporation Commission regulations and
use their guidelines for responsible wind turbines. If approved, she also hopes the
County will place the following conditions on the applicant: obtain all relevant permits,
allow agencies access to the tower, follow post-construction wildlife monitoring
procedures, and have a decommissioning fund at the end of the tower’s life cycle to
remove the turbine and foundation which consists of hundreds of tons of concrete. She
stated there should be public input into the drafting of a County wind ordinance as
many people do not want them on National Forest land due to land destruction, and a
detailed site plan should be required from the applicant. She also stated with no
property tax collected on National Forest land, there is no mechanism for communities
to share in the revenue. Ms. Bolgiano stated Dr. Nina Pierpont, author of Wind Turbine
Syndrome, recommends a setback of at least two miles from residences or schools due
to noise from turbines.
Kim Sandum indicated she does not have a problem with this tower but she is
concerned this may be a precursor to other wind projects and urged the Board to be
prepared for a larger wind project. The County currently only has zoning for small
wind turbines and is drafting a new ordinance. Ms. Sandum previously provided
Community Development with a draft ordinance developed by a land planner working
for the Shenandoah Valley Network. She stated the best wind sites in Virginia are off
the coast. In a November 16, 2007 letter, a federal agency expressed concerns on
impacts on wildlife and listed several species of concern, said Ms. Sandum.
Supervisor Cuevas informed Mr. Miles that several Board members and staff
spent a day at Mount Storm with Dominion Power and spoke with some of the local
residents and landowners where towers were placed. Supervisor Cuevas also attended
three meetings of different companies regarding wind turbines. County staff has been
in contact with officials where wind towers are in operation and are reviewing their
ordinances. He noted this is a serious issue since it appears the new administration will
emphasize alternative sources of energy.
-----
December 10, 2008 (28)
S08-48 Lincoln Homestead Farm, Inc., 7884 Harpine Highway, Linville, for a
residence involving a non-family division on property located on the
east side of Harpine Highway (Route 42) approximately 1/4 mile
northeast of Williamsburg Road (Route 782); Election District #2;
Zoned A-1; Tax Map #65-(A)-19.
Ms. Stultz presented a letter from Phillip C. Stone, President of the Lincoln
Society, which states “The Society has reached an agreement, conditioned on the
ability to get the property divided, to take an option on the parcel containing the
Lincoln Homestead and family cemetery for a period of up to two years.” During the
two years, the Society will pursue funding to acquire, restore and maintain the Lincoln
Homestead as a museum.
Ms. Stultz informed the Board that the cemetery is on a separate parcel of land
with a separate tax map number in the middle of the remaining acreage. Ms. Stultz
and the Shank family believe the Shanks are the owners of the cemetery plot but land
records indicate the cemetery landowner resides on Turleytown Road. A letter sent to
the address on record was returned. According to Ms. Stultz, dividing 10 acres off
from the parent tract would allow a dwelling to be built on the remaining 41 acres.
She explained that the house and acreage could be handled as an adjoining transfer
without a special-use permit. If the Society is unable to raise the necessary funds
during the two-year option period, and the division has been done, the house and 10
acres can be sold to anyone.
Supervisor Kyger stated that restricting the use of the property from what it can
currently be used for can be considered a “taking” of the property.
Richard Shank, part owner of the Lincoln Homestead, stated the home is a
Virginia Historical Property. The Shank family thought they owned the cemetery until
they found out it is listed under a different address. This is the Lincoln family
cemetery and two of Lincoln’s slaves are also buried there.
Kathie See from KlineMay Realty, who is working with the Shank family,
indicated the family would like the property to remain historical but it is a big project
for an individual to purchase the land and renovate the home. She said new legislation
was passed making grants available for the restoration of Presidential properties.
County Attorney Miller stated the reason for the special-use permit is that this
property is zoned A-1 and to be subdivided, unless a residence is already on both
parcels, both the new parcel and remaining parcel require special-use permits be
issued. The fact that this is a historical house has no bearing on the request so there are
no conditions regarding the historical nature of the property.
December 10, 2008 (29)
Ms. Stultz explained that the property can be divided for a family member or as
an adjoining transfer at any time without requiring Board approval. If either property
does not contain a house, a non-family request has to come before the Board. If there
was currently a house on both properties, the owner would not need to come before the
Board.
-----
S08-49 Dean and Kim Withers, 18012 New Market Road, Timberville, for a
residence involving a non-family division on property located on the
south side of New Market Road (Route 211) approximately 1,800 feet
east of Henkel Lane (private); Election District #1; Zoned A-2; Tax
Map #41-(A)-74A.
Ms. Stultz provided Board members with a note of opposition from Daniel
Bender indicating he thought the County was discouraging rural development.
Kathie See from KlineMay Realty spoke on behalf of the Withers. This request
is on A-1 land which adjoins A-2 property and three small tracts along the road which
are zoned A-1. Ms. See noted the small A-2 tract is not prime agricultural land as it is
wooded and hilly. If the Withers want to build a house on this property in the future, a
special-use permit would be required. This land is not suitable to be a working farm.
She stated the Withers want to sell this tract of land due to family health issues.
Mike Pugh asked for support for Mr. and Mrs. Withers because they are
making this request due to very serious health issues.
-----
S08-50 Fox Run Farms, L.L.C., 825 Chapel Hill Lane, Weyers Cave, for
biodiesel production not to exceed 1,500 gallons per day for private use
and commercial wholesale on property located at 1936 Cecil Wampler
Road, Mt. Crawford, on the south side of Cecil Wampler Road (Route
704) approximately 1,500 feet west of Pleasant Valley Road (Route
679); Election District #3; Zoned A-2; Tax Map #124C-(A)-34 and
#124C-(A)-35.
Ms. Stultz noted that the applicant obtained a special-use permit to convert the
feed mill to a commercial feed mill earlier this year and the fire marshal had some
issues with the site plan submitted at that time. If this request is approved, another site
plan will be submitted. The soybeans used will be grown elsewhere and brought to the
property. A special-use permit goes with the land and Mr. Heatwole may not always
be the owner of the property. The building code requires handicapped rest rooms so he
would need to get septic approval and install restrooms in one of the business
buildings.
The applicant, Ian Heatwole, indicated the request will benefit the public
because he will process crops grown on his farm into higher-value products, provide
similar processing services for other farmers, expand marketing options for locally-
produced oil seeds and provide an opportunity for alternative oil seeds to be grown
locally. Mr. Heatwole stated this project is a green infrastructure and the limited size
of the operation substantiates the requisite to decentralize processing operations by
using local products that return back to the local community and eliminate shipping. It
is important to “Buy fresh, buy local” for the feed energy used to grow the produce,
Mr. Heatwole said.
Mr. Heatwole is currently using the site to process grains grown on his farm
into cattle feed. He highlighted the operation and his proposed use for this mill. A
mill has been in operation on this property for over 120 years. He stated that at one
December 10, 2008 (30)
time there were 40 mills in the area but this is the only one remaining in the County.
There will be no operational changes and the character of the site will not change
substantially. Mr. Heatwole requested that condition #4 requiring a handicapped
accessible restroom in one of the business buildings be removed. Mr. Heatwole said
when the special-use permit for the mill was approved in May 2008, the Health
Department had no problem with a restroom in Mr. Heatwole’s house serving the one
employee. He stated the benefit of an ordinance that allows him to seek this permit
was agreed upon by Board members who traveled to Bassett, Virginia, to visit Red
Birch Energy Inc.’s biodiesel site. Mr. Heatwole stated he has worked cooperatively
with the Board and staff to bring appropriate scale biodiesel and biofuel production to
the Valley.
In response to a question from Supervisor Cuevas, Ms. Stultz said the first
special-use permit indicated Mr. Heatwole must meet the Statewide Building Code. It
did not specifically address the handicapped-accessible restroom.
Mr. Heatwole said he thought the first permit stated the bathroom in the house
could serve the business.
Anthony Beery, a farmer and current owner of the mill, is excited about the
possibility of producing fuel and feed locally. He has a supply of soybeans but no
market for them, so this mill would expand his options. Soybeans are a good crop
rotation with corn. He emphasized that this mill is not only for Mr. Heatwole’s private
use but for use by other farmers. Mr. Beery noted farming is very capital intensive so
developing a site to help other farmers makes economic sense, and the negative impact
of odor or noise to the surrounding area is minimal. The mill would provide farmers
with more options so he urged to the Board to approve this request.
Steve Boyle stated that he lives 150 feet east of the mill and he disagreed that
there is minimal pollution because there is a lot of noise and dust pollution, as well as
particulate matter. He expressed concern about the impact this mill will have on the
residential area. Mr. Boyle stated he had done research on biodiesel fuel and provided
several articles to the Board regarding the hazards of biodiesel fuel production. One
article he referred to stated that production of biodiesel fuel produces less air pollution,
but must be done in areas zoned for industrial uses because flammable fluids are
produced. He stated that the article, “Getting Serious about Safety” indicates
production can be dangerous and should be treated like any other chemical process
which can cause fires or explosions. Safety can be compromised in smaller plants
trying to produce at minimal costs. He noted that this mill burned to the ground 12 to
15 years ago and was rebuilt. Mr. Boyle said the mill smells like burnt popcorn and
December 10, 2008 (31)
nauseates him. He asked that the production of biofuels not be allowed in the
residential area.
Dick Wettstone, a resident near the mill, indicated he supports farmers and
alternative fuel production, but he was concerned about the location of the mill.
According to his research, the fuel should be produced in an industrial zone or isolated
area. Mr. Wettstone expressed concern about water contamination, fire hazards, odor
and air pollution. He asked the Board to consider this request carefully due to the risks
involved in this process in a residential area.
Frank Johnson, who lives directly across the road from Steve Boyle, said he
was concerned about fire hazards and he currently endures dust and odors. He said this
production can be very dangerous if not handled properly and if there is an explosion
during high winds, homes could be lost.
-----
Ms. Stultz reported this request was the result of a zoning violation and
numerous complaints to the Zoning Administrator and the Sheriff’s Office.
Supervisor Eberly disclosed that he lives 4/10 of a mile from this property,
leases land for a cattle operation 100 yards from this property, and frequents Deavers
Lane to check on his cattle. Supervisor Eberly stated he is a distant neighbor, not an
adjoining neighbor, and is able to participate in the transaction fairly, objectively, and
in the public interest under Virginia Code 2.2-3114(G).
The applicant stated she has a temporary lease that expires May 1, 2009.
Although she has a kennel license which allows 20 dogs, she has 15 dogs and no
puppies. Ms. Hartuniewicz reported her dogs are show dogs and this is not a
commercial kennel. Since the kennels are 12 feet from the five-foot allowance from
the road, they are in compliance. The special-use permit summary states the property
has no building to house the dogs at night or during inclement weather, but Ms.
Hartuniewicz stated she brings the dogs in between 8:00 p.m. and 9:00 p.m. each night
and encloses them in crates on the porch with heat lamps to keep them warm. She
walks the dogs each morning and places them in kennels which are cleaned twice a day
with a mild mixture of ammonia or bleach. In regard to complaints, Ms. Hartuniewicz
stated the Sheriff’s Office received two complaints (9/23/08 and 10/8/08). After the
second complaint she purchased bark collars that the dogs wear daily. Since the
kennels are 12 feet from Deavers Lane, runoff from washing the cages should not be
an issue. The kennels are more than 45 feet from the closest property. She said a
veterinarian who visits at least twice a month told her the dogs are healthy and is
willing to supply a letter regarding care of the dogs.
Robert Deavers stated he came to the meeting with his 81 year-old father and
other neighbors who are concerned their wells will be affected by bleach and ammonia
going into the ground. Mr. Deavers has lived there 58 years and stated it was a quiet
neighborhood until last summer when neighbors could not put their windows up or sit
on their decks. Mr. Deavers indicated his father’s front door is 75 feet from where Ms.
Hartuniewicz walks the dogs and there is an odor. He presented a video tape of the
dogs barking after Ms. Hartuniewicz purchased the bark collars. Mr. Deavers said he
and his father would ask the Board to deny this request.
Ron White, a previous neighbor, sold a house trailer near Ms. Hartuniewicz.
He drove by recently and was shocked as the dogs were “yapping” the entire 15
minutes he was there. He expressed concern about property values and tax revenues in
the area.
Gloria McDonaldson noted that her father-in-law owned the house next door to
Ms. Hartuniewicz which she inherited. She plans to keep the well-maintained house as
a rental property but has been unable to rent it with a kennel next door. She stated the
house has been vacant since July.
December 10, 2008 (32)
Ms. Hartuniewicz responded that the neighbors have never complained to her.
She said she could bring the dogs in when someone comes to look at the rental
property next door. She keeps the lot clean and stated she will only be there four more
months. Regarding the dogs barking in the video, she stated it is a dog’s nature to bark
if a stranger comes on the property. She removes the bark collars during the day.
-----
S08-52 Jimmie L. Ritchie, Sr., 11997 Bulldog Hollow, Broadway, for a second
residence (for daughter) on property located on the west side of Bulldog
Hollow (Route 830) approximately 1.1 miles north of Mayland Road
(Route 259); Election District #1; Zoned A-2; Tax Map #52-(A)-284.
Betty Ritchie said she and her husband want to put a home in for their daughter
and hopes the Board will allow them to do so.
-----
At 8:42 p.m., Chairman Floyd declared the public hearing closed and
reconvened the regular meeting.
-----
Supervisor Cuevas explained that the test tower (wind turbine) project is
similar to cell towers that have been approved in the past. Since this is a temporary
tower to gauge the value of the site for possible uses in the future and only concerns
about those future uses, not opposition to this issue, were expressed, he is in favor of
approving the request.
Conditions:
(1) Use shall be located in substantial accordance with plot plan as approved.
(2) As required by the Building Official, engineered drawings of the tower shall be
required, and the proper permits shall be obtained.
(3) After one year of testing, the subject tower shall be removed from the property.
The one year shall start with the date of the certificate of occupancy.
(5) This tower shall not be placed into operation until such time as a certificate of
occupancy is obtained from the County.
-----
Supervisor Eberly stated that he thinks it is in the public’s interest to protect the
Lincoln Homestead and cemetery but understands the Board cannot dictate how.
42) approximately 1/4 mile northeast of Williamsburg Road (Route 782); Election
District #2; Zoned A-1; Tax Map #65-(A)-19.
-----
Supervisor Cuevas confirmed with Ms. Stultz that the Withers’ property had
been divided before with adjoining transfers. To be consistent with the Board’s
policies on A-1 land divisions for non-family members he recommended denial of this
request.
-----
Chairman Floyd said due to concern from citizens, he would like the Board to
visit the Fox Run Farms site prior to the next board meeting, weather permitting.
Supervisor Cuevas stated action should be taken on this request at the next meeting so
Mr. Heatwole knows what direction he can take for this business.
Administrator Paxton stated the field trip to Fox Run Farms will be scheduled
at 1:30 p.m. on January 14, 2009.
-----
-----
Supervisor Cuevas noted that Mr. Ritchie’s request is consistent with the policy
of the Board and the guidelines of comprehensive land use in A-1 districts.
conditions, the Board approved S08-52, Jimmie L. Ritchie, Sr., 11997 Bulldog Hollow,
Broadway, for a second residence (for daughter) on property located on the west side
of Bulldog Hollow (Route 830) approximately 1.1 miles north of Mayland Road
(Route 259); Election District #1; Zoned A-2; Tax Map #52-(A)-284.
Conditions:
(1) Use shall be located in substantial accordance with plot plan as approved.
(2) Residence shall comply with the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code and
the proper permits shall be obtained.
(3) Septic shall be installed in accordance with permit approved by the Health
Department.
(6) The residence shall not be occupied until such time as a certificate of occupancy
is issued by the County. No certificate of occupancy shall be issued until all
other conditions of this permit are met.
oooooOooooo
At 8:52 p.m., Chairman Floyd opened the public hearing to receive public
comment on the following ordinance amendments:
-----
An ordinance to Ordain Article III, Chapter 16A, Water and Sewer, Section 14,
Broadway Regional Wastewater Treatment System.
-----
Mr. Miller stated this ordinance amendment is to move the Elkton polling
location from the Municipal Building back to the Elkton - East Rockingham Area
Community Center.
-----
Mr. Miller explained this ordinance establishes fees for the Fire Marshal to
review building plans and for those fees to be collected by the Community
December 10, 2008 (35)
-----
An ordinance amendment to Repeal and Re-ordain Chapter 6 Buildings,
Section 6-17.1(c), Amend Fees for Certain Building and Demolition Permits.
Mr. Miller stated this ordinance is to update the fees for certain building
permits and demolition permits. These fees will be collected by Community
Development when the permits are issued.
-----
At 8:56 p.m., Chairman Floyd closed this portion of the public hearing
and reconvened the regular meeting.
-----
ORDINANCE ENACTING
ARTICLE III,
SECTION 16A-14
OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
OF
ROCKINGHAM COUNTY, VIRGINIA
That Article III, Section 16A-14. “Broadway Regional Wastewater Treatment System”
be and hereby is enacted as follows:
(a) Discharge limits. The pollutant limits listed below are established for
Rockingham County users discharging into the BRWTF for the purpose of protecting
against Pass Through and Interference, as those terms are defined in Broadway’s
Sewer Use Ordinance. No user is permitted to discharge wastewater, measured at the
point of discharge to the BRWTF, containing pollutants in excess of the following
monthly averages:
(b) Applicability. This Section 16A-14 applies to all users located within
Rockingham County that discharge wastewater to the BRWTF.
-----
ORDINANCE AMENDING
SECTION 6A-6
OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
OF
ROCKINGHAM COUNTY, VIRGINIA
That Section 6A-6. “Precincts and polling places – Establishment; authority” be and
hereby is amended as follows:
That block indicating the Elkton Municipal Building as the polling place for the Elkton
Precinct of Election District No. 5 shall be and hereby is amended to indicate the
Elkton - East Rockingham Area Community Center as the polling place for the Elkton
Precinct of Election District No. 5.
-----
ORDINANCE
ENACTING
SECTION 6-17.3
OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
OF
ROCKINGHAM COUNTY, VIRGINIA
That Section 6 – 17.3 “Fire Prevention Fee” be and hereby is enacted as follows:
An additional fee of 5% of the fees set forth in Section 6-11 shall be applied to
all residential building permits and an additional fee of 10% of the fees set forth in
December 10, 2008 (37)
Section 6-11 shall be applied to all commercial building permits. Such additional fees
shall be collected by the Department of Community Development when fees for
building permits are collected and shall be transferred to the Rockingham County
Department of Fire and Rescue.
-----
ORDINANCE REPEALING
AND
RE-ENACTING
SUB-SECTION 6-17.1(c)
OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
OF
ROCKINGHAM COUNTY, VIRGINIA
(1) A fee of fifty dollars ($50.00) shall be charged for each permit for the
installation of a wood stove or range hood.
(2) A fee of three hundred dollars ($300.00) shall be charged for each
permit for the installation of a hood suppression system.
(3) A fee of fifty dollars ($50.00) shall be charged for each permit for the
installation and piping for above and in-ground tanks.
(4) A fee of twenty-five dollars ($25.00) shall be charged for each permit
for the removal of above and in-ground tanks.
(5) A fee of twenty-five dollars ($25.00) shall be charged for each permit
for gas and oil lines for residential and commercial use groups.
(6) A fee of twenty-five dollars ($25.00) shall be charged for each permit
for manufactured or prefabricated homes.
(7) For sprinkler systems the fee shall be three hundred twenty-five dollars
($325.00) plus $1.10 for each sprinkler head.
(8) For fire alarm systems the fee shall be two hundred seventy-five dollars
($275.00) plus $2.50 per associated device.
(9) For a fire standpipe system the fee shall be two hundred seventy-five
dollars ($275.00) plus $15.80 per riser.
(10) For a fire pump system the fee shall be two hundred seventy-five dollars
($275.00)
(11) For a private fire main system the fee shall be two hundred twenty-five
dollars ($225.00)
(12) For a spray booth system the fee shall be one hundred twenty-five
December 10, 2008 (38)
dollars ($125.00)
For other fire prevention permits required, but not elsewhere listed, the fee shall be
fifty dollars ($50.00) plus any applicable costs as determined in writing by the Fire
Marshal.
oooooOooooo
At 8:57 p.m., Chairman Floyd opened the public hearing to receive public
comment on proposals for Landfill (Methane) Gas Collection and Sale, and Operation
and Maintenance of a TV Translator System.
Administrator Paxton noted that the County has approved the State’s process
for using the Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act of 2002
(PPEA) process for constructing projects in the County.
One project falling under this process is a methane gas project with
Rockingham Memorial Hospital (RMH) that is in the developmental stage and will
involve collecting methane gas and transferring it to RMH for heating the new
hospital. RMH is covering the entire cost of the project. Administrator Paxton
explained that the County is administering this project because the County landfill
produces the methane gas. Some money will be paid to the landfill to offset operating
costs.
Supervisor Eberly stated that several citizens in his district use translators for
all TV stations. They do not want to see their reception degraded or be forced to
utilize different channels because WHSV is operating the system.
can pick up. Administrator Paxton noted that digital signals do not travel as far as
analog signals.
Supervisor Cuevas stated that sometime ago the WVPT station was available to
schools in remote areas such as Fulks Run. He suggested the County find out if the
school system is still utilizing WVPT for teaching purposes. Administrator Paxton
noted that WVPT is not on the County towers and they have already converted to
digital so the impact on the schools apparently has been addressed.
Supervisor Kyger stated that the analog channels schools receive can be
received off video stream.
Supervisor Cuevas also noted citizens west of Broadway cannot get radio
stations after 5:00 p.m.
Administrator Paxton explained that no action was necessary as the PPEA was
only for public comment so the Board can proceed when the final presentations are
received.
Alice Harris said she spoke with Public Works Director Warren Heidt
regarding a proposed methane gas line running across the middle of her family’s farm
where there is a section of virgin trees. She said the use of methane gas by RMH as an
alternative fuel is a good idea but her family does not want the line to go across their
property. Ms. Harris stated the line should be able to run along the road or across
some other property. She noted that Mr. Heidt said if her family did not want the line
to cross their property, the proposal would be removed from the table. Ms. Harris,
therefore, requested that the proposal be taken off the table.
Mr. Hedit stated that Ms. Harris has been a good neighbor to the landfill.
There are four proposed paths for the methane gas lines, two of which cross Ms.
Harris’ property. He indicated both could be realigned to stay within the VDOT
easement along Grassy Creek Road or could be elevated to cross an adjacent property.
Mr. Heidt told Ms. Harris that if she was opposed and the County would have to
condemn her property to move forward, it would not be wise for the County to do so
and an alternative path would be pursued.
Terry Fertitta said he submitted a special-use permit for a flea market which
was tabled until this evening’s meeting and was apparently overlooked. He further
stated he has five or six landfill easements across his property which he is not happy
about because he has not been treated well by the County or the subcontractors. He
said he does not want the methane line to go through his property.
Chairman Floyd stated that the Board plans to look at Mr. Fertitta’s property in
January.
-----
At 9:12 p.m., Chairman Floyd declared the public hearing closed and
reconvened the regular meeting.
oooooOooooo
OTHER.
It was noted that the Finance Committee reviewed the Valley Brethren –
Mennonite Heritage Center application at its meeting earlier today (December 10,
2008).
-----
Mr. Miller expressed the need for a work session of the Board to discuss
subdivisions in A-2 districts. He suggested this work session be scheduled at 3:00 p.m.
on January 28, 2009.
-----
Chairman Floyd expressed his appreciation to the Board for working with him
as Chairman this past year.
-----
Supervisor Kyger suggested that as the Board organizes for 2009, consideration
be given to having two board meetings in December as there are usually a lot of
requests in December, particularly after having only one meeting in November. He
recommended that meetings be held the 1st and 3rd Wednesdays of December instead
of the 2nd Wednesday.
oooooOooooo
ADJOURNMENT.
________________________,
Chairman