Green Hydrogen Financing 1718957414
Green Hydrogen Financing 1718957414
Green Hydrogen Financing 1718957414
We are pleased to present this Climate Finance Leadership Initiative (CFLI) India report on Financing
Green Hydrogen in India in support of the National Green Hydrogen Mission ((NGHM)NGHM) spearheaded by the
Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE). The NGHM establishes an ambitious vision for the future
of green hydrogen in India that builds on the country’s trailblazing efforts to deploy renewable energy at
scale. We look forward to working with the stakeholders of India’s energy transition to help spur domestic
demand and cement the country’s position as a leading producer and, in time, a global export hub of
green hydrogen.
CFLI India’s Members, comprising 10 leading Indian and international financial institutions and
corporates, with the objective of mobilising private capital towards the Government of India’s climate
priorities, are honoured to share a set of considerations that offer a private-sector view on the incentives
deployed under the NGHM
NGHM.. These considerations, shared at the request of the MNRE, are informed
by engagements with stakeholders from across the green hydrogen value chain. They focus on creating
demand for green hydrogen, the enabling infrastructure that is needed, and suggest ways to reduce
financing costs – in line with the policy’s mission.
In the last year, India’s hydrogen market has seen important developments and secured multiple investor
commitments towards the manufacturing of green hydrogen and its derivatives, despite a challenging
macro-environment and the uncertainties inherent to a sector still at an early stage. We believe that
with proactive policies, partnerships between key private and public sector participants, and innovative
financial solutions, India can become a global leader in green hydrogen.
On behalf of CFLI India, we thank you for your leadership and commitment to India’s climate ambitions.
Our Members look forward to working with you to advance India’s green hydrogen transition.
Sincerely,
4 Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for Green Hydrogen in India
5 Policy support
6 Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen market
6 Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen market
13 Section 3.
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India
14 Challenge 1: Incentivising demand
16
Challenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure for green hydrogen deployment
17 Challenge 3: High financing costs in emerging markets
18 Section 4.
Private Sector Considerations for Policymakers
19 Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen production costs
21 Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable demand for green hydrogen
23 Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers for a thriving ecosystem
25 Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
26 Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake agreements
26 Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real options
26 Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven hedging products
26 Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, guarantees, and viability gap funding
26 Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and capacity building
27 References
29 Appendix 1: Abbreviations
30 Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions
34 Appendix 3: Major Policy Milestones
36 Appendix 4: List of Figures and Tables
Section 1. Preamble
Section 1.
Preamble
Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India In pursuit of sustainable growth, governments are turning to clean technologies to support
Policy support their development. As countries raise ambition on climate and set ‘net zero’ targets to curtail
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen emissions, decarbonising hard-to-abate sectors will be a critical means to this end. Green
market hydrogen – hydrogen produced through renewable energy – has sparked interest among
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen policymakers, given its potential to contribute to a cleaner economic growth trajectory,
market especially in hard-to-abate sectors. To date, 53 countries have hydrogen strategies, and
Section 3. another 30 are developing similar policies to transition to it (BloombergNEF 2024).
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand As India assumes a prominent role in the global economy, the adoption of alternative fuels
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C such as green hydrogen in its industries will be critical to mitigating global greenhouse gas
for green hydrogen deployment
emissions. Beyond mitigation, green hydrogen also provides a transition pathway for India
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C to reduce its reliance on imported fossil fuels and establish export opportunities. To this
markets
end, the Government of India’s Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) launched
Section 4. the National Green Hydrogen Mission (NGHM) in 2023 aiming to promote demand for
Private Sector Considerations for
green hydrogen, facilitate an increase in production, and aid in developing key enablers for
Policymakers
the sector. However, the economics of green hydrogen in India remain challenging due to
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs significant capital costs, the nascency of the sector, the higher cost of renewable energy, and
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
its intermittent nature. Therefore, public–private engagement will be essential to build on
demand for green hydrogen India’s success in renewables and fuel its green hydrogen ambitions.
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
for a thriving ecosystem We – the Climate Finance Leadership Initiative (CFLI) India – offer a private sector view
Section 5. of practical next steps for consideration by the Government of India in deploying policy
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing incentives to develop India’s green hydrogen industry and realise its ambitions of becoming a
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake global production and export hub.
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing Feedstock and
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake reductant
agreements Refineries Fertilisers Steel Methanol
Power
Source: CEEW analysis
in India
Policy support
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen
market
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen
market
Hydrogen is becoming increasingly critical as a fuel source for India’s core industrial sectors:
the country produces and consumes an estimated ~5.6 million tonnes per annum (MTPA) of
Section 3.
grey hydrogen annually, amounting to nearly 6 per cent of global consumption (IEA 2021).
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India
To actualise India’s aspirations of building a low-carbon and self-reliant economy, the
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand
Government of India has declared green hydrogen a sunrise sector (MNRE 2023) and enacted
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C
for green hydrogen deployment
supportive policies to enable an industrial shift to achieve this vision by 2030. Furthermore,
as countries around the world also look to transition to green hydrogen, Indian policymakers
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C
markets see an opportunity for the country to attract foreign investment, develop robust electrolyser
manufacturing capabilities, and lead innovation in this sector.
Section 4.
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers This section highlights domestic policies, sectors, and trends that are shaping the contours of
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen India’s green hydrogen industry. In line with the national policies, our analysis forecasts that
production costs India’s core grey hydrogen consuming sectors, including the fertiliser and refining industries,
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable will drive initial demand for green hydrogen. As green hydrogen technology and its associated
demand for green hydrogen
economics become increasingly viable, other applications of hydrogen in the steel, mobility
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
and shipping sectors can materialise at scale. However, tapping into export opportunities and
for a thriving ecosystem
establishing a conducive enabling ecosystem will be critical to realising the government’s
Section 5. targets and propelling this sector forward in the long term.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake 2021 2022 2023 2024
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Feb 2022 Jun 2023 Oct 2023 Feb 2024
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
GHP launched SIGHT scheme R&D Roadmap Scheme guidelines
guarantees, and viability gap funding by the MoP incentives for Green for pilot projects
announced for Hydrogen using
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
electrolyser Ecosystem in hydrogen/green
capacity building manufacturing and India released by hydrogen in
green the MNRE shipping, steel, and
References hydrogen/ammonia green transport
NGHM National Green Hydrogen Mission production
Appendix 1: Abbreviations GHP Green Hydrogen Policy
SIGHT Strategic Interventions for Green
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions Hydrogen Transition
SECI Solar Energy Corporation of India
Appendix 3: Major Policy Milestones MNRE Ministry of New and Renewable Energy
MoP Ministry of Power
Appendix 4: List of Figures and Tables R&D Research and Development
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen Yadav and Guhan 2020). India’s fertiliser and refining 8
8.00 4.50
0.50
market industries, where grey hydrogen functions as an 1.90
5.60
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen intermediary and most production and consumption is 6
0.10
Section 3.
remaining share of grey hydrogen, produced as a by- 2
3.00
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India
product in certain industrial processes, is commercially 0
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand traded and utilised for glass making, laboratory
FY 2020
Domestic production
FY 2020
Potential demand
FY 2030
Projected hydrogen
through import demand
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C research, and pilot projects. substitution
for green hydrogen deployment
Fertilisers Refineries Petrochemicals
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C Given the demand dependence on the fertiliser and
markets Source: CEEW analysis; (Monna, et al. 2021)
refining industries, India’s grey hydrogen consumption Note 1: CEEW based its projections on announced capacity expansion plans
Section 4. has seen marginal growth in the last decade, attributed for refineries and consumption trends from FY 2010 to FY 2020 for fertilisers,
ammonia, and methanol.
Private Sector Considerations for primarily to a low compound annual growth rate Note 2: CEEW assumes completely indigenised production of fertilisers,
Policymakers (CAGR) of approximately 1 per cent in these sectors ammonia, and methanol.
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen since the financial year (FY) 2015. However, hydrogen
production costs consumption in the fertiliser and refining industries Emerging trends in India’s green
could double to nearly 10.6 MTPA by FY 2030 if
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
the respective sectoral production capacity targets are
hydrogen market
demand for green hydrogen
met. In the case of the fertiliser industry, this includes Domestic demand creation
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
for a thriving ecosystem increasing domestic production to offset imports as
outlined by the Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilisers, India’s hydrogen demand and production are set
Section 5. while for the refining industry, the Ministry of to nearly double by FY 2030, led primarily by its
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing Petroleum and Natural Gas (MoPNG) aims to increase core hydrogen-consuming sectors. However, only a
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake capacity by setting up new refineries across the country. fraction of this may be green. Phase I of the NGHM’s
agreements Similar increases can be expected in the petrochemicals implementation roadmap posits refining, fertilisers,
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real sector, where consumption may grow to 1.3 MTPA and the city gas sectors as leading India’s green
options for the same reasons. Together, these three sectors are hydrogen transition from FY 2023-FY 2026, while
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven anticipated to drive India’s total grey hydrogen demand Phase II identifies steel, mobility, and shipping as
hedging products up from 5.6 MTPA in FY 2020 to 11.9 MTPA in FY sectors that could explore green hydrogen uptake
2030. through FY 2026-FY 2030. However, despite this
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
we note that the total domestic demand for green
hydrogen in FY 2030 may be short of the NGHM’s
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
5 MTPA target, thus highlighting the role export
capacity building
opportunities could play in supporting growth of the
References sector in the near term.
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing 2.00
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Source: CEEW analysis
*Statistics referred from (Raj, Lakhina and Stranger 2022)
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 4.
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
demand for green hydrogen
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
for a thriving ecosystem
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing Export-focused green hydrogen hub
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake AM Green Ammonia (AMGA), a venture led by the founders of leading renewable energy company, Greenko
agreements Group, is building one of the world’s largest green ammonia platforms at a brownfield site in Kakinada (an
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real industrial base for India’s oil and gas industry in Andhra Pradesh). Backed by global institutional investor GIC,
options the partnership, which spans multiple locations including Kakinada, aims to produce 5 million tons per annum
of green ammonia by 2030. The facility will comprise 1,300 MW round-the-clock renewable energy power,
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven enabled through a combination of renewable energy sources and long duration energy storage to be provided by
hedging products Greenko. Electrolysers will be powered by renewable energy to produce green hydrogen that is then converted to
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, green ammonia.
guarantees, and viability gap funding
AMGA will set up the plant with an overall investment exceeding USD 1 billion and has secured an offtaker for
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and 25 per cent of the facility’s initial capacity. Utilising a build-own-operate model, the developer will sell green
capacity building ammonia for the project’s 25-30-year lifetime. For the first time in global markets, AMGA is offering short and
medium-term contracts against the market standard of long-term only partnerships, enabling the creation of
References
deeper and wider global green ammonia markets.
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
Developing a domestic Hydrogen hubs simplify supply
agreements electrolyser ecosystem chain development
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
L&T Electrolysers Limited, a newly incorporated Much like India, countries around the world are
options
entity of L&T, is focused on manufacturing increasingly turning to hubs to bolster supply of
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven pressurised alkaline electrolysers using green hydrogen and, in turn, create a reliable
hedging products technology from McPhy Energy, France. green hydrogen ecosystem. In October 2023,
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, L&T commissioned its first indigenously the United States launched the Regional Clean
guarantees, and viability gap funding manufactured 1 MW hydrogen electrolyser at Hydrogen Hubs Program (H2Hubs) (Department
the green hydrogen plant at A M Naik Heavy of Energy n.d.). This initiative includes grants
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
Engineering Complex in Hazira, Gujarat. The of up to USD 7 billion to establish 6-10 regional
capacity building
company spearheaded the complete value chain, clean hydrogen hubs across the country. The
References including the engineering and manufacturing programme requires that eligible projects be
of the electrolyser, in collaboration with Indian involved in the “production, processing, delivery,
Appendix 1: Abbreviations vendors and suppliers, thus setting a benchmark storage, and end-use of clean hydrogen”
for ‘Make in India’ initiatives. L&T Electrolysers (Department of Energy n.d.). Seven hydrogen
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions plans to leverage its upcoming giga-scale facility hubs have already been chosen (Jennifer L. 2023).
in Hazira to meet the growing demand for green
Appendix 3: Major Policy Milestones
hydrogen, maximise product localisation through
Appendix 4: List of Figures and Tables an enhanced local supply chain, and automate
for cost competitiveness.
Section 4.
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
demand for green hydrogen
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
for a thriving ecosystem
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements 3.00
Breakeven green hydrogen cost (USD per kg)
urea
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 4.
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
demand for green hydrogen
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
for a thriving ecosystem
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
4.00
4.00 3.97 3.90
3.75
Section 5. -0.35
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing 3.50
3.34
3.13 3.13
-0.48
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake 3.00 3.15
-0.13
agreements -0.07 -0.07
-0.15
2.67
2.54
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real 2.47 2.40 -0.41
2.2
options 2.00 -0.21
1.84
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven 1.63 1.63
hedging products
1.00 Estimated impact on
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, LCOH of 1.87 USD/kg
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions Reduction in electrolyser costs Reduction in renewable energy costs SIGHT scheme incentives Market-driven cost reduction
Section 2. Other important factors that can impact the cost of Reducing goods and services tax
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
green hydrogen production include the efficiency of the
Green Hydrogen in India The Government of India could reduce the GST for
electrolyser, scale of domestic production, and costs of
Policy support components used in green hydrogen/green ammonia
supporting distribution and storage infrastructure.
production (solar and wind-electricity generation
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen
market Establishing a supportive power banking modules), including during its sale as a final commodity.
Under the existing GST structure, electrolysers are taxed
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen framework at 18 per cent, and renewable energy setups at 13.8 per
market
Renewable energy banking could also be instrumental cent under a composite structure. The reduction in GST
Section 3. in reducing the cost of green hydrogen by increasing could be planned for a stipulated period until a 5 MTPA
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India the utilisation of electrolysers. As per our models for a production capacity is established.
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand solar-only operation, electrolysers currently have a 33
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C per cent utilisation factor with 30 per cent oversizing Reducing capital costs through green debt
for green hydrogen deployment of solar power plants. While the GHP already allows
Central and state governments could consider
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C banking for a period of 30 days, hydrogen-consuming
providing direct fiscal support through low-cost loans,
markets state governments could also make similar allowances
government-owned institutions, and other forms of
for green hydrogen projects on a monthly basis, injected
Section 4. financial assistance. The provision of low-cost green
at any 15-minute time block. This would further
Private Sector Considerations for debt at rates commensurate with other green bonds
improve the utilisation of electrolysers and reduce green
Policymakers or loans will be necessary to reduce the WACC for
hydrogen costs. There is already precedence for this
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen green hydrogen projects. This could help reduce green
given that several state governments allow up to 100 per
production costs hydrogen production costs without significantly
cent (Gulia, Banga and Garg 2021) of their renewable
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
burdening government finances.
energy to be banked at different terms, even monthly
demand for green hydrogen (Sharma 2022). To facilitate uniformity in renewable
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers energy banking provisions, the MNRE could consider
for a thriving ecosystem standardising and reducing the terms for power banking
Section 5.
vis-à-vis green hydrogen projects across states.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake Providing low-cost open-access electricity
agreements Waivers on interstate open-access charges (MNRE
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real 2023) could also support the provision of wheeling
options power between special economic zones, given that the
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven production sites of green hydrogen and its derivatives
hedging products may be located at a considerable distance from renewable
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, assets and across state lines. Similar to the central
guarantees, and viability gap funding government, states could provide waivers on ISTS
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and charges. States such as Rajasthan, Andhra Pradesh, and
capacity building Uttar Pradesh already provide waivers or have reduced
the intrastate open-access charges in their respective
References green hydrogen policies.
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
market waiving off open-access charges may have the 30,000 2,162
(USD 270 mn)
largest impact on government finances (Figure 3,145
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen
8). This impact, when annualised, could vary for (USD 393 mn)
market
for green hydrogen deployment loss of revenue for both the central and state 1,468 (USD 183 mn)
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers outlay in the NGHM, increasing the effectiveness of Support for open-access charges (5 MTPA green hydrogen production)
for a thriving ecosystem viability gap funding and PLI in the NGHM. Source: CEEW analysis
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements Consideration 2: Catalysing Stipulating green hydrogen purchase
obligations
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real sustainable demand for green
options India’s green hydrogen ecosystem is experiencing a
hydrogen supply-side push, but still lacks the necessary demand-
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products Established and growing demand for green hydrogen side pull required to scale. Through the Energy
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, will be instrumental in developing economies of scale, Conservation (Amendment) Act, 2022, the central
guarantees, and viability gap funding driving down the cost of green hydrogen, and creating government could mandate the offtake of green
a virtuous cycle. Mandated green hydrogen purchase hydrogen by instituting blending requirements in
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building obligations (HPO) for domestic industries can help industrial units, such as in the fertilisers and refining
initiate demand. Promoting exports to markets that industries. Blending mandates, with periodic upward
References
have signalled intentions to import green hydrogen or revisions clearly outlined, may be needed in the early
green ammonia is another lever that can be employed to stages of this transition to help stimulate demand. A
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
generate demand. small blending proportion would spread the incremental
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions cost of green hydrogen over the total volume of
hydrogen used, thereby cushioning its impact on the
Appendix 3: Major Policy Milestones
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Hydrogen Financing
Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India
Policy support
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen The policy considerations presented in the prior section represent a suite of high potential,
market near-term actions the government could pursue to accelerate private investment in domestic
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen green hydrogen production. However, not all barriers to investment can be solved through
market
government-led interventions. Private sector financial institutions, developers, and offtakers
Section 3. must partner with multilateral development banks, donors, and other development finance
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India institutions to deploy innovative financing solutions at scale in the green hydrogen sector.
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C Financing green hydrogen and green ammonia projects remains a challenge, highlighted by
for green hydrogen deployment
the few projects that have secured sufficient financing to commence development. However,
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C
as demand increases, financiers must develop innovative financing solutions in response to
markets
market dynamics. In the meantime, existing projects that have received financing, as well as
Section 4. projects for proximate energy sources, such as renewables and liquefied natural gas, present
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers valuable lessons.
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs To inform these considerations, we engaged in discussions with various stakeholders,
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable including buyers, developers, lenders, private equity, and development finance institutions,
demand for green hydrogen to gather initial high-level learnings from early investments in this sector and present them
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers in this section.
for a thriving ecosystem
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India Biswas, Tirtha, Deepak Yadav, and Ashish Guhan. 2020. A M, Annapoorna. 2022. GST rates on solar power based
Green Hydrogen Economy for India: Policy and Technology devices and systems. Clear. 16 Feb.
Policy support Imperatives to Lower Production Cost. New Delhi: Council on
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW). Malik, Leeza, and Geetam Tiwari. 2017. “Assessment of
market interstate freight vehicle characteristics and impact of future
BloombergNEF. n.d. “Global Hydrogen Strategy Tracker”. emission and fuel economy standards on their emissions in
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen India.” Energy Policy 108:121-133.
market CEEW-CEF. 2023. “Advanced Renewable Energy Cost and
Tariff Calculator”. Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare. 2023. “Green
Section 3. Agriculture”. Press Information Bureau. 28 March.
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India CEF, CEEW. 2022. “What is banking?”.19 April.
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers. 2022. “Year- end
Center for Strategic & International Studies. 2022. “China’s Review of the Department of Fertilizers-2022”. 23 December.
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C Hydrogen Industrial Strategy”. Center for Strategic &
for green hydrogen deployment International Studies. 03 Feb. Ministry of Commerce. n.d. “Export Import Data Bank Version
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C 7.1 - TRADESTAT”. Accessed Jan 16, 2024.
Clear. n.d. GST rates and HSN code for Other Electrical
markets
Machines. Ministry of Law and Justice. 2022. “THE ENERGY
Section 4. CONSERVATION (AMENDMENT) ACT, 2022.” New Delhi: The
Dep. of Energy, US Gov. n.d. Regional Clean Hydrogen Hubs. Gazette of India.
Private Sector Considerations for
Accessed Nov 16, 2023.
Policymakers
MNRE. 2023. Green Hydrogen Standard for India. New Delhi:
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen European Commission. n.d. “Hydrogen”. Ministry of New and Renewable Energy. doi.
production costs
Ghosh, Arunabha, Tulika Gupta, Shuva Raha, Hemant Mallya, MNRE. 2023. National Green Hydrogen Mission. New Delhi:
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable Deepak Yadav, and Nandini Harihar. 2022. Rules for an Ministry of New and Renewable Energy.
demand for green hydrogen Energy-Secure Global Green Hydrogen Economy. New Delhi:
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers Council on Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW). MNRE. 2023. R&D Roadmap for Green Hydrogen Ecosystem
for a thriving ecosystem in India. New Delhi: Ministry of New and Renewable Energy.
Gulia, Jyoti, Ginni Banga, and Vibhuti Garg. 2021. Banking
Section 5. Restrictions on Renewable Energy Projects in India. MNRE. 2023. Scheme Guidelines for implementation of
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing Lakewood, Ohio: Institute for Energy Economics and Financial ‘Strategic Interventions for Green Hydrogen Transition (SIGHT)
Analysis. Programme - Component I: Incentive Scheme For Electrolyser
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
Manufacturing’ of the National Green Hydrogen Mission. New
agreements IBM. 2023. Indian Minerals Yearbook 2021. Nagpur: Indian Delhi: Ministry of New and Renewable Energy.
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real Bureau of Mines.
options MNRE. 2023. Scheme Guidelines for implementation
IEA. n.d. “Dashboard: Cost of Capital Observatory”. Accessed of ‘Strategic Interventions for Green Hydrogen Transition
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven November 2023. (SIGHT) Programme - Component II: Incentive Scheme For
hedging products
Green Hydrogen Production (under Mode 1)’ of the National
IEA. 2021. Global Hydrogen Review 2021. Paris:
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, Green Hydrogen Mission. New Delhi: Ministry of New and
International Energy Agency (IEA).
guarantees, and viability gap funding Renewable Energy.
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and IEA. 2023. Hydrogen. Paris: IEA.
MNRE. 2024. Scheme Guidelines for Implementation of
capacity building
IEA. 2023. Scaling up Private Finance for Clean Energy in Strategic Interventions for Green Hydrogen Transition (SIGHT)
References Emerging and Developing Economies. Paris: International Programme Component-II : Incentive for Procurement of
Energy Agency (IEA). Green Ammonia Production (under Mode-2A) of the National
Appendix 1: Abbreviations Green Hydrogen Mission. New Delhi: Ministry of New and
L, Jennifer. 2023. “US DOE’s $7B Clean Hydrogen Hub Renewable Energy.
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions Grant: The 7 Chosen Ones”. carboncredits.com. 23 October.
Appendix 3: Major Policy Milestones Lin, Max Tingyao. 2022. “China sets green hydrogen
production target in national development plan”. 23 Mar.
Appendix 4: List of Figures and Tables
Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India
CAGR Compound annual growth rate MoP Ministry of Power
Policy support
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen CCTS Carbon Credit Trading Scheme MoPNG Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas
market
CCUS Carbon capture, utilisation, and storage MT million tonnes
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen
market FCEV Fuel-cell electric vehicle MTPA million tonnes per annum
Section 3. FY Financial year MW megawatt
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand GHP Green Hydrogen Policy NGHM National Green Hydrogen Mission
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C GST Goods and Services Tax PLF Plant load factor
for green hydrogen deployment
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C GW gigawatt PLI Production-linked incentives
markets
HGV Heavy goods vehicle PM-PRANAM Prime Minister - Promotion of Alternate
Section 4. Nutrients for Agriculture Management
Private Sector Considerations for HPO Hydrogen purchase obligation Yojana
Policymakers
HRS Hydrogen refuelling station R&D Research and development
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs IIT Indian Institute of Technology RE Renewable energy
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
demand for green hydrogen
ISTS Interstate transmission system ROW Right of way
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers kW kilowatt SECI Solar Energy Corporation of India
for a thriving ecosystem
kWh kilowatt-hour SEZ Special economic zone
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing LCOH Levelised cost of (green) hydrogen SIGHT Strategic Interventions for Green
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake Hydrogen Transition
agreements
MGV Medium goods vehicle
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real MMBtu metric million British thermal unit TPA tonnes per annum
options
MMSCM million metric standard cubic meter WACC Weighted average cost of capital
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
MNRE Ministry of New and Renewable Energy
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding MoEFCC Ministry of Environment, Forest and
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and Climate Change
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India Table A1 lists the assumptions for the cost curve across various end-use sectors of the economy. As discussed in
Policy support
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen
market
reported literature or derived using appropriate conversion parameters.
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen
market
5.2 Shipping Light diesel oil INR/litre 64.96 96.50 ’000 TPA 2.20
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing 5.3 Furnace oil USD/tonne 399.85 445.25 ’000 TPA 729
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements 6.1 Steel: Hot metal kg/tonne of
Coke USD/tonne 184.00 241.20 13
production product
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options 6.2 Steel: Gas-based
kg/tonne of
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven direct reduced iron Natural gas USD/MMBtu 7.47 14.80 68
product
hedging products (DRI) production
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, 7 Methanol USD/tonne 415 600 MTPA 2.46
guarantees, and viability gap funding
8 Urea imports USD/tonne 249 462 MTPA 10.29
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building 9 Non-urea imports USD/tonne 314 592 MTPA 6.64
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
Sources: (i) Base case costs of incumbent fuels or commodities: jet fuel and shipping fuel prices (MoPNG 2022); delivered natural gas prices estimated on this basis
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions of (Petroleum Planning and Analysis Cell 2023), (MoPNG 2015); cost of coking coal for steel production: (Ministry of Commerce n.d.); cost of imported methanol,
urea, non-urea fertiliser and ammonia imports (Ministry of Commerce n.d.)
(ii) Consumption figures for incumbent fuels or commodities: jet fuel (MoPNG 2022); natural gas in fertilisers and refining (Petroleum Planning & Analysis Cell 2020);
Appendix 3: Major Policy Milestones shipping fuels (MoPNG 2022); steel production figures (IBM 2023); coking coal in steel: imported methanol, urea, non-urea fertiliser, and ammonia imports (Ministry
of Commerce n.d.)
Appendix 4: List of Figures and Tables
Financing
Financing Green
Green Hydrogen
Hydrogen in
in India
India 31
31
Section 1. Table A3 lists all the modelling inputs considered for estimating the levelised cost of hydrogen (LCOH) in Figure 7.
Preamble Estimation of LCOH across scenarios is done sequentially, as listed in the table. All considerations from a preceding
Section 2.
scenario are carried forward, unless otherwise mentioned in the table.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India TABLE A3:
Policy support
Inputs for estimation of levelised cost of hydrogen (LCOH)
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen 27 Open access rate: Central transmission 0.09 INR/kWh
market utility (CTU) - Solar electricity
(CEEW-CEF 2023)
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen 28 Open access rate (CTU) - wind electricity 0.11 INR/kWh
market
PARTIAL GST WAIVER (ELECTROLYSER)
Section 3.
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India 29 Existing GST rate 18 % (Clear n.d.)
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand 30 Proposed GST rate 5 %
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C
PARTIAL GST WAIVER (RENEWABLE ENERGY)
for green hydrogen deployment
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C 31 Existing GST rate 13.80% % (Annapoorna M. 2022)
markets
32 Proposed GST rate 5% %
Section 4.
BENEFITS DUE TO THE STRATEGIC INTERVENTIONS FOR GREEN HYDROGEN TRANSITION (SIGHT) INCENTIVES
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers 33 Year 1 base incentive under SIGHT 4,440 INR/kW
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
34 Year 2 base incentive under SIGHT 3,700 INR/kW
production costs
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable 35 Year 3 base incentive under SIGHT 2,960 INR/kW (SECI Limited 2023)
demand for green hydrogen
36 Year 4 base incentive under SIGHT 2,220 INR/kW
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
for a thriving ecosystem 37 Year 5 base incentive under SIGHT 1,480 INR/kW
Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India
Policy support Key components Features
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen Green Hydrogen Policy (GHP) (Ministry of Power 2022)
market
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen Implementing agency Ministry of Power
market
Launch year 2022
Section 3.
General Aims to facilitate the supply of renewable energy to the green hydrogen sector in an expedited,
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India
easy, and economical way
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand
Definitions Defines green hydrogen/ green ammonia as “produced by way of electrolysis of water using
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C
renewable energy, including renewables which has been banked and hydrogen or ammonia
for green hydrogen deployment produced by biomass”
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C
markets Renewable energy access To facilitate the supply of renewable energy, the GHP enables the following:
Section 4. • A waiver on interstate transmission charges for 25 years on projects commissioned before
Private Sector Considerations for 30 June 2025
Policymakers
• Granting open access to plants within 15 days of application
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs • Provides guidelines on the banking of renewable energy, which is permitted for up to 30 days
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable • Grants connectivity on a priority basis under the generation end for interstate transmission of
demand for green hydrogen renewable energy
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers • Allows developers to set up bunkers near ports for green ammonia storage for exports
for a thriving ecosystem
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven • Contribute to India becoming self-reliant through clean energy
hedging products
• Decarbonisation of the economy, reduced dependence on fossil fuel imports, and leadership in
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital, green hydrogen market and technology
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and Expected outcomes The expected outcomes by 2030 are as follows:
capacity building
• Green hydrogen production capacity of at least 5 MTPA
References
• Renewable energy capacity addition of ~125 GW
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
• Total investments over INR 8 lakh crore
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions • Create more than 6 lakh full-time jobs
Section 2. Phase I (FY 2023 – FY 2026): Creating adequate and sustainable demand:
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
• Incentives will target the indigenisation of a green hydrogen value chain through adequate
Green Hydrogen in India domestic electrolyser manufacturing capacity
Policy support
• Encourage the utilisation of green hydrogen in key sectors such as refining, fertilisers, and city
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen gas to create a sustained demand and attract investments
market
• Lay the foundation for future transition in other hard-to-abate sectors such as steel, mobility,
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen and shipping
market
• Establish regulations and standards in line with international norms
Section 3.
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India Phase II (FY 2026 – FY 2030): Enable a deep decarbonisation of the economy:
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand • Commercial scaling of green hydrogen projects in steel, mobility, and shipping
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C
• Undertake pilots in other potential sectors such as railways, aviation, etc.
for green hydrogen deployment
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C
markets Mission components The NGHM consists of the following interventions:
Section 4. • Demand creation through export markets, domestic markets, and import substitution
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers • Incentivising supply through the SIGHT scheme
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen • Key enablers through key resources such as finance; renewable energy, land, and water; R&D;
production costs ease of doing business; creating infrastructure and supply chain; regulations and standards;
skill development; and public awareness
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
demand for green hydrogen Strategic Interventions for Green Hydrogen Transition (SIGHT) is a comprehensive incentive
programme that facilitates a green hydrogen value chain. These incentives target: (i) domestic
Consideration 3: Leveraging critical enablers
manufacturing of electrolysers through production-linked incentives under Component I (ii)
for a thriving ecosystem
production of green hydrogen and derivatives through viability gap funding under Component II of the
scheme. As of March 2024, two tranches of the SIGHT scheme have been released that cumulatively
Section 5.
provision incentives for 3,000 MW electrolyser capacity, 650 kTPA of green hydrogen production,
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
and 550kTPA of green ammonia production.
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Integrated mission Calls on 13 central ministries and state governments to coordinate to achieve the outlined mission
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real strategy objectives. Some of these are as follows:
options
• Ministry of New and Renewable Energy: Overall coordination and implementation, formulation
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven of schemes and financial incentives, etc.
hedging products
• Ministry of Power: Policies to facilitate the delivery of renewable energy
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding • Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas: Policies to facilitate uptake in refining and city gas
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and distribution sectors
capacity building
Budgetary outlay Total outlay of INR 19,744 crore (~USD 2.4 billion), broken down as follows:
References
• SIGHT: INR 17,490 crore (~USD 2.2 billion)
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
• Pilot projects: INR 1,466 crore (~USD 180 million)
Appendix 2: Cost Curve Assumptions
• R&D: INR 400 crore (~USD 49 million)
Appendix 3: Major Policy Milestones
• Others: INR 388 crore (~ USD 48 million)
Appendix 4: List of Figures and Tables
Section 2.
Key Trends and Emerging Opportunities for
Green Hydrogen in India
Policy support
Current trends in India’s grey hydrogen
market Figures
Emerging trends in India’s green hydrogen
2 Figure 1: Use cases of green hydrogen as a decarbonisation tool
market
5 Figure 2: Green hydrogen related policy milestones
Section 3.
Challenges to Scaling Green Hydrogen in India 6 Figure 3: Total hydrogen demand in India (MTPA)
Challenge 1: Incentivising demand 7 Figure 4: Projected green hydrogen demand in India by FY 2030 and FY 2050 (MTPA)
hallenge 2: Limited enabling infrastructure
C 10 Figure 5: Hydrogen demand sites in India (FY 2020, in tonnes per annum (TPA))
for green hydrogen deployment 14 Figure 6: Green hydrogen cost curve
hallenge 3: High financing costs in emerging
C 19 Figure 7: Estimated impact of the policy considerations on green hydrogen production costs
markets
21 Figure 8: Estimated impact of the considerations on finances of state and central governments (INR crore)
Section 4.
Private Sector Considerations for
Policymakers
Consideration 1: Reducing green hydrogen
production costs Table
Consideration 2: Catalysing sustainable
demand for green hydrogen
3 Table 1: The hydrogen colour spectrum
Section 5.
Initial Learnings on Green Hydrogen Financing
Learning 1: Standardise medium-term offtake
agreements
Learning 2: Mitigate offtake risk with real
options
Learning 3: Manage currency risk with proven
hedging products
Learning 4: Scale use of concessional capital,
guarantees, and viability gap funding
Learning 5: Invest in project preparation and
capacity building
References
Appendix 1: Abbreviations
CFLI India is Co-Chaired by N. Chandrasekaran, Chairman of Tata Sons, and Shemara Wikramanayake,
Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer of Macquarie Group, and comprises 10 institutions namely
GIC Private Ltd., Goldman Sachs India, HDFC Bank Ltd., HSBC India, Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited,
Larsen & Toubro, Macquarie Group, NITI Aayog, State Bank of India, and Tata Sons. For more information,
visit https://www.bloomberg.com/cfli.
About CEEW
The Council on Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW) is one of Asia’s leading not-for-profit policy
research institutions and among the world’s top climate think tanks. The Council uses data, integrated
analysis, and strategic outreach to explain — and change — the use, reuse, and misuse of resources. The
Council addresses pressing global challenges through an integrated and internationally focused approach.
It prides itself on the independence of its high-quality research, develops partnerships with public and
private institutions, and engages with the wider public. CEEW has a footprint in over 20 Indian states and
has repeatedly featured among the world’s best managed and independent think tanks. Follow us on X
(formerly Twitter) @CEEWIndia for the latest updates.
This report was made possible through support from Bloomberg Philanthropies.
The views expressed in this study are that of the authors. They do not necessarily reflect the views
and policies of the Council on Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW) or Bloomberg Philanthropies.
Illustrations and images in this publication may have been generated using AI.
© CFLI 2024