(Strings Webpage) The Future of String Theory - 100 Open Questions
(Strings Webpage) The Future of String Theory - 100 Open Questions
(Strings Webpage) The Future of String Theory - 100 Open Questions
We encourage you to think of comments and questions on these questions that you
can share at our session. You are also welcome to suggest new scientific questions that
might plausibly be answered in the next ten years. We hope that these will serve to
stimulate discussion at the session as well as future research.
Our plan for the session is for each of us to speak for 15 minutes and then open the
floor to your comments and questions on any topic.
You may also consider submitting your comments and questions to us in advance.
While we cannot guarantee that we will have enough time for everyone, we will try to
start with those who have contacted us in advance.
Sincerely,
Hirosi Ooguri and Andy Strominger
Sergio Aguilar
Ofer Aharony
Hint: For asymptotically free gauge theories, a good starting point could be
understanding the string dual of the free gauge theory.
3. Within a given string theory, what topological data of the background specifies
distinct branches of the moduli space of 𝟒-dimensional, 𝑵 = 𝟏 compactifications?
In other words, is there a generalization of the distinguishing minimal "Wall's data"
of Calabi-Yau threefolds (which fully determines 𝟒-dimensional, 𝑵 = 𝟐 Type II
backgrounds) to 𝟒-dimensional, 𝑵 = 𝟏 string theory compactifications?
David Andriot
Hint: Can string theory provide a controlled and viable quintessence model?
Dionysios Anninos
Hint: Some hints (cautiously interpreted) might stem from the appearance of horizons of
the cosmological type, and the structure of semiclassical Wheeler-DeWitt wave
equation.
Stefano Antonini
6. How should we interpret the breakdown of bulk EFT at late times in evaporating
black holes/in closed universes?
Hint: A holographic dual theory should be able to describe the experience of a bulk
observer. In highly non-isometrically encoded spacetimes this seems to not be the case,
even at low curvature, unless the observer experiences a drastic breakdown of EFT. Is
there a consistent way to describe this bulk EFT from a holographic theory? Or should
we completely give up the bulk EFT?
Iosif Bena
7. There has been a great deal of work on counting black hole microstates, and on
using Euclidean saddle points to achieve this. But what does the actual Lorentzian
microstate structure look like?
Micha Berkooz
8. What are we averaging over in gravity? How much does it wash over relative to
the various dual theories (if at all)? In 𝑫 > 𝟐, it seems that various proposal work
in some regime, but none works in all regimes.
Nathan Berkovits
9. Why is the same scattering equation used by Gross-Mende near the tensionless
limit of the string also useful for computing 𝜶′ = 𝟎 super-YM/sugra scattering
amplitudes as shown by Cachazo et al.?
Nikolay Bobev
10. Is there a version of the OSV conjecture for (supersymmetric) black holes in AdS?
Hint: Perhaps use AdS/CFT and the many explicit results for partition functions of
supersymmetric CFTs on compact Euclidean manifolds as guidance to formulating such a
conjecture.
Shira Chapman
Hint: Can quantum information measures point us in the right direction to look for such
a system?
Shai M. Chester
12. What can be learned about quantum gravity from a non-perturbative computation
of correlators in holographic CFTs for finite 𝑵 and coupling?
Hint: Black hole states should be dual to high dimension operators in the CFT, and
quantum gravity should give a prediction of how the statistics of these states change as a
function of 𝑁 and coupling.
Minjae Cho
13. How do we describe strings in time-dependent backgrounds?
Hint: Find a time-dependent solution to the string field equations (if no exact worldsheet
CFT description is available). What are the physical observables we should compute in
such a background?
Atish Dabholkar
Xi Dong
Michael R. Douglas
16. Is there a simple description of the complete set (or moduli space) of all string/M
compactifications with 𝟖 supercharges? And, of all such quantum gravity theories.
Are they the same?
Roberto Emparan
17. Which singularities can string theory resolve, and which it likely cannot?
Hint: String theory (with finite alpha' effects, but no loops) seems to be able to deal with
naked singularities that violate weak cosmic censorship, but appears powerless to
resolve the ones in black hole interiors.
Johanna Erdmenger
18. Can we use recent developments in string theory for a new look at understanding
non-abelian gauge theories?
Hint: Combine insights from bootstrap, amplitudes, dual resonance, AdS/QCD, EFTs, you
name it...
19. Can concepts from quantum information theory be used to find the space of QFTs
with gravity duals, possibly beyond string theory, and/or to prove the AdS/CFT
conjecture?
Alon Faraggi
20. Is the Higgs particle fundamental or composite? Does the Higgs sector consist of a
single Higgs state, as in the Standard Model, or of a multi-state sector, as in the two
Higgs doublet model and the supersymmetric models? Can one construct
composite Higgs string models that can be competitive with the string models that
utilise a fundamental scalar Higgs state (e.g. hep-ph/9306235 or 2404.16933) in
producing qualitatively detailed flavour structure? To what extent can the cubic
and quartic SM Higgs couplings be probed at the HL-LHC?
Matthias Gaberdiel
21. Can we prove the 𝐀𝐝𝐒𝟓 /𝐂𝐅𝐓𝟒 duality at least at one point in moduli space?
Hint: Can we construct the worldsheet theory that is dual to free SYM in 4𝐷?
Steven Giddings
22. How does string theory address the question of scattering at energies far beyond
the Planck energy, and particularly that of its unitarity?
Hint: Many may believe that the resolution lies in dualities like AdS/CFT; for those that
do: What is the precise nature of the “holographic map,” and in particular how do we
use it to sharply construct quantities relevant for describing physics seen by bulk
observers? (And is it described as an isometry between Hilbert spaces, or something
else?)
Rajesh Gopakumar
Hint: Short distance (UV) on the boundary CFT translates into short distance on the
worldsheet of the dual string theory. Should therefore be able to translate OPEs in the
former to that of the latter.
Victor Gorbenko
24. What is the worldsheet theory of the confining string in pure large-𝑵 Yang-Mills?
Hint: It may be easier to understand very long static or rotating strings first.
Monica Guica
Tobias Hansen
26. What is the world-sheet theory for type IIb strings on 𝐀𝐝𝐒𝟓 × 𝐒 𝟓?
Hint: Recent progress on fixing the AdS Virasoro-Shapiro amplitude from conformal
bootstrap provides new input for this question.
Jonathan Heckman
27. What is the space of quantum field theories which arise from decoupling limits of
quantum gravity?
Gary Horowitz
28. What replaces the semiclassical description of spacetime near a black hole
singularity, and how is it described holographically?
Veronika Hubeny
29. If entanglement underlies the essence of physical systems and in particular the
emergence of classical dynamical spacetime, how does it work in (or chime with)
the generally covariant context of a Lorentzian spacetime?
Hint: Figure out what type of subsystems can be meaningfully entangled, understand
how bulk locality can arise from these, and subject the proposal to scrutiny in extreme
regimes (such as for gravitational shock waves and more ambitiously black hole interior
and cosmology).
Daniel Jafferis
30. What is the framework that describes observations in the interior of dynamical
spacetimes?
Hint: What lessons should be taken from state specific reconstructions and the role of
the observer?
Andreas Karch
31. Can we get the holographic dual of type IIB on 10d Minkowski space from the
Carroll limit of 𝑵 = 𝟒 SYM?
No hint. But if the answer is yes, I assume we'll know within the next 10 years :)
Cindy Keeler
Hint: We have evidence that EFT provides inaccurate answers (e.g. for quantum
information questions about black holes), and some notion that the complexity of the
question asked may hinder EFT's accuracy. However we have not codified which
theories, or which questions within those theories, fail to be accurately addressed by
EFT means.
Manki Kim
33. Can we formulate string theory in cosmological backgrounds, e.g., de Sitter and
quintessence?
Hint: String field theory in Ramond-Ramond and time dependent backgrounds?
34. Can we provide a UV complete prescription for gravitational path integral? Does
this lead to a better understanding of black hole information problem?
Igor Klebanov
Shota Komatsu
Hint: Based on the analogy with quantization of non-compact and compact phase
spaces, one possibility may be to replace matrix integrals dual to non-compact Calabi-
Yau's with finite discrete sums.
David Kosower
Background: String theory had its origins as a theory of hadrons. Since then, we've
discovered there's an enormously rich structure of string theory as a fundamental
theory. But the utility of having a "string-like" theory of hadrons, to bridge the gap
between perturbative QCD and low-energy expansions such as chiral Lagrangians, would
still be great. It would allow a systematization of nonperturbative contributions to jet
physics and improve the precision of theory predictions for collider physics. The
required theory would be an "effective" string theory, by analogy with effective
Lagrangians it would have a cut-off above which it would lose validity; it would have
many parameters which would be determined by matching at the cut-off (in the case of
strong interactions, to perturbative QCD). The evolution of these parameters would be
determined by string RG equations, and so on.
37. What are the prospects for developing these ideas in the next ten years?
Raghu Mahajan
38. It would be desirable to have a classical action for closed string field theory which
is not an infinite series of n-point amplitudes. What is the correct underlying
mathematical structure that is needed to write down such an action? Or is it simply
not possible?
Juan Maldacena
39. Could we understand better any holographic example relating matrix integrals to
Euclidean gravity solutions that are described by Einstein gravity?
Hint: Understand better the connection between the D(-1) brane matrix integral and its
gravity dual, the near horizon region of D(-1) branes. Are there interesting quantities we
can compute on both sides and make a comparison?
Emil J. Martinec
40. In gauge/gravity duality, horizon formation in the bulk geometry is dual to the
deconfinement transition in the gauge theory; how are these deconfined degrees
of freedom described on the bulk side of the duality?
Hint: Can we use giant gravitons, supertubes and/or other stringy probes to keep track
of the underlying branes in the bulk?
Henry Maxfield
41. When does perturbative quantum GR provide a reliable approximation for
cosmological spacetimes?
Hint: For old black holes, for calculating some quantities, we’ve recently learned of large
non-perturbative gravitational effects. Do similar considerations apply to late time de
Sitter space, for example?
René Meyer
42. Can string theory unravel the physics of the strange metal phase of high
temperature superconductors?
Hint: We have successful bottom-up AdS/CFT models which reproduce the main
properties of the strange metallic phase of high temperature superconductors. In order
to make further progress in understanding these phases, the construction and analysis
of top-down AdS/CFT dual pairs inspired by our bottom-up models might be useful.
Joseph Minahan
Hint: Can we use AdS/CFT and future progress in understanding (2,0) SCFTs beyond the
BPS level (perhaps involving bootstrapping) to address the M theory question?
Shiraz Minwalla
44. Is the tree-level Einstein S matrix the only consistent asymptotically flat classical n
graviton S matrix (classical= only poles and no cuts) that does not include pole
exchange contributions from particles of arbitrarily high spin?
45. Do the tree-level n graviton Einstein, Type II and Heterotic S matrices constitute
an exhaustive listing of such S matrices once we drop the constraint on the spins of
exchange poles?
Notes:
o `Consistent' means respecting all relevant general physical principles.
o #44 has been established for 4-graviton scattering assuming a constraint on growth
of tree level S matrices with energy (CRG conjecture). Exercise: Prove CRG and
extend to n-point scattering.
o Either a proof or counterexample would be interesting. In searching for
counterexamples note that
[a] Tree-level Type II/ Heterotic graviton S matrices on 𝑅 4 × CY are universal
(independent of the CY).
[b] May be useful to systematically study warped string compactifications for which
the dilaton is a modulus.
Sebastian Mizera
46. Can recent insights into the S-matrix bootstrap lead to a better understanding of
confining strings in non-Abelian gauge theories?
Miguel Montero
47. Can we precisely quantify or prove a bound on the amount of breaking of global
symmetries in quantum gravity? (e.g., scale/coefficient of symmetry breaking
operators)
Hint: Try to make sense of black hole loops or wormhole effects generating EFT
operators. Perhaps first try AdS quantum gravity, where CFT crossing can relate light to
heavy stuff.
Gregory W. Moore
48. Can methods of supersymmetric field theory and/or string theory be used to
define new invariants of smooth four-dimensional manifolds? (``New'' in the sense
that they can distinguish non-diffeomorphic manifolds which cannot be
distinguished by the Seiberg-Witten invariants (and hence by the Donaldson
invariants).)
Hint: Evidence is mixed whether (K-theoretic or elliptic) Donaldson invariants for non-
Lagrangian field theories will produce such invariants.
Hint: Good people have tried hard for the past 14 years, and we are still waiting for the
"Ah Ha!" moment. So if the answer is yes, probably a new idea is required.
50. Is there a universally applicable (and acceptable) definition of fully local (aka fully
extended) Quantum Field Theory?
51. Will AI answer all the questions in this document, and render the profession of
theoretical physicist obsolete?
Jakob Moritz
52. Can we use microscopic constructions of de Sitter cosmologies in string theory,
such as KKLT, in order to find a notion of microstates that can account for the de
Sitter entropy? Or, given any Anti de Sitter vacuum in string theory, can we give a
general prescription for finding microscopic degrees of freedom that produce the
dual CFT in the IR?
Nikita Nekrasov
53. Do non-unitary 2d CFTs and RG flows around them represent Lefschetz thimbles
for non-perturbative definition of string theory?
Hint: Liouville theory at complex values of the b parameter, WZW model for complex k,
to some extent, can be defined through unitary 𝑑 = 4, 𝑁 = 2 theory.
54. What is the world-sheet formulation of string theory in non-stationary
backgrounds?
Paul-Konstantin Oehlmann
55. String Universality seems to be almost established in theories with a lot of Susy
and spacetime dimensions but is there anything we can really say from the bottom
up when there is no supersymmetry?
Hint: Non-Susy string theories provide one top-down direction for UV complete non-
susy theories but is there a bottom-up principle as to why those may be the only one.
Hirosi Ooguri
56. Can we define a distance between any pair of conformal field theories that are
not necessarily related by marginal perturbations? More generally, what is the
structure of the space of all quantum field theories?
Reference:
o Michael R. Douglas, http://arxiv.org/abs/1005.2779.
o Constantin P. Bachas, Ilka Brunner, Michael R. Douglas, Leonardo Rastelli,
http://arxiv.org/abs/1311.2202.
58. Can we settle the question of whether the KKLT construction can be realized in
string theory?
Sridip Pal
Veronica Pasquarella
60. How can category theory and representation theory be extended to fully
understand the embedding of the Standard Model in string theory?
Hint: As far as I know there are several attempts towards understanding the role they
play in different setups. My opinion is that they are complementary parts of a more
complete perspective.
Hint: The lore is that the symmetry must be either broken or gauged at high energies. If
it’s broken, is the minimum value of the cross section simply related to the scale of
breaking? If it’s gauged, is it related to the scale of magnetically charged objects? For
proton decay, an oft-used bound is given by the lowest dimension baryon-number-
violating operator in the SMEFT with a coefficient suppressed by the Planck scale. Is
this naive expectation actually correct?
Sabrina Pasterski
63. How can we better utilize the annual Strings meeting to foster collaboration
among the various subfields of high-energy theoretical physics?
João Penedones
64. Can we identify the essential property of some quantum mechanical systems that
leads to an emergent gravitational description?
Hint: Study an example with a finite number of degrees of freedom. How are the Lin-
Maldacena geometries encoded in the wavefunctions of the degenerate ground states
of the Berenstein-Maldacena-Nastase matrix quantum mechanics?
Cheng Peng
65. Can we find a set of axioms that help rule out inconsistent ensemble average
theories?
Eric Perlmutter
66. Can we quantitatively describe large scale structures in the space of unitary,
generic CFTs?
Andrea Puhm
67. What is the holographic dual of a black hole in asymptotically flat space and are
infrared effects important in the discussion of unitary evolution?
Hint: What tools from AdS can we carry over or adapt to flat space?
Grant Remmen
68. Can we prove that string theory is the only consistent perturbative ultraviolet
completion of gravity?
Hint: Can we cast the question in terms of the S-matrix at weak coupling and identify a
set of constraints that uniquely bootstrap the amplitudes of string theory, including
crossing, dual resonance, n-point factorization, and possibly other criteria?
Moshe Rozali
69. Can we understand in detail the emergence of a smooth black hole horizon as an
effective description of a single unitary quantum system (e.g. 𝑵 = 𝟒 SYM) in a pure
highly excited microstate?
Hint: The continuous spectrum in the presence of the black hole hints at some effective
coarse graining. Aspects of thermalization indicate that this coarse graining is closely
related to the emergence of quantum statistical mechanics for closed unitary systems
(as encoded e.g. in the ETH). In simple examples such coarse graining can be derived
from first principles.
Ivo Sachs
Hint: Explore finite exactly marginal backgrounds with mixed RR and NS fluxes.
Ricardo Schiappa
Hint: This is likely reachable within matrix models, minimal, and topological string
theories. Will those results serve as a clue towards generic string theoretic backgrounds
or will something else be required?
Ashoke Sen
72. Can non-perturbative string theory be defined as the sum of the contributions
from its saddle points?
Hint: For generic complex values of the coupling constant, the Borel resummation of the
perturbation expansion around a saddle point is expected to generate the result of the
path integral over the Lefschetz thimble associated to that saddle point. So, if we knew
how to generate perturbation expansion around all the saddle points and also how the
desired integration contour is expressed as a sum of the Lefschetz thimbles, we have in
principle a non-perturbative definition of the theory. In string theory, we have a
systematic procedure for generating perturbation expansion around the perturbative
saddle and the Euclidean D-brane saddles. Can we develop such expansions around
other saddle points (e.g. the NS 5-brane saddles, wormholes etc) and in parallel explore
how the desired integration contour might be expressed as a union of the Lefschetz
thimbles of different saddles?
Atul Sharma
Hint: Find a use for the w-infinity symmetry of celestial holography to bootstrap
graviton loop amplitudes in Einstein gravity, similar to Costello's two-loop all plus gluon
amplitude computation in certain QCD-like theories using celestial holographic and
twistorial techniques.
Gary Shiu
74. Does the Gibbons-Hawking entropy for (quasi) de Sitter space actually count
microstates?
Hint: Perhaps progress in understanding the wavefunction of the universe can shed light
on this problem.
Aninda Sinha
75. Can Quantum information ideas help us narrow the space of theories in the S-
matrix bootstrap and along these lines is string theory special?
Kostas Skenderis
76. Would holography help us understand, or shed new light on, some of the
mysteries of the Standard Model (why this specific field content, neutrino masses,
etc.), or more generally to questions like “what is dark matter and dark energy”?
Hint: Holography maps gauge symmetries in the bulk to global symmetries of the
boundary theory, so if there is a dual three-dimensional QFT which is dual to our four-
dimensional universe it should have as its global symmetry the gauge group of the
standard model. Can we classify, say using bootstrap ideas, (or find examples of) such
theories with low-lying spectrum of operators that matches the field context of the
Standard Model? Such QFTs would provide a non-perturbative definition of quantum
gravity coupled to the standard model and may provide new insight about long-standing
questions.
Julian Sonner
77. Can quantum gravity be realized and explored as an emergent many-body phase
in real-world experiments? If so, what can be learned from them?
Douglas Stanford
78. Do correlation functions decay to zero for large time/space separation in de Sitter
quantum gravity?
Andrew Strominger
79. What is one example of a top-down construction of a 2D celestial dual for a string
compactification to four dimensions?
Hint: Work of Stieberger and Taylor and Castiblanco, Giribet, Marin and Rojas suggest a
relation to the 2𝐷 string worldsheet CFT. Both compute the 4𝐷 S-matrix.
80. Does conformally self-dual gravity with 𝑮𝝁𝝂 = 𝚲𝒈𝝁𝝂 have a consistent quantum
definition on 𝐀𝐝𝐒𝟒? If so, what is its holographic dual?
Hint: See Ward, Richard S. "Self-dual space-times with cosmological constant.” Comm.
Math. Phys. 78 (1980).
Hint: The effect is roughly proportional to the change in the first time derivative of the
dipole moment, which is large at a beam dump. The experimental challenges, which
include minimizing field transients, resemble those for the electric Aharonov-Bohm
effect as discussed for example in van Oudenaarden et.al., Nature 391 (1998) or R.
Weder J. Math. Phys. 52 (2011).
Haoyu Sun
82. Is it possible to systematically extend the power of integrability beyond the planar
limit?
Hint: A rather comprehensive review was given in arXiv:1012.3997, consistent with the
common lore that integrability is not too useful beyond the planar limit. The latest
results, which are from arXiv:1711.05326, suggest that one should consider the
worldsheet in general topology, and treat handles using twisted operators to always
maintain locality. Is there a non-perturbative way to implement this? This perspective
begs a further question: can one use integrability to compute correlators or anomalous
dimensions of extended operators, say in the planar limit for simplicity?
Yuji Tachikawa
83. The founding members of modern string theory, who have been so influential thus
far, will gradually retire and/or go to their next stage of existence. Will the string
theory community as a whole survive this transition? We will definitely see how
well we would cope with this in the next ten years.
Hint: Train an LLM with the very best papers written by the founding members, so that it
can continue to set the trend of the community.
Tadashi Takayanagi
Hint: Understand how the AdS/CFT calculates various quantities (e.g. energy spectra,
correlation functions, entanglement entropy and complexity) in the language of
quantum circuits or their generalization.
Washington Taylor
85. Can recent progress on holography and the black hole information problem
provide useful insights into the formulation of a nonperturbative background-
independent theory of quantum gravity and/or the structure of the string
landscape?
Ethan Torres
86. How do we classify all of the possible branes in supersymmetric string theories?
Hint: In the past couple of years, some works motivated by the Swampland Cobordism
Conjecture have provided evidence for new non-BPS branes in Type II and heterotic
string theories.
Extra credit: One of these branes (a non-BPS 4-brane in E8 × E8 heterotic string theory)
has an integer charge lattice. Does taking a large-𝑁 limit of these lead to a sensible non-
SUSY AdS6 /CFT5 correspondence?
Piotr Tourkine
87. Can we build numerically consistent two-to-two S-matrices in four dimensions
that satisfy crossing, unitarity, analyticity, and display Froissart growth?
Hint: A better understanding of Regge theory and a way to implement it within the S-
matrix bootstrap would allow to improve the control on the various limits of the S-
matrix, high energy, large spin, etc. Conversely, the numerical S-matrix program should
tell us precious information on possible non-perturbative Regge behaviours.
Gustavo J. Turiaci
88. Can we derive the rules for computing the gravitational path integral from string
theory? How constraining is the expectation that black holes behave as ordinary
quantum systems on such rules?
Mithat Unsal
Irene Valenzuela
90. Can we find a bottom-up rationale for the Swampland Distance Conjecture (i.e.
the existence of towers of states becoming exponentially light at the infinite
distance boundaries of the moduli space)?
Hint: Can we find an inconsistency using black hole physics or S-matrix bootstrap if the
tower is not there?
Thomas Van Riet
91. Do we think holography without supersymmetry in the UV & full stability of the
vacuum (dS holography, non-SUSY AdS & celestial holography) is achievable?
Hint: Should one look at non-unitary field theories as a proxy for describing meta-stable
vacua inside theories with stable SUSY vacua?
Hint: There are often asymptotically AdS regions in the Euclidean continuation of the
cosmological spacetime.
Shreya Vardhan
93. What is the bulk dual of a single high energy eigenstate of the boundary theory?
Hint: If we could show that such states have exponentially high circuit complexity, what
would that tell us about the region behind the horizon?
Vatsal
Spenta Wadia
95. What is the signature of the black hole singularity in the dual field theory on the
boundary of 𝐀𝐝𝐒𝒅 (𝒅 > 𝟐)?
Xi Yin
96. Can string field theory be formulated at a fully non-perturbative and quantum
level?
Masahito Yamazaki
Hint: Formulate string theory as a "game" with a well-defined "reward", and let the
machines take care of the "trial and error" part.
Alexander Zhiboedov
Hint: Current bootstrap bounds allow essentially any QFT at low energies. This is in sharp
contrast with explicit constructions in string theory which come with a lot of extra
structure. To narrow this theoretical gap we perhaps need to learn how to impose
quantum consistency of black holes.
Yoav Zigdon
99. Can we construct a ground-state wavefunction of the Universe from string theory
that corresponds to our Universe?
Hint: Such a wavefunction might describe a phase of the early Universe with extended
objects wrapping Euclidean time.
Anonymous