Airbus FAST Magazine 44 p8 p16
Airbus FAST Magazine 44 p8 p16
Airbus FAST Magazine 44 p8 p16
FAST 44
Alain LEROUX Head of Multi-Programme and Business Consolidation Airbus Customer Services
Background
As a result of a major accident resulting from a fuel tank explosion, in 1996 the Federal Aviation Authority (FAA) Technical Centre undertook researches into fuel tank flammability and ignition risks. Since 2000, Airbus has actively been involved in flammability reduction, conducting studies for the FAA and flight tests on the A320 prototype in 2003. As a result of these researches, the FAA has developed a rule that requires operators and manufacturers of air transportation categories to take actions that will reduce the exposure to catastrophic fuel tank explosion. This can be achieved by mitigating the two main conditions that must be present in a fuel tank to support combustion that can lead to a fuel tank explosion: An ignition source, A flammable fuel-air gaseous mixture. The prevention of ignition is covered by the FAA (SFAR 88) and EASA (INT- Policy 25/12) requirements for which Airbus demonstrated the full means of compliance in May 2006. As well as aircraft and equipment modifications, these requirements have also been introduced in the new Critical Design Configuration Control Limitations (CDCCLs). The process has been set up to reduce the potential ignition sources within the fuel tanks (i.e. pumps, wirings...) whereas the Fuel Tank Inerting System (FTIS) is a means to reduce the flammability of the fuel tanks. So both are complementary and cannot supersede each other.
Fuel vapour
Flammability reduction
Ignition source
Oxygen
The FAA and EASA have developed requirements for design precautions to mitigate the risks associated to fuel tank flammability.
FAA
On 21 July 2008, FAA required operators and manufacturers to incorporate a Flammability Reduction Means (FRM) or Ignition Mitigation Means (IMM) on fuel tanks having a flammability exposure exceeding certain thresholds, following the official published FAR 25, 26, 121, 125 and 129 amendments. These amendments affect new aircraft type certification, new aircraft in production and inservice aircraft produced after 1 January 1992 (see information box on the following page).
FAST 44
EASA
notes
For new aircraft, EASA (European Aviation Safety Agency) have issued for consultation a draft amendment to CS-25 (NPA 200819) which is harmonized with the corresponding American standard (FAR 25). A final decision is expected by the 2nd quarter of 2009. For in-production and in-service aircraft, EASA have stated they will publish in 2009 a NPA to CS 26 and a Safety Directive to be adopted by the 4th quarter of 2010 after taking into account the received comments.
Airbus demonstrated that only the centre tank of some of its existing aircraft has fleet average flammability exposure exceeding 7% and is affected by the requirements of the FAR Part 26. There is no necessity to do any modification on other tanks. It concerns the following aircraft: A320 Family, A330-200, A340-200, A340-300, A340-500, A340-600, A300-600. At the date of publishing, the rules apply only for passenger aircraft produced and delivered after 1 January 1992 flying with US operators or N-registered passenger aircraft.
SYSTEM DESCRIPTION
information
The Airbus solution for the A320 Family and A330/A340 Family is based on a system developed with the supplier, Parker, which reduces the oxygen levels of the centre tank ullage space. The installation of this new device is designed to avoid the modification of existing systems and structures. The Fuel Tank Inerting System (FTIS) interfaces with the following systems: Fuel systems, Environmental Control Systems, Engine bleed air supply systems. Several other alternate means have been studied (e.g. reduction of heat sources, tank pressurisation and foam). But they lead either to important structure modifications or operational constraints. One solution studied was to use bottled nitrogen, but it was dismissed due to the significant required additional airport infrastructure and the impact on aircraft Turn Around Time (TAT).
FAST 44
10
Figure 1
Installation of the FTIS (Fuel Tank Inerting System) in the left hand side of the belly fairing
The system is installed in the left hand side of the aircraft belly fairing as shown in figure 1.
PRINCIPLE
The system (see figure 2) provides protection against fuel tank fire and explosion by creating an inert condition within the ullage space of the fuel tanks. This is achieved by using oxygen depleted air known as Nitrogen Enriched Air (NEA) to displace the oxygen in the tank ullage spaces. The system is based on a continuous flow principle and produces NEA from conditioned engine bleed air by gas separation, then injects it into the tank.
notes
Figure 2
Ullage is the space within a fuel tank above the liquid propellant.
Oxygen Enriched Air (OEA)
11
FAST 44
TECHNICAL DESCRIPTION
The architecture (see figure 3) is broken down in two major subsystems: 1) The Conditioned Service Air System (CSAS) 2) The Inert Gas Generation System (IGGS)
THE CSAS
from the sensors. The ozone converter reduces the amount of ozone in the bleed air to protect the IGGS components. The CSAS controller, located in the avionics bay, performs the system control and health monitoring BITE (Built In Test Equipment) and is interfaced with the Flight Warning System (FWS) and maintenance computer.
THE IGGS
Some bleed air is taken from the pneumatic air distribution system and then cooled down to a level compatible with the IGGS subsystem using the air from the exiting ECS (Environmental Control System) ram air channel. It is organized into two functional elements: a temperature control subsystem and the CSAS Isolation Valve with an ozone converter subsystem. Driven by the CSAS controller, the solenoid Controlled Isolation Valve ensures the shutdown of the system if the engine bleed air pressure is abnormally low or if over-pressure or over-temperature is detected
A320: Installation of the Isolation valve and Ozone converter
It uses Air Separation Modules (ASM) to filter the conditioned air stream, creating Nitrogen Enriched Air (NEA) and Oxygen Enriched Air (OEA) (see figure 4); the OEA is sent overboard. The air at the ASM inlet remains clean, free of hydrocarbons, dust and other contaminants thanks to the HEPA (High Efficiency Particle Air) filter. Being connected to the fuel tank, the system must meet very stringent safety requirements:
A320: Nitrogen Enriched Air going into the centre tank
C35
Ozone converter
ASM
Flight direction
C35
FAST 44
12
Air greater than 200 C must not come into contact with fuel or fuel vapour, Fuel tanks must not be over-pressurized, Prevention means for fuel ingress upstream to the ASM. Sensors, valves and controllers ensure these safety requirements. Downstream of the ASM is an oxygen sensor ensuring that the oxygen concentration is below 12%. A Dual Flow Shut Off Valve is then used to control the NEA flow to the fuel tank and enables the system to switch between low/mid/high NEA flows, and to isolate the IGGS from the fuel tank. NEA is distributed from the IGGS to the fuel tank through a twin check valve which provides a double barrier to the potential back-flow of fuel. The IGGS controller provides system control and health monitoring/ BITE.
FWC CFDIU/CMC
CSAS controller
Isolation valve
Centre tank
O3 converter
Overboard exit
It is the core of the Inert Gas Generation System. The objective is to reduce the centre wing tank ullage O2 concentration to below 12% during most conditions. Each ASM is a semi-permeable hollow bre
membrane bundle contained in a pressure containment canister. This canister is a cylinder with three ports. There is only one ASM on the A320 Family aircraft, two on the A330-200 and A340-200/300, and three on the A340-500/600. Nitrogen Enriched Air Product
O2 Rich Waste
NEA
13
FAST 44
FTIS operation
information
The Fuel Tank Inerting System (FTIS) operates during flight when the bleed air is supplied. The system does not operate when the aircraft is on the ground, except during maintenance operations. It has three flow modes designed to achieve the flammability reduction objective during the different flight phases: Low is used in climb and cruise, Medium is used in approach and slow descent, High is used in descent. The FTIS will not be operational when either the electrical power or the bleed are unavailable, nor when the anti-ice is ON with a nonoperating engine (i.e. A330).
OPERATIONAL IMPACTS
Any system fault leading to the loss of inerting capability generates a cockpit and maintenance message at the end of the flight (flight phase 10) for maintenance purposes: For A320 Family a maintenance STATUS: INERT FAULT, For A330/A340 Family an ECAM message: FUEL INERTING SYS FAULT. The aircraft can be dispatched under Minimum Equipment List (MEL) with the system inoperative during 10 days with no specific maintenance action. The implementation of these new cockpit and fault messages requires upgraded standards of the Flight Warning Computers (FWC) and maintenance computers (CFDIU for the A320 Family, CMC for the A330/A340 Family) (see information note).
MAINTENANCE IMPACTS
n s ctio ilot a p No
for
Temperature Controle Module
r ed qui re
The FTIS has automatic control with no requirement for crew intervention.
In order to ease the maintenance, the heat exchanger with the Hot Air Bypass Valve, the Temperature and pressure sensors of the CSAS subsystem are installed in the Temperature Control Module (TCM) (see figure 5).
Figure 5
CSAS Temp Control Module (TCM) Ram Air Flow CSAS Heat Exchanger
FAST 44
14
Airbus has taken the same approach for the design of the IGGS. A pallet is used to group the major IGGS components. They are as seen in figure 6: The Gate Valve, The HEPA filter, The Pressure sensor, The Temperature sensor, The ASM (s), The Oxygen sensor, The Dual Flow Shut Off Valve and ducting. In order to maintain the system performance and to minimize the exposure to unscheduled maintenance, some scheduled maintenance actions are required as described in table 1.
Tie rod attachments (MS14103 Spherical Brg.) Dual Flow Shut Off Valve Temperature sensor Pressure sensor O2 sensor Gate valve Air inlet NEA outlet filter Aft pallet bracket OEA outlet Nameplate ASM
Table 1 Task time (hours) Check labor time (hours) Interval 0.75 1.2 27,000 hours Procedure 1 2 Remove and replace, leak test Remove and replace, leak test Remove and replace
0.28 Replace lter element Ozone Converter cleaning Heat Exchanger cleaning Check valve and DFSOV Leak test 3 0.58
0.45
7000 hours
0.75
6000 hours
Under such a hypothesis, a strong coordination with every operator is a must. A well-prepared retrofit and embodiment planning has to be set up between the operators and Airbus to avoid any industrial bottlenecks.
1 2
1.0
1.5
12,000 hours
No special tools or test equipment required for scheduled maintenance tasks Drain cap is opened to check for liquid fuel ingress following no operation MMEL periods or after a fuel tank overll 3 Valve Leak test is performed at the liquid drain plug location and the test port location between the check valves
15
FAST 44
glossary ASM: Air Separation Module BITE: Built In Test Equipment CFDIU: Centralised Fault Display Interface Unit CMC: Centralised Maintenance Computer CSAS: Conditioned Service Air System DFSOV: Dual Flow Shut Off Valve EASA: European Aviation Safety Agency ECS: Environmental Control System FAA: Federal Aviation Administration FAR: Federal Aviation Regulations FRM: Flammability reduction Mean FTIS: Fuel Tank Inerting System FWC: Flight Warning Computer HEPA: High Efciency Particle Air IGGS: Inert Gas Generation System IMM: Ignition Mitigation Mean MEL: Minimum Equipment List NEA: Nitrogen Enriched Air NPA: Notice for Proposed Amendment OEA: Oxygen Enriched Air RFC/RMO: Request For Change/ Retrot Modication Offer STC: Supplemental type Certicate TC: Type Certicate
Airbus Upgrade Services through the RFC/RMO process will provide customized commercial and technical services consisting of a retrofit package with: Two Service Bulletins: - One SB for the structural and electrical provisions, - One SB for the equipment installation allowing the customer to complete the retrofit in packages during C-checks, Airbus kits (brackets, pipes, rods, wiring, etc.), Specific FTIS equipment from Parker and Liebherr, The coordination of the kit and equipment deliveries.
Flight Warning Computers and maintenance computers standards should accept messages provided by the FTIS (see information for the requested corresponding standards). Upon request, technical support on site can be provided. Airbus will also provide relevant training courses to your maintenance staff.
EMBODIMENT ON AIRCRAFT
About 500 man-hours are needed with a lead-time of 7/8 days if done in one operation (provisions and installation). This takes into account the aircraft preparation (scaffolding, centre tank venting and all the tests). The work can be done in two packages (provisions, then equipment installation) allowing the operator to perform the modification within two C-checks.
information
Airbus documentation
SFAR 88: S.I.L. 28-072
Fuel tank protection against ignition source, FTIS: OIT 999.0007/06 ATA28-FAA NPRM on ammability reduction system retrot,
CONTACT DETAILS RFC/RMO queries [email protected] Technical queries Ronan ALLARD Design Manager Upgrade Services Airbus Customer Services Tel: +33 (0)5 62 11 07 73 Fax: +33 (0)5 62 11 08 47 [email protected]
Conclusion
To comply with the FAA ammability reduction rules, Airbus have developed the most cost effective technical compromise in terms of maintenance and operations. Airbus is fully committed in supporting the operators with these new requirements taking into account
FAST 44
the deadlines set up by the authorities. This can only be achieved with the cooperation of the concerned operators that will overcome this challenging embodiment of the Fuel Tank Inerting System technology by scheduling the installation in due time.
16