This document provides an overview of legal method and key concepts in law. It discusses:
- Legal method is the study of law and approaches used to meet individual and state needs.
- Law is a system of rules that govern behavior and are enforced by social institutions. Laws are made by governments through legislatures.
- Definitions of law focus on it being rules developed by governments to regulate conduct in areas like crime, trade, and social relations.
- The functions of law include protecting rights, settling disputes, and maintaining social order. Law is general, definite, and imposed by the state on all within its territory.
This document provides an overview of legal method and key concepts in law. It discusses:
- Legal method is the study of law and approaches used to meet individual and state needs.
- Law is a system of rules that govern behavior and are enforced by social institutions. Laws are made by governments through legislatures.
- Definitions of law focus on it being rules developed by governments to regulate conduct in areas like crime, trade, and social relations.
- The functions of law include protecting rights, settling disputes, and maintaining social order. Law is general, definite, and imposed by the state on all within its territory.
This document provides an overview of legal method and key concepts in law. It discusses:
- Legal method is the study of law and approaches used to meet individual and state needs.
- Law is a system of rules that govern behavior and are enforced by social institutions. Laws are made by governments through legislatures.
- Definitions of law focus on it being rules developed by governments to regulate conduct in areas like crime, trade, and social relations.
- The functions of law include protecting rights, settling disputes, and maintaining social order. Law is general, definite, and imposed by the state on all within its territory.
This document provides an overview of legal method and key concepts in law. It discusses:
- Legal method is the study of law and approaches used to meet individual and state needs.
- Law is a system of rules that govern behavior and are enforced by social institutions. Laws are made by governments through legislatures.
- Definitions of law focus on it being rules developed by governments to regulate conduct in areas like crime, trade, and social relations.
- The functions of law include protecting rights, settling disputes, and maintaining social order. Law is general, definite, and imposed by the state on all within its territory.
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 35
LEGAL METHOD
• It is an introductory course for new students to help them lay a foundation
for proper understanding and application of the various substantive rules and principles which they will come across. • The phrase ‘ legal methods’ contains two words – “legal” and “method”. • The word “legal” means something related to law, while the word “method” means a way or procedure of doing something in an organised and planned manner. • Thus, legal method is defined as the way and manner of doing things relating to law in the society. • Malemi in his book Nigerian Legal Method defines it as the study of law, and various methods, approaches, processes and procedures that can effectively and beneficially be used to meet the needs of the individual and the state. INTRODUCTION TO LAW • Law is a term which does not have a universally accepted definition, but one definition is that law is a system of rules and guidelines which are enforced through social institutions to govern behavior. • The corresponding word for the term ‘law’ in Hindu system is ‘Dharma’, in Islamic system it is ‘Hukum’, in Roman it is ‘Jus’, in French it is ‘Droit’, and in German it is ’Richt’. • Laws are made by governments, specifically by their legislatures. • The law shapes politics, economics and society in countless ways and serves as a social mediator of relations between people. DEFINITION OF LAW • Law is a rule of conduct developed by the government or society on a certain area. The law follows certain practices and customs to deal with crime, trade, social relations, property, finance, and more. The law is controlled and enforced by the governing authority. • The term law is commonly used for three things: • At first it is used to make “legal orders”. It represents the rule of adjustments of relationship and order conduct by systematic application of force of organized political society. • Secondly, law means the entire legal body which exists in one politically organized society. • Third, the use of law means official control of politically organized society. This gives rise to the real administration of justice and official content to guide judicial action. Law at its narrowest or strict sentiment is civil law or the law of the land. • Many jurists attempted to define the term Law. A. Idealistic definition - • According to Salmond – “the law may be defined as the body of principles recognizes and applied by the state in the administration of justice”. • In other words, law consists of rules recognized and acted upon by the courts of Justice. • John chipman Gray’s Definition of Law:- “the Law of the State or of any organized body of men is composed of the rules which the courts, that is the judicial organ of the body lays down for the determination of legal rights and duties.”. • B. POSITIVIST SCHOOL DEFINITION – • According to Austin “law is aggregate of rules set by men politically superior or sovereign to men as politically subject.” • “A law is command which obliges a person or persons to a course of conduct.” • He says, laws are man-made rules by sovereign imposed upon the society it governs. He equates a law to a “command” by a body which is politically higher. • HISTORICAL SCHOOL OF LAW - • Savigny's definition of law: He says that law is not a body of rules set by determinate authority but as rules consist partly of social habitat and partly of experience. He says law is found in the society, it is found in custom. FUNCTIONS OF LAW • Laws protect individual rights and freedoms. • The laws provide a framework and rules to help settle disputes between individuals. • Without law there will be no way to set the standard. • Laws help societies to maintain order. • To ensure maximum freedom of individuals; and • To satisfy the basic needs of the people. NATURE OF LAW • Law is a general rule of human behaviour in the state. It applies to all people of the state. All are equally subject to the laws of the state. • It is definite and it is formulated by the state. It is a rule made and implemented by the state. • State always acts through law. Laws are made and enforced by the government of the state. • It creates binding and authoritative values or decisions or rules for all the people of the state • Sovereignty of state is the basis of law and its binding character. • The purpose of law is to provide peace protection and security to the people and ensure conditions for their round development. CLASSIFICATION OF LAWS 1. Public and private law 2. Civil and Criminal law 3. National and International law 4. Statute and common law 5. General and special law 6. Natural and physical law • PUBLIC LAW – • It is concerned with the legal relation between the state and the individuals. All laws relating to the distribution and exercise of power by the state are the part of the public law. • The aim of the public law is promotion of social objectives and the protection of collective interest of individuals. • Example – criminal law, constitutional law and administrative law • PRIVATE LAW – • It is that part of the law which determines relationship between individuals in their ordinary private capabilities. • The primary purpose of private law is the protection of private interests. • Example - The law of contracts, law of torts, law of property. • CRIMINAL LAW – • Means law relating to crime. • It deals with offences and their punishments. • One of the major objectives of the criminal law is to punish the wrongdoer for action which is deemed to be contrary to the interests of the state and its citizens. • CIVIL LAW – • It provides remedies to individual victims, which are recognized by statutes or decided cases. • The civil law creates a framework which delvers the rights and obligations of individuals in their dealings with one another. • NATIONAL LAW – refers to internal legal rules of the country. • INTERNATIONAL LAW - body of rules which are regarded as legally binding on their relationship with other nations. • STATUTE LAW - law laid down in the acts of parliament. Bill proposed in the parliament becomes acts. • COMMON LAW – consists of those principles, usages and rules of action applicable to the Govt., security of personas and property. • Example – common law of Hindus regarding marriage, succession of property. • GENERAL LAW – those laws applicable to all persons and things in a country. • SPECIAL LAWS – applicable only to certain special circumstances. QUESTION OF LAW • Questions which arise for determination before a Court of law are considered either question of law or question of facts or a mixture of both, known as mixed questions of law and fact. • Question of law is that whose answer is already prescribed by rule of law. Thus, the question as to what is reasonable and proper punishment for murder is a question of law. • Such a state of affairs may be a matter of common occurrence because the language of the statute is often capable of assorted interpretations and it is during this sphere that the lawyers play the foremost important role. • For instance, A child under seven years of age does not have sufficient mental capacity to understand the nature of the consequences of the act done by him. • This rule is prescribed by law, that a child under seven years of age is incapable of committing a crime. The courts, therefore, have no option but to answer the question of the criminal capacity of such a child in the negative. QUESTION OF FACT • Question of fact is a question which must be answered by reference to facts and evidence and inference arising from those facts • It is usually dependent on particular circumstances or factual situations • Question of fact is that whose answer is not prescribed by law • Question of fact means a question apart from a question of law. Thus, • i). any question not answered by a fixed rule of law; • ii). Any question is other than what the law on a particular point is; • For instance, whether a child is under seven years of age or not, is a question of fact. And whether he can be tried for an offence, is a question of law. LAW AND ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE – PRINCIPLES & REMEDIES • Administration means management and justice means to right and equitable implication. • This phrase “administration of justice” means the maintenance of right within a political community by means of the physical force of the state. • There are two essential functions of the state – 1. war 2. administration of justice. • the main function of administration of justice is the protection of individual’s rights, enforcement of laws and punishment of criminals. • There are three points to define administration of justice – 1. Political organised society 2. Physical force of the state 3. Maintenance of right as the object. • ‘live well, and let live’ is the aim of justice. • Law on the other hand is the instrument of justice. It is the principle which enunciates and declares what is just and thus, law and justice are related. ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE • Justice may be natural justice(moral justice) or positive justice (legal justice). • Man, is by nature a fighting animal and needs teaching and discipline in order to be right. • According to Hobbes, “a common power is necessary to keep people within control in the community”. • First stage – in early stage when the society was primitive and private, vengeance and self help were the only remedies available to the wronged person against the wrongdoer. He could get his wrong addressed with the help of relative or friends. • Second stage – the second stage of development of society was characterised by the state coming into the existence in its rudimentary form when its function were only persuasive in nature. It did not have enforcing power by which it could punish the wrongdoer. • Third stage – wrongs could be redressed by payment of compensation by the wrongdoer to the victim who was affected by the wrongful act. Thus upto this time, the justice remained private in nature without the compulsive force of the state. • In the fourth stage of the society the state became more organised and more powerful. The state appointed people to adjudicate the rights and duties and secure their protection and enforcement. • In this way, courts came into existence. ADVANTAGES & DISADVANTAGES OF ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE • Uniformity and certainty • Impartiality • Collective wisdom • Provides stability • Security • DISADVANTAGES – • Rigidity • Technicalities • Complexity NECESSITY FOR ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE • For protection of rights • For peace and stability • For integration of society • To check injustice • To promote welfare • To promote equity • To educate people KINDS OF JUSTICE • Administration of justice can be broadly defined under two categories – civil and criminal. • They differ from each other in various ways – 1. They are administered by different set of courts 2. Procedures with administration of these two kinds are different. 3. Results of the proceedings are also different. 4. The difference between these two depends upon two different types of wrongs. ADMINISTRATION OF CIVIL JUSTICE • The wrongs which are the subject matter of civil proceedings are called civil wrongs. • The rights enforced by civil proceedings are of two kinds – 1. primary rights 2. sanctioning or remedial rights. • Primary rights are those rights which exist as such and do not have their source in some wrong. • Primary rights are those rights which exist as such. It arises our of a conduct. All fundamental rights are primary rights. A primary right may be enforced by specific enforcement. • Sanctioning rights are those which come into existence when primary rights are violated. • Sanctioning rights are enforced in two situations – 1. When it is not possible to enforce a primary right. 2. When even though the law can enforce the primary right, it odes not enforce it as a matter of policy and awards damages only. • The aim of sanctioning rights are to impose pecuniary penalty for loss or to award compensation. • The object of civil administration of justice is to ascertain the rights of the parties and the party who suffers from the breach of such rights is to be helped by way of paying damages or getting injunction, restitution and specific performance of contracts etc. CRIMINAL ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE • Administration of criminal justice deals with public wrongs. all offenses included in Indian Penal Code(IPC) are public wrongs. • The administration of criminal justice is to punish the offender. Punishment may be described as the infliction by State Authority, of a consequence normally regarded as an evil (for example imprisonment or death) on an individual found to be legally guilty of a crime. • It is the State which punishes the Criminal. Punishment necessarily implies some kinds of pain inflicted upon the offender or loss caused to him for his criminal act which may either be intended to deter him from repeating the crime or maybe an expression of society disapprobation for his Anti Social conduct or it may also be directed to reform and regenerate him and at the time ported the society from criminals. • Therefore the two main statues which deals with administration of criminal cases in our country are criminal procedure code i.e. Crpc and Indian penal code . • The procedure of administration of criminal justice in our country is divided into three stages namely investigation, inquiry and trial. The Criminal procedure code 1973 provides for the procedure to be followed in investigation, inquiry and trial, for every offence under the Indian Penal Code or under any other law. THEORIES OF PUNISHMENT • Punishment is a term which is inherent to criminal justice. • RETRIBUTIVE THEORY - The Retributive Theory of Punishment, or the ‘Theory of Vengeance’, as many people in the society would perceive it as, is the most basic, yet inconsiderate theory of inflicting a penal sentence over a perpetrator. • It is based on a very small doctrine, namely the doctrine of Lex talionis, which if translated, means ‘an eye for an eye’. • DETERRENT THEORY – the term ‘deter’ means to abstain from doing an act. The main purpose of this theory is to prevent criminals from doing the crime or repeating the same crime in future. • Under the theory, severe punishments are inflicted upon the offender so that he abstains from committing a crime in future and it would also be a lesson to the other members of the society as to what can be the consequences of committing a crime. • PREVENTIVE THEORY – Salmond and Holmes are the supporters of this theory. According to this theory, the punishment is for the purpose of disabling or preventing the criminal from committing the offense again. • Preventive mode of punishment works in three ways – 1. By inspiring all prospective wrong doers with the fear of punishment 2. By disabling the wrong doer 3. By transforming the wrong doer so that he would not commit the act again. • REFORMATIVE THEORY – the main objective is to reform the character of the criminal so that he will desire to do what is right instead of fearing to do what is wrong. • The theory points out that the crime is a disease so proper care should be taken of those who have committed a crime instead of awarding a severe punishment. • The theory takes into account the factor which compels the criminal to commit crime – his family, education, socio-economic background.