Gentle Parenting: What it is for Teachers (and parents!)

Many people, especially educators and school administrators dealing with behavior challenges in the classroom, are working hard to understand where the disconnect between adult expectations and student conduct is occurring. With the rising levels of disengagement, impulsivity, and what some term a “student apathy crisis,” there’s a natural urge to seek a clear-cut explanation. Gentle Parenting, due to its growing popularity and somewhat misunderstood principles, has frequently landed in the spotlight as a convenient scapegoat.

The problem is that the term “Gentle Parenting” has become a buzzword, easily weaponized and misinterpreted by those looking for a cause to blame, and more times than not, it is mistaken for “Permissive Parenting“.

What many critics fail to recognize is that Gentle Parenting is not the same as Permissive Parenting. Gentle Parenting focuses on empathy, connection, respectful communication, and an understanding of a child’s developmental needs. It involves setting boundaries, establishing expectations, and applying natural consequences in a way that values both the child’s dignity and their long-term emotional well-being. In contrast, Permissive Parenting eschews or fails to enforce necessary limits, often allowing children to act without guidance, structure, or meaningful consequences.

By lumping Gentle Parenting together with its permissive counterpart, skeptics fail to see the nuanced, intentional efforts that gentle parents make to foster emotional intelligence, respect, and resilience in their children. These efforts often translate to children who can articulate their emotions, empathize with others, and understand the rationale behind expectations set by adults. When done well, this approach cultivates internal motivation and cooperative behavior, qualities that educators frequently wish to see in their students.

However, because the concept of Gentle Parenting has become so visible and trendy, it’s easy for those less familiar with its true meaning to conflate it with the absence of structure or standards. They assume that the rise of unmotivated, disengaged students must be related to parents who don’t say “no” or fail to reinforce rules. Yet, attributing classroom behavior issues to Gentle Parenting ignores a host of other factors—ranging from classroom management strategies and school policies to mental health challenges, socio-economic conditions, and even the upheavals of recent global events.

(This post may contain affiliate links that won’t change your price but will share some commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read our disclosure policy for more information.)

If people continue to oversimplify and blame Gentle Parenting for what’s happening in educational environments, they not only do a disservice to parents genuinely striving for respectful, empathetic guidance, but they also miss the chance to address the more complex and systemic issues affecting student behavior. Ultimately, recognizing and preserving the distinction between Gentle and Permissive Parenting is essential, not just for the sake of parental reputation, but for the long-term benefit of children’s personal growth and academic success.

What is Gentle Parenting?

Gentle Parenting, also known as Respectful Parenting, is a philosophy that emphasizes understanding a child’s feelings and fostering mutual respect. It’s not about letting children have their own way all the time, as is often mistakenly assumed. Instead, it’s about using intentional parenting techniques that balance setting boundaries with nurturing a positive parent-child relationship. Sarah Ockwell-Smith, a prominent advocate of the gentle parenting philosophy, often emphasizes that Gentle Parenting involves hard work, conscious parenting, and understanding child development—not just allowing permissive behavior.

Social media has played a significant role in spreading the gentle parenting philosophy, as well as the misconceptions surrounding it. Platforms often showcase curated snippets of mindful parenting techniques, but these brief glimpses rarely capture the full spectrum of hard work, long days, and occasional moments of utter despair that come with parenting.

Critics often point to temper tantrums and epic meltdowns as evidence of Gentle Parenting’s “failure.” However, these are natural aspects of child development, especially in young kids who are still learning to regulate their nervous systems and process big emotions. Rather than labeling such moments as bad behavior, Gentle Parenting focuses on helping children understand their feelings and providing calming tools, such as deep breaths, a bear hug, or a calming mantra. This is not to say that the child’s behavior is excused; rather, it’s guided toward a better understanding of appropriate responses in real life.

A common misconception about Gentle Parenting is that it’s only effective for young children or that it’s incompatible with the real world. Critics often argue that children raised this way will struggle when faced with life’s demands or societal expectations. However, evidence suggests the opposite. Positive discipline techniques, when combined with an understanding of a child’s needs and choices, prepare children for the complexities of adulthood.

Books like “The Whole-Brain Child” and Sarah Ockwell-Smith’s “The Gentle Parenting Book” provide actionable strategies to bridge the gap between childhood and the real world (ad).

One of the biggest challenges for parents transitioning to this approach is dealing with their own upbringing. Many find themselves battling the ingrained habits passed down by their own parents, who might have used more punitive or authoritative methods. This internal conflict often surfaces during major meltdowns or challenging behavior, when the urge to revert to “mean mommy monster” tactics feels almost overwhelming. However, adopting a loving mantra or a calming mantra, such as “I am the calm my child needs,” can help parents navigate these moments and choose a gentler parenting decision.

The Distinction Between Gentle and Permissive Parenting

One of the key misunderstandings about the gentle parenting approach stems from confusing it with a permissive parenting style. Permissive parents often have a hard time setting firm limits, which can lead to challenging behavior as children fail to learn when their child’s choices might not align with doing the right things. In these households, if a little one throws a temper tantrum, a permissive parent might give in immediately just to restore peace, missing the chance to help the child navigate their emotions or understand the good reason behind certain expectations.

This lack of boundaries can grow more problematic as older children emerge, where guiding them through more complex issues—like limiting screen time, ensuring proper use of a car seat, or choosing favorite books over endless shows—becomes more difficult when they’ve never been taught how to handle life’s natural disappointments.

In contrast, a gentle parenting decision involves using a whole different set of tools that show empathy and respect without abandoning structure. Yes, children are human beings with big emotions and a need to feel good inside, but that doesn’t mean all requests get a free pass. Rather, gentle parents choose a gentle approach that maintains good relationships by combining empathy with clear boundaries.

For example, if Leo—let’s call our hypothetical child “Leo” to focus on Leo’s needs—refuses to put on his shoes, a gentle parent won’t simply say “good job” and ignore the issue. Instead, they’ll explain how wearing shoes keeps his feet warm or prevents injury, and if Leo still decides not to wear them, he might feel the chill of the cold floor outside.

Through this flow child experience, Leo naturally learns why he might want to wear shoes without his parent shaming him or reacting in the wrong way.

This approach doesn’t mean the parent never has a long day or becomes frustrated; it’s natural to feel overwhelmed. When that happens, taking a little bit of time to breathe, stepping to the other side of the door to calm down, or reading a new book on child development can help. A calm parent can return to address the situation from a place of understanding. Over time, these children internalize the lesson and become more aware of their bodies, their behaviors, and their impact on others.

They learn to cope with disappointment, follow through on requests for good reason, and adhere to boundaries because they understand them—not just to avoid punishment.

In the end, a gentle parenting approach aligns with the principles found in resources like “The Whole Brain Child” and encourages the parent to view their child as a collaborative partner rather than a subordinate. While permissive parenting focuses on keeping the peace at all costs, gentle parenting fosters growth, resilience, and emotional intelligence. It may not always be easy, but it’s a great idea for those who aspire to be the best parents they can be.

Gentle Parenting Versus Authoritative Parenting

Millennial parents, who are often at the forefront of adopting Gentle Parenting practices, frequently face much frustration in a society still dominated by older, more authoritative parenting styles. Authoritative parenting, while also effective, often relies on a top-down approach that might include punitive measures or rewards to ensure compliance. In contrast, Gentle Parenting takes a different route, focusing on positive reinforcement and joyful connection to guide a child toward good behavior.

For example, instead of yelling when a child throws an object, a gentle parent might calmly state, “Throwing things can hurt people. Let’s find a different way to show our big emotions.”

However, that doesn’t mean that the behavior should be allowed to continue. When a child is acting out in this way, their emotions are completely ruling their physical reactions. It isn’t until he or she can level this out that the understanding of the behavior will change. On that same note, an unregulated adult will never be able to regulate a child, so if you find your own frustrations growing in trying to eliminate a behavior, it is important to recognize that.

In these moments, parents should first focus on regulating themselves, perhaps by taking a few deep breaths or stepping away for a moment to reset. Seeking support, whether from a partner, a trusted friend, or even professional guidance, can also help restore emotional balance before re-engaging with the child.

The Role of Natural Consequences

This gentler approach does not mean there are no consequences. The Cleveland Clinic points out that natural consequences are a cornerstone of Gentle Parenting. By allowing children to experience the outcomes of their choices, parents help them develop a sense of accountability without resorting to negative words or punitive measures. These consequences are not imposed arbitrarily or out of anger; instead, they occur naturally as a result of a child’s own decisions.

This reinforces a more authentic kind of learning—one in which a child gains understanding through firsthand experience, rather than simply following rules out of fear or obligation.

For instance, if a child refuses to wear a coat on a chilly day, they might eventually feel cold—an uncomfortable sensation that encourages them to think twice before declining their coat the next time. In such a scenario, the parent does not need to issue threats, shame the child, or engage in a power struggle. The environment itself provides the necessary feedback. This approach fosters a stronger internal moral compass, helping children understand the logic behind a request or boundary, rather than feeling forced to comply to avoid punishment.

Furthermore, allowing natural consequences to unfold enables children to practice problem-solving skills. If they forget to bring a favorite toy to the park and feel disappointed later, they may be more inclined to remember it next time. Rather than having a parent lecture or scold them, the child’s own feelings of regret inform their future behavior.

Over time, these small life lessons build resilience and independence, preparing children for larger challenges as they grow older. They start to recognize that their actions—and in some cases, inactions—play a direct role in shaping the circumstances they encounter.

This approach also serves to preserve the parent-child relationship by minimizing conflict and resentment. When children understand the connection between their choices and the resulting outcomes, they are more likely to see their parent’s guidance as supportive rather than controlling. Without the tension of imposed punishments, parents and children can maintain a more harmonious atmosphere at home, which helps promote open communication and trust.

In this way, natural consequences encourage learning that is both respectful and lasting. Instead of struggling with defiance or relying on external rewards, children gain a sense of ownership over their behavior. Parents, too, benefit from this dynamic, as it relieves them from the role of constant enforcer and allows them to model empathy, patience, and understanding—qualities that guide children not just in the moment, but for years to come.

Real-Life Examples of Gentle Parenting

One example of Gentle Parenting in action might involve a grocery store scenario. Imagine a parent dealing with a major meltdown in the checkout line. Instead of resorting to threats or bribes, a gentle parent might take the child aside and acknowledge their feelings: “I see that you’re upset because we couldn’t get the toy. It’s hard when we don’t get what we want, but we can’t buy it today.” They might then offer a calming tool, like a big hug or encouraging deep breaths, to help the child regulate their emotions, but will not get the child the toy.

This kind of reaction fosters a joyful connection and helps the child feel seen and understood. It’s not about avoiding conflict but about approaching it in a way that strengthens the parent-child relationship. Over time, these interactions teach children that their feelings matter but also that there are boundaries and expectations in place.

Progress, Not Perfection

Adopting Gentle Parenting practices can be particularly challenging for parents with big reactors—children who express their emotions intensely and frequently. These situations require a clear plan and consistent use of calming tools to prevent a downward spiral into slaughterhouse screams or total failures. Parents might also find it helpful to focus on their own mental health by practicing self-care and seeking support from like-minded communities or resources like Sarah Ockwell-Smith’s books (ad).

Positive parenting is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Every child is unique, and what works for one may not work for another. For instance, while some young kids respond well to natural consequences, others might need a more structured approach to understanding the impact of their actions. The key is to remain flexible and committed to the principles of mutual respect and positive reinforcement.

Gentle Parenting also emphasizes the importance of modeling good behavior. Children learn a great deal from observing their parents, so demonstrating patience, kindness, and the ability to take deep breaths during stressful situations can have a profound impact. This kind of intentional parenting lays the foundation for a strong parent-child relationship built on trust and mutual respect.

It’s important to acknowledge that Gentle Parenting is not without its critics. Some argue that it’s a whole different ballgame for parents who are juggling multiple responsibilities or dealing with challenging circumstances, such as a new baby or a particularly demanding job. Others claim that it’s unrealistic to expect parents to remain calm and composed at all times. However, advocates emphasize that the goal is not perfection but progress. Even small steps toward a gentler approach can yield significant benefits for both parents and children.

The Long-Term Benefits of Gentle Parenting

In conclusion, Gentle Parenting is a positive thing that encourages mutual respect, mindful parenting, and a deeper understanding of a child’s needs and behavior. It’s not about permissiveness or avoiding life; it’s about teaching a child what to do with their emotions and actions. One of the greatest challenges facing millennial parents is the pressure to do everything “the right way.” Social media often amplifies this pressure, creating unrealistic expectations and fostering guilt when things don’t go as planned.

It’s essential to remember that parenting is a journey, not a destination. Mistakes are inevitable, but they don’t define a parent’s worth or their ability to raise happy, well-adjusted children.

In addition to these important considerations, it’s also worth noting that Gentle Parenting doesn’t come with a one-size-fits-all manual. Families are as unique as the individuals who make them up, and what works beautifully for one household may not resonate with another. The principles of Gentle Parenting—empathy, understanding, respectful communication, and patient guidance—can be adapted to suit various cultural backgrounds, personal values, and even the temperaments and developmental stages of different children.

This flexibility is key because it acknowledges that parents and children grow together. The methods and techniques that seemed effective when a child was a toddler may need rethinking as they become older and face new challenges.

Moreover, Gentle Parenting encourages ongoing reflection. Instead of adhering to rigid rules or strict behavioral formulas, parents are invited to pay close attention to their child’s evolving emotional landscape and to their own inner responses. When parents are aware of what triggers frustration or impatience in themselves, they can approach those moments more mindfully, turning a potentially fraught interaction into a learning experience—both for the child and the parent. This reflective quality enables a deeper connection and can help families navigate difficult times without resorting to punitive measures.

Another important aspect is the recognition of how social and cultural factors shape parenting. In an increasingly interconnected world, exposure to a wide array of parenting styles and philosophies can be both enlightening and overwhelming. While the accessibility of parenting resources, forums, and online communities can provide much-needed support, these same spaces can also heighten feelings of comparison and inadequacy. Gentle Parenting invites parents to refocus their attention on the relationship they have with their child rather than external judgments. It’s about trusting one’s own instincts while remaining open to learning and growth.

This method also subtly challenges long-standing societal norms that often emphasize obedience over understanding. By encouraging dialogue, empathy, and cooperation, Gentle Parenting fosters a home environment where a child’s voice is valued. This nurtures resilience, self-awareness, and emotional intelligence, setting the stage for stronger relationships later in life—both inside and outside the family unit.

Ultimately, Gentle Parenting’s essence is rooted in kindness, empathy, and respect. It recognizes the dignity of children as individuals still learning to navigate the world, and it respects the complex role of parents who are learning right alongside them. By embracing mistakes, resisting the urge to strive for perfection, and maintaining the focus on connection and communication, families can create supportive, loving environments where both parents and children have the freedom to be their authentic selves and grow together.

Benefits of Gentle Parenting in the Classroom

The benefits of Gentle Parenting extend far beyond the toddler years and have a noticeable impact in classroom settings as children mature. When raised in an environment that emphasizes mutual respect, open communication, and empathy, children often carry these values into their academic lives. Over time, these children tend to develop stronger emotional literacy, which enables them to identify and articulate their feelings clearly, rather than resorting to acting out.

This skill is invaluable in a school setting, where students face daily challenges like navigating friendships, adapting to new rules, or coping with academic stressors.

Instead of melting down during a difficult math lesson or becoming frustrated with a classmate who disagrees with them, these students are more likely to use calm words, seek help in an appropriate manner, or take a moment to self-regulate before proceeding.

From a teacher’s perspective, the positive ripple effects of a Gentle Parenting background are evident in better classroom dynamics. Students who have been encouraged to understand the rationale behind guidelines at home often find it easier to accept classroom rules. Rather than feeling these rules are arbitrary impositions, they recognize them as structures designed to keep everyone safe, focused, and productive. This understanding reduces pushback and fosters a willingness to cooperate.

Teachers may find they can spend less time managing disruptions and more time actually teaching. Lessons flow more smoothly, and students learn more effectively when they know the rules exist for a good reason and are not simply enforced out of adult authority or tradition.

The emphasis on natural consequences also dovetails seamlessly with many modern classroom management strategies. Just as a child at home learns not to leave their coat behind because they’ll feel the chill later, students can understand that if they don’t submit their assignment on time, they might miss out on a fun classroom activity or risk falling behind their peers. Such experiences teach responsibility without harsh punishments, instilling in students a greater sense of ownership over their actions and outcomes. Coupled with positive reinforcement—where teachers acknowledge and praise students’ constructive behaviors—this approach nurtures intrinsic motivation.

Students learn to behave well and engage meaningfully in class because it feels rewarding and respectful to do so, not simply to avoid reprimands or earn superficial rewards.

Ultimately, the values cultivated through Gentle Parenting can be powerful assets as children transition into their school years. By promoting emotional resilience, empathy, and thoughtful decision-making, these principles help create an environment where teachers and students collaborate in a supportive, enriching academic community.