Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

From $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

Grave Mercy
Grave Mercy
Grave Mercy
Ebook491 pages8 hours

Grave Mercy

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

4/5

()

Read preview

About this ebook

Packed with love, magic, and deadly games of courtly intrigue and treason, book one of Robin LaFevers's fast-paced YA trilogy set in 15th-century France combines romance with captivating action.

Why be the sheep, when you can be the wolf?

Seventeen-year-old Ismae escapes from the brutality of an arranged marriage into the sanctuary of the convent of St. Mortain, where the sisters still serve the gods of old. Here she learns that the god of Death Himself has blessed her with dangerous gifts—and a violent destiny. If she chooses to stay at the convent, she will be trained as an assassin and serve as a handmaiden to Death. To claim her new life, she must destroy the lives of others.

Ismae’s most important assignment takes her straight into the high court of Brittany—where she finds herself woefully under prepared—not only for the deadly games of intrigue and treason, but for the impossible choices she must make. For how can she deliver Death’s vengeance upon a target who, against her will, has stolen her heart?

LanguageEnglish
PublisherHarperCollins
Release dateApr 3, 2012
ISBN9780547822419
Grave Mercy
Author

Robin LaFevers

Robin LaFevers, author of the New York Times best-selling His Fair Assassin books, was raised on fairy tales, Bulfinch’s mythology, and nineteenth-century poetry. It is not surprising that she grew up to be a hopeless romantic. She was lucky enough to find her one true love, and is living happily ever after with him in California. Visit her online at robinlafevers.com and on Twitter @RLLaFevers. 

Read more from Robin La Fevers

Related to Grave Mercy

Titles in the series (1)

View More

Related ebooks

YA Action & Adventure For You

View More

Related articles

Reviews for Grave Mercy

Rating: 3.9899900540540543 out of 5 stars
4/5

999 ratings156 reviews

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

  • Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    5/5
    Purchased after reading 2 sample paragraphs on the Kindle. Hopefully this will wash the taste of sloppily written UF out of my mouth cause the opening is gorgeously written.

    R.L. LaFevers is now one of my favorite authors. Despite this being the first in a series, this book is complete in itself. Thank you, thank you for the lack of a cliffhanger.

    The writing style in this book really reminded me of the elegance of J. Carey's Kushiel's Dart without any sex. And speaking of sex, although this qualifies to me as an entry into PNR, there is NO sex - although there is romance--some may argue against it, but to me sex doesn't equal romance.

    I am eagerly awaiting the next installment from Ms LaFevers and will tentatively add her to my auto-buy list.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    Grave Mercy
    3.5 Stars

    In a time period replete with prejudice and superstition, Ismae Rienne is shunned by family members and villagers alike for being a daughter of Death. Escaping the cruelty of an arranged marriage, Ismae seeks sanctuary at the convent of St. Mortain where she is instructed in the art of assassination and learns to make good use of the gifts bestowed by her father. On her first assignment, Ismae finds herself woefully unprepared for the political intrigue and deadly machinations of the court of Brittany and will have to make the most difficult choice of all between the destiny she longs to fulfill and the love of a man she may be forced to kill.

    Despite the minor elements of magical realism included in the narrative, this is a work of historical fiction revolving around the early life of Anne, Duchess of Brittany.

    As an Anglophile, most of my knowledge of this time period related to English history, so the focus on Brittany and France was both novel and interesting. Anne led a fascinating life and it was fun learning more about the various people and events depicted in the book.

    The story itself was well paced albeit a little too lengthy. The slow burn romance is a highlight of the tale and will resonate with fans of Maria V. Snyder's Poison Study series. In fact, there are many similarities between Snyder's Yelena and LaFever's Ismae.

    The series continues with different heroines, but neither is particularly appealing so it will remain on the backburner for now.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    Original story set in medieval Brittany, with a twist. Ismae is one of the scarred daughters of the god/saint of Death, Mortain. She is rescued from a forced marriage by Mortain’s convent and trained in the art of assassination, but then must make her way in the treacherous surroundings of the fragile court of the Duchess of Brittany. I like the world, and the ideas behind the story, but Ismae is alternatively too wise and too naïve to be super believeable. Also, I find the sudden rescue in the ending to be a little too pat – if I think of it as a Romance novel, then it is well and excellently done. As a YA paranormal-ish book, it leaves something to be desired.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    Great page turner. The book is well written and full of intrigue.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    This was a really excellent book. The characters were engaging and likable, as well as realistic- they all had excellent motives. As for the setting, it was very historically plausible from what little I know of Britain's early history. As for plot it was speedy and gripping. The only thing I would contest is the YA genre- it felt much more adult to me.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    At half the length this start of series may have rated an extra star, but the handling of the romance element and the dawdling pace made it not worth the time I spent reading it. With a near historical setting and present deities it seems to stagger in the steps of Bujold's Five God books without the humor or humanity which separate those works far from the common.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    teen fiction; historical romance involving a convent of assassins. File this one under "guilty pleasure." Satisfactory romance involving 16-17y.o. in medieval Brittany (at some point during its long conflict with France). Best not to examine the details of the plot too closely, but makes for an enjoyable, light read--probably PG-13 (tons of violence, not too graphic, some kissing, and a couple scenes where the couple "lay together").
  • Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    5/5
    Wow! I really loved this book, but mostly because I really loved Ismae! The story takes place in 15th century Brittany and follows Ismae from a forced marriage when she is 14, which she escapes with the help of her village's herbwitch, to the convent of St. Mortain, where she is taught to serve the God of Death by becoming his assassin. Because she was treated horribly by everyone she knew growing up, she was all for it. She never wanted to feel weak or at the mercy of another ever again. By the age of 17, she is ready for her first assignment, which leads to her posing as the mistress of Gavriel Duval, the bastard brother of the young Duchess of Brittany. She is thrown into an unfamiliar world full of deceit and backstabbing in the court of the Duchess, and she doesn't know who to trust when everybody seems to have ulterior motives.

    I was enthralled right from the start. The change in Ismae from weak and powerless to strong and capable was fun to watch. The characters were well written and the back story, most of which was taken from the pages of history itself, was well written. The world building was phenomenal! The book was a bit long, but it didn't seem bogged down with unnecessary information, and I found it to be an easy read because it was so well written.

    In summary, I enjoyed reading this book very much and highly recommend it to those who love a good book that combines fantasy and historical fiction.,

    5/5 stars.

    I received a copy of this book free of charge in exchange for my honest opinion.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    I enjoyed this, but didn't love it. It's a wonderful premise, and I love that it seems each book of the series will be a complete story, but it just didn't grab me as much as I'd hoped it might.

    Also, somewhat spoilery reaction to one tiny scene pertaining to the romance aspect of the book: I am SO SICK of books with a romance where the male love interest does something aggressive that makes the girl uncomfortable and then she second guesses herself afterward all: well, I probably was enjoying myself. In this case, the main character actually has the thought process that the guy could have raped her and she's "not even sure she would have fought very hard" because of the "spell he cast" over her.

    ...

    BLARGH. Of course, people can react in any number of ways to sexual assault, but I hate the subtle implication that if a man is aggressive with you or takes you beyond your comfort zone, then it's just boys will be boys. You're discomfort or fear is silly, and you were probably aroused anyway. The main guy character is revealed to be a very good person, but at this point in the book Ismae is distrustful of him, unsure of his motives, and very, very uncomfortable around men in general. It just made me feel so icky to read the whole exchange, even though I imagine it's not something most readers would have a problem with since it's a tiny scene in a giant book.

    I did like the story overall and the characters, but even after I'd finished I kept thinking of this scene. I'd definitely have less of an issue if this weren't marketed as YA, I think. So many adult romances use this trope, and it doesn't bother me as much when it's a grown woman having the same thought process in fiction. Possibly because I know that so many teen girls deal with stupid pressures like this all the time, and the general media message is pretty firmly in line with the one presented in this book. I want YA that challenges this idea, that points out that it's okay to feel uncomfortable and SAY you feel uncomfortable, that it's okay to get angry or frustrated when someone crosses your boundaries. It's okay to HAVE boundaries and you don't have to know what they are until you reach them, but it should be ok to point out if they're being crossed. I don't think teen girls get to hear that often enough.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    Really enjoyed this! Was worried about it straying from the main assassin-nun plot and getting ridiculous, but it ended up as a decent work of YA historical fiction. Could be biased because I love Breton history, but overall it was immensely entertaining. Can't wait to read the second book.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    I have such conflicting feelings about this book.

    First off, I'll say I loved the time period and setting. The entire background of the political conflicts, the different saints, and the hidden motives of characters was so intricate and well done. It felt real.

    Second, Ismae is an engaging, passionate, and endearing protagonist. Unlike in some assassin books, she actually seems decent at doing assassin-like things. It's hard to tell if her essential character grew or evolved over the course of the book, but at the very least she learned new things and became her own person.

    In general, the intrigue of the book feels like it would have come off better in a perspective other than first-person present-tense, however the immediacy of this tone did add a lot to the more adrenaline filled scenes.

    The thing that left me scratching my head throughout the book was consistency. Low-born Ismae uses the most formal diction out of all the characters. Formerly renowned knight Duval is described as paper-work loving by all yet spends more time sneaking out at night than the assassin. Finally, in the beginning of the story, Ismae is motivated to join the convent and become an assassin when she hears she will be able to take a stand against men. Her thoughts come through crystal clear (thanks, perspective): all men are horrible, abusive, and not worth a thing. However, asides from one or two run-ins, she spends the rest of the book pretty content to trust in quite a few male characters upon limited introductions. She trusts this "instinct" that they're good. Where did this feeling come from??? Certainly not from 3 years spent training in a convent. Especially a convent which takes in girls and claims to despise men yet equips these same girls sacrifice honor, personal pride, and dignity in the face of duty. I'm sorry, but what even.

    (Ok, and Ismae said sooo many times, "womanly charms" when referring to physical features. I can't even. That phrasing is just so awkward.)

    So, yes, other than that, it was a nice read. Ismae's interactions with the saints and her powers was cool.

  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    It took me a while to get into LaFevers' writing but by about 1/3 of the way into the book, I couldn't put it down. I loved the story, Ismae and, most especially Duval. I thought this was a very original story. After all, how often is our heroine a daughter of Death? I found the idea of an entire convent devoted to killing people novel. By the end of the story, I was proud of Ismae and in love with Duval.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    I read this for the "an adventure/espionage novel" part of my 2018 reading challenge. Interesting concept, but it was a little bit predictable and it didn't quite suck me in.
  • Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    5/5
    Nun Assassins! Freaking brilliant
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    I borrowed this from a friend and I am quite pleased I did. I really enjoyed this book. A bit different from my usual reading. I was hooked from the beginning, and finished the story of Ismae in 6 nights. I love the authors' portrayal of Death-we call him the Grim Reaper. Here he is named Mortain, one of the ancient gods.
    And I will tell you no more about this book! You'll have to read it for yourself. It will be worth it.
  • Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    5/5
    Gah! So good! Best love story I've read in ages and ages - the descriptions of the physical sensations of live are just brilliant. Read it, right now. Go on, I'll wait.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    I don't know why it took me so long to finish this book! The story was not lacking in excitement or intrigue, yet I found myself struggling to read it; that is until I downloaded the audiobook. The story is mainly political - a lot of it based on real event in Brittany at the time - with an overlay of the fantastical.

    Isame is a young, and sometimes naive character, but written in a way that's more lovable than annoying. I could understand why it took her such a long time to explore the depth of her gifts - special skills from the god of death himself - but I wished she had done some of it earlier in the narrative.

    While no insta-love or love triangle (or the angst that generally follows such devices), I found the romantic spin of the story a little sudden - Duval is not a novice, and I would imagine that he would be very cautious around the young assassin, so it seemed sudden, his change in feelings. However, seeing as it was told from Isame's point of view, I'm willing to let it go.

    By far my biggest hang up was Isame's seeming unconcern for her other sister (Sybella) that she bumps into now and then. I wonder why she didn't make contact or even think of Sybella more often; other than when it seemed necessary to advance the plot.

    I'm most likely going to read the other two books in the series, based on two entirely different characters. I have a feeling I might like Sybella's story a lot more.

  • Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    5/5
    I just finished Grave Mercy and am left aw struck. The world between the pages has managed to lure me in and bury deep within my soul. It was full of suspense, royalty, bitter emotions, and unconditional love. It had many twists and turns that left me on the edge of my seat.

    It is a story about a young girl who is convent raised to be an assassin. She is taught all the ways to kill and then sent on missions to look for the marque of death. When she is sent with Duval to the palace her world gets a tad crazy. She isn't sure who to confide in other then fulfilling her service to Mortain and her commitment to the duchess. Secrets have to be revealed and lies have to be uncovered... She doesn't expect to feel anything of the sorts of love, but the match is lit and there is no turning back. In the end a slow burn romance turns into a full burn flame.

    I just fell head over heels in love with the characters and quickly became envious and jealous of Ismae. Her life was dangerous, but it was also magical, romantic, and intense. I loved how strong she was and how she always followed her heart no matter the consequence... She was a bada$$ heroine that pulled me in and left me captivated.

    Overall, this book exceeded all expectations. It consumed me with it's regal setting and left me wanting to bid the lord good night. I definitely recommend it to all readers! Even if you aren't a YA fan... I still think you will enjoy it.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    This sounded like a perfect book for me. Assassin nuns who were worshipping a god in the guise of a saint (saint Mortmain) and who were trying to keep Brittany (yah Greater Celtic Supernation) Ismae is a novice, sent on her first mission with a man who is at first hostile to her and then warms up, She was married but the marriage was never consummated, Her father treated her badly and she bears the mark of the god/saint of death she is brought to the convent to be trained and then I was annoyed. You see nothing of her learning, nothing about her learning how she's immune to most poisons, nothing about the difference between learning to fight in skirts and trousers, none of that that would have made the story compelling to me, instead in the space of a few pages she's done with the training and then on with protecting Anne of Brittany ( a real historical figure) and reading the wikipedia entry there are a few more historical figures who feature in the story.

    There's a review on the back from the New York Times where it says that it "leaves you craving more" and that was the case with me, but not just that I wanted to read more in the series, partially to see how the world develops but also I wanted more in this story, I felt like I was missing too much of the story.

    Not a bad read, could do better.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    Really nice to read a book with no love triangle!
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    I liked the plot and loved the depth of the characters.
  • Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    5/5
    I loved the effects on my soul when I read this book. I was whisked away into the swirling rapids of this world. It was an adventure, a mystical world filled with danger, mistrust and gods.(I love multi gods)Oh the gods, they are a fascinating group although we really only get a glance at one, Death he is unique. A dark figure misunderstood even by those who serve him.
    The Story is of Ismae, a mistreated, misunderstood and misjudged woman who finds solace and a new life at a convent. Our heroine, has some unique traits of her own. She is a daughter of Death, and in training to be a full time Assassin Nun. Yes, really. She has some serious skills with weapons, poisons, and feeling the souls of those she deals her skills on. She has been told to do as she was told, no questions, no wavering. Ah, but she is bright and she has something else in her heart.
    Duval, the thorn in her side will take her into a place where everything she has been taught will be questioned. She will learn much of her order, her world and who she really is. Not without great loss, or great pain.
    Loved it- Thank for the heads up G.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    This is a great read with a fabulous blend of history, fantasy and adventure and reminded me a little of the 'Study' series by Maria V. Snyder. Set in the Middle Ages, Ismae is an impressive protagonist. She is determined, strong, independent, and a trained assassin, but treats others with compassion. The book includes a range of wonderful supporting characters from Duval's youngest sister to the big, ugly, loveable Beast. There is a touch of romance in this book, but unlike many YA books, it is honest and believable. Dealing with history, religion, court intrigue, death and espionage, and with twists and turns on every page, "Grave Mercy" is a terrific story. Looking forward to the sequel.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    And another foul book. Well-written, interesting characters, interesting setting (and apparently 90% historical, too). But between the plotting and the utterly incompetent heroine, I was slogging throughout. I did finish it, though, which makes it better than the last few of this type I've tried.

    Honestly, I spent two-thirds of the book trying to figure out if the abbess was simply stupid, incompetent, or laying deep plots and lying directly and by omission to the heroine. Turns out it's apparently not the last, still not sure about which of the first it is. It was blatantly obvious that Ismae did not have the training or knowledge necessary to carry out her mission as directed...and the abbess' solution was - not to give her a quick review of what she should have known, not to give her extra training or a way of getting it, but to give her a knife that would kill instantly. Because that will solve her problems as she goes to court not knowing Duval's family links and trying to play mistress while having skipped all her classes on the "womanly arts".

    Which reminds me - I wonder if there's a monastery teaching Death's sons how to kill? Probably not such a focus on seduction there, if it exists. Or does Death only sire daughters? If so, why?

    The romance was utterly predictable, and therefore boring. And just why did she object to pretty men? Neither her father nor her husband could be described as pretty - she should have been shyer of Beast or Duval than De Lornay. But that's the traditional form, the abused girl is afraid of pretty men. I don't know.

    The story itself wasn't bad, and it was interesting when I found out at the end that it was mostly historical (though the primary male character was fictional...and presumably the heroine as well, though she got no mention in the afterword) except that the plotting was toned down. But the meta questions kept jumping up and disrupting any flow of the story for me.

    The convent had so many holes in its plotline that it just made no sense at all (girls only (as previously mentioned)? Girls mostly taught to seduce? The most broken girls go out first - the one that's practically sane gets locked up inside? and the biggest meta - these girls have been broken by the status quo, and then are trained to support and protect it - and none of them object). Every once in a while there would be a magical bit (the marques, the soul rush, Ismae's resistance to poison) that made it seem not entirely a scam...but again, for large portions of the book, I was trying to figure out how the convent could have been using hypnosis or drugs to simulate the magic for their tools.

    Overall very nasty, as every single trustworthy person either turns betrayer, dies, or is otherwise rendered helpless to do anything. And as I said above, Ismae is utterly incompetent at her tasks (did she really go out the window? If so, she made it absolutely certain that she was linked to the death - no chance of playing innocent), either because of lack of training or because she is certain she knows what to do and ignores all reason. She pulls out more-or-less success because she's as incompetent at plotting as she is at assassination (OK, when she finally begins to _think_ about her assassination tasks I start to like her better), and she has allies, mostly against her will.

    I have to remember that I do _not_ have the same tastes in books as my sister (who praised this book highly, which is why I read it).
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    There were parts of this story that dragged and parts of it that moved quickly. I was mildly disappointed to have figured out who the traitor was ahead of time but I didn't figure it out so far in advance that the story was a misery. I feel like it took forever for Ismae and Gavriel to figure things out but felt like it wouldn't have felt like quite so long if their relationship development made more sense to me. It was just not totally clear why they were changing their minds a lot of the time.

    The saints and their development and how the order of Mortain was run were really interesting. I liked that Ismae came to look at them with clearer eyes after meeting the saint but wish that we could have spent more time exploring that. Kind of hoping it comes up in the next book.
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    A fresh mythological take on a time of medieval france and brittany. A convent of female assassins.
  • Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    5/5
    Grave Mercy (His Fair Assassin, Book 1)
    By Robin LaFevers
    Houghton Mifflin
    Pub. Date. 4/3/12
    From NetGalley

    ***Review does contain some spoilers***












    Grave Mercy is a young adult novel about girls raised in a convent and trained to become assassin nuns. They are also all fathered by the God/Saint of Death, Mortain. The story opens on the life of Ismae Rienne, the daughter of a turnip farmer who bears a scar on her back from where the tincture the Herbwitch gave her mother when her step-father tries to have her get rid of the child while she is pregnant didn’t work. Her mother dies, she is beaten by her father, who is afraid of her, and sold off to be married to a pig farmer, who doesn’t know about the mark, but when he sees it, it also afraid of it and beats her. She has been teased and tormented her entire life, mostly by boys, and isn’t entirely trusting of men. She is rescued and sent to the Convent of St. Mortain, where she spends three years training, learning about poisons, how to kill a man in just about any way imaginable, and supposedly learning about how to be seductive and a temptress, except she skips those lessons because she thinks they’re silly. She is sent out to kill people at the order of the Abbess, who has received a message through the Seeress, who has received orders from the God. All of her victims bear a marque, a black smudge indicating where they have been marked by the God for death.

    She follows these orders blindly until she is sent off with Gavriel Duval, who claims she has ruined two of his investigations, and the Abbess sets him up to take Ismae with him, claiming she is his mistress. They are both horrified at the idea, but do it. Through him, Ismae is introduced to life outside of a small town and outside of the convent, to political intrigue, the problem of learning how to know who to trust. She is also introduced to his half-sister, Anne, the duchess of Brittany, who is embroiled in the middle of a political mess as her council, who are encouraging her to take a husband, because a woman can’t rule alone and show strength, and the barons, many of whom are vying for her hand in marriage. She has been promised to many since she was a child.

    Ismae begins to question whether or not the seer and abbess at the convent really are the voice of the God and what if they make a mistake about who she's supposed to kill? There is the possibility they're not always right, and maybe some people can be redeemed if they genuinely are sorry for what they have done (which turns out to be true, so the convent is wrong about that—she knows because the ones she is supposed to kill are marqued by the God, and the one she lets repent instead who has a marque, the marque disappears afterward.)

    It's semi-historical, around the time France is pretty much taking over Europe, and the one little Duchy of Brittany is being held by an as of yet uncrowned young woman of about fourteen who is the legitimate heir. It centers around her family as well, for the man that Ismae has been pretending to be the mistress of Duval, is her half brother and her staunchest defender. There are plot convolutions as betrayals to the young duchess abound, the one man her brother tries to arrange a marriage for her with is pushed to his death, and eventually he is poisoned by the man they all thought they could trust. Anne eventually has to retreat from her current seat, as her Marshall and one of the members of her Privy Council have taken up arms against her and approaching her quickly. She is saved by her young half brother, François, who is one of the people Ismae managed to convince to repent, and has been sent by Duval to help her with all of his troops.

    After the battle, when Ismae returns to see if she can find some friends, one of whom has been taken and the other, still alive, asks her to please kill him, she uses the special weapon given to her by the Abbess that releases the soul so her friend dies quickly and painlessly. She starts to do this for everyone on the battlefield who is still alive. As she is doing this, she realizes there is a figure on the edge of the battlefield, and it is her father, Death. When she is finished she is afraid he'll be angry at what she's done, because all the convent has taught her about it vengeance, but he seems actually very pleased at what she's done, and has a comforting presence like a father would have, not the cold, dark feelings one would expect from Death. He shows her the vast choices she has, not just the one outlined by the convent, and she decides she wants to use her powers for mercy, not for vengeance. The character development is mostly centered on Ismae, the main character, and the Duchess, who is younger than her but very much in the process of having to grow up quickly. Since Ismae came from a background where men routinely abused women, the vengeance part fit very nicely into her ideas of the world when she first started at the convent. The Duchess has no experience of that, but knows about the court and plotting and intrigues, so they are in a way opposites of each other, and they learn from other. Both Ismae and the Duchess, Anne, are strong female characters, but for different reasons, and as Anne grew she became more assured of her power as Duchess and stopped listening so much to all her counselors who kept telling her she had to have a husband to rule. Ismae also learned to stand up for herself with the Abbess, a figure she both loved and was afraid of.

    I was so hooked into this book I read it in one day. The ideas are unique, the plot very convoluted but not hard to follow—we know what Ismae knows, so there are a lot of, “Oh, that makes more sense now,” moments when things are revealed to her. I didn’t necessarily identify with Ismae in terms of her character, but I did as a person, and I definitely identified with Anne as someone learning to speak up for herself, which I think a lot of young adult readers will also identify with. I loved that they were truly strong female characters. Ismae was definitely able to take care of herself, and didn’t need to be rescued. When the attackers descend on her and Duval, she kills as many men as he does. She is very concerned about appearing weak, though eventually she does give in to her emotions. In a way, maybe that’s a lesson in the necessity for having a strong balanced female main character, because when all a female main character does is fight back how she feels and kill, although she does plan with more of a feminine touch, she starts to become a little more like a man than a woman. It was a little nice when she started having to wear dresses and find new ways to conceal her weapons, because it was the two worlds meeting and her having to adjust. Anne is very smart and quick witted, but she can’t protect herself, she depends on her brother for that, and once he’s out of the picture, she’s somewhat helpless except for the people Ismae has convinced to stay with her, and Ismae is now her protector.

    I enjoyed this book very much. I don’t often give books five stars unless I feel they really deserve it, and this one did. The only thing that was a little formulaic was the romance, but it was well done formulaic, so I’ll give it that. It is a riveting read, fast paced, and exciting, and I simply did not want to stop reading it, and that was on my computer, when I prefer actual text, so that says something. There is a snippet at the end about the next book centering about one of the other characters from the convent, which comes out next year, and it looks just as fascinating. This was a truly gratifying read, and I look forward to the sequel with enthusiasm.
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    this was a good easy read. nothing super impressive but it also wasnt bad, i read it fairly fast and it kept me interested
  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    “This is what I want to be. An instrument of mercy, not vengeance.”


    I felt like this book could've been something more. The main character is an assassin, yet I don't see much of any assassinations. I needed more badassery; this book was basically sprinkles of action throughout long stretches of boredom. The only action-filled scenes were at the beginning of the story and they were awesome, so I didn't expect this path that the book took a turn to.

    The historical aspect of this book kind of bored me - I don't normally read historical fiction - but I felt like it could've been weaved into the story more artfully. The romance was bland and predictable. When I read this book's synopsis, my expectations soared; and by the way everyone was singing the book's praises, I expected it to be something more. However, I was sorely disappointed. This book had so much potential, which is such a shame.

    Nevertheless, I'll still be reading the sequels - but with lowered expectations. In between the stretches of boredom, there were many parts of this book that just made you want to keep reading. The writing was pretty good and the similes and metaphors the author uses were incredible. So, to conclude this review, I will add some quotes that particularly impressed me from the book.

    “Behind me, the door opens and Louyse bustles in. “My lady! Come away from there before you catch your death!”

    Her words bring a smile to my lips. Does she think Death is some small bird with my name written on it, beating at the window in the hope that I will catch it?”



    “For while I am Death’s daughter and walk in His dark shadow, surely the darkness can give way to light sometimes.”
  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    Ismae is abused and treated as a commodity for most of her life. She bears scars from the poison used on her mother while she was pregnant with her. On the night of her marriage, she is whisked away to a convent of St. Mortain, the patron saint/god of death. At the convent the girls and women are trained to kill those bearing the mark of the St. Ismae is given the duty of protecting the young duchess who is facing war with France and needs a suitor. She must go with DuVall, the duchess' half brother to live in the castle and navigate courtly intrigue, betrayal, love, and her duty.

Book preview

Grave Mercy - Robin LaFevers

Dramatis Personae

Ismae Rienne

Her father

Guillo the pig farmer

The herbwitch

At the Convent

The abbess

Sister Thomine, martial arts instructor

Annith, a fellow novitiate

Sister Serafina, poisons mistress and convent healer

Sybella, a fellow novitiate

Sister Widona, stable mistress

Sister Beatriz, instructor in womanly arts

Sister Eonette, convent historian and archivist

Sister Arnette, arms mistress

Sister Claude, sister in charge of the rookery

Sister Vereda, the ancient seeress

Runnion, traitor to Brittany and Ismae’s first kill

Martel, French spy and Ismae’s second kill

The Privy Council

Viscount Maurice Crunard, chancellor of Brittany

Madame Françoise Dinan, the duchess’s governess

Marshal Jean Rieux, marshal of Brittany and the duchess’s tutor

Captain Dunois, captain of the Breton army

The Breton Court and Nobility

Anne, Duchess of Brittany, Countess of Nantes, Montfort, and Richmont

Duke Francis II (deceased)

Baron Lombart, a Breton noble

Gavriel Duval, a Breton noble

Benebic de Waroch, the Beast of Waroch and knight of the realm

Raoul de Lornay, a knight of the realm

Baron Geffoy, a Breton noble

Lady Katerine Geffoy, his ladywife

Madame Antoinette Hivern, mistress of the late Duke Francis II

François Avaugour, a knight of the realm

Alain d’Albret, a Breton noble with extensive holdings in France, and one of Anne’s suitors

Charles VIII, king of France

Anne de Beaujeu, regent of France

Norbert Gisors, ambassador for the French regent

Fedric, Duke of Nemours, one of Anne’s suitors

Maximilian of Austria, the Holy Roman emperor, one of Anne’s suitors

Chapter One

Brittany 1485

I bear a deep red stain that runs from my left shoulder down to my right hip, a trail left by the herbwitch’s poison that my mother used to try to expel me from her womb. That I survived, according to the herbwitch, is no miracle but a sign I have been sired by the god of death himself.

I am told my father flew into a rage and raised his hand to my mother even as she lay weak and bleeding on the birthing bed. Until the herbwitch pointed out to him that if my mother had lain with the god of death, surely He would not stand idly by while my father beat her.

I risk a glance up at my husband-to-be, Guillo, and wonder if my father has told him of my lineage. I am guessing not, for who would pay three silver coins for what I am? Besides, Guillo looks far too placid to know of my true nature. If my father has tricked him, it will not bode well for our union. That we are being married in Guillo’s cottage rather than a church further adds to my unease.

I feel my father’s heavy gaze upon me and look up. The triumph in his eyes frightens me, for if he has triumphed, then I have surely lost in some way I do not yet understand. Even so, I smile, wanting to convince him I am happy—for there is nothing that upsets him more than my happiness.

But while I can easily lie to my father, it is harder to lie to myself. I am afraid, sorely afraid of this man to whom I will now belong. I look down at his big, wide hands. Just like my father, he has dirt caked under his fingernails and stains in the creases of his skin. Will the semblance end there? Or will he, too, wield those hands like a cudgel?

It is a new beginning, I remind myself, and in spite of all my trepidations, I cannot extinguish a tiny spark of hope. Guillo wants me enough to pay three silver coins. Surely where there is want, there is room for kindness? It is the one thing that keeps my knees from knocking and my hands from trembling. That and the priest who has come to officiate, for while he is naught but a hedge priest, the furtive glance he sends me over his prayer book causes me to believe he knows who and what I am.

As he mutters the ceremony’s final words, I stare at the rough hempen prayer cord with the nine wooden beads that proclaim him a follower of the old ways. Even when he ties the cord around our hands and lays the blessings of God and the nine old saints upon our union, I keep my gaze downcast, afraid to see the smugness in my father’s eyes or what my husband’s face might reveal.

When the priest is done, he pads away on dirty feet, his rough leather sandals flapping noisily. He does not even pause long enough to raise a tankard to our union. Nor does my father. Before the dust from my father’s departing cart has settled, my new husband swats my rump and grunts toward the upstairs loft.

I clench my fists to hide their trembling and cross to the rickety stairs. While Guillo fortifies himself with one last tankard of ale, I climb up to the loft and the bed I will now share with him. I sorely miss my mother, for even though she was afraid of me, surely she would have given me a woman’s counsel on my wedding night. But both she and my sister fled long ago, one back into the arms of death, and the other into the arms of a passing tinker.

I know, of course, what goes on between a man and a woman. Our cottage is small and my father loud. There was many a night when urgent movement accompanied by groans filled our dark cottage. The next day my father always looked slightly less bad tempered, and my mother more so. I try to convince myself that no matter how distasteful the marriage bed is, surely it cannot be any worse than my father’s raw temper and meaty fists.

The loft is a close, musty place that smells as if the rough shutters on the far wall have never been opened. A timber and rope bed frame holds a mattress of straw. Other than that, there are only a few pegs to hang clothes on and a plain chest at the foot of the bed.

I sit on the edge of the chest and wait. It does not take long. A heavy creak from the stairs warns me that Guillo is on his way. My mouth turns dry and my stomach sour. Not wanting to give him the advantage of height, I stand.

When he reaches the room, I finally force myself to look at his face. His piggish eyes gorge themselves on my body, going from the top of my head down to my ankles, then back up to my breasts. My father’s insistence on lacing my gown so tight has worked, as Guillo can look at little else. He gestures with his tankard toward my bodice, slopping ale over the sides so that it dribbles to the floor. Remove it. Desire thickens his voice.

I stare at the wall behind him, my fingers trembling as I raise them to my laces. But not fast enough. Never fast enough. He takes three giant strides toward me and strikes me hard across the cheek. Now! he roars as my head snaps back.

Bile rises in my throat and I fear I will be sick. So this is how it will be between us. This is why he was willing to pay three silver coins.

My laces are finally undone, and I remove my bodice so that I stand before him in my skirt and shift. The stale air, which only moments before was too warm, is now cold as it presses against my skin.

Your skirt, he barks, breathing heavily.

I untie the strings and step out of my skirt. As I turn to lay it on the nearby bench, Guillo reaches for me. He is surprisingly quick for one so large and stupid, but I am quicker. I have had long years of practice escaping my father’s rages.

I jerk away, spinning out of his reach, infuriating him. In truth, I give no thought to where I will run, wishing only to hold off the inevitable a little longer.

There is a loud crash as his half-empty tankard hits the wall behind me, sending a shower of ale into the room. He snarls and lunges, but something inside me will not—cannot—make this easy for him. I leap out of his reach.

But not far enough. I feel a tug, then hear a rip of cloth as he tears my thin, worn chemise.

Silence fills the loft—a silence so thick with shock that even his coarse breathing has stopped. I feel his eyes rake down my back, take in the ugly red welts and scars the poison left behind. I look over my shoulder to see his face has gone white as new cheese, his eyes wide. When our glances meet, he knows—knows—that he has been duped. He bellows then, a long, deep note of rage that holds equal parts fury and fear.

Then his rough hand cracks against my skull and sends me to my knees. The pain of hope dying is worse than his fists and boots.

When Guillo’s rage is spent, he reaches down and grabs me by the hair. I will go for a real priest this time. He will burn you or drown you. Maybe both. He drags me down the steps, my knees bumping painfully against each one. He continues dragging me through the kitchen, then shoves me into a small root cellar, slams the door, and locks it.

Bruised and possibly broken, I lie on the floor with my battered cheek pressed into the cool dirt. Unable to stop myself, I smile.

I have avoided the fate my father had planned for me. Surely it is I who has won, not he.


The sound of the bolt lifting jerks me awake. I shove myself to a sitting position and clutch the tattered remains of my chemise around me. When the door opens, I am stunned to see the hedge priest, the same small rabbit of a man who’d blessed our marriage only hours before. Guillo is not with him, and any moment that does not contain my father or Guillo is a happy one by my reckoning.

The priest looks over his shoulder, then motions for me to follow.

I rise to my feet, and the root cellar spins dizzily. I put a hand to the wall and wait for the feeling to pass. The priest motions again, more urgently. We’ve not much time before he returns.

His words clear my head as nothing else can. If he is acting without Guillo’s knowledge, then he is most assuredly helping me. I’m coming. I push away from the wall, step carefully over a sack of onions, and follow the hedge priest into the kitchen. It is dark; the only light comes from the banked embers in the hearth. I should wonder how the priest found me, why he is helping me, but I do not care. All I can think is that he is not Guillo and not my father. The rest does not matter.

He leads me to the back door, and in a day full of surprises, I find one more as I recognize the old herbwitch from our village hovering nearby. If I did not need to concentrate so hard on putting one foot in front of the other, I would ask her what she is doing here, but it is all I can do to stay upright and keep from falling on my face in the dirt.

As I step into the night, a sigh of relief escapes me. It is dark out, and darkness has always been my friend. A cart waits nearby. Touching me as little as possible, the hedge priest helps me into the back of it before hurrying around to the driver’s bench and climbing in. The priest glances over his shoulder at me, then averts his eyes as if he’s been burned. There’s a blanket back there, he mutters as he steers the nag out onto the cobbled lane. Cover yourself.

The unyielding wood of the cart presses painfully into my bruised bones, and the thin blanket scratches and reeks of donkey. Even so, I wish they’d brought a second one for padding. Where are you taking me?

To the boat.

A boat means water, and crossing water means I will be far from the reach of my father and Guillo and the Church. Where is this boat taking me? I ask, but the priest says nothing. Exhaustion overwhelms me. I do not have the strength to pluck answers from him like meager berries from a thorny bush. I lie down in the cart and give myself over to the horse’s jolting gait.


And so my journey across Brittany begins. I am smuggled like some forbidden cargo, hidden among turnips or in hay in the back of carts, awakened by furtive voices and fumbling hands as I am passed from hedge priest to herbwife, a hidden chain of those who live in accordance with the old saints and are determined to keep me from the Church. The hedge priests, with their awkward movements and musty, stale robes, are kind enough, but their fingers are unschooled in tenderness or compassion. It is the herbwitches I like most. Their chapped, raw hands are gentle as lamb’s wool, and the sharp, pungent smell of a hundred different herbs clings to them like a fragrant shadow. Often as not, they give me a tincture of poppy for my injuries, while the priests merely give me their sympathy, and some begrudgingly at that.

When I awake on what I reckon to be the fifth night of my journey, I smell the salty tang of the sea and remember the promise of a boat. I struggle to sit up, pleased to find my bruises pain me less and my ribs do not burn. We are passing through a small fishing village. I pull the blanket close against the chill and wonder what will happen next.

At the very edge of the village sits a stone church. It is to this that the latest hedge priest steers our cart and I am relieved to see the door bears the sacred anchor of Saint Mer, one of the old saints. The priest reins his horse to a stop. Get out.

I cannot tell if it is fatigue or disdain I hear in his voice, but either way, my journey is almost done, so I ignore it and clamber out of the cart, sure to keep the blanket clutched tight around me lest I offend his modesty.

Once he secures the horse, he leads me toward the beach, where a lone boat waits. The inky black ocean spreads out as far and wide as my eye can see, making the vessel seem very small.

An old sailor sits hunched in the prow. A shell bleached white as bone hangs from a cord at his neck, marking him as a worshiper of Saint Mer. I wonder what he thinks of being woken in the middle of the night and made to row strangers out into the dark sea.

The sailor’s faded blue eyes skim over me. He nods. Climb in. We en’t got all night. He thrusts an oar at me, and I grasp it to steady myself as I get into the boat.

The small vessel dips and rocks and for a moment I am afraid it will tip me into the icy water. But it rights itself and then the priest steps in, causing the hull to sink even lower.

The old sailor grunts, then returns the oar to its pin and begins rowing.

We reach the small island just as dawn pinkens the eastern horizon. It looks barren in the early, spare light. As we draw closer, I see a standing stone next to a church and realize we’ve come to one of the old places of worship.

Gravel crunches under the hull of the boat as the old sailor rows right up onto the beach. He jerks his head toward the stone fortress. Get out then. The abbess of St. Mortain be expectin’ ye.

Saint Mortain? The patron saint of death. A tremor of unease washes through me. I look at the priest, who averts his eyes, as if looking at me is too great a mortal temptation.

Clutching the blanket close around me, I climb awkwardly from the boat and step into the shallows. Torn between gratitude and annoyance, I curtsy slightly, careful to let the blanket slip from my shoulder for the merest of seconds.

It is enough. Satisfied at the priest’s gasp and the old sailor’s cluck of his tongue, I turn and slog through the cold water to the beach. In truth, I have never flashed so much as an ankle before, but I am sorely vexed at being treated like a temptress when all I feel is bruised and broken.

When I reach the patchy grass that grows between the rocks, I look back toward the boat, but it has already put out to sea. I turn and begin making my way to the convent, eager to see what those who worship Death want of me.

Chapter Two

Two ancient standing stones mark the entrance to the convent. The chickens in the courtyard are just now beginning to stir, scratching in the dirt for their breakfast. At my approach, they cluck and flutter away.

I pause at the door, wishing I could find a corner and sleep until my head clears, but the sailor said the abbess is expecting me, and while I do not know much about abbesses, I suspect they are not fond of waiting.

My heart beats wildly as I raise my hand and knock. The heavy door opens at once, revealing a short, plain woman covered in black from head to toe. Without saying a word, she motions me inside.

I follow her through a sparsely furnished room, then down an equally austere corridor that leads into the heart of the convent. My guide knocks once on a closed door.

Enter, a voice commands.

My guide opens the door and motions me inside. The furnishings are simple but sturdy, and early-morning light pours in through the east-facing window. My eyes are immediately drawn to the woman who sits at the large desk in the middle of the room. She wears a black gown and wimple, and her pale face is striking in its beauty.

Without looking up, she motions me toward one of the chairs. My footsteps echo lightly among all that space as I approach her desk. I clutch the blanket tight around me, then sit.

The abbess lifts her gaze from her work, and I find myself staring into a pair of eyes as cool and blue as the sea. Ismae Rienne.

I flinch, startled she knows my name.

Do you know why you’re here, child?

I do not know what answer she is looking for, I only know that I am overcome with a sudden desire to earn her approval. Because I displeased my new husband?

Displeased him? The abbess gives a delicate snort that makes me like her even more. From what I hear he practically wet his braies in fear of you.

I feel the familiar shame rise up in my cheeks and I look down at my lap.

The fault lies not with you, daughter. She says this so gently it makes me want to cry. I have never shed a tear, not throughout all my father’s beatings or Guillo’s mauling, but a few kind words from this woman and it is all I can do not to bawl like a babe.

So tell me, she says, drawing a quill and ink pot close. Do you know the circumstances of your birth?

I risk a glance at her face, but she is focused on what she is writing on her parchment. Only that my mother did not wish to bear me. She went to an herbwitch for poison, hoping to purge me from her womb.

And yet you lived. She looks up. The words are quiet but hold the power of a shout in the stillness of this room.

I meet the abbess’s steady gaze. And yet I lived.

Do you have any idea what that means?

You mean other than having to spend my life in the shadows, dodging blows and staying out of sight so as not to cause others undue fear?

Yes, other than that. Her voice is dry as bone. She leans forward, her eyes alight with some purpose. Did they not claim, Ismae, that you were sired by Death Himself?

I nod cautiously.

Well and so. After many trials, you are now here.

Trials? I ask. Is that what my life has been? A series of trials to be passed?

You come to us well tempered, my child, and it is not in my nature to be sorry for it. It is the well-tempered blade that is the strongest.

"And who exactly is us?" My whole body stills, waiting for her answer.

You have found refuge at the convent of St. Mortain. Although in truth, Mortain is older than any saint, older even than Christ.

One of the old gods we now call saints, I murmur.

Yes, one of the old gods. One not easily cast aside by the Church. And so we call Him saint, but as long as we serve Him, He cares not what He is called.

How does one serve Death? Am I to spend my life collecting bodies in the bone cart?

The reverend mother does not flinch. We carry out Mortain’s will when He wishes to alter the warp and weft of life’s weave for some purpose of His own.

I look at her blankly, not understanding what weaving has to do with Mortain. She sighs and pushes away from her desk. Perhaps some refreshment is in order.

I want to beg her to tell me more of what being Death’s daughter might hold, but I suspect this woman does not suffer fools gladly, so I hold my tongue.

She takes a flagon of wine and two crystal goblets from the cupboard behind her desk. She pours the wine into the goblets and hands one to me. The cut crystal is finer than anything I have ever seen, and I hold it gingerly, afraid it will shatter in my hands.

Here at the convent, it is our job to train those who are sired by the god of death. We teach them to perform their duties quickly and efficiently. Usually, we find that He has given His daughters some special skill or art. Abilities that will aid you as you carry out His work.

His work. The words are ripe with possibility. I take a sip of wine to steady myself. It is sweet and crisp on my tongue.

If I may guess a little about you? the reverend mother asks. I nod, and she continues. You never get sick with the ague or the chills or the flux. Even the plague leaves you untouched, is that correct?

I feel my eyes widen at her uncanny knowledge. How do you know such things?

She smiles. And I know you can survive harsh beatings and heal within days. Do you also have dreams that foretell death?

No. I shake my head, sorry to disappoint her. But sometimes I can tell when people are going to die.

She tilts her head to the side. Go on.

I look down and study the wine in the goblet. I can see them fading sometimes. It’s like watching a flame grow dim in a lantern. And once, I saw a mark. On the blacksmith. He had a faint black smudge on his forehead in the shape of a horseshoe. Three days later he was dead.

She leans forward in her chair, eager now. How did he die?

He was kicked in the head by one of the horses as he worked.

Ah. A pleased smile hovers at the corners of her mouth. Mortain has given you powerful gifts. She takes up the quill and makes a notation on the parchment in front of her. Small beads of perspiration begin to form on my forehead and I take another sip of wine to steady myself. It is hard to air old secrets.

So, she says, looking back up at me. You are well equipped for our service.

Which is?

We kill people. The reverend mother’s words fall like stones into the quiet of the room, so shocking that my body goes numb. I hear the splintering of crystal as my goblet hits the floor.

The abbess ignores the shattered goblet. Of course, many die without our help. However, there are those who deserve to die but who have not yet encountered the means to do so. At Mortain’s bidding, we help them on their way.

Surely He does not need our help?

Anger flares in the abbess and for the first time I feel the iron will I have only vaguely sensed before. Who are you to say what the god of death needs or doesn’t need? Mortain is an old god and has no desire to be forgotten and fade from this world, which is why He chooses to bestir Himself in the affairs of man. She stares at me for a moment longer, then the tension leaves her, like a wave going out to sea. What do you know of the old gods? she asks.

Only that they were once the nine old gods of Brittany but now we call them saints. And we must leave them an occasional offering or prayer if we do not wish to offend them or incur their wrath.

You are close, the abbess says, leaning back in her chair, "but that is not the whole of it. The old gods are neither man nor God, but something in between. They were the first inhabitants of our land, sent to do God’s bidding in this new world He had created.

"At first, the relationship between gods and man was a difficult one, the gods treating us much as we treat cattle or sheep. But soon we learned to honor them with prayer and offerings, which led to harmony between us. Even the early Church, when it arrived, was content to let us honor the old gods, although we learned to call them saints then. But lately, that has been changing. Just as France has gobbled up most of the smaller kingdoms and duchies so it may claim all their power for its own, so too does this latest pope work to extinguish any trace of the old ways, wanting all the prayers and offerings for his own church.

"So now more and more put aside the old ways and traditions that honor the gods of Brittany. But not all. Some still raise their voices in prayer and make their offerings. If not for that worship and supplication, the old gods would fade from this world. Surely you can understand why Mortain would not wish that. He feeds off our belief and worship much as we feed off bread and meat and would starve without it.

So, it is our job to believe and to serve. If you choose to stay here and take the vows, you will be sworn to serve Mortain in any way He asks of you. In all things. In all ways. We carry out His will. Do you understand?

Is that not murder?

No. You would not expect a queen to wash her own clothes or lace her own gown; she has her handmaidens for that. And so it is with us; we serve as handmaidens to Death. When we are guided by His will, killing is a sacrament.

She leans forward then, as if eager to tempt me with what Mortain offers. If you choose to stay, you will be trained in His arts. You will learn more ways to kill a man than you imagined possible. We will train you in stealth and cunning and all manner of skills that will ensure no man is ever again a threat to you.

I think of my father and of Guillo. I think of all those in the village who worked so hard to make my life a misery. The young boys who threw stones at me, the old men who spat and stared at me with terror in their eyes, as if they expected me to snatch the souls from their old, wrinkled bodies. The younger men who fumbled clumsily at my skirts in dark corners, guessing correctly that my father cared not for my safety or reputation. It would be no hardship at all to kill the likes of them. I feel like a cat who has been dropped from a great height only to land on her feet.

As if plucking my thoughts from my head, the abbess speaks again. They won’t all be like them, you know.

I look up in surprise and she continues. Those Mortain sends you to kill. They won’t all be like the pig farmer.

My ears are deaf to her warning. I am certain all men are like that, and I would kill them all gladly.

But she presses further, to be sure I fully understand. He will ask for sacrifices, but it is not your role to question. Only to serve with love and obedience. A whisper of emotion crosses her face, a memory of some pain I can only guess at. That is the nature of our service, she says. Unquestioning faith. Can you do that?

What if I say no?

Then you will be taken far from here and given to a kind, gentle man in need of a wife.

I weigh the choice that is no choice at all. To be removed from the world of men and trained to kill them, or to be handed to one like a sheep. If you think I am fit to serve, Reverend Mother, I will do so gladly.

She smiles and leans back in her chair. Oh, you are fit to serve. You have already passed the first test.

Something about her smile makes me uneasy. I have?

The abbess nods to the shattered goblet on the floor. Your wine was laced with poison. Enough that a sip would kill a man twice your size. You experienced slight discomfort, nothing more.

I am shocked into silence as she so easily confesses to poisoning me, and I remember the warm, dizzy feeling I had earlier.

Now come. The abbess stands, walks over to the door, and opens it. Annith will get you settled. Welcome to the convent.

Chapter Three

When I step out of the reverend mother’s office, a girl just slightly younger than I am is waiting. Just like the abbess, she is strikingly fair, with eyes the color of the shifting sea and wisps of pale hair escaping from her veil. Next to her I feel shabby and tattered, as if my very presence is a sacrilege in a convent full of beauty. But the girl smiles at me and tucks my arm through hers as if we have been friends since birth. I am Annith, she says. Let’s get you to the infirmary.

As much as I want to go with her, as much as I want to embrace this new life set before me, I hesitate. There is something I need to understand first. Wait.

Annith tilts her head to the side. What?

If I hadn’t passed the test, would she have let me die of poison? A chill scuttles across my shoulders at how close I came to meeting Death face to face.

Annith’s face clears in understanding. But no! The abbess would have fetched a bezoar stone to neutralize the poison or called for a tincture of amaranth to revive you. Now come. She tugs gently at my arm, and she is so certain and reassuring that it chases away my last remaining doubt.

Our footsteps echo faintly off the stone walls as Annith leads me down a corridor. Doors line the walls on either side of us, and I wonder what secrets these rooms hold and how soon I will be allowed to learn them.

Annith stops when we reach a long chamber with clean, white walls and a row of beds. Fresh air pours in from the window and I hear the sound of waves casting themselves upon the rocky shore beyond. A nun in a midnight blue habit works at a table with a mortar and pestle. At our arrival, she carefully puts her task aside before turning to greet us.

She is of middle years, and her black wimple does not flatter her olive skin. It does, however, match the faint mustache on her upper lip. I am filled with relief that she is not beautiful like the others. At least I will not be the ugliest one here.

The reverend mother sends a new patient? The note of eagerness in the nun’s voice strikes me as unseemly.

Yes, Sister Serafina, Annith says. She has had a bad beating, with many bruises. Possible broken ribs and injuries to her internal organs.

I stare at Annith with new respect. How has she learned all this? Did she listen at the door? Looking at her fresh, delicate face, I find it hard to imagine her doing anything so deceitful.

The nun wipes her hands on a linen cloth and goes to a plain wooden cupboard to retrieve a glass flask. It is not as elegant or ornate as the crystal goblet, but it is every bit as fragile. Even so, she thrusts it into my hands and motions me to a wooden screen in the corner of the room. Evacuate into that, if you please.

I stare stupidly at the flask. The nun looks at Annith. Was her hearing affected, do you think?

No, Sister. Annith’s face is solemn, the picture of dutiful respect, and yet I am sure I can sense a faint spark of humor.

Sister Serafina turns back to me. Piss, she says, a little loudly in case Annith is wrong about my hearing. I need you to piss into the flask so I can tell if you have any internal injuries.

Mortification fills me at this request, but Annith gives me an encouraging nudge. I hurry over to the privacy of the screen and find a chamber pot. I lift my skirts, position myself, and pray I will hit the flask.

The nun speaks again. Her voice is low, but my hearing is sharp from so many years spent listening for my father’s moods.

Did the reverend mother test her?

Yes, Annith tells her. With the wine.

Praise Mortain! She sounds well and truly grateful, and I cannot for a moment imagine why. When I emerge from behind the screen, there is a look of exultation on her plain face. As she takes the flask from me, admiration shines in her eyes, as if she’s just discovered I am not simply a plow horse, but a finely blooded mare. Annith will settle you in one of the beds while I mix a tisane to hasten your healing. She is still smiling as she turns back to her worktable.

Over here. Annith’s hand is gentle on my elbow as she guides me to one of the beds. It is covered in clean white linen, and I am terrified of sullying it. Take off your clothes, Annith orders. I’ll get you a clean shift.

I remember the reverend mother’s command for obedience, but I find I cannot bring myself to do what she asks. Just as the dust from my ragged gown will mar the clean linens, I am sure the sight of my hideous scar will mar Annith’s view of me. I have known her for mere minutes, but already I am afraid to lose her affection.

She returns to my side holding a shift that bears the clean, crisp scent of lavender. Seeing me still clothed, her face softens. Do you need help?

No. I wrap my arms around myself. It is just . . . I . . . my flesh is scarred and ugly and I don’t wish to offend.

Nonsense, she says, and pats my arm. Here at the convent of St. Mortain, we all have scars. As she turns away to give me a moment of privacy, I cannot help but wonder what her scars might be.

I slip out of my old, torn chemise, certain I can still smell the reek of pigs where Guillo touched it.

Matrona’s curse, was it?

I flinch at Sister Serafina’s voice. Desperate to cover myself, I yank the new shift over my head so quickly that I become dizzy. I wait for the sensation to pass before turning to the nun. Pardon me?

She gestures to my back. What your mother used, child. When you were in her womb.

I do not know the name of the herbwitch’s poison.

I do. Her eyes are full of compassion. Only Matrona’s curse would leave such a scar. Now, into bed with you.

Annith hovers as I climb into bed, then leans over and tucks the covers around me. When she is done, Sister Serafina hands me a small cup of foul liquid she swears will make me feel better. I drink the tisane—which tastes of rotten berries and old hay—then hand the cup back. This feeling of being fussed over is new and I cannot tell if I like it or not.

Annith settles herself on the stool next to my bed, then glances over her shoulder to assure herself the nun has returned to her worktable. You may not be able to tell, she says in a low voice. But Sister Serafina is delighted by your arrival. Other than herself, no one here is immune to the effects of poison, and she can scarce keep up with supplying the convent. It will most likely be one of your primary duties when you are healed, helping her in the workroom.

With poisons? I ask, not sure I understand her correctly.

Annith nods, and I glance back at the nun, who is busy once again at the worktable. My head is full of more questions, but as I turn back to ask one, I realize that the bed against the farthest window is occupied.

At first, I am glad, glad I’m not the only one for them to fret over. And then I see that the other girl’s wrists are tied to the bed.

Panic rises in my chest, sharp and hot. It must show on my face because Annith turns and follows my gaze. It is only so she won’t hurt herself, she hurries to explain. She was brought here three nights ago, thrashing and screaming. It took four nuns to restrain her.

My eyes are drawn back to the girl. Is she mad?

Mayhap. Certainly those that brought her here thought so.

Was she given the same test as I was?

She isn’t well enough to be tested yet, but she will be once she is better.

When I look back at the girl, I see her eyes are open and she is staring at us. Slowly, she smiles. It is even more disturbing than her

Enjoying the preview?
Page 1 of 1