Marissa Meyer’s books always have a way of pulling me in. They are so easy and fun to read. I admit the first half of this book was slow and not much Marissa Meyer’s books always have a way of pulling me in. They are so easy and fun to read. I admit the first half of this book was slow and not much happened, but then the second half - I couldn’t put the book down!
I still like the morality debate between the Renegades and the Anarchists. Both are flawed, but you do end up loving the main characters — Adrian, Nova, and Max. And also, their friends.
I absolutely love the running theme of secret identities - the romance is an enemies to lovers story (and there is Nova still pretending to be a Renegade), but also what’s more interesting than that is the added layer of both characters having secret identities that are nemeses.
But I do feel like this storyline has been stretched out from the first book, and I expected it to change here or take a new turn — but the more I read, the more I could see the author was maybe trying to strengthen the development and intensity of that conflict?
The book also had some really cute moments - between Nova and Adrian, yes, but also the brothers relationship between Adrian and Max was wonderful. The book did end in a way that has me desperate for the next book, though. 😬
Highly recommended if you’re a fan of superheroes and super-villains, secret identities, romance, some humor, family dynamics, and just a fun book!
But, while I did enjoy the book and the characters, I have to say that this series isn’t exactly on par with Meyer’s previous series - The Lunar Chronicles. It does have great appeal, but TLC is for everyone, and the characters and plot are a bit richer and more compelling than Renegades. Both are great but I do recommend starting with TLC, and if you love that then there is a huge chance you will enjoy the Renegades trilogy as well!...more
I really enjoyed this book. It was a heartwarming read - not without its share of angst and heartache, though. 💗
The writing: BeRating: 3.5/5 stars. 👍🏼
I really enjoyed this book. It was a heartwarming read - not without its share of angst and heartache, though. 💗
The writing: Beautiful and captivating (some lines poetic - because the male character is called Poet, but it’s clever, fun, easy, and never overwhelming).
The romance/plot: I loved it. A forbidden romance between an uptight princess of Autumn and a very popular Court Jester of Spring... I adored the characters, Briar and Poet, so much (unique and complex, even though they frustrated me at times - but characters can’t always act the way you want them to). There’s one part of the story and a character that completely touched my heart but I feel like it’s a spoiler, so find out yourself! 😉
The world building: was interesting - four kingdoms, each defined by a season. It’s Fantasy because it has its fictional natural laws and political ones as well.
* I was surprised the book had a very heavy theme and issue it dealt with - the mistreatment and oppression of people with disabilities and special needs in this fictional world. Honestly, I’m not sure how I feel about that part of the book. It felt to me like too serious or extreme a problem to not be the central plot or conflict. More than the romance, I ended up concerned about how this aspect of the story would turn out.
Maybe very slightly spoilery down here: You see how that injustice directly affects the main characters — and their emotional struggle with that, the painful choices they have to make because of it — more than it is a plot about fighting against injustice. (Because this is essentially a character driven story about love, courage and inspiring change - so I had to stop hoping for an all out rebellion, or to knock down some awful characters I hated. 😋). To be honest, it was painful and sometimes uncomfortable to read that aspect of the world. But then, it does end up giving room to teach some people in the book a lesson... It strives for positive change. Still, I hope we see how that progresses in the companion book(s) with even more resolution - since I think it’s set in the same world. ((And I have to add, there’s beautiful representation through one character that I absolutely adored.)) end of possible spoilers
There’s a lot of diversity in the book too that I really liked.
Overall, I really enjoyed it. Again - I loved the characters so much! It really was an emotional journey with them! And I would love to read more about Poet and Briar. I signed up for the author’s newsletter for a free outtake, which I’m going to read now!...more
After seeing the mixed reviews, I had no idea what to except - but it I could see this had dragons in it and forbidden rActual rating: 3.5/5 stars
After seeing the mixed reviews, I had no idea what to except - but it I could see this had dragons in it and forbidden romance, and so I just gave it try!
I'm glad I did! I ended up really enjoying the book!
Despite this being a Fantasy story, it was very character driven - which I absolutely loved. Asha is such a complex (and starts as an almost morally grey) heroine, and goes through amazing character development. She is the king's daughter and dragon slayer, known as "Iskari" - meaning "life taker". Her people are afraid of her and blame her for a dragon (that she once lured with her "stories") burning half the city - and leaving her scarred. Most interestingly, she sees herself as inherently corrupt and "wicked" - made to be ashamed of her own desires and thoughts. And the entire book, everything that happens, contributes to Asha's character development and growth from that. It's a wonderful slow build.
I really loved all the side characters - including Asha's brother Dax, her cousin Safire (cast aside for having a royal father and a slave "Skral" mother), Roa, Torwin and how they all play into the story! The politics and history dividing these characters in this world are interesting! From royalty to enemies to slaves and rebels.
Of those supporting characters, my favorite was Torwin (the Skral slave of Asha's awful betrothed, the Commandant). He's the most fleshed out of them too. So pure with real strength and determination despite his harsh life.
I also really enjoyed the romance in this one! Not just because of the 'forbidden love' aspect - but the slow burn between Asha and Torwin was so well done. He's not afraid of her like everyone else is, and steadfastly shows her tenderness and understanding she's missing. They don't have the best start (Asha is prejudiced against the Skral at first) or an easy journey, but then things change and you can see how and why they connected. I really loved their moments together!
The plot had an excellent pace and kept me engaged the entire time I read! The world building was very interesting with its twist on dragons - their intelligence and how they communicate through the telling of stories. The dragons actually play a role in the book and aren't just 'there'. Still, I do wish they had an even larger part. The idea of a rider forming a "link" with their dragon was really intriguing, and could have been fun to explore further (maybe in the next book!).
The political part of the story - the division of the realm and the brewing rebellions - also shaped the plot and added suspense very nicely!
* That being said, the only thing I'm not sure how I feel about is the "religion" aspect in the book -- shown both through the "old stories" and the presence of the "Old One" (a higher power) influencing the plot. It feels almost reminiscent of (or inspired by) biblical tales more than shaping a completely original fantastical one. Or rather, it's a blend of both... I don't know if that worked for me. But at least I like that Asha's motivations are personal and driven by her own character growth and self discovery - not just for a religious cause. I mean, that's fine too, but in Fantasy books I enjoy character based heroism more!
On the other hand, I think it's unique and interesting of this book to portray the idea of religion/faith (even in a fictional world) in a positive light. Most Fantasy books show an opposite side on that. So, I guess that's a cool direction too.
Overall, this was a very enjoyable read and it kept me engaged, caring about the characters, and finding so many memorable moments that stood out! If you like fierce and complex heroines, excellent and gradual character development, complicated and slow burn romances (that are also very sweet), mythology and legends, and yes, of course dragons - then give this book a try!
I'm excited about the sequel to know what happens next with Asha and Torwin, and also learning more about Dax, Roa and Safire - since I'm pretty sure it's a companion sequel!...more
"Why do we desire, above all other things, that which has the greatest power to destroy us?”
Rating: 3.5/5 stars.
A nice, atmospheric autumn rea
"Why do we desire, above all other things, that which has the greatest power to destroy us?”
Rating: 3.5/5 stars.
A nice, atmospheric autumn read. It was also a quick read at 300 pages - but to be honest, I think that was a downside. I mean, loved the settings & the characters/their relationship. Rook and Isobel were delightful - I loved the banter and enjoyed the romance. 💖
But, the plot... It was a bit thin. The world and story had so much potential, (and we got hints of bigger things), but I felt it was wrapped up a bit too quickly. It was a satisfying ending, but it felt too simple. Like there could have been more to the story.
But overall, I really did enjoy this book and recommend it. Maybe my expectations were just too high! 😄...more
This time, the story follows Lyss - Ash's sister, and Raisa and Han's youngest - heir to the throne and aI liked this even better than the first book!
This time, the story follows Lyss - Ash's sister, and Raisa and Han's youngest - heir to the throne and also known as the fierce Captain Gray to her soldiers, and the ghost story "The Gray Wolf" to the Ardenine enemy.
The setting: is mostly centered on the Fells (nortern part of the map) and the events run almost parallel in time to the previous book - so Ash doesn't make an appearance (although Jenna and her dragon do!).
Plot: I really loved how different Lyss is as a warrior princess from her mother Raisa. She's tired of the unchanging war, still grief stricken from thinking her brother is dead, and is willing to take a risk. And so, she and her friends take the war forward into Arden, starting with taking over the industrial city of Delphi - and imprisoning any survivors, which includes the young Ardenine Captain, Hal Matelon. (An event mentioned in the previous book, which propels the Thanes' rebellion).
* All the characters are great, and what I loved most is the romance in this book! Star crossed romances of enemies falling in love is one of my favorite tropes! And unlike the frustrating insta-love between Ash&Jenna in the first book, this one worked so much better! Cute moments with hope for more development in the next books!
* Also, another character introduced is Breon - a street performer who gets unknowingly roped into a plot to kill the princess. His story takes the "magemark" plot forward with his mysterious past and unknown connection to Carthis and its evil "Empress Celestine" - like Jenna and Evan Strangeward, who both make appearances in the book!
Overall: There's a lot to enjoy, and so many characters shaping up the story. I think my one gripe actually is that there are so many main players in the overall story that I don't know how they will all fit in in the next book. And I want them all to be there. From the title of the next book, I can guess who it will be about - which is interesting - but I also want more of Lyss, Hal, Ash, and Jenna (mostly because of her dragon - Cas).
My biggest hope is that this series will not have a tangle of love triangles - with the first series, at least I knew that Han and Raisa would be center stage throughout.
Buddy-read with Kristalia! (Hopefully, you'll finish it one day, Krista! 😋😉💗)...more
"History is written by the victors. The truth is, the villains were less villainous, and the heroes less heroic,
5 stars for the entire series!
"History is written by the victors. The truth is, the villains were less villainous, and the heroes less heroic, than you’ve been told.”
I can't believe it's over! I never wanted it to end! But this finale gave me everything I wanted in an ending to this series and more. I'm still reeling with the feels and they are all good!
I feel like this book is what a finale should be. If there was a lot of time setting up and building the world/characters/plot/schemes in the previous books, then this one makes it all worth it! Everything comes out of the bag here! Every chapter was filled with suspense, intrigue and just so much going on that I was getting anxiety, constantly worried about the characters - especially Han. He was amazing in this book!
“He won’t make his move until he knows he can win it all.” “But what if that never happens?” Raisa said. “He won’t settle,” Cat said. “He’ll wait forever if need be.”
If the previous one was Raisa's moment to shine then this one belongs to Han. He's the perfect blend of street-wise and political cleverness motivated by profound love and loss. Great character development. And it's this book that really made me fall in love with Han!
“Haven’t you heard about me?” he said, with a tight smile. “I’m really a very dangerous person.” And he did look dangerous until he said, “Look, could you watch Dog for me while I’m gone? I can’t take him where I’m going.”
All of the characters are great in this. There's more of the supporting characters - Dancer (yay!), Micah (I knew he had potential), Cat, and Crow (so many feels with this character), except sadly (and this hurts) again there isn't nearly enough of Amon. I expected and wanted more for him, especially since he started off as somewhat of a 'main character' in the first two books.
I like how the series took time to let us understand all the parts of this world - explored through the characters' lives and trials. It's a story about a country/realm shared by diverse and feuding people, their twisted history shaping their present, and how that all is challenged by new conflicts and revelations. There isn't only one side to take or just one big bad villain to defeat and save the day. The political schemes and secrets (and murder mysteries) kept me on edge, and along with the characters, you don't know who to trust.
And of course, there's a good dose of forbidden-love fueling the story (beautiful shipper bliss with no more triangles -- finally! -- just tons of obstacles). If I was unsure about Han/Raisa together before reading this book, I am 100% convinced now. After the first two books kicked off with multiple possible 'romances', it takes a lot to make the final romance feel like the real thing. And it really really does! I believed in and loved this pair of beautiful and passionate characters who defended each other and fought relentlessly (especially Han with all he's done and would do to be with Raisa!)
"I don’t want your throne,” Han said. “Then what do you want?” Raisa asked. “You.”
"Didn’t you ever wish you could have a…a partner? A friend? Somebody you could say anything to—where you didn’t have to pick and choose words like a merchant at market? Someone who wants you for yourself?”
(Enough quotes because I won't spoil the really good ones in my review!)
I loved all of it and I anticipate a book hangover when I wake up tomorrow (as usual this book kept me up till 4:30 am) and I will probably wish there was still more to read of this story.
Overall, it's an incredible final book! The series is a wonderful treat for YA fantasy fans like me! Or maybe if you read a lot of the genre, it won't feel entirely new or blow you away with originality. And yet I didn't mind one bit and enjoyed it completely. It's like getting a box of sweets, with flavors you're familiar with, but they end up surprising you by tasting better than you expected! Weird and random analogy, I know. It's way too late in the night/morning for my sleep deprived self to make sense.
So yeah, I'm happy with this finale. It is definitely my favorite book in this series. ...more
First half of the book was great and kept throwing surprises and intense moments, one after another -- but then the next half showed a bit of 'middle First half of the book was great and kept throwing surprises and intense moments, one after another -- but then the next half showed a bit of 'middle book syndrome'. I was still completely engaged in the events and characters, but there's a lot I was waiting for to happen and wanted to know more about, (big spoilers in there>>)(view spoiler)[the book never actually showed Han in the wizard council meetings after becoming a member (we barely got a mention of it), and there wasn't another try to visit Alger Waterlow after he freaked out over Dancer being a Bayar, and even that revelation wasn't mentioned again after that (did Dancer tell Cat about it? We need more focus on Dancer!) -- what we had was the book going in circles with the political plans and threats up until the coronation (hide spoiler)] but clearly all the big stuff is being kept for the final book. And the fourth book is about 600 pages long, so I am expecting it to have everything I'm hoping for! And I am invested enough in this series and its characters to have really high hopes!
Which is why I'm going to start the next book now despite it being 12:30 am (this series keeps making me stay up and I have no will power).
But before ending the review -- one more thing that disappointed me is that Amon got a bit sidelined as a character. He's one of my favorite characters, not just as a love-interest for Raisa (I adore their friendship too), and he was mostly in the background in this book. I get that Han and Raisa are the leads, but the supporting characters like Amon, Dancer, Cat (and even Micah) are great too. Within 500+ pages, I think there could be room to show a bit more of them.
All in all, still loving this! And despite my excitement for the final book, I don't want the series to end soon. ...more
“But it’s not enough to know right from wrong. You need the strength to do what’s right, even when what you want most in the world is the wron
“But it’s not enough to know right from wrong. You need the strength to do what’s right, even when what you want most in the world is the wrong thing.”
4 stars! (Would give it 3.5 to be objective but my enjoyment level pushes it up).
I'm having such a great time reading this series!
The setting is different from the first book -- the characters go to neighboring wizard and military schools! I really enjoyed the school setting. And for a while in the book, the characters in the wizard school (Han, Dancer, Micah, Fiona...) have no idea that the princess is in disguise and enrolled as a cadet across the bridge with Amon and his crew.
And I'm not usually a fan of school settings -- it's part of why I'm not a fan of contemporary YA -- but here, it's more like a year long training and preparing for the dangers and war building back in their home.
The web of intrigue and political conflict keeps twisting further in the queendom despite our MC's being away from the conflict and in school. But there's lots of plotting and secrets surrounding them and reaching them. (I still need to know who Crow -- Han's mysterious tutor -- is!).
The book starts a bit slow (a chunk is spent with them being on the road on their way to the school), but then picks up the pace and I couldn't put it down!
I enjoyed the character development the most in this book!
Just because you’re the enemy of my enemy don’t mean you’re my friend, Han thought.
In the first book, I couldn't get a feel for Han's "streetlord" side very much. And near the end, his feelings after everything was taken from him didn't get much focus. But in this book, it's all over him -- his anger and hate towards his enemies, his drive for revenge, and his daring attitude. And he's in the same school with his enemies and "blueblood" wizards he never thought he'd have to measure up against. More than that, despite every powerful person trying to use him for their own agendas, he's kind of using them for his own interests and plans too. I'm excited to see how that works out in the next books (I expect lots of trouble for him)!
Raisa really could become one of my favorite female MC's!
I tend to stir people up, not settle them down.
She has more reason to doubt herself, she's in disguise, she's out of her element but works hard to learn and adapt. But outside of her refuge, she's still in the focus of every twisted and dangerous plot. In the previous book, she's wondered if it's just the dress and jewelry that make her a princess but now, she has none of that but retains that strength of character that shows the queen she'll be. Except when she's trying to navigate her love life...
To be honest, I wasn't as annoyed by the love triangle as I might have been. It helps that I like both the guy characters -- Han is great of course, and Amon is a perfect cutie pie that I adore so much!! But she doesn't fall for them at the same time and I think the feelings and heartbreak she goes through teach her something about herself that just adds to her character growth.
Raisa and Han's interactions (and romance) are also interesting because he still thinks she's Rebecca Morley, former upperclass tutor, and not the Princess heir -- who he's already grouped with all the people responsible for the terrible things he went through.
And did I just mention how much I love Amon? Because I do! It's a shame he didn't get even one POV chapter in this book, but he's still a prominent character. I know that the "good", loyal, and steadfast characters aren't people's favorite but I tend to like them as much as the morally dubious ones. Especially when they're tortured but take it in stride like Amon.
Another wonderful character is Dancer -- who I wish had a bigger role than just Han's loyal BFF. But I loved the addition of Cat as their friend too, and I actually shipped Cat and Dancer the second they met even though she's so awful to him!
As for Micah, he spent most of the book being a rip off of Draco Malfoy, and I was disappointed because he showed a lot of potential as a gray and morally confused character in the previous book. But near the end of the book that potential creeped back up (only in scenes with Raisa, apparently), so I'm back to being a bit interested in what his future choices will be.
There's a lot more characters in this book and you don't know who to trust, and who could be a future threat or ally! It's fun!
But the series is still tropey so far (there's some Harry Potter/Hogwarts deja vu here and there), but I don't mind that. It's still such an engaging read and overall the story keeps building and is keeping me hooked!
Actual rating: 3.5/5 stars. (Rounded to three Goodreads stars even though I might change to four later - undecided)
Okay, so this book pretty much Actual rating: 3.5/5 stars. (Rounded to three Goodreads stars even though I might change to four later - undecided)
Okay, so this book pretty much consumed me for the past couple of days. I could not put it down until I got all the answers to this captivating and romantic ghostly mystery.
The story revolves around three characters who are closely connected in a pretty complicated way that reveals itself as the story goes on. Our main character Juliet Emerline, is a girl who's just lost her mother when we meet her; and she's also a girl who's lost her hearing at a young age but is talented at lip-reading. At her mother's cemetery, she comes across another grief stricken man at an enclosed grave with only the word "Hawk" on the headstone. Once alone, she steals a flower from that grave - one that surprisngly allows a ghost to start appearing to her. A ghost that she can hear talk and sing, and who she forms a tight bond with (and falls in love with). The ghost, who she calls Hawk, doesn't remember his life or how he died. But he and Juliet know the answers are somehow connected to the man who was at his grave, Viscount Thorton; the same man who is trying to buy her childhood home and wants to marry her. And he offers her a job selling hats at his estate. So, for the sake of her ghost, she sets out to Thornton's estate to solve the mystery of his death and past life, and how it relates to the viscount and an old gypsy lady who watches over his grave.
I really liked the setting being nineteenth century England, which gives the perfect atmosphere for a gothic romance. It vaguely reminded me of Jane Eyre during Juliet's time in Thornton's manor, where she and her ghost "Hawk" keep growing wary because of the disturbing rumors surrounding the enigmatic viscount and the sounds that Hawk hears and warns Juliet about coming from above her room. Also because of the time period, Juliet has always felt like she might not be accepted or comfortable socially because of her disability. But this challenge to step out adds to her character growth and how she gains confidence and self-acceptance through her journey in the book.
There is a triangle in this book and as much as I tried to focus on the mystery and ignore it - it really took priority. But while it did not endear me to triangles in stories, it wasn't the regular kind, and both sides of the romance here each have their share of beautiful moments. The three characters are connected in a complicated and interesting way (especially the two men) that is revealed through the book - it's a part of the mystery I can't spoil. Triangles usually make all the characters involved look bad, no exceptions here, but I think I understood Juliet's feelings for both men and the conflict that presents, especially since one of them is a ghost (who she can't touch without sad consequences). There's an intriguing secrecy and unpredictability about the two male characters, as different as they are from on another, which had me at times questioning how trustful one is over the other -- which is a good thing in a mystery novel. (And it's always a great thing when characters are complex.) Still, the book managed to make me feel for all three characters.
The mystery is what really captivated me in the novel. It kept unfolding bit by bit in a way that had me dying to skip to the end at times, because of all the theories it built up in my head. There are enough clues that made me guess a couple of things ahead of the characters (which was exciting to wait to be sure, but then one might argue these parts are made a bit predictable). But, new questions and surprises kept popping up that kept me constantly wondering, and the bonds between the characters made me care more to know every detail. And I was afraid this would have slow pacing but I was surprised that I was never bored.
My complaint, and unfortunately it made me take down stars from my rating, is that I was a bit disappointed by the ending. It did not leave any loose ends, nor was I upset by anything in particular, and I liked how the 'mystery' concluded (what we learn happened), but I was not really satisfied by how it was presented to us. There was so much built up, to the point of suspense, that I expected more from the ending. Some important information and events I was waiting for were "told" to Juliet rather than "shown". Maybe it's just me having let my expectations grow too high. But the ending did feel a bit too convenient, and too neatly and quickly settled. The ending as it is in the book should have gotten more of an emotional response from me, but I just felt like something was missing. And yet nothing was notably missing and everything was indeed concluded by the end. Oh, well.
That being said, overall this was just the kind of book I've been wanting to read. A romantic mystery with a ghost (yes, I've been looking for this actually - not weird!), interesting characters, some diversity, painful backstories, and a beautiful setting. Yes, it could have been a bit better at the end, but that doesn't stop me from appreciating the whole book and how for the most part, it was an enthralling and enjoyable experience that I would want repeated in a heart beat through the upcoming novels in this series. I don't think the rest of the books continue this story (this one looks to be concluded), but they will probably have the same romantic and haunting atmosphere which I really liked in this book!
Also, I wish that more books in this genre (New Adult) tried something new like this, instead of the usual contemporary. This genre needs more of the historical, the paranormal, the fantastical... There is a readership for this type of novel, I'm sure of it as I'm definitely one of them.
I can't believe it's over... I feel like I'm having a major b
“She’s our lost princess. And she’s coming home.”
Actual rating: 4.75/5 stars!
I can't believe it's over... I feel like I'm having a major book hangover after two amazing fun-tastic months of non stop Lunar Chronicles!
[image]
This review will probably be longer than I want it to be -- only because I have so much to say before I can say it's totally over and focus on the next book I'm reading.
I've kind of stopped expecting anything action-filled or mind blowing from final books in sci-fi/fantasy series... I just hope for a satisfying ending now. Was I satisfied with the ending to the Lunar Chronicles? Yes. A big fat yes! But wait -- it also turned out to be 800+ pages of fast paced, surprising, non-stop action, danger, and fun, while also keeping a hold of your heart in all the right ways. So, just about that epic and exciting finale I'd stopped hoping for - and finally got! I'm not saying the book was perfect -- I have a tiny gripe or two I'll mention at the end of the review -- but it was pretty damn close to it.
So I feel this book is really where the story begins and ends. It's what all the previous books were leading up to -- the Lunar revolution that Cinder and her friends are starting. All the character drama and misunderstandings (I'm looking at Kai and Cinder) were dealt with at the end of the previous book, and now mostly everyone is unified on this goal. And so most of the book takes place on Luna.
[image]
Unlike the world-building in previous books where we don't learn that much about this changed futuristic Earth, this book explores pretty much all of Luna. To recruit fighters, Cinder's revolution takes her and the gang into the outer sectors - where Wolf's family lives (who's left of them) - and also the tunnels a.k.a the mutant wolf soliders' barracks, among other places. So many characters moving around, so many things happening at once at so many places -- it's a roller coaster across Luna.
My love for this series mostly stems from how much I've come to adore the characters, so the character development was a real treat for me here.
Cinder -- this girl has really grown up. She's come a long way from being the reluctant and confused girl or the hesitant leader in the previous books-- she's fully embraced her identity and role in this revolution. She's become passionate and fierce -- her powers showing her a true match for Levana.
[image]
"If that means I have to lose so these people can go free, so be it. What you don’t seem to realize is that this isn’t about me. It’s about the people who have lived in oppression for far too long. Levana’s rule is coming to an end.”
But there's always this gray area that Cinder faces -- what she's willing to do and how much she's willing sacrifice to beat Levana. Sometimes she's scared and has self-doubts, but it's war and people around her get hurt. I keep going from cheering for her and at some points just being anxious wondering what her choice will be as a leader.
Did it matter that they were willing to die for her cause? Did it matter that they would sacrifice their own lives so she might succeed? She didn’t know. She didn’t know.
I've always loved Kai since the 1st book, but if he hasn't impressed you yet, he really pulls through in this one. He has to play his part with Levana and he has his own planet and country to think about but he's still an important part of the revolution - still part of the team. He has so much faith in Cinder.
He set his brow against hers, the tips of his hair brushing her cheeks. “I’m on your side,” he said. “No matter what.” "I know.”
And yet, I like that he doesn't totally rely on her. He's still a decisive emperor who challenges Levana in his own way (view spoiler)[(watch out for that wedding scene) (hide spoiler)]. And despite he and Cinder being the youngest couple in the group, there was always something very grown up and patient about their relationship even through the angst, fears and misunderstandings in the previous books.
Oh, and I loved how Kai fit into the group (how I love this quirky gang). The interactions he's involved in are brief but awesome. His little "bromantic" chat (or relationship counseling) with Thorne is everything!
Can I finally get to Thorne and Cress? Yess!
[image]
I don't know if I should talk about them together or individually - they both have great character development on their own. And the romance helps inspire that, rather than take over their storylines.
She would be brave. She would be heroic. She would make her own destiny.
Cress and Thorne - they make each other better. She secretly wants to be braver, he now secretly wants to do the right thing for the right reasons - and they sort of inspire each other and believe the best in one another. Oh, and they are adorable In the previous book, their slow-burn of feelings was left unspoken, so it continues here -- quiet but obvious emotions that do come to a heated and wonderful point. They're my favorite couple in the series, for sure -- and I'll stop now before I post any spoilery quotes I really wanna share!
And of course Thorne remains hilarious in this book. He and Iko -- who is wonderful and very much at the center of it all with Cinder -- each provide the kind of humor that will keep you smiling as you read. And the number of times Thorne said something he shouldn't have and got kicked or smacked by Cinder. I live for those moments. Thorne and Cinder's banter carries on.
And Iko is a hero here and her friendship with Cinder is so heartwarming.
"I’m broken. I’m literally broken.” Iko settled a hand on Cinder’s shoulder. “Yeah, but broken isn’t the same as unfixable.”
And there is a new character I ship pretty hard with Iko -- tell me if you notice the potential sparks too!
Scarlet was back in top form in this book after being a bit MIA in the last book. I love how bold and feisty she is. Just so badass. She really impressed me here. And Wolf just about broke my heart in this book. Things get tough for Wolf here, but he and Scarlet together... These two, I loved them even more in this book. Their relationship is the enduring "fairytale love" that you can't help but feel for. I mean, Wolf is a cutie pie -- how could I not want a happy ending for him?
I also loved Scarlet's friendship with Winter -- they're pretty much opposites. Sweet (Winter) and spicy (Scarlet). I'm this close to using a Power-puff Girls reference - or did I already? Anyway, I love how it developed. They escape the palace together, they recruit scary looking Wolf men into their army, they face near death experiences together -- the stuff of legendary friendships.
Winter: "Hello, friend." Scarlet: "Hello, crazy."
Now last but not least... Winter (and Jacin). I already liked Winter when I read her prequel story "The Princess and the Guard" in the book, "Stars Above". She's made the choice not to use her powers and that caused her to slowly lose her grip on her sanity. But her determination is her strength. She's also pretty adorable - flighty but caring with a touch of mischief. Her story here also takes a lot of inspiration from Snow White (more than I expected - but in a good way), yet also unique to her character.
As for Jacin Clay... I really liked Jacin both in "Cress" and "the Princess and the Guard". In the previous book, he was sarcastic, cool, had an interesting dynamic with with the team. But here, it's like it's all about Winter for him. All his motivations revolve around her - or it seemed that way. I started to lose interest in him. I mean I like how protective he is of her, but he seemed to lose character when we saw little else. At least, he admits it:
“I fear tomorrow will be even more difficult for you, Sir Clay. Do try to think of me when you can.” "Try, Princess?” He smirked up at her. “I can’t seem to think of much else.”
I like when Scarlet called him out in a way:
"Don’t snap at her,” said Jacin. "Don’t coddle her,” snapped Scarlet.
That being said -- Jacin and Winter are definitely "true love" material. They've been there for each other their whole lives, and their forbidden love is hard not to fall for. They were just probably my least favorite couple, and I liked them still.
Levana was her usual crazy self. She's as diabolical as ever, but mostly I felt she was just there to make life difficult for everyone. But there's more revealed about her and her past that I already knew because I'd read her prequel novel, Fairest, but if you haven't then you get to learn more about her.
Now, don't read thisunless you've read Winter - it's very spoilery on the ending: (view spoiler)[As for the one gripe I had with this book.... I don't want to nitpick (and I notice no one really had a problem with this). But there was a little snag in the story for me --- when they exposed what was under Levana's glamour in a broadcast video to throw her off. And they were her burn scars. Of all the things that could be used against her... That? It felt wrong... Now, I understand it's "war" and the idea is that Levana is being exposed as a "liar" -- as opposed to Cinder who doesn't hide her cyborg parts:
Cinder hated her own mind for labeling the queen as grotesque. She had once been a victim, as Cinder had once been a victim. And how many had labeled Cinder’s own metal limbs as grotesque, unnatural, disgusting? No. Levana was a monster, but it wasn’t because of the face she’d kept hidden all these years. Her monstrosities were buried much deeper than that.
Yes, that made it better a little bit. But still, I wish the book didn't go there in the first place with that particular tactic. Even at one point, Iko described Levana's face as "horrifying" (whether or not she knew the cause of the scars). Books are about representation, so you gotta be careful what you put out there. Levana, the brain-washing tyrant we all hate is not real. But burn victims are. I'm probably blowing this up and making it sound worse than it is, but it's still the one part of the book I didn't totally love. (hide spoiler)]
The book never dragged but just around 80% or so... it was suddenly showing how very long the book is. But then things picked up quickly and really big stuff started happening during the final battle scenes... It might have given me a heart attack or two.
In short: this series is unforgettable, and it's already one of my favorites. I don't know when I'll find another series that makes me so invested in everything about it, and can make me smile even when I'm completely stressed out. This book is an epic finale that is packed with suspense, surprises, emotion and a lot of fun. I won't say much on the very end of it -- except that it's a wonderful conclusion and you should definitely, without a doubt, follow it up with reading the epilogue in "Stars Above"!
Actual rating: firm 4 stars as the finale to the trilogy. But on its own, I would give it 3.5 stars.
I have no clue how to start this review. My thoughActual rating: firm 4 stars as the finale to the trilogy. But on its own, I would give it 3.5 stars.
I have no clue how to start this review. My thoughts are all over the place, my feelings are swirl of mixed emotions, and since I've never reviewed the previous books, I don't know where to start!
Warning: This review might feel like it was written by two different people. I am that torn about how I feel about this book!
I'll start by saying that I loved this trilogy from the first book. I know some readers took time to get into the series, but the very first chapter of book one was a hook-in for me. The Winner's Curse and The Winner's Crime consumed all my time (and thoughts) for the four days it took me to finish them a few months ago. I could not put them down. So I was expecting the same experience (and more) from the final book.
I wish I could say this book was the same for me as the first two. I really do. But honestly (and I know this is an unpopular opinion), it wasn't exactly.
--I'll start with what I LIKED about the book (because there is a lot to like):
The characters: In this series, it's always the characters that come first for me. Arin and Kestrel are amazing characters that develop beautifully and tragically throughout the series. In this book, the wounds they've suffered from the previous books are more apparent than ever. I think that's what the book is more about - exploring what the war has done (and is doing) to the main characters more than just the event of the war itself. Both characters are haunted by what they've each lost. They've been through hell apart and together, and now they are both facing their darkest challenges inside themselves and around them. But they're stronger together and for each other; they're equals in every way. I love that about them, and that important aspect of their characterization and relationship is very much there in the book.
Kestrel and Arin are not the only main characters in this final installment. There is Roshar, the Dacran Prince, who has allied his army's forces with the Herrani in this war against the Valorions. I did not expect to love Roshar so much but I'm dangerously close to saying a lot of his scenes made the book for me - or parts of the book! He had the best lines. His banter with Arin was so refreshing amidst the seriousness of war. There is a real depth to their friendship that surprised me. And Roshar is hardly the comic relief. There's a lot more to him that he hides under his wit and smugness. I wouldn't mind a novella or something from Roshar's POV.
I also have to mention Verex (still so adorable) and Risha. They don't appear until later in the book (unfortunately) but they still have their parts to play in the story - especially Risha.
The Writing:I don't remember being so in awe by the author's way with words in the first two books. Or maybe I was too immersed in the story to notice. But wow, is this book beautifully written! The subtle way the use of imagery can paint the strength of the character's emotions and state of mind... Subtle but also evocative. Maybe, not all the book was completely engrossing for me, but when it counted, it really did make me feel. One example is (view spoiler)[the way this book handled Kestrel's relationship with her father. She goes through a long journey to come to terms with her feelings, and so I expected a huge confrontation with her father when they meet. But like the majority of this book, the most intense scenes are still so... quiet. Despite that, this one scene felt powerful to me. It made me cry - which I don't remember happening with a book in years. (hide spoiler)]
One more thing I loved: The ending! I won't spoil it but I am totally and completely satisfied and happy with how this trilogy ends. The last 20% or 15% of this book was an emotional ride. One that left me either smiling or in tears - or both.
--What I DIDN'T LIKE:
As you can see there was a lot for me to love. But - and unfortunately this is a pretty strong "but" - there are also aspects of the book I didn't totally enjoy.
Truthfully - it just didn't have the same magical hold over me as the previous two books. Not nearly.
Yes, the characters are amazing, the writing was overall gorgeous (and impactful when it counted), and the conclusion was all I wished for...
But then why was it so easy for me to put down the book and get distracted from it? Why is that for 60% or 70% of this book - I can't believe I'm using this word for this series - I was bored.
The books starts and ends very strongly. But the in-between felt to me like I was drifting in and out of the same events. For a book set during a war, there was a lot of downtime. They would strategize for the battles, hang around the camp, talk, strategize some more, actually have one brief battle or two before retreating - then repeat (minus the action). I was waiting for the suspense to build or come to a head... I really had to wait. I actually thought I would enjoy the character's strategizing and show of cleverness (and I did to an extent) but the scenes lacked excitement and thrill.
And to my disappointment I felt that way a little about the romance. There is no doubt Arin and Kestrel are absolutely perfect together here. In this book, they have to rebuild things within themselves and together - it's a slow burn all over again but also with the same depth they had before present. But the subtle growth (or regrowth) of their relationship in this book.... It didn't work for me. I understood it. Unlike the first two books, the surrounding danger here didn't threaten their relationship directly, there was no reason for more angst between them... I get that. The lack of drama is not what bothered me. I liked that they finally found each other. But that old spark they had... It was really softened here. Only once or twice I felt completely gripped during their moments together. And those were moments I'd already been anticipating since the previous book's end. Nothing really surprised me here. For readers who (unlike me) were never big fans of the romance that was center in the first book, this probably won't be an issue.
I can truly appreciate the book for what it is - a beautifully written and satisfying conclusion. It's just not the same for me as the other two books. It just felt very different. I liked it but I didn't LOVE it like the other two. And I can't help comparing it to them, because it is the third and final book. I expected more. Everything was tempered down and even the lovely writing made it all feel slow and dreamlike at times. Which isn't always a good thing.
---I might have contradicted myself in this review more than once. That's what happens when my thoughts and emotions are so conflicted - I make very little sense. I almost didn't post this review, because of that. I reeeally wanted to love this as much as almost everyone did. :(
All the disappointment and expectations aside, this trilogy as a whole is really unforgettable and it stands out among YA novels with characters that will make other books have a lot to compete with. ...more
Actual rating: 3.5/5 stars, rounded up to 4 stars.
I didn't expect much from this book, but I was so pleasantly surprised! I really liked it! Not tActual rating: 3.5/5 stars, rounded up to 4 stars.
I didn't expect much from this book, but I was so pleasantly surprised! I really liked it! Not the most complex or orignal - but perfectly enjoyable and just what I like, all the same!
Yes, it wasn't that different from a lot of YA Fantasy, but that combined trope of revenge, warring kingdoms, and star-crossed love is exactly my favorite type! And this was done nicely!
I thought the Pacing really worked well! After reading ACOWAR where one "meeting" scene would go on for four chapters, I really appreciated the concise and to-the-point approach here! And yet, the emotional scenes still had a strong punch and I was completely invested in the characters!
I liked Em (short for Emelina) - our main character. She's a princess of a fallen kingdom of magically-powered people called the "Ruined" but is regarded as useless because of her lack of powers. Still, she's fierce, determined and skilled in battle. She orchestrates a plot to marry the prince of the invading kingdom by disguising herself as his actual fiancee - to save her kidnapped sister and launch an attack with an allied force of "warriors" from another kingdom.
I like all the Characters, especially the absolutely adorable cinnamon roll - Prince Cas! (short for Casimir - everyone needs a shortened nickname, I guess). His father is a tyrant of a king who killed Em's mother, but Cas starts as a sheltered (yet well trained) prince, who gets a kind of wake-up call while being married to Em. He starts to confidently question his father and his decisions, while Em (whose original plan includes killing him) is not prepared for how different he is from what she imagined.
In short, I thought the Romance between them was adorable, and of course, I enjoyed all the angst that came with the deception and forbidden love. I don't care about cliches - I liked it.
I'm also excited to know more about Aren - Em's best friend, who's fiercely loyal and gifted with a lot of Ruined power. And I also liked Iria, and Galo, and I'm curious about Olivia. I don't care one bit about - Cas's cousin, whose name I can't even remember.
The World-building isn't that clearly etched but we get a good enough idea of the history that propelled the events in the book. So, I was fine with it. I do wish the book had a map, though. I need maps in books with various kingdoms and strange names and locations I have to remember!
The ending definitely has me excited for the sequel, which I will read asap!
Overall: A good choice of for fans of YA Fantasy. Not the most compelling or fleshed out in the genre, but still promising and very enjoyable!
Buddy-read with Spira-virgo. (Or at least, I think it's a buddy-read. Still waiting for your thoughts, Oz! 😋)...more
Actual rating: Undecided whether it leave to it 3/5 stars, or add a half star to 3.5/5 because I still love the characters and world a lot. Hmm.
AActual rating: Undecided whether it leave to it 3/5 stars, or add a half star to 3.5/5 because I still love the characters and world a lot. Hmm.
A year ago, I happened to come across the first book in this series, Nameless, and after deciding to give it a try - with zero expectations - the book turned out to be everything I was looking for! It had intriguing world building, incredible development of layered characters, unlikely love (both romantic and familial) between enemies, spies and a growing revolution of the oppressed. It was great!
And when I started this, I instantly remembered why I loved it (even though I needed to refresh my memory of the last book a bit), and cared for the characters as if I'd finished the first book yesterday!
This sequel's strengths:
It expanded more on the world building, now that the characters have escaped the confines of the Ram Gate. Beyond the "Ram" and "The Wolf", we learn more about the other clans, "The Raven" and even the " Kodiak" - as well the actual history between the clans. I like how the clans are inspired by the author's love of history and various tribes and peoples. From what I've read in interviews, The conquering Ram are loosely inspired by the Spartans, The Wolves by the Vikings, The Raven by the Native American "Navajo" tribe, and The Kodiak by the "Maori". I don't know much or anything about them, but the fictional counterparts were interesting. The Ram is set apart as the villain and mighty enemy of the three allied clans. And so the unlikely love between the Ram and the Wolf that makes our little group of characters puts them on the run as they find themselves responsible for the rebellion they've started.
The first book reminded me a little bit of the The Winner's Curse when I read it, which definitely helped towards me enjoying it. But this book didn't really remind me of any other story as it went into very unpredictable paths.
The characters are the strength of the series. Gryphon and Zo are separated for more most of the book - each one having been led to believe, by their "friend", that the other was killed by the Ram. Despite their grief, each has to stay on course of their missions - he, for the promise he made her, and she, to take care of Tess and Joshua. The character development continues as beautifully as it did in the first book. Now a deserter to his clan and a wanted-man, Gryphon still struggles with his loss and choices especially now that (he thinks) he doesn't have Zo to fight for. But he's not the same man who thought his kindness a weakness and was desperate to prove himself to his brutal clan. He grows into his convictions on his own, and gets even more eye openers in this book. And Zo has grown so much from the girl who'd closed off her heart to anything but revenge and hate for the Ram. Since the events of the last book and having feelings for Gryphon, her walls break and now every choice she makes is for the people she loves and calls her family.
The romance is still so great and satisfying! But what I also like about this series that it focuses on familial love, not just by blood, just as strongly as romantic, if not more. Gryphon and Joshua's fierce mentor/brotherly bond, and Zo's love and protection towards Tess and Joshua. So the characters are really the heart of the series. And I think even the lying jerk, Gabe, is redeemable.
The sequel's weaknesses:
The problem with this book is that despite all that happens, it didn't feel like much happened. Except for going in circles. Especially compared to the first book which never had a dull moment. This one felt very much like the "middle" book in the series. Mostly bridging between the beginning and end. It set up some potentially big events but not enough that I was satisfied. The only thing I felt got its due development were Gryphon and Zo's feelings for each other. Besides that, I felt the ending was abrupt. My exact reaction to reaching the final page is: "that's it??!". I wasn't convinced or happy with one decision made at the very end - which felt hastily made. And the writing overall just didn't feel like it had the same amount of attention the first book had.
So... I need the last book to really feel like the story has moved forward.
That being said, I am very much looking forward the final book and I hope it has the same high stakes action and drama as the first. And I hope it brings out the twists I know this series is hiding and that I'm waiting for!
Nouf *LostinFantasy*
>
Books:
forbidden-love-angst
(50)
Loading...
