Katie's Reviews > Tropic of Cancer
Tropic of Cancer (Tropic, #1)
by
by
Considering I often found this virtually unreadable I'm amazed I got to the end, reading every word. First published in 1934 when undoubtedly it would have been shocking with its relentless lexicon of crude language including every racial slur out there and its insistence on referring to just about every woman as a c**t. It's a book in which men relentlessly revel in degrading women. Miller deploys an Emerson quote in his foreword, the gist of which is that new novels ought to take the form of autobiography and record experience truthfully. But if this is an unfiltered expose of the male psyche then the male psyche is one ugly place. I actually didn't buy the honesty ticket at all. A lot of the time it felt like Miller was posturing. He failed to get his early novels published and his bitterness and anger seems at virtually all times his source material. In fact I found it's only when he isn't feeding his bitterness and cynicism that his writing excels - there were some beautiful descriptions of Paris and I especially loved his appraisal of Matisse. The rest of the time it often felt like the work of a brilliant mind moored to the emotions of an adolescent boy.
I recently read one of Anais Nin's journals. She was a good friend of Miller's and I found lots of similarities between the two of them - first and foremost, the posturing, the desperation to be taken seriously as artists, as if, underneath, they were riddled with insecurities. Like Miller, Nin could be brilliant when she came out from behind her pose but ultimately I can't help thinking they were both essentially poseurs. But what do I know? This made it into the Guardian's top 100 novels. I can only imagine the majority of voters were men.
I recently read one of Anais Nin's journals. She was a good friend of Miller's and I found lots of similarities between the two of them - first and foremost, the posturing, the desperation to be taken seriously as artists, as if, underneath, they were riddled with insecurities. Like Miller, Nin could be brilliant when she came out from behind her pose but ultimately I can't help thinking they were both essentially poseurs. But what do I know? This made it into the Guardian's top 100 novels. I can only imagine the majority of voters were men.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Tropic of Cancer.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 24, 2020
–
Started Reading
March 24, 2020
– Shelved
March 26, 2020
–
Started Reading
March 26, 2020
–
12.58%
"What happens when you combine the intellect of a clever man with the emotions of an adolescent boy."
page
40
March 26, 2020
–
Finished Reading
April 9, 2020
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Teresa
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Apr 09, 2020 12:28PM
I read Miller when I was younger, college-age -- he was practically forced upon me (by a male) -- and I agree with your assessment, Katie. I haven't read him since and have no desire to.
reply
|
flag
Teresa wrote: "I read Miller when I was younger, college-age -- he was practically forced upon me (by a male) -- and I agree with your assessment, Katie. I haven't read him since and have no desire to."
I certainly won't be reading any more of his books. I'm bewildered this features in the Guardian's top 100 books.
I certainly won't be reading any more of his books. I'm bewildered this features in the Guardian's top 100 books.
A good, well argued review Katie ........ I can’t say I’m a Miller fan but I was intrigued by his close friendship with Lawrence Durrell, one of my most favourite writers. They were very different writers/ characters.
Richard wrote: "A good, well argued review Katie ........ I can’t say I’m a Miller fan but I was intrigued by his close friendship with Lawrence Durrell, one of my most favourite writers. They were very different ..."
Thanks Richard. I wouldn't have had those two down as friends - though Anais Bin said Miller was polite snd softly spoken so I guess a lot of the macho claptrap in this book was just posturing.
Thanks Richard. I wouldn't have had those two down as friends - though Anais Bin said Miller was polite snd softly spoken so I guess a lot of the macho claptrap in this book was just posturing.
Jonathan wrote: "Agreed..in its time it probably rated high, but not in 2020"
It made it into the Guardian's top 100 novels of all time, which was compiled recently!
It made it into the Guardian's top 100 novels of all time, which was compiled recently!
Elyse wrote: "Katie: I hope you are fanning well during these days which I don’t even know what adjective to use any longer.
I read this before I was probably mature enough to even understand it.
Thanks for ..."
Thanks Elyse. As a single mum it's all very stressful but I'm lucky to have a garden. I can't imagine how difficult it must be for people in apartment blocks or people in abusive relationships. Stay safe!
I read this before I was probably mature enough to even understand it.
Thanks for ..."
Thanks Elyse. As a single mum it's all very stressful but I'm lucky to have a garden. I can't imagine how difficult it must be for people in apartment blocks or people in abusive relationships. Stay safe!
I had similar feelings when I read a short story by Colette - there does seem to be a lot of posing - although Nin and Miller are a bit later.
Hemingway can be included here - in there struggle to be ex-mainstream, they come off as boors and bores.
Hemingway can be included here - in there struggle to be ex-mainstream, they come off as boors and bores.
Laura wrote: "I had similar feelings when I read a short story by Colette - there does seem to be a lot of posing - although Nin and Miller are a bit later.
Hemingway can be included here - in there struggle to..."
Miller with his macho claptrap makes Hemmingway look like a pussycat, Laura! Perhaps Paris at that time encouraged pretentious playacting - Miller certainly bought into the starving artist stereotype and this book almost might be like a comic send up of that role if Miller's prose wasn't so laden with dirge and pretension.
Hemingway can be included here - in there struggle to..."
Miller with his macho claptrap makes Hemmingway look like a pussycat, Laura! Perhaps Paris at that time encouraged pretentious playacting - Miller certainly bought into the starving artist stereotype and this book almost might be like a comic send up of that role if Miller's prose wasn't so laden with dirge and pretension.
You deserve a medal for making it to the very end! I read most of it, and then just gave up - couldn't do it. Most of it awful stuff. Great review, Katie. I agree, he was a posturing dick throughout.
Dreadful, I can't fathom how you made it to the end, but I did enjoy that last quip! I imagine you're right about the gender of the voters.
Robin wrote: "You deserve a medal for making it to the very end! I read most of it, and then just gave up - couldn't do it. Most of it awful stuff. Great review, Katie. I agree, he was a posturing dick throughout."
Thanks Robin. Posturing dickhead is perfect!
Thanks Robin. Posturing dickhead is perfect!