Melissa (Sailing the Greek Isles)'s Reviews > Every Summer After
Every Summer After
by
by
Outlier alert!
Let me start out by saying that there are many great reviews for this book, so if the synopsis appeals to you, go read those reviews and take mine with a grain of salt. One of the reasons this book didn't connect with me was that I just got finished reading another coming of age novel (Our Little World ) which I thought was much better and rang more authentic, so I couldn't help but compare.
This is a story told in two timelines: When Persephone is thirteen, her parents buy a lake house on Barry's Bay and she meets brothers Sam and Charlie, and they become friends. Sam and Percy develop a very close friendship over the years, which eventually turns to romance. Something happens that splinters the relationship and Sam and Percy haven't spoken for twelve years. Until Charlie calls with the news that their mother has died, and since she was like a second mom to Percy over the years, Percy returns to Barry's Bay for the funeral and to see Sam again.
The Canadian setting is fantastic and well described. I got a real sense of place with this book and would love to visit the places the author talks about.
What didn't really work for me:
So much of this book feels like a really bad YA novel. The dialogue is stilted and unrealistic, and I realize that teenagers are super focused on sex but some of the scenes involving those situations were just cringey to me. Instead of talking about their feelings, everyone is jumping into bed at the slightest provocation (even as adults).
I could never get a real sense of the time period. If the present day was really the present day, then Sam would have gone to college in 2010. Why was she calling him on the "dorm phone"--why didn't he have a cell phone? She mentions texting a little bit and email, but it felt off the with the way they were communicating with each other.
I called the "big twist" way before it was revealed, I know that others might like that the author waited until 80% into the book to reveal it, but it felt to me as if it was drawn out for longer than it needed to. Plus...anyone who has read my reviews knows how I feel about (view spoiler)
Overall, I don't feel like I read the same book as everyone else who adored it. I didn't connect with the characters and got alternately bored and annoyed with them throughout the book. You may like this if you're looking for a beach read, and I'm definitely the outlier because many of my trusted reviewer friends loved it.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
Let me start out by saying that there are many great reviews for this book, so if the synopsis appeals to you, go read those reviews and take mine with a grain of salt. One of the reasons this book didn't connect with me was that I just got finished reading another coming of age novel (Our Little World ) which I thought was much better and rang more authentic, so I couldn't help but compare.
This is a story told in two timelines: When Persephone is thirteen, her parents buy a lake house on Barry's Bay and she meets brothers Sam and Charlie, and they become friends. Sam and Percy develop a very close friendship over the years, which eventually turns to romance. Something happens that splinters the relationship and Sam and Percy haven't spoken for twelve years. Until Charlie calls with the news that their mother has died, and since she was like a second mom to Percy over the years, Percy returns to Barry's Bay for the funeral and to see Sam again.
The Canadian setting is fantastic and well described. I got a real sense of place with this book and would love to visit the places the author talks about.
What didn't really work for me:
So much of this book feels like a really bad YA novel. The dialogue is stilted and unrealistic, and I realize that teenagers are super focused on sex but some of the scenes involving those situations were just cringey to me. Instead of talking about their feelings, everyone is jumping into bed at the slightest provocation (even as adults).
I could never get a real sense of the time period. If the present day was really the present day, then Sam would have gone to college in 2010. Why was she calling him on the "dorm phone"--why didn't he have a cell phone? She mentions texting a little bit and email, but it felt off the with the way they were communicating with each other.
I called the "big twist" way before it was revealed, I know that others might like that the author waited until 80% into the book to reveal it, but it felt to me as if it was drawn out for longer than it needed to. Plus...anyone who has read my reviews knows how I feel about (view spoiler)
Overall, I don't feel like I read the same book as everyone else who adored it. I didn't connect with the characters and got alternately bored and annoyed with them throughout the book. You may like this if you're looking for a beach read, and I'm definitely the outlier because many of my trusted reviewer friends loved it.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Every Summer After.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 8, 2022
–
Started Reading
May 8, 2022
– Shelved
May 11, 2022
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 129 (129 new)
message 1:
by
Srivalli
(new)
-
added it
May 11, 2022 08:37AM
Fab review, Melissa. Sorry that this one didn't work for you. Hope your current read is better.
reply
|
flag
Srivalli wrote: "Fab review, Melissa. Sorry that this one didn't work for you. Hope your current read is better."
Thanks Srivalli, hoping to get a better one next!
Thanks Srivalli, hoping to get a better one next!
Michael wrote: "Fantastic review,Melissa! Sorry this was such a letdown. I’ll skip it."
Thanks Michael!
Thanks Michael!
Nilguen wrote: "Stellar review, Melissa! Sorry this was a disappointing read. Hope you’ll enjoy your next book 🧡!"
Thanks Nilguen!
Thanks Nilguen!
Bummer this didn’t work for you Melissa! Considering you liked Our Little World better, maybe this isn’t for me 😔 but we shall see! Great review!
Go for the outlier status! We have to call them as we see them, and I think there's not a book out there that works for everyone. I, for example, despise The Little Prince, even though everyone else I know thinks it's a work of genius. :-)
message 9:
by
Melissa (Sailing the Greek Isles)
(last edited May 11, 2022 09:18AM)
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Catherine wrote: "Bummer this didn’t work for you Melissa! Considering you liked Our Little World better, maybe this isn’t for me 😔 but we shall see! Great review!"
Thanks Catherine! I certainly wouldn't read them back to back if you're going to read both.
Thanks Catherine! I certainly wouldn't read them back to back if you're going to read both.
Sarah-Hope wrote: "Go for the outlier status! We have to call them as we see them, and I think there's not a book out there that works for everyone. I, for example, despise The Little Prince, even though everyone els..."
So true! I try to always be honest about what I think about a book.
So true! I try to always be honest about what I think about a book.
Fabulous review, Melissa! I've been seeing only praise for this book so your perspective helps tremendously. Hope your next book is going much better! 💕
Jayme wrote: "I rarely enjoy YA/Coming of age so thanks for this helpful review! 💕"
Yes, I think it is not a book for you.
Yes, I think it is not a book for you.
Nevin wrote: "Reading your review, I may skip this one. Thanks for an honest review Melissa 💝"
Thanks Nevin, just wasn't for me.
Thanks Nevin, just wasn't for me.
RoshReviews wrote: "Fabulous review, Melissa! I've been seeing only praise for this book so your perspective helps tremendously. Hope your next book is going much better! 💕"
Thanks Rosh!
Thanks Rosh!
great & honest review, Melissa! glad that the Canadian scenery was well-done, at least yay for that haha
C wrote: "great & honest review, Melissa! glad that the Canadian scenery was well-done, at least yay for that haha"
I always appreciate when a book has a good sense of place, that you can't just pick it up and move it anywhere (ahem, The Paris Apartment).
I always appreciate when a book has a good sense of place, that you can't just pick it up and move it anywhere (ahem, The Paris Apartment).
Ugh can't stand unnatural dialogues, thank you for the review! I'm usually in agreement with you so this is a skip for mee!💕
Kay wrote: "Ugh can't stand unnatural dialogues, thank you for the review! I'm usually in agreement with you so this is a skip for mee!💕"
Thanks Kay, it got really annoying after a while.
Thanks Kay, it got really annoying after a while.
I wish I'd seen your review before I started this one! I decided to DNF and your list of things that didn't work for you confirms I made the right call.
Katie wrote: "I wish I'd seen your review before I started this one! I decided to DNF and your list of things that didn't work for you confirms I made the right call."
Glad I could confirm!
Glad I could confirm!
I need to hurry up and read this one, I am so sorry it was a miss for you Melissa! I always feel disappointed when I guess twists! Thank you for your great and honest review! 🧡
darlington wrote: "Did one of the love interests cheat on the other? if yes this book is an instant skip for me🥲"
See my spoiler above, but the short answer is (view spoiler)
See my spoiler above, but the short answer is (view spoiler)
Ellie wrote: "I need to hurry up and read this one, I am so sorry it was a miss for you Melissa! I always feel disappointed when I guess twists! Thank you for your great and honest review! 🧡"
I'll be interested to see your thoughts, hope you enjoy it more than I did.
I'll be interested to see your thoughts, hope you enjoy it more than I did.
Maren’s Reads wrote: "Excellent review! So sorry this one missed the mark. Hope your next one is a winner!"
Thanks Maren!
Thanks Maren!
I'm with you on this review. I really wanted to love it because of the way it started out but too much of it was cringey and very predictable. Great review!
Vanathi wrote: "I'm with you on this review. I really wanted to love it because of the way it started out but too much of it was cringey and very predictable. Great review!"
Thanks Vanathi, I was hoping it would be better based on everyone's high praise, but it just didn't work for me.
Thanks Vanathi, I was hoping it would be better based on everyone's high praise, but it just didn't work for me.
I always appreciate an honest review, Melissa! I loved this book, but I can understand where it fell short for you. I guessed the twist very early on as well, but it didn't ruin my enjoyment somehow. 💗
Kat wrote: "I always appreciate an honest review, Melissa! I loved this book, but I can understand where it fell short for you. I guessed the twist very early on as well, but it didn't ruin my enjoyment someho..."
I know that I'm definitely an outlier on this one. It just did not connect with me.
I know that I'm definitely an outlier on this one. It just did not connect with me.
susana ♡ wrote: "Yikes. Officially removing it from my TBR. Truly feels like PWMOV 2.0. BYEEE!"
I never read that one and I'm glad I didn't now if it sounds like this one.
I never read that one and I'm glad I didn't now if it sounds like this one.
i also feel like charlie took advantage of her vulnerability she was already so emotional abt sam then he kept talking abt how sexy she was it was weird
Addison wrote: "i also feel like charlie took advantage of her vulnerability she was already so emotional abt sam then he kept talking abt how sexy she was it was weird"
I completely agree! I thought it was pretty slimy of him to do that.
I completely agree! I thought it was pretty slimy of him to do that.
Nope nope nope. I'm good on this one. Also I don't like when the time period is ambiguous as well... what is a dorm phone lmao. I went to uni in 2011 and there certainly was no dorm phone. Disgusting communal showers, yes. Dorm phone, no.