nikki ༗'s Reviews > Swift and Saddled

Swift and Saddled by Lyla Sage
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11573189
's review

liked it
bookshelves: contemp-romance, cowboys, fav-covers, romance, horse-girl, 2024-shelf, standalone-series

3.5

ngl, i was a bit disappointed w this one.

starting with the positives: wes is sweet as pie. he's definitely a cinnamon roll hero, and i liked the conversations had around depression (esp w relationships). the setting is cute and i love the entire ryder family dynamics. the spice was 🤌🏼 i would also jump a man's bones after seeing him rescue a precious baby cow 🥺

however.. i really just did not vibe w ada. i was expecting black cat energy, maybe sassy... but instead she was a "recovering 'i'm not like other girls girl'" which i'm sorry, but i couldn't stand being in that mindset. why give us this cool tattooed girly just for her to explain it away as her running away from "femininity". i sympathized w her for her shitty past relationship, but overall i just didn't really connect w her.

i also normally love a post-hook-up trope where one of them is trying to deny their feelings after, but not when that person is flat out avoiding, running away from, and giving the other person the cold shoulder. we lose valuable storytime where they could've been relationship building and it creates an unsatisfying instalove timeline. i remember hitting the 50% mark and feeling like ?? not much has happened?? also as a horse girl, i need more horse riding 😆

overall, it was ok. just not something for me, which the first one was moreso.

i liked the hints we got at cam and dusty (i sense much angst hehe) and of course, gus and teddy. i look forward to their books. hopefully with more horse riding lol
79 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Swift and Saddled.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 30, 2023 – Shelved
July 30, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
August 6, 2023 – Shelved as: contemp-romance
January 6, 2024 – Shelved as: cowboys
January 6, 2024 – Shelved as: fav-covers
January 6, 2024 – Shelved as: romance
March 12, 2024 – Shelved as: horse-girl
March 17, 2024 – Started Reading
March 18, 2024 –
44.0% "oooo cam & dusty 👀 feels angsty hehe"
March 20, 2024 – Shelved as: 2024-shelf
March 20, 2024 – Finished Reading
July 21, 2024 – Shelved as: standalone-series

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Sabrina (semi-hiatus) Oh noo. I’ve seen mixed reviews for both books and I just got both recently so I’m like 😅 I’m glad you were able to enjoy some of the book despite the disappointing. Hope your next reads are better 💜


nikki ༗ Sabrina wrote: "Oh noo. I’ve seen mixed reviews for both books and I just got both recently so I’m like 😅 I’m glad you were able to enjoy some of the book despite the disappointing. Hope your next reads are better 💜"

i liked the first book better bc i identified a lot w the fmc (anxiety / panic issues). i also felt like their past history had a better foundation to their relationship, whereas this book didn't have a lot to go off of. but i can also see why someone else would like this book, it just wasn't my fav! you might like it better ☺️


Sabrina (semi-hiatus) Sounds like id like the first one as well then given the relatability with anxiety. I’ll have to see but that’s good to know in terms of each couples relationship so I’ll keep that in mind. Yeah, some books are a hit and miss for us considering what we’re able to relate to lol but I’m glad you did with the first one and at least you were fond of the mmc here 😂 I swear some feel like the saving grace of a book sometimes!


elise ୨୧ Hmm I was wanting to read this. Sorry you didn’t like it 🫶🏻 glad the first was enjoyable at least!!


message 5: by Zeph (new)

Zeph rose sorry you were a bit disappointed by this !! hopefully the next one will redeem itself


DIVINITY🌙 I’m sorry this one disappointed you but glad it was still overall a good read 💗


Lilyya ♡ totally agree with you !! hope your next read is better tho<3


nikki ༗ elise ୨୧ wrote: "Hmm I was wanting to read this. Sorry you didn’t like it 🫶🏻 glad the first was enjoyable at least!!"

a lot of other ppl have enjoyed it but yeah it just wasn't for me. i'm hoping the next book will be more my speed tho, i'm very excited for gus/teddy!


nikki ༗ Zeph wrote: "sorry you were a bit disappointed by this !! hopefully the next one will redeem itself"

i think it will, i'm very excited for gus/teddy !


nikki ༗ DIVINITY🌙 wrote: "I’m sorry this one disappointed you but glad it was still overall a good read 💗"

for sure, it wasn't bad but just not my fav! next book i have a good feeling tho 💙


nikki ༗ Lilyya wrote: "totally agree with you !! hope your next read is better tho<3"

thanks bb, you as well 💖


back to top