Esta's Reviews > The Golden Enclaves

The Golden Enclaves by Naomi Novik
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
106941014
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: owned

I felt nervous going into The Golden Enclaves because I was delighted with A Deadly Education and The Last Graduate with their much more complex, unconventional and gritty perspectives on the magical school trope and I really needed the final instalment to deliver.

So did it?

The truth is that I read this during the holiday chaos, knee-deep in festive vibes and margaritas. Admittedly, my focus might've been more on spending cherished time with friends than the book and I probably wasn’t as immersed as I should have been. Maybe I should have read it when I could have given it the focus it deserves, because it’s not necessarily an easy read. It’s uncomfortable, dark and tightly woven.

Nonetheless, I still really liked it and it was a worthy conclusion. If I met El/Galadriel in real life, I feel like we would be friends, and for me, she’s relatable on so many levels. Again, I know she’s not for everyone, yet I have grown to love her stream-of-consciousness snarky dark-queen narration and the way she challenges traditional notions of heroism.

Like its predecessors, The Golden Enclaves still retains all the same funny, profound, clever and savage parallels to life and capitalism. I can’t really talk about much else without spoiling this book and the previous books, however, I will say, I was surprised, shocked, amused and delighted.

I guess there are some plot directions that are super extra and I caught myself thinking what the hell am I reading, but in the end, I found when I let it go and embraced it, the story came together really nicely for me and this overall was a satisfying conclusion to the series.

Also, I have decided I too would like a sassy mouse familiar named Precious who keeps my best interests at heart and occasionally bosses me around.


The Scholomance trilogy blog

1. A Deadly Education - 5⭐️
2. The Last Graduate - 5⭐️
3. The Golden Enclaves - 4⭐️

______

Please be gentle with my emotions Ms. Novik.
151 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Golden Enclaves.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 1, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
September 1, 2023 – Shelved
December 10, 2023 – Started Reading
December 25, 2023 – Finished Reading
January 16, 2024 – Shelved as: owned

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

Hope you enjoy this one.


Esta Niharika wrote: "Hope you enjoy this one."

Thanks so much Niharika! It's a page turner so far, after The Last Graduate ended on that massive cliffhanger. 🤯


Barbara (NOT RECEIVING NOTIFICATIONS!) I hope your emotions are holding Esta!


Mica Santos ⇢ Didn't know this series, adding the first one. Looking forward to read your thoughts, Esta! 💜


message 5: by Esta (last edited Dec 12, 2023 01:37PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Barbara**catching up! wrote: "I hope your emotions are holding Esta!"

20% in and they are holding Barbara... But no guarantees they'll hold the entire duration 😂😭😱


E.M. Williams My household loved that book. Older kid keeps demanding a Book 4, even though I don't think Novik has plans to continue the series.


Esta Mica Santos ⇢ wrote: "Didn't know this series, adding the first one. Looking forward to read your thoughts, Esta! 💜"

Yesss! I'm super intrigued to see what you think Mica. It's like Hogwarts, except Hogwarts is infested with deadly monsters trying to kill you day-in-day-out. You'll either love or loathe the snarky stream-of-consciousness narration style--Fingers crossed for the former. 🤍


message 8: by Esta (last edited Dec 12, 2023 02:16PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta E.M. wrote: "My household loved that book. Older kid keeps demanding a Book 4, even though I don't think Novik has plans to continue the series."

So happy you and your household loved this trilogy EM 🥰 I love your review on it, so well-articulated. I probably would feel the same as your older kid and want another book once I finish this series because I always dread finishing a series I'm so invested in 🥲


Mica Santos ⇢ Esta wrote: "Mica Santos ⇢ wrote: "Yesss! I'm super intrigued to see what you think Mica. It's like Hogwarts, exce..."

I'm definitely intrigued, Esta! Does it read like very YA?


message 10: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Mica Santos ⇢ wrote: "I'm definitely intrigued, Esta! Does it read like very YA?"

Hmm, I would say it leans more toward YA than adult, but I never found the voice "too" young. She's very sassy, cynical and sarcastic but also has a maturity beyond her years.


message 11: by Federico (new)

Federico DN Emotional roller coaster mode on.


message 12: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Federico wrote: "Emotional roller coaster mode on."

Screaming, laughing, but no ugly crying yet... stay tuned.


message 13: by Zainab (new)

Zainab Qadeer - HIATUS HAPPY READING MY GORGEOUS LOVE ❤️❤️❤️


message 14: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Zainab wrote: "HAPPY READING MY GORGEOUS LOVE ❤️❤️❤️"

Zainab my love you're back!!! 😍🥰 Hope uni treated you well and I hope you have a lovely break from it too, if you're getting one. 🤍🤍🤍


Coco (Semi-Hiatus) I might have give this series another try. Happy to see you're loving it!


message 16: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Coco wrote: "I might have give this series another try. Happy to see you're loving it!"

Thanks so much Coco, I have officially finished the series. 🥂 🥲🤍 Hmm, I would recommend to not force it, if you didn't enjoy it the first time, the stream-of-consciousness narration and cutaway exposition is pretty relentless through all 3 books and the third book I might have found the most dense. I can so relate why this style doesn't work for everyone! But somehow I still really liked it? I grew to love Galadriel/El a lot.


Coco (Semi-Hiatus) Congrats on finishing the series! & Thanks for letting me know! I guess I'll keep the first novel in my DNF pile. Much appreciated, Esta!


Margaret M - (too far behind to catch up although trying to spend more time on GR) Happy New Year Esta. Happy 2024 💞🎉🍾


message 19: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Margaret M - Away until Feb - wrote: "Happy New Year Esta. Happy 2024 💞🎉🍾"

Happy New Year Margaret and happy 2024 to you too! Wishing you a year of sublime reads 🤍🎊📚


message 20: by Debbie Y (new)

Debbie Y What a great review, Esta! I completely understand your point about not being fully focused on the book because of daily chaos and can very much relate to that. I’m glad you were still able to enjoy the book, though. 🖤🖤


message 21: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Debbie Y wrote: "What a great review, Esta! I completely understand your point about not being fully focused on the book because of daily chaos and can very much relate to that. I’m glad you were still able to enjo..."

Thanks so much Debbie! It does seem to get hectic around this same time each year. I'm definitely off to a sluggish start, and looking forward to being more immersed soon. Missing it a lot. I'm glad to see you also got some good reads in over the holidays too. <3


message 22: by Mimi (new)

Mimi As someone who had two imaginary mice as a child, I second wanting a sassy mouse familiar. Awesome review, Esta :)


message 23: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Mimi wrote: "As someone who had two imaginary mice as a child, I second wanting a sassy mouse familiar. Awesome review, Esta :)"

Haha I love that you had two imaginary mice as a child, Mimi, you get it! And thanks 😁


message 24: by Rowan (new)

Rowan An excellent review, Esta! So glad you have enjoyed this series! 🥰


message 25: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Rowan wrote: "An excellent review, Esta! So glad you have enjoyed this series! 🥰"

Much appreciated Rowan, thanks! 🥰 Loved discovering Novik in 2023 and cheers to discovering more gems in 2024 for us all 🎊


Charles I’m glad you enjoyed this final chapter in the story. In truth I was so happy to actually just see the book, I had thought it was a duology and you know about The Last Graduate. I also think I would like to meet El and Precious ( I wondered if that was Naomi’s Lord of the Rings reference). Terrific review! (less)


message 27: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Charles wrote: "I’m glad you enjoyed this final chapter in the story. In truth I was so happy to actually just see the book, I had thought it was a duology and you know about The Last Graduate. I also think I woul..."

I understand how happy you must have been, because thinking she ended The Last Graduate on that note sounds like unimaginable torture! And thanks so much Charles. El & Precious are the best!


message 28: by A (new)

A Mac I'm glad you ended up enjoying this one despite some initial reservations and despite questioning some of the things that happened (sounds like it got a little over the top in some places!). Great review, Esta!


message 29: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta A wrote: "I'm glad you ended up enjoying this one despite some initial reservations and despite questioning some of the things that happened (sounds like it got a little over the top in some places!). Great ..."

Thanks so much, A! Sometimes I overthink things and take myself out of the story, so perhaps it is my own fault 😆


Shelley's Book Nook Fabulous review as always, Esta. 🤗💕


message 31: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Shelley's Book Nook wrote: "Fabulous review as always, Esta. 🤗💕"

Much appreciated Shelley, thanks so much 🥰🤗


message 32: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Your review is perfect Esta glad you enjoyed.💖


message 33: by Esta (new) - rated it 4 stars

Esta Lisa wrote: "Your review is perfect Esta glad you enjoyed.💖"

Thank you so much Lisa! Much appreciated. 💓


back to top