Manny's Reviews > Morgon og kveld

Morgon og kveld by Jon Fosse
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1713956
After a while, you realise that all of Jon Fosse's books are really parts of the same book, or maybe different drafts of the same book. I don't mean that in a bad way: it's just how he is. Morgon og kveld seems to provide about a quarter of the material that later got turned into Septologien, and Melancholia I-II provided another quarter. Septologien improves on both of them, but the earlier books retain their own individual charm, and that is exactly as it should be. I'm sure there are hundreds of thousands of authors who wish their own œuvres made this much sense.

He has a beautiful, inimitable style. I see some people complaining that he has no sense of humour, and in fact that's not at all true: it's a subtle humour inherent in the rhythms and word-choices he uses and I can see several of his translators tearing their hair out over the technical challenges it sets them, which they admit are basically insurmountable. It's worth learning some Nynorsk just to be able to read him in the original; if you already know a Scandinavian language, you'll find it's surprisingly easy, and you won't regret the time you invested.
9 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Morgon og kveld.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 24, 2024 – Started Reading
December 24, 2024 – Shelved
December 26, 2024 –
page 35
25.74% "You know what it's like. You just got born, and then five pages later you find it's time to die."
December 29, 2024 – Shelved as: swedish-norwegian-and-danish
December 29, 2024 – Shelved as: transcendent-experiences
December 29, 2024 – Shelved as: translation-is-impossible
December 29, 2024 – Shelved as: why-not-call-it-poetry
December 29, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

notgettingenough I must make those translators happy and read some.


Manny This would be a good one to start with!


message 3: by Chadi (new)

Chadi Raheb I'd like to read Fosse but unlike Not I enjoy cheating on translators. So I'll have to wait until I can properly read in Norwegian... [sighs]


Peter Great review Manny. I also read that one in Nynorsk.


Manny Chadi wrote: "I'd like to read Fosse but unlike Not I enjoy cheating on translators. So I'll have to wait until I can properly read in Norwegian... [sighs]"

Hur går det med din svenska? Om jag inte redan rekommenderat Gunilla Bergström och Astrid Lindgren, så gör jag det nu :)


Manny Peter wrote: "Great review Manny. I also read that one in Nynorsk."

I remember you said it was good, that was one of the reasons I thought I would check it out.

He has such an interesting take on Christianity. You can't decide if it's very sophisticated or very naive. Which indeed is often a sign that someone is writing insightfully about religion.


message 7: by Chadi (new)

Chadi Raheb Manny wrote: "Chadi wrote: "I'd like to read Fosse but unlike Not I enjoy cheating on translators. So I'll have to wait until I can properly read in Norwegian... [sighs]"

Hur går det med din svenska? Om jag int..."


I svenska kan jag läser nu barnböcker.
Ja, jag läste Mumintrollets första vinter och också läste/lyssnade på annan på CLARA :) Nu läser jag God Natt Alfons Åberg; bra och lätt :)


Manny Jag äääälskar Godnatt Alfons Åberg, jag kan den nästan utantill. Sidan jag gillar mest:

Pappa kommer. Pappa tittar. Pappa hittar inget lejon.

Sen säger Pappa:

"Lejon finns inte ofta i garderober. Godnatt, och sov gott, för nu är jag ganska trött."


message 9: by Chadi (last edited Dec 30, 2024 11:46PM) (new)

Chadi Raheb Manny wrote: "Jag äääälskar Godnatt Alfons Åberg, jag kan den nästan utantill. Sidan jag gillar mest:

Pappa kommer. Pappa tittar. Pappa hittar inget lejon.

Sen säger Pappa:

"Lejon finns inte ofta i garderober..."


I'm only a few pages through and “Men Alfons vill inte sova gott." has been my favourite sentence so far 😁

Have you watched the animation(s)? I remember there was an Alfie Attkins (or something like that in English -why on earth would they "translate" the name?!) on TV when I was a kid. Was lovely!


back to top