Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 3K views

    Qutub Minar or Dhruv Satambh - Prof. M.S Bhatnagar

    Uploaded by

    Pramod
    The document discusses the true nature and purpose of the so-called Kutub Minar in Delhi, India. It summarizes a discussion between a history professor and his students with a tour guide at the site. Through their questioning, it is revealed that none of the common explanations for the tower's construction are satisfactory. The professor later realized from an aerial photograph that the tower's shape resembles a lotus flower, indicating it was actually an ancient Hindu astronomical observatory called the Dhruva Stambha.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Qutub Minar or Dhruv Satambh - Prof. M.S Bhatnagar

    Uploaded by

    Pramod
    3K views5 pages
    The document discusses the true nature and purpose of the so-called Kutub Minar in Delhi, India. It summarizes a discussion between a history professor and his students with a tour guide at the site. Through their questioning, it is revealed that none of the common explanations for the tower's construction are satisfactory. The professor later realized from an aerial photograph that the tower's shape resembles a lotus flower, indicating it was actually an ancient Hindu astronomical observatory called the Dhruva Stambha.

    Original Description:

    Qutub Minar

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document discusses the true nature and purpose of the so-called Kutub Minar in Delhi, India. It summarizes a discussion between a history professor and his students with a tour guide at the site. Through their questioning, it is revealed that none of the common explanations for the tower's construction are satisfactory. The professor later realized from an aerial photograph that the tower's shape resembles a lotus flower, indicating it was actually an ancient Hindu astronomical observatory called the Dhruva Stambha.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    3K views5 pages

    Qutub Minar or Dhruv Satambh - Prof. M.S Bhatnagar

    Uploaded by

    Pramod
    The document discusses the true nature and purpose of the so-called Kutub Minar in Delhi, India. It summarizes a discussion between a history professor and his students with a tour guide at the site. Through their questioning, it is revealed that none of the common explanations for the tower's construction are satisfactory. The professor later realized from an aerial photograph that the tower's shape resembles a lotus flower, indicating it was actually an ancient Hindu astronomical observatory called the Dhruva Stambha.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 5

    The so cal l ed Kut ub Mi nar - t r ut h r ev eal ed f r om sk y

    Peopl e usual l y see t hi s t ower f rom ground. Prof Bhat nagar hi red a hel i copt er
    and t ook a phot o f rom t he sky. That i s when he real i sed t hat i s a bl oomi ng l ot us
    f l ower.
    18-Oct-10 http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm
    http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm 1/5
    '-
    !::C!;:S S?El:.: SER!ES- DBRUVl ST1MBBA ?O:. rZR
    THE aUTB-MINAR
    1
    f=-fI '" ..
    , :( -Z14 7-J
    ' ,
    ,I -=
    , '
    -j
    ,
    -'---- -
    .;
    , , .'
    DHRUV A ST AMBHA
    at Mehrauli, (Delhi),
    Erroneously called "the QUTS MINAR.
    My dear reader,
    FROM
    PROF. M S.8HATNAGAR
    764. MIRZAJAN STREET,
    GHAZIABAD (INDIA)
    June 10, 1977.
    Thi s unique and unprecedenteddiagrarn (Fig 1) Is
    that of the so-called OUTS MI NAR. .It uncovers
    t he trut h and knocks out all confusing, contra-
    dict ory and fllbrkat ed explanations given by
    chroniclers of the Mosl em Kings of Defhi and
    some archaeologists about the history and
    purpose of this tofty stone-tower .
    A visit which fost ered present research
    In 1961 some college student s WEnt with
    me to t he Qutb Minar and engaged an official
    an M. A. wi t h Hi story, Questions and
    answers bet ween our party and t he Sarkari
    guide are given below in brief :-
    0 , WMI was the purpose of buildi ng thi s
    'MI NAR' ?
    A, Vi ctory Tower.
    Q. Whose victory over whom ?
    A . Md, Ghori 's vi ctory over Rai Pithau'ra
    (Prithvi Raj),
    Q . Where?
    A, At Talain near Panipal.
    Q. Why is the Victory Tower at Del hi?
    A. Do not know? One gentleman from
    t he visitors. a l ecturer in Hi story in the Univer.
    si tv of Delhi, t ook up the thread and answered:
    1 he Victory Tower wa!> commenced by Ghori
    because Del hi became his capita l.
    . Q . Objection , Si r, GhOli never had his
    capital at Delhi. HI!> capital was at Ghazni,
    What logic Is I here in buil oing ,the VicTory Tower
    in Del hi?
    A. Silence,
    Q Even if the Minar w a<; commenced by
    Ghar. its name ought to have been 'GHOR]
    MtNAR' and not 'OUTB MINAR', Why i s it
    ... ,, 11., .-1 'n ... h .,
    18-Oct-10 http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm
    http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm 2/5
    1
    .... .. _ ..... _ .. -.

    Fig. 1
    "DhrulfiJ SliJmbhiJ "
    IS ObsliJi ned frGm the sky
    A . It was probably OUl ubuddin Aibak,
    Slave of Ghori, who lai d the foundation of the
    mmar for his ma!>ter.
    0, If this is true, what made him choo!; e
    Del hi as t he si te for t he VIct ory Tower ?
    Dr. D. S TRIVLDA ca/ls "GHRUVA ST.t.MBHA" by the ,,'ame 'VI5HNUDHVAJA"
    - -
    ( 2 I
    DHRUVA ST.U!BE:1. LT UEHRA.ULI
    A. Delhi was the capi, .. 1 of Qutbuddin Aibak,
    O. 1\ is sai d that t he bUIlding of the Mi nar was commenced during
    t he l ile time of Ghari. When Ghori was alive, t he Quc!:> tion of his slave's
    ctlpi t al hei ng at Delhi does not arise. After t he death of Ghar, OutbuddlO
    was crowned as Sul tan at l ahore, He ru led from lahore and not Delhi
    and ultImately died al lahore. HIS ca pit <l l was at l ahore 7 Why did he
    build t he vICt Ory tower at Del hi ?
    A, S,lellce
    SOllle body from Ihe cluaience <I !> sclted that the Minar is not a vict or.,.
    t ower hut, il ' Mazina' lMue7ZIO's Tower in' att ached to
    ul.l slam Mosq',e' .
    o The wOld 'Ouwwfl j ul Islilm Mosql ,e' is unkn own 10 contempo-
    rary histor y 0 1 India, This wOld was coinet1 by SIr Saiyid Ahm'ld Khan in
    I he f irst par i of the ni neteenth ren tury. Do nOI be sUlpri sed t o know
    that the name 'OUTB MINAR', t oo, IS not known t o I ndian History. It is
    alSO:l recent fabrication, If. l or the of argument , we take it for
    "ranled that the minar is a muezzin's ' t ower, t he mosque assumes
    primary impolI<lnce and the l ower secondary, but unfol tun":l l e1y the
    mosque, as you see it (Fig . 4). IS in complete ruins. How do you account
    tor th e mosque nf pdmary importance t o he in rui ll s ancJ Ihe muezzi n's
    l ower, .. huildlnQ of no conse quence, t o be sla.nding in full majesty ?
    A, No AnswPT.
    Fig.2,
    ["lar ge menl cfth.
    danielll lOTL:S
    18-Oct-10 http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm
    http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm 3/5
    FlOWEIt in full
    bloom undt'. Fi g. 1.
    Br the 511mt IIl1thor : STONES SPEI-K'i No. r.
    "1)01"': Itlc REn I,On "'. "clhi. h"lon"! I" SII"'IJ \ltA"S 11 .... ':'
    ,
    ( 3 )
    STONES SPEAK SCrlc:: D:lRUVA FOLDER
    'Masjid & Mazina' with regard to the Dulb Minar IS a "COCK & BULL
    STORY", The socal1ed Outb Minar <lnd the ruined Jdnli close by
    ,
    cannot be asoibed to the same builder . The Dutb Minar is a much older
    t'Jwer
    QURANIC INSCRIPTIONS ON 1 HE MINAR.
    The Durani e inscript ions on t he Minar are for ced and lifeless lnser
    tions between forceful and beautiful fr iezebands of pure HINDU DESI GN,
    To consider the minar of Moslem origin fr om the Quranic i nscriprlons
    would be labelling a non-Muslim as a Mus.alman because ci rcumcision
    has been forced on him.
    THE DHRUVA STAMBHA
    The Minar is In fact the OHRUVA STAMBHA Or the central obse ..
    vatioo tower of an ancient Hindu Astronomical Observatory. Fig 1 is
    based on observat ion fr om a two seater aeroplane made to hover over I he
    top 01 the DHRUVA S r AMBHA. The tower looks like a 24-pet" lIed lotus
    fl ower (Fig: 2). each pelal leprt:ser.ling an 'HORA', ;,e., an hOUf on a
    24hour dial (Fig. 3) \'ellical f:',o:,-ction lines drawn hom I he mid pOlllls
    18-Oct-10 http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm
    http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm 4/5
    Fig. 3
    A3"TAONOMICAL DIAL
    Noti ce the black band vvith 24 segments.
    an ' HQRA' or an hour. The outer vvsll of
    similar i n outline to [he black band.
    ear:h representing
    the Outh Mm8r is
    81 Ille .same ,wlhor: ",." ".
    'r"f""' .. n f,.;'t if 7fT .. iT ",ptl 'If ......

    fIJI <;(1"' -'" i" i ? ..
    (4 I
    STONES SPEAK
    DHRUVA STAMER! FOLDER
    I
    0: stone-flutings on t he t op of each storey of the towar to the horizontal
    plane at its base create a lotus flower similar 10 what can be seen
    from the sky over the top of the tower- bottom fig. 1
    24-PetalJed architectural lotus fl ower is purely a Hindu concept. It
    cannot be attributed to any Moslem king from dr'l parts of Western Asia
    where lotuses do nOI grow.
    You are the proud possessor of the 'LOTUS' projection of the
    DHRUVA STAMBHA which is the. result of original thinki ng, perseverance
    and expense. Such a projection was neither drawn nor conceived by any
    architect at archaeologist in the past. let any body come forward and

    challenge the statement. Now, yO\! can reasonably silence all those who
    believe the DHRUVA STAMBHA to be a production of Md. Ghari or
    QUlbuddin Ai uak Sullans associ at ed wilh thi :. 'Minar' defiled its casi ng
    reversed stones bearing human 0'_ animal figures and inserted Arabic
    inscriptions. These Sullans can, of COurse, be praised for not making any
    claim that they built the No body has left any inscription
    as!>erting Ihat he started the Minar.
    Your intt:rest in my work, dear reader, is the rP.al force behind the
    researCh I am conducling. Thanking you for your good Will ,
    Sincere1r yours,
    -M. S. BHATNAGAR
    18-Oct-10 http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm
    http://satyashodh.com/kutub.htm 5/5
    Fig, 4
    "The crumbling Jami Maslid was named as QUWWAT-Ul'ISlA.M
    MOSQUE by Sir Saiyid Ahmad ' Khan. The celebrated IRON
    prlL4R can be seen In front of the Central arch. To CAll the
    towering DHRUVA S TAM6 H-". (Qutb MInar) a Mazina of this
    r u in .. d rnosque i s the height of absurdjty.
    A5H:lK. Pitl,,.rERS, 3\NolVYII;l M a l k ~ t , GHA2; I ABAO.
    He. 1/ .
    -

    You might also like