Michigan Voter Guide 2012: November 6, 2012 General Election Guide
Michigan Voter Guide 2012: November 6, 2012 General Election Guide
Michigan Voter Guide 2012: November 6, 2012 General Election Guide
www.MichiganfaMiLy.Org
(517) 374-1171
table of CoNteNts
United StateS PreSident........................ Michigan SUPreMe coUrt ..................... 3 7
dear Michigan Voter: This 2012 Voter guide is designed to help you make an informed decision when you vote on tuesday, november 6th. The guide is non-partisan and is not intended to endorse or oppose any candidate, either explicitly or implicitly. We have printed candidate responses exactly as we received them on signed questionnaires. Presidential information is taken from
United StateS Senator ........................ 10 State Board of edUcation .................. 12 UniverSity BoardS ................................ 14 endorSeMentS ...................................... 16 US hoUSe of rePreSentativeS .............. 17 Michigan hoUSe of rePreSentativeS .... 18 Minor PartieS ...................................... 19 Ballot ProPoSalS ................................. 22 voting SelectionS ................................ 25
the candidates websites and uS Senate information from the congressional research Service. unfortunately, some candidates did
not respond to our questionnaire. each candidate was contacted at least four times by phone, mail or email.
Please consider passing this Voter guide along to friends, family and others in your community to increase its usefulness. We also encourage you to visit our electronic Voter guide at www. michiganfamily.org, where you will also find information for Mi house candidates, including endorsements and questionnaire responses. Thanks for being an informed voter. See you at the polls on november 6th!
SaME-SEX MarriagE i believe that same-sex couples should be allowed to marryive always believed that gay and lesbian americans should be treated fairly and equally. i was reluctant to use the term marriage because of the very powerful traditions it evokes. and i thought civil union laws that conferred legal rights upon gay and lesbian couples were a solutionWhat ive come to realize is that for loving, same-sex couples, the denial of marriage equality means that, in their eyes and the eyes of their children, they are still considered less than full citizens. Source: www.barackobama.com/news/entry/marriage aBorTion/rEProDuCTiVE righTS The President has repeatedly stood behind a womans right to choose. he has: reversed the global gag rule, ending the ban on government aid for international groups that provide abortion information; Fought against republican attempts to defund Planned Parenthood, one of the largest providers of womens health services in the country. Source: www.barackobama.com/record/on/contraception 2nD aMEnDMEnT President obama advocates reasonable, common-sense laws that uphold liberty, ensure citizen safety, and are fully compatible with a robust Second amendment. i am very mindful of the fact that sportsmen in america may have gone hunting with their fathers, their grandfathers, their mothers, their grandmothers, and that this is part of a tradition and a way of life that has to be preserved. and theres nothing that i will do as president of the united States that will in any way encroach on the ability of sportsmen to continue that tradition. Source: www.barackobama.com/truth-team/entry/boltons-claims-on-the-un-and-gun-rights
SaME-SEX MarriagE Marriage is more than a personally rewarding social custom. it is also critical for the well-being of a civilization. That is why it is so important to preserve traditional marriage the joining together of one man and one woman. as president, Mitt will not only appoint an attorney general who will defend the defense of Marriage act a bipartisan law passed by congress and signed by President clinton but he will also champion a Federal Marriage amendment to the constitution defining marriage as between one man and one woman. Source: www.mittromney.com/issues/values aBorTion/rEProDuCTiVE righTS Mitt romney is pro-life. Mitt believes that life begins at conception and wishes that the laws of our nation reflected that view. But while the nation remains so divided, he believes that the right next step is for the Supreme court to overturn roe v. Wade a case of blatant judicial activism that took a decision that should be left to the people and placed it in the hands of unelected judges. With roe overturned, states will be empowered through the democratic process to determine their own abortion laws and not have them dictated by judicial mandate. Source: www.mittromney.com/issues/values 2nD aMEnDMEnT as the Supreme court recently reaffirmed, the Second amendment protects one of the american peoples most basic and fundamental individual rights: the right to Keep and Bear arms. The Second amendment is essential to the functioning of our free society. Mitt strongly supports the right of all law-abiding americans to exercise their constitutionally protected right to own firearms and to use them for lawful purposes, including hunting, recreational shooting, self-defense, and the protection of family and property. Source: www.mittromney.com/issues/gun-rights
non-Partisan
Nominated by the Republican Party Convention education: university of Michigan, Ba; detroit college of Law, Jd recent positions: circuit court Judge, oakland county, 1998 to present; Private civil Litigation Practice, 1981 1998 Marital Status/children: Married, 3 children religious faith/denomination: catholic age: 56 endorsements: Michigan right to Life Pac; Michigan citizens for traditional Values; Michigan chamber of commerce Pac community or civic involvement: crossroads for Youth; Baker college Paralegal Program advisory Board; adjunct Professor cooley Law School; Michigan Judges association; Michigan Judges association corrections committee; oakland county Bar association & Michigan Bar Foundation Member, indigent defense commission - appointed by gov. Snyder Website: www.colleenobrien.org 1. The purpose of the criminal justice system is to protect society, control crime, punish individuals who commit crimes and rehabilitate if appropriate. in recent years, the criminal justice system has been ineffective in stopping the revolving doors on our jails and prisons, especially with crimes related to drug/alcohol addiction and mental health issues. Because studies have shown a strong correlation between effective treatment of substance abuse and mental health problems and a reduction in crime, i believe the use problem-solving courts (drug courts, Mental health courts, domestic Violence courts) could assist in this area. 2. as judges, we must apply the laws and policies passed by the Legislature regardless of any personal policy preference we may have. hence, there is less judicial discretion than the general public might think in family law cases. however, i believe there are things we can do within that framework to protect the family unit. as alluded to above, domestic violence courts and drug/substance abuse courts try to identify and treat the cause of the criminal acts, and if successful help the family unit intact. This is the type of program that allows judges, within the law, to assist in a familys well-being.
non-Partisan
Colleen oBrien
Nominated by the Democratic Party Convention education: dartmouth college, aB; university of Michigan, Jd recent positions: Judge, 46th district court, 2002-present; attorney- Private Practice, 1987-2002; Federal Judicial Law clerk, 1985-1987 Marital Status/children: Single, no children religious faith/denomination: christian-united Methodist age: 55 endorsements: national organization for Women-Mi, Planned Parenthood, Fannie Lou hamer Pac community or civic involvement: Southern oakland county chapter of the naacP; oakland county chapter of the national congress of Black Women; Womens Fund of the Southfield community Foundation; Western international optimist club Website: www.JudgeSheliaJohnson.com 1. The primary purpose of the criminal justice system is to keep law and order, to deter and rehabilitate criminal behavior by convicting and punishing, under due process of law, those who are guilty of crimes while protecting the innocent and the community. The system is less effective considering the increasing number of violent and theft offenses, all of which are precipitated by substance abuse, joblessness, homelessness, mental illness. alternatives are: psychological counseling; and specialty courts, such as drug courts, veterans courts, domestic violence courts, with intensive probation and regular reporting to a judge, with the goals of rehabilitation, training, and sanctioning. 2. in family disputes, judges must remain neutral and primarily consider the best interests of the children involved and if property is in dispute, render a fair and equitable decision considering the circumstances of the parties. community well-being is a secondary concern, which may not always arise except where violence or sexually inappropriate behavior is perpetrated against a party or children. in those instances judges should weigh the interests of the parties, with consideration to community well-being in determining whether protective orders should be issued or whether custodial rights should be limited.
non-Partisan
all of the votes below are votes on the final version of a bill before it was sent to the President for his signature or veto. Therefore, while bills may undergo significant change throughout the legislative process, these are votes where both candidates voted on identical language. all of the titles, summaries and descriptions are taken directly from the congressional research Service at the Library of congress. if we added any language, we put the words in italics. if we deleted words, we used ellipses () to indicate that we omitted language. We selected votes from the final eight years that representative hoekstra and Senator Stabenow served simultaneously in congress. h.r. 1 - Title as enacted: american recovery and reinvestment act of 2009; Popular Title: Economic stimulus bill. Stabenow YeS hoekstra no h.r. 2 Title as enacted: Childrens health insurance Program reauthorization act 2009 Stabenow YeS hoekstra no h.r. 2965 - Dont ask, Dont Tell repeal act of 2010 - Provides for repeal of the current department of defense (dod) policy concerning homosexuality in the armed Forces, to be effective 60 days after the Secretary of defense has received dods comprehensive review on the implementation of such repeal Stabenow YeS hoekstra no h.r. 3435 - (cash for clunkers Program) Makes emergency supplemental appropriations of $2 billion for FY2009 and FY2010 to the national highway traffic Safety administration (nhtSa) of the department of transportation (dot) for the consumer assistance to recycle and Save Program. Stabenow YeS hoekstra YeS
Todd Courser
Michelle Fecteau
W hat iS the MoSt PreSSing ProBleM facing oUr edUcation SySteM today and What WoUld yoU do aBoUt thiS ProBleM?
1. expand School choice options, including more charter schools. 2. Place the Parents in control, letting them decide which type of learning environment is best for their child. 3. advocate for education reform, providing our children with an education that utilizes funding to its full potential. 4. Work to end common core (the nationally mandated curriculum), letting teachers do their jobs without needless government red-tape. 5. encourage american exceptionalism, helping students to understand the history and greatness of our nation. 6. i will advocate for families, students and educators to bring quality education back to Michigan.
Party affiliation: democrat education: Michigan State university, BS relations/Political Science; Michigan State university, Ma Labor & industrial relations recent Positions: executive director, Wayne State university chapter american association of university Professors, 2007 present; Labor Program Specialist Wayne State university, 1996 -2007 Marital Status/children: Married, 7 children religious Faith: catholic age: 51 community and civic involvement: Foster Parent 1992 2002; Foster parent of the Year 1997; Past Board Member of Wayne county Society of autistic citizens; Past Board Member of insights for open adoption; Founded neighborhood support group for parents of special needs children; Block captain north rosedale Park community; Volunteer, alternatives for girls endorsements: american Federation of teachers; Michigan education association
W hat iS the MoSt PreSSing ProBleM facing oUr edUcation SySteM today and What WoUld yoU do aBoUt thiS ProBleM?
The challenge of providing all students the educational experience needed to reach their full potential given high and increasing levels of poverty and financial contraints. i would work to increase awareness of povertys clear and consistent effect on childrens educational achievement and the negative longterm consequences it can have on the future of all Michiganders. i would develop a diverse network of organizations concerned about these and other issues and provide them with information on developing policy and legislative initiatives to enable them to have an effective voice in the process. i would also seek to obtain information from them regarding the impact a policy might have, or is actually having, especially at the school or local level. i would work to ensure that groups representing families, educators, and children, including those with special needs, are heard and i would assist these groups in organizing effectively.
lupe ramos-Montigy
Party affiliation: democrat education: Ba, elementary education/Spanish, Pan american university; Ma, grand Valley State university recent Positions: Public school teacher, principal, bilingual director; community/Political involvement. Marital Status/children: divorced, 2 children religious Faith: n/a age: 68 community and civic involvement: Student advancement Foundation Board; Friends of the court advisory Board; committee to honor cesar chavez; democratic Party, local, state and national involvement endorsements: Michigan education association; uS Senator carl Levin; george heartwell, Mayor of grand rapids
W hat iS the MoSt PreSSing ProBleM facing oUr edUcation SySteM today and What WoUld yoU do aBoUt thiS ProBleM?
i believe the most pressing problem facing our education system today is the lack of trust and communication with those involved in providing the best schools for all our students. The educational army who are the educators in the school buildings, i believe, should not be the first to be blamed for all the impediments associated with student-learning. Students, families, educators, legislators, and communities must work in lock-step to provide the leadership necessary to close the achievement gap and prepare the future world leaders of tomorrow. education is the foundation of our democracy and the path to a good life. it will be my responsibility as a member of the State Board of education to bring people together to deter the erosion of the foundation of our democracy, PuBLic education.
uNiveRsity boaRds
Michigan State university
Joel Ferguson (incumbent)
(Select Two Candidates)
Party affiliation: democrat education: Michigan Sate university, Ba recent Positions: 18 years(3 terms) on the Michigan State university Board of trustees Marital Status/ children: Married, 5 children religious Faith: n/a age: 40 community and civic involvement: n/a endorsements: Building trades; Mea; Michigan Farm Bureau
Party affiliation: republican education: Michigan State university, BS recent Positions: Michigan State university Board of trustees, 2005-2012; Michigan State university Foundation Board, 2007-2012; central Michigan university Board of trustees, 1998-2004 Marital Status/children: Married, 3 children religious Faith: christian age: 57 community and civic involvement: capitol area united Way board member; Lansing christian School Foundation; executive committee endorsements: Michigan Farm Bureau; right to Life of Michigan; citizens for traditional Values
Brian Mosallam Party affiliation: democrat candidate chose not to respond. Jeff Sakwa
Party affiliation: republican education: Michigan State university, Ba recent Positions: President, noble realty inc. for 26 years Marital Status/children: Married, 2 children religious Faith: Jewish age: 52 community and civic involvement: President, defeat the Label (anti Bullying Movement); Board Member anti defamation League (oldest civil rights movement); West Bloomfield education Foundation (Money raising arm for West Bloomfield Schools) endorsements: attorney general Bill Schuette; Former Secretary of State terri Land; Former West Bloomfield Schools Superintendant Joanne andrees
Dan horning Party affiliation: republican education: university of Michigan, BgS recent Positions: regent emeritus, The university of Michigan Marital Status/children: 2 children religious Faith: Presbyterian age: 53 community and civic involvement: n/a endorsements: right to Life robert Steele Party affiliation: republican
education: university of Michigan, aB, Md recent Positions: 20 years university of Michigan Medical School clinical assistant professor; 25 years cardiologist, private practice Personal: Married, 4 children religious Faith/denomination: chrisitan age: 54 endorsements: dr. Larry arn, President of hillsdale college; Michigan right to Life; uS rep. Mike rogers community and civic involvement: 2010 candidate for uS congress, 15th district; 25 year member heritage Foundation, founding member Se Michigan committee for heritage; Former board/treasurer club Wolverine swimming.
uNiveRsity boaRds
Wayne State university
(Select Two Candidates)
education: university of Michigan, BS; Wayne State university, Md recent Positions: chief of plastic surgery, detroit Medical center and Wayne State university; chief of plastic surgery, St. Johns hospital, detroit Marital Status/ children: Married, 6 children religious Faith: catholic age: 58 community and civic involvement: Founder and president of operation Kindness, providing surgery in third world areas for children with congenital and traumatic deformities endorsements: n/a
Satish Jasti
Party affiliation: republican education: Wayne State university, BS; university of chicago, MBa recent Positions: Vice President, Bank of ann arbor, Plymouth, Mi; Founder, President and ceo, Lotus Bank Marital Status/children: Married, 2 children religious Faith: hindu age: 53 community and civic involvement: american red cross of Se Michigan, Former Board Member and audit committee chair; novi chamber of commerce, Former chamber of the Board; detroit economic club, Sustaining Member endorsements: n/a Party affiliation: democrat education: grand Valley State university, BS; detroit college of Law, Jd recent Positions: oBrien Law office, PLLc, 1992 to Present; northville Public School district curriculum council, 2010 to Present Marital Status/ children: Married, 3 children religious Faith: catholic age: 45 community and civic involvement: Bridgepointe, LLc Volunteer; detroit hispanic development corporation Board Member; northville Public School district curriculum council - council Member endorsements: Michigan education association; american Federation of teachers; uaW
eNdoRsemeNts
The following organizations endorse candidates seeking public office. all endorsements were provided by the endorsing organization and should not be considered as an endorsement by Michigan Family Forum. The information is public information available on the internet. For more information about endorsement selections, we have provided you with the phone numbers and websites of the endorsing entities. The description of each organization was taken directly from the website of the endorsing organization. in some cases, an organization may endorse more than one candidate in each district. SC - Sierra Club: our mission is to: (1) explore, enjoy, and protect the wild places of resources; (2) Practice and promote the responsible use of the earths ecosystems and resources; (3) educate and enlist humanity to protect and restore the quality of the natural and human environment; and (4) use all lawful means to carry out these objectives. 517-484-2372 www.michigan.sierraclub.org PP - Planned Parenthood: Planned Parenthood advocates of Michigan works to protect and enhance the ability of its affiliates to deliver reproductive health care services by affecting policy makers through electoral and non-electoral activities. The Planned Parenthood Pac focuses on endorsing prochoice political candidates and electoral work. 517-482-1080 www.miplannedparenthood.org FB - Farm Bureau: Farm Bureau worksto support action not just on farm issues, but on many of the same things youre concerned about: protection of private property rights and the quality of the rural environment, tax policies and economic growth, and the quality and safety of our food supply. 517-323-7000 www.michfb.com rTl -right To life: right to Life of Michigan is a nonpartisan, nonsectarian, nonprofit organization of diverse and caring people united to protect the precious gift of human life from fertilization to natural death. 616-532-2300 www.rtl.org CC - Chamber of Commerce: The Michigan chambers mission is to promote conditions favorable to job creation and business growth in Michigan. 517-371-2100 www.michamber.com aFl-Cio: The aFL-cio represents millions of working people who belong to unions dedicated to improving the lives of working families, bringing fairness and dignity to the workplace and securing social equity in the nation. 517-487-5966 www.miaflcio.org EQM - Equality Michigan Pride PaC: equality Michigan Pride Pac is Michigans only statewide political action committee which focuses on the needs of Michigans gay and transgender residents, as well as the concerns of allied progressive groups. www.eqmipridepac.com CTV - Citizens for Traditional Values: ctV seeks to broaden public understanding of the importance of personal freedom and traditional family values. 517-321-1390 www.ctvmichigan.org
anSWer key
d in
ex
St
Bl
BU
r e
PU
r ee
fU
ed
n c
fo
ea
io
io n
-o
g e
Se
PS
g et
ia
eM
Pt
Pt
Pt
ic
Se
Se
r d er
ie
lt
e-
e-
o h
it
it
la
Sc
ea
Bo
Ba
PU
Pr
Sa
Sa
li
li
Bl
ic
SF So So F
So u
SF So u SF
SF o
SF u
SF SF SF SF So F
SC
io
FB
rtL cc
ctV
anSWer key
io
io
eP
io
Pa
ed
Pe
eP
a c
en
er
io
en
io
Se
in
r c
in
ed
Pt
e-
it
in
iv o
ef
Sa
Se
Pt
io
So So o o
u o
So o
F o
F F
o u
o F
SC
r en
eS
PP
FB rtL cc
aFL
ctV
miNoR PaRties
PreSident
grn uSt nLP Stein, Jill 17 trotting horse Ln Lexington, Ma 02421 goode, Jr., Virgil h. 90 e church St rocky Mount, Va 24151 anderson, ross c. 418 douglas St Salt Lake city, ut 84102 www.jillstein.org www.goodeforpresident2012.com www.voterocky.org
Vice PreSident
uSt clymer, James n. 301 Letort rd Millersville, Pa 17551 grn honkala, cheri 1928 Mutter St Philadelphia, Pa 19122 nLP rodriguez, Luis 716 orange grove ave San Fernando, ca 91340 Boman, Scotty 4877 Balfour rd detroit, Mi 48224 Matkin, richard a. 30 W harry ave hazel Park, Mi 48030 Mikkelson, harley 3122 W caro rd caro, Mi 48723 Litle, John d. 2763 arrowwood trl ann arbor, Mi 48105
ballot PRoPosals
ProPoSal 12-1
a reFerenduM on PuBLic act 4 oF 2011 the eMergencY Manager LaW Public act 4 of 2011 would: establish criteria to assess the financial condition of local government units, including school districts. authorize governor to appoint an emergency manager (eM) upon state finding of a financial emergency, and allow the eM to act in place of local government officials. require eM to develop financial and operating plans, which may include modification or termination of contracts, reorganization of government, and determination of expenditures, services, and use of assets until the emergency is resolved. alternatively, authorize state-appointed review team to enter into a local government approved consent decree.
ProPoSal 12-2
a ProPoSaL to aMend the State conStitution regarding coLLectiVe Bargaining This proposal would: grant public and private employees the constitutional right to organize and bargain collectively through labor unions. invalidate existing or future state or local laws that limit the ability to join unions and bargain collectively, and to negotiate and enforce collective bargaining agreements, including employees financial support of their labor unions. Laws may be enacted to prohibit public employees from striking. override state laws that regulate hours and conditions of employment to the extent that those laws conflict with collective bargaining agreements. define employer as a person or entity employing one or more employees.
ProPoSal 12-4
a ProPoSaL to aMend the State conStitution to eStaBLiSh the Michigan QuaLitY hoMe care counciL and ProVide coLLectiVe Bargaining For in-hoMe care WorKerS This proposal would: allow in-home care workers to bargain collectively with the Michigan Quality home care council (MQhcc). continue the current exclusive representative of in-home care workers until modified in accordance with labor laws. require MQhcc to provide training for in-home care workers, create a registry of workers who pass background checks, and provide financial services to patients to manage the cost of in-home care. Preserve patients rights to hire in-home care workers who are not referred from the MQhcc registry who are bargaining unit members. authorize the MQhcc to set minimum compensation standards and terms and conditions of employment.
ProPoSal 12-6
a ProPoSaL to aMend the State conStitution regarding conStruction oF internationaL BridgeS and tunneLS This proposal would: require the approval of a majority of voters at a statewide election and in each municipality where new international bridges or tunnels for motor vehicles are to be located before the State of Michigan may expend state funds or resources for acquiring land, designing, soliciting bids for, constructing, financing, or promoting new international bridges or tunnels. create a definition of new international bridges or tunnels for motor vehicles that means, any bridge or tunnel which is not open to the public and serving traffic as of January 1, 2012.
votiNg seleCtioNs
For your convenience, you may wish to write the names of the candidates you plan to vote for in the blanks below.
President uS Senate uS house Mi house of representatives Mi Supreme Court (select two names) Mi Supreme Court Partial Term (select one name) State Board of Education (select two names) university Boards (select two names for each university)