Kabarole District in Uganda Tourism Development Business Plan
Kabarole District in Uganda Tourism Development Business Plan
Kabarole District in Uganda Tourism Development Business Plan
Uganda
PREPARED FOR
FORWARD
Kabarole District plays a distinctive role in the geography and history of Uganda. Located at the foot of the Rwenzori Mountains, and at the crossroads of routes leading from the Kampala to the east and the vastness of Central Africa to the west, and north and south along the Great Rift Valley, Kabarole has seen numerous movements of people over long periods of time. It was the vanguard of, what was actually a brief period of colonisation, and now in the context of a modern state there is a renewal in cultural pride and sense of identity that predates that period. With improved communications, better security and increasing optimism, Kabarole is prepared once more to see movements of people this time domestic and international visitors, coming to sample what Kabarole has to offer. With forests, mountains, savannahs and lakes, Kabarole can showcase some unique wilderness areas, and wildlife experiences, as well as the sparkling gems of our unique and cultural significant Crater Lakes. Our livestock are impressive and our agriculture delivers wide variety of produce, so visitors have much to sample. With the rehabilitation of our estates, not least of these is a satisfying cup of tea! Although sometimes difficult to see and experience, our culture runs deep and we can offer a truly African cultural experience that ranges from the rural to the royal! This District Tourism Development Plan, is an important step towards realising our goal of Kabarole District as a quality tourist destination. There is no doubt there are significant challenges to face and many of our people face harsh economic realities, we need to maintain our sense of culture and we need to improve our level of environmental stewardship. In all these we intend for tourism and this plan will play a meaningful part. We look forwarding to collaborating and supporting our local communities that are energetically developing community tourism products, our local entrepreneurs that are building up an impressive array of accommodation and tours, our local basket makers and crafts people that produce high quality work, our neighbouring districts that share part of the tourism circuits, as well as the tour companies from Kampala, Nairobi and beyond facilitating the arrival of guests. We will be making all efforts to make this plan work and Kabarole an enjoyable and rewarding place to visit.
What is life? It is the flash of a firefly in the night. It is the breath of a buffalo. It is the little shadow which runs across the grass and loses itself in the Sunset.
Crowfoot , TOUCH THE EARTH
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Consultancy Team would like to thank all the people who were involved in the development of this Sustainable Tourism Development Plan for Kabarole District, especially the community members who endured long discussions with complete openness and objectiveness. The Team would also like to thank the staff of non-governmental conservation organisations, academic and cultural institutions, tour and hotel operators who supplied information and/or participated in the tourism workshop and design charettes, without whose input and enthusiasm, this plan would not have been complete. The Team deeply appreciates the support and guidance of the guides, rangers and chimpanzee trackers during the many excursions in the field. It is with deep respect that we acknowledge their information that was provided under sometimes difficult situations. The following organizations were also instrumental in the production of this Sustainable Tourism Development Plan: Ministry of Trade, Tourism and Industry World Bank African Wildlife Foundation
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 2 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS ..................................................................................................5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.................................................................................................7 METHODOLOGY & PROCESS......................................................................................9 EXISTING CONDITIONS ............................................................................................11 3.1 Location ..............................................................................................................................11 3.2 Demographics and Livelihoods ..........................................................................................11 3.3 Land Use .............................................................................................................................18 3.4 Infrastructure.......................................................................................................................19 3.5 Policy Context.....................................................................................................................23 3.6 Planning Context.................................................................................................................28 3.7 Tourism Market Demands and Accommodation Facilities ................................................30 4 TOURISM DEVELOPMENT PLAN ...............................................................................36 4.1 Physical Analysis ................................................................................................................36 4.2 Opportunities and Constraints Analysis..............................................................................38 4.3 Overall Tourism Development Plan ...................................................................................41 5 ZONING PLAN ...........................................................................................................47 5.1 Zoning ................................................................................................................................47 6 TOURISM CIRCUIT PLAN ..........................................................................................50 6.1 District Tourism within the Regional Context... 59 7 FIRST PHASE TOURISM DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS ..................................................61 7.1 Crater Lakes Interpretation Center......................................................................................61 7.2 Karambi Tombs Rehabilitation...........................................................................................63 7.3 Community Issues...............................................................................................................64 8 PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT ACTIONS..............................................................73 8.1 Code of Conduct .................................................................................................................73 8.2 Actions ................................................................................................................................74 8.3 National Level Authorities..................................................................................................74 8.4 District Level Authorities....................................................................................................75 8.5 Uganda Wildlife Authority .................................................................................................77 8.6 Private Sector Tourist Industry ...........................................................................................77 8.6 Community Based Tourism Sector.....78 8.8 Non Government Sector .....................................................................................................79 8.9 Community Based Tourism Enterprises .............................................................................82 9 RECOMMENDATIONS ...............................................................................................84 10 REFERENCES ...............................................................................................................86 APPENDICES....90
Figures Figure 1: Map of Kabarole District....................................................................................................11 Tables Table 1: Table 2: Table 3: Table 4: Table 5: National Tourism Policy Strategies ...................................................................................25 Visitor statistics for National Parks for RMNP and KFNP (2000-2004) ..........................30 Existing Accommodation in Kabarole District..................................................................31 Physical attractions in Kabarole District ...........................................................................32 Existing reported tourism products and services Kabarole District* ................................34
5
Table 6: English renderings of Kabarole Crater Lakes....................................................................35 Table 7: Constraints to tourism in Kabarole and actions to address them......................................38 Table 8: Potential negative impacts of tourism................................................................................40 Table 9: Options for the poor to becomeinvolved in tourism ..........................................................69 Table 10: Options for community involvement in tourism................................................................82 Boxes Box 1. Education Data .....................................................................................................................22 Box 2: Reported existing tourism activities in Kabarole District .....................................................31 Box 3: Building and Development Trends and Aspirations ............................................................65 Box 4. Pigments and Pigsbooze - Basketry in Kabarole District. ....................................................67 Box 5: Tooro Kingdoms Social Programmes ..................................................................................72 Box 6: Sources of best practice information on tourism development ............................................81 Box 7: Steps for the establishment of community based tourism...................................................82 List of Acronyms
ARO BCE CE CPI CVK DRC EDSA EIA IGCP KFNP LC 1- 5 MoLG MTTI NGO PA PAMSU PEAP QENP RMNP TPC TSWR UCOTA UNESCO UWA UWEC WCU WTO WWF African Regional Office Before Common Era (BC) Common Era (AD) Community Protected Area Institute Crater Valley Beach Resort Democratic Republic of Congo Edward Stone Associates Environmental Impact Assessment International Gorilla Conservation Programme Kibale Forest National Park Local Councils 1- 5 Ministry of Local Government Ministry of Tourism Trade and Industry Non Government Organisation Protected Area Protected Area Management and Sustainable Use Poverty Eradication Action Plan Queen Elizabeth National Park Rwenzori Mountains National Park Technical Planning Committee Toro-Semliki Wildlife Reserve Uganda Community Tourism Association United Nations Education and Science Organisation Uganda Wildlife Authority Uganda Wildlife Education Centre (Entebbe Zoo) Wildlife Clubs of Uganda World Tourism Organisation World Wide Fund for Nature
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
One of the key recommendations in the new national Tourism Policy for Uganda is the decentralization of tourism function, which calls for a bottom-up planning approach in tourism development. The Ministry of Tourism, Trade and Industry (MTTI) through the PAMSU1 Project is supporting priority districts in preparing District Tourism Development Plans to ensure that tourism development is integrated into the overall district development plans The International Gorilla Conservation Programme (IGCP) (a coalition of the African Wildlife Foundation, Fauna and Flora International and WWF) is supporting the development of these District Tourism Development Plans. The IGCP has been involved in the development of gorilla tourism in South West Uganda since its inception and contributed to both national and regional tourism processes. It is now playing a role in producing the Western Ugandan plans. In January 2004, EDSA was commissioned by IGCP to develop District Tourism Development Plans for the Kisoro and Kanungu Districts in South West Uganda. These two districts were selected as pilot sites for the development of tourism plans, due to the potential in Kisoro and Kanungu Districts to develop flagship sustainable destinations that would benefit the stakeholders without compromising the environment. In June of 2005, EDSA and IGCP were again commissioned to prepare District Tourism Development Plans for Kasese and Kabarole Districts in Western Uganda. Sustainable tourism can heighten local awareness of the importance of conservation, provide new incentives for governments and the local communities to preserve protected areas and generate revenue for local and regional economies.
This report outlines Tourism Development for Kabarole District. In line with the requirement of the national Tourism Policy for Uganda, this plan aims to provide the
The development objective of the Protected Area Management for Sustainable Use Project (PAMSU) is the sustainable and cost-effective management of Ugandas wildlife and cultural resources. Through PAMSU, sustainability is promoted through a combination of delivering funds to improve Ugandas ability to attract tourists to its wildlife and cultural heritage while encouraging cost-effective management strategies to reduce overall operating costs of the institutions managing these resources. PAMSU is designed to encourage continued development of tourism opportunities, policy and infrastructure as a necessary condition for growth with the return of tourism (ARO, 2002). Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 7
1
framework for tourism development that allows for controlled development, which does not generate any serious environmental or socio-cultural problems and which will be used as a means for environmental and cultural conservation. This plan also ensures that tourism development is tailored to the specific characteristics and needs of each area of the District with maximum participation of community residents in the development process and tourism benefits occurring, to the greatest extent possible, to the local communities. Tourism development in Kabarole District is comparatively well developed, but with significant potential and improvements possible. The opportunities offered by recent infrastructure improvements, especially the improved road connection to Kampala, will bring increased market access. The district has some key tourist attractions, both natural and cultural and offers some of the best Chimpanzee tracking in the country. The private sector is enthusiastic, organised and has developed accommodations at all levels. The District level authorities have not thus far really engaged in tourism, and through this plan will proactively improve their active engagement in the industry in support of the private sector, community and NGO efforts. The cultural leadership, especially the Kingdom of Tooro, has a key role to play, and will also step up their efforts to develop tourism. Community groups are very active in cultural and development efforts, and there are developing academic institutions that will bring sound research analysis, training and facilities to the sustainable tourism development effort. Fort Portal is a key tourism hub on routes to Murchison Falls in the North, Queen Elizabeth, Rwenzori and the Gorilla Forests to the south, with up graded links to Kampala and with Kibale Forest at its doorstep. The highland climate tea estates and the unique and very attractive crater lakes, means there is a very high potential for tourism in Kabarole. This plan identifies numerous tourism circuits many of which will benefit local communities, and two first phase projects the Crater Lake Interpretive Center and the Karambi Tombs Rehabilitation. The plan makes a number of recommendations including the protection of the threatened traditional and cultural landscapes, especially biodiverse grazing and grasslands around the crater lakes. It also identifies the need for more social and ecological research into the crater lakes and increased support for community tourism efforts. To achieve this there will need to be a significant improvement in the tourism development capacity within the District Government, which currently has no staff or budget for tourism development.
METHODOLOGY
Five approaches were used to prepare this document: 1. Research into the history, culture, flora and fauna of Kabarole District. Documentation that was reviewed included policies and plans produced by government, consultants, and NGOs. A full list of references cited can be found in Section 10. 2. Interviews with a representative section of the various stakeholders including private sector tour operators and lodge owners. 3. Stakeholder meetings and open discussion with a wide cross-section of residents. The project began with a kick-off meeting with MTTI, consultants and representatives of the Association of Tour Operators. 4. On-site visits to numerous existing facilities (hotels, restaurants, houses, government offices, natural areas etc). Over the course of two days, District Planners and the consultancy team visited a range of existing and potential tourism attractions across Kabarole. These included Kibale Forest National Park, Tea Estates, Crater Lakes, Rwagimba Hotsprings and Ft. Portal. 5. Participatory Planning Workshop and Design Charettes that were held in Kabarole and attended by a wide cross-section of the residents of Kabarole District. The District Council had compiled lists of relevant stakeholders from local government, the private sector, NGOs, marginalized groups, and religious organisations who were then invited to participate in the participatory planning workshop and design charettes2. The composition of the 32 strong participants included the range of key stakehoders identified in the tourism policy. A full list of workshop participants can be found in Appendix 2.
PROCESS
The process of developing this Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan included the following stages: 1. Compilation and analysis of background documentation 2. Stakeholder meeting in Kampala
2
The Planning and Design process was initiated via the use of a planning workshop and design charette. The workshop and design charettes accelerated the planning process by creating an interactive environment with all major stakeholders working together without the normal interruptions that delay communications. It also provided an opportunity to achieve consensus on the most worthy approach to the tourism development plan. This planning process assists in reviewing program issues, environmental constraints and provide insight into the physical and market potential of the various products. The participatory workshop oriented design process is a most effective and efficient means of providing stakeholders with a specific work product quickly and comprehensively. This inclusive workshop format can provide an early feasibility review of the overall districts with minimal investment of both time and money. Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 9
3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Field visits in Kabarole District with the district planners and local residents Participatory planning workshop and design charette in Ft. Portal. Presentation to stakeholders in Kampala Preparation of the draft plan Review of Draft Plan by stakeholders Revisions to Draft Plan Submission of Final Plan to MTTI
The purpose of undertaking a participatory planning approach to tourism development in the District was to ensure that locally relevant issues were incorporated, and that people living within the district developed ownership over the plan.
10
3
3.1
EXISTING CONDITIONS
LOCATION
The district is located in the western part of Uganda, and the main city of Ft. Portal is 320 km west of Kampala. Kabarole District borders the districts of Bundibugyo in the west and north, Kasese and Kamwenge in the south and Kyenjojo in the east. Kabarole has a total area of 1,844.25 km2 of which 137, 802 hectares is covered by forest.
Figure 1
3.2
11
number of the ethnic groups in the Great Lakes Region including the Baganda, Bunyoro, Batooro, Banyankole and Banyarwanda, although this migration pattern is challenged by some authorities (Chrtian 2003). From the late fifteen Century the Bunyoro Kingdom, centred on what is now Hoima District was the dominant force in the Region. In the 1840s a Bunyoro Prince, Kaboyo, seceded and formed the Tooro Kingdom. Conflict between the two kingdoms especially under the powerful King Cwa II Kabalega (1869-1898), who also strongly resisted British colonisation, led to 18 years of Bunyoro occupation and to the near extinction of the Tooro lineage, but in 1888 the infant Tooro Prince, Kasagama, assisted by a Bakonzo Chief, was rescued and sent to Ankole. Kasagama later played a significant role in the modernisation of the Kingdom.
The first encounter of the region with Europeans was in the following year, 1889, during H.M Stanleys limp southward, after a very arduous trip across the continent from the west, and up the River Congo. The objective of this expedition, assisted by the famous Zanzibari slave trader Tippu Tip, was the rescue of Emin Pasha, who governed Equatoria a large area what is now northern Uganda, Southern Sudan and Eastern Congo, on behalf of the Khedive of Egypt. Emin Pasha of German-Jewish origin was a convert to Islam, and was in the reluctant company of Stanley (Stacey 2003). The British established colonial rule over the region following the defeat of the Bunyoro King, Kabalega in 1899. This area played a key role with the construction of a number of forts. The Tooro Kingdom, who had allied
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 12
themselves with the British, became a client Kingdom and subsequently administered the Tooro District, centred on Fort Portal. A federal system based on the Kingdoms was established in 1962, at Ugandas independence. But after the monarchies were abolished in 1967, Toro was declared a large district. In 1974, Toro district was subdivided into three districts that included Semliki, Rwenzori and Toro, and in 1980 the latter became Kabarole district while the other two became Bundibugyo and Kasese Districts. In 1993 the traditional Kingdoms were re-established as cultural entities, which has led to a cultural revival. 3.2.2 Demographics The district has a population of 356,914 people of which 178,560 are females and 178,354 are males. Ethnic groups in the district are predominantly the Batooro, with the Bakonzo and Baamba in the foothills of the Ruwenzori Mountains. Bakiga communities are scattered across the district, stemming through migration and resettlement schemes from the highly populated Kigezi Region. The first organised resettlements were in 1955, and the Bakiga also provided a labour force for the tea industry. Small refuge settlements of Banyarawnda, established in the late 1950s are becoming increasingly integrated (Rwagweri, 2003). Urbanisation is low at 11% but increasing.
Only 11% of the Districts population live in urban areas like Ft. Portal.
3.2.3 Livelihoods Agriculture is the dominant activity in the District, with main food crops such as plantain, banana, maize, sweet potato, cassava, and a variety of beans.
13
Cash crops include coffee and tea. Eucalyptus is increasingly grown as a source of fuel and building material. The predominance of subsistence cultivation was not always the case, as the Batooro were principally pastoralists up until the African rinderpest pandemic of 1920. Virtually the whole of the districts cattle population was wiped out. This led to major disruption in the lives of the people and a rapid, if disruptive transformation, to a subsistence agricultural society which left its long term marks on society. (Rwagweri, 2003). The Batooro, for example, were long reluctant to enter the tea industry labour force, leading to the importing of Bakiga from Kigezi. Other traditional activities are carried out as part of the agricultural life including craftwork, basketry and blacksmithing. Trading and urban activities are focused on Fort Portal. 3.2.4 Health There are Two Private Hospitals, One Referral Hospital, Two Health Centre IVs, 11 Health Centre IIIs and 34 Health Centre IIs. 3.2.5 People and Parks There are three Protected Areas (PAs) in Kabarole District managed by Uganda Wildlife Authority. (see map on following page):-Toro-Semiliki Wildlife Reserve, Kibale Forest National Park and Rwenzori Mountains National Park. The fourth protected area is Itwara Central Forest Reserve, managed by the Forest Department Part of Toro-Semiliki Wildlife Reserve (TSWR) is found in Kabarole District. TSWR was established in 1929 as a game reserve and covers an area of
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 14
542 km. It comprises of the Wasa River that flows from the Rwenzori Mountains to the Lake Albert, forming a traversing riverine system that supports unique forest tree species as well as providing habitat for a variety of wild animals. TSWR is one of the reserves in Uganda with high concentrations of large ungulates including the Uganda Kob, elephants, buffaloes, bushbucks and warthogs. Primates including chimpanzees, baboons, red tailed monkeys, while notable birds such as the shoebill and the saddle billed stocks can also be observed. The TSWR is especially unique as an area of transition for three of Africas bio-geographical regions (Sudano-sahelian, Guinea-Congolian and Zambezean). Diverse habitats occur in the valley floor of the reserve supporting a variety of vegetation types such as grasslands, riverine forests, scrub woodland, swamp forests, papyrus swamps and savannah woodland mosaic. (Toro-Semiliki Wildlife Reserve, Short Term Operations Plan, 20032005) Rwenzori Mountains National Park (RMNP) is approximately 995 km and is located across three districts - Kabarole, Kasese and Bundibugyo. In 1994 RMNP was designated a World Heritage Site, indicating the international environmental importance placed on this national park. The Rwenzori mountain ecosystem is one of the largest and most significant water catchment ecosystems in Uganda and constitutes a major source of the White Nile through the Semiliki River, which flows into Lake Albert (Rwenzori Mountain National Park Management Plan 2004-2014).
15
Kibale Forest National Park (KFNP) was gazetted in 1993 and covers an area of approximately 795 km. KFNP has a variety of conservation values. It is the third largest forested National Park in Uganda and supports nine endangered mammal species, including chimpanzees and red colobus, considered to be globally threatened or nearly so (Kibale Forest National Park, General Management Plan 2003-2013). The main tourism activities conducted in Kibale Forest National Park are accessed from Kabarole and include chimp tracking, forest walks and birdwatching.
Conflicts between the protected area and the local communities stem from wildlife leaving the park and raiding crops in the neighbouring fields. Around the Rwenzoris, primates (e.g blue monkey, vervets, red tailed monkey and baboons) and bushpigs are the main culprits. In response to this the PA has initiated the planting of a natural barrier Mauritius thorn as well as scaring and chasing of the wildlife back into the protected areas. An innovative concept that has been introduced in Uganda to ease the People versus Parks tension is that of Community-protected area institutions (CPI). Community-protected area institutions (CPI) aim to involve communities in park decision making. The CPIs support and provide advice during negotiations for benefit sharing and resource use, to screen community proposals for funding under the revenue sharing programme, and to address community-protected area problems (e.g. including wildlife crop raiding, problem animal control, and illegal activities in PAs) (Mapesa and Makombo, 2002).
16
A revenue sharing arrangement distributes 20% of gate fees collected by UWA to the sub-county local government, which then uses it within its budget. Through the CPIs, local people write project proposals that are approved and endorsed through the local government. A preference is given to environmentally sensitive, self-sustaining initiatives that benefit the parish as a whole. (Mapesa and Makombo, 2002). The Wildlife statute stipulates that collaborative management is a recommended approach to protected area and wildlife management. This can be with local communities, the private sector, NGOs, local governments and other government agencies. UWA has developed a Community Conservation Policy that supports their collaborative work with local communities and has developed several programs and a range of strategies to achieve them. The programs developed are as follows: Institutional framework for community conservation Revenue sharing Collaborative management Problem animal management Wildlife user rights Trade in wildlife and wildlife products Conservation education and awareness programmes (Uganda Wildlife Authority, Community Conservation Policy, June 2004).
17
Itwara Central Forest Reserve is a large natural forest with significant biodiversity values. The Forest Authority (formerly known as the Forest Department) has recently emerged from several years of institutional development. It has a programme of forest tourism.
3.3
LAND USE
The district has a rich endowment of vegetation types and agro-ecological zones, from the mountains to the lowlands. The Afro-alpine heaths, montane bamboo and montane forests are some of the rarest types on the continent. Lowland forests are also significant with the total forest area of the district at almost 22% of which 3.6 is degraded. Grassland covers 12% of the district, and there are significant lakes and wetlands, but agriculture, at 53%, is the single largest land use. The major economic activity, therefore, in Kabarole is agriculture. The crops grown are mostly food crops like sweet potatoes, maize, cassava, soya beans, groundnuts, sunflower, yams, millet and bananas. The land is very fertile and the foot hill of the Rwenzori Mountains provide favourable conditions for farming. Coffee is grown for cash. The district is also among the few districts in Uganda which grow high quality tea, although only 3% of the district is under this land use. Most of the tea produced is sold for cash with the majority of the tea plantations peripheral to the Itwara and Kibale forests.
Cultivation covers most hilltops and little of the original forest outside the parks still remains.
The land is highly fragmented due to traditional practices of inheritance and high population density. Land is held in customary private ownership although there are few relatively well off farmers with leasehold titles. Grazing lands are communally owned and land fragmentation, as mentioned, is a common feature. The concept of land use planning is still new and is only practiced to a limited extend in the
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 18
townships, where specific areas are assigned for industries, commercial building, residential, road networks and institutional sites. Substantial parts of the district lie in protected areas. 18% of the district is Tropical High forest (included in Kibale Forest National Park, Rwenzori Mountain National Park (RMNP) World Heritage Site, Itwara Central Forest Reserve and Toro Semiliki Wildlife Reserve (TSWR). Cultivation covers most hilltops and, little of the original forest outside the parks still remains. Small fragments of grassland remain (albeit threatened) within the agricultural area, with indications of high biodiversity values. Given the historic, cultural and biological diversity of these grassland areas attention to their conservation is warranted. Land shortage, coupled with intensive use for subsistence agriculture, has led to soil degradation, poor yields and ultimately poverty. All this leads to high dependence on some park resources (UWA, 2000). Some small-scale artisan fishing takes place within inland water bodies; the crater lakes, wetlands and rivers. These can be significant income/nutrition sources at the local level.
3.4
INFRASTRUCTURE
3.4.1 Roads The main arterial road from Kampala to Ft. Portal has recently been upgraded to tarmac. This continues on through the district to Kasese Town. Although there is a need for the district to extend the road network particularly to productive rural areas, it already has substantial road coverage. The road network currently spans 718 km of both feeder and access roads.
4-wheel vehicles are required for some of the roads in the rainy season. Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 19
3.4.2 Air Transport There is currently only one airstrip in Kabarole near Lake Saaka. However, this airstrip is disused and not operational. Therefore, there is no air connection with Kampala. The Makwano Tea Estate is currently planning on adding an airstrip and this will help access tremendously to Ft. Portal and the district. 3.4.3 Electricity Although hydroelectric power is limited to major urban centres, there are high hopes that the government through the Rural Electrification Program will extend electricity to the productive rural areas.
There is use of solar energy and gas for lighting and drying of foodstuffs for export. But the most common source of fuel especially in the remote areas is firewood, which poses a serious danger to the environment. 3.4.4 Water Due to the heavy rainfall in the Rwenzoris, there is abundant water available in Kabarole District. There are several large rivers that flow through the district (Mpanga, Mahoma, Rwimi and Nsonbe) and Kabarole has one of the highest densities of crater lakes in the world. However, it is only in Ft. Portal where there is municipality piped water to buildings.
20
3.4.5 Communication The district has two post offices - in Fort Portal Municipality and Rwimi Town Council - with modern telecommunication exchanges. The district is also adequately connected to the major telephone companies like MTN and Uganda telecom (Mango) services.
As regards TV and radio, the District also has access to Uganda Television network and a number of FM radio stations including Voice of Toro and Radio Uganda. 3.4.6 Housing There are four types of houses in Kabarole district and this has a direct relation to demographic changes especially population increase. These are (DoE, 2001): traditional non-upgradable, constructed with mud, wattle and grass thatch (sorghum stalks, papyrus ); upgradable traditional houses commonly made of mud mixed with cement or sun dried bricks with poles and iron sheets. These are common in trading centres and in the outskirts/suburbs of Ft. Portal Town; semi permanent houses made of sun-dried bricks/stones, walls with rough cast and iron sheet roof with ordinary foundation; and permanent houses made of brick walls, stones, cemented floor, iron sheet or tiled roofs. This is common in trading centres, Ft. Portal Town Council and few well-to-do families in rural areas.
21
3.4.7 Education Kabarole District has 127 primary schools and 31 secondary schools. It has a typical education infrastructure. However, compared to other districts the girl participation in secondary school is much better and there is a good pupil to teacher ratio. One of the bigger achievements in this District is the formation of the Mountains of the Moon University which has already begun providing a few courses and currently based in Ft. Portal. The University has purchased property on the shores of Lake Saaka and is in the process of planning a new campus. Box 1. Education Data
Primary Schools 127 (113 government, 9 private, 5 community) Secondary Schools 31, (14 government, 5 private, 12 Community) Teachers training colleges 3 National Technical Institute 1 Primary pupils 98,892 (50% female) Secondary pupils 10,216 (48% female) Primary teachers 1,704 (50% female). Secondary teachers 540 (20% female) Teacher pupil ratio: Primary 1:58, Secondary 1:19 Source: Uganda Handbook District Information
22
3.5
POLICY CONTEXT
3.5.1 Poverty Eradication Action Plan Government's strategy for economic transformation is spelled out in the Poverty Eradication Action Plan (PEAP) 2000. Three conditions are envisaged as pre-requisite for economic growth to eradicate poverty (ARO, 2002): structural transformation (agricultural modernization, industrialization, institutional reforms and capacity development); participation by the poor in economic growth by expanding smallholder agriculture, employment, the services sectors and rural non-farm enterprises; and sustainable economic growth with judicious management of land, forests, wetlands, rangelands, rivers, lakes and the environment.
This Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan is aligned with the PEAP, and in particular addresses participation by the poor in tourism planning, development and operation. The sustainable development of the tourism industry is promoted, with responsible use of natural resources and biodiversity conservation. 3.5.2 Tourism policy A core objective of the Tourism Policy for Uganda is to stimulate the industry in Uganda, and ultimately to increase the present level of tourist arrivals from about 200,000 to about 500,000 over the next decade. Although Uganda was the primary tourism destination in East Africa during the 1960s, political and social turmoil during the 1970s and 80s led to the destruction of tourism infrastructure, and widespread hunting of wildlife: virtually to extinction in many protected areas. The policy aims to ensure that tourism is used as a vehicle for poverty reduction, within the resource base and market limitations. The policy denotes that tourism development should provide a mechanism for conservation, by generating revenue to develop National Parks and protected areas, but that it should also be socially and culturally acceptable (MTTI, 2003). A number of key institutional, economic, environmental and cultural objectives are highlighted within the policy. Those that are most directly relevant to this Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan have been paraphrased below (MTTI, 2003). Economic objectives: Derive greater revenues from an increasing number of pleasure tourist arrivals and promote longer lengths of stay and higher daily expenditure. Distribute revenue earnings widely, with the large-scale participation of communities and districts in tourism. Environmental objectives: Channel tourism revenue towards the conservation of natural resources, and use protected area entry fees to generate interest in environmental protection and generate revenue for local government and communities.
23
Cultural objectives: Emphasize tourism development based on Uganda's rich culture and history, and on the diverse traditions and hospitality of its people (e.g. museums, performance art, monuments) to encourage a Ugandan identity and cultural pride.
The objectives have been used to develop a range of strategies that address product development linked to environmental and cultural resources, and communities. Those relevant to the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan have been summarised in Table 1.
The Engabu za Tooro theatre and dance troupe is very unique to Kabarole.
24
Theme
Product development, marketing, market segments
It should be noted that MTTI has devised a marketing strategy in collaboration with the European Union.
25
3.5.3 Local government All communities in Uganda are organised in the five-tier local government system that starts at the village (LC 1) to the district level (LC 5). There are councils comprising of elected community representatives. Many functions of government (income tax collection, service provision and aspects of environment management) have been decentralised to the district (LC 5) and sub-county (LC 3) according to the Local Government Act (1997). Of the revenue collected by sub-counties, 65% is retained at that level and 35% remitted to the districts. The 65%, at the sub-county is shared amongst the county (LC 4), sub-county (LC 3), parish (LC2) and village (LC 1) at the ratio of 1:6:1:5 respectively for local development and service provision (UWA, 2000). The local government system has both administrative and legislative functions and a hierarchy of employed officials, whose roles are outlined in Appendix 6.
Local Government officials were very actively involved in the preparation of the plan.
3.5.4 Supplements to the policies for the purposes of this plan The Tourism Policy of Uganda promotes the development of various forms of tourism, including domestic, foreign, ecotourism and cultural tourism. For the purposes of this plan, standard definitions from international nongovernmental organisations have been used:
26
Tourism: The activities of persons travelling to and staying in places outside their usual environment for not more than one consecutive year for leisure, business and other purposes (WTO, 2002: 101). Tourist: A visitor who stays at least one night in collective or private accommodation in the place visited (WTO, 2002: 101). Ecotourism: Responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment and improves the well-being of local people." (The International Ecotourism Society, 1992). This means that those who implement and participate in ecotourism activities should follow the following principles: Minimize impact Build environmental and cultural awareness and respect Provide positive experiences for both visitors and hosts Provide direct financial benefits for conservation Develop environmentally and socially friendly facilities Provide financial benefits and empowerment for local people Raise sensitivity to host countries' political, environmental, and social climate Support international human rights and labour agreements
Local Communities were key role players in the preparation of this plan.
Although communities are mentioned within the tourism policy as participants in the tourism industry, they were not highlighted as key role players. Given the emphasis on this district tourism development plan on poverty alleviation, the promotion of cultural tourism, and domestic tourism, they have been prioritised as tourism stakeholders.
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 27
3.6
PLANNING CONTEXT
3.6.1 Three-Year Kabarole District Development Plan Kabarole District Local Council prepared a 3-yr medium term development plan in line with national policy as outlined in the Poverty Eradication Action Plan and complimentary policies. The planning process was comprehensive and included consultations with many stakeholders. This plan covers three financial years, 2004/2005, 2005/2006 and 2006/2007 and addresses key development concerns and aims at improving the quality of life of the people of Kabarole. This plan is in two parts. Part one analyses the current poverty situation and sets outs goals, objectives and strategies in six district directorates. Part two is the Public Investment Programme, which comprises project profiles of the projects to be implemented in the plan period 2003-2006. It should be noted that tourism does not fall under any directorate and there is very little mention of tourist related development or activities in this plan. The district does acknowledge the importance of RMNP and KFNP and the potential for private sector involvement (Kabarole District Development Plan). Additionally, there is no tourism project slated for development in the next three years. Most of the projects are for construction of roads, protection of springs, supply of water and electricity, construction of health centres, soil and water conservation, wetland management, new schools etc. 3.6.2 Uganda Wildlife Authority Management Plans The mission of UWA is to conserve and sustainably manage the wildlife and protected areas of Uganda in partnership with the neighbouring communities and other stakeholders for the benefit of the people of Uganda and the global community (Mapesa and Makombo, 2002). It is important that there is harmonisation between the District level tourism efforts and national park tourism activities of UWA. The national parks contain the main nature and wildlife attractions that are drawing international tourists, while Districts are overall responsible for the anchor zones, second tier attractions and communities. The Districts are aiming to encourage visitors that are visiting the parks to spend more time and money in the districts. Community tourism projects acknowledge the support that they received from UWA staff in developing their project, including in kind contributions of transport and cross-visits to other community tourism projects. This Plan provides the opportunity to further harmonise Park and District level plans, UWAs Strategic Plan for 2002-2007 states the following strategic objectives that are related to this plan (UWA, 2002): tourism and self-generated revenue: Optimise and stabilize tourismbased revenue within safe limits of the resource base and encourage the appreciation of wildlife and protected areas by Ugandas citizens;
28
promote and provide technical services and support to local investors in the ecotourism initiatives; ensure development of accommodation facilities for all visitor grades; community conservation and benefits: Optimise protected areas contribution to the welfare of neighbouring communities, and improve relations with local communities; and wildlife management outside PAs: Ensure UWA meets its obligations regarding problem animal control and safeguard wildlife outside PAs.
Kibale Forest National Park deserves a special mention as has the reputation as the independent travellers dream. (Briggs, 1998). Specifically the Kibale Forest Management Plan Zones the national park into 6 zones. There are two tourism zones the Kanyanchu Site and the newly developed Sebetoli zone alongside the Fort Portal Kampala Road (UWA, 2003). The tourism zones contain, tourism infrastructure, a network of visitor trails and limited staff accommodation. There is a 4-day hiking trail linking the two zones through the parks wilderness zone. UWA has a specific tourism plan for Kibale and its revision will be carried out in close collaboration with District staff. The park plan envisages greater promotion of Kibale Forest at international level but also integrated with nearby attractions. The plan identifies the importance of providing up to date information to the publishers of travel guidebooks, as well as revising entrance fees and upgrading infrastructure. Community groups already provide services to tourist within the park, although the reduction in tourist numbers in recent years led to declining motivation and standards. Kibale has some of the best trained and experienced wildlife guides, making it a potential site for regional tourism
29
training. Integrated resource use zones provide the potential for additional community tourism e.g. herbalist tours. The District will make efforts to improve the facilities for independent travellers who make up a significant sector and yet are not particularly well catered for.
3.7
DEMANDS
AND
ACCOMMODATION
The main tourism attractions in Kabarole are Kibale Forest National Park (KFNP), the UNESCO World Heritage Site of Rwenzori Mountains and Toro Semiliki Wildilfe Reserve, although for the latter, the main tourism activities are accessed from Bundibudyo district. Table 2 shows the visitor statistics for KFNP and RMNP over a five-year period. Very scant statistics are available for Toro Semiliki Wildlife Reserve over this period.
Table 2: Visitor statistics for National Parks for RMNP and KFNP (20002004) National Park 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 Rwenzori Mountain National closed 117 250 435 592 Park Kibale Forest National Park 1149 1849 4899 5998 5463
Source: Uganda Wildlife Authority booking office Note that not all of these visitors would have entered the parks through entry points within Kabarole and are whole park figures
30
Stakeholders present during the planning workshops identified a wide range of additional tourism attractions, activities and facilities within the district. Table 3 presents the existing accommodation facilities reported in Kabarole. This information should be used as a general guide until it can be verified with in situ evaluations of pertinent issues including current visitation levels/occupancies, quality and standards, numbers of beds/capacity, and facilities.
Table 3: Existing Accommodation in Kabarole District. Name of accommodation No. of rooms Rates (UG Shs) establishment St Josephs Inn Tooro Resort Ataco Country Resort Rwenzori View Guesthouse Rwenzori Travelers Inn CVK Nkumba Mountains of the Moon Semiliki Safari Lodge Ndali Lodge Palace Motel Kiko Guest House Tree house (Kibale FNP) Njare Guest House Dage Guest House Kasunga Training Centre Rujuna Hill Top Guest House Amabere Ganyima Mwima Guest House Riveria Chimpanzee Guest House Kenneth Inn 33 8 8 7 N/A 20 cottages, 18 rooms 5 100 8 8 15,000 50,000 60,000 50,000 25-35,000 30-50,000 25,000 Under renovation 200,000 200,000 25,000 25,000 40,000 40,000 50,000 10-25,000 45-50,000 N/A N/A N/A N/A
2 5 30 7 2 5 N/A N/A
The range of existing tourism activities reported by workshop participants is indicated in Box 2. Box 2: Reported existing tourism activities in Kabarole District
Bird watching Education and research Fishing in rivers Forest walks, to see waterfalls, trees and wildlife Game viewing (i.e. Itware, KFNP) ) Photography and filming Scenic viewing Traditional music Village walks (including visits to see beer brewing, blacksmith, and various cultural attractions) 31
A variety of natural and cultural attractions in Kabarole were listed by workshop participants. Given that it was not possible to visit all of the attractions during the time period allocated for district field visits, an indicative appreciation of current use levels by foreign and domestic tourists was sought from participants who were also asked to indicate the attractions that were, in their opinion, the most attractive. Table 4: Physical attractions in Kabarole District 1. Caves Amabere ganyina Mwiru located at Nyakasura Bukuuku sub county 2. Hot springs Rwagimba located in Kibiito sub-county 3. Water falls Amabere ganyima Mwiru Mahoma Yerya falls (proposed for Hydro electric power generation) located in Kisomoro sub-county 4. Crater lakes Saaka located in Kichwanba sub-county Nyabikere located in Ruteete sub-county Nkuruba located in Ruteete sub-county Mwegenya located in Buheesi sub-county Ntanda located in Buheesi sub-county Kigere/Balaamu Wabikere Hamugoma Kifurukwa (abandoned) Bwabya/Bukoni Busoro S/County Nyinambuga Ruteete S/County Lyantonde Ruteete S/County Abdallah Ruteete S/C Nyamiirima Ruteete S/C Nyinabulitwa Ruteete S/C 5. Tea estates Rweeitera Ruteete sub-county Buzirasgama Busora sub-county Rwenzori tea Hotel to be renovated Kiamara Busoro sub-county Mpanga Estate Busoro Sub-County Kijura Hakiabaale sub-county (Toro-Kahuma) Kiko tea estate Ruteete sub-county 6. Toro Kingdom Palace Karambi tombs
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 32
Palace of the 1st king of Toro Palace in Kibiito sub-county Kagoma village and tomb
7. Historical sites Fort Gerald Portal Kichuwamba mass grave site Malibo/Kasoro monuments - Nyakaseke Fort Portal Municipality Fort Lugard ruins Sir Samuel Baker Palace (Ndaiga) Fort Wavertree ruins Kateebwa War Memorial Mounument Kisomoro sub-county 8. Landscapes Toro Botanical Gardens Kamutebi swamp, Bukuuku Grazing Landscape Katokoma Swamp Mugunu Swamp 9. Protected areas Highest number of primate species in the world Chimpanzee viewing Organic/wild coffee Birds Forest walks Primates, bush pigs, elephants Mountain Trails Caves 10. Scenic view points Lake Saaka hills Kabarole Hill Kyatwa Hill Kibiito Sub-county Rwenzori Mountain ranges Oruha forest reserve Hill Nyamirima hill overlooking lake Nyamirima
There were also a range of existing products and services that participants reported were currently sold to tourists. These are outlined in Table 5.
33
Lake Nkuruba Crater Lake: -Crater rim forests -5 primate species -210 bird spp.
Lake Nkuruba Nature Reserve Church Owned, Leased to Kabarole Tours (Private Sector Operated)
Nature walks, Bird-watching, swimming etc, Starting point for a Long Distance Crater Lake Trail 4days, 3 nights, camping linking other sites (started 12/04, so far 3groups total 8 people
Crater Lake
Kitojo Fellowship Home Private home run as a family homestay Accommodation Ndali Lodge
Forest restoration
Employment Support to School (building classroom) Proposed extension of water supply to village from hydro Other slides. Contact the person.
Rwigo Campsite Lake Lyantonde Community campsite Views of crater lakes and Kibale F NP, view of tea fields, occasional views of chimps Chimpanzee Guest House
Privately owned Campsite with bandas Village walks Mahoma waterfall Caves Vent crater Nature trails and birdwatching
employment
34
Crater Lakes Stories and Myths The major attraction of Kabarole District outside the parks are the crater lakes. These are not only geologically and ecologically interesting but have many cultural associations. They are linked with the original mythic ancestors of the Kings - the Bacwezi who are deified in various forms. At the workshop, participant Mrs. P.K. Ruyooka, of the Crater Valley Beach Resort (CVK) translated almost half the names into English, Table 6. This is the first step towards creating visitor interpretation centred around the rich culture of the crater lakes, and warrants further research with community authorities. The full list of lakes can be found in the Annex 6. Table 6: English renderings of Kabarole Crater Lakes
Name English Translation 2. Kasindikwa Shamans Lake 4. Wabikere Frogs Lakes 5. Hamugoma On the Edge Lake 6. Saaka 7. Mwegenywa 9. Nyinabulitwa Mother Lake 10. Nyamirima Lake of Darkness 11.Nyabikere Lake of Toads and Frogs 14.Njarayabaana Lake of Hungry Children 15.Mubiro 17.Kaisamukoma Causes Kings Death Lake 18.Nyamugasani Kings Graves Lake 27.Rwenjubu Lake for Forest Hogs 32.Nyinambuga 33.Kifurukwa Abandoned Lake 36.Lyantonde 38.Kanyanswiga African Spinach Lake 40.Rukwanzi Lake of Beads 43.Kasenda Lake of Slopes 47.Kamiramacumu Spear Swallowing Lake 48.Kiribwato Lake of Canoes Source: Fisheries Department, Kabarole English Names translated by Mrs. P.K. Ruyook Hitory, Stories and comments Large frog population
35
4
4.1
Lake Nkuruba is the only Crater Lake that is remaining unspoilt by deforestation.
The district receives fairly well distributed rainfall throughout the year with an average rainfall ranging between 900-1600mm annually and two rain seasons that come between March to May and August to November. There are heavy downpours during the rainy season. 4.1.4.2 Temperature The annual Temperatures normally range between 25C and 28.0C. During the summer season it does get hot in the lower areas of the district although in parts of Bunyangabu, Burahya and Fort Portal, the temperatures do occasionally fall well below 20 degrees Celsius. 4.1.5 Vegetation The vegetation in Kabarole District varies according to altitude. Lower elevations have varied habitats including thick bush, forest, swamps and crater lakes while higher elevations have montane forests and moorland. Decreasing temperatures with increasing altitude have resulted in a remarkable zoning of vegetation. The most striking plants can be found above 3,000 m, where areas of giant tree heathers support unique aerial epiphytic gardens. The alpine zone includes the giant lobelias and groundsels, hallmarks of the Rwenzori.
The Kamutebi swamp is the largest such vegetation ecosystem in Kabarole District.
37
4.2
2. Low prioritization and focus of tourism by district administration 3. Lack of approved district tourism plan 4. Absence of organised tourism development or promotion organization 5. Inadequate skills in development, marketing and management of tourism products, goods and services including safety.
Lobby for development of standard curriculum in tourism Implement training programs to address specific needs/gaps Encourage partnerships with private sector that ensure transfer of skills in managing tourism facilities In existing training facilities, needs assessment to identify gaps should be implemented to address poor training Lobby and advocate for the establishment of a regional tourism training school Establish linkages with relevant volunteer organizations to support skills development in tourism management Establish linkages with institutions in the district to provide training e.g. wildlife training institute- Katwe Identify gaps in quality and lack of infrastructure with input from relevant technical expertise (MTTI, consultants) Where relevant district administration improves facilities and tourism attractions Where relevant district administration supports communities to improve facilities and tourism attractions Develop by-laws that set standards for tourism Disseminate information on possible funding bodies e.g. GEF small grants, STABEX, DFCU Development fund, Bank of Uganda fund, microfinance institutions Allocate funds for a strategy fund to support tourism 38
9. Lack of planning /development guidelines related to tourism infrastructure 10. Absence of approved tourism training institution in the region 11. Gender mainstreaming
Encourage partnerships with private sector partners that bring investment resources Lobby donors to allocate resources for tourism development Create awareness about the positive values of the protected areas and tourism Develop benefit sharing schemes for the local communities Encourage community participation in the management and planning of Pas Encourage development of a district tourism Marketing strategy Ensure regular collection of information on tourism products for dissemination to the tourism industry Provide incentives for investors to tourism development in Kasese Engage relevant expertise to support development of planning/development guidelines related to tourism infrastructure and product Develop bylaws to ensure guidelines are implemented See point 5.
Threats 1. Existing armed conflicts in neighbouring DRC 2. Conflicts between local communities and protected areas/conservation 3. Poaching
4.Insufficient land for agriculture owing to rapid population growth 5. Poor land use leading to encroachment on protected areas 6. Poverty
Encourage participation of women in tourism activities Sensitize local communities on the importance of gender equity Proposed actions to address threats Establish cross border collaboration/communication Develop public relations programme Encourage benefit sharing Develop problem animal control programs and support implementation of plan Strengthen law enforcement operations Encourage benefit sharing Sensitization/education on the importance of conservation Review and update penalties for poaching Support development of alternative sources of income to combat poverty Support development of alternative resource use Develop culturally/religiously sensitive family planning programs Engage relevant agencies to improve land use practices Develop and implement a land use strategy Support implementation of poverty alleviation strategies Support tourism projects that encourage benefit sharing with the poor Support health sensitization programs Develop bylaws to improve basic health hygiene e.g. pit latrines, boiling water etc etc Encourage linkages across wildlife, livestock and human health that improve communication and collaboration Sensitize communities on the negative health impacts of eating game meat Sensitize the local communities and tourists on the negative impact of begging on culture and status of the communities Develop information leaflets for tourists to channel donations through established reputable 39
7. Diseases
8. Begging syndrome
organizations/schools Sensitization on the negative environmental impacts of littering Develop and implement municipal waste management plans Implement environmental audits for existing mining activities Ensure comprehensive Environmental Impact Assessment conducted for proposed mining activities Strengthen collaboration with security agencies and service providers Sensitize service providers on the risks of terrorism and possible mitigating activities e.g. barriers Support implementation of landmine removal program with security agencies
Table 8: Potential negative impacts of tourism impact of Proposed actions to mitigate negative impacts of tourism Raise awareness on the dangers/transmission of HIV to both local communities and tourists Disseminate information on the ABC concept Ensure availability of condoms Sensitize local communities on the negative impacts of prostitution Implement programs that encourage the girl/boychild to stay in schools Encourage development of alternative sources of income Strengthen cultural institutions Support development of cultural groups Implement change in curriculum to teach local languages and cultural values Sensitize and inform tourists to respect the cultural norms of the local people Sensitize tourists on the value of the assets in their natural environment and cultural home Sensitize both tourists and tourist providers on the dangers/negative environmental impacts of improper waste disposal Encourage use and sale of biodegradable products Ensure adequate waste disposal and removal facilities available through out the district Support studies to establish the levels of acceptable use by tourists to both cultural and natural areas Develop and enforce regulations to maintain established numbers of tourist
40
2. Prostitution
4. Illegal acquisition of cultural and natural assets by some tourists 5. Pollution littering
6.Environmental/product degradation
Encourage partnerships that share profits/benefits with the local communities Support projects that produce supplies for the tourism industry locally
Additional weaknesses that were discussed, but that there was insufficient time to explore actions included communication problems, security, marketing and advertising, reliance on a limited range of tourism products, a lack of investment, inflation, lack of tourists, low levels of revenue shared from parks with communities that is not shared with affected people, and that local culture was being diluted by foreign culture.
4.3
Trekking the scenic crater lakes will be encouraged in the new plan.
41
Based on the several community workshops that were held in the District, it is apparent that Kabaroles citizens are receptive to the prospect of appropriate tourism development. Those who participated were enthusiastic and endorsed the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan concept. The Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan achieves the following aims: 1. Promotion of the district as a unique tourism destination of Western Uganda. 2. Recognition that all tourism development has costs, and that the benefits to local communities must out weigh the costs. 3. Sustainable use of the natural resources.
One of the main aims of the plan is that it benefits local communities.
The Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan promotes the cultivation and application of innovative development solutions for the long-term economic benefit and participation of the local population. It will also attract quality tourism development while concurrently fostering protection of the culture and heritage of the residents of Kabarole. With the implementation of scalable development, it is expected that other economic opportunities will follow for local participation and ownership to the benefit of district residents e.g. transportation, food service, crafts, laundry, waste collection and recycling, fishing tours, recreational services, music, security, landscaping, catering etc. The Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan is also based on the simple premise that the Local District Council desires an increase in quality sustainable tourism with its related employment opportunities for Kabarole.
42
The Council recognizes the need to create infrastructure in the district to facilitate those opportunities.
4.3.2
Guiding principles The need for development that is compatible with environment has driven the various criteria for tourism development in Kabarole. Some of the key principles of the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan are: 1. The establishment of an overall sustainable tourism development style related to the high environmental and social values of the area. 2. The establishment of appropriate planning guidelines related to all aspects of tourism development. 3. To strengthen and show case the unique cultures of the district 4. To protect biodiversity and the forests. 5. To protect and further enhance sensitive ecological areas. 6. The establishment of appropriate buffer and support zones to tourism areas. Specific Guiding Principles used incorporated into the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan include: Balance economic, social and environmental issues to achieve ongoing benefit to residents, visitors, and future generations; No tourism development on ridgelines; No tourism development on slopes over 30%; No tourism development within critical view corridors; and No tourism development in the conservation areas that could degrade the physical and visual aesthetics of the area. Presentation of culture in a self-affirming and dignified manner that does not undermine specific cultural practices or services.
43
Kabarole District has great potential developing into a flagship sustainable tourism destination that would benefit the stakeholders without compromising the environment. Sustainable tourism can heighten local awareness of the importance of conservation, provide new incentives for governments and the local communities to preserve protected areas and generate revenue for local and regional economies. 4.3.3 Key elements of the Plan Key elements of the plan are: Plan Duration District Zoning Plan Model Projects Objectives, strategic directions, actions Circuits The District Zoning Plan develops the broad zoning within the district. This provides broad guidance as to WHERE tourism development should occur. The Pilot Model Projects guide WHAT kinds of tourism developments can occur within the district, and help build the capacity within the district to deliver high quality sustainable tourism. The Overall objectives, strategic directions and actions are the strategic elements of the plans and link in with national and international policies and give guidance to HOW tourism should be implemented within the ten years of the plan. The CIRCUITS link the different attractions, accommodations and transport systems together into potential flows for tour operators. Duration of the Plan: The plan shall be for ten years. Implementation of the plan, at least from the Local Government shall be tied in with the annual rolling District Development Plan. A review shall be held after five years to follow progress and make any amendments as necessary. 4.3.4 Pilot Projects The Pilot/Model projects are NOT intended to be the only projects that are taken forward within the life of the plan, but models and pilots that, when successfully implemented, will significantly improve the tourism product within the district and can stimulate other similar projects. Within the plan some further projects are identified that can also be taken forward. The models therefore: Provide examples for a range of products that can be developed to enhance district tourism products Act a pilots where the private, public and community sectors can gain further experience in developing a product Kick start a project by providing a worked project concept Provide a focus for public, private and community investments. The pilot model projects provide models across the districts. Each district can refer to the other district plans to understand these templates. Eight model projects have thus been developed across four districts where plans have been developed. The model projects are:
44
1. Canopy Walk: Kisoro District Bwindi Forest 2. Board Walk and Trail: Kisoro District Echuya Forest Trail 3. Holocaust Museum: Kanungu District Kanungu Town 4. Ecolodge: Kanungu District Bwindi Forest 5. Cultural Centre: Kabarole District Karambi Tombs 6. Visitor Centre: Kabarole District Crater Lakes 7. Mid-Range Lodge Kasese District Bwenda Lodge 8. Ecotour Operator Kasese District Kasese Town 4.3.5. Goals and Purpose of Kabarole Tourism Development Plan Long Term Goal: The economic, social and environmental benefits from tourism are increased in real terms on a sustained, long-term basis and equitably distributed within the district, while the potential costs of tourism are minimised. Purpose of the 10 year Tourism Plan: The purpose is to improve tourism infrastructure, human resources, enabling environment and resource base within the District and that it is better known on the international market place. Tourism development in the district will therefore aim to: Increase the total flow of cash income within the district of Kabarole. Support and effectively interface and benefit from the parks based tourist products. Strengthen and support communities materially and culturally Promote improved management and productivity of natural resources (in terms of flow of materials, support to both biodiversity and of the environment, and ecosystem services) Increase the number of responsible tourists visiting the district. Strategic Directions The following strategic directions are identified to achieve these goals and objectives. 1. Increase the capacity of individuals and institutions to manage a superior quality and equitable tourism product. (Capacity Building, investment, governance) a. Training on job, short courses, seminars, hospitality (Jinja & in time Mountains of the Moon University) 2. Develop an attractive and appropriate well laid out, tourism infrastructure within the District which minimises negative impacts (marketing, impact assessment) a. Improve attractions, accommodations, transports systems, b. Impact assessment and monitoring c. Planning controls 3. Develop and maintain an enabling environment within the district a. Peace and security, basic services etc (security) b. Well-managed and equitable park system well integrated with local communities. (governance, environment, participation)
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 45
c. Community led sustainable natural resource land management (environment and natural resources) 4. Expanded International and National Marketing:
Existing resorts will need to be upgraded to meet the new market demands.
46
5
5.1
ZONING PLAN
ZONING
In keeping with recommendations of the Tourism Policy for Uganda, the 3-Yr Kabarole District Development Plan, the KFNP Management Plan and the Rwenzori Mountain National Park (RMNP) General Management Plan, the primary objectives of the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan are to support viability/development of the district as a tourism pole, and to encourage sustainable livelihoods. The Plan establishes zoning categories (see below), which are based on an underlying philosophy of creating a balance between tourism development objectives and reasonable utilization of the land and its carrying capacity. Recognizing the importance of future tourism development and growth of Kabarole and its inhabitants, the location of the various tourism elements takes precedence as a planning criterion in the development of the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan. The Strategy for the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan suggests the demarcation of four main zones: Tourism Anchor Zones Secondary Tourism Zones Conservation Zones Residential and Agricultural Zones
5.1.1 Tourism Anchor Zones The component of the land uses which requires special consideration will be the Tourism Anchor Zones because of their need to interface with all kinds of tourists and desire to capitalize on amenity exposure. These are the zones that may already have a high traffic of tourism flow. There will be two tourism anchor zones Ft. Portal Town, and Rwimi. The later zone is created to act as a base to go to Rwimi River, Crater Lakes, Southern Part of Kibale Forest National Park etc.
47
5.1.2 Secondary Tourism Zones The Secondary Tourism Zones are spread out throughout the district and include the swamps, crater lakes, waterfalls etc. Planning and regulations in these areas would not be as stringent as in the anchor areas.
5.1.3 Conservation Zones The third and probably the most important land use component in Kabarole are the Conservation areas. These areas will encompass forests and swamps, and will form the backbone of the Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan. Activities in the conservation zones of Rwenzori and KFNP will mainly include tracking, nature walks, and scenic viewing and other related tourism activities. No major infrastructure development will be allowed. Minimum infrastructure to be allowed in this zone will be for interpretive purposes and aimed at facilitating visitor access to the area with as little impact on the natural resources as possible. This will include trails, shelters for resting and protection from adverse weather conditions, boardwalks, canopy viewing platforms and a few interpretive panels for orientation and interpretation. Whether or not to allow resource harvesting by communities in this zone will depend on the results of the planned review of the multiple use programme (UWA, 2002).
48
5.1.4 Residential and Agricultural Zones All those areas that are not in the Tourism or Conservation zones will be designated Residential and Agricultural Zones. As one would expect, this zone will cover the largest area (Approx. 65%).
Interspersed among these four strategic zones will be the support services such as commercial, educational, medical, industrial, utility services, sports etc.
49
In order to create varied experiences and at the same time diversify the tourism product, several circuits have been identified. Local knowledge and wisdom was helpful in creating these circuits, which have been identified in map on following page. These circuits are: 1. Cave, Waterfall and Swamp Tour day Leave after breakfast from Ft. Portal, travel by road to Kamutebi Swamp for birdwatching travel by road to Amabere Caves and Waterfalls- picnic lunch at the top of the nearby crater rim - back to Ft. Portal by 1 p.m.
2. Crater Lakes Tour day This is the tour that begins at 8.00 a.m. from Ft. Portal travel to the proposed Crater Lakes Interpretation Center located on the edge of the crater rim of Lake Saka after guided tour of the facility, hike south-west towards Lake Nyabikere and Lake Kigere- view Amabere Caves and waterfalls - picnic lunch at the top of the nearby crater rim back to Ft. Portal by 1 p.m.
50
3. Heritage Tour day Tour begins at 8.00 a.m. from hotel in Ft. Portal - first stop will be Ft. Jerry travel north to Ft. Wavertree Ruins - picnic lunch at the ruins back to Ft. Portal by 1 p.m.
51
4. Royalty Tour day Tour begins at 8.00 a.m. from hotel in Ft. Portal - first stop will be the Kings new palace in Ft. Portal drive south to the rehabilitated Karambi Tombs Visitor Center travel south to Kagoma Palace. - picnic lunch at the palace back to Ft. Portal by 1 p.m.
5. Tea Estate Tour day Tour begins after breakfast from hotel in Ft. Portal travel on the Ft. PortalKampala road to Mukwano Tea Estate take a tour of the tea estate and return back to the factory for morning tea and biscuits take a guided tour of the tea processing and become a tea taster for five minutes - back to Ft. Portal by 12 p.m.
52
6. Kibale Forest 1 day Tour begins after breakfast from hotel in Ft. Portal travel to Kibale Forest National Park attend an orientation talk on the park and ecosystems- take a guided walk to the treehouse and elephant wallow lunch at the Kanyanchu Tourist Site take a guided afternoon chimpanzee trek - back to Ft. Portal by 6 p.m.
7. Rwenzori Hiking 2 days This is a two day trip which begins from Ft. Portal and goes east to the base of the Rwenzoris hike for five hours and camp on the slopes return to Ft. Portal following day by lunch
Rwenzori foothills
53
8. Itwara Forest Reserve, Kijura Escarpment & Semliki Wildlife Reserve - 2 days This is a two day trip which begins from Ft. Portal and goes north to Itwara Forest reserve for a game drive to view Elephants, Primates and forest hogs lunch in the park travel to scenic point at Kijura Escarpment for afternoon tea camp overnight at the edge of the escarpment morning forest walk in Semliki Wildlife reserve return to Ft. Portal following day by lunch.
9. Rwagimba Hotspring 2 days This 2 day wellness tour begins in Rwimi Town drive on the Nyakigumba Road and then left to Rwimi River hike to the Hotsprings - spend overnight at a hotel close to the hotsprings following morning at the Hotsprings and return to Rwimi by evening.
Rwagimba Sulphur Hotsprings are popular with the local people. Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 54
10. Rwimi River - day The river bird-watching walk begins in Rwimi Town after breakfast and goes east along the river picnic morning tea by the river return to Rwimi by lunch.
11. South Kibale Forest 1 day This circuit begins in Rwimi Town after breakfast and goes east along to an area of Kibale Forest that has never before been opened to tourism view primates and large trees and a guided talk of forest ecosystems - picnic lunch in the forest return to Rwimi by evening.
55
12. Crater Lakes and Waterfall - 2 days Begin tour after breakfast from Rwimi Town and travel north to Bunyuruguru Crater Lakes first stop will be the Mwitampungu Explosion crater followed by Lake Ntanda camp overnight at edge of the crater rim of L. Ntanda following morning trek to Lake Mwege Nywa and Mahoma Falls travel back to Rwimi by evening.
Lake Nyinambuga is one of the more beautiful lakes in the Bunyuruguru Crater Lake system
REGIONAL CIRCUITS 13. Semliki Safari Lodge 3 days This circuit connects with Bundibugyo District - trip begins in Ft. Portal Day one : Travel to Semliki Lodge lunch and night game drive - Day two : early morning and evening game drive Day three : leisure time return to Ft. Portal by evening.
56
14. Semliki National Park 4 days This circuit connects with Bundibugyo District - trip begins in Ft. Portal Day one : Travel to Semliki National Park Headquarters visit the Bambuti Village and go on a guided forest tour by the Bambuti to Sempaya Hotsprings and the forest- night one camping at the Park Hqs. - Day two : leave early morning for a long trek through the park to Semliki River and Ituri Forest-night camping in the forest along the river Day three - return to Park Hqs.- overnight at Hqs. Day four: leisure time return to Ft. Portal by evening.
Explore the Semliki Forest National Park with the original inhabitants, the Bambuti.
15. Bigodi Wetland Sanctuary and Magombe Swamp 2 days This tour begins after breakfast in Ft. Portal travel to Bigodi Wetland Sanctuary and Magombe Swamp which is located in Kamwenge District and is located just east of Kibale Forest National Park lunch at the KAFRED (Kibale Association for Rural Development) Hqs. late afternoon guided walk into the swamp to see red Colobus, black and white Colobus, red tailed monkey, great blue turaco, butterflies etc. night at the local bandas early morning bird (138 species) and primate walk to the swamp return for lunch in Ft. Portal.
57
Tour orientation and lunch will be at the KAFRED (Kibale Association for Rural Development) Hqs.
16. Rwenzori Climb 8 days This tour starts from Ft. Portal go east by road to the base of the Ruwenzoris begin climbing the north route all the way upto Guy Yeoman Hut (in Kasese Distrcit) and then return back via Nyabitaba and Nyakalengija return to Ft. Portal or continue to Kampala from Kasese Town.
It should be noted that there are numerous should be explored once there is critical mass extremely important if we are to ensure neighbouring districts and countries provide advantage to the tourism product.
other opportunities for circuits and these and market demand. Regional circuits are sustainable tourism. The linkages with varied experiences and give an added
6.1
59
The following regional tourism products were identified that link Kabarole district to neighbouring districts and DRC: Sempaya Hotsprings Semliki River Batwa/Bambuti culture Birds (660 species can be found approx. 30 species are rare worldwide) Semliki natural forest Forest elephant, giant forest hog, shoebills, night game drives Forest savannah chimps Upmarket bush lodge Bigodi swamp Mpanga Waterfall Katoosa martyrs shrine
The following actions are recommended to districts to enhance regional tourism:a. Integrate district tourism plans with regional tourism circuits b. Local government officials to participate in discussions about regional tourism c. Local government to promote regional tourism initiatives by developing relevant bye-laws d. Provide information on regional tourism products at key locations throughout the districts e. Encourage communication between tour operators across the region f. Encourage linkages between different enterprises across the region e.g. transport, lodges
60
7.1
Views from the deck of the Crater Lake Interpretation Center Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 61
7.1.2 Concept and Programme There is currently insufficient knowledge of the crater lakes including the geology, ecosystems, culture and legends. Apart from providing tourist information, The Crater Lake Interpretation Center would also be an active centre for research. The Centre will therefore: Collect Information about crater lakes, carry out research, and advise on management of ecosystems Provide and train first class guides Develop high quality educational displays to demonstrate interconnection of the lakes and people (natural and social scientific aspects) To provide a high quality visitor experience who will learn about the lakes through guides and attractive displays, lectures and demonstrating research. To develop a trail network to link in with other lakes and attractions including a trail over to Amebere Caves.
The Center will be a collaborating institution with the Mountains of the Moon University and will share some of the scientists and research students.
The programme for the development is: Entry Drive and Parking Visitor Arrival and Drop-off
62
Reception and Ticket office Crater Lakes Exhibition Space Caf Deck and Viewing Area Research Rooms andSmall Auditorium Service Parking Area Kitchen and store Trails to various Crater Lakes.
7.2
The existing tombs and grounds are dilapidated and need to be rehabilitated.
Problems Facing the Royal Tombs A number of challenges were identified facing the Karambi Tombs: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Present structures do not reflect Batooro Culture Deterioration of the existing structures Inadequate Information about the Tombs The site security is inadequate Encroachment of the royal Tomb site by other users Theft and deterioration of Regalia Inappropriate use of the site e.g. soccer field, grazing, footpaths
7.2.2 Concept and Programme The main concept is to provide a memorable experience to visitors right from the time that they arrive into the gates of the property. Much thought has
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 63
been placed on the arrival experience and a Visitor Center has been introduced to provide an interpretive experience to visitors. All visitors will pass through the Visitor Center before moving to the tombs. Local guides will then walk the visitors through the various elements of the tombs. The programme for the Karambi Tombs Rehabilitation is: Entry Drive and Car/BusParking Visitor Center Reception and Ticket office Royal Tombs Childrens tombs Sacred Grove Relatives Tombs Ceremonial Building
7.3
COMMUNITY ISSUES
Workshop participants considered how people of the district, and especially the poorest inhabitants, could directly and indirectly benefit from the development of the Crater Lake Interpretation Center and Karambi Tombs Rehabilitation. Two groups considered the different attractions separately, with regard to the hypothetical development of a community based tourism enterprise or a joint venture. They were also asked to consider educational and infrastructure requirements that would
64
facilitate improve local living standards while also improving the quality of experience for tourists. 7.3.1 Overarching community issues in Kabarole Kabarole District is an attractive district that has taken significant steps in developing a tourism product that promises to deliver benefits at the community level. It contains a number of nationally important and globally significant nature-based tourism attractions, which are supported by similar attractions within neighbouring districts and countries. It also has an interesting history and culture, although this is not obvious to most visitors. The district along with others in Western Uganda produces craftwork of international standing. Private sector tourism is relatively well developed and has been the driving force Box 3: Building and Development behind the Kabarole District Trends and Aspirations Tourism Association, which as A challenge at the community level in developing tourism achieved much in promoting products is that the tastes and aspirations of tourism within the district. community members are often opposite to that of tourists. Investment in tourism has Tourists from developed, often urban areas are been high mainly from the seeking to reconnect with nature and looking to experience community and district level communities in harmony with nature. There investors but less from the is also a movement in the developed world which has been called new traditional which attempts to bring national and international level communities in the North towards sustainability by returning to investors. There is a danger more village and walkable scale that as the district becomes developments, and a return to traditional building techniques. more attractive to outside Ugandan communities in efforts to achieve opposite investment the social and development and modernity are moving in the building, and it is direction including using modern materials for environmental linkages, which easy for them to think that their aspirations are the same as characterise many of the the tourist wants but this is not actually the fact. current tourist enterprises, will In designing development tourism products in a very be lost. Efforts will be made to competitive market, it is critical, but achievable, to strike a maintain the links between balance between these different trends and meet differing aspirations. Uganda already has examples where tourism enterprise and inappropriate (and often very expensive) developments have development community as a actually deteriorated the quality of tourist experience and the part of this plan. Parts of the value of the attraction, while scarce community level District have only recently investment monies have been wasted. This is an important Planning control authorities as well as national emerged from a period of role of Districtorganizations, to provide, guidance, technical level support instability and rebel activity, capacity and appropriate controls. and key protected areas have been open for only for a short period (3yrs). There are signs of recovery in tourism but maintaining security is a critical task to building a sustained tourism product for the district. The Crater Lakes area has a number of sympathetic modest scale private sector enterprises that support community development. Few have purely community run and the most successful of these has been, albeit sympathetically, taken over by a local private operator in the recent past. Community projects have, however, as much potential to divide communities as to unite and benefit them. Appropriate governance at the community level is as important as at any other to ensure benefits are shared equitably. The tourism pot is small yet the needs are great.
65
Tourism development needs to be carefully planned and developed incrementally, and the expectations of the tourism sector to make major inroads into poverty of itself should not be overstated. However, it undoubtedly could have a positive impact in reducing poverty levels, with sound careful and implementation, and with integration of other sectors. Organic agriculture is one such synergy. International demand for organic agriculture is increasing. With high population densities soil fertility management will be critical. The district produces craftwork of international quality, especially basketry, and with planning, could be exported in significant quantities. Craftwork at the household level can be critical for household needs and provide essential cash for women to fund, for example, their childrens education. Craftwork is reasonably well marketed in the town itself. Indications of international demand are positive. The major gap is the collection and marketing of the baskets preferably though fair trade channels. 7.3.2 National level support A number of national level intuitions are well placed to support the community level tourism development, these include; NDERE. Ndere is made up of Ndere Troupe, Ndere Foundation and the Uganda Development Theatre Association. The Ndere Troupe is the national ballet, performing at international level with a focus on the national dances. The troop members themselves often come from disadvantaged backgrounds. Ndere Foundation provides financial sustainability, while the Uganda Development Theatre Association promotes the use of theatre and dance as a development tool. It currently works with 1,300 dance and drama groups throughout the country and several in Kabarole District. Ndere is developing an ecotourism arm, which blends visits to natural assets with cultural experiences for visitors. Ndere could provide significant inputs into cultural tourism development in the district UCOTA. Uganda Community Tourism Association. UCOTA is an umbrella organization that was founded in 1998 with the purpose of promoting community-base tourism in Uganda. It supports communities with capacity building, marketing, networking, advocacy and enterprise development. Many of the community groups the team met appreciated past UCOTA support. The organisation operates a website to market community projects and products. UCOTA. Like community dance groups which cannot support themselves from income from performances, only 1% UCTOAs income comes from its membership. A further 9% comes from sales of craftwork and the remainder (90%) from donor support. The reliance on donor funding makes the organisation vulnerable to resource troughs, which it is now experiencing. If UCOTA can take a sufficiently business like approach (fair but efficient) it would be ideally placed to develop (relatively) high volume international craft exporting, this could increase their own non-donor income and also increase number of households benefiting from craftwork sales in the region.
66
67
7.3.3 Strategic Directions for Community Based Tourism Strategic directions for the District Tourism Plan related to community based tourism. The District will. Maintain a high level of security throughout the district, and work with appropriate agencies to achieve this. Build upon historical and cultural assets, by preserving and show casing them Implement careful planning control to avoid eroding attractions by poor development (see information box) Provide training for Planning Department members in planning controls Build upon and support existing tourism products Supplement tourism development with export of craft sales and development of organic agriculture. Promote development tourism. Many tourists want to know that some of the money they are spending on travel benefit local communities. The districts can support efforts to promote tourism projects that do this. Work with private sector and opinion and community leadership to encourage communities to increase their profitable involvement in tourism in appropriate ways (see table 9) Increase the capacity for tourism promotion and development by a number of actions including: Developing a Tourism Development Taskforce made up of appropriate district officers, community leaders and private sector operators. Develop a Tourism Workplan as part of the Annual District Development Plan on a rolling basis. Appoint a District Tourism Officer. This person will have skills in community development and work with communities over community based tourism. Improve accessible information on the project through the district website and other media channels.
Work with communities over Community Based Ecotourism. Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 68
Zoning specifications should be included within District Plans to ensure that uncontrolled and inappropriate development would not take place in the vicinity of the two sites. Such development might jeopardise the sustainability and commercial viability of the proposals, and therefore the realisation of local benefits (e.g. some agricultural production may not be compatible with tourism development zones). The location of suggested attractions and complementary products should be controlled (e.g. craft stalls, restaurants, bars). Tourism stakeholders proposing to operate in the vicinity should be organised to responsibly coordinate commercial activities. Issues to address would include linking rights to responsibilities, quality standards (i.e. on products, services, accommodation etc.), rotation of guides, training, price standardisation, dealing with hawkers and beggars, and avoiding the honey pot syndrome (where people flood into an area from outside to take advantage of new opportunities). The participants identified specific ways in which different groups of poor people could become involved in tourism. These included those outlined in Table 9.
Table 9: Options for the poor to become involved in tourism Group Orphans People with disabilities Women/ widows Options for involvement in tourism Training to be self reliant Mobilise them for craft making and business They can be role models Storytelling, music, dance and drama Literature writing Producing for the tourism industry, selling of, herbs etc Mobilise women groups for quality craft production and opening centres for tourists Storytelling, folklore, music, dance and drama Mobilised to run homestays for tourists Improve the quality of local beverages (obshera, omuramba) Trainers of trainees Formation of youth cultural groups Involvement in craft making Involvement in tour guiding Security operatives in PAs/ Tourism sites Selling labour in hotels, camps, restaurants and transport sectors Participation in tourism planning process Start their own business Participation in maintenance of tourist footpaths Detailed feasibility studies should be implemented for both of the sites to predict the commercial viability of the sites. Local visitors (especially children from schools), domestic tourists (including business travellers and those visiting friends and relatives) and foreign tourists should be considered within these studies. Initial observation indicate that both the Crater Lake
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 69
Youth
Centre and the Karambi Tombs Visitor Centre could act to both diversify the range of attractions for tourists in the district, and also distribute visitors more widely across Kabarole. 7.3.4 Crater Lake Interpretation Centre Lake Saka Purpose of Center The centre will have the following objectives: 1. To support and spread benefits of the centre to the local community (see below) 2. Host local and educational tourism to allow Ugandans to learn and experience their own attractions and assets, and promote national and international cultural exchange. 3. Generate revenue for the University with a formal revenue sharing fund to assist local communities Institutional Arrangements Institutionally the Visitor Centre will be part of the Mountains Of The Moon University collaborating with other institutions. Institutions in the immediate location include primary and secondary schools, the Holy Cross Brothers Centre, the army barracks, the prison, the teachers training technical College, as well as villages in the Kamutebi Swamp Tourism Zone. The University will develop a structure that will allow the active participation of appropriate groups possibly through a representative committee structure. Community involvement and benefits 1. Use of Traditional Ecological Knowledge, Culture and Folk Law. The local people especially long established communities with local knowledge on, the lakes and use, names, ecosystems, history, folklore, legends, will form part of research teams to understand the lakes both scientifically but also traditional knowledge and experience. 2. Outlet and Development Centre for Community Products The centre shop will provide and outlet for community products. It will engage in support to communities in product development, marketing and quality control, 3. Market for Agricultural Produce The centre will be a market for agricultural produce. Currently the community produces a. Mild products, poultry, eggs, beef, goats, b. Crops (bananas, millet, cassava) and Horticulture Products 4. A Source of Information and Learning Centre for the Community The centre will be a source of information for the centre and an opportunity for extra-mural community based education programmes, including tourism management and hospitality training. 5. Employment The centre will provide employment opportunities, both as guides and research assistants but also in servicing the centre. 6. Improved infrastructure
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 70
Communities will have improved access to infrastructure, roads, electricity, water, health services, that will come the university development . 7. Resource and Repository for local Culture The centre will collect local information and make it available for current and future generations. 8. Equitable development In an effort to promote equitable benefits and revenue sharing the University will Provide fair reward for knowledge and skills Develop a revenue sharing mechanism following the community trust model (e.g. National Parks) Research into and assist with the management of the negative aspects of Tourism 7.3.5 Rehabilitation of the Karambi Royal Tombs Objectives of the project The following objectives were identified 1. The preservation and promotion of Tooro culture for current and future generations 2. To research, identify and secure Karambi and later other royal tombs in Tooro kingdom3 3. Provide an opportunity for income generation for the Tooro kingdom and local community. Current activities at the sites The current activities at the site include the following: Burial rituals Spiritual and cultural management Care of regalia (by Queen of the tombs) Care of sacred animals (the royal bull and heifer) Care of the sacred tree Physical management of the site Physical Management Programme Physical management of the site will include the following: construction and maintenance of the cultural houses (traditional houses) security, maintenance and presentation of royal tomb regalia documentation of royal tomb regalia traditional fencing of the royal tomb site training of local guides develop interpretation materials (literature)
Management and Marketing Maintaining Primary Function of the Tombs (Preservation of Cultural heritage) Tourism is Carefully Managed Appropriate Marketing developed Community participation and benefits
1. Communities mobilised and sensitised about cultural values 2. Extend employment opportunities to the immediate neighbouring community members 3. Recruitment and training as tour guides 4. Consulting the nearby communities and working with them on how to best secure and manage the tomb 5. Participating in the Kingdom social programmes 6. Share a percentage of the revenue from the Tombs 7. Sale appropriate handicrafts and other products
72
Sustainable tourism development is defined as, . . .tourism which is developed and maintained in an area (community environment) in such a manner and at such a scale that it remains viable over an indefinite period and does not degrade or alter the environment (human and physical) in which it exists to such a degree that it prohibits the successful development and well being of other activities and processes (Butler, 1993). However, rather than determining whether tourism is, or is not sustainable, it has been suggested that stakeholders should instead address the process of how tourism can develop and operate sustainably (Clarke, 1997). The SWOT analysis undertaken during the Kabarole workshop identified a range of issues pertinent to locally appropriate tourism development, given the prevailing socio-economic conditions. These issues have been supplemented with international best practice to derive code of conduct and a series of planning, economic, social and environmental actions that will promote responsible tourism development and poverty alleviation. The Tourism Policy for Uganda provides a basis for this approach given its support for the principles of Agenda 21 for the Travel and Tourism Industry (MTTI, 2003). The code of conduct and actions will form the basis of stakeholder planning during the annual work planning process. POLICY GUIDELINES FOR KABAROLE DISTRICT Tourism in Kabarole district should: (in line with national local policies and laws) Support environmental protection e.g. Reforestation etc Support community development Respect culture of local people Contribute to poverty reduction Establish a code of conduct for tourism in the district Control tourism development Quality, planning control Good planning and licensing to avoid congestion and over production CODE OF CONDUCT FOR TOURISM ENTERPRISES TOWARDS COMMUNITY Orientate Visitors to local Social Norms to promote mutual respect Carryout Social and Cultural Assessment Respect Cultural Sites Avoid Displacing Communities Or Sustainable Livelihoods Follow best practice in terms of the participation and benefit to local Communities
1. Take personal responsibility for participating in the tourism industry, planning processes. 2. Value the respect and dignity of people in the development, marketing and promotion of tourism. 3. Encourage mutually respectful, friendly and beneficial relationships between residents of Kabarole, tourists and visitors: especially with regard to the rights of privacy. 4. Combat any exploitation in any form of tourists or residents in Kabarole, especially with regard to the sexual or financial exploitation of women, youth, and marginalized groups 5. Promote gender equality in all sectors of tourism planning and development, and opportunities for people with disabilities to engage. 6. Promote a culture of mentoring: where the skilled and experienced within the district pass on their knowledge to others. 7. Buy locally produced food, drink, furnishings and crafts that reduce transportation costs, and discourage products those that exploit rare or endangered species, or have adverse negative social consequences. 8. Charge fair prices for products and services.
8.2 ACTIONS
Critical actions were identified during the planning process to promote tourism. These have been divided into 10 major subject areas and divided amongst 6 key stakeholder groups. These actions should be validated during the participatory annual development plan process. Subject areas: Security and disaster management 1. Planning and integration: monitoring, data collection) 2. Participation 3. Capacity building 4. Marketing, product development and promotion 5. Investment and financial 6. Governance and accountability 7. Social responsibility 8. Impact assessment 9. Environment and resource management. (including coordination, design, evaluation,
8.3
74
1. Security: Maintain the high levels of security needed for sustained tourism development, the appropriate central government agencies shall liase with local government to maintain regional security. 2. Planning: Ensure that district plans are integrated with existing and proposed attractions in other district and with regional (international) tourism circuits. 3. Planning: Integrate district tourism plans with broader national- and districtlevel planning processes, including the National Tourism Policy. 4. Planning: Support spatial plans, which zone areas for different types of development (including tourism), by appropriate legislation to facilitate their effective implementation. 5. Capacity Building: Introduce information about tourism into school curriculum of relevant districts, including information about the positive and negative economic, environmental and social impacts of tourism.
8.4
75
7. Participation: Use the Harmonised participatory planning guidelines for parishes/wards (MoLG, 2003b), and involve all stakeholders during all stages of the planning process.4 8. Participation: In recognition of their opportunity costs and to stimulate the participation of poor people and vulnerable groups, incentives such as the reimbursement of travel costs, subsistence and provision of meals during meetings will be considered [consistent with budgetary constraints} (MoLG, 2003a). 9. Capacity Building: Promote opportunities for community based tourism enterprises and joint ventures between the private sector and community organisations, where community members have negotiated contracts that include provisions for equitable rights, responsibilities, risks and opportunities. 10. Capacity Building: Develop criteria for planning permission to investors and developers regarding the promotion of equity, employment and training for local people (especially the poor, women, people with disabilities and youth), and procurement from local product and service providers. 11. Capacity Building: Train farmers to minimise erosion by planting trees, terracing, and undertaking selective harvesting, and avoid overgrazing, to improve the productivity of their land and also minimise the potential for landslides onto access roads. 12. Capacity Building: Support extension programmes that promote sustainable agricultural techniques to local farmers, to enhance self-sufficiency and productivity, build capacity, and reduce reliance on natural resources. 13. Investment: Create policies and strategies that evoke an enabling environment, and reduce barriers and provide access for the poor and marginalized to markets for their products and services5 14. Investment: Use the funding options (including conditional, unconditional, equalization grants, Graduated Tax, donors, private sector) to help finance community based tourism projects (MoLG, 2003a). 15. Investment: Where returns from user fees are attractive, provide institutional support for the private sector investment under the Build Operate and Own (BOO) arrangement (MoLG, 2003a) 16. Governance: Promote opportunities for local people to have a measure of ownership and control over tourism enterprise development. Use the opportunities to build capacity among local people in business, financial management, environmental management and hospitality. 17. Governance: Ensure accountability and transparency throughout the Councils tourism planning process. Where NGOs or other independent agencies transfer funds to local governments to finance CBT, ensure that there is transparency, control and accountability and appropriate levels of financial management skills (MoLG, 2003a). 18. Impact assessment: Undertake Environmental and Social Impact Assessments prior to approval of tourism projects and infrastructure, in line
Critical stakeholders include the private sector, public sector (e.g. UWA), NGOs/CBOs, service providers, traditional institutions (clans/elders), parish councils, and representatives of marginalized groups, livelihood groups and the poor (MoLG, 2003a&b). 5 Products (e.g. local food and drink, crafts, honey) and Services (e.g. traditional dancing, storytelling). Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 76
4
with national and district policy. Assess the life-cycle of a development; planning, construction, operation and decommissioning, and invoke the precautionary principle where appropriate. 19. Impact assessment: Ensure undertaken for approved projects. that mitigation recommendations are
20. Impact assessment: Plan and develop tourism infrastructure so that it not only promotes tourism, but also uplifts the standards of living for the residents of Kabarole (e.g. road quality and safety, recreational facilities, information centres etc). 21. Environment: Coordinate, plan and develop waste disposal and public health systems both to the benefit of the community and to enhance the attractiveness of Kabarole to visitors.
8.5
E.g. to remove litter, or restore eroded areas, and set up a community conservation programmes. Hoteliers, Tour operators & Guides 77
4. Social responsibility. Demonstrate an ethic of corporate social responsibility (CSR) and fair trade and quantify support for communities (e.g. number and value of bursaries for students; value of donations channelled to community projects and community infrastructure). 5. Social responsibility: Practice preferential local purchasing and employment, monitor and report on activities that stimulate the local economy, gender equity, employment of marginalized people. CoC 6. Environment: Landscape gardens and surrounding areas with indigenous plants and non-invasive species to promote conservation and education among staff and guests. 7. Environment: Use renewable, non-polluting sources of energy whenever possible (e.g. solar, wind, and micro-hydroelectric). Set realistic targets to reduce energy consumption. 8. Environment: Use sewage treatment systems that return harmless effluent back to the environment and require little energy or chemicals. Consider installing compost toilets for small developments, or reed bed systems for larger developments. Avoid the use of environmentally damaging chemicals, and promote the use of biodegradable and organic pest control, detergents and treatment agents. 9. Environment: Promote the ethic of reduce, reuse and recycle among enterprise staff, local people and tourists. Work with suppliers to reduce the volume of packaging, or to return packaging to suppliers for re-use
8.7
78
6. Marketing. Tourists want to meet the people of Kabarole. Design opportunities for interactions between visitors and hosts for cultural exchange and provide opportunities for visitors to learn more about the natural and cultural heritage8. 7. Marketing: Consider ways in which the cultural heritage and craft skills within Kabarole can be further adapted to provide attractive tourist products and attractions, while not devaluing important traditions. 8. Capacity Building: Train local guides who can offer tours of the outstanding natural features of Kabarole, and who can educate visitors about the local environment. In addition to existing forms of tourism in protected areas (e.g. gorilla trekking), also consider agrotourism, fishing, hiking or craft making as options for visitors. 9. Capacity Building: Sensitise residents regarding the potential needs and expectations of different types of tourists. For example by using radio, workshops and schools to explain how tourism is everyones responsibility. 10. Capacity Building: Use the interest from tourists in local culture to stimulate education and pride among the residents of Kabarole of their heritage, and pass on stories, dances, songs and traditional skills to the youth. 11. Impact Assessment. Stimulate opportunities for marginalized members of society to actively participate in the tourism industry (e.g. women, orphans, youth, people with disabilities, the landless). 12. Impact Assessment. Consider how tourism can be developed so that does not negatively affect the way of life and peoples livelihoods (e.g. avoiding conflicts over resources, not interfering with childrens schooling). Tourism should not compromise respect for social and cultural and religious rights, or the essential human rights of people to food, a safe and clean environment, work, health, and education.
8.8
Through for example: guided tours of local villages, meals with traditional food and drink, demonstrations of craft making skills, cultural dances, storytelling, games, traditional music and song, local festivals, local guiding and agrotourism. Develop educational and interpretation material in support of these activities. 79
Provide information about donors who may support community-based tourism, capacity building, and conservation initiatives. 4. Capacity Building: Provide skills in financial management, procurement and accountability in cases where community members are in control of funds (MoLG, 2003a). 5. Capacity Building: Ensure that realistic plans for tourism development are developed, which are implementable with available resources and budgets. Empower stakeholders with information regarding potential or available resources for tourism development, to ensure that expectations are realistic (MoLG, 2003a). 6. Capacity Building: Facilitate and support the development and operation of locally owned and run SMMEs that are both directly related to tourism (e.g. accommodation, guiding) and also those which support the tourism industry (e.g. transportation, internet, laundry services, micro-finance). 7. Capacity Building: Assist new and emerging businesses in addressing gaps in the market rather than overcapitalising on existing strengths, to promote commercially viable development across the district. 8. Capacity Building: Provide training to build local capacity by developing a pool of district and local facilitators who understand tourism development, to enhance community acceptance and ownership of the training and planning. This ensures that once the external experts withdraw, local expertise remains within the district. (MoLG, 2003a).9 9. Capacity Building: Consider establishing a local association accessible by all interested members of the community, and especially marginalized members of society, to provide a mechanism for information about tourism to be reviewed and for local concerns to be addressed (e.g. quality, access, marketing, social impacts etc.). 10. Capacity Building: Provide visitors and staff with information that helps them to reduce their impact on the environment: consider their activities in hotels and transportation in addition to natural and protected areas, environmentally sensitive souvenirs, and perhaps design and distribute a pamphlet for their reference. 11. Marketing: Develop organised tours and menus of attractions on routes on which tourists can be guided by their hosts, meet local people, learn about local culture and natural heritage, and buy fairly traded local produce. 12. Marketing: Expand the use the internet to cooperatively market Kabaroles tourism attractions. 13. Impact assessment: Obtain information regarding options for economic participation in the tourism industry that creates the best deal for the people of Kabarole: consider joint ventures with the private sector, community based tourism enterprises, and privately owned businesses with equitable contracts that are independently negotiated.
Training needs may include; project planning and management; leadership training skills, gender and empowerment, business/tourism/crafts skills, community and resource mobilisation, financial management, procurement and accountability, documentation/communication, and lobbying, networking and advocacy. 80
14. Environment: Consider offering indigenous tree-replanting schemes in locally de-forested areas as mechanisms for tourists to absorb the carbon dioxide emissions produced during their flights and vehicle travel. Box 6 lists a number of reports/books by international agencies that provide best practice information on sustainable tourism development. Box 6: Sources of best practice information on tourism development
A. Books and reports Ashley, C., Roe, D. and Goodwin, H. (2001) Pro-poor tourism strategies: Making tourism work for the poor: A review of experience, Pro-poor tourism report No. 1, ODI/IIED/CRT, April 2001 Basche, C. (1999) Being green is your business: An easy guide to environmental action for tour operators, travel agents and tour wholesalers, Tourism Council Australia and Commonwealth of Australia CSIR (2000) Guidelines for human settlement planning and design, CSIR Building and Construction Technology, Pretoria Global Reporting Initiative (2002) Sustainability reporting guidelines, Global Reporting Initiative Husler, N. and Strasdus, W. (2003) Training manual for community-based tourism, InWent, Addendum to The ecotourism training manual for protected area managers DSE-ZEL Zschortau, DSE DOKU 1956 Mehta, H, Baez,A and OLoughlin P. (2002) International Ecolodge Guidelines, The International Ecotourism Society, Washington DC Murray, R. (2002) The Zero Waste Plan, Greenpeace Environmental Trust. Pam Wight & Associates (1999) Catalogue of Exemplary Practices in Adventure Travel and Ecotourism, Canadian Tourism Commission Spenceley, A., Relly, P., Keyser, H., Warmeant, P., McKenzie, M., Mataboge, A., Norton, P., Mahlangu, S., and Seif, J. (2002) Responsible Tourism Manual for South Africa, Department for Environmental Affairs and Tourism, July 2002 Strasdas, W. (2002) The ecotourism training manual for protected area managers, DSE-ZEL Zschortau, DSE DOKU 1956 Sweeting, J. E. N. and Sweeting, A. R. (2003) A practical guide to good practice: Managing Environmental and Social issues in the accommodation sector, The Centre for Environmental Leadership in Business, Tour Operators Initiative for Sustainable Tourism Development Sweeting, J. E. N., Bruner, A. G. and Rosenfeld, A. B. (1999) The Green Host Effect: A integrated approach to sustainable tourism and resort development, Conservation International Talacko, J. and Andrews, G. (1998) Being green keeps you out of the red: An easy guide to environmental action for accommodation providers and tourist attractions, Tourism Council Australia and CRC Tourism Tourism Queensland (1999) Grow your ecotourism business: a support kit for operators. B. Websites Canada Tourism Commission www.canadatourism.com Conservation International www.conservation.org CSIR www.csir.co.za Global Reporting Initiative www.globalreporting.org Ecolodges www.eco-mon.com International Ecotourism Society www.ecotourism.org Pro-poor tourism www.pro-poortourism.org.uk Responsible tourism www.icrtourism.org.uk; www.nri.org/NRET/nret.htm Rocky Mountain Institute www.rmi.org Tourism Council Australia www.tourism.org.au Vehicle Certification Agency www.vca.gov.uk/fcb.htm
81
8.9
Table 10: Options for community involvement in tourism Type of Nature of local involvement Examples enterprise/institution Kitchen staff in a lodge Private business run Employment Supply of goods and services Sale of food, building materials, etc. by outsiders
Enterprise or informal sector operation run by local individuals Community enterprise Joint venture between community and private operator Enterprise ownership Self-employment Supply of goods and services Collective ownership Collective or individual management Supply of goods and services Employment or contributed labour Contractual commitments or shared ownership Share in revenue Lease/investment of resources Participation in decisionmaking Craft sales, food kiosk, campsite, home stays Guiding services Hawking, sale of fuel wood, food Community campsite Craft centre Cultural centre Guesthouse
Revenue-sharing from lodge and/or tour operation to local community on agreed terms Community leases land/resources/concession to lodge/tour operation Community holds equity in lodge/tour operation
Within a Training manual for community-based tourism developed by the German development agency, InWent, a series of steps are suggested that communities, groups and individuals could use to help establish CBT enterprises. These are outlined in Box 7. Box 7: Steps for the establishment of community based tourism
a. Set up a community meeting to launch the idea of community-based tourism in your area b. Identify current involvement of the community and region in tourism and compare it with other existing economic sectors c. Present the potential positive and negative changes in the community due to tourism. d. If the community is still interested in CBT, go to the next step e. Initiate a community structure to participate in the tourism venture f. Identify person(s) in structure to drive the process (formal and informal key stakeholders and groups, e.g. youth group, womens group, handicraft group) g. Identify what support is required for your tourism venture h. Identify appropriate support agencies/individuals
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 82
i. j. k. l. m. n. o. p. q. r. s. t.
u. v. w. x. y. z.
Assess your local attractions; incorporate what the community holds important (beliefs, values, sense of place, tourism resources, etc.) Prioritise your attractions and your capacities by performing a SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats) analysis Decide on the type of tourism you feel will suit your area Conduct a market analysis (current and potential tourist demand, activities desired) Conduct a competitor analysis (identify competing destinations, assess their strengths and weaknesses, market shares, identify competitive advantages for your destination) "Basic decision: Does CBT appear to be feasible and desirable in your area? Should it be pursued? If so, go to the next step Prepare a draft work plan for tourism development (including a map and seasonal calendar) Check that the draft plan meets legal, environmental and other requirements Obtain broad community support for the draft plan Prepare a detailed business plan for tourism development including detailed plans for each of the elements of the plan partners. Conclude agreements with any outside parties government and regulatory bodies and possible joint venture partners Conduct several training sessions with interested members of the community: Service: Homestay (accommodation, toilet facilities), food supply, transportation Handling visitors, customer care and hospitality skills Product development issues, including nature and cultural programme Income distribution and rotation system Handicrafts First aid Management skills, legal issues and financial control Marketing and communication (in cooperation with tourist boards and/or tourism companies) Basic language training Special training sessions for local guides Election of a community tourism committee Launch a marketing campaign in cooperation with tourism enterprises and/or tourism board Run 2-3 pilot tours with associated friends and relatives of stakeholders including an evaluation of pilot tours and, if necessary, changes in the program or goal Arrival of first tourists groups Carry out regular monitoring and evaluation of CBT If successfully implemented, phase-out of outside consultants and supporters, like NGOs and donor organisations
83
RECOMMENDATIONS
Training strategies:
Tourism training should be market led with private sector ownership, regulated by public institutions. Training for specific activities and programmes should be selffinancing. General support should be obtained from the private sector through a proposed tourism and training levy. Institutional training should focus on training needs. Proper curricula and close links with the tourism sector should be developed. Tailor-made training courses should be provided for tour guides, tourism community staff, specialised guides and local district staff to work with tourism. Training should focus on the need for manpower required for development of niche markets. In-house training and train-the-trainer programmes should be provided to improve the level of staff capabilities. Stricter licensing of training institutions should be introduced to ensure the training quality level. The Hotel and Tourism Training Institute in Jinja should be operated closely linked to the private sector in order to improve the Institutes financial status. The quality of the training should be improved through introduction of a certification, diploma and accreditation system
84
The press should be provided with information about tourism and media (newspapers, radio and television) should be provided with information to establish a wide public coverage on the national as well as the local level of tourism. Exchange visits for district tourism officials. Training in tourism planning (e.g. controlling development). Information on insurance/liabilities. Fire safety information. Linkages and concession agreements through with UWA to promote community involvement (e.g. concessions at Bwindi). Planning guidelines for reviewing submissions: local employment/ procurement/ employment for public and private sector, and NGOs. Coordination of informal sector: avoid hawkers. How to deal with security problems when they occur: quickly, media etc, resolve rapidly and restore confidence. Tourism information Centre should be widely provided at major accommodation facilities as well as at strategic entry and tourist points e.g. Entebbe airport, UTB etc.
85
10
REFERENCES
Africa Regional Office (ARO) (2002) Protected Areas Management and Sustainable Use Project, Project Appraisal Document, Africa Regional Office, AFTES Atukunda, A. and Nuwe, J. B. (2002) Queen Elizabeth Protected Area, Uganda, pp 89-96 in Carabias, J., de la Maza, J., and Cadenda, R. (eds) Capacity needs to manage protected areas: Africa, The Nature Conservancy, USA BCA 2004. Bakonzo Cultural Association Concept Paper. BCA. Beltran, J. (ed) (2000) Indigenous and Traditional Peoples and PAs: Principles, guidelines and case studies, WCPA and IUCN, Gland, p7-8, cited in Drumm, A., and Moore, A. (2002) Ecotourism development: A manual for conservation planners and managers, Volume 1: An introduction to ecotourism planning, @Nature conservancy, Arlingon, Virginia, USA Blomley, T., Franks, P., and Kabugenda, A. (2000) Biodiversity Conservation within the Context of Decentralised Governance: Towards Institutional Landscapes? The case of Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda, cited in UWA (2000?) op. cit. Briggs, P. 2003. Uganda The Bradt Travel Guide. Butler, R. W. 1993. Tourism an evolutionary perspective, In Nelson, J. G., Butler, R., and Wall G. (eds.) Tourism and sustainable development: piloting, planning, managing, Department of Geography Publication Series No. 37, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, 27-43. Bunyoro-Kitara Kingdom Website http://www.bunyoro-kitara.com/empire.htm Carnegie, J., Abbot, J., and Goldman, I. (2001) Manual for parish development planning, Draft 1, September, Khanya Clarke, J. 1997. A framework of approaches to sustainable tourism, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 5 (3), 224-233. CPPP (2002) Community Public Private Partnership Tourism Strategic Document Cunningham, A.B. 1996. People Plants and Plant Use: Recommendations for Multiple-use Zones around and Development Alternatives around Bwindi Impenetrable National Park. People and Plants Working paper 4, UNESCO, Paris. Dalal-Clayton, B. and Bass, S. (2002) Sustainable Development Strategies: A resource book, Earthscan Publications Ltd, London Daxbacher, L. (2004). The Poverty and Social Impact Analysis (PSIA) Pilot Study in Uganda. A report for DFID. Department of Environment (DoE) (1991) Kasese District Environmental Action Plan, 2002-2004, Kasese District Local Government Elkington, J. 1997. Cannibals with Forks: The Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business, Oxford: Capstone Publishing Ltd. Frangialli, F. 2001. World Tourism organization perspectives on the International Year of Ecotourism, Industry and environment, UNEP, 24 (3-4), July-December, 4
Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 86
Goodwin, H. and Francis, J. 2003. Ethical and responsible tourism: Consumer trends in the UK, Journal of Vacation Marketing, 9 (3), 271284. Husler, N. and Strasdus, W. (2003) Training manual for community-based tourism, InWent, Addendum to The ecotourism training manual for protected area managers DSE-ZEL Zschortau, DSE DOKU 1956 Kamugisha, J.R., Ogutu, Z.A., and Stahl, M. (1997) Parks and People - Conservation and Livelihoods at Crossroads: Four Case Histories, Regional Soil Conservation Unit (RSCU), Swedish International Development Co-operation Agency (SIDA) Nairobi, Kenya, cited in UWA (2000?) op. cit Kasese District Local Government (KDLG) (2002) Kasese District Environmental Action Plan (20022005), The Republic of Uganda Kanongo, M. (1990) Draft Report of baseline data, report for CARE-Development Through Conservation (DTC) Project. Phase 1, Dec. 1989-Feb. 1990. DTC Project, Ikumba, Uganda, cited in UWA (2000?) op. cit. Kibale National Park General Management Plan, 2003-2013, Uganda Wildlife Authority, July 2003 Mapesa, M. and Makombo, J. (2002) Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda, pp 7787 in Carabias, J., de la Maza, J., and Cadenda, R. (eds) Capacity needs to manage protected areas: Africa, The Nature Conservancy, USA Mehta, H, Baez, A and OLoughlin P. (2002) International Ecolodge Guidelines, The International Ecotourism Society, Washington DC Mentor Consult (2001) Synthesis report on community based planning projects in Uganda, MoLGLGDP, Ministry of Agriculture Animal Industries and Fisheries PMA, CARE International Ministry of Tourism, Trade and Industry (MTTI) (2003) Tourism policy for Uganda, The Republic of Uganda Ministry of Local Government (MoLG) (2002) Guide to participatory planning for lower local councils, Republic of Uganda Ministry of Local Government (MoLG) (2003a) Community based planning in Uganda: Final report of the community based planning project, The Republic of Uganda Ministry of Local Government (MoLG) (2003b) Harmonised participatory planning guide for parishes/wards, Republic of Uganda Moyini, Y. and Uwimbabazi, B. (2000) Analysis of the Economic Significance of Gorilla Tourism in Uganda, Final Draft, Environmental Monitoring Associates (EMA) Ltd report to IGCP, June 2000 MTTI. 2004. Uganda Tourism Bill, 2004. Ministry of Tourism Trade and Industry. MTWA. 1997. Final Report of the Ministrial Appointed Concessions Review Committee. Submitted to the Ministry of Tourism, Wildlife and Antiquities, Kampala, Uganda. MWTA. 1997. Recommended Actions for Individual Concessions: Report of the Ministerial Appointed Concessions Review Committee, December. Submitted to the Ministry of Tourism, Wildlife and Antiquities, Kampala, Uganda.
87
Queen Elizabeth National Park, Kyambura Wildlife Reserve, Kigezi Wildlife Reserve General Management Plan, Uganda Wildlife Authority September 2000 Rwagweri A. 2003. Tooro and Her Poples: Past, Present and Future Rwenzori Mountains National Park, World Heritage Site, General Management Plan, 2004-2014. Uganda Wildlife Authority Spenceley, A. (2003) Tourism, Local Livelihoods and the Private Sector in South Africa: Case studies on the growing role of the private sector in natural resources management, Sustainable Livelihoods in South Africa Research Paper 8, Sustainable Livelihoods Southern Africa project, Institute of Development Studies, Brighton UK, Available at www.ids.ac.uk/env/slsa/index.html Spenceley, A. (2003b) Managing sustainable nature-based tourism in savannah Africa: a practical assessment tool, Unpublished doctoral thesis, University for Greenwich, UK, November 2003 Stacey, T. (2003) Tribe. Stacey International Strasdas, W. (2002) The ecotourism training manual for protected area managers, DSE-ZEL Zschortau, DSE DOKU 1956 Taylor, D. 1990. Late quaternary pollen diagrams from two Ugandan mires: evidence for environmental change in the Rukiga highlands of south west Uganda. Paleogeography, paleoclimatology, paleoecology, 80 pp 283-300. The Story of Africa. http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/africa/features/storyofafrica/2generic1.shtml Toro Kingdom Website 2005. http://www.torokingdom.org
World Travel and Tourism Council (WTTC) (2003) Country League Tables: The 2003 Travel & Tourism Economic Research, WTTC Young, E. B. (2000) Queen Elizabeth National Park, Khambura Wildlife Reserve, Kigezi Wildlife Reserve, General Management Plan, Uganda Wildlife Authority, September 2000 Zaninka, P. (2001) The impact of (forest) nature conservation on indigenous peoples: the Batwa of south-western Uganda, in Nelson, J., and Hossack, L. (eds) (2003) Indigenous peoples and protected areas in Africa: From principles to practice, Forest Peoples Programme, UK.
89
Appendices
APPENDIX 1: TERMS OF REFERENCE
DRAFT TERMS OF REFERENCE KABAROLE DISTRICT TOURISM DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Identification of tourism circuits within the district based on the existing and potential attractions; Identification of tourism circuits that will feed into regional tourism development (namely with DR Congo) Product (Facility and activities) development for tourism in the district to enhance tourist experience, diversification and product connectivity; Identify Stakeholders that maximize benefits to the district through a proposed tourism development plan; Develop a work schedule for implementing agreed activities including specification of the staging of development of identified tourism sites taking into
90
consideration the need for integrated development of tourist attractions, activities, services, transportation and other infrastructural development within each area. Establish guidelines that will promote the development of community enterprises related to tourism; Establish planning and management guidelines for environmental, business and socio-cultural management and involvement; Establish guidelines for the type of facilities and services needed, taking into account carrying capacity, protection of the environment and planned infrastructural development. Identify and recommend policy issues for the district especially in relation to zoning for tourism development;
3.1.1 Contextual Analysis Policy contextual review: Evaluate the government objectives, policies and plans for the country and regional rural development levels for tourism development in the District. Due to the regional nature of some of the protected areas that have major tourism attractions (e.g. mountain gorillas, volcanoes), the team is expected to incorporate regional issues in the development of the plan and to this end the regional context should also be analysed. Macro and Micro-environmental survey for tourism in the District: Undertake an analysis of the environmental, historical, economic, social, political, resource and land-use characteristics. 3.1.2 Document Review: The Planning Team will review all documents relevant to the District tourism including,
The New Tourism Policy; District Development Plan; Integrated Tourism Master Plan for Uganda; Uganda Sustainable Tourism Programme Documents; Any other relevant documents.
PHASE 2:
This phase will be initiated by introducing the Planning Team to District Officials and Stakeholders. 3.2.1 Tourism Assets Audit for the District Inventory of current and potential tourist attractions and activities; Inventory of existing and planned tourist accommodation; Inventory of the transport and communication infrastructure for tourism development; Human Resource requirements.
3.2.3 Methodology Field Trip Consultation with stakeholders Consultation with UGSTDP Stakeholders Workshop at the end of the trip Key informant/Focal group interviews Presentations
3.2.4 Specific Outputs List of tourism attractions, resources in the District; Inventory of tourism infrastructure in the District; List of tourism products (activities, facilities and services); Institutional profiles of key stakeholders for tourism development in the District. Preliminary plan development: products, circuits, strategies etc. PHASE 3: FINALISATION OF DEVELOPMENT PLAN
3.3.1 Development plan finalization Draft tourism development plan: collate the findings of the field survey preparation phase and the consultants suggestions into a draft tourism development plan; Review of the development plan: Stakeholders consultations to review draft tourism development plan (2 day workshop); Presentation of final plan.
Workshop (2 day with stakeholders); Distributed for comment; Presentations to key stakeholders including: District and local community representatives.
3.3.3 Specific Output Final Tourism Development Plan for the District. 4.1 Proposal
Prior to the commencement of the study the Planning Team will submit a proposal detailing: 4.2 Methodology; Sample constitution and size; Survey structure; Time frame; Resources required; Expertise required
The planning team will consist of the following skill mix: 4.3 Tourism Development Planner; Eco-tourism Specialist; Community Tourism Specialist; Infrastructure Planner; District Planner Transboundary protected area management Consultation:
The Planning Team will meet with key stakeholders Individuals and agencies to contact include but are not limited to the following; Ministry of Tourism, Trade and Industry; Uganda Sustainable Tourism Development Programme(EU-Tourism Project); Uganda Wildlife Authority: Tourism and Community Conservation program head, Bwindi National Park); Hoteliers; Tourism Promotion Services: Uganda Tourist Board; Tour Operators; Private Sector groups; Donors: World Bank (PAMSU), EC-BCP, USAID; NGOs; District, local communities, local government; Security agencies.
93
ORGANISATION
James Finlays (U) Ltd. Crater Valley Resort Semliki Safari Lodge Min of Tourism, Trade & Industry PAMSU Project, Min of Tourism PAMSU Project, Min of Tourism UGSTDP/MTTI SATNET Kabarole Kabarole District Engabo za Tooro Fisheries Dept Kabarole Kabarole District Local Govt Kabarole Tourism Ass. Tooro Botanical Gardens Kabarole Research Centre Kabarole (KTA) KDLG Tooro Kingdom Forest Dept Kabarole Local Govt Kabarole Local Govt Kabarole Local Govt KDA Kabarole District Private Sector consulting KTA KDLG IGCP and AWF Consultant EDSA
94
95
96
Indicative Roles
Attend community meetings to discuss/identify problems/needs of the area and available resources Contribute locally available materials and labour towards the community projects Provide basic operation and maintenance costs Mobilise community members for planning meetings Oversee implementation of village council decisions Monitor project implementation (site monitoring) and report to village council Providing site security On the spot monitoring of project implementation Verifying contractors works before payment by sub-county Mobilising community contribution for project implementation Organising community operation, management and maintenance Collection of user fees
Project Management Committee (eg Water Source Committee. They are supposed to be composed of representatives of users, LC Executives, disadvantaged groups, and women.
Under the LGDP modality, the Parishes are supposed to receive Indicative Planning Figures to guide their prioritization process. They are also encouraged to plan for investments they will implement using local resources. 11 It should be noted that whereas the Parish Chiefs have the responsibility and potential to perform broader functions in regard to planning, project implementation, monitoring and management, till to-date they have not been oriented and equipped with the skills to perform this function and are still focusing on their conventional function of Graduated Tax collection which is even in a number of cases not forthcoming. Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 97
10
C. Implementation structures in Lower Local Governments The Lower Local Governments include Sub-counties/Divisions and Town Councils. Key Actor
Sub-county/Division and Town Council
Sub-county Committee
Executive
Sectoral Committees (The sectoral committee work closely with the TPCs and report to council through the Executive Committee)
Technical Planning Committee (TPCs are composed of the Sub-county chief/Town Clerk, Subaccountant/Town Treasurer and all extension staff in the Subcounty/Town Council) Investment Committee12
The IC is a sub-committee of council but with co-opted membership of varying and relevant expertise. Ideally the IC consists of the following representation. Council representatives, Relevant retired civil servants, Representatives of disadvantaged groups (e.g. women, youth, the disabled), Community representatives, Personnel from relevant technical departments in the sub-county and district Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 98
12
Indicative Roles
Planning authority in the district. Its major role is soliciting of actual planning ideas and feeding them to the Planning Unit and approval of investment projects, plans and budgets Formulate three year development plan for the district Incorporate plans of lower LGs Forward plans to Ministry of Local Government Oversee the implementation of council decisions Monitor and supervise projects and other activities undertaken in the local government, NGOs and other development players Prepare sector plans (like health, education and water etc.) and submit to council for consideration Foster co-ordination and collaboration in implementation of sector activities in the district (including the activities of NGOs and CBOs) Monitor and assess the progress of implementation of sector activities in the district Submit routine and periodic reports to council Advise council regarding preparation of plans and budgets Appraises individual investment projects before presentation to council Co-ordinate implementation of the district projects on behalf of council Certifies investment projects Mentor Lower LGs Authorise procurement of councils requirements Award contracts for works, goods and services Maintain a pre-qualified list of contractors and suppliers Maintain a list of contracts awarded and a blacklist of poor contract performers Advise accounting officers on tendering procedures Ratifies below-the-threshold procurements
99
1. Kigere/Balama
2. Kasindikwa 3. Kaitabarogo 4. Wabikere 5. Hamugoma 6. Saaka 7. Mwegenywa 8. Ntanda 9. Nyinabulitwa 10. Nyamirima 11.Nyabikere 12.Kanyamukale 13.Kitere 14.Njarayabaana 15.Mubiro 16.Nyamugoro
Shamans Lake
Mubuhara zone, Bwanika parish, Kichwamba sub county As above, near Muhoti barracks Do (behind Muhoti Barracks) As in one above Kichwamba s/c Kicwamba s/c, Bwanika parish Buheesi s/c, Nyamiseke parish, Nyamiseke zone As above Ruteete s/c Do (Nyamirima zone) Do Rwimi s/c, Kaina parish, Kaina zone Rwimi s/c, Kadindimo parish, Kajumiro A zone Rwimi s/c Kaina parish, Kaina zone As above Kibito s/c, Mujunju parish, Nyamugoro zone
250,000m
40,000m Not established 200,000m 500,000m 800,000m 250,000m 300,000m 300,000m 150,000m 400,000m 150,000m 200,000m 100,000m 100,000m 100,000m
17.Kaisamukoma
Do
50,000m
18.Nyamugasani 19.Nyamiteza
Kings Lake
Graves
Rwimi s/c, Kaina parish, Kaina zone Kibiito s/c, Mujunju parish, Kyatwa zone
200,000m 100,000m
20.Ntambi 21.Kyanga 22.Rwankenzi 23.Rwandakarra 24.Nzigamire 25.Marusi 26.Budallah Kabarole District Tourism Development Plan 100
Rwimi s/c, Kaina parish, Kagoro zone As above but Kaina zone Ruteete s/c, Kasenda parish, Nsongya zone Ruteete s/c, Nyabweya parish, Kibuga zone As above but Kibwera zone Do Ruteete s/c, Nyabweya parish, Nyabweya zone
27.Rwenjubu 28.Ndikya 29.Kanyango 30.Mwamba 31.Rugembe 32.Nyinambuga 33.Kifurukwa 34.Bwabya 35.Bukoni 36.Lyantonde 37.Nyahirya 38.Kanyanswiga 39.Nkuruba 40.Rukwanzi 41.Mbajo 42.Mahuhura 43.Kasenda 44.Kyerere 45.Kanyamasirra 46.Kesibenda 47.Kamiramacu mu 48.Kiribwato 49.Aballah
Ruteete s/c, Kasenda parish, Kikeeri zone Do Do Ruteete s/c, Mukimya zone, Kasenda parish Do but Rugembe zone Ruteete s/c, Kasenda parish, Do Busoro S/c Do Ruteete Do Do Do Do Do Do Do Do Do Do Do Do Do
000m 160,000m 60,000m 100,000m 180,000m 250,000m 150,000m 100,000m 80,000m 150,000m 120,000m 100,000m 100,000m 130,000m 100,000m 150,000m 150,000m 80,000m 120,000m 90,000m 150,000m 160,000m
Lake of Beads
Lake of Slopes
Addresses for correspondence: Hitesh Mehta c/o EDSA 1512 E. Broward Blvd. Suite 110 Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301 USA Tel: +1 954 524 3330 Fax: +1 954 524 0177 Rob Wild P.O. Box. 872, Providenciales, Turks and Caicos Islands British West Indies Tel/Fax: +1-649-941-4641