1

ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-1

Alternative Linear Motion Systems
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design
Topic 5
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-2
Iron Core Linear Motors
Provide actuation forces from
30 N (7 lbf) continuous to over
11,000 N (2,500 lbf) peak
Two-part construction features
a 3-phase laminated coil and a
single sided magnet track
consisting of rare-earth
magnets mounted on a rigid
steel base plate
These linear motors deliver
excellent performance in rapid
point-to-point positioning
applications while virtually
eliminating the efficiency-
robbing effects of friction,
inertia, backlash and wear
associated with rotary-to-linear
drive mechanisms
Source: Anorad
2
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-3
Iron Less Linear Motors
Provide actuation forces from 8
N (2 lbf) continuous to nearly
2,000 N (450 lbf) peak
Their two-piece assembly
features a 3-phase ironless coil
and a balanced dual-sided U
shaped magnet channel
Their ironless coil design
eliminates cogging (magnetic
dtente) and makes them the
optimal choice for extremely
consistent velocity control in
scanning-type applications and
allows them to achieve the
highest levels of positioning
accuracy, repeatability and
resolution
Source: Anorad
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-4
Linear Motors
Pros
Direct drive minimizes the number of parts
Velocity and acceleration not limited by the actuator
Ranging from less than 1m/s to more than 10m/s
Unlimited travel
Smoothness of motion
Accuracy and resolution is not limited by the actuator
Zero wear
Very simple installation
Very clean operation
Cons
Optimal transmission ratio is not achieved
High currents, large thermal loads
Some motors create high attractive forces (10x the thrust force)
Vertical axes require safety breaks and/or counter balances
Much more expensive components ($10/lbf thrust vs. $2/lbf for a ball
screw system).
Not self-locking, therefore needs constant servo control
3
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-5
Typical Application
Source: Anorad
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-6
Brushless DC Linear Motor
Never a problem with an unused portion's brush
surfaces corroding
Good power density
Non-contact generation of force
Closed loop control provides resolution limited only by
sensor and electronics
Ironless-core design has flux crossing gap that is
intersected by windings
No attractive force to load bearings
Requires a sandwiched design
4
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-7
Brushless DC Linear Motor (contd.)
The DC brush linear motor is ideal for long stroke, open or closed loop
servo, linear motion applications with speeds from 1 in/s [25 mm/s] to 100
in/s [2.5 m/s]
The motor is commutated using brushes on the moving permanent magnet
secondary in conjunction with a stationary commutator bar on the coil
assembly. This results in only the coils directly beneath the secondary with
current flowing in them.
The short moving brush assembly
is magnetically attracted to the
long stationary laminated coil
assembly. A customer supplied
bearing system is required to
guide the moving secondary and
to maintain a .025" [0.63mm] gap
between the secondary and the
coil assembly.
Source: H2W Technologies
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-8
Mountings
Linear motor moving coil mounted to the underside of an air bearing
carriage that rides on a simply supported rail:
Linear motor moving coil mounted to the side of an air bearing
carriage that rides on a T-shaped rail that is fully supported along its
length
Warning: Motor force is
not aligned with center of
friction and center of
mass. Moments will occur
as a result, resulting in
rotation of the slide.
Source: Alexander Slocum, Precision Machine Design
5
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-9
Mountings (contd.)
Linear motor moving coil mounted to the sides of an air bearing
carriage that rides on a T-shaped rail that is fully supported along its
length
Linear motor moving coil mounted to the inside of an air bearing
carriage that rides on a T-shaped rail that is fully supported along its
length
Source: Alexander Slocum, Precision Machine Design
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-10
Voice Coils
Ideal for short strokes
No phase switching circuitry required
Can be used to drive fast tool servos (e.g., for piston turning
machines)
Source: Alexander Slocum, Precision Machine Design
6
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-11
Voice Coils (contd.)
Typical configurations:
Source: H2W Technologies
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-12
Types of Linear Motors
0 1 2 - Ironless core
Brushless DC motors
5-10 x F
a
1 Stepping motors
510 x F
a
1 2 - Iron core
2
Rare earth
0 1 Voice coils
AlNiCo
Attractive
force
Axial force F
a
Types
Source: Alexander Slocum, Precision Machine Design
7
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-13
Piezoelectric Actuators
Sub-nanometer resolution
Large force generation (>
10,000 N)
Sub-millisecond response
No backlash, stiction or friction
No magnetic fields
Extremely low steady-state
power consumption
No wear and tear
Vacuum and clean room
compatibility
Operation at cryogenic
temperatures
Variety of stacked PZT
translators with typical
displacement ranges of 5 to
200 m
Source: Physikinstrumente
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-14
PZT Principle
PZT are made from a
ceramic material
(crystal) that changes
dimensions when a
voltage is applied
x
y
z
y+
y-
x-
x+
8
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-15
But
Hysteresis
High actuation voltage >100 V
Aging
Aging refers to reduced piezo
gain, among other things as a
result of the de-poling process
Aging can be an issue for
sensor or charge-generation
applications (direct piezo
effect), but with actuator
applications it is negligible
because re-poling occurs every
time a higher electric field is
applied to the actuator material
in the poling direction
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-16
Piezo Linear Motor (Nanomotion)
The Piezoelectric effect in piezo ceramics converts electrical field to
mechanical strain
Under special electrical excitation drive and ceramic geometry of
Nanomotion motors, longitudinal extension and transverse bending
oscillation modes are excited at close frequency proximity
The simultaneous excitation of the longitudinal extension mode and the
transverse bending mode creates a small elliptical trajectory of the ceramic
edge, thus achieving the dual mode standing wave motor
Source: Nanomotion
9
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-17
Piezo Linear Motor (Nanomotion)
Source: Nanomotion
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-18
Piezo Linear Motor (Nanomotion)
The periodic nature of the driving force at frequencies much higher than the
mechanical resonance of the stage and allows continuous smooth motion
for unlimited travel, while maintaining high resolution and positioning
accuracy typical of piezoelectric devices
While the driving voltage is not applied, the ceramic plate is stationary and
generates holding torque on the stage
Holding torque of the Nanomotion motor does not cause any position shift
Source: Nanomotion
Friction strip Motor
By coupling the ceramic
edge to a precision stage, a
resultant driving force is
exerted on the stage,
causing stage movement
Travel can be linear or
rotary, depending on the
coupling mechanism
10
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-19
Piezo Linear Motor (EDO Ceramics)
The piezoelectric motor operates using solid state piezoelectric ceramic
crystals
The piezoelectric effect exhibited by the ceramic crystals causes the ceramic
to expand and contract as an electric field is applied across the polarized
electrodes of the crystal
The expansion and contraction under an alternating electric field causes a
controlled, sinusoidal vibration
This vibration drives the friction shoe that is coupled to flat friction strips,
through friction, providing well controlled linear motion for the motor
Each vibration cycle produces a
small step, as small as a few
nanometers
The accumulation of these steps
at a rate of 130,000 steps per
second allows the motor to travel
at speeds of up to 12 inches per
second with a blocked force of up
to 0.4 pounds
Source: EDO Ceramics
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-20
Flexure Head Video
11
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-21
Schematic of Servo Loop
Source: EDO Ceramics
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-22
Piezo Linear Motor (EDO Ceramics)
Source: EDO Ceramics
12
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-23
Stepping Motors
Simple design
Modest efficiency
High attractive force requires robust bearings
Microstepping can be used
Closed loop servo mode, good to sensor resolution
Current sequence in a Sawyer motor to produce linear motion:
Source: Alexander Slocum, Precision Machine Design
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-24
Sawyer Motor
A two axis Sawyer motor (platen and air bearing to support the
motor not shown).
Multiple forcers are used to control yaw.
Source: Alexander Slocum, Precision Machine Design
13
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-25
Sawyer Motor
Moving Forcer Assembly:
The forcer is made up of an
aluminum housing that contains
the motor windings, lamination
stacks, and permanent magnets
The active surface of the
lamination is slotted to form teeth
with a pitch of .040" [1 mm]
The forcer comes in different
widths and lengths, depending on
the required force
Multiple forcers can be supplied with a single platen to allow for
independent moving heads
Platen:
The platen is a precision ground steel plate that is slotted to form 0.02x
0.02[0.50x 0.50 mm] square teeth on the surface
The spaces between the platen teeth are filled with epoxy to provide a flat
air-bearing surface for the forcer
The stroke of the forcer is a function of the length and width of the platen
Source: H2W Technologies
Moving Forcer
Platen
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-26
Sawyer Motor (contd.)
Dual Axis Linear Stepper Motors are ideal for open loop positioning
applications with light payloads
Speeds up to 80 in/s [2 m/s] and strokes up to 40x 60[1 m x 1.5
m]
Linear stepper motors are capable of very precise position, velocity
and acceleration control when coupled with a microstepping drive
and indexer
The moving assembly called the forceris supported by
magnetically preloaded air-bearings imbedded in the active surface
of the forcer between the forcer and platen
The bearings support the payload and maintain the required .001
[0.025 mm] gap between the platen and the forcer
The motion achieved with a full step is .010[250 microns] and with
a microstep its .00004[1 micron]
Integrating a linear encoder with the stepper motor provides a
closed loop system
Source: H2W Technologies
14
ME EN 7960 Precision Machine Design Alternative Linear Motion Systems 5-27
Sawyer Motor - Advantages
Low profile and small cross section
High speed
Low cost positioning stage solution
No servo tuning required
Multiple forcers on a single platen
Source: H2W Technologies