Whitter Field EOR
Whitter Field EOR
Whitter Field EOR
GEOLOGICAL
SURVEY
PROFESSIONAL
PAPER
679
GEOLOGICAL
SURVEY
PROFESSIONAL
PAPER
679
FOREWORD
Southern California is rich in petroleum and natural gas accumulations
both on land and offshore. Over the past century, California has produced
more than 8 billion barrels of oil and more than 23 trillion cubic feet of gas.
The petroleum industry is one of the major economic factors of the State and
involves a capital investment in excess of $7 billion and employs more than
100,000 people. Daily production of petroleum measures in excess of 1 million
barrels of oil, which is about 65 percent of the requirements for the region.
The situation is one of current shortage of production and projected increase
in need. As a natural extension of development of State tidelands, which
began in earnest in 1958, a public sale of Federal wildcat leases in 1968 drew
a surprisingly large total of $603 million.
During normal development of a prospective petroleum-bearing oil pool
on the Rincon structural trend, about 6^ miles southeast of Santa Barbara,
a gas blowout occurred on January 28,1969, during completion of the fifth
well being drilled from Platform A on Federal Tract OCS P-0241. Until
February 7, when the well was killed by cementing, uncontrolled flow led
to local oil pollution on the sea surface. Reservoir,damage during this
period caused a subsequent moderate and steady oil seepage from the
sea floor that has since caused a continual slick on the surface. This seepage,
estimated to be at a daily average rate of 30 barrels in the 4-month period
March through June 1969, was substantially reduced by early September to
less than 10 barrels per day as a result of a drilling and grouting program
authorized by the Secretary of the Interior following recommendations of a
special Presidential Advisory Panel.
The Santa Barbara incident was the first significant oil-pollution experience resulting from drilling or working 7,860 wells under Federal jurisdiction
on the Outer Continental Shelf since 1953. In consequence of this event, by
direction of the Secretary of the Interior, Federal operating and leasing
regulations have been strengthened, and additional safeguards have been
added in all Federally supervised operations.
The purpose of this report is to present specific information that will
help provide a better understanding of the geologic framework of the Channel
region and of the circumstances relating to the oil seepage in the vicinity of
Platform A. The four chapters of this report and accompanying appendixes
have been compiled by staff members of the U.S. Geological Survey. Several
petroleum companies have permitted use of their proprietary technical data
in order to prepare a balanced and complete report. Opportunity to include
these data is gratefully acknowledged.
This report incorporates information upon which the recommendations
of the Presidential Advisory Panel were based as well as information that
subsequently has become available.
W. T. Pecora
Director, U.S. Geological Survey
CONTENTS
Foreword ___________________________________________________
(A) Geologic framework of the Santa Barbara Channel region, by J. G. Vedder, H. C.
Wagner,and J. E. Schoellhamer________________________________
(B) Petroleum development in the region of the Santa Barbara Channel, by R. F.
Yerkes, H.C. Wagner,and K. A. Yenne ___________________________
(C) Geologic characteristics of the Dos Cuadras Offshore oil field, by T. H. McCulloh _ _ _
(D) Seismicity and associated effects, Santa Barbara region, by R. M. Hamilton, R. F.
Yerkes, R. D. Brown, Jr., R. O. Burford, and J. M.DeNoyer ______________
References cited.________________________________________________
Appendix A______________-___________________________-__-_--_Appendix B_ __________________________________________________
Appendix C_ ___________________________________________________
Appendix D_____________________________________________-_____
Appendix E____________________-____________________--_----__-
PLATES
[In pocket]
Page
III
1
13
29
47
69
71
73
73
75
76
Geologic Framework
of the Santa Barbara
Channel Region
By J. G. VEDDER, H. C. WAGNER, and J. E. SCHOELLHAMER
GEOLOGY, PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT, AND SEISMICITY OF THE
SANTA BARBARA CHANNEL REGION, CALIFORNIA
GEOLOGICAL
SURVEY PROFESSIONAL
PAPER
679-A
CONTENTS
Page
Regional setting-___________________________________________
Stratigraphic summary ________________________________________
Cretaceous marine rocks _____________________________________
Paleocene and Eocene marine rocks _____________________________
Oligocene marine and nonmarine rocks ___________________________
Miocene marine rocks ______________________________________
Lower part __________________________________________
Middle part __________________________________________
Upper part_ _ ________________________________________
Miocene volcanic rocks ______________________________________
Lower and upper Pliocene marine rocks__________________________
Lower and upper Pleistocene deposits ____________________________
Holocene deposits ________________________________________
Generalized structure of the Santa Barbara Channel region._______________
Geologic history.___________________________________________
1
1
2
2
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
5
5
5
11
ILLUSTRATIONS
FIGURE 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
365-228 O - 69 - 2
2
6
8
9
10
REGIONAL SETTING
An enormous thickness of Lower and Upper Cretaceous marine sedimentary rocks lies in the San
Raf ael Mountains to the north of the Santa Ynez
Mountains, and it is possible that similar thick successions may also be widely distributed deep in the
subsurface beneath much of the Santa Barbara
Channel region. South of the Santa Ynez fault (pi. 1),
Lower Cretaceous strata crop out in the western
Santa Ynez Mountains, and fragmentary sections of
Upper Cretaceous strata are scattered along the fault
throughout its length. Middle Cretaceous rocks have
not been found in the channel region. Much of the
western part of San Miguel Island is formed by Upper
Cretaceous sedimentary rocks, and equivalent strata
have been penetrated by wells on Santa Cruz Island
and farther east on the mainland. An exploratory
well near the middle of the channel between More's
Landing on the mainland and Diablo Point on Santa
Cruz Island is reported to have bottomed in Cretaceous rocks. In general, the Upper Cretaceous sequences are composed of interlayered sandstone, silty
claystone, and small amounts of pebble and cobble
conglomerate that contain fossil faunas that range
from the Campanian Stage to the Lower Maestrichtian
Stage (Popenoe and others, 1960). On San Miguel
Island the Upper Cretaceous succession is about
10,000 feet thick (Kennett, in Redwine and others,
1952); north of the Santa Ynez fault the combined
Lower and Upper Cretaceous formations are more
than 20,000 feet thick. Jalama is the formation name
commonly applied to the Upper Cretaceous rocks and
Espada to the Lower Cretaceous rocks (Dibblee, 1950).
PALEOCENE AND EOCENE MARINE ROCKS
Variegated strata, including red beds, that disconformably overlie the Eocene succession from the
vicinity of Goleta eastward are composed chiefly of
nonmarine conglomerate, sandstone, and claystone.
These nonmarine strata are as much as 5,000 feet
thick in the Carpinteria district, but westward they
thin, tongue into, and are underlain by marine sandstone and siltstone beds that have an aggregate thickness of about 3,500 feet. The western limit of the
red-bed section is in the vicinity of Gaviota Pass.
Nonmarine beds also crop out on Santa Rosa Island
and are present in the subsurface sections in deeper
parts of onshore and offshore oil fields. East of the
area of plate 1, the nonmarine section thickens to as
much as 8,000 feet and incorporates both older and
younger rocks, so that both late Eocene and early
Miocene strata are included at the base and top. The
marine beds, which extend westward at least to the
vicinity of Point Conception, contain mollusks and
foraminifers that are assigned to the Refugian Stage
(Schenck and Kleinpell, 1936). Nonmarine beds east
of the channel region have yielded vertebrate remains
I Lithology
Formation
Feet
0- ^200,
Terrace /
deposits (N)/ 1
-r=--.
cene/
-:
z:
-^
UJ
CJ>
O_
=^~^^
Claystone and
diatomaceous
mudstone
Thin-bedded claystone
and laminated
diatomite
P=E5l
Ip*-t
Gravels
Diatomaceous siltstone
csj
Sisquoc
Description
11 "J -1"
a
4^#
Terrace
Porcelaneous and
cherty siliceous
shale
Wji
fe>
fe
ff
(^==-
$3flt3
Barbara
i3
*j^
CJ
0
Tranquillon 1.7-
%f5S
i_
.
Rmcon
Monterey
PjjcCECb
UJ
C3
O
Description
f/
Boulder, cobble,
and pebble gravel;
sand, silt, and clay
Series
Formation
Vaqueros
Sespe (Nj/1
OLIGOCENE
/ Alegria
B
^F^
_T^"^^-^
-Ir/Kr:
-~
Cozy Dell
z
Rmcon
Vaqueros
^1
Organic shale;
thin limestone
lentils
Claystone
300
Sandstone
fegga^g
Santa
I'.V-r
.. _
Sespe (N)
Coldwater
J"/\AA/V\
t : =---:
....
f.-.-.v.v.
888
te
Cozy Dell
Arkosic sandstone
Sandstone
-: >:->:-
Jalama
&-=f=
Claystone and
siltstone; finegrained sandstone at top
and middle
J*
SJ.;r' E-TTT^-~
Juncal
'1
CLOWER
RETACEOUS
+
t: -_ -
Carbonaceous
shale and thin
sandstone
(O'O- O- O
J.O- O -o-
6>zfii
Sandstone
Claystone and
shale
Claystone and
shale
-':/$ *
Serpentine intrusions
CJ
If-
prd
Franciscan
' %
UJ
CJ
O
JE^=rS
Massive diatomaceous
mudstone; thin limy
beds and concretions
Siliceous shale,
laminated,orgamc
Alternating laminated
shale; hard limestone
^S>.~ap~
Jalama
=^^^
~=ir=i
CO
"Santa
Marganta"
UJ
Franciscan
Sandstone
~ ^
pj::.j;
Sandstone
OO
Basal pebbly
sandstone
Hard sandstone
and shale
o- o-^
p: .-. .:
CZ>
PUP
Siltstone with
locally thick
sandstone and
conglomerate
interbeds
to
^ 2
tlV^L.".
Claystone and
shale
^r-~ "
^r_^=
feL^
en
r-----^
S^-tE
=i
fo
Q
O
1-0
0-0
Matihia
UJ
OC
t->
Q_
nPlCO
(lower part
commonly
called
CSI
CSI
C3
O
ur
Z
UJ
CJ
0
\ Blanca A
Espada
/Co- O- O- O
v.-.-.v.-.
J|i
OL.
Q- ^
fo o o o
fer^V?
(o- o-o-o
To o- oto o o o
Wo- tt o-
iT: H?.:
Claystone
Alternating thick
conglomerate
and siltstone
CT'o* o-"p
Qu
Anita
oc 2
Variegated arkosic
sandstone and
siltstone; basal
sandstone and
conglomerate
/.
: rm.v
V.TV.T.-
f$
Massive mudstone,
thick conglomerate
lenses
( A"AA/\/\
CJ
Matihia
TV
:r.v::
UJ
C3
O
<=>
[*$>:&=
fe.4
l|T-=.-
C:o>: := >
HHI-^
~=
. |
Siliceous shale
Marine sandstone
<>
Description
^ r-r:
Variegated sandstone
and siltstone
^3
z:
LLJ
o
7. . .-.-. _
gen
Feet
|JJ^
Claystone
I Lithology
UJ
fen*r-
UJ
^---7-^
Feet
V-L-CTC
4 v
tet
E!
2
O_ C3
I thology
Formation
Conglomerate,
sandstone,
and shale
_ _ _ FAULT _ _ _ _
Sheared shale and
sandstone intruded
by greenstone and
serpentine
::: :
Rincon
-<a-
:^.-=-=r-
M-zia 1
fe^f?5r
Continued to r ght
Formation
| Lithology
A'V*
'..*
Feet
?. 0 A
*'.A ff
A-e r
A '.*.i >
Ok
A
N
A- AO
Formation
| Lithology
. . /
A?:>' It
"Santa
Margarita"
fo^". A
AO A.JQ\O O \
>o'^?. "\
[S^I'o5
Monterey
g
oo
z
CJ>
O
m
Hard, fine- to coarsegrained sandstone
and silty claystone
mterbedded
< vrr.'ir
-J^
^r^
IS**-"
Forammiferal silty
shale; fossiliferous
sandstone interbeds
;;
Thick-bedded sandstone
- FAULT-
"~~~~ls9
Unnamed
fc;.V?^>-|
&?.-.* &:
R\
'^>> f~\J
5^
- FAULT-
Alternating thick-bedded
sandstone, thin-bedded
sandstone and foramimferal shale; concretionary;
cobble conglomerate at
base
pj^i4
Unnamed
- .v:
?TT5=-??
JJ
p^M
Alternating olivine basalt,
amygdaloidal and
sconaceous basalt,
basalt and andesite
breccia, grading upward
to basalt and andesite
agglomerate, tuff,
and sandstone
Description
Dune sand
Diatomaceous shale
O . ^ o*
"Conejo
Volcanics"
5^1*1? <s
CJ>
O
CJ>
O
LLJ
fSrlfc*
STCTi?
5^0i
vv'-^vTX
^^^D1
^^*p -""^x/v
iTil.'7/I o
Vl/i/i ^
J^y.V.V
Tuffaceous siliceous
diatomaceous shale;
thin beds of dense
limestone near base
xrvcri
i?s^y?
Feet
!l
I Lithology
<2sSH inn v\
/! .- .
' IA_A"A A,"
\A "A~A A"
'Conejo
Volcanics"
p^^
Variegated mudstone,
sandstone,
grit, and conglomerate; massive to
very thick bedded
Formation
Monterey
rfi'A' A9
F^>
Series
.'A>>^
A-
Feet
Description
300 Sandstone and conglomerate
Description
Rhyolite. andesite, and
basalt breccia, agglomerate, and sconaceous
flows
(pofoo9o
JL^~
z
O
2
Q_
Unnamed
gV.V.V.*;
fe?=^^H
to
Alternating thin-bedded
shale and thick-bedded
sandstone
$=I=jr
FAULT
^^
'%.'5^
Cozy Dell
At
4
c
r
San
Onofre
Thin-bedded hard sandstone, siltstone beds
in upper and lower
parts, middle part
massive hard
sandstone
Matiliia
^1
^
'a
Cozy
Dell
fl
^T-^.*r-
" "*
3^
'iM
6S
Ss&J
P
t
^w
I
s
V5.-?5
LLJ
O
O
^- -v=s-
C3
Elr=S
Juncal
f=3^=3f
LLJ
Unnamed 5i^^
2/
Oiorite
, O
LLJ LLJ
S
LLJ
Q=
CJ>
Greenstone
y,V:
pfe's
ri~VTT I
Thick-bedded sandstone
j vv^f:
Tim-bedded shale and
mudstone. thin micaceous sandstone
interbeds
.1
1"
Sandstone, conglomerate,
and siltstone
*.".".".*.
Hornblende diorite
- -
FAULT
Chlorite schist
EXPLANATION
(N)
Nonmarme unit
All others are marine
2000
i- 3000 FEET
FIGURE 3. Onshore structure section, Santa Barbara to Santa Ynez fault. T on fault indicates movement toward observer;
A, movement away from observer.
h 0.35=^
--J-3&: ?
^=^
x^tfw
v^^- ^- ^-
///,
"*
' r^ i K i S**.S*L K. i
-rr** w k i rx
^%f
I
RINCON TREND
MONTALVO TREND
SEA LEVEL
- 500
INDEX
2 NAUTICAL MILES
VERTICAL EXAGGERATION
APPROXIMATELY X 6
Interpretation of seismic data by S C Wolf, 1969
10
EXPLANATION
, Santa Barbara
,Summerland
Fault
-5000
Structure contour
Dashed where approximately located.
Contour interval 500feet
Drilling platform
Ventura
FIGURE 5. Schematic structure contour map of the Rincon trend.
GEOLOGIC HISTORY
11
Petroleum Development
in the Region of the
Santa Barbara Channel
By R. F. YERKES, H. C. WAGNER, and K. A. YENNE
GEOLOGY, PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT, AND SEISMICITY OF THE
SANTA BARBARA CHANNEL REGION, CALIFORNIA
GEOLOGICAL
SURVEY PROFESSIONAL
PAPER
679-B
CONTENTS
Page
Page
Production. ______________________________
Natural seeps near Santa Barbara._ ____________
Onshore asphalt deposits __________________
Onshore oil and gas seeps __________________
Offshore oil seeps and asphalt deposits _________
Oil and gas fields __________________________
Rincon trend area _______________________
Ventura oil field _____________________
San Miguelito oil field _________________
Rincon oil field ______________________
Carpinteria Offshore oil field _____________
Dos Cuadras Offshore oil field ____________
Ojai area_____________________________
Tip Top oil field._____________________
Lion Mountain oil field _________________
Weldon Canyon oil field ________________
Oakview oil field (abandoned) ____________
Canada Larga oil field _________________
Goleta area ___________________________
Summer-land oil field (abandoned) __________
Summerland Offshore oil field ____________
Mesa oil field __ _____________________
Goleta oil field (abandoned) ____________
La Goleta gas field (abandoned) __________
Coal Oil Point Offshore oil field. __________
13
13
14
14
15
15
15
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
18
18
18
18
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
21
21
21
21
TABLE
Page
TABLE 1. Production and geologic data on oil and gas fields of the Santa Barbara Channel region
22
in
365-228 O - 69 - 4
PRODUCTION
14
Written records, dating from as early as 1792, describe effects of offshore seeps in the Santa Barbara
Channel. Oil and tar "slicks" have long been a trade-
mark of the channel. In 1792, Captain Cook's navigator, Vancouver, recorded on passing through the
Channel (Imray, 1868):
The surface of the sea, which was perfectly smooth and
tranquil, was covered with a thick, slimy substance, which
when separated or disturbed by a little agitation, became very
luminous, whilst the light breeze, which came principally from
the shore, brought with it a strong smell of tar, or some such
resinous substance. The next morning the sea had the appearance of dissolved tar floating on its surface, which covered
the sea in all directions within the limits of our view....
(Fewkes, 1889). Evidence of submarine seeps recorded by the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey during
channel crossings prior to 1900 is also reported in several annual reports, such as for 1855 and 1859.
Sea-floor deposits of tar in the Point Conception,
Goleta, and Carpinteria areas have been studied by
Vernon and Slater (1963), who photographed tar
mounds l1/^ miles offshore and east of Point Conception, in 90 feet of water. There, a sheet of tar covers
an area of at least one-fourth of a square mile and
has a 10- to 12-foot scarp at its seaward edge. Elsewhere, near Point Conception, tar mounds are as much
as 100 feet in diameter and 8 feet in height. They
appear to be distributed along east-trending anticlines
in Monterey Shale. At Coal Oil Point and off Carpinteria, the mounds are only a few inches high, and some
are elongated along fractures in the Monterey. Prolific gas and oil seeps also issue from the sea floor
about a mile off Coal Oil Point.
Tar mounds are formed where tar is slowly extruded from sea-floor vents forming mounds like
shield "volcanos." In some places, pencillike strands
or "whips" of tar, through which the more fluid tar
flows, were observed issuing from the centers of the
mounds. If seepage through the whips is slow enough,
they become more dense than sea water and sink to
form part of the mound; if seepage is faster, the whip
is torn away by agitation of the water and it floats to
the surface to become part of the drifting tar so common to beaches of the area.
Drill cores from a group of mounds show that the
tar fills all fractures and interstices in the host rock
15
16
river bed with the cable-tool rigs, the water could not
be controlled, and the wells were abandoned. For many
years the Ventura oil field had the reputation of
being one of the most difficult in California in which
to complete deep wells (Hertel, 1929).
Exploratory drilling for oil was begun in 1914, but
the first well was suspended after 2 years of work,
because formation water could not be controlled. The
second discovery well was begun in May 1916; in
September the well blew out at 2,253 feet. The blowout destroyed the rotary rig and formed a crater
around the well from which gas, oil, and water were
sprayed, confirming the presence of petroleum under
high pressure. Subsequent efforts to develop oil
production from this level, known as the upper "light
oil" zone, were relatively unsuccessful. Water shutoff was difficult to attain, the zone was flooded, and
the excessive gas pressures caused several more severe
blowouts. One well, after being shut in, broke out at
the surface 400 to 500 feet from the well, where a geyser of water, oil, and gas shot 8 or 10 feet into the air
until the well bore was reopened (Hertel, 1929). - Finally, in April 1919, hard-won experience and improved
methods resulted in successful completion of a commercial well at about 3,500 feet in what is called the
upper "heavy oil" zone. After this success, additional
and better wells were completed in successively deeper
zones: 3,700 feet in 1921; 3,855 feet in 1922; and also in
1922, a well for 1,900 bpd from 5,050 feet. In 1925, a
real "gusher" was completed for more than 4,600 bpd
from 5,150 feet. By 1928, more than 100 wells, some
flowing at rates of 5,700 bpd, had been completed at
depths to 7,100 feet. At the same time, the field was
being expanded areally; it is now about 7 miles along
the east-west axis and about 1 mile wider'
In addition to the difficulties of controlling formation water, the Ventura field is almost unique in
California for its abnormal reservoir pressures below
depths of about minus 6,000 feet. Although these
conditions had long required the use of heavy-mineral
drilling muds, considerably higher pressures were encountered in the early 1940's in the "D-7" zone at
depths below about minus 9,000 feet. Initial reservoir
pressures in the "D-7" zone near the crest of the anticline range from about 85 percent of inferred lithostatic pressure at minus 6,000 feet to about 92 percent
of that at minus 9,000 feet (Watts, 1948). These
pressures produce very high gradients in the well
bore and well-head pressures as great as 5,300 psi
(pounds per square inch). In addition to drilling
hazards resulting from these high fluid pressures, wells
commonly failed by collapse and shearing of pipe
(Watts, 1948).
17
The Tip Top field, located about 5 miles southsouthwest of Ojai, was discovered in 1918. The discovery well had an initial production of 15 bpd from
a depth of about 430 feet in fractured Miocene shale
that is exposed at the surface. Only small production
was obtained from a total of eight wells. The peak
production year was 1935, when the daily average
was 18 barrels of oil. The area did not produce in
1968.
Lion Mountain oil field
18
The Goleta area includes the following fields' Summerland (abandoned), Summerland Offshore, Mesa,
Goleta (abandoned), La Goleta gas (abandoned), Coal
Oil Point Offshore, Elwood, South Elwood Offshore,
Las Varas (abandoned), and Glen Annie gas (abandoned).
19
The Las Varas field was discovered in 1958; all producing zones were in the Sespe Formation at depths
of about 2,400-3,000 feet. The deepest test was to
3,404 feet in Eocene beds. Only two of seven wells
drilled were completed. The peak production year
was 1958, and the field was abandoned in 1960. The
structure consists of a small northeast-trending anticline that is bounded on the south by an east-trending
south-dipping reverse fault (California Division of
Oil and Gas, 1961).
Glen Annie gas field (abandoned)
The Refugio Cove field consists of two separate accumulations, one on either side of Refugio Canyon.
The initial discovery in 1946 was east of the canyon.
The discovery well produced 5,000 Mcf gas per day
from a depth of 2,500 feet in the Vaqueros Formation.
Minor production was discovered in 1958 west of the
canyon. This production came from about 3,550 feet
in the Sespe Formation. The deepest test, 6,148 feet,
bottomed in the Eocene. Of the 18 wells drilled, only
three were completed. The fields were abandoned in
1961 after producing 990,000 Mcf of gas and 3,000
barrels of oil.
20
The Alegria Offshore field was discovered in February 1962. Production in this one-well field is from
a depth of 4,033 feet in Sespe-equivalent sands. The
peak production year was 1964, when the average was
748 bpd. Production for 1968 was 23,000 barrels of
oil and 439 M2cf gas.
21
The first commercial oil well in California was completed in 1866 just east of the channel region; it was
located on the basis of oil seeps. Since that time, the
channel region has participated directly in the successful development of every phase of southern California's oil industry, from prospecting on land because
of the presence of oil seeps, to prospecting offshore
by geophysical methods.
The oil fields along the Rincon anticlinal trend, including the offshore Carpinteria field, have completely
dominated the production statistics of all the other
channel-region fields combined:
Field
884,853
9.884
894,737
203.576
1,098,313
Note that the 1968 production from Carpinteria Offshore alone exceeds that from all the other non-Rincon trend fields combined. The large production of
the Rincon -trend fields is attributable to thick, oilsaturated sections and relatively high porosities and
permeabilities.
22
Date of
discovery
Average depth
to
shallowest
production J
(feet)
f
\
July
Feb.
Oct.
Aug.
1959
1962
1962
1955
Oct.
Jan.
Feb.
Aug.
Feb.
1929
1931
1945
Aug.
Aug.
Mar.
Jan.
Mar.
1948
1961
1961
1961
1968
July
Oct.
July
Nov .
Feb.
July
Mar.
May
Dec.
Sept.
1928
1931
1960
1958
1927
1932
1958
1929
1962
1960
3 ,400
3 ,700
May 1935
June 1949
Apr. 1955
1 ,200
3 ,550
1 ,545
430
3 ,050
1945
1966
1918
June 1951
Mar. 1965
1946
Dec.
Dec.
Oct.
Nov.
Nov.
1927
1937
1953
1931
1966
1894
Nov . 1958
June 1917
Apr.
Feb.
Aug.
July
1947
1951
1957
1955
\
J
Average
API
gravity
(degrees)
4 ,300+
4 ,000+
22
38
2 ,558
26
1 ,300
2 ,000
22
40
2 ,850
2 ,600 +
39
26
30
40
34
Number of wells,
December 1968
Producing
Total 2
1
2
3
45
33
12
88
3
Abandoned
3
32
6
8
1
3
4
75
41
33
1
89
3
3
45
8
2 ,137
3 ,350
400
3 ,800
2 ,400
2 ,200
2 ,900
2 ,400
6 ,800
4 ,150
7 ,000
6 ,200 +
140
3 ,000
9 ,000
11 ,500
35
37
42
38
17
21
29
30
24
29
31
63
30
31
26
31
31
19
34
30
29
16
15
28
56
22
48
21
1
8
---3
Abandoned 1961
Abandoned 1928
15
Abandoned 1960
1
5
9
10
Abandoned 1966
2
10
8
2
2
Abandoned 1955
8
2
2
3
3
Abandoned 1961
421
327
291
218
34
47
75
83
82
118
11
11
8
46
31
986
1 ,295
57
86
9
18
67
47
1
1
Abandoned
23
Oil production
(thousands of barrels)
1968
Cumulative
to 1-1-69
23
7
80
3
102
74
28
78
18,993
12,067
6,549
116
642
20
377
9,884
986
1
985
19,226
581
265
260
5
102,792
99,131
3,520
5,564
116
Net withdrawal
formation gas
(millions of cu ft)
1968
Cumulative
to 1-1-69
439
3,805
109
34
75
3,893
227
227
483
0.816
418
406
12
6,816
141
3
1
3,733
28.5
12
6
6
22
5
2,568
1,612
259
697
831
1,929
1,285
8,415
1,089
102
980
7
22,894
363
181
182
1
106
512
5
3
99,493
65,212
13,568
20,713
53,262
3,449
3,210
20,783
732,098
29,107
3,257
25,598
161
91
1,098,894
1
1
19
2
4,527
2,323
630
1,574
972
2,812
8,537
18,566
561.578
"23
0.578
80,685
13
2,206
19,625
77
14,819
3,958
10,476
385
6,951
2,494
18
2,476
12,426
11,178
84,996
29,967
54,973
57,093
490,983
56
15,363
8
139,007
20,815
207
130
77
67
302
2
*0.990
152,978
83,134
37,729
32,115
155,054
4,444
*1,704
64,602
1,914,819
*10,312
7,613
*10,291
9
39
2,927,386
Water production
(thousands of barrels)
1968
Cumulative
to 1-1-69
1
1
34
16
48
4,138
3,526
612
1,938
107
107
4,944
933
13,629
1,289
3,156
433
16,669
4,580
2,963
2,888
75
20
6
5
1
3
22
4,453
3,287
258
908
628
299
3,856
12,342
10,463
364
1,021
8,567
1,105
33
1,072
6,743
14,203
520
13,681
2
24
Geologic data
Producing
formation and age
1964 |
748
AT T*PT?TA
1964 j
P<TT C tlO'DT1
1956
55
1943
1935
1946
1947
1967
3,105
1,261
1,728
160
9,894
1948
1966
637
1964
13,539
1962
518
PAPTTAW
[
1
P A T? "P T MT'T'D T A
PHAT
HTT
DHTMT1
PHMPTDTT HM
T\r\ C
OT'POLTA'DT
Sespe, Oligocene
)
J
H'PTO Ur\"DT
HTTCtin'DT'
PT T A T\"D AOOTTOtfPiTPT
ELWOOD
C A \7TOT A
nVPQttnPT1
1930
40,069
1936
2,698
( Pa o ^
----
1958
1935
2
3,027
1938
1950
1955
1935
1954
45
55
2
18
118
1959
1961
6,735
1950
1954
3,515
2,918
1951
6,758
1967
4,164
1 RQQ
.R71
1964
10,362
LION MOUNTAIN
OAKVIEW
WELDON CANYON
{
SAN MIGUELITO
n/~\TTrpTj
r'T r-Tf* f* F\
r\ "PTTO UO'DT'
RIIMM'RRT.AMn-
-_
__
SUMMERLAND OFFSHORE
PI T nne>ne> . Mi nne>np
1
>
25
Remarks
Offshore tract No. and
completion data
Method of discovery 3
State 2199.
Stratigraphic trap-Faulted
anticlinal
nose.
Faulted anticline
on Rincon trend.
Geologic mapping-
Faulted anticline
on Rincon trend.
{ Faulted anticline--
Stratigraphic trap
in fold.
Asymmetrical
anticline.
Anticlinal dome- Faulted anticline-Faulted dome -----
Geologic mapping-
Faulted asymmetric
anticline.
Faulted anticline-Pinchout--- -----State 2879; wells completed on
ocean floor.
Stratigraphic trap,
Faulted anticline
on Rincon trend.
Geologic mapping-
Faulted anticline
on Rincon trend,
Geologic mapping-
Faulted anticline-
Anticline- ------
26
WEST MONTALVO
McGrath
Totals
Year
Bpd
1930
45,323
1962
1958
1956
815
7,501
106
107
Geologic data
Producing
formation and age
_________
365-228 O - 69 - 6
Method of discovery 3
Geologic mapping and gas seeps.
Remarks 1 2
Offshore tract No. and
completion area
Excessively high reservoir pressures
below 6,000 ft subsea.
Includes a tideland lease, developed
by wells drilled from shore.
27
Geologic Characteristics
of the Dos Cuadras
Offshore Oil Field
By T. H. McCULLOH
GEOLOGY, PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT, AND SEISMICITY OF THE
SANTA BARBARA CHANNEL REGION, CALIFORNIA
GEOLOGICAL
SURVEY
PROFESSIONAL
PAPER 679-C
CONTENTS
Page
Introduction- __________________----------------------------------------Acknowledgments ______________---___----------------------------------Structure- _ ______________----------_--------------------------------Lithology and stratigraphy ___________________--_--_-----------------------Petrophysical characteristics __________________-----------------------------Fluid properties_________________--_---_-----------------------------Reservoir and reservoir characteristics- _ ________________--_--------------------Seepage and subsurface fluid communication-_____________-----------------------Subsidence potential-________-____--_-------------------------------------
2^
^9
30
^2
34
^6
41
42
^5
ILLUSTRATIONS
Page
FIGURE 6. Composite type log of the Dos Cuadras oil field- _ ____________________________
7-9. Graphs showing:
7. Porosity versus depth for analyzed core samples, Dos Cuadras oil field._________
8. Permeability versus porosity of analyzed sandstone cores, Dos Cuadras oil field____
9. Oil gravity versus depth, Dos Cuadras oil field._________________________
10. Schematic relations between producing "zones," stratigraphic subdivisions, and structural
divisions in the Dos Cuadras oil field-_________________________________
11. Graph showing fluid pressures and fluid-pressure gradients versus depth for the Rincon
trend including the Dos Cuadras oil field__________ _____________________
12. Graph showing fluid pressures, fluid-pressure gradients, and uncased and perforated intervals of Dos Cuadras oil-field wells that were shut in or drilling on January 28,
1969 ________________________________________________________
13. Map showing Dos Cuadras oil-field oil and gas seepage area._____________________
31
34
35
37
37
38
40
44
TABLE
Page
TABLE 2. Comparison of certain geologic and engineering characteristics of the Dos Cuadras oil
field with the Wilmington, Calif.,oil field-______________________________
Hi
46
By T. H. McCuLLOH
INTRODUCTION
The Dos Cuadras Offshore oil field is a large multizone anticlinal accumulation of oil of intermediate
gravity in a sandstone and siltstone sequence of early
Pliocene age ("Repetto Formation"). The accumulation occurs in an elongate, doubly plunging, faulted
culmination of the Rincon anticlinal trend beneath
OCS leases P-0241 and P-0240, about 5^ miles south
of Santa Barbara. Figure 5 shows the generalized
structure along that part of the Rincon trend from
the eastern part of the Ventura oil field to the area
south of Santa Barbara. An area of roughly 1,000
acres is estimated to be potentially productive from
multiple sandstone reservoirs at subsea depths of 4,000
feet and less, but revisions to the estimate will probably be required as more detailed geologic information becomes available from drilling.
When compared with any other known anticlinal
oil field of "giant" dimensions 1 and comparable area
in the Santa Barbara Channel region, in the eastern
Ventura basin, or in California, the Dos Cuadras
petroleum accumulation is unique in one special way.
The shallowest commercial reservoirs of the other
small-area "giant" anticlinal fields are covered and
confined by a thousand to many thousands of feet of
relatively impermeable strata incapable of yielding
commercial amounts of fluid hydrocarbons to a well
bore. By contrast, at the structurally highest point
beneath OCS P-0241, the top of the shallowest major
reservoir of the Dos Cuadras field is overlain by a
section of less than 300 feet of interbedded siltstone,
claystone, and minor sandstone. Even these uppermost 300 feet of strata are porous and permeable
29
30
STRUCTURE
Mud line
Gamma
ray
500
.E.S.
E -^
1000
*3 1500
2000
2500
- H-2
3000
3500
K
L
4000
M
365-228 O - 69 - 7
31
32
normal fault and the east-northeast-trending tear been used for continuous, accurate, and fairly detailed
fault.
lithologic determinations in nearly all the wells
Near the eastern limits of the Dos Cuadras field, drilled.
The stratal sequence beneath Platform A on OCS
understanding of the structure of the east-plunging
Rincon trend beneath OCS P-0240 is very incomplete. P-0241 is best discussed by reference to the type log,
Not only are fewer data available here, but also less figure 6. Three parts of the logs of two wells (Nos.
time and attention have been directed by the writer 1 and 5), drilled 500-700 feet east of Platform A, have
to interpretation of the structural data. The sea- been joined to form one idealized log showing standard
floor geology and the data from exploratory wells borehole electrical (or induction-gamma ray) properties
indicate that the general structure is a steeply plung- of the complete 4,200-foot-thick stratigraphic column
ing anticlinal fold (pi. 3). The generalized seismic penetrated between 200 feet and about 4,850 feet
interpretation is consistent with this view. The ir- below sea level. This composite log is uncomplicated
regular distribution of hydrocarbons suggests the by the repetitions or deletions of some strata in actual
presence of permeability barriers produced by faults logs of most of the wells. The type log shows three
across the fold axis; similar conditions exist farther major lithologic divisions in the section. The uppereast along the Rincon trend in the productive strata most 287 feet (from the top down to the C horizon)
displays electrical properties like those of a section in
beneath OCS P-0166.
which siltstone and claystone or shale predominate
The deformation responsible for the structure along
and sandstone lenses and beds are subordinate. Bethe Rincon trend cannot be precisely dated at the
neath this cap of fine-grained and thinly bedded
Dos Cuadras field; the strongly folded and extensively
strata is a 2,250-foot section (between the C and the
faulted conformable sequence ranges in age from late
H-2 horizons) in which the predominant lithology is
Miocene through late Pliocene and is unconformably
sandstone interbedded with subordinate siltstone,
overlain by a nearly flat lying and slightly faulted
mudstone, or shale. Below the base of the predomithin veneer of stiff fossiliferous silt and sand. The
nantly sandstone section (below the H-2 horizon and
fossil shells have yielded radiocarbon dates ranging
about 3,400 feet drilled depth in the No. 1 hole), the
from 8,750300 to 13,920350 years.
section is composed almost entirely of siltstone, clayOnshore, on the south limb of the Ventura Avenue stone, and shale, interrupted by a few scattered thin
anticline, early Pleistocene strata dip steeply and are
beds of sandstone. The rocks of these three major
conformable with folded Pliocene beds. This dip
subdivisions are considered in some detail below.
indicates a mid-Pleistocene date for the greatest part
of the deformation. Evidence of continuing deformaAt the time of the drilling of well A-21 the uppertion and uplift along structural elements that are
most
200 feet of strata beneath Platform A had been
associated with the Ventura Avenue anticline is
cored
only in small part and had been subjected to
described by Putnam (1942).
borehole geophysical logging in only one well on OCS
P-0241. Knowledge of these strata was restricted to
LITHOLOGY AND STRATIGRAPHY
the following: log measurements in stratigraphically
Sandstone, siltstone, claystone, and shale are the equivalent beds in wells about half a mile east, southpredominant rock types (in order of decreasing abun- east, and north of Platform A; percussion core samples
dance) comprising the lower Pliocene and uppermost taken at 5- to 15-foot intervals in three shallow
Miocene strata penetrated by drilling in the Dos (greatest depth, 150 feet) holes drilled at and near
Cuadras field. A limited number of rubber-sleeve and the Platform A site for engineering investigations
conventional cores and some sidewall cores permit prior to platform construction; and information
direct observation of some of the rocks and lithologic gleaned from responses to problems encountered
description by conventional petrographic means. during construction of the platform supports and
However, for most of the section, less direct methods during drilling of the shallowest parts of the first
of determining lithology have been used. Logs of four exploitation wells. Taken together, these diverse
spontaneous potential and electrical resistivity (IES and fragmentary sources indicate the following charlogs), gamma radiation, and gamma-gamma radiation acteristics for the strata between the sea floor and
("formation density") were recorded in most of the the C horizon at the location of the platform. Siltstone
wells drilled. These logs have been interpreted in and claystone predominate in the section and are
the light of core samples recovered from these wells interbedded with subordinate lenses and thin (as much
and with knowledge and experience gained in equiv- as a few feet) beds of fine-grained sandstone, in part
alent or similar rocks elsewhere. The results have calcareous and weakly cemented. Oil saturation was
33
34
(}
10
20
30
50
Sea floor
60
1
*fff*x
X* 3
KB=0
Naof
samples
Punch]
cores 1
i 10
70
i
-E
vr*-
PETROPHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS
40
Sea level
V*"*
No recovery
1000
39
500
7
3
"i
18
11
1000
I
<>&&>
''
.*.*
1500
13
vet*
1500
19
20
2000
i
- **
12
2000
EXPLANATION
Jgpfr*t.
0 "sr^
2500
'
3000
l~
j'*
* R^!l^,
0 "*"
X
Foundation core holes
A1.A2, A3; Dames
and Moore, 1968
.
Well A-21, Union Oil Co.
lease OCS P-0241;
Core Labs. Inc.,
1/30/69
Well A-20, Union Oil Co.
lease OCS P 0241;
Core Labs. Inc.,
12/11/68 and 1/11/69
2500
28
|
i
3000
o
41
20
20 -
30
40
50
35
36
Petroleum and natural gas are complex fluid hydrocarbons of widely ranging composition and physical
properties. They are uncommon, mobile, and highly
fugacious constituents of certain especially favored
parts of the discontinuous veneer of sedimentary
rocks that rests on essentially non-oil-bearing rocks
in the deeper parts of the earth's crust. Petroleum
has a tendency to escape from underground natural
reservoirs and seep to the surface. It is well known
that seepages served as guides to early prospectors
and still form the basis for some petroleum exploration. This escaping tendency is also used in the controlled production of crude oil and accounts in large
part for the expulsion of oil from reservoir rocks
through flowing wells. Unfortunately the tendency
also accounts for the uncontrolled flow of oil from
"gushers," "wild wells," and blowouts and has necessitated the use of numerous precautionary procedures
and special mechanical devices.
The motive force behind the tendency for oil and
gas to escape from the pore spaces of rocks and move
to the surface is the force of gravity. Crude oil is
A. P. 1. GRAVITY, IN DEGREES
24
26
28
30
~i
32
34
36
Sea floor
a 1000
3
"5.
ja 2000
JO
i
<NI
EXPLANATION
O
3000
A-21 conventional
core extractions
4000
i
0.94
i n
0.93
r" i '
0.92
0.91 0.90
0.89 0.88
0.87
0.86
SPECIFIC GRAVITY AT 60 DEGREES FAHRENHEIT
' r
0.85
on samples of fluid obtained from selected exploitation wells that had achieved settled rates of production
following the blowout. These latter data are consistent
with the pre-blowout data and indicate that the tendency for the oil to be more dense in reservoirs nearer
the surface extends upward into the so-called "Red
zone" (fig. 10), the name applied to the thin producible
sands within the capping layer close to the B-15
marker.
Analogies between the crude-oil gravities of the
Dos Cuadras field and those of other fields in California lead to the conclusion that the denser crudes
in the shallower reservoirs at Dos Cuadras contain
limited quantities of potentially gaseous constituents
in solution and probably are undersaturated. By the
same reasoning, the less dense crudes from the deeper
reservoirs in the "Repetto Formation" might be expected to contain appreciable quantities of dissolved
low-molecular-weight fractions and to be saturated
or nearly saturated with gas. This expectation is
supported by the limited data available at the time
of completion of well A-20, and by the somewhat
more extensive data made available to the Presidential
Advisory Panel in May 1969 by the operator (lessee).
Analyses of the recombined separator samples from
tests of exploratory hole No. 2 give the following data:
(1) Lower zone sample (minus 2,677 to minus 2,028 feet)
at average reservoir pressure and temperature of
1,095 psig (pounds per square inch gage) and 105 F
at minus 2,350 feet had a field-tested gravity of 27.1
37
WE LL
U C
p
P D
WE
\- Red zone
>
^/
/
1 0
Brown zone
-? w
/
| Red zone
E E
R
402
C'P")F upper zone <
402
upper zone <
C R
oL G
L
-F 0
\j
1 402
/'
^Thi
st fault
H
1
c E
jm :'W:f.
: ;S;:S&;S:::::S:S:;S:SH:x:SA
Zone y^i^SSiWift -S
\-^-mm^;mmyf^K,
402
,.
402
1000 FEET
500
__I
I
APPROXIMATE VERTICAL SCALE
Note: F-G markers are included in 402 upper zone above thrust fault
and in 402 lower zone below thrust fault
38
the mobile (producible) hydrocarbons decrease in den- depths of minus 4,000 and about minus 9,000 feet
sity (increase in API gravity) with increasing depths, range above "normal" along gradients of 0.6-0.9 psi
from 21 or less at depths less than minus 1,000 feet per foot of depth. These well-known abnormalities
to 33 or more at depths greater than minus 3,500 feet. raise questions concerning fluid pressure gradients at
Also evident is the fact that the reservoir fluids range the Dos Cuadras field, since it is located along the
from strongly undersaturated (with respect to gas) same structural trend.
at shallow depths to saturated and at bubble-point
Data regarding fluid pressures in reservoirs of the
pressures for the deepest interval tested (minus 3,962 Dos Cuadras field come from measurements made
to 3,300 feet).
during drill-stem tests, production tests, and pressureCalifornia oil fields generally are characterized by buildup tests, and from determinations based on the
so-called "normal" fluid pressures, that is, fluid pres- weights of drilling fluids required to maintain pressures equal to the hydrostatic pressure exerted by a sure control in drilling wells. Prior to the leasing of
column of nearly fresh water extending from the sub- OCS P-0241, a gradient of 0.454 psi per foot was well
surface point of measurement to the surface (or to established on lease OCS P-0166 in the "Repetto Forthe natural ground- water level in the aquifer). In con- mation" reservoirs (fig. 11) from many determinations.
trast to this are the fluid pressures in the deeper zones Before Platform A was constructed, exploratory hole
of the onshore fields along the Rincon trend, particu- No. 1 had demonstrated that 71 and 72 pounds per
larly the Ventura field, where fluid pressures range cubic foot drilling mud (0.493 psi per foot and 0.500
upward from "hydrostatic" to values approaching the psi per foot gradients, respectively) could be safely
"lithostatic" pressure, or pressure due to the weight used in drilling near the Platform A site to depths of
of a column of rock extending from the subsurface minus 3,356 feet (1,680 psi). At greater depths
point of measurement to the surface vertically above "kicking" of the mud column necessitated higher mud
that point. The "lithostatic" pressure gradient is weights (at minus 3,821 feet, 80-pound mud was recommonly assumed to be 1 psi per foot of depth, and quired, indicating a fluid pressure of 2,120 psi on a
most calculated gradients depart very little from this gradient of 0.555 psi per foot). Trial production tests in
assumption. Figure 11 summarizes the published exploratory well No. 2 about 1 mile west of the Platpressure data from onshore Rincon trend fields (Watts, form A site yielded pressure measurements consistent
1948; Glenn, 1950; Duggan, 1964) and from the Dos with a pressure gradient of 0.44 psi per foot down to
Cuadras field. Pressures in onshore wells between minus 2,677 feet. Before the. blowout of well A-21,
exploitation well A-25 was drilled to a total vertical
depth of 4,051 (minus 3,963 feet); gas "kicking" occurred at minus 3,448 feet (after drilling below 9%-inch
casing cemented at minus 3,318 feet) requiring 73
DCS P-0166, gradient of
0.454 psi per foot
pounds per cubic foot mud (0.505 psi per foot gradient).
At total drilled depth of 4,051 feet the hole began to
"unload" 77-pound mud, but use of 78-pound mud led
to loss of circulation, indicating a fluid pressure of
2,146 psi on a gradient of about 0.538 psi per foot.
OCSP-0241,wellA-25,mud _|
weights and production test
These data are shown in figure 11, and have been corroborated
by more detailed information gathered
DCS P-0241, well A-20,
since the blowout. Evidently, the "Repetto" reservoir
pressure buildup 4/3/69
rocks of the Dos Cuadras field, down to the base of the
dominantly sandy section, contain fluids that are at
or only slightly above "normal" hydrostatic pressures
on a gradient of 0.44 psi per foot. Below the base of
the dominantly sandy section, and especially below the
I marker at about minus 3,440 feet, the minor thin
sandstone beds are charged with fluids at notably
greater pressures. These same sandstones are also
10,000
10,000
2000
4000
6000
the
sources of the gas-saturated oils of lower density
STATIC PRESSURE, IN POUNDS PER SQUARE INCH
(higher API gravity).
Taken together, the compositions and pressures of
FIGURE 11. Fluid pressures and fluid-pressure gradients versus
depth for the Rincon trend including the Dos Cuadras oil the fluids in the reservoir rocks of the Dos Cuadras
field.
field tell much about the nature of the reservoirs and
39
40
4000
1000
2000
3000
4000
FIGURE 12. Fluid pressures, fluid-pressure gradients, and uncased and perforated intervals of the Dos Cuadras oil-field
wells that were shut in or drilling on January 28,1969.
41
42
feet per barrel. Well A-21 was scheduled for a com- Survey for the period March 22 to August 31,1969, is
pletion similar to that of A-20, but when it blew out, given in Appendix B.
communication was opened, at least temporarily, from
SEEPAGE AND SUBSURFACE FLUID
the highly productive "402 lower zone" sands to all
COMMUNICATION
the lower-pressure sands up to the C marker. The
Although natural seepages of oil and gas have long
documented high rate of controlled production of well
been
a matter of record at several places (both offA-20 though a choke of less than 1 inch diameter
shore
and onshore) along the Rincon trend, no doculeads one to speculate about the possible rate of flow
mented
observation identified the Dos Cuadras sector
of well A-21 through a partly blocked bore hole of
as
a
seepage
source until work was undertaken on
unknown diameter against only moderate back presOCS
P-0241
following
the lease sale.
sure through the ruptured capping rocks to the sea
In a letter dated February 29,1968,11 months prior
floor.
to the blowout of well A-21, Mr. F. J. Simmons, DisAll reservoirs in the Dos Cuadras field are sandtrict Drilling Superintendent for Union Oil Co. of
stone with porosities ranging from nearly 40 percent
California, notified Mr. D. W. Solanas, Regional Oil
at the top of the "Brown zone" in the upper (P) block
and Gas Supervisor for the Conservation Division of
to 25 to 30 percent for sands in the "402 lower zone."
the Geological Survey, of observations made on FebAverage reservoir permeability ranges between nearly
ruary 23, and confirmed on February 28,1968, "a fairly
1 darcy at the top of the "Brown zone" to a low of 50
large oil slick with some gas bubbles" at a location
millidarcys for the interval between the G and H
within OCS P-0241 approximately 2,300 feet west and
3,500 feet south of the northeast corner of the lease.
markers in the upper (P) block. Oil gravity ranges
Mr. Simmons further stated, "From all indications and
between 18.5 API in the "Red zone" to 35 in some
records available to us, this is apparently a natural
of the thin sands below the I marker. Reservoir gasseep." This opinion is consistent with the tendency
oil ratios range from negligible in the shallower sands
toward intermittent activity of some known seeps
to 185 cubic feet per barrel for the "402 lower zone."
along the trend. The stated location is almost exactly
The crude oil in the shallower sands is strongly underon a line connecting Platforms A and B (along the C
saturated, but that in the lower sands of the "402
horizon axis of the Dos Cuadras culmination) and
lower zone" appears to be saturated. Interstitial
about 960 feet westerly along that line from the
water content appears to be low to moderate throughcenter
of Platform A.
out, but data are insufficient to permit setting figures
Somewhat
later in 1968, after tentative selections
on these quantities. Solution gas analyses are so few
had
been
made
for sites for three projected drilling
that conclusions may have to be revised, but available
platforms
on
OCS
P-0241, eight shallow coreholes
data show compositions that are normal for such crude
were
drilled
to
obtain
on-site information to aid in
oils except for a surprisingly high C02 content, sugplanning
foundations
for
these large structures. Three
gestive of an unusually oxidized (and perhaps stagcoreholes
were
drilled
in
the vicinity of what was to
nant) accumulation.
become the site of Platform A, three more at PlatProduction from the field has been so limited that
form B site, and two at the site of proposed Platform
reservoir performance cannot be evaluated. From
C, about 2,600 feet westerly from B. Technicians of
analogies between the reservoirs of Dos Cuadras field
Dames and Moore, Inc., who planned and supervised
and those of some other shallow California fields, it
these operations under contract to the operator, obmight be expected that the reservoir drive mechanism
served live oil shows while drilling and coring all
is a combination of solution gas expansion, accomthree holes at site A, and subsequently reported these
panied and followed by gravity drainage, with natural
findings along with descriptions of oil-saturated core
water drive being of minor importance. Present desamples and measurements of bulk densities indicative
velopment plans call for injection of water to help
of very high porosities for these oily shallow beds. No
maintain reservoir pressure after sufficient production
fluid hydrocarbons were reported from any of the
data are available for sound planning.
cores from the coreholes at the B or C sites.
On July 28,1969,14 wells were producing 10,000
Even though there are no earlier documented obbarrels of oil per day from the lower Pliocene zones servations of natural seepage from the Dos Cuadras
(one "Red zone," 10 "Brown zone," one lower "Brown field, there is abundant suggestive evidence that the
zone" to upper "402 upper zone," and two "402 lower accumulation may have been seeping over a long
zone" wells). A total of 635,000 barrels have been period of time. Apart from the very general and
withdrawn since controlled production for pressure
widespread evidence that most large or highly prodrawdown was authorized following the blowout. The
ductive petroleum accumulations seep at least some
amount of seepage estimated by the U.S. Geological
low-molecular-weight hydrocarbon fractions (McCul-
43
44
1
Approximate location of natural
seepage first sighted 2/23/68
and officially reported 2/29/68\^
y^
2
to 5/12/69 \_
( ^^
OCS P-0241
___
\
~~"A No- l
\
f~~~~"^--^ ^/^C,) cv~~"
\/
~~,/ ~~~ ~~~~^^-/^
Hocations of major boi^
7/^
-^
~^
500
i i
1000
i
FEET
surveV 3/16/69
OCS P-0241
A No. 4
Ax.
FIGURE 13. Dos Cuadras oil-field oil and gas seepage area.
|SUNj
45
SUBSIDENCE POTENTIAL
46
Wilmington, Calif.
(extracted from, Gilluly
and Grant, 1949)
Dos Cuadras
(compiled by T. H. McCiMoh)
About 2,200
("Tar")
About 2,500
("Tar" and "Ranger")
1,800
(All zones)
Early Pliocene
("Repetto Formation")
Early Pliocene
("Repetto Formation")
30
28
12 -25
21-33
340
299
Max 2,700
Min50
Max 2,200+
Min 50(?)
Well productivity, in
barrels of oil
per day.
Maximum flank dip
angle.
Maximum width of field
(productive limits),
in miles.
Productive area, in acres
Maximum surface subsidence,
in feet.
33
About 3
About 1
1 7,800
1,000
29 (to 1966)
lHalbouty (1968).
Seismicity and
Associated Effects
Santa Barbara Region
By R. M. HAMILTON, R. F. YERKES, R. D. BROWN, JR., R. O. BURFORD,
and J. M. DENOYER
GEOLOGY, PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT, AND SEISMICITY OF THE
SANTA BARBARA CHANNEL REGION, CALIFORNIA
GEOLOGICAL
CONTENTS
Page
Seismicity _ _ ______________________________________________
Recent (instrumental) evidence ________________________________
Historic record- __________________________________________
Geologic record-_________________________________________
Future earthquakes ________________________________________
Associated effects ___________________________________________
Ground motion and failure-___________________________________
Tsunamis ______________________________________________
Seismic effects on oil field installations ___________________________
Oil-field operations ________________________________________
Summary.________________________________________________
47
47
49
50
63
63
63
64
64
65
66
ILLUSTRATIONS
Page
48
49
49
51
TABLE
Page
TABLE 3. Partial list of earthquakes felt in the vicinity of Santa Barbara Channel, 1800 to 1952___-,_------_________--_-_-----_---ill
52
The Santa Barbara Channel region is located within the circum-Pacific seismic and volcanic belt and
has been tectonically active throughout much of
Cenozoic time. This tectonism seems to have been
accelerated during the latter part of this era, maximum activity having occurred in Quaternary time.
One way of depicting the seismic setting of the Santa
Barbara Channel region in relation to the rest of
southern California is to show the distribution of
recent large earthquakes (fig. 14). Since 1912, more
than 20 earthquakes of magnitude 6.0 or larger have
occurred in southern California. The San Jacinto
fault zone, which trends southeast from San Bernardino
and is part of the San Andreas fault system, was the
site of eight of these shocks; four others occurred
near Bakersfield during the Kern County earthquake
sequence of 1952; and two were located in the Santa
Barbara Channel. The 1927 earthquake of magnitude
7.5, west of Point Arguello, should perhaps be grouped
with the other two events in the channel region because all three may have occurred on faults in the
Transverse Range province.
RECENT (INSTRUMENTAL) EVIDENCE
48
FIGURE 14. Earthquakes of magnitude 6 and greater in southern California since 1912. Modified from Alien and others (1965).
49
120l 00'
Santa Rosa
Islan
SanMiguel
Island
Santa Cruz .
Island .
FIGURE 16. Earthquake sequence in 1968 in the Santa Barbara Channel (Sylvester and others, unpub. data).
,
epicenters of earthquakes that occurred during the period
June-August 1968;O, epicenters of earthquakes that occurred during the period July 1967 to June 1968.
50
collapse of the front facade, and failure of some older mapped at the time, but contemporary accounts and
interior adobe walls. Nunn (1925) reports that crude recent geologic studies (Wallace, 1968; Vedder and
oil was extruded through beach sand at several points Wallace, 1968) demonstrate substantial right-lateral
along the Santa Barbara coast about 3 hours before displacement on a fault break at least 150 miles long.
the main earthquake and at approximately the same The effects of this earthquake are comparable to those
time as a series of slight foreshocks began. An oil of more recent earthquakes of about 8.0 magnitude.
spout also was observed at the shoreline near the west Early descriptions indicate that all the houses in
end of the present Summerland oil field one night Santa Barbara were damaged (Wood, 1955) and that
after an earthquake in 1883 (Goodyear, 1888). The shaking in the Santa Clara River Valley east of
epicenter of this magnitude 6.3 earthquake was prob- Ventura was severe. Differential subsidence occurred
in the river bed, and long cracks formed from which
ably less than 10 miles southwest of Santa Barbara.
The third major earthquake occurred on November water was ejected to heights of 6 feet.
11,1927, northwest of the channel off Point Arguello
GEOLOGIC RECORD
(Byerly, 1930). This shock, with a magnitude of 7.5,
An indication of long-term seismic activity is proranks as the second largest California earthquake
vided by data on the amount, rate, and nature of
since the San Francisco earthquake of 1906. Effects
crustal deformation at the earth's surface. Accurate
were most pronounced at Surf and Honda, just north
dating of the deformation of such features as young
of Point Arguello, where people were thrown from rock units, terraces, drainages, or other geologic
their beds, the concrete highway was cracked, a railmarkers yields a useful and reliable extension of
road bridge was damaged, and several hundred
historic and instrumental records.
thousand cubic feet of sand were shaken down from
The Santa Barbara Channel region is a part of the
a beach cliff. Buildings were damaged along the
Transverse Range province, in which west-trending
coast from Cambria, about 80 miles northwest of Point
structures and topographic features contrast with the
Arguello, to Gaviota, 28 miles to the east. A seismic
predominantly northwest structural and topographic
sea wave was generated by the main event, and seistrends found elsewhere in California, especially those
mic disturbances from the main shock and some of its
of the adjoining Coast Range, Sierra Nevada, and
stronger aftershocks were felt in ships at sea. The
Peninsular Range provinces (fig. 1). Many of the
seismic sea wave, or tsunami, was observed at Surf
latest fault movements in the Santa Barbara Channel
and Pismo Beach, 10 and 40 miles, respectively, north
region seem to involve vertical slip, although many
of Point Arguello. The wave was at least 6 feet high
and resembled a large storm wave. At Port San Luis of the larger fault zones, such as the Santa Ynez,
(Avila) near Pismo Beach, a 5-foot wave was followed Big Pine, and Santa Monica, may have had major leftlateral components of movement in the geologic past.
by 1 hour of water agitation. Tide gage records at
The Santa Ynez fault zone, which trends westward
San Francisco and San Diego confirm this tsunami.
for
about 82 miles along the northern margin of the
The last of the four important earthquakes occurred
Transverse
Ranges (fig. 1), exhibits some physiogon June 30,1941. Its magnitude was 5.9-6.0, and its
raphic evidence that suggests recent movements, and
epicenter was located in the channel about 5 miles
it has been considered an active tectonic feature by
south of the coastline between Santa Barbara and
some geologists (Page and others, 1951). The magCarpinteria. Several communities along the Santa
nitude 7.5 earthquake off Point Arguello in 1927 may
Barbara coast were damaged.
have occurred on the westward extension of the Santa
The historic records of the channel region document
numerous periods characterized by sequences of fre- Ynez fault zone.
The Big Pine fault, a major left-lateral fault with
quent or nearly continuous low-magnitude seismic
activity without exceptionally large shocks (table 3). oblique slip near its western end, may have had
Such sequences are called "earthquake swarms" and measurable movement during historic time. The
are commonly associated with volcanic activity; how- southern California earthquakes of November 1852
ever, there is no evidence of a volcanic origin for the (table 3) were accompanied by about 30 miles of surearthquake sequences in the Santa Barbara Channel face faulting in Lock wood Valley (Townley and
region.
Alien, 1939) about 40 miles northeast of Santa Barbara.
A more distant earthquake, but one that strongly The exact trend and location of the surface faulting
shook the northern part of the Santa Barbara Channel is unknown, but geologic evidence and contemporary
(Wood, 1955) occurred January 9,1857. Its epicenter reports indicate that it may have been along the Big
was on the San Andreas fault near Fort Tejon, about Pine fault. Independent evidence of very young
50 miles northeast of Santa Barbara. The surface movement along the fault includes scarplets that cut
faulting that accompanied this earthquake was not Quaternary terrace deposits and apparent left-lateral
51
offset of stream channels (Vedder and Brown, 1968). because they conformably overlie older rocks, they
The Malibu Coast fault, a segment of the Santa provide clear evidence that the structure has been
Monica fault zone southeast of the Santa Barbara formed since early Pleistocene time. At Loon Point,
Channel, is not known to have had recent movement 6 miles east of Santa Barbara, upper Pleistocene
However, faulting and local warping associated with alluvial fan deposits are tilted and cut by a northeastthe fault have deformed upper Pleistocene marine- trending thrust fault that offsets the base of the
terrace platforms and their deposits at seven known oldest fan by at least 400 feet (Lian, 1954). This
localities along a 20-mile segment of the fault border- faulting may have continued into Holocene time.
ing the south side of the Santa Monica Mountains Faulted terrace deposits are well exposed about 2
(Yerkes and Wentworth, 1965).
miles southeast of Carpinteria, where highway cuts
That recent topographic surfaces and very young reveal a southwest-dipping (40) reverse fault that
rock units have been deformed in the eastern part of juxtaposes upper Pleistocene marine terrace deposits
the channel region has long been recognized. In the and highly deformed Tertiary sandstone and siltstone.
Ventura anticline, lower Pleistocene strata form the This fault may also cut the present topographic surupper part of a sedimentary sequence that is more face; presumably it has moved during Holocene time.
than 40,000 feet thick. These lower Pleistocene beds
Several west-trending faults have been mapped in
dip 35-60 on the south flank of the anticline, and, the northeast part of the channel (fig. 17), and sub119 35'
Santa
Barbara Q
3420'
EXPLANATION
____1____
Fault
Bar and ball on downthrown side
SMILES
Platform
Anticlinal axis
Bathymetry by R. G. Martin, Jr.. 1969.
from U S Geological Survey
precision fathometer records
FIGURE 17. Bathymetric contours and structural features of the central part of the Rincon trend.
11
May
i ftnn
1812
7-8 to
7-9.
I IIH?)
I IIK?)
10:30
12-21
1815 - 1-18 to
1-30.
IX
Morning
12-8
i q qn
I IIK?)
VTTT
Local time
10-8 to
11-18.
99
Month
and day
Year
Maximum
R.F.
intensity 1 Magnitude
-do-
Santa Barbara-
-do-
-do-
General location of
maximum intensity area
and (or) epicentral area
IX-X
VTTT
R.F. intensity 1
Santa Barbara area
DT OCTO _
San
Remarks
[Question mark entries are used for original queried entries, or where present author entered an interpretation based on incomplete data. Remarks enclosed in parentheses are interpretations drawn from incomplete
accounts. The primary source for the information presented is the catalog of Townley and Alien (1939); data after 1928 have been compiled from various sources and are limited to the larger events]
TABLE 3. Partial list of earthquakes felt in the vicinity of Santa Barbara Channel, 1800 to 1952
ro
O
W
H
>
03
>
03
B
ii
o
F
O
f
O
to
3-26
1862
1872
02:30
19:30
15:00
VIIK?)
4-16
I860
3-14
IX-X
1-9
IX
VIK?).
VIII,
7-10
VI
IX X
1-f
20:15
6-25
1855
1857
14:00
- 4-20 to
5-31.
3-1
- 1-29
11-27 to
11-30.
1854
1853
1852
Owens Valley-
Goleta
Fort Tejon
Santa Barbara-
Fort Tejon-
Santa Barbara-
Los Angeles-
VIK?)
III(?)
VIIK?)
VI
Santa Barbara
-do-
V('
Santa Barbara
CO
W
>
8H
"d
*J
ui
O
O
VI
O
HH
H
02
do
III
VI
19:00
04:30
8-30
9-5
1881
1883
u u
i no3
VI(?)
01:20 to
08:15.
7-9
(?)
03:14
6-14
1890
III
02:00
4-7
1885
HI
8-2 to 4
1884
9-13
Santa Barbara
22:30
11-12
08:30
4-12
1880
do
Santa Barbara
Ventura
do
do
Ventura
Ventura County-
-----
V ( "> 1
V(?)
IV(?)
IIK?)
IIK?)
V(?)
Ill
IIK?)
IV(?)
IIK?)
do
1-8
1878
V VI
R.F. intensity 1
Santa Barbara area
do
6-23
1877
23:50
12-21
1875
Local time
Year
General location of
maximum intensity area
and (or) epicentral area
Month
and day
Maximum
R.F.
intensity 1 Magnitude
An
shonk ppn1-pr>pri
-i n-t-pnsia lon^l
Remarks
TABLE 3. Partial list of earthquakes felt in the vicinity of Santa Barbara Channel, 1800 to 1952 Continued
Jr1
td
td
Kj
1 1
fO
d
o
i
f
O
0
O
f
Cn
VIK?)
VIIIIX.
7-27 to
8-14.
IIK?)
Los Alamos -
VIII
7-27
22:57
Pine Crest-
Santa Barbara-
Do.
V(?)
-do-
Santa Barbara-
Southern California
Santa Barbara-
VI(?)
IIH?)
vim
mm
IIH?)
VII
VII
Ventura
7-21
2-7 to
2-9.
1902
21:30
12-23
5-29 to
6-3.
16:10
7-26
1895
1898
21:12
7-29
1894
6-24 to
7-19.
04:00
6-1
1897
16:35
5-18
as
O
ii
O
u
>
Cd
>
>
M
"3
M
O
as
o
0202
o
II
II
02
OJ
21:30
9-10
7-3
1907
August
01:10
3-18
1905
IIK?)
IIK?)
VI
20:40
10-20
IK?)
IK?)
Pine Crest-
Ojai
Ventura
IIK?)
10-15
1904
IIK?)
Remarks
Los Angeles-
UK?)
10-14
UK?)
IK?)
do
-do
UK?)
R.F. intensity 1
Santa Barbara area
Los Alamos
General location of
maximum intensity area
and (or) epicentral area
VIII
12-12
10-21
Local time
Maximum
R.F.
intensity 1 Magnitude
Ventura
Year
Month
and day
TABLE 3. Partial list of earthquakes felt in the vicinity of Santa Barbara Channel, 1800 to 1952 Continued
!>
a!
H
OJ
O
II
H
OJ
M
a!
H
OJ
TJ
M
H
O
f
M
.9
O
&
O
f
O
57
P
rO
H
)-> h
T3 V C rO rO
(U 4-1
-P
rO
+J
,Q
r-l
fc
(U bO fc
<1) -P , C rO
H 3 -H -H PQ
C f> 3 ^
(U
O rO rO
O > M 1 -H
O
M C
>> C M-i
rO
H -H O -H CO
> T)
fi
rO k -H bO fc
,Q rO M -H rO
O C O J (U
fc fc S
C
0)
4-i
ft (!)
PQ -H rO **
^
3 -H O
0 C O C -H
O rfl 1 h -H
1 CO bO O O
M
3 4-1 (U
k O -H -H
(U rfl fc H C
bO (1) ,C rO O
k C -H O S
rO
J
O
M
H
OJ
-H
rO
-H
rO
H
(U
4-i
H
(U
M-i
O
M
H
rO
O
M
H
rO
^
O-H
O rO
f, -n
03 O
A:
r-l T3
H
rO -H
OM
O (U
H
rO
OO
O -M
fc
r-l -H
O
H
, 0)
bO C
H -H
r-IPu
O
ft (U
fc-l->
rO C
rC O
MS
<C
<C
rO C
0 rO
O
H rO
fc
-)-) 3
, !->
bO C
-H (U
r-l >
<
,x
O
O
ff.
M
O
O
fi
M
M rO
(U
(U k
H rO
rO
fc rO
(U fc
*O rO
to
e ^
rO >,
O PQ H
-H
3 M
rO 1-3 (U
-M -H
H
. C A! (U
bO rO O bO
-HCOOC
r-l
,C <
C
-H
M
H
>, O
rO-l->>J
^ H rO
(U (U 0) -M
> (4n rCrO
(1)
co
M
M
M
1
M
M
M
M
M
O
M
H
rO
O ^1 r-l
H
H
Q)
^ C -H
O O H
O
(U
1
r f^
+J
3
rO
O
-M
M >, C
r-l rO
C
rO
CO rO
fc
k rO
rO ^a
(U ^
C rO
PQ
C ^a co
H rO
(U
^
rO
3
^a -o
T3
O C
^ rO
Pu
^ rO
f,
H rO
f^-H
rO C
(U ^
O
M
(U
^
rO
3
o*
3
-H
C
<U
>
'-N
r-l -H
rO
(U H
rO
MH rO -H k
O ,^~i rO
>i
bO >
i 1 C "H ^
Q) ^ i 1 rO
O (U M DQ
H
3
H
^
bO
*H
H
M
(U
f-i
(U
H
C
(U
O
rO
-P
C
rO
CO
rO
-H
C
rO
CO
-H
rO
>.
H
-H
.
bO
-H
H
M
"O
(U C -H
^ rO H
rO H (U
O'M
(U
-M
rO
^i
(U
O
"O
SO
E- H
S
P-L,
rO
H >, k
Q) -I-* rO
3 C ^a
bO 3 4
-H O rO
S 0 PQ
<
-H
n3
rO
C1) -H
i
H
T3
C
(DC
T3 fM rrj
C1)
M
S4
C1) >! (U
+J -H i-l
cJ C <U
( \) 3 bO
CJ O C
0 <
tj fJ
,i {, rO M
cJ ^
. O
_
O 3 J
^! -H
oo C -H
(U rO
^
-H
C
(U
>
<U
H
rO
0
O
H
M
M
rO
PU
4-1 -H
M M
J-t C
(U (U
^ -)-)
C OJ C
O PQ -H
n
(U
C
rO
CO
rO
H
C
rO
CO
(1)
T3
(3
C3
T:3
(3
T3
rO
C
rO
r-l
M
^3
r-l
rO
PQ
3
bO
H
S
rO
M
(1)
>
H
K
O H
H co
T3
J.^
^t
t>0 "H
H-O -H
i~H 4 rC *
rO bO-H
' U C -H rO
( U X r-l -n
J^ O 03 O
S. :
H
H rO -H -H C
fc-H 3 rO
^ 3 S ^a
rO -H
rO
(U C rO ^ h
C (U ft rO rO
> O (U >
(U
O3^
^ <-H
rO
rO -H ^
PQ
3 rO rO >
cT-nS Hd rO
0
j -H
ft
"O M C
fc -H C M rO
rO rO rO M CO
_r^
CO
^~
H\
H\
M
M
M
M
J >
-M
,
bO
-H
H
M
>>
H
_Q
rO
^a
O
^
PU
fa [/)
rO-H M C
3 O -H
(U J J
-o
H C
<U
S rO M -H
CO (U fc
^
H O >
(U -H fl) ft!>
> rO bO (U
O
C fc "O
X
C
H M
-H rO
H
M rO
(U M O T->H
4-i rO J 0 M >,
S
M H
X
T3 T3
(U
O >1 C C M >
O -)-) (d rO (U -H
XI -H
-H -H
M M O M -H O
C ft O-H (U
bO (U M > M ft
C -H -H -H CM
O C ft r-l <U <U
fc M O O -M ^
H
CO
rO
h
rO O
rQ
rO
+j
C
rO
CO
M -)-)
rO-H
-!-> fl
C 0
rO
H
H
3
rO
rO
H
H
H 3 (U
rO J bO
rO
H C S
i 1 rd TO
0) (/)
MH
S
>i O
H fc
r-l 4-i
rO
h "O
(U C
C rO
(1)
U)
rO
T; 3
J-.
n0
f
5
O
r-l
<1)
3
bO
-H
CO
M
M
OJ
PU
C
O
n
H
M
rO
(U
k
O
^
ft
O
O
-H
^
rO
S
MH
c o
rO
CO
^
O
ft
(1)
CO M ^
,
1
1
1
^t
^_i
C
3
O
O
-H
3
O
rO O "O
PQ ft 0)
rC
(1)
C
rO
CO
H
H
.|_J
0-
M
M
M
M
M
H
C
3
O
O
i:3
"rC
-H bO
-H C
ft<C
(U
O M
^ O
(U J
ft
.
rO
(1)
K*l
rO
h
rd
>
h
rO
PQ
4-i H
(U (U
(U >iH H
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
O
C
H
"O
h
rO
C
k
<1)
PQ
-H
"4-i rO
(U T3 O
fa
rO
^
^
rO
PQ
rO
H
rO
CO
T3
0
S
-H
rO
-n
0
6.3
04:00 to
23:00.
II IIK?)
-do-
7-5
VIK?)
do
10:21
7-3
VIK?)
Santa Barbara-
08:38
7-3
VIK?)
6-29 to
10-9.
Remarks
IK?)
IIK?)
R.F. intensity 1
Santa Barbara area
Santa Barbara-
IX
6-29
06:42
II VII
2-7 to
4-15.
IV
Ojai------------------
09:30
1-28
1925
IX
VIIK?)
Santa Barbara
18:48
6-20
1920
General location of
maximum intensity area
and (or) epicentral area
12-30
02:08
6-18
Year
Maximum
R.F.
intensity 1 Magnitude
1924
Local time
Month
and day
TABLE 3. Partial list of earthquakes felt in the vicinity of Santa Barbara Channel, 1800 to 1952 Continued
>
>
o
H
W
>
II
CO
M
i
.3
O
F
M
Oi
00
1926
V
IIIC?)
UK?)
IV
02:15
10:18
05:53
8-12
8-13
10-30
1-12
2-18
5-3
17:30
15:21
6-27
6-29
VIIK?)
Santa Barbara
VenturaVIIK?)
Santa Barbara-
07:30
6-24
IV
IIK?)
Ojai
5-14
VI(?)
IIK?)
IIK?)
IIK?)
Ojai-
Santa Barbara-
Ojai
-do-
VK?)
VI+
IVC?)
7-30
7^6 to
7-9.
O
II
H
>
Cd
>
CO
H
O
H
CO
H
H
O
H
O
CJ
CO
CO
H
ii
CO
CO
1927
Year
15:00
09:45
09:42
20:12
09:49
7-3
7_6
8-6
8-8
9 ~ 28
00:17
03:20
17:55
04:24
1-1
5-15(?)
7-15
8-4
Ventura
V+
VI+
Imperial Valley
V+
VIII
Ventura
III+
12-19(7)
to
12-20(?)
____
Ventura-
Santa Barbara
do
do
General location of
maximum intensity area
and (or) epicentral area
Imperial Valley
V-VI
VC?)
V+(?)
IV
II
Maximum
R.F.
intensity 1 Magnitude
11-24
11-4 to
11-11.
Local time
Month
and day
IIK?)
IK?)
IV (0)
________________
________________
R.F, intensity 1
Santa Barbara area
Buildings swayed.
Remarks
TABLE 3. Partial list of earthquakes felt in the vicinity of Santa Barbara Channel, 1800 to 1952 Continued
GEOLOGY,
DSECHANNEL,
PVSANTA
EBICAL
TSLARMORPILMBCEAIUNTRMYA,
OS
O
03:25
17:54
3-10
6-30
4-1
1930
1933
1941
1945
IV
VII-IX
IX+
VIII
VI-VII
15:43
23:51
19:32
05:51
11-4
8-5
03:00 to
03:30
11-4
11-18
04:40
8-26
Santa Barbara-
5.4
Long Beach
---
Santa Barbara
UK?)
VIII
IIK?)
IV(?)
Santa Maria-'
--
VI-VII
IK?)
5.9
6.3
7.5
Santa Barbara-
as
H
S
O
W
>
OT
H
o
H
d
H
as
!SH
8-27
7-21
Year
1949
1952
03:52
06:52
VI
Maximum
R.F.
Local time intensity 1
7.7
4.9
Magnitude
VIII(?)
Kern County
Remarks
III(?)
R.F. intensity 1
Santa Barbara area
General location of
maximum intensity area
and (or) epicentral area
Month
and day
TABLE 3. Partial list of earthquakes felt in the vicinity of Santa Barbara Channel, 1800 to 1952 Continued
fed
t"
o
r
I-H
"d
CO
>
Cd
fed
fed
fed
tr1
O
d
K
63
The intensity of ground shaking during an earthquake depends largely on local geologic factors; chief
of these are the thickness and physical properties of
the materials composing the uppermost few hundred
meters beneath the site. In general, the greatest amplitudes and longest durations of ground motion
have been observed on thick, water-saturated, unconsolidated materials.
Although field experimental data that bear on
ground amplification are sparse, research has been
been done on seismic waves generated by underground nuclear explosions in Nevada and recorded
64
Some of the effects that might accompany earthquakes in the channel region have been demonstrated
by several moderate earthquakes in the Los Angeles
area, the Kern County earthquake of 1952, and the
Alaska earthquake of 1964.
In October 1941, a moderate earthquake (magnitude
4.9) affected the southwest part of the Los Angeles
basin. The epicenter (as located instrumentally) was
about 3 miles southeast of the Dominguez oil field on
the Newport-Inglewood zone of faults and folds. On
the same date, 15 flowing wells in the western part
of the Dominguez field were damaged by subsurface
movement on and near a previously recognized southdipping reverse fault that trends west, subparallel
to the Dominguez anticline. Bravinder (1942) concluded (1) that the faulting was due to relief of preexisting stresses near the crest of the anticline, and
(2) that the relieved stresses were chiefly tectonic in
origin.
In November of the same year (1941) a second
earthquake, with a magnitude of 5.4, occurred with
an instrumental epicenter about 4 miles south of that
of the October earthquake. No subsurface damage
was reported, although the Long Beach oil field is
less than 2 miles from the epicenter; however, surface
installations in the Torrance-Gardena area northwest
of the epicenter were damaged. Two storage tanks
on unconsolidated alluvium were "destroyed" and two
more were badly buckled, a 6-inch oil pipeline (broken
in one place during the October earthquake) was ruptured in four additional places, and an 8-inch naturalgas pipeline was broken. Ground cracks formed near
the broken oil line (Wood and Heck, 1941).
Two and a half years later, on June 18, 1944, two
moderate earthquakes (magnitude 4.4 and 4.5) occurred, with instrumental epicenters between that of
the October 1941 shock and the Dominguez oil field.
Later the same day, 16 oil wells in the Rosecrans
field, 4J/4 miles northwest of the epicenters and 2Ms
miles northwest of the Dominguez field, were found
to be damaged by subsurface movement on a southdipping reverse fault that trends west at a small
angle from the axis of the Rosecrans structure
(Martner, 1948). The faulting of October 1941 and
June 1944 is attributed by Richter (1958) to direct
seismic shaking or readjustment of the local strain
pattern.
65
The removal of large volumes of fluid from Cenozoic clastic strata, such as those that contain California
oil reservoirs, has led to complex readjustments within and above the reservoirs. Such readjustments
commonly result in differential subsidence of the
ground surface over and around the reservoir, and,
in some places, in earthquakes and fault displacements. Although these effects may be prevented or
minimized by maintaining original reservoir fluid
pressures through fluid injection during extraction of
the petroleum, fluid injection itself has recently been
recognized as the probable cause of earthquakes in
two places.
More than 40 examples of differential subsidence,
horizonal displacement, or surface faulting have been
associated with the operation of 28 California and
Texas oil fields (Yerkes and Castle, 1969). Maximum
66
recorded movements are: more than 29 feet of differential subsidence and 11 feet of horizontal displacement in the Wilmington oil field and 2.4 feet of fault
displacement in the Buena Vista oil field, California.
Differential subsidence is the most common and
widespread of the effects, but it is easily detected
only in shoreline areas where it may result in local
flooding. Where level surveys have determined the
size and shape of the subsidence bowl, the subsided
areas are centered over and extend well beyond the
producing area. Subsidence was first reported in 1926
over the Goose Creek oil field near Houston, on the
Texas Gulf Coast (Pratt and Johnson, 1926). The
most spectacular and costly example of differential
subsidence in the United States is that of the Wilmington oil field, where an elliptical area of more than
29 square miles has been affected. Large subsidence
bowls also have been delineated over California oil
fields at Huntington Beach, Long Beach, and Inglewood.
Centripetally directed horizontal displacement of
the ground surface accompanies differential subsidence, but can be precisely documented only by triangulation surveys, and hence has been determined
in only three United States oil fields: Buena Vista,
Inglwood, and Wilmington, all in California. Surface
installations such as foundations, piers, and piles are
most seriously affected by such displacements.
Surface faulting, in addition to being the most conspicuous and easily documented effect, may also occur
suddenly, and it is therefore potentially more damaging to oil wells and surface structures. Subsidenceassociated surface faulting is most commonly high
angle and normal, peripheral to the subsidence bowl,
and downthrown on the oil field side; it commonly
trends subparallel to the isobase contours. Examples
of this type have developed over the Goose Creek and
Mykawa fields in Texas and over the Inglewood and
Kern Front fields in California. The surface fault at
Kern Front developed over a preexisting subsurface
fault; the surface break extends for 3 miles and is the
longest known example of this type. Displacement
has been virtually continuous for at least 20 years
and totaled more than 1 foot in 1968.
A thrust fault has formed in response to intense
horizontal compression induced by measured subsidence in a unique example at the Buena Vista oil field
in California. The fault sheared about 20 wells at
depths no greater than 794 feet below the surface and
no further than 1,800 feet from the fault trace, but
the fault has not been detected in numerous other
wells it should intersect if it were a tectonic feature.
Cumulative displacement during 38 years of nearly
continuous movement totals more than 2.4 feet.
Subsurface effects associated with oil-field operations also have been observed at the Wilmington oil
field. In the central part of the field, sharply defined,
nearly horizontal shear movements occurred at average depths of 1,550 and 1,770 feet in December 1947
and November 1949 (Frame, 1952). The movements
were recorded at Pasadena, 28 miles away, as seismograms that were characterized by unusually large
developments of long-period motion, suggestive of
a shallow focus and lack of sharpness at the beginning
of the motion (Hudson and Scott, 1965). Oil wells
intersected by the slippage surfaces were damaged
during each event; the maximum horizontal displacement in each event was about 9 inches (Frame, 1952),
but the sense of displacement was not recorded. The
November 1949 event was a major economic disaster,
involving 302 wells, chiefly in the central part of the
subsidence bowl; damages exceeded $9 million. Similar, less costly events also occurred in August 1951
and January 1955.
Fluid injection seems to have caused earthquakes
in at least two places. The injection of water into a
12,000-foot deep well at the Rocky Mountain Arsenal
northeast of Denver, Colo., is generally considered
to have initiated the earthquake sequence that began
there in 1962 (Healy and others, 1968). Three of
these earthquakes had magnitudes greater than 5 and
resulted in minor damage. The probable cause of the
earthquakes was weakening of rock through increased
pore pressure, which allowed natural rock stresses to
be released. Another situation that possibly is similar
to that in Denver was subsequently recognized in the
oil field near Rangely, Colo. (Healy and others, 1968).
The earthquakes there occurred in areas of highpressure gradients generated by injection of water
for purposes of secondary recovery.
SUMMARY
Remarks
67
Hazard Continued
Remarks Continued
68
Operators have provided the information that platforms on offshore Federal leases have been designed
by engineering consultants in conformance with
regional construction code standards. For example,
the platforms on Dos Cuadras field have a freeboard
69
REFERENCES CITED
70
APPENDIX A
History of Well No. A-21, Lease OCS P-0241, as Compiled by M. V. Adams,
Petroleum Engineer, U.S. Geological Survey, June 1969
71
72
After checking out and testing the HOWCO pumping units 1,000 barrels of sea water was pumped down
the drill pipe at a rate of 27 barrels per minute and
a pressure of 2,500 psi. The water was followed with
210 barrels of 116-lb mud pumped at a rate of 27
barrels per minute and a pressure of 2,650 psi. At
this point a line blew off the fracing head and it was
necessary to shut down the HOWCO pumps to repair
it. After effecting repairs the mud in the drill pipe
was displaced with 230 cubic feet of sea water and
the well was shut in. During the entire operation
the casing pressure on the well had remained at 190
psi. However, after pumping the mud the bubble at
the east end of the platform was noticeably smaller
but after 10 minutes it had returned to its original
size.
In the meantime a massive effort had been made
on the part of essentially all of the operating and
service companies in the area to assemble mud, equipment and cement for a maximum effort to kill the
well. This effort commenced at 11:05 a.m. on February
7, by pumping sea water with dye, calcium chloride
water and mud down the drill pipe while repairing
leaks in lines and organizing the pumping operation.
Steady pumping down the drill pipe began at 4:00
p.m. and by 5:00 p.m. all nine HOWCO units were in
operation pumping mud down the drill pipe at a rate
of 30 barrels per minute and a pressure of 3,750 psi.
At this time the rig pumps started pumping mud
down the annulus. By 5:30 p.m. the bubble began to
decrease and the well was eventually killed with 13,000
barrels of 90-lb to 110-lb mud.
73
APPENDIX B
Seepage at Lease OCS P-0241 estimated by the U.S. Geological Survey for the
period March 22 to August 31, 1969
Time period
To
From
Mar.
Apr.
May
May
22 3
3
3
23*
June
June
June
June
July
July
July
July
Aug.
15 5
19
27 5
29
2s
3
14 5
16 6
I6 7
Days
elapsed
Apr. 2
May 2
May 22
June 14
June 18
June 26
June 28
July 1
-- July 13
July 15
July 31
Aug. 31
Totals
12
30
20
23
4
8
2
3
1
11
2
16
31
12
51
1
253
4
128
86
163
1,954
3 .0
7 .3
17 .7
25 .6
9 .2
22 .8
6
17
1
23
2
8
2 .8
324
681
246
101
83
57
48
39
29
77
36
112
224
-- -
360
901
600
691
120
239
27
22. 7
12. 3
4. 4
20. 8
7. 2
24
13
29
7
18
7
7. 2
60
90
30
330
40
240
310
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
20
15
10
4,011
2,057
APPENDIX C
Drilling Programs Authorized for Lease OCS P-0241 Following Recommendations of the Presidential Advisory Panel Transmitted June 2,1969
Well
Rig
Drilling Producing
distance, zones
in feet
A-3
Vertical
1,260
plug
back
1,159
A-22
Vertical
475
A 24
Vertical
A-44
Slant
Perfs.
(RT)
Casing depth vertical penetration, in feet, for in______dicated casing diameter, in inches________
20
16
13 378
10 3/4
9 5/8
(cement
(drive) (cement) conductor) (cement) (cement) (cement)
Brown
608-1,140
19
104
Red
344-471
16
107
1,092
Brown
578-1,082
101
1,971
plug
back
1,705
Brown--
713-1,677
10
B-13-- Vertical
1,284
Brown--
738-1,279
B-18-- Vertical
1,150
core
hole
B-30
Vertical
1,275
Brown- -
B-40
Slant
1,610
B-47-- Slant
1,588
plug
back
1,400
276
801
196
255
797
101
261
832
15
92
310
886
15
98
299
670-1,264
14
101
315
861
Brown--
813 1,601
90
332
900
Brown
826 1,395
10
284
811
Brown
test
and
shut-in
648-53
772-97
1,089-94
108
867
74
Well
Rig
Drilling
distance, Producing zones
in feet
Perfs.
CRT)
Upper zones
A 37
Slant
2,300
Yellow
Purple
1,385-2,210
10+
101
234
857
E
1,744
A ,_! I o
o T -i -* +- _
ocnn
Yellow
Purple
Yellow
1,350 2,385
10
100
235
855
E
1,975
R Ul
^1 an-h
Yellow
Purple
Yellow
1,470-2,400
10+
98
345
879
1,831
Yellow
Purple
Yellow
1,565-2,662
B-U3
Slant
U7^
2,750
12
100
237
827
E
1,912
Lower zones
A-30
Vertical
3,500
Purple
Orange
Green
2,180-3,438
10+
100
255
1,052
E-2
3,107
A-36-- Vertical
4,250
Purple
Orange
Green
2,810-4,160
11
100
255
1,015
E-l
3,445
B-29-- Vertical
3,900
Purple
Orange
Green
2,060-3,818
10+
100
360
1,134
E-l
3,330
B-2
4,150
Orange
Green
2,960-4,090
10+_
101
306
1,151
E-l
3,231
Vertical
75
APPENDIX D
Status of wells drilled from Platform A on Lease DCS P 0241, May 10, 1969, showing selective pressure
drawdown zones authorized
Well
A-20
Rig
Vertical
Drilling
distance,
in feet
Producing
zones
Perforations
(drilled depth, in feet)
Production
(bbl oil per day)
3 cno
Purple
Orange
Green
2,131 3,427
2,110
591-1,070
564
2,433-3,876
1,056
plug
back
3,442
A-21
Vertical
1,081
(redrill)
Brown
A-25
Vertical
4,550
plug
back
3,900
Orange
Purple
Orange
Green
A-38
Slant
3,030
plug
back
1,086
Brown
685-1,010
/Will-
Slant
3,010
plug
back
1975
Brown
Yellow
946 1,916
Shut in
982
76
APPENDIX E
Blowouts from outer Continental Shelf drilling and workovers since enactment of OCS Lands Act of 1953
No.
--
____
-
---
How
controlled
__
---
Volume
oil spill
___
__
133
--
4428
3299
?860
Extent of damage
2
3
4
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15 -16 -
Vermilion Block 26
OCS 029, well A-l
Union Oil of California
Eugene Island Block 175
OCS 0438, well A-6 Sinclair Oil S Gas Co.
South Pass Block 27
OCS 0353, well 25
Shell Oil Company
West Delta Block 45
OCS 0138, well E-7
CATC
S. Timbalier Block 134
OCS 0461, well D-l
Gulf Oil Corporation
Vermilion Block 115
OCS 0770, well 1
Phillips Petroleum
Co.
Grand Isle Block 9
OCS 035-S, well 1-34 B
Freeport Sulphur Co.
West Delta Block 28
OCS 0384, well 3
Chevron Oil Company
West Delta Block 117
OCS-G-1101, well A-5
Gulf Oil Corporation
Eugene Island Block 273
OCS-G-0987, well 4
Pan American Petroleum
Corp.
Eugene Island Block 158
OCS-G-1220, well B-3
Shell Oil Company
S. Marsh Island Block
48 OCS 0786, well B-4
Gulf Oil Corporation
S. Timbalier Block 21
OCS 0263, well 70
Gulf Oil Corporation
Ship Shoal Block 208
OCS G-1294
Union Oil of California
Eugene Island Block
275 OCS G-0988, well A-9
Texaco Inc.
S. Timbalier Block 67
OCS 020, well C-12
Humble Oil B Refining
Co.
Gas; 11,435';
6-8-56 to
11-7-56.
Drilled
relief
well.
Lost platform,
rig, and two
wells by crater.
Gas; 11,290';
10-19-57
(11 hours).
Gas; 1,869';
6-14-58 (2
hours).
Oil; (swabbing);
10-15-58 to
11-21-58.
Bridged-
Gas; 4,880';
7-27-59 (4 hours).
Bridged
Gas; 13,001';
11 18-60 (4
hours).
Bridged
None reported.
Gas; (shallow);
3-18-62 (36
hours).
Gas; 10,871';
1-15-64 (12
hours).
Gas and oil; (completed); 1 20-64
to 1-27-64.
Gas; 684'; 6-30-64
(2 days)
Ceased----
Mud
No damage.
BridgedBy last of
three
relief
wells.
Bridged -
(None reported. )
Explosion, then
fire. Two other
wells also. Lost
platform. Seven
casualties.
Caught fire but
little damage.
(None reported.)
--- ----
(None reported.)
Ceased
Gas; 15,867';
3-15-65 (5
days).
Gas; (shallow);
9-16-65 (Several
days).
Gas; 11,716';
9-25-65 to
10-8-65.
Oil; (workover);
2-5-66 (15 min.).
Bridged
Installed
valve.
(None reported.)
(None reported.)
Ceased----
(None reported .)
Little damage.
Ceased---Ceased
Bridged-
How
controlled
77
Volume
oil spill
Extent of damage
(None reported.)
19
20
21
22
90
24
S. Timbalier Block
OCS 0463, well J-15
Gulf Oil Corporation
South Pass Block 62
OCS G-1294
Shell Oil Company
Grand Isle Block 43
OCS 0175
Continental Oil Co.
S. Timbalier Block 67
OCS 020, well C-16
Humble Oil & Refining
Co.
S, Marsh Island Block
38 OCS 0784
Pan American Petroleum
Corp.
Vermilion Block 119
OCS 0487, well D-ll
Continental Oil Co.
Vermilion Block 46
OCS 0709, well A-3
Mobil Oil Corporation
Ship Shoal Block 72
OCS 060, well 3 Mobil
Oil Corporation
Oil; (workover);
2-21-68 (1 hour).
Closed
valve .
Cemented
drill
pipe.
Later removed
rig, platform
settled.
Mud
Capped----
900 bbl
per day;
2,500 bbl
total.
No damage,
300-500 bbl
per day
(None reported
on platform.)
Pacific region
1
Cemented