Alchemy PDF
Alchemy PDF
Alchemy PDF
DOI 10.1007/s10781-009-9070-3
In 1987, Tibetan doctors in Lhasa resumed the public practice of a major, week-long
Buddhist ritual known as Accomplishing Medicine (sman sgrub, pronounced
men-drup). Held on the grounds of the state-funded Factory of Traditional
Tibetan Medicines in the center of the capital, the ceremonies are conducted by
doctors who work in the Lhasa Mentsikhang (the Hospital of Traditional Tibetan
Medicine) and elsewhere in Tibet. In 2001, when I attended this event, the ritual
officiant was the highly regarded physician and Sakya lama, Tsultrim Gyeltsen, and
the ritual actors were mainly senior Mentsikhang doctors, all of whom were
authorized to perform the ceremonies by virtue of possessing the empowerments
F. Garrett (&)
Buddhist Studies, Centre for the Study of Religion,
University of Toronto, 170 St. George St., Toronto, ON M5R 2M8, Canada
e-mail: [email protected]
123
208
F. Garrett
(dbang) and oral transmissions (lung) of the Buddhist Yuthok Heart Essence
(G.yu thog snying thig) tradition. Over the course of the week, these doctors
engaged in a complex series of procedures simultaneously inside and outside the
building. Gathered around a large man: d: ala erected inside a highly decorated
medium-sized meeting room, Tsultrim Gyeltsen led one group of doctors in a
continuous course of recitation, while outside in the courtyard another group conducted a multi-day series of burnt offering (sbyin sreg, Skt. homa) rituals. At the
end of the week Tsultrim Gyeltsen conducted a public long-life empowerment (tshe
dbang). Attended by large numbers of lay people, the event joined medical, religious and lay communities and interests. Many lay people and physicians asserted
that the efficacy of the factorys medicines would be enhanced by this ritual performance, one aim of which is to consecrate the gathered medicinal materials.
Although it is conducted yearly now in a large-scale way in the Tibetan capital
(after a 32 year hiatus beginning in 1955),1 and it is a familiar practice on a more
local and individualized level both inside and outside the Peoples Republic of
China, Accomplishing Medicine has been little commented upon in secondary
scholarship. Aside from a few short ethnographic and practitioner-oriented accounts
of the practice, it has been little explored, its history and literary context unstudied.2
This article, the first in a series, will consider in a preliminary way the textual
existence of Accomplishing Medicine. Leaving ethnographic observations for
another study, the present article will instead begin with the texts that were held in
the hands of the doctor-ritualists I observed in 2001. Sitting in a ring around the
central man: d: ala, what were those doctors reading as the week progressed? Where
did those pages come from, and how do their contents fit into the larger context of
Buddhist or medical ritual or doctrinal literature? What larger historical traditions
did those doctors embody as they sat together in full tantric ritual dress during that
hot week in July, and what might this tell us about historical and contemporary
connections between Buddhist and medical traditions?
In this essay I will argue that while the Accomplishing Medicine ceremonies are
in part focused on the empowerment of medicinal substances, in the ordinary sense
that they are said simply to make medicines work better, there is much more to the
practice than this. A long contextual history of Accomplishing Medicine links it
intimately with esoteric Buddhist yogic and contemplative exercises that are heavily
focused on the alchemical transformation of human waste products into purified
1
Although in 2001, I was told by the Mentsikhang administration that the event had been reestablished as
a yearly ceremony, I have recently heard that it was not performed in 2007 or 2008.
The only two ethnographic accounts of the ritual that I am aware of do not address its history or
literature; see a short ethnography of an Accomplishing Medicine ritual performed by Bonpos in Dolpo in
Kind (2002), and a short article on the performance of an Accomplishing Medicine to accompany a
medical research study in Craig (Forthcoming). Accomplishing Medicine and its contemplative context as
performed in India is addressed in a chapter on ethical and spiritual training for doctors, in Jacobson
(2000). Several short but very interesting ritual manuals on Accomplishing Medicine by the Thirteenth
Dalai Lama have been translated in Thub bstan rgya mtsho, Mullin and Cox (1988, pp. 331354). The
Fourteenth Dalai Lama discusses the importance of Accomplishing Medicine briefly in Bstan dzin rgya
mtsho et al. (2007, pp. 253266). A contemporary Tibetan doctor describes the rite briefly in Donden and
Hopkins (1997, pp. 214218). Some early Accomplishing Medicine literature has been discussed in
Walter (1980). Also see the commentary to Plates 5253 in Dorje and Meyer (1992).
123
209
sacramental substances in a process that unites practitioners with deities and that
aims for supermundane results, such as the attainment of immortality and other
paranormal powers. I will suggest further that this sphere of theory or practice is
what accounts for the close relationship between the development of Tibetan
medicine and the Buddhist Nyingma tradition in particular, and that this littlestudied link is not a marginal feature of Tibetan medicine but rather one that has had
a significant shaping factor on each tradition throughout history.
123
210
F. Garrett
Karmay (1998).
Craig (Forthcomming).
10
11
12
13
123
211
15
For more on these traditions, see White (1996), Walter (1979, 1980), Fenner (1979).
123
212
F. Garrett
and death. (Such an aim is not unique to these practices, of course, as yogic
contemplatives of various esoteric traditions work at creation of a rainbow body.)
Lesser aims include the enhancement of the yogis health or the attainment of
magical or supernatural powers, or siddhi, all of which may make his or her religious practice more effective.
Although the bcud len and sman sgrub traditions do have distinct bodies of
literature, the practices are closely intertwined and share many techniques and
theories. I will leave the question of exploring these tangled connections for a later
study, however, focusing in this article mainly on the sman sgrub, or Accomplishing Medicine, tradition. As I will explain further below, Accomplishing
Medicine is a Buddhist practice with many forms, and it is part of the regular
religious activity of various traditions of Tibetan Buddhism. It is not, in other words,
solely, or even chiefly, an activity of the medical tradition. I will begin, however,
with a discussion of how Tibetan historians have represented the entry of this
Buddhist practice into the medical tradition.
16
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, p. 60). This section can be found translated into English in Kunzang
(2001, p. 179). On the questionable attribution of these figures as Indian, see Taube (1981, p. 15).
123
213
Medicine Buddha calls bdud rtsi sman grub the essence of all the teachings,17 no
small praise, and yet what is actually involved in doing the practice, or where one
might look to learn more, is not made explicit. At G.yu thogs death, his son Bum
seng asks him about the teaching, receiving a rather unhelpful reply:
Are there three different types of consecration, that is one in great detail, a
medium one, and a short one in the Ritual of Turning Medicine into Nectar?
G.yu thog replied: In the greatly detailed type of ritual there are 12 basic
consecrations. Each of them has 10 branch consecrations. So altogether there
are 120 consecrations. In the medium type there are 9 basic consecrations.
Each of them has 10 branches. So there are altogether 90 consecrations. In the
short type there is one basic consecration and 10 branches, so there are 10
consecrations.18
While this is the extent of G.yu thogs explanation here, elsewhere in the biography
the practice is particularly associated with the propitiation of the eight medicine
goddesses and the Medicine Buddha, and with instructions for meditating on the
Medicine Buddha man: d: ala situated within the practitioners body.19 G.yu thog tells
his son Bum seng to practice the bdud rtsi sman grub after first propitiating the
deities. G.yu thog advises Bum seng to begin with taking refuge to the three jewels
and end by dedicating merit, as part of a daily morning practice of 21 recitations of
the name of the principal deity and his mantras and seven recitations of the names of
the attendant deities and their mantras.20
While we may still be unclear about what precisely is involved in doing the
practice of bdud rtsi sman grub, the beneficial effects of doing the practice are
expressed throughout the biography. Most prominently, one may gain the power
over life and death.21 At G.yu thogs deathbed his son asks him pointedly about the
benefit of the bdud rtsi sman grub practice, and G.yu thog mentions only the
practices ability to extend lifespan:
Formerly in India Tsho byed gzhon nu gave the detailed consecration but
once, and the person who received it lived 120 years longer than his apportioned span of life. My ancestor Dre rje Vajra gave once the medium consecrations to a person who subsequently lived 90 years longer than he
otherwise would have done. I have once given to a 93-year-old person the
short consecration, and he was able to live to the age of 103.22
17
Blo bzang chos grag et al. (1982, p. 99), Kunzang (2001, p. 202).
18
Kunzang (2001, p. 318). This citation is present in Rechung Rinpoches translation but not in the 1982
Beijing edition of the biography. The Beijing edition and Rechung Rinpoches translation are based on a
Lhasa Zhol printing houses woodblocks; Rechung Rinpoche has added some sections, however,
including this one, from the Sde dge edition block-prints. I have not had the opportunity to check the Sde
dge text, and so here report only on Rechung Rinpoches translation.
19
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, pp. 8586), Kunzang (2001, p. 193).
20
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, p. 301), Kunzang (2001, p. 320).
21
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, p. 146), Kunzang (2001, p. 224).
22
Kunzang (2001, p. 318). This also appears to be a segment added by Rechung Rinpoche from the Sde
dge edition block-prints (see note 15 above).
123
214
F. Garrett
While extending lifespan seems to be the dominant benefit, other gains are
mentioned. The eight medicine goddesses in India praise the bdud rtsi sman grub
as the spirit of the awareness of all Buddhas of the three times; the instructions for
practicing the power-over-life vidyadhara; the hammer which conquers armies of
disease and evil spirits, pith instructions upheld by the Buddha; and the aural
transmission of the d: akins.23 G.yu thogs father tells him that by practicing the
bdud rtsi sman grub, You will certainly be liberated from illness, evil influences,
disasters and malignant spirits (nad gdon bar chad bgegs), and you will possess
magical powers, clairvoyance, power and strength.24 When G.yu thog engages in
the practice at his fathers urging, he reports that I manifested immeasurable signs
and abilities, and I had a vision of the Medicine Buddha with five companions,
surrounded by a thousand Buddhas. With this, I recognized my own mind as the
dharmakaya.25 Some advantages are helpful for doctors in particular: after
G.yu thog khyung po rdo rje receives the teachings from his father, for example, his
patients bodies appear transparent, revealing all illnesses as clearly as one can see
an olive in the palm of the hand.26
By the time of this seventeenth-century biography of G.yu thog, the practice of
bdud rtsi sman grub was arguably the most central feature of the lifestory of the
founding father of the medical tradition. The biography characterizes the practice in
general as a sadhana focused on deities special to the medical tradition, and in
particular as the tantric act of generating a Medicine Buddha man: d: ala within ones
own body. The reward for this effort is most notably an extended lifespan, but also
to be achieved are a realization of the nonduality of ones own mind and the
Buddhas mindin other words, a traditionally Buddhist realization of ultimate
realityand supernormal powers, including the ability to diagnose any illness by
seeing into patients bodies. Note that these are benefits that attach to the practitioner, and not to the medicinal substances used for healing patients, suggesting that
Accomplishing Medicine or Turning Medicine into Nectar is, in this context, not
essentially aimed at empowering medicines, although they may do that along the
way, but is rather a religious practice specifically for the benefit of doctors.
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, p. 146), Kunzang (2001, p. 224).
24
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, p. 170), Kunzang (2001, p. 238).
25
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, p. 171), Kunzang (2001, p. 239).
26
Blo bzang chos grags et al. (1982, p. 71), Kunzang (2001, p. 185).
123
215
or Amr: tadhara). This figure is one of five supramundane deities associated with the
yoga tantras, belonging to the Ratnasambhava Buddha family; these deities are
supramundane because they are propitiated on the path to liberation, in contrast to
mundane deities who assist with worldly aims. It is here, in the fourth of the Eight
Means of Accomplishment, that we may find teachings of Accomplishing Medicine
and associated topics that became so important to the medical traditions in Tibet. We
can see here, therefore, that in the eyes of Nyingma doxographers, Accomplishing
Medicine is generally seen to be a Mahayoga sadhana cycle focused on a personal
meditation deity, aimed ultimately at liberation from sam
: sara.
In the Nyingma Collected Tantras (Rnying ma rgyud bum) canon, the Means
of Accomplishment sections Nectar Qualities Immortality tantras (Chi med bdud
rtsi yon tan gyi rgyud), as they are called at the beginning of this section of the
canon, include at least twelve distinct texts (although the number and order varies
slightly by canon edition), reaching together over 600 folios in length.28 This is a
fairly large body of literature. These tantras cover a range of esoteric topics,
including primarily contemplative, ritual, alchemical and yogic subtle body practices, much of which is focused on use of the five nectars (bdud rtsi lnga, Skt.
pancamr: ta). These are five impure products of the human bodyfeces, urine, red
bodhicitta or (menstrual) blood, white bodhicitta or semen, and flesh or marrow
(dri chen, dri chu, rak ta or byang sems dmar po, byang sems dkar po, sha chen
or rkang mar)which are to be transformed through a yogic and/or culinary
alchemy into powerful purified substances. The teachings from these tantras have
27
A deity man: d: ala for Vajramr: ta is depicted at Raghu and Lokesh (1995, pp. 3839).
Detailed comparisons of various editions of the Rnying ma rgyud bum can be found online at the
Tibetan and Himalayan Digital Library (http://www.thdl.org/collections/literature/ngb/), documenting
work directed by David Germano, and also at Rig dzin Tshe dbang nor bu Edition of the rNying mai
rgyud bum: An Illustrated Inventory (http://ngb.csac.anthropology.ac.uk/), a catalog by Cathy
Cantwell, Robert Mayer and Michael Fischer.
28
123
216
F. Garrett
been sources for centuries of writing on the use of the five nectars. The tantra known
as the Eight Chapters on Nectar (Bdud rtsi bam po brgyad), for instance, was
also included in the Bka gyur, and has been an especially important source for
Tibetan medical and religious writers focused on all manner of tantric ritual practices utilizing nectars.29 The long-life practice of essence-extraction (bcud len) and
related rituals propitiating the wrathful deity Swirling Nectarwhich spawned a
large body of writing by medical and religious writers on essence-extraction over
hundreds of yearsis the subject of the fourteen-chapter Swirling Nectars
Immortality Tantra (Bdud rtsi khyil ba chi med tshei rgyud) in this Nectar
Qualities Immortality tantras collection. The Precious Rosary Tantra of the
Nature of the Five Nectars of all [the Buddhas] (Thams cad bdud rtsi lngai
rang bzhin rin po che phreng bai rgyud), contains in the ninth of its seventeen
chapters a section on Accomplishing Medicine, and the last tantra of the collection,
the Nectar which Possesses the Light of Wisdom (Bdud rtsi ye shes od ldan gyi
rgyud), is the collections main locus of practical writings on the healing of illness.
The Nectar Qualities Immortality tantras teachings thus range from the most
exalted teachings on the attainment of immortality or absolute liberation, to the
more everyday level of healing common illnesses.
Each of the Eight Means of Accomplishment is given Indian provenance with the
attribution of an Indian originator or source of transmission. The Nectar Qualities
cycle is associated with the Indian master Vimalamitra. Tradition reports that in
India a d: akin gave Vimalamitra the tantra of the deity Mahottara,30 known in
Tibetan as Supreme Heruka (Che mchog he ru ka). Supreme Heruka is the Ratna
family deity associated with Nectar Qualities, embodying all the Buddhas
enlightened qualities. He is also the deity located in the very center of the Eight
Means of Accomplishment man: d: ala, thus placing the teachings of the Nectar
Qualities cycle at the very center of the entire Means of Accomplishment tradition.
Vimalamitra, who spent many years in Tibet in the late eighth or early ninth century, is one of the primary transmitters of Mahayoga and early Great Perfection
(Rdzogs chen) teachings into Tibet. He is especially associated with the Great
Perfection Mind Series (Sems sde) teachings, the Mahayoga Web of Magical
Transformations (Sgyu phrul drwa ba, Mayajala) tantras, and the deity cult of
Nectar Qualities.31 Vimalamitra shared these teachings with Padmasambhava
(although an actual relationship between the two figures is unlikely, so the
mechanics of this transmission is unclear), who taught them to King Khri srong
lde btsan, who promptly had them hidden away.32 The Nectar Qualities teachings
were controversial for Tibetans in the ensuing centuries, likely a result of their
29
For example see Skyem pa tshe dbang (2000, pp. 133134). The full title of the Bdud rtsi bam po
brgyad is Thams cad bdud rtsi lngai rang bzhin dngos grub chen po nye bai snying po mchog. See
Walters dissertation for a translation of the first, third and sixth texts of this set.
30
31
David Germanos work (unpublished manuscript) on the early history of Great Perfection authors has
been helpful for this section.
32
The teachings of both Vimalamitra and Padmasambhava on these topics are addressed in Walter
(1980).
123
217
esoteric and ethically transgressive nature. In the tenth century, the practice of
Accomplishing Medicine was apparently well known enough, and well feared enough, to be condemned in King Yeshe Ods Ordinance, an anti-Nyingma decree
banning dangerous ritual practices dominant in Tibet at the time.33 Consider the
distance traveled by this practice cycle, once outlawed as a danger to the state, a
millennium later performed for public consumption in the Chinese governmentsponsored medical factory of Tibets capital!
_
Vimalamitra, Padmasambhava, and Srsimha,
with his Tibetan translator
Vairocana, comprise the founding fathers of the Nyingma tradition. That these
figures play a critical role in the Nyingma tradition is well known; less often
addressed is the equally critical role they have played in the formation and development of the medical tradition in Tibet. The intertwining of Nectar Qualities
teachings with the history of the medical tradition makes clear that it is with the
Nyingma school that medicine has been particularly connected.
Links between the medical tradition and the Treasure tradition (gter lugs) further
strengthen this bond with the Nyingma. Although the Eight Means of Accomplishment cycles are attributed to Indian originators, the figures responsible for their
centrality in Nyingma practice and literature are two Tibetan Treasure Revealers
who found what Khri srong lde btsan had squirreled away in the ninth century.
Living at around the same time as G.yu thog yon tan mgon po and his students were
editing or composing the Four Tantras (Rgyud bzhi) and the Yuthok Heart
Essence (G.yu thog snying thig), these two figures organized a chaotic mass of
practices and rituals into a coherent textual corpus. Prime among these is Nyang ral
nyi ma od zer (11241192), the first of Tibets prolific Treasure Revealers, and the
central architect of the Eight Means of Accomplishment tradition. Nyang ral discovered one of two sections of the Eight Means of Accomplishment, the Gathering
of All Sugatas (Bde gshegs thams cad dus pa), which records the story of how
these teachings were given by a dakini to a set of eight Indian masters who then
became experts in those practices. Nyang rals large Gathering of All Sugatas
collection, comprising thirteen volumes in the Mtshams brag manuscript edition,
includes a Root Tantra of the Heruka Assembly (Che mchog dus pa rtsa bai
rgyud) and several individual works on Accomplishing Medicine. Nyang rals
incarnate successor, Gu ru Chos dbang (12121270), also a prolific Treasure
Revealer, is responsible for recovery (or authorship) of the second section of the
Eight Means of Accomplishment, that of the Consummation of Eight Secret
Means of Accomplishment (Bka brgyad gsang ba yongs rdzogs). Here too we
find writings specifically addressing Accomplishing Medicine.34
The Eight Means of Accomplishment and its Accomplishing Medicine teachings
are thus among the very earliest of revealed Treasures in Tibet, allegedly traceable
back to the time of the first diffusion of Buddhism into Tibet. Dudjom Rinpoches
account of the early Treasure tradition names Grags pa sngon shes (b. 1012), who is
33
34
A third treasure revealer associated with the Eight Means of Accomplishment canon is Rig dzin rgod
ldem (13371408/09); he was extremely prolific, but I have not identified any texts of his that pertain to
sman sgrub practices.
123
218
F. Garrett
said to have discovered the Four Tantras, as the second great Tibetan Treasure
Revealer, and so with the Four Tantras and the Nectar Qualities texts sharing this
early history, we have the medical tradition firmly situated in the important spot of
the Treasure traditions origins.35 The fact that the Nectar Qualities deity is at the
center of the Eight Means of Accomplishment man: d: ala also indicates the degree to
which the medical tradition located its religious practice in a very important, not at
all marginal, Buddhist arena.
35
36
Only four of these works are included within the Yuthok Heart Essence anthologies published under
that title at Chagpori in the late nineteenth century or more recently by the Ngak Mang Institute (these
collections will be discussed below). It is not clear to me whether the tenth of these, entitled Brang tii
dngul bre las drang srong ser skya spun gsum gyi rig gtad kyi chog mthong gsal me long zhes bya ba
bzhugs so, pages 3747 in volume 46, should be considered part of the Yuthok tradition according to the
Rin chen gter mdzod.
123
219
Heart Essence cycle, Jam mgon kong sprul includes a 30-folio work by Karma
chags med (16101678), an influential Karma Kagyu scholar known for his
syntheses of Kagyu and Nyingma teachings, which became especially important in
the Dpal yul and Gnas mdo traditions. The next cycle includes a sadhana text that
has been transmitted in the Bri gung Dkar brgyud pa tradition, but that was
authored by the renowned physician Zur mkhar mnyam nyid rdo rje (14391475).
Founder of the Zur tradition (zur lugs) of medicine, Zur mkhar mnyam nyid rdo rje
is also closely tied to the development of the Yuthok Heart Essence tradition, as I
will explain further below.
The third cycle of the Precious Treasury Accomplishing Medicine section
features four texts from the Heart Essence of Vimalamitra (Bi ma snying thig)
tradition revealed by Mchog gyur gling pa (18291870), a prolific Nyingma
Treasure Revealer who was one of Jam mgon kong spruls own teachers. This is
followed by a set of three guru sadhana teachings from a text revealed by Jam
dbyangs mkhyen brtsei dbang po (18201892), another of Jam mgon kong spruls
teachers and one of the main figures in the non-sectarian (ris med) tradition.
Next, the fifth cycle contains a famous set of early teachings known as the Great
Vase of Nectar: Healing Techniques (Gso thabs bdud rtsi bum chen) and A
Vase of Immortality Nectar (Chi med bdud rtsi bum pa), attributed to Rdor bum
chos kyi grags pa, an extremely prolific Revealer whose treasures were of great
importance to the medical tradition. These texts are said to be eighth-century works
by Padmasambhava, and they contain a wealth of specific healing techniques for a
wide range of disease conditions, many of which are cited as authoritative by later
medical writers, such as Sangs rgyas rgya mtsho.37
The seventh cycle consists of works revealed by another renowned Treasure
Revealer, Ra mo shel sman ye shes, who lived in the thirteenth century, and edited
in the nineteenth century by Jam dbyangs mkhyen brtsei dbang po. The eighth is a
15-folio Accomplishing Medicine work by Ratna gling pa (14031473), a prolific
Nyingmapa especially known for his authoritative compilation the Collected
Tantras of the Ancients. The ninth cycle features four texts by the Nyingmapa Legs
ldan rdo rje (15121625), and the tenth consists of two works revealed by Jam
dbyangs mkhyen brtsei dbang po. The eleventh and twelfth cycles reprint four
Accomplishing Medicine works by Nyang ral nyi ma od zer and Gu ru Chos dbang,
two of the major organizers of the Eight Means of Accomplishment tradition,
discussed above, and the final cycle records another work by the nineteenth-century
Mchog gyur gling pa. Following these thirteen cycles on Accomplishing Medicine
practices across centuries of writing, the Precious Treasury appends nearly 300
pages of writing specifically on the related practice of essence-extraction (bcud
len); I will not summarize those here, but their inclusion by Jam mgon kong sprul
within the broad category of Nectar Qualities practice should be noted.
Without doubt, a full study of this entire corpus would make a magnificent
contribution to our understanding of the Accomplishing Medicine literary tradition,
37
For references to these works in medical texts, see Skyem pa tshe dbang (2000, p. 985), Sangs rgyas
rgya mtsho (1994, pp. 11451147), Zur mkhar pa blo gros rgyal po (1989, p. 515). Lineage holders of the
Bdud rtsi bam po brgyad are listed along the tops of the seventh and eighth thangkas in Dorje and
Meyer (1992).
123
220
F. Garrett
but short of reaching that stage, I can make three simple points. First, the great
volume of writing on the topic of Accomplishing Medicine (recalling that the
Precious Treasury records only a selection of writings on any given topic) is truly
impressivedespite having rarely been mentioned in secondary scholarship, this is
clearly a major component of Buddhist thought and practice. Second, we may add
this topic to our list of those to which both medical and religious writers were
dedicated, as another example of the interpenetration of medical and religious
realms.38 And third, we should take note of the fact that the Yuthok Heart Essence
itself is but one tradition among many; further research into the particular distinguishing features of these various Accomplishing Medicine traditions will help us
better understand both what we read in these texts and what we see on the ground
when observing an Accomplishing Medicine ritual performance.
For more such examples, see Garrett (2005, 2007, 2008), Gyatso (2004), and Garrett and Adams
(2008).
39
40
Cited in Ibid.
123
221
42
43
The NgaK Mang Institute, founded in Xining in 1999, is an organization dedicated to the preservation
and promotion of tantric traditions and communities through various culture, health and education projects in Tibet and through a network of regional branches worldwide.
123
222
F. Garrett
Sngags mang zhib jug khang (2005, p. 2), and see similar comments on p. 7.
45
Ibid., p. 7.
46
This is actually not true without exception: the Ngak Mang edition divides the work into 49 distinct
texts, but in doing so it divides several works that in the Leh edition are united under a common text title
(although identified by distinctive section headings).
123
223
terms of its contents, a diverse assortment of topics. The 49 texts include writings on
rites of empowerment and long-life, tantric commitments and liturgies for daily
practice; several forms of outer, inner and secret sadhana instructions; supplication
to the protector deities and lineage gurus, and offerings of torma and medicines;
completion stage and Great Perfection yogas; and the occult use of spells and
recipes for healing and exorcism, as well as recommendations for the use of
mantras, yantras, divination, poisoned razors, spinning blades and other protective
and wrathful magical operations. Despite this diversity, the collections practices are
conceptually (if not sequentially) organized into three stages of teaching, meant to
form a complete contemplative-yogic curriculum for the Tibetan doctor. First, its
generation stage (bskyed rim) approach-accomplishment (bsnyen sgrub) practices include directions on approaching the personal deity (yi dam) through
mantra recitation and a request that the deitys charismatic power (byin rlabs) will
descend into the practitioner, followed by a request that the accomplishments of
the various classes of d: akin and sugatas enter ones awareness, both of these being
preliminary steps to taking on the identity of the deity. Also part of this stage of
practice are a range of ritual or magical operations (las tshogs), such as spells,
exorcisms, divinations, and offerings of medicines and torma. Next, the collection
presents a range of completion stage (rdzogs rim) practices, including subtle body
channel (rtsa) yogas that manipulate the presence of the deity in the practitioners
body, wind (rlung) yogas that transform speech into mantra, and quintessential drop
(thig le) yogas that transform the mind into the dharmakaya, plus a form of the set
of six yogic exercises that involve the transformation of inner heat, dreams, clear
light, illusory body, intermediate state, and consciousness transfer, and also a
teaching of subtle body yogic movements (rtsa rlung phrul khor). Finally, the
collection includes a brief set of Great Perfection teachings, including pointing-out
(ngo sprod) instructions for breaking through to primordial purity (ka dag khreg
chod) and directions for the practice of natural release or self-liberation (rang grol).
Considered a full tantric practice cycle, the Yuthok Heart Essence is thus said to
have the power to bestow enlightenment in a single lifetime, giving its practitioners
the ability to attain a rainbow body.47
The Yuthok Heart Essence Guru Sadhana therefore contains a complete tantric
practice that is ultimately oriented toward Nyingma Great Perfection teachings. This
entire set of teachings is also referred to collectively and in a general sense as
Accomplishing Medicine (sman sgrub). Although this core collection is held ordinarily to be the creation of G.yu thog yon tan mgon po, scribed by his student Sum ston
ye shes gzhungs, only the first twenty works of this core collection are in fact
attributed to Sum ston, with the next twenty works, roughly, attributed to the fifteenthcentury Zur mkhar mnyam nyid rdo rje, and the last ten texts attributed to the nineteenth-century Karma jigs med chos kyi seng ge (who is also known as Khams smyon
dharma seng ge). The anthology underwent various revisions and expansions over
many centuries, in other words, and it is therefore impossible to say what G.yu thog
yon tan mgon po may in fact have taught, or even what Sum ston ye shes gzhungs may
47
Sngags mang zhib jug khang (2005, 4). The introduction to this edition contains a more thorough
summary of the collections contents than I have given here.
123
224
F. Garrett
have actually recorded. Zur mkhar mnyam nyid rdo rje revised and expanded the
collection in the fifteenth century, as did Sangs rgyas rgya mtsho in the seventeenth
century. In the early nineteenth century, Kong sprul yon tan rgya mtsho (18131899)
included portions of the anthology in his Precious Treasury, and the anthology was
again revised by Chagporis Karma jigs med chos kyi seng ge in the late nineteenth
century. A body of literature has also grown around this core collection, such that the
Ngak Mang Institutes edition of the Yuthok Heart Essence, for example, has nearly
thirty additional small texts preceding the core collection, an assortment of hymns and
liturgical arrangements outlining rites for recitation, fire offering, empowerment, and
so forth, authored by Jam dpal bde legs rgya mstho (d.1777), Kong sprul yon tan rgya
mtsho, Karma jigs med chos kyi seng ge, and others.48
The woodblock prints produced at Chagpori at the time of Karma jigs med chos
kyi seng ge are those that are most commonly used today. Without manuscript
evidence from an earlier period, we cannot claim definitively that any of the works
in this anthology are as early as Sum ston ye shes gzhungs or G.yu thog yon tan
mgon po, and indeed we may not be able to date them confidently to any earlier than
the nineteenth century. Nevertheless, the tradition does consider them to be the
teachings of G.yu thog, and further text critical research will no doubt reveal other
evidence that will help clarify the collections dating.
Conclusion
In this article I have considered the literary, doctrinal and historical contexts of the
central Buddhist ritual performed by doctors in Tibet. Although for some, the
practice of Accomplishing Medicine is primarily a process of enabling medicinal
pills to work more effectively, the question of just how it is that this happens, and
what else happens along the way, has been little investigated. In the preceding pages
we have seen the practice to be part of a larger contemplative and yogic curriculum
aimed at developing a doctors transcendent wisdom and power to an extent that he
or she is transformed into the deity itself, in typical tantric Buddhist fashion,
acquiring all the attendant supernormal abilities that such a being may have. This
transmutation of the practitioner is alchemical on various levels: the coarse material
objects of ritual practice are transformed into purified elixirs (and so the medicinal
pills are empowered), and also the coarse physical body of the ritual practitioner
is similarly purified, and his or her coarse technical abilities are also transformed
into supernormal powers. In this medicine sadhana (sman sgrub), the doctorpractitioner accomplishes all of these aims, him or herself becoming medicine itself,
capable of transmitting the Medicine Buddhas healing power directly into patients
bodies. This understanding underlies my choice of Accomplishing Medicine as a
translation for sman sgrub: the term hints at the idea that it is not only the medicines themselves that are accomplished (both in the sense of being completed or
perfected, and in the sense of having superior ability or potency), but it is also the
doctor-practitioner who has, through this sadhana, accomplished the act of making
48
123
225
him or herself into medicine. Accounts of the sman sgrub practice in G.yu thogs
biography support this notion, as does an examination of the Yuthok Heart
Essence practices, and their siblings in the Nectar Qualities tantras, all of these
sources clearly presenting this as a religious practice for doctors benefit. Of course,
such doctors, as Great Vehicle Buddhists, are to work ultimately for the benefit of
others, so the distinction may not be quite so clear cut; my emphasis on sman sgrub
as religious cultivation for doctors, moreover, is not meant to undermine the perceived effects of these procedures on the medicines themselves, but rather simply to
expand our understanding of how this process works.
This article has also addressed the historical nature of the connection between
Buddhist and medical traditions in Tibet. While the interpenetration of these realms
is often noted, the precise lines of connection have been little studied, and thus the
close associations between the Yuthok Heart Essence tradition and key Nyingma
figures are especially illuminating. The strong Gelukpa orientation of the Chagpori
and Mentsikhang medical institutions in Central Tibet from the time of the Fifth
Dalai Lama up to today, as well as in the exile medical community in India, makes
this important and continuing bond between medical and Nyingma traditions all the
more fascinating. (Eric Jacobson notes that the Dharamsala Mentsikhang must
employ a Nyingma lama particularly for the purpose of initiating medical students
into these practices.49) Today, at a point in history when many aspects of Tibetan
medicine considered religious are being eliminated from the tradition, particularly in Tibetan regions that are governed by China, the continued importance of the
vibrant Accomplishing Medicine ceremonies indicates a point of flourishing interconnection between medical and religious domains.
NgaK Mang
page numbers
Leh 1981
page numbers
11
49
123
226
50
F. Garrett
13
25
35
39
42
44
60
74
76
80
82
492
101
135
557
140
567
145
575
149
582
154
175
178
180
429
This text has also been published independently as Khams-smyon Dharma-senge, Rlabs chen rgyal
_ pai rgyan zes bya ba bzugs so (Delhi, 1973) [Delhi : s.n.,
bai spyod pa las Sman sgrub dran_ sron_ dgons
1973], Ritual for the preparation of medicinal pellets according to the Gyu thog snin_ thig cycle.
123
227
215
221
355
359
258
541
266
268
290
41
307
67
310
71
313
74
316
78
322
87
326
93
331
102
333
104
337
111
338
112
339
112
341
114
343
115
116
346
121
123
228
123
F. Garrett
348
124
142
143
362
145
366
150
387
183
390
186
398
199
431
253
432
254
441
443
268
270
445
272
448
276
450
451
278
278
454
282
458
286
461
291
463
294
469
303
472
306
229
474
309
477
314
482
322
485
326
489
332
494
338
500
348
503
351
504
353
505
353
Acknowledgements I am grateful to the Kluge Center at the U.S. Library of Congress for its support
during my research on this paper. Thanks also to Barbara Gerke, Gene Smith, Ben Wood, Dr. Dorjee
Rapten Neshar, and Sienna Craig.
References
Blo bzang chos grags, Jo bo lhun grub bkra shis, & Dar mo sman rams pa. (1982). G.yu thog gsar rnying
gi rnam thar. Pe cin: Mi rigs dpe skrun khang.
Bstan dzin rgya mtsho, Klong-chen-pa Dri-med-od-zer, & Patrick Gaffney. (2007). Mind in comfort and
ease: The vision of enlightenment in the great perfection: Including Longchen Rabjams finding
comfort and ease in meditation on the great perfection. Boston: Wisdom Publications.
Craig, S. (Forthcoming). From empowerments to power calculations: Notes on efficacy, value, and
method. In V. Adams, M. Schrempf & S. Craig (Eds.), Medicine between science and religion.
London: Berghahn Books.
Donden, Y., & Hopkins, J. (1997). Health through balance: An introduction to Tibetan medicine.
Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.
Dorje, G., & Meyer, F. (Eds.) (1992). Tibetan medical paintings: Illustrations to the Blue Beryl
treatise of Sangye Gyamtso (16531705) (2 Vols). New York: Harry N. Abrams.
Fenner, T. (1979). Rasayana Siddhi: Medicine and alchemy in buddhist tantras. Wisconsin: University
of Wisconsin.
Garrett, F. (2005). Ordering human growth in Tibetan medical and religious embryologies. In E. L. Furdell
(Ed.), Textual healing: Essays on medieval and early modern medicine (pp. 3252). Leiden: Brill.
Garrett, F. (2007). Buddhism and the historicizing of medicine in thirteenth century Tibet. Asian
Medicine: Tradition and Modernity, 2(2), 204222.
Garrett, F. (2008). Religion, medicine and the human embryo in Tibet. Routledge Critical Studies in
Buddhism. Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
123
230
F. Garrett
Garrett, F., & Adams, V. (2008). The three channels in Tibetan medicine, with a translation of Tsultrim
Gyaltsens A clear explanation of the principal structure and location of the circulatory channels as
illustrated in the medical paintings. Traditional South Asian Medicine, 8, 86115.
Gayley, H. (2007). Soteriology of the senses in Tibetan buddhism. Numen, 54, 459499.
Gu ru chos kyi dbang phyug. (1979). Sman sgrub las tshogs. In Bka brgyad gsan ba yons rdzogs: A
complete cycle of Rnin-Ma-Pa practice focusing upon the Ancient eight pronouncements of
Gu-ru rin-po-che (pp. 305324). Paro: Ngodrup and Sherab Drimay.
Gyatso, J. (2004). The authority of empiricism and the empiricism of authority: Medicine and buddhism
in Tibet on the eve of modernity. Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East,
24(2), 8396.
Gyurme, D. Guhyagarbha Tantra: An introduction (Part 2). Wisdom Books, http://www.wisdombooks.com/FocusDetail.asp?FocusRef=47.
Gyurme, D., Kapstein, M., & Jigs-bral-ye-ses-rdo-rje Bdud-joms. (2002). The Nyingma School of
Tibetan Buddhism, its fundamentals and history. Boston: Wisdom Publications.
Jacobson, E. (2000). Situated knowledge in classical Tibetan medicine: Psychiatric Aspects. Harvard
University.
Karmay, S. (1998). The ordinance of Lha Bla-Ma Ye-Shes-Od. In S. Karmay (Ed.), The arrow and the
spindle: Studies in history, myths, rituals and beliefs in Tibet (pp. 316). Kathmandu: Mandala
Book Point.
Kind, M. (2002). Mendrub: A Bonpo ritual for the benefit of all living beings and for the empowerment of medicine performed in Tsho, Dolpo. Kathmandu: WWF Nepal Program, University of
Zurich.
Kohn, R. J. (2001). Lord of the dance: The Mani Rimdu festival in Tibet and Nepal. Suny Series in
Buddhist Studies. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Kunzang, R. R. J. (2001). Tibetan medicine, Illustrated in original texts. Indian Medical Science Series
No. 112. Delhi: Sri Satguru Publications.
Raghu, V., & Lokesh, C. (1995). Tibetan Mandalas: Vajravali and Tantra-Samuccaya. Sata-Pitaka
Series V. 383. New Delhi: International Academy of Indian Culture.
Sangs rgyas rgya mtsho. (1994). Gso ba rig pai bstan bcos sman blai dgongs rgyan rgyud bzhii gsal
byed bai durya sngon poi malli ka zhes bya ba bzhugs so (2 Vols). Dharamsala: Tibetan Medical
& Astro Institute.
Skyem pa tshe dbang. (2000). Rgyud bzhii rnam bshad. Zi ling: Mtsho sngon rigs dpe skrun khang.
Sngags mang zhib jug khang (Ed.) (2005). G.yu thog snying thig (Vol. 9), Sngags Mang Dpe Tshogs.
Pe cin: Mi rigs dpe skrun khang.
Stablein, W. (1976). The Mahakalatantra: A theory of ritual blessings and tantric medicine. Columbia
University.
Taube, M. (1981). Beitrage Zur Geschichte Der Medizinischen Literatur Tibets. Sankt Augustin:
VGH Wissenschaftsverlag.
Thub bstan rgya mtsho, Mullin, G. H., & Cox, C. (1988). Path of the Bodhisattva Warrior: The life and
teachings of the thirteenth Dalai Lama. Ithaca, N.Y., USA: Snow Lion Publications.
Tucci, G. (1980). The religions of Tibet. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche, Kunsang, E. P., & Schmidt, M. B. (2005). Blazing splendor: The memoirs of
the Dzogchen Yogi Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche, as told to Erik Pema Kunsang & Marcia Binder
Schmidt (1st ed.). Kathmandu, Nepal: Rangjung Yeshe Publications.
Walter, M. (1979). Preliminary results from a study of two Rasayana systems in Indo-Tibetan esotericism.
In M. Aris & A. San Su Kyi (Eds.), Tibetan Studies (pp. 319324). Warminster: Aris and Phillips.
Walter, M. (1980). The role of alchemy and medicine in Indo-Tibetan tantrism. Indiana University.
White, D. G. (1996). The alchemical body: Siddha traditions in Medieval India. Chicago: University
of Chicago Press.
Zur mkhar pa blo gros rgyal po. (1989). Rgyud bzhii grel pa mes poi zhal lung (2 Vols). Krung goi
pod kyi shes rig dpe skrun khang.
123