Nurse Jurisprudence
Nurse Jurisprudence
Nurse Jurisprudence
Jursiprudence
Ailyn B. Pineda
Lecturer
LEGAL CONCEPTS
AND ISSUES IN
NURSING
RESPONSIBILITY AND
ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THE
PRACTICE OF PROFESSIONAL
NURSING
n Nurses
WHAT IS LIABILITY?
n Is
PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE
refers to the
commission or omission of an
act, pursuant to a duty, that a
reasonably prudent person in the
same or similar circumstance
would or would not to, and acting
or the non-acting of which is the
proximate cause of injury to
another person to his property.
n NEGLIGENCE
ELEMENTS OF PROFESSIONAL
NEGLIGENCE
1.
2.
3.
4.
SPECIFIC EXAMPLES OF
NEGLIGENCE
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
MALPRACTICE
nImplies
EXAMPLES OF MALPRACTICE:
n Misdiagnosis
of an illness, failure to
diagnose or relay diagnosis
n Birth Injuries
n Surgical Complications
n Prescription errors
n Failure to provide treatment
n Anesthesia related complications
n Failure to follow advance directive
n Failure of hospital or pharmacy to
dispense the right medicine, dosage
DOCTRINE OF
RESPONDEAT SUPERIOR
n Means
EXAMPLES:
n The
INCOMPETENCE
n Is
1.
2.
3.
4.
GUIDELINES TO AVOID
MISTAKES OF NURSING
STUDENTS
LEGAL DEFENSE IN
NEGLIGENCE
n The
4.
Telephone Orders
n
n
n
n
CONSENT TO
MEDICAL AND
SURGICAL
PROCEDURE
n Consent
n The
nurses responsibility in
witnessing the giving of informed
consent involves:
n (1) witnessing the exchange b/w the
client and the physician (2)
witnessing the client affix his
signature (3) establishing that the
client really understood.
ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS OF
INFORMED CONSENT:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
WHO MUST
CONSENT?
Patient must consent in his own behalf
If he is incompetent, or physically unable,
and is not in emergency case, consent
must be taken from another who is
authorized to give it in his own behalf.
CONSENT
OF MINORS
Parents or someone standing in their
behalf, gives the consent to medical or
surgical treatment of a minor. Parental
consent is not needed if the patient is
married or emancipated
CONSENT OF
MENTALY ILL
A mentally incompetent person cannot
legally consent to medical or surgical
treatment. The consent must be taken
from parents or legal guardian
MENTAL COMPETENCY
nAll
EMERGENCY
SITUATION
No consent is necessary because
inaction at such time may cause greater
injury. If time is available and an
informed consent is possible, it is best
that this be taken to protect all the
parties concerned.
REFUSAL TO
CONSENT
A patient who is mentally and legally
competent has the right to refuse the
touching of his body or to submit to a
medical or surgical procedure no matter
how necessary, nor how imminent the
danger to his life or health if he fails to
submit to treatment.
CONSENT FOR
STERILIZATION
Sterilization is the termination of the
ability to produce offsprings. The
husband and the wife must consent to
the procedure if the operation is primarily
to accomplish sterilization. If emergency
cases like ectopic pregnancy and
abruptio placentae, consent from patient
MEDICAL RECORDS
n Was
CHARTING DONE BY
NURSING STUDENTS
WHAT IS A CONTRACT?
n Is
Kinds of Contracts
n Formal
n Implied
Illegal Contracts
n Those
INTENTIONAL
WRONGS
A nurse may be held liable for
intentional wrongs
TORTS
n A
EXAMPLES OF TORT:
n ASSAULT
FALSE IMPRISONMENT
n Is
USE OF
RESTRAINTS
n Restraints
INVASION OF RIGHT TO
PRIVACY AND BREACH OF
CONFIDENTIALITY
DEFAMATION
Occurs when a person discusses another
individual in terms that diminish reputation.
n SLANDER- is oral defamation of a person by
speaking unprivileged or false words by which
his reputation is damaged
n LIBEL- is defamation by written words,
cartoons or such representations that cause a
person to be avoided, ridiculed or held in
contempt or tend to injure him in his work
n
CRIMES,
MISDEMEANORS, AND
FELONIES
nCRIME
is defined as an act
committed or omitted in violation of
the law. Criminal offenses are
composed of two elements: (1)
Criminal Act (2) Evil/criminal intent
nIn criminal action, the state seeks
the punishment of the wrongdoers
Criminal Actions
n Deal
Criminal Negligence
n Reckless
Imprudence- when a
person does an act or fails to do
involuntary without malice, from which
damage results immediately.
n Simple Imprudence- means that the
person or nurse did not use
precaution and the damage was not
immediate or the impending danger
was not evident or manifest
Criminal Intent
n
Classes of Felonies
Circumstances
Affecting Criminal
Liability
PREPARED BY:
ailyn brillo pineda
Circumstances
affecting Criminal
Liability
J-E-M-A-A
Justifying
Circumstances
SELF-DEFENSE
These are the defenses in
which the accused is
deemed to have acted in
accordance with the law
and therefore the act is
lawful. Since the act is
lawful, it follows that there
is no criminal, no criminal
liability and no civil liability
Justifying Circumstances
A person may not incur criminal liability under the following circumstance:
There is no mens rea or criminal intent
The circumstances pertain to the act and not to the actor. Hence all who
participated in the act will be benefited. Thus if the principal is acquitted
there will be no accomplices and accessories.
These apply only to intentional felonies, not to acts by omissions or to
culpable felonies or to violations of special laws
When he acts in defense of his rights
When he acts in defense of his relatives rights
When he acts in defense of a strangers rights and that the person
defending is not induced by revenge or evil motives.
When any person who, in order to avoid an injury does an act which
causes damage to another provided that an evil sought to be avoided
actually exists.
When he acts in the fulfillment of a duty or in lawful exercise of a right or
office.
Exempting Circumstances
There are certain circumstances under which the law exempts a person
from criminal liability
The basis is the lack of any of the elements which makes the act/
omission voluntary, i.e. freedom, intelligence, intent or due care.
These defenses pertain to the actor and not the act. They are personal
to the accused in whom they are present and the effects do not extend
to the other participants. Thus if a principal is acquitted, the other
principals, accessories and accomplices are still liable.
They apply to both intentional and culpable felonies and they may be
available in violations of special laws.
An imbecile or an insane person, unless the latter has acted during a
lucid interval
A person under nine years of age
A person over nine years of age and under fifteen unless he acted with
discernment.
A person while performing a lawful act with due care causes an injury
which is merely an accident.
Any person who acts under the compulsion of an irresistible force
MITIGATING CIRCUMSTANCES
n
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
AGGRAVATING
CIRCUMSTANCES
Are those attending the commission of a crime and
which increase the criminal liability of the offender or
make his guilt more severe.
1. When the offender takes advantage of his public
position
2. When the crime is committed in contempt of or with
insult to public authorities
3. When the act is committed with insult or disregard
of the respect of the offended party on account of
his rank, age, sex
n
AGGRAVATING
CIRCUMSTANCES
AGGRAVATING
CIRCUMSTANCES
9. When the act is committed
with evident premeditation or
after unlawful entry
10. When craft, fraud, or
disguise is employed
when the wrong done in the
commission of the crime is
deliberately augmented by
causing other wrongs not
necessary for its commission
ALTERNATIVE CIRCUMSTANCES
n those
Rape
Forcible abduction
Arson
Treason
In crimes against chastity like seduction and
acts of lasciviousness
Those acts committed in a merciless or
heinous manner
MORAL TURPITUDE
n is
MURDER
- is the unlawful killing of a
human being with intent to
kill. It is a very serious
crime. Nurses should keep
in mind that death resulting
from a criminal abortion is
murder. Euthanasia is also
considered murder.
HOMICIDE
- is the killing of a human being
in another. It may be committed
without criminal intent, by any
person whom kills another,
other than his father, mother, or
child or any of his ascendants
or descendants, or his spouse,
without any of the
circumstances attendant the
crime of murder enumerated
above being present.
ABORTION
- is illegal according to the
revised penal code. The patient
should assume responsibility
for her abortion. She should be
made to sign a statement
relieving the hospital and its
personnel from liability
n INFANTICIDE-
CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCES
n R.A.
4.
5.
WILLS
n It
n HEIR
NURSES OBLIGATION IN
THE EXECUTION OF A
WILL
n The
LIVING WILL
n Is
nurse especially those taking care of well-todo patients should remember that the main
requisite for making a will is testamentary
capacity or sanity. The person who makes a will
should at least be 18 years old and is not
prohibited by law. The will is written and should
be witnessed by three credible witnesses,
unless it is holographic will. A Holographic will
is one that is entirely written, dated and signed
by hand. There is no legal reason for the nurse
to refuse to witness the preparation of a will.
WHAT IS AN INCIDENT
REPORT
n It
n
n
n
n
n
n
n Prima
n Subpoena
GOD BLESS!!!
THE END