The Epidemiology of Global Micronutrient Deficiencies by Regan Bailey Et Al
The Epidemiology of Global Micronutrient Deficiencies by Regan Bailey Et Al
The Epidemiology of Global Micronutrient Deficiencies by Regan Bailey Et Al
Current knowledge
Around the world, pregnant women and children under 5 years
of age are at the highest risk of MNDs. Iron, iodine, folate, vitamin A, and zinc deficiencies are the most widespread MNDs
and are common contributors towards poor growth, intellectual impairment, perinatal complications, and increased risk
of morbidity and mortality. Of greatest concern is the fact that
the cycle of MNDs perpetuates across the generations, with farreaching consequences on the future population.
Practical implications
Addressing MNDs has traditionally been accomplished through
supplementation, fortification, and food-based approaches
including dietary diversification. Of note, intervention in the
first 1,000 days of life is most effective for breaking the cycle
of malnutrition; however, a coordinated, sustainable commitment to scaling up nutritional interventions at the global level
is needed. Supplementation is a cost-effective solution but does
Infancy
Childhood
Stunted
Reduced mental
capacity and
productivity
Frequent infections
Inadequate growth
Higher mortality rate
Adulthood
Reduced productivity
Poor socioeconomic
status
Malnourished
Increased perinatal
complications and
mortality
Adolescence
Stunted
Reduced mental
capacity
Frequent infections
Fatigue
Micronutrient deficiencies have consequences throughout an individuals life span and are perpetuated across the generations.
not address the root cause of the MND. Over the long term, food
fortification may offer a more effective means to address MNDs,
as it enables a larger segment of a population to be targeted.
Recommended reading
Black RE, Victora CG, Walker SP, et al: Maternal and child undernutrition and overweight in low-income and middle-income
countries. Lancet 2013;382:427451.
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
Key insights
Micronutrient deficiencies (MNDs) have a direct impact on individuals and on societies, resulting in poorer health, lower
educational attainment and decreased work capacity and
earning potential. Nutrition is the most powerful adaptable environmental factor that can be targeted in order to reduce the
burden of disease across an individuals entire life span. MNDs
are preventable and the return on investment for the provision
of micronutrients is high. Understanding how to interpret the
biomarkers of MNDs alongside clinical and functional indicators is key to characterizing the global burden of MNDs and to
identifying the optimal interventions.
Office of Dietary Supplements, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Md., b Department of International Nutrition,
The Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md., USA
E-Mail [email protected]
Key Words
Epidemiology Micronutrient deficiencies Vitamins
Minerals
Abstract
Micronutrients are essential to sustain life and for optimal
physiological function. Widespread global micronutrient
deficiencies (MNDs) exist, with pregnant women and their
children under 5 years at the highest risk. Iron, iodine, folate,
vitamin A, and zinc deficiencies are the most widespread
MNDs, and all these MNDs are common contributors to poor
growth, intellectual impairments, perinatal complications,
and increased risk of morbidity and mortality. Iron deficiency is the most common MND worldwide and leads to microcytic anemia, decreased capacity for work, as well as impaired immune and endocrine function. Iodine deficiency
disorder is also widespread and results in goiter, mental retardation, or reduced cognitive function. Adequate zinc is
necessary for optimal immune function, and deficiency is associated with an increased incidence of diarrhea and acute
respiratory infections, major causes of death in those <5
years of age. Folic acid taken in early pregnancy can prevent
neural tube defects. Folate is essential for DNA synthesis and
repair, and deficiency results in macrocytic anemia. Vitamin
A deficiency is the leading cause of blindness worldwide and
also impairs immune function and cell differentiation. Single
Regan L. Bailey
Office of Dietary Supplements, National Institutes of Health
6100 Executive Boulevard, Suite 3B01
Bethesda, MD 20892 (USA)
E-Mail [email protected]
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
Key Messages
Introduction
Micronutrient is the umbrella term used to represent
essential vitamins and minerals required from the diet to
sustain virtually all normal cellular and molecular functions [1]. While the required amounts of micronutrients
are very small, micronutrient deficiency (MND) can have
wide-range negative health impacts that will ultimately
result in death if untreated. MNDs are common, affecting
an estimated 2 billion people worldwide [2]. The most
common deficiencies exist for vitamin A, folate, iron, iodine, and zinc; however, several other MND disorders exist. Coexistence of multiple MNDs frequently occurs.
MNDs often occur as part of a cycle of malnutrition and
may be coupled with protein or energy malnutrition.
Pregnant women and their children 5 years of age and
Defining Deficiency
The nutritional status of a micronutrient can be characterized along a continuum from deficiency to excess (fig.1)
[3]. The sufficiency status for micronutrients can be determined along this continuum using biomarkers, dietary intake data, or nonspecific functional indicators, like stunting
or low birth weight. Ideally, MND is determined by a valid
and reliable biomarker. Biomarkers are typically defined as
biological measurements (i.e. blood, urine, etc.) that are
used to indicate normal biological processes, pathogenic
processes, or pharmacologic responses to therapeutic intervention [4]. Unfortunately, biomarkers are not available
for all, while other existing biomarkers are not practical or
feasible for widespread assessment or for use outside the
clinical setting. Furthermore, biomarkers may be influenced by inflammation, infection, hydration status, age,
kidney function, and analytical method, all of which make
their interpretation difficult. Finally, a number of issues exist concerning the use of cut points for biomarkers to determine deficiency and sufficiency as there is a distribution
around the cut point, cut points may differ by many factors
(e.g. by age group or by analytical method), and the selection of which cut point to use is problematic. National sur-
Optimal
100
Function (%)
Marginal
Deficiency
Marginal
Death
Toxicity
Death
23
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
Causes of MNDs
MNDs are only one form of undernutrition. Other
forms of undernutrition are more readily visible and, for
this reason, MNDs are often referred to as hidden hunger
[5]. At the most basic level, MNDs, like all forms of undernutrition, occur due to insufficient intake or sufficient intakes combined with impaired absorption due to infection,
disease, or inflammation [6, 7]. For infants, MNDs may
result from maternal MND in utero or rapid postnatal
growth [8]. The antecedents to these immediate causes for
undernutrition are complex and can be fully appreciated by
examining the 2013 UNICEF Conceptual Framework for
the Determinants of Undernutrition (fig.2) [6]. The underlying causes that contribute to the immediate causes include food insecurity, inadequate care or feeding practices,
and an unhealthy environment with inadequate access to
health services. Nutritional status is greatly impacted by infection [9]. Infection is the leading cause of child mortality
[10]. Acute respiratory infection and diarrhea are the most
common causes of infant mortality, and MNDs contribute
greatly to the immune response [11]. Undernutrition is the
leading cause of immunodeficiency worldwide [7].
The basic root cause of most undernutrition is poverty. As a result, low- and middle-income countries
have the highest burden of MNDs; however, MNDs exist even in certain population groups in higher-income
countries. The United Nations Millennium Development Goals include eradicating extreme poverty and
hunger as their priority goal [12]. Like poverty, undernutrition and MNDs often occur as part of an intergenerational cycle (fig.3). During pregnancy and lactation,
there are increased macro- and micronutrient requirements [13]. Pregnant mothers without optimal nutritional intakes have children with suboptimal nutritional status including impaired physical and mental development, setting the infant on a deleterious course of
stunting, increased likelihood for infection, and devel24
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
BASIC
causes
UNDERLYING
causes
IMMEDIATE
causes
Unhealthy household
environment and inadequate
health services
Disease
Short-term consequences:
Mortality, morbidity, disability
Long-term consequences:
Adult height, cognitive ability, economic
productivity, reproductive performance,
metabolic and cardiovascular disease
Intergenerational consequences
may also be associated with enhanced absorption of environmental metal toxins such as cadmium [19].
Iron status is typically assessed through plasma ferritin, transferrin saturation, and hemoglobin concentrations. Ideally, all of these biomarkers are available to make
an assessment; however, routinely, only 1 or 2 of these are
available in screening and assessment. Hemoglobin is
most often used to determine anemia. Ferritin is reflective
of body iron stores; but, because it is also an acute-phase
protein, ferritin will be elevated in acute or chronic disease, and tests may yield misleading results. Globally, the
World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that 25%
of the population (1.62 billion people; CI 1.501.74 billion) has anemia [16]. Preschool children (47.4%) and
pregnant women (41.8%) have the highest prevalence
overall. Africa (67.6 and 57.1%) and Southeast Asia (65.5
and 48.2%) have the highest burden of anemia in preschool children and pregnant women, respectively [16].
Women in perinatal life stages and their infants (<6
months of age) are considered to be at the highest risk for
iron deficiency. Routine iron supplementation in pregnancy and infancy is recommended in areas without endemic malaria [20]. Iron supplementation in those with
malaria may exacerbate the falciparum-related complications and mortality [20]. Recently, it has been proposed
to dovetail efforts with iron nutriture in conjunction with
malaria control programs [21]. Fortification programs
with iron exist in several countries with the food vehicles
of choice ranging from flours, dairy products, condiments, sugar, and salt to infant formulas. Fortification
and supplementation may be appropriate for areas with
high concentrations of vegetarians.
25
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
Fig. 2. Updated UNICEF Conceptual Framework for the Determinants of Undernutrition (adapted from UNICEF [6]).
Elderly
Increased morbidity
(osteoporosis,
mental impairment, etc.)
Increased mortality
Baby
Low birth weight
Higher mortality rate
Impaired mental
development
Increased risk of chronic
disease
Child
Adult
Pregnant
women
Inadequate
vitamin and
mineral status
Stunted
Reduced mental capacity
Frequent infections
Inadequate growth catch-up
Reduced productivity
Higher mortality rate
Adolescent
Stunted
Reduced mental capacity
Fatigue
Increased vulnerability
to infection
Fig. 3. The conceptual framework for the cycle of micronutrient inadequacies across the life span (adapted from
Vitamin A
Vitamin A is a fat-soluble vitamin that has multiple
roles in the body including vision, cell differentiation, immune function, reproduction, and organ and bone formation and growth. Vitamin A comes from animal sources in the diet preformed as retinol or retinyl esters, or
from provitamin A carotenoids found in plant sources.
Provitamin A carotenoids, which exhibit differential vitamin A activity, are converted to the active forms of the
vitamin (retinal and retinoic acid) for use by the body.
Vitamin A deficiency (VAD) has been associated with
increased rates and severity of infections and is a primary
cause of childhood morbidity and mortality in the developing world, particularly in Africa and Southeast Asia
[22]. VAD is the leading cause of preventable blindness in
children. VAD causes xerophthalmia, a series of ocular
manifestations like night blindness, Bitots spots, and corneal ulcerations and lesions [1]. The WHO estimates that
250500 million children are blind because of VAD, and
26
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
ACC/SCN [14]).
g/l. During pregnancy, different urinary iodine excretion rates may occur [41]; therefore, during pregnancy,
sufficiency status is defined as a median urinary iodine
concentration of 150249 g/l, with concentrations <150
g/l defined as insufficient [42]. It is intuitive to think that
thyroid hormones may serve as a biomarker of iodine status; however, thyroid hormones, with the exception of
thyroglobulin [43], do not appear to be adequately sensitive to change in iodine status [44, 45].
Pregnant females and infants (<24 months of age) are
the population groups at highest risk of iodine deficiency.
As previously stated, in pregnancy, requirements are
greatly increased, and infants have the highest requirements per kg of body weight of any age group [30]. Exclusively breastfed infants may also be at risk if not provided
iodine in complementary foods [46]. While iodine is
found in breast milk [15], its concentration is dependent
on maternal intake and status [47, 48].
Globally, 2 billion are estimated to have inadequate
iodine status [49, 50]. As many as half of the European
population (52%, 459.7 million people) is estimated to
have inadequate iodine status and more than 500 million
individuals are affected in Southeast Asia. While the group
of highest concern is pregnant females, we have no global
estimation of the burden of iodine deficiency in this group
[51]. Approximately 30% (241 million) of the worlds
school-aged children have insufficient iodine intakes [52].
Iodine
Iodine is a trace mineral, and its primary function is in
the synthesis of thyroid hormone. Approximately 60% of
the total body pool of iodine is stored in the thyroid gland
[30]. Thyroid hormone is necessary for regulation of human growth and development. Iodine in foods and dietary supplements is generally either in a salt or organic
form [31]. The iodine content of many foods is dependent
upon soil concentration of the element and fertilization
and irrigation practices [15]. The iodine content of fish
and seaweed is also highly variable [32]. Iodine stores in
vivo during a sufficient state are estimated at 60 g, and
during deficiency, stores are much lower in the 10- to 20g range [30]. Iodine absorption and utilization can be
impaired by the presence of goitrogens [33] or exposure
to percolate, disulfides, and thiocyanates (from tobacco
exposure) [34]. Hypothyroidism can occur in individuals
when dietary intakes are lower than 1020 g daily, and
it is frequently accompanied by goiter [15].
Thyroid hormones are essential for optimal fetal and
postnatal central nervous system growth and development [35, 36]. Maternal iodine requirements increase by
more than 50% during pregnancy to meet fetal needs and
because of enhanced renal clearance of iodine and alternated iodine metabolism during pregnancy [37]. Maternal iodine deficiency, particularly when it occurs during
early pregnancy, can lead to irreversible neurological
complications and mental retardation in the offspring referred to as iodine deficiency disorder (IDD) [35]. IDD
represents a spectrum of diseases affecting the entire life
course. From infancy to adulthood, IDD includes goiters,
impaired mental function, and hypo- or hyperthyroidism. At the most severe form, in utero iodine deficiency
can result in cretinism [38].
Typically, iodine status is assessed via urinary iodine
content because it is a reliable indicator of recent intake
as approximately 90% of ingested dietary iodine is excreted in urine across the range of dietary intakes [30, 36, 39]
and because renal clearance is relatively constant [40].
The WHO defines iodine insufficiency in children and
adults as a median urinary iodine concentration of <100
27
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
is added to sugar [24] in addition to intermittent supplementation programs, together yielding a low rate of VAD
determined by serum retinol [25]. Despite the Cochrane
reviews limiting maternal, neonatal, and infant vitamin A
supplementation in developing countries [26, 27], continued emphasis should be placed on vitamin A supplementation programs in Southeast Asia given the clearly documented effects on ocular health and mortality [22, 28, 29].
Folate
Folate is a generic term for multiple forms of the essential B vitamin. Folate naturally occurs in foods, whereas folic acid is a synthetic form of the vitamin that is used
in fortified foods and in dietary supplements. Folic acid
is much more bioavailable than folate naturally occurring
in foods and when ingested is converted by dihydrofolate
reductase to the dihydrofolate and then the tetrahydrofolate form of folate; these reduced compounds are identical to those that would arise from ingestion of natural
folate. Folate is essential for synthesis of purines and thymidylate and, therefore, is involved in DNA synthesis,
stability, and repair. Folate is also involved in one carbon
metabolism and, as such, can alter DNA methylation,
which is an important epigenetic determinant in gene expression, in the maintenance of DNA integrity, and in the
development of mutations.
Folate deficiency can be determined by serum, plasma,
or erythrocyte folate concentrations. Folate deficiency is
very low in countries with mandatory or voluntary folic
acid fortification programs [52]. Folate deficiency causes
megaloblastic or macrocytic anemia and increases the
likelihood for pregnancies affected by neural tube defects.
The global prevalence of anemia secondary to folate deficiency is very low. Folate deficiency in pregnancy has also
been associated with low birth weight, preterm delivery,
and fetal growth retardation [53, 54]. Globally, only about
30% of women take folic acid supplements prior to conception [55]. No good estimates of global folate deficiency exist for those considered to be of highest risk: women
of reproductive age, pregnant females, and young children [56].
Folic acid supplementation in the periconceptional
period unequivocally reduces the occurrence of neural
tube defects [57, 58]. For this reason, the governments of
both the United States and Canada instituted national
fortification programs with folic acid to enhance the diets
of reproductive-aged females [5961], and neural tube
defect rates decreased in both the United States [62] and
Canada [6365]. Since this time, more than 75 countries
have instituted folic acid fortification programs, and the
amount of folic acid added varies by country [66]. Several more countries allow folic acid to be added to flour
on a voluntary basis, while other countries fortify with
iron and other B vitamins, but not with folic acid [67, 68].
28
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
29
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
effect of zinc on anthropometry, but not linear growth, vitamin A, and zinc together and determined that 18 of
was also seen in a Peruvian clinical trial in which mothers the 20 countries with the highest burden of multiple
MNDs are in Africa, with Afwere supplemented prenatally
ghanistan and India (WHO
with zinc; infants born to zincSupplementation as a strategy
region Asia) completing the
supplemented mothers had
greater weight gain, higher calf requires that provision of supplements list. Iodine may be the excepand chest circumference, and
tion to the clustering of
is feasible and that adequate
MNDs, and iodine deficiency
more calf muscle area than
educational programs are in place to is region specific and does
children born to mothers
garner compliance.
without zinc supplementation
not necessarily track with
[74]. Zinc supplementation
countries with a high hidden
during pregnancy is associated
hunger [5]. However, defiwith a significant reduction in preterm births without an ciency in other micronutrients, like selenium, iron, and
effect on infant birth weight [75].
vitamin A, can exacerbate iodine deficiency by altering
Deficiency in zinc is thought to be one of the primary thyroid function [8183].
causes of morbidity in developing countries and, yet, surprisingly little is known about the status of the world [76].
Strategies and Interventions
Given the issues concerning the assessment of zinc status
Several options exist to combat MNDs, including supby biomarkers, estimates of inadequacy are largely based
on the prevalence of child stunting, estimates of dietary plementation, fortification, and food-based approaches
intakes, and the availability of zinc from the food supply like dietary diversification. The choice of intervention
[76]. Globally, it is estimated that 17.3% of the population strategy or strategies should depend on the cause, severhas inadequate zinc intakes, with the highest estimates in ity, and scope of the MND. The intervention strategy
Africa (23.9%) and Asia (19.4%). Pregnant females and should always try to eliminate the root cause and must be
their young children are the highest-risk groups for zinc considered within the cultural preferences [2]. Underdeficiency. Currently, the WHO and UNICEF recom- standing the sustainability and feasibility of interventions
mend provision of zinc supplements for 1014 days along is critical a priori. Ensuring continued access to the interwith oral rehydration therapy for acute diarrhea; how- vention or strategy is of upmost importance depending
ever, no routine supplementation recommendations cur- on the intervention.
In general, supplementation is the approach to utilize
rently exist for the prevention of zinc deficiency.
when an MND is severe and requires a therapeutic approach to treatment, or for the purpose of prevention [2].
Multiple MNDs
Supplementation can be daily or intermittently (i.e. 12
Single MNDs rarely happen in isolation; more often, times per year). Widespread success has been achieved
multiple MNDs are occurring simultaneously [1, 5]. Mul- with vitamin A supplementation for the prevention of
tiple MNDs appear to be mainly driven by a lack of food night blindness and infant mortality; the success is in part
security, defined by the Food and Agriculture Organiza- due to the intermittent requirements for supplementation (1996) at the World Food Summit as follows: when tion (i.e. 12 times per year vs. daily). Supplementation as
all people at all times have access to sufficient, safe, nutri- a strategy requires that provision of supplements is featious food to maintain a healthy and active life [77]. Many sible and that adequate educational programs are in place
factors contribute to food security and MNDs, including to garner compliance. Ideally, supplementation is limited
lack of available quality and diversity of foods, poverty in to these purposes because supplementation does not adcertain population groups, lack of access to health care dress the root cause of the deficiency. However, suppleand nutrition education, subsistence farming practices, mentation offers a relatively cost-effective short-term sovolatile food prices, urbanization, high rates of infection lution to MNDs. There are growing concerns that supple(both acute and chronic), and issues with sanitation, cli- mental nutrients may exhibit different physiological
mate change, and access to potable water [5, 7880].
responses and absorption than nutrients found in food;
Estimates of multiple MNDs have been difficult to as- this has been noted for folic acid, zinc, and iron.
certain due to limitations in the available data. Muthayya
Food fortification is a more long-term strategy to comet al. [5] estimated global hidden hunger indices for iron, bat MNDs than supplementation. Fortification differs
30
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
Disclosure Statement
Regan L. Bailey and Keith P. West Jr. have no conflicts of interest to disclose. Robert E. Black presides on the governing boards
of the Micronutrient Initiative and Vitamin Angels; he is also a
member of the Creating Shared Value Advisory Council of Nestl.
13 Picciano MF: Pregnancy and lactation: physiological adjustments, nutritional requirements and the role of dietary supplements. J
Nutr 2003;133:1997S2002S.
14 ACC/SCN: Fourth Report on the World Nutrition Situation: Nutrition throughout the
Life Cycle. Geneva, ACC/SCN in Collaboration with IFPRI, 2000.
15 Food and Nutrition Board: Dietary Reference Intakes for Vitamin A, Vitamin K, Arsenic, Boron, Chromium, Copper, Iodine,
Iron, Manganese, Molybdenum, Nickel, Silicon, Vanadium, and Zinc. Washington, National Academy Press, 2001.
16 de Benoist B, McLean E, Egli I, Cogswell M:
Worldwide Prevalence of Anaemia 1993
2005: WHO Global Database on Anaemia.
Geneva, World Health Organization, 2008.
17 Lozoff B, Smith JB, Kaciroti N, et al: Functional significance of early-life iron deficiency: outcomes at 25 years. J Pediatr 2013; 163:
12601266.
18 Flour Fortification Initiative, GAIN, Micronutrient Initiative, USAID, The World Bank,
UNICEF: Investing in the Future: A United
Call to Action on Vitamin and Mineral Deficiencies Global Report 2009. Ottawa,
2009.
19 Silver MK, Lozoff B, Meeker JD: Blood cadmium is elevated in iron deficient US children: a cross-sectional study. Environ Health
2013;12:117.
20 World Health Organization: Conclusions
and recommendations of the WHO consultation on prevention and control of iron deficiency in infants and young children in malaria-endemic areas. Food Nutr Bull 2007;
28(4 suppl):S621S627.
21 Stoltzfus RJ: Iron and malaria interactions:
programmatic ways forward. Adv Nutr 2012;
3:579582.
22 Sommer A, Tarwotjo I, Hussaini G, Susanto
D: Increased mortality in children with mild
vitamin A deficiency. Lancet 1983; 2: 585
588.
23 World Health Organization: Global Prevalence of Vitamin A Deficiency in Populations at Risk 19952005. WHO Global Database on Vitamin A Deficiency. Geneva,
World Health Organization, 2009.
31
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
References
32
Bailey/West/Black
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM
86 Sonkaria S, Ahn SH, Khare V: Nanotechnology and its impact on food and nutrition: a
review. Recent Pat Food Nutr Agric 2012; 4:
818.
87 Srinivas PR, Philbert M, Vu TQ, et al: Nanotechnology research: applications in nutritional sciences. J Nutr 2010;140:119124.
88 Soofi S, Cousens S, Iqbal SP, et al: Effect of
provision of daily zinc and iron with several
micronutrients on growth and morbidity
among young children in Pakistan: a clusterrandomised trial. Lancet 2013;382:2940.
89 De-Regil LM, Suchdev PS, Vist GE, et al:
Home fortification of foods with multiple
micronutrient powders for health and nutrition in children under two years of age. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2011; 9:CD008959.
33
Downloaded by:
130.105.200.99 - 9/10/2016 10:23:13 AM