Pamphlet 60 - Edition 7 - Aug 2013 PDF
Pamphlet 60 - Edition 7 - Aug 2013 PDF
Pamphlet 60 - Edition 7 - Aug 2013 PDF
mphl
et60
Ch
lor
inePi
pel
ine
s
Edi
ti
on7
Augus
t2013
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................ 1
1.1 SCOPE .......................................................................................................................... 1
1.2 CHLORINE INSTITUTE STEWARDSHIP PROGRAM............................................................... 1
1.3 DEFINITIONS AND ACRONYMS ......................................................................................... 2
1.4 DISCLAIMER .................................................................................................................. 3
1.5 APPROVAL .................................................................................................................... 3
1.6 REVISIONS .................................................................................................................... 3
1.7 REPRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 3
2. GENERAL.......................................................................................................................... 3
2.1 BASIC CONSIDERATIONS ................................................................................................ 3
2.2 ROUTING....................................................................................................................... 4
2.3 FEDERAL, STATE AND LOCAL REGULATIONS .................................................................... 4
3. DESIGN ............................................................................................................................. 5
3.1 GENERAL DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS............................................................................... 5
3.2 INSTALLATION AND CONSTRUCTION ................................................................................ 5
3.3 INSULATION AND LINE PROTECTION ................................................................................ 7
3.4 THERMAL PIPE EXPANSION ............................................................................................ 7
3.5 LIQUID EXPANSION IN LIQUID PIPELINES .......................................................................... 8
3.6 VALVE LOCATION ........................................................................................................... 8
3.7 VENT AND DRAIN BRANCHES .......................................................................................... 9
3.8 MECHANICAL CLEANING ................................................................................................. 9
4. MARKING .......................................................................................................................... 9
4.1 LINE MARKERS .............................................................................................................. 9
4.2 LINE MARKER W ORDING ................................................................................................ 9
5. PREPARATION FOR USE ................................................................................................ 9
5.1 PRESSURE TESTING .....................................................................................................10
5.2 CLEANING ....................................................................................................................10
5.3 DRYING ........................................................................................................................10
5.4 TESTING FOR LEAKS .....................................................................................................10
6. OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES...........................................................11
6.1 GENERAL .....................................................................................................................11
6.2 OPERATION GUIDELINES ...............................................................................................11
6.3 MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES AND PRECAUTIONS ..............................................................12
7. INSPECTION, TESTING, AND MONITORING .................................................................13
7.1 GENERAL .....................................................................................................................13
7.2 CONTINUING SURVEILLANCE AND DAMAGE PREVENTION .................................................13
7.3 MONITORING OF EXPANSION BOTTLES ...........................................................................14
8. EMERGENCY PLANNING................................................................................................14
8.1 EMERGENCY CONTROL PLAN ........................................................................................14
8.2 SARA AND TITLE III ......................................................................................................14
8.3 CAER SYSTEM ............................................................................................................15
8.4 SECURITY ....................................................................................................................15
i
9. PERSONNEL QUALIFICATION .......................................................................................15
10. RECORDKEEPING AND ACCIDENT REPORTING .........................................................15
10.1 RECORDKEEPING..........................................................................................................15
10.2 REPORTING REQUIREMENTS .........................................................................................16
11. REFERENCES ..................................................................................................................17
11.1 INSTITUTE PUBLICATIONS ..............................................................................................17
11.2 DOT REGULATIONS ......................................................................................................17
11.3 OSHA REGULATIONS ...................................................................................................17
11.4 ASME STANDARDS ......................................................................................................17
11.5 AMERICAN PETROLEUM INSTITUTE PUBLICATIONS ..........................................................18
APPENDIX A -- ASME CODE CASE 2211 ...............................................................................20
APPENDIX B -- PAMPHLET 60 CHECKLIST ..........................................................................22
DRAWING ................................................................................................................................23
ii
CHLORINE PIPELINES 1
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 SCOPE
It is recognized that pipelines built prior to the publication of this edition of this pamphlet
may be operating successfully without adhering to all recommendations contained
herein. Operators of such facilities should evaluate discrepancies and validate that they
do not pose disproportionate risks to safe operation or the environment. Continued
operation without adhering to all aspects of this pamphlet is generally acceptable
provided:
(2) The system does not violate applicable codes or regulations; and
The Chlorine Institute exists to support the chlor-alkali industry and serve the public by
fostering continuous improvements to safety and the protection of human health and the
environment connected with the production, distribution and use of chlorine, sodium and
potassium hydroxides, and sodium hypochlorite; and the distribution and use of
hydrogen chloride. This support extends to giving continued attention to the security of
chlorine handling operations.
2 PAMPHLET 60
Chlorine Institute members are committed to adopting CI’s safety and stewardship
initiatives, including pamphlets, checklists, and incident sharing, that will assist members
in achieving measurable improvement. For more information on the Institute’s
stewardship program, visit CI’s website at www.chlorineinstitute.org.
ASME Code ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code (Section VIII - Rules
for Construction of Pressure Vessels, Section IX - Welding
and Brazing Qualifications, and ASME B31.3 - Chemical Plant
and Petroleum Refinery Piping) (11.4.1, 11.4.2)
dry air or nitrogen air or nitrogen dried to a dew point of -40oF (-40oC) or below
measured at the operating pressure
kPa Kilopascal(s)
PTFE polytetrafluoroethylene
CHLORINE PIPELINES 3
1.4 DISCLAIMER
The information in this pamphlet is drawn from sources believed to be reliable. The
Institute and its members, jointly and severally, make no guarantee and assume no
liability in connection with any of this information. Moreover, it should not be assumed
that every acceptable procedure is included or that special circumstances may not
warrant modified or additional procedure. The user should be aware that changing
technology or regulations may require a change in the recommendations herein.
Appropriate steps should not be confused with federal, state, provincial, municipal or
insurance requirements, or with national safety codes.
1.5 APPROVAL
The Institute's Transportation Issue Team approved Edition 7 of this pamphlet on August
21, 2013.
1.6 REVISIONS
1.7 REPRODUCTION
The contents of this publication are not to be copied for publication, in whole or in part,
without prior Institute permission.
2. GENERAL
Chlorine pipelines are operated in either the liquid or vapor phase. Suitable steps must
be taken in design and operation to ensure adequate control of the process temperature
and pressure. The chlorine phase diagram (CI Pamphlet 100 (11.1)) defines the
temperature and pressure combinations needed to maintain the desired state. It is
essential that a study of operating conditions be thoroughly carried out, because unusual
equipment design and pressure ratings may be required to address the potential for
vaporizing or condensing in the pipeline.
Phase changes are generally most difficult to handle during start-up. The introduction of
liquid chlorine into a pipeline can cause flashing from the liquid to the gas phase at the
leading edge of the liquid. A pressure drop in the pipeline can also cause such a phase
change to occur. This phase change can cause "vapor locks" in the line if the gas is not
purged. The presence of chlorine vapors in a liquid pipeline can cause flow restrictions.
4 PAMPHLET 60
Chlorine vapor introduced into a pipeline may expand, cool, and partially condense.
When this happens, sudden pressure swings may occur in the line pressure. An
effective way to prevent this is to provide a source of heat for the pipeline. A phase
change can also be caused by pipeline cooling due to ambient conditions. For pipelines
exposed to ambient conditions lower than the process temperature, regulated heat
tracing and/or insulation should be considered. Changes in elevation and ambient
conditions can also cause a phase change.
Pressure reduction points, such as pressure control or regulating valves, are the most
likely locations for phase changes in a pipeline. In gas pipelines the refrigeration effect
of expanding chlorine gas may cause a portion of the gas to condense into the liquid
phase. A pressure drop can cause the liquid to vaporize in liquid pipelines.
Design Considerations
2.2 ROUTING
When choosing a route for a pipeline, special consideration must be given to populated
and environmentally sensitive areas. Consideration should also be given to potential
pipeline damage due to adjacent pipelines, soil conditions, traffic, vandalism, commercial
operations and other conditions along the route. These considerations are especially
important when the pipeline traverses ground not under direct control of either the
producer or the consumer. To comply with DOT regulations, a class location study may
be required (49 CFR 192.5 (11.2.1)).
The DOT regulations in 49 CFR (11.2.1) governing the transportation of gas (including
chlorine gas) by pipeline are outlined below:
49 CFR Part 195 regulates the transportation of hazardous liquids by pipeline. Although
liquid chlorine is not on the 49 CFR Part 195 list of hazardous liquids, many of the
recommendations herein have been written in accord with these regulations.
3. DESIGN
The minimum specifications for materials used in chlorine service can be found in CI
Pamphlet 6 (11.1). Additionally, piping materials conforming to API SPEC 5L may be
considered for chlorine pipelines. API pipelines are more ductile than process piping
materials indicated in CI Pamphlet 6. Design specifications need to be determined
based on the potential range of operating conditions of the pipeline system including
start-ups, abnormal operating conditions, shutdowns, and system evacuation. In
selecting materials careful consideration should be given to the minimum temperature to
which any part of the system may be subjected. Additional cold service charpy testing
per ASME Code may be required if API SPEC 5L piping is used. It should be noted that
the boiling point of chlorine at atmospheric pressure is -30oF (-34oC). This is the
temperature a pipeline may be subjected to when a liquid chlorine pipeline is vented to
atmospheric pressure. For the vapor pressure curve of chlorine, see CI Pamphlet 1
(11.1).
The designer should review and consider applicable federal regulations such as 49 CFR
Part 195 (11.2.1).
General
Pipelines may be installed above or below ground. The entire system should be
evaluated to determine the preferred method.
• Provision must be made to evacuate the line to a safe location. This includes
a controlled device at one or both ends of the pipeline.
• Underground piping can suffer 3rd party damage due to poor excavation
techniques. The design should consider means to reduce any major damage
to the pipeline.
• Design techniques that have been used include increased depth of cover,
increasing wall thickness, and concrete coating of the pipe.
• For gas pipelines, leak detection systems are required by Title 49 CFR, Part
192. Consideration should be given to installing an automated leak detection
system on liquid pipelines. This could be something as simple as measuring
mass flow on each end of the line or a leak detection system which employs
both pressure analysis and mass balance to verify the line is not leaking.
Welding
The welding of steel pipelines must be performed in accordance with written welding
procedures that have been qualified under Section IX of the ASME Code (11.4.2) or
Section VI of API 1104 (11.5.1). Welders must be certified for each procedure.
Heat Treatment
All butt welds are to be 100% radiographed. A combination of radiography and/or dye
penetrant testing procedures should be used for all welds depending on the weld
configuration. The weld area and pipe should be thoroughly cleaned after dye penetrant
testing.
Radiographic techniques will identify many types of weld defects but are not fully
effective for all weld configurations. Dye penetrant testing will sometimes locate weld
defects including some not identified by radiographic techniques.
The necessity to keep the line contents at the intended phase is the primary
consideration in determining the need to insulate a system. Insulated pipes should have
an appropriate exterior painting system similar to an uninsulated pipe. A reflective outer
jacketing should be considered when covering insulated piping. This would reduce heat
pick-up from ambient sources. Recommended insulation is polyurethane foam or foam
glass block protected by an adequate outer fire resistant weather barrier.
Any heat tracing installation should be designed such that the surface temperature of the
pipe shall not exceed 300oF (149oC), see CI Pamphlet 1 (11.1)
Where the risks for elevated temperatures exist, including fire or any other undesirable
heat source (e.g. hot vent streams, adjacent steam lines or combustible materials), the
chlorine line should be protected. The designer may consider physical isolation from
other pipes in the pipe rack, erection of a fire resistant barrier between the lines, or
insulation of the chlorine line. Insulation in this case should be fire resistant material
such as foam glass with a fire resistant barrier on the outside.
All new buried pipelines, as well as repairs to existing lines, must be coated and
wrapped. All buried pipelines must be evaluated to determine the need and adequacy of
cathodic protection. Any changes to conditions along the route may require modifications
to the external protection of the pipeline.
Provision must be made for thermal pipe expansion in the system. It is recommended
that aboveground pipelines be designed utilizing flexibility analysis. If drains or vents are
present they must be taken into account when designing for expansion.
8 PAMPHLET 60
Liquid chlorine has a very high coefficient of thermal expansion. If liquid chlorine is
trapped between two valves, the pressure of the blocked-in section will increase as the
line temperature increases. The pressure can rise beyond the pressure rating of the line
with the potential to cause a leak or line failure.
An expansion chamber is connected to a pipeline to allow expansion room for the liquid.
An expansion chamber should be installed on top of the pipeline and be filled with dry air
or an inert gas. The gas in the expansion chamber is compressed as the pressure in the
line increases and protects the line from experiencing the extremely high pressure that
can be caused by liquid-full hydraulic expansion.
Institute Drawing 136, which is included in this pamphlet, shows two suggested
alternatives for expansion chamber installation. The expansion chamber should be
designed so it can be isolated and cleared. Expansion chamber installation should
include pressure indication to warn when the rupture disc has allowed flow into the
chamber.
When expansion chambers are designed to meet the ASME Code, a pressure relief
device may be required. However, ASME Code Case 2211 allows the user to provide
overpressure protection via system design in lieu of a pressure relief device. Therefore,
if the expansion chamber is designed to withstand a pressure greater than the maximum
system pressure, a pressure relief device may not be required on the expansion
chamber. ASME Code Case 2211 is included in this pamphlet as Appendix A.
The expansion chamber should have a volume of at least 20% of the pipeline section
being protected based on thermal expansion of liquid chlorine between 0oF (-18oC) and
140oF (60oC).
If offsite isolation valves are required, they should be located and protected to prevent
access by unauthorized persons. Preferably, isolation valves should be located within
an industrial site.
Isolation valves may be closed manually, remotely and/or automatically when a leak is
detected. For automated remotely activated valves, valve position should be monitored.
Remote operated valves require an energy source to close and should be equipped for
manual as well as automatic operation. These may be used in either liquid or vapor
pipelines.
Precautions should be taken to avoid liquid hammer in the event of a too rapid closure of
the valve. This can be accomplished by controlling the rate of valve closure or by
installing a buffer vessel.
CHLORINE PIPELINES 9
The use of vent and drain branches in a chlorine pipeline should be limited to the
minimum number necessary for operation. Branches increase the risk of a leak and are
difficult to insulate, allowing a location for corrosion to initiate. Branches added to test
and prepare the line for service should be minimized.
Vents and drains should be located inside the supplier’s or customer’s plant site.
The designer needs to review the requirements associated with mechanical cleaning or
inspection.
If a pigging system will be used for cleaning or if a smart pig will be used for inspections,
the following features should be included at a minimum. Additional features may be
required for use of pigs or smart pigs:
4. MARKING
New, relocated, or replaced chlorine gas pipelines and modified sections of existing gas
pipelines are to be pressure tested in accordance with 49 CFR Part 192 Subpart J and
CI Pamphlet 6 until all leaks have been located and eliminated. To increase the rated
pressure of a chlorine pipeline, it must comply with 49 CFR Part 192 Subpart K.
Chlorine gas piping intended to operate at a hoop stress of 30% or more of the specified
minimum yield stress (SMYS) must meet the requirements of 49 CFR Part 192 Subpart
J. This includes a hydrostatic test for a minimum of eight continuous hours at 1.25 times
the maximum pressure to which the system may be subjected.
Less stringent testing conditions may apply depending on the pipeline DOT location
class, intended operating pressure, the extent of the piping installation and the scope of
modifications made to existing pipelines.
Air or inert gas may be used as a test medium. The operation of a chlorine gas piping
system, tested in this manner, may be limited to lower stress conditions. Care should be
taken to limit personnel exposure while conducting tests with these media. Refer to CI
Pamphlet 6 (11.1) for more information on pipeline pressure testing.
Although 49 CFR Part 195 does not apply to liquid chlorine pipelines, it is recommended
testing be done as specified above for chlorine gas piping.
5.2 CLEANING
The preferred method for removal of dirt, weld spatter, chlorine, etc. from a chlorine
pipeline is with a pig, which is forced through the pipeline by dry air or nitrogen pressure.
CI Pamphlet 6 (11.1) explains several chlorine piping system cleaning methods. The
aqueous and abrasive cleaning methods are most commonly used on large pipelines.
The solvent cleaning method is not normally used for cleaning pipelines because of the
need to address the environmental and industrial hygiene risks associated with most
solvents. If moisture is introduced into a pipeline, all moisture-absorbing gaskets and
valve packing should be replaced. Consideration should be given to removing valves
prior to introducing moisture.
5.3 DRYING
Refer to CI Pamphlet 6 (11.1) for details regarding proper drying of a chlorine line after it
has been exposed to moisture (liquid or atmospheric) and for details on the special
attention needed to ensure that valves do not contain water.
Refer to CI Pamphlet 6 (11.1) for details on testing chlorine piping for leaks.
CHLORINE PIPELINES 11
6.1 GENERAL
The pipeline operator must have procedures for the operation and maintenance of
chlorine pipelines. For new pipelines, the procedures must be prepared before the start
of pipeline operation. Various regulations require proof of personnel being trained on the
procedures.
The procedures must be reviewed and updated once per calendar year or at a period
not exceeding 15 months and kept at locations where operations and maintenance
activities are conducted (49 CFR 192.605 (11.2.1) and 29 CFR Part 1910 (11.3)).
Before placing a pipeline in service review Section 5 and ensure the following:
a. Clean the line and ensure it is free of oil and grease. Chlorine will react
vigorously with hydrocarbon-based lubricants.
During Operation
a. The line should be maintained at conditions that insure the proper state, gas
or liquid, at all times.
c. If line is to be emptied, close isolation valves. Use dry air or inert gas to
purge to the appropriate controlled device. After liquid is purged proceed to
“Removing Pipelines from Gaseous Chlorine Service.”
12 PAMPHLET 60
a. Slowly reduce line pressure and flow to insure that the gaseous state is
maintained.
c. If line is to be emptied, isolate the pipeline. After evacuation, use dry air or
inert gas to purge to the controlled device. Isolate the purge system when
complete.
Welding
Do not attempt to repair chlorine piping or equipment by burning or welding until all
chlorine and traces of chlorine-associated residues have been purged from the system.
Burning or welding can cause steel to react rapidly with chlorine and even burst into
flame. Hot work of any kind must not be performed on an in-service chlorine pipeline.
Following hot work, lines should be cooled prior to introduction of chlorine. Refer to
Section 3.2 for welding guidelines.
Moisture
Every effort should be made to prevent the introduction of moisture into a dry chlorine
piping system. Pipelines not in service should be sealed, dried, and padded. Wet
chlorine is very corrosive to steel piping.
All materials used as lubricants, greases, packings, seals and gaskets (CI Pamphlet 95
(11.1)) must be nonreactive with chlorine. Chlorine will react vigorously with
hydrocarbon based lubricants (CI Pamphlet 164 (11.1)).
Fluorocarbon grease may be used as a gasket dope but care should be taken to ensure
it will not degrade the gasket. Where thread dope is used, care must be taken to
prevent the material from entering the piping system. Thread dopes may include PTFE
tape, PTFE paste, white lead paste, litharge and glycerin. Special chlorine compatible
lubricants are used in the assembly of valves for chlorine service.
Protective Coatings
Valves
Each valve necessary for the safe operation of the system shall be inspected and
operated in accord with manufacturer’s instructions and applicable regulations.
CHLORINE PIPELINES 13
7.1 GENERAL
Due to the characteristics of chlorine, the guidelines listed below are in some cases
more rigorous than those required by regulation. The owner/operator shall have written
procedures for inspection and surveillance. All activity must be documented to verify
adherence to procedures as required by regulation (CI Pamphlet 6 (11.1)).
For buried pipelines outside the physical confines of the operator's facility, a damage
prevention program should be maintained. All operators of buried pipelines must comply
with requirements to participate in a one-call network to provide notification of excavation
when required by state or federal law (49 CFR 192.614). Public education may be
required (49 CFR 192.616).
Weekly Patrol
The pipeline and pipeline right-of-way should be surveyed visually each week. The
survey should be by pedestrian patrol, vehicular patrol, or aircraft patrol as best suited
by the routing of the line. The inspector should look for leaks, vegetation kills, or
impending excavation or construction that could damage the line.
Monthly Inspection
The pipeline should be inspected for leaks, damage, or serious external corrosion each
month. On underground pipelines, the cathodic protection voltage should be checked at
points that represent the voltage over the entire length of the line.
Bi-Monthly Inspection
The cathodic protection rectifiers, reverse current switches, and interference bonds
should be inspected and preventive maintenance performed every two months (not
exceeding 10 weeks). Coating or insulation deterioration should be repaired as
necessary. Any required maintenance should be performed (49 CFR 192.465).
Valve Inspection
Valves necessary for the safe operation of the system should be inspected and partially
operated at intervals not exceeding 7.5 months (49 CFR 195.420).
14 PAMPHLET 60
Annual lnspection
An inspection should be conducted every calendar year (but no longer than 15 months
apart) that includes the following:
For underground lines with cathodic protection applied, a continuous overline cathodic
protection survey should be conducted once every five years to determine the level of
uniformity of cathodic protection.
With each inspection of the pipeline, the expansion bottles will be inspected for proper
operation. Refer to Institute Drawing 136 which is included in this pamphlet.
8. EMERGENCY PLANNING
Each pipeline operator will have written procedures to minimize the hazards resulting
from a chlorine pipeline emergency. Reference CI Pamphlet 64 (11.1) as a guide to
establishing an emergency control plan. For gas pipelines, this may be required by 49
CFR 192 and by federal, state and/or local regulations.
The Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act (SARA), which includes the
Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (Title III) should be reviewed to
ensure that pipelines comply with applicable requirements of these regulations.
CHLORINE PIPELINES 15
8.4 SECURITY
Needs for security should be developed with local, state and federal agencies.
9. PERSONNEL QUALIFICATION
Each pipeline operator should have a written qualification program for individuals who
perform operational, inspection and maintenance tasks on pipelines. This includes
record keeping and emergency response training. For gas pipelines, this may be
required by 49 CFR Part 192 and by local, state, and/or federal regulations.
10.1 RECORDKEEPING
Pipeline Operation
A manual of written procedures for operation of the pipeline must be prepared, made
available and kept current by the owner/operator (49 CFR 192.605 (11.2.1)). For the
operating life of the pipeline, training programs for the pipeline facility operating
personnel should be maintained and updated, as necessary. At least once each
calendar year but not exceeding a period of 15 months, the performance of operating
personnel should be reviewed and it should be verified that operating supervisors
maintain a thorough knowledge of their responsibilities. A record of operating history
must be maintained. An emergency control plan with written procedures should be
established as detailed in Section 8.
Pipeline Maintenance
A manual of written procedures for maintenance of the pipeline must be prepared, made
available and kept current. For the life of the pipeline maintain records of inspections,
tests, investigations, repairs and modifications to the pipeline. These records should
also include information on line patrols, leak surveys, actual leaks and instances of
maintenance line breaks.
16 PAMPHLET 60
There are no requirements to make reports to PHMSA for pipelines handling liquid
chlorine. However, in the case of a leak reporting will be required to other federal
agencies. An immediate telephone report to the National Response Center at 1-800-
424-8802 (call 202-267-2675 in Washington, D.C.) is required if the release is over the
Reportable Quantity (RQ).
The pipeline operator should be aware of state and local reporting requirements. It is
the operator's responsibility to fulfill those requirements for health, safety, environmental
and operating regulations.
CHLORINE PIPELINES 17
11. REFERENCES
The following publications are specifically referenced in CI Pamphlet 60. The latest
editions of CI publications may be obtained at www.chlorineinstitute.org.
Pamphlet # Title
11.2.1 Code of Federal Regulations. Title 49. Chapter 1. Parts 190-192 & 195. Office of the
Federal Register National Archives and Records Administration. U.S. Government
Printing Office: Washington, DC, (revised annually).
11.3.1 Code of Federal Regulations. Title 29. Part 1910. Office of the Federal Register
National Archives and Records Administration. U.S. Government Printing Office:
Washington, DC, (revised annually).
11.4.1 Rules for Construction of Pressure Vessels, Section VIII, Division I, ASME Boiler and
Pressure Vessel Code; ANSI/ASME BPVC-VIII-I; The American Society of Mechanical
Engineers: New York, NY, 2013.
11.4.2 Welding and Brazing Qualifications, Section IX, ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel
Code; ASME BPV-IX, an ANSI standard; The American Society of Mechanical
Engineers: New York, NY, 2013.
18 PAMPHLET 60
11.4.3 Pipe Flanges and Flanged Fittings, ASME B16.5, an ANSI standard; The American
Society of Mechanical Engineers: New York, NY, 2013.
11.4.4 Factory-Made Wrought Steel Buttwelding Fittings, ASME B16.9, an ANSI standard; The
American Society of Mechanical Engineers: New York, NY, 2012.
11.4.5 Square and Hex Bolts and Screws (Inch Series), ASME B18.2.1, an ANSI standard; The
American Society of Mechanical Engineers: New York, NY, 2012.
11.4.6 Square and Hex Nuts (Inch Series), ASME B18.2.2, an ANSI standard; The American
Society of Mechanical Engineers: New York, NY, 1987.
11.4.7 Process Piping; ASME B31.3; an ANSI standard, The American Society of Mechanical
Engineers: New York, NY, 2012.
11.4.8 Welded and Seamless Wrought Steel Pipe, ASME B36.10, an ANSI standard; The
American Society of Mechanical Engineers: New York, NY, 2004.
11.5.1 Welding of Pipelines and Related Facilities, ed. 20, Standard API 1104; American
Petroleum Institute: Washington, DC, 2010.
CODE CASE FOR SECTION VIII, DIVISION 1 AND 2 PRESSURE VESSELS WITH
OVERPRESSURE PROTECTION BY SYSTEM DESIGN
A.1.1 Inquiry
A.1.2 Reply
It is the opinion of the Committee that a pressure vessel may be provided with
overpressure protection by system design in lieu of a pressure relief device as
required by UG-125(a) of Section VIII, Division 1 and by AR-100 of Section VIII,
Division 2 under the following conditions:
c. The User shall ensure that the MAWP (see UG-98) of the vessel is
greater than the highest pressure which can reasonably be expected to
be achieved by the system. The User shall conduct a detailed analysis
which examines all credible scenarios which could result in an
overpressure condition. The “Causes of Overpressure” described in
Section 2 of API Recommended Practice 521 Guide for Pressure-
Relieving and Depressuring Systems shall be considered. An organized,
system approach, using a multi-disciplinary team such as a Hazards and
Operability Analysis (HazOp), Failure Modes, Effects and Criticality
Analysis (FMECA), Fault Tree Analysis, Event Tree Analysis, ”What-If”
Analysis or other similar methodology shall be used. In all cases, the
User shall determine the potential for overpressure due to all credible
operating and upset conditions, including equipment and instrumentation
malfunctions.
• An analysis showing the maximum pressure which can result from each of the
scenarios examined in the item listed above.
• This case number shall be shown on the Manufacturer’s Data Report for
pressure vessels that will be provided with overpressure protection by system
design, and it shall be noted on the data report that prior Jurisdictional
acceptance may be required.
22 PAMPHLET 60
This checklist is designed to emphasize major topics for someone who has already read
and understood the pamphlet. Taking recommendations from this list without
understanding related topics can lead to inappropriate conclusions.
REMINDER:
DRAWING
24 PAMPHLET 60
1300 Wilson Boulevard « Suite 525 « Arlington, VA 22209
Telephone: (703) 894-4140 « Fax: (703) 894-4130
Email: [email protected] « Website: www.chlorineinstitute.org
THE CHLORINE INSTITUTE Technical inquiries: [email protected]