Malaria Global Health Final Paper
Malaria Global Health Final Paper
Malaria Global Health Final Paper
Malaria
Makenzie D. Lee
.
MALARIA 2
Abstract
Malaria is a mosquito-borne disease that is most prevalent in developing regions, such as the
sub-Saharan African region. Malaria is transmitted through the bite of an infected female
Anopheles mosquito. This report will discuss the disease specifics surrounding malaria,
measures are vital to evading transmission. Factors surrounding health determinants and burden
of disease will be reviewed, as poverty and lack of education are key factors within this disease.
The topic of malaria will be incorporated into the five tiers of the Frieden health impact pyramid.
Each tier will be discussed in-depth and the relation to the disease will be determined.
Recommendation for future interventions towards malaria will be incorporated, as well as the
Diffusion of Innovation Model of behavior change theory. Further, global health professional
Introduction
This global health impact report will discuss the burden of disease surrounding malaria.
Malaria will be defined, including symptoms, treatment, and prevention. Key factors of global
health and health determinants will be included. The use of the Frieden health impact pyramid
will be incorporated and utilized to further evaluate the presence of malaria, while understanding
Malaria remains a prevalent disease affecting overall health of many around the world.
Malaria can be defined as “a mosquito-borne disease caused by a parasite” (Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC), 2019, para. 1). Malaria is rarely present in developed countries,
such as the United States of America; however, it continues to be present in much of the world,
specifically those areas in developing countries. “In 2014, 97 countries had ongoing
transmission of malaria and about half of all people in the world lived in places at risk of
malaria” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 333). “In 2017, there were an estimated 219 million cases of
The parasite causing malaria infects mosquitos, which in turn feed on humans (CDC,
2019). The bite must come from a female Anopheles mosquito (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 333). After
the infected mosquito bites a human, transmission occurs. “Malaria is caused by parasites in the
genus Plasmodium, five species of which infect humans; P. falciparum, P. vivax, P. ovale, P.
malariae, and P. knowlesi” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 333). Malaria is considered a dangerous disease
as it may result in death. With early detection and prompt treatment, malaria may be curable.
“Almost 550,000 people died of malaria in 2013” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 333). “The estimated
number of malaria deaths stood at 435,000 in 2017” (WHO, 2019, para. 1). Although death rates
remains most prevalent. “Malaria occurs mostly in poor, tropical and subtropical areas of the
world” (CDC, 2019, “Geography”, para. 1). “About 80 percent of the cases occurred in Africa,
12 percent in Southeast Asia, and 5 percent in the Eastern Mediterranean region” (Skolnik, 2016,
pp. 333). The parasite P. falciparum is most prevalent in Africa (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 333). “For
the sub-Saharan Africa region, malaria is the leading cause of death for all age groups and for the
under 5 years of age” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 334). “About 90 percent of the deaths were in Africa,
and almost 80 percent of those who died were children under 5 years of age, almost all of them
in Africa” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 333-334). Africa is considered the most affected by malaria due
to an efficient mosquito responsible for high transmission, the predominant parasite species is
Plasmodium falciparum that is likely to cause severe malaria and death, weather allows
transmission to occur year-round, limited resources and socioeconomic instability (CDC, 2019).
period occurs prior to the onset of the first symptoms, typically seven to 30 days (CDC, 2019).
stage (sensation of cold, shivering), a hot stage (fever, headaches, vomiting; seizures in young
children), and finally a sweating stage (sweats, return to normal temperature, tiredness)” (CDC,
2019, “Uncomplicated Malaria”, para. 1). Symptoms may also present in any combination,
including fever, headaches, nausea, chills, sweats, aches, etc. (CDC, 2019). Complicated malaria
can also be referenced as severe malaria. “Severe malaria occurs when infections are
(CDC, 2019, “Severe Malaria”, para. 1). Complicated malaria can include, but is not limited to,
MALARIA 5
anemia, respiratory distress, cerebral malaria, kidney injury, metabolic acidosis, etc. (CDC,
2019).
Communicable diseases, such as malaria, are considered infectious diseases. These are
“illnesses that are caused by a particular infectious agent and that spread directly from people to
people, animals to people, or people to animals” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 25). Additionally, when
as “the sum of years loss due to premature deaths (YLLs) and years lived with disability
(YLDs)” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 26). In sub-Saharan Africa, malaria is ranked number one in
leading causes of DALYs (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 34). Malaria is ranked number three in leading
causes of death in children under five (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 35). “In terms of DALY’s, malaria is
the sixth leading cause among all age groups and the fourth leading cause among those under 5
years of age” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 334). In understanding the vast differences when considering
the burden of disease of malaria, it is important to compare developed and developing countries.
For example, the United States of America (a developed country) had zero DALYs per 100,000
in 2017 in regards to malaria, whereas Niger (a developing country within Africa) had 10,767.04
DALYs per 100,000 (Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME), 2017).
MALARIA 6
While discovering the burden of disease of which malaria is, it is beneficial to understand
the effects of this disease. For that reason, the application of the health impact pyramid will be
used to address the issue of malaria, with a primary focus on the sub-Saharan African region
where malaria is predominantly present. The “5-tier pyramid best describes the impact of
different types of public health interventions and provides a framework to improve health”
(Frieden, 2010, pp. 590). From the base of the pyramid, and in an ascending order, the five tiers
include, socioeconomic factors, changing the context to make individuals’ default decisions
healthy, long-lasting protective interventions, clinical interventions, and lastly counseling and
education (Frieden, 2010). The base of the pyramid indicates the biggest influence. “In general,
public action and interventions represented by the base of the pyramid require less individual
effort and have the greatest population impact” (Frieden, 2010, pp. 591). Each level of the health
Socioeconomic Factors
The first tier of the health impact pyramid (the base) is socioeconomic factors. These are
often referred to as “social determinants of health, that help form the basic foundation of a
society” (Frieden, 2010, pp. 591). Health determinant factors can include sex, age, education,
socioeconomic status, employment, government, culture, access to resources, and many more
An important determinant of health surrounding malaria is sex and age. Some groups
with the highest risk include “infants, children under 5 years of age, pregnant women and
patients with HIV/AIDS, as well as non-immune migrants, mobile populations and travelers”
MALARIA 7
(WHO, 2019, “Who is at risk?”, para. 1). The most vulnerable include young children and
pregnant women (CDC, 2019). Young children have not yet developed immunity and pregnant
women have decreased immunity, thus making this group of individuals in the greatest danger of
contracting malaria (CDC, 2019). “Partial immunity is developed over years of exposure, and
while it never provides complete protection, it does reduce the risk that malaria infection will
Socioeconomic status is another aspect, likely one of the most important, of the health
determinants surrounding malaria. The sub-Saharan African region is stricken with poverty and,
therefore, a lack of basic resources. Socioeconomic status can be defined as, “a person’s
economic, social, and work status” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 20). The burden of malaria causes
considerable cost to the individuals, total population, and government. Costs to individuals
include purchasing medications for treatment, cost of appointments and possible hospitalization,
preventative costs, etc. (CDC, 2019). Government costs include resources, purchasing of
medications and supplies, staffing of healthcare workers, preventative measures, etc. (CDC,
2019). Considering direct costs of malaria aids in understanding of how poverty acts as a risk
factor for this disease. It is estimated that costs related to malaria equate to at least 12 billion US
dollars per year (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 20). The low socioeconomic status of this region allows for
lack of resources and instability. Lack of resources hinders preventative measures and/or
treatment to be implemented in these high-risk areas, such as sub-Saharan Africa. “The more
likely you are to access services of appropriate quality, the more likely you are to stay healthy”
mostly in poor tropic and subtropical areas (CDC, 2019). The environment within sub-Sahara
Africa allows for transmission of this disease throughout the year. “The long lifespan and strong
human-biting habit of the African vector species is the main reason why approximately 90% of
the world's malaria cases are in Africa” (WHO, 2019, “Transmission”, para. 3).
Cultural factors and education also coincide with malaria health determinants. “Culture
helps to determine how one feels about health and illness, how one uses health services, and the
health practices in which one engages” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 20). Lack of education promotes lack
of understanding the importance of the disease and its transmission. “People with higher
educational attainment have higher socioeconomic status and more control over their lives than
people of lower status” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 20). In a culture where poverty is vastly present, and
therefore lack of education, much of the population may not even be aware of the basic facts
Goals (SDGs). The 17 SDGs are considered “an urgent call for action by all countries—
n.d., para. 1). The main goal behind the SDGs is to “recognize that ending poverty and other
deprivations must go hand-in-hand with strategies that improve health and education, reduce
inequality, and spur economic growth—all while tackling climate change and working to
preserve our oceans and forests” (SDGs, n.d., para. 1). Many of the SDG’s relate to malaria,
however, goal number one, no poverty, and goal number three, good health and well-being, are
most related (SDGs, n.d.). As mentioned, poverty plays a large role in malaria transmission in
MALARIA 9
treatments.
The next tier of the health impact pyramid is changing the context to make individuals’
default decisions healthy. “The second tier of the pyramid represents interventions that change
the environmental context to make healthy options the default choice, regardless of education,
income, service provision, or other societal factors” (Frieden, 2010, pp. 591). Important
resources as well will in turn promote health decisions as the individuals will have the ability to
use preventative measures. “The defining characteristic of this tier of intervention is that
individuals would have to expend significant effort not to benefit from them” (Frieden, 2010, pp.
591).
(LSM). LSM is the “management of aquatic habitats that are the potential breeding sites for
mosquitoes, to prevent the completion of immature development” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44).
LSM “provides the dual benefits of reducing numbers of house-entering mosquitoes and those
that bite outdoors” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44). LSM, if initiated, would allow for manipulation
of the environment therefore making these changes unavoidable. Changes made would affect the
modification, habitat manipulation, biological control, and larviciding (Tizifa et al., 2018).
Habitat modification includes “permanent change of land and water including landscaping,
drainage of surface water, land reclamation, and filling” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44). Habitat
manipulation contains “water level manipulation, includes measures such as flushing, drain
MALARIA 10
clearance, shading, or exposing habitats to the sun” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44). Biological
control includes “introduction of natural enemies into aquatic habitats (e.g., predatory fish,
invertebrates, para-sites, or disease organisms)” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44). Larviciding
mosquitoes” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44). Possible implementation of LSM would result in
The third tier of the health impact pyramid is long-lasting protective interventions. This
is considered “protective interventions that do not require ongoing clinical care” (Frieden, 2010,
pp. 592). In relation to the burden of malaria, protective interventions include vector control and
preventative treatment.
Two major forms of vector control include insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) and indoor
residual spraying (IRS). The goal of vector control is to prevent transmission of the disease by
reducing the vector population. ITNs are either conventional nets or long-lasting nets. Long-
lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) last up to three years compared to conventional nets which last
up to 12 months (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 42). The insecticides used aim to kill mosquitos, thus
controlling the vector causing disease. “The insecticides also repel mosquitoes, reducing the
number that enter the house and attempt to feed on people inside” (CDC, 2019, “How do ITNs
work?”, para. 2). “In 2017, about half of all people at risk of malaria in Africa were protected by
mosquito nets”, para. 2). The use of ITNs does come with constraints. These include cost,
socioeconomic status, distribution, etc. (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 43). This again relates to the
health determinant of poverty in relation to disease. “ITNs were shown to reduce the death of
MALARIA 11
children under 5 years from all causes by about 20%” (CDC, 2019, “Insecticide-treated Bed
Nets”, para. 1). Additionally, to ITNs is IRS. The goal of IRS is similar to ITNs; vector control.
“Many malaria vectors are considered “endophilic”; that is, the mosquito vectors rest inside
houses after taking a blood meal” (CDC, 2019, “Indoor Residual Spraying”, para. 1). Through
IRS, these mosquitos can be controlled. IRS involves coating surfaces of a house with a residual
insecticide which will kill mosquitoes once in contact with these surfaces (CDC, 2019).
Constraints to IRS use include cost in high transmission areas and health risks and environmental
hazards related to the insecticides used” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44).
during pregnancy and children who have yet acquired immunity are populations most at risk of
pyrimethamine) to all pregnant women without testing whether or not they are infected with the
malaria parasite” (CDC, 2019, “IPTp”, para. 1). It has been shows that IPTp may be
administered at each routine visit, starting in the second trimester (CDC, 2019). Malaria
infection during pregnancy can have adverse effects on both mother and fetus, including
“maternal anemia, fetal loss, premature delivery, intrauterine growth retardation, and delivery of
low birth-weight infants (<2500 g or <5.5 pounds), a risk factor for death” (CDC, 2019,
“Intermittent Preventative Treatment of Malaria in Pregnant Women (IPTp)”, para. 2). As well
as IPTp, preventative treatment for children includes intermittent preventative treatment during
intervals corresponding to routine vaccination schedules” (CDC, 2019, “What is IPTi”, para. 1).
Treatment is to be given regardless of malaria infection status of the child (CDC, 2019).
Limitations to IPTp and IPTi include cost and access. Again, in relation to poverty and access to
resources, if families are unable to receive healthcare treatments or even have the ability to go
Clinical Interventions
Next on the health impact pyramid is clinical interventions. This represents any current
ongoing interventions (Frieden, 2010). Interventions to malaria can include diagnostics and
treatment. When considering diagnostics, two main tests are known. These include a rapid
diagnostic test and microscopy. “Diagnostic testing improves the overall management of
patients with febrile illnesses and may also help to reduce the emergence and spread of drug
resistance by reserving antimalarials for those who actually have the disease” (WHO, 2019,
“Diagnostic Testing”, para. 1). A Rapid Diagnostic Test is an “alternate way of quickly
person’s blood” (CDC, 2019, “Malaria Diagnostic Test”, para. 1). This may be beneficial in
developing countries that lack resources to perform microscopy testing. The rapid diagnostic test
was developed to “make it easier to test for malaria in low-resource settings” (Skolnik, 2016, pp.
335). “Blood for the test is commonly obtained from a finger-prick and results are available
within 15–30 minutes” (WHO, 2019, “Various Types of RDT’s on the Market”, para. 1).
Additionally, microscopy diagnostics may be performed. These include a blood sample that is
stained and reviewed under a microscope in a lab. Often considered the gold standard for
diagnostics, again it may not be the most available for developing countries.
MALARIA 13
Treatment of malaria has been most beneficial with prompt initiation. Treatment is
recommended within 24 hours of the first symptoms (CDC, 2019). “Appropriate treatment of
malaria is essential to reduce malaria morbidity and mortality” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 335). “Drugs
such as chloroquine, Fansidar (sulfadoxine and pyrimethamine), and mefloquine were used
earlier as standard treatments for malaria” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 335). Currently, antimalarial
treatment has changed. “The best available treatment, particularly for P. falciparum malaria, is
artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT)” (WHO, 2019, “Diagnosis and Treatment”, para.
1). Treatment aims to cure the disease and prevent further transmission. The main objective of
treatment is to guarantee a “complete cure, that is the rapid and full elimination of the
Plasmodium parasite from the patient’s blood, in order to prevent progression of uncomplicated
malaria to severe disease or death, and to chronic infection that leads to malaria-related anaemia”
(WHO, 2019, “Treatment”, para. 1). Additionally, mass drug administration (MDA) may be
defined population or every person living in a defined geographical area (except those for whom
the medicine in contraindicated) at approximately the same time and often at repeated intervals”
(CDC, 2019, “Use of Antimalarials to Reduce Malaria Transmission”, para. 2). Complications
of malaria treatment arise with antimalarial drug resistance. Currently there is no vaccine to
prevent malaria. When drug resistance occurs, treatment becomes more difficult. With ensuring
The final tier of the health impact pyramid is counseling and education. This is
considered “education provided during clinical encounters as well as education in other settings”
(Frieden, 2010, pp. 592). Included within their tier is the role of a nurse. Nursing advocacy
MALARIA 14
remains a significant aspect of disease prevention and treatment. According to the American
Nurses Association (ANA), advocacy is a “pillar of nursing” (ANA, n.d., para. 1). Nurses must
be able to perform diagnostic testing and have skills in treatment. Malaria is predominantly
present in developing countries, where poverty is often significant. Poverty increases the
likelihood that a population has lack of education. In relation to malaria, many educational
opportunities exist. It is important to educate all, even more so those who are the highest risk.
Education should include symptoms and prevention. Particularly with IPTp and IPTi, education
follow-up appointments. It is also important to encourage and advocate for the use of
preventative measures such as ITNs and IRS. Although resources may be present, benefits are
not received if the population is not educated in its use. Through promotion of education and
Innovation Model. Diffusion is defined as “the process by which innovations are communicated
over time among members of different groups and societies” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 152). An
innovation is defined as “an idea, practice, service, or other object that is perceived as new by the
individual or group” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 152). The main idea of this model is that
“communication is needed to promote social change” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 152). Additionally, it
suggests that people can be encouraged to adopt the innovations (Skolnik, 2016, pp.152). This
can be incorporated when discussing malaria as preventative measures and treatments can be
viewed as innovations. This includes adopting the technologies, accepting it into the current
culture, and maintaining its existence. Communication encourages recognition and therefore
Considering malaria has remained a burden of disease for a substantial period of time,
future interventions and improvements must be considered. The global plan for addressing malaria
(Skolnik, 2016, pp. 335). A large aspect of future malaria endeavors includes the need for
additional funding. “Funding for nets, and other malaria prevention and control interventions, is
likely to plateau or even decline in the next few years due to the current economic situation” (CDC,
2019, “Long-lasting Insecticide-treated Nets (LLINs)”, para. 3). Funding for malaria includes
preventative treatments such as IPTp, IPTi, ITN, and IRS. “In 2015, malaria funding totaled US$
2.9 billion, representing only 45% of the funding milestone for 2020 (US$ 6.4 billion)” (WHO,
2019, “Urgent Need for more Funding”, para. 1). Due to malaria being most prevalent in
developing countries with poverty, funding must be raised to promote disease eradication.
openings such as windows, doors, and eaves or installation of ceilings” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp.
44). “Historically, improved housing was thought to have contributed to the elimination of
malaria in the USA and to its decline in Europe” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp. 44). In regions such as
those of sub-Saharan Africa, housing is often very under-developed, often lacking basic
protection from the elements. “Modern houses tend to be more protective against malaria than
traditional houses made of natural materials that leave multiple gaps through which mosquitoes
can enter, and in some settings, they offer protection equivalent to ITNs” (Tizifa et al., 2018, pp.
44).
MALARIA 16
“Continuous development of new drugs to fight malaria is also critical, given the speed with
which malaria has developed resistance to other drugs and the limited number of drugs that now
work effectively against malaria” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 336). Due to the large burden of disease in
some areas, drug resistance is occurring. “Five countries have now shown resistance to ACT and
there is no new proven drugs available to combat malaria” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 336).
Many new projects through WHO are underway with hopes of malaria eradication. The
Malaria Policy Advisory Committee (MPAC) was established to “provide independent strategic
(WHO, 2019, “Malaria Policy Advisory Committee”, para. 1). The Rapid Access Expansion
pneumonia, and diarrhea for children under 5 in sub-Saharan Africa” (WHO, 2019, “Rapid
Access Expansion Programme (RAcE)”, para. 1). Mekong Malaria Elimination (MME) program
supports “malarial elimination in the GMS by facilitating coordination and dialogue among
Global Health can be defined as “health problems, issues, and concerns that transcend
national boundaries and may best be addressed by cooperative actions” (Skolnik, 2016, pp. 7).
Within the field of global health, many professional opportunities and career paths are available.
Global health often surrounds burden of disease in under-developed regions. Work with the
CDC and WHO may allow abroad travel to such locations to provide education, treatment,
possibility to become an educator specifically for global health. It is important to educate others
about the importance of global health, burdens of disease, and health determinants affecting the
world. Through nursing, another career path includes public health nursing. This focuses on the
importance of the health and well-being of others. Becoming an advocate in the field of global
health is extremely important when advocating for those who are less fortunate. Poverty stricken
regions with lack of resources and education need someone to promote change and provide
education.
MALARIA 18
Conclusion
promoting change. Many health determinants and factors are prevalent within the topic of
malaria and need to be considered. Through the integration of the health impact pyramid, it is
clear that many factors surrounding malaria exist. It has been shown that burden of disease can
be vastly different depending on location and the socioeconomic factors present. Nurses must
continue to advocate and educate for disease prevention and health maintenance.
MALARIA 19
References
https://www.nursingworld.org/practice-policy/advocacy/
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2019). Parasites—Malaria. Retrieved from
https://www.cdc.gov/parasites/malaria/index.html
Frieden, T. (2010). A framework for public health action: The health impact pyramid. American
Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME). (2017). GBD Compare. Retrieved from
https://vizhub.healthdata.org/gbd-compare/
Skolnik, R. (2016). The principles and goals of global health. In Riegelman, R (Ed.), Global
https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/?menu=1300
Tizifa, T., Kabaghe, A., McCann, R., Van den Berg, H., Van Vugt, M., & Phiri, K. (2018).
Prevention efforts for malaria. Current tropical medicine reports, 5(1), pp. 41-50. doi:
10.1007/s40475-018-0133-y
room/fact-sheets/detail/malaria