Volume 4, Issue 5, May– 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology

ISSN No:-2456-2165

Assessment of Health Care Waste Management

(HCWM) in Iraq; Effects and Control
Imadaddin A. H. Al-Nakkash1; Sedik A.K. Al-Hiyaly2 ; Basim.H.Faraj2 and Asala, S.A. Kasim3
1
Ministry of health and environment- Public health administration, Baghdad- Iraq.
2
Environmental Research Center- University of Technology, Baghdad- Iraq.
3
Ministry of health and environment- Al-Kindi Teaching Hospital, Baghdad- Iraq.

Abstract:- This study was carried out to define and implications on the general health and the surrounding
assess the health care waste management (HCWM) in environment (4).
official and private hospitals all over Iraq, in addition to
the public health centers (PHC) focusing on the The technical aspects of the waste management such
development of a short and medium term plan of action as waste handling, storage, development, financial aspects,
and estimating the real needs of sound management. staff responsibilities and roles, surveillance and control
About 43% of official hospitals lack from big containers being essential components in sustaining the operation of
for collecting and segregating of health care wastes. All HCWM system(5) have been seriously affected. It is well
hospitals are in lack of proper unites of treatment and known that field experience of the inclusion of HCWM
disposal of hazardous liquid wastes while 65% of planning within the health care institutions is the first step
hospitals are deficient of incinerators. Most of health towards encouraging the development of better hygienic
institutions do not have adequate well trained staff to practices and optimizing the operation of existing HCWM
handle such health care wastes particularly in official systems. It can also become the catalyst for the
hospitals. However, generated hazardous solid wastes development of material HCWM plans in due course (6)
had been studied and found to be about half a ton per
month in official hospitals, 167 kg per each private Health waste management is part of the hospital
hospitals and 83.3 kg of the PHC center. Accordingly, a hygiene and infection control where the efficient HCWM in
short term and medium term plans of action have been health institutions is of essential importance and role
formulated. towards breakage of infection chain in addition to its
complementary role in infection control inside the health
Keywords:- HCWM, PHC, Official Hospitals, Private institute (7).
Hospitals, Incinerators.
The responsibility of HCWM is shared between
I. INTRODUCTION different sectors starting from the health institute down to
the municipalities services (transportation and proper final
Health care wastes include all wastes (solid and disposal) where together with the essential role of the
liquid) that are generated by health care institutes and ministry of environment participation in monitoring
medical laboratories of both official and private sectors (1). different stages of wastes disposal and legislation of laws
About 75-90 % of these produced wastes are ordinary and regulations towards better management (9).
wastes similar to municipal wastes while the remaining
percentage (10-25 %) are considered as hazardous health Infection may spread to susceptible from hazardous
care wastes (2). The quantity of such wastes varies according HCW either directly by contacts or indirectly by rodents
to several variables such as management instructions, and insects within the hospital particularly if the wastes
health institutes, funds, percentage of materials and the were not handled, packed or stored properly (10).
extent of daily health care provided. However, disease
agents may transfer by different ways such as absorption Improper handling and safety precautions may lead to
via skin cracks, absorption through mucous membrane, via occupational disease. It was reported that about eight cases
respiratory track inhalation and by ingestion where the of occupational AIDS had occurred in France in 1993
infection can be spread by direct contact with body fluids where two cases have been reported to be due to the
and/or by rodents and insects (3). presence of cracks in skin of cleaners (10). Thirty-nine AIDS
cases were registered in the USA in 1993 due to miss
During last two decades, health services were puncturing by needles (11, 12).
deteriorated due to the absence of obvious and sound
polices, strategies and enforcement of legislation for Hazardous HCW categories consist of various medical
handling and disposing of health care wastes (HCW) which wastes such as infections, pathological, sharp,
resulted in poor management of health care wastes and pharmaceutional, cytotoxic, chemical, heavy metals,
causing an increased exposure of patients, medical and radioactive, pressurized containers and used batteries and
support staffs to various hazardous wastes. However, thermometers (1).
improper management of HCW have had serious

IJISRT19MY670 www.ijisrt.com 861

Volume 4, Issue 5, May– 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
All individuals exposed to hazardous health-care Available HCW
Hospitals
waste are potentially at risk, including those within health- No. of storage container
Provinces total No.
care establishments that generate hazardous waste, and Beds
those outside (14). Those sources who either handle such No. %
waste or exposed to it as a consequence of careless Baghdad 37 9363 29 78
management. In general, the main groups at risk are Diala 9 913 2 22
medical doctors, nurses, health-care auxiliaries, patients in Babylon 8 1249 5 62
health-care establishments or receiving home care, visitors Salahaldeen 8 1289 1 12
to health-care establishments, workers in support services Wassit 9 965 3 33
allied to health-care establishments, such as laundries, Karbala 5 720 4 80
waste handling, and transportation, workers in waste Holly Najaf 5 1185 4 80
disposal facilities (such as landfills or incinerates),including Al- Diwanya 6 980 4 66
scavengers and home-based health-care, such as dialysis, Al-Muthana 4 1070 2 50
and that generated by illicit drug use(usually intravenous). Al-Anbar 11 1370 8 72
Nasiriya 7 1037 3 42
The major sources of health care waste are various
Basra 10 2864 6 60
hospitals, PHC and research centers, blood banks, nursing
house of elderly people and mortuary and autopsy centers Missan 7 773 3 42
(15)
. Mosul 14 3211 9 64
Kirkuk 5 995 0 0
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS Total 145 36347 80 55.17
Table 1:- The Availability of HCW Big Storage Containers
This study has covered 145 official hospitals, 73 in Different Hospitals in Each Province
private hospitals and 1717 PHC centers all over Iraq expect
three Kurdish provinces. Regarding the contribution of both municipality and
health services in collecting, transporting and disposing
The data collections were obtained via survey health care wastes. The studied provinces were
questionnaire suggested by the WHO regional office for significantly varied where in certain provinces such as
south-East Asia (16) with minor change being adapted to the Karbala and Kirkuk have showed that there was no obvious
Iraqi hospitals. Also a questionnaire for PHC centers was contribution of health services while the local municipal
adapted to conduct this national survey of health-care waste service has fully transported and discharged these health
practices. The data were collected by carrying site wastes from hospital to landfill sites. Other provinces such
observations and direct interviews with health or support as Diala and Al-Diwanya showed very weak efforts having
workers (waste workers, cleaners, etc.). This was carried by maximum percentage of both authorities not exceeding
pre-trained primary health care physicians in Baghdad and 44% and 16% respectively and this means that significant
other provinces. These data were supervised and confirmed waste quantities were not soundly handled (Table 2).
by official senior physicians in hospitals and province
health directorate. Collection of data was carried during the Also, it seems that only 3 studied hospitals which
last three months of the years 2004. form only 2% from total number of 145 hospitals had
proper sewage disposal treatments, while the remaining
The mean generating rate of health-care wastes was health institutes which were about 142 hospitals had no
calculated in general for hospitals according to the bed such facilities.
occupancy rate in each hospital.
Regarding incinerators, only eighty-four official
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION (58%) and 63 private hospitals (90%) have working
incinerators. However, 1462 PHC centers (86%) lack
Table 1 displays all examined provinces, total number incinerators and depend on primitive ways in discharging
of hospitals in each province, number of beds of each solid health-care wastes via burning them improperly and
hospital and storage containers of HCW with their under unhealthy environmental situation while others try to
percentage. transfer their wastes to the nearest official hospital
containing incinerator.
It seems clearly that 44.83% of all studied hospitals
had no HCW storage containers over all examined
provinces. However, both Wassit and Holy Najaf provinces
had the highest percentage (80%) had HCW containers
followed by Baghdad province with percentage of 78%
while Kirkuk province did not have any such container
followed by Salahaldeen province with percentage of 12%.

IJISRT19MY670 www.ijisrt.com 862

Volume 4, Issue 5, May– 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Contribution percentage of Country Generating rate of
transporting HCW % HCW Kg/bed/day
Provinces
Municipality Hospital North America 7.0 – 10.0
contribution contribution Latin America 3.0
Baghdad 81 15 Western Europe 3.0 – 6.0
Diala 22 22 Eastern Europe 1.4 – 2.0
Babylon 50 25 Middle East 1.3 – 3.0
Salahaldeen 50 50 East Asia(High Income) 2.5 – 4.0
Wassit 34 55 East Asia(low income) 1.8 - 2.2
Karbala 100 0 Jordanian Kingdome 0.5
Holly Najaf 80 20 Hungary 0.16
Al- Diwanya 16 0 Table 4:- Generated Rate of Health-Care Wastes in
Al-Muthana 50 50 Different Hospitals in World Countries
Al-Anbar 54 27
Nasiriya 42 58 The first stage of HCW is disturbed; step of
Basra 60 40 segregation of hazardous wastes at the level of their first
Missan 43 14 production site; and that is because of lack of monitoring
Mosul 71 29 and awareness of the hazardous effect of HC wastes. There
Kirkuk 100 0 is an essential need for a training program being carried in
Total 81 24 all health institutes in order to prepare the working
Table 2:- Contribution of both Municipality and Hospital personnel to bear responsibility accordingly. Lack of big
Services in Transportation Health Care Wastes from storage containers in hospitals disturbs the HCWM at the
Hospitals to Landfill Sites storage step of the task reflects negatively on the
transportation step.
Also, most studied health institutions have untrained
HCW personal at different stages of health-care waste Obviously, health care wastes are transported by non-
management and so segregation and proper transportation competent cars which add to the possibility of
is not done soundly. Furthermore, 77% of the official contamination and spread of infection due to disuse and
hospitals suffer shortage of HCWM workers and most misuse of carriage. Also, about 98% of hospitals have no
examined health institutions don not have HCWM waste-water disposal treatment units. Several hospitals
requirements and personal safety equipment. drain their liquid sewage without any treatment directly to
the river which may cause biological & chemical pollution
The mean generating rate of hazardous solid health- and hazards and form serious threat to people living
care wastes in different institutions was calculated in around.
general for hospitals according to the bed occupancy rate in
each hospital and the mean is given in Table 3. The lack of incinerators in most health institutions
(official and private) led to the accumulation of wastes
The mean health-care solid wastes generating rate per within and around the hospital or PHC center which are
bed was calculated and found range from 1.4 to 1.7 already not segregated and carry much hazards of
kg/bed/day. However, such medical solid wastes are within contamination due to misuse and segregation that take
the range of various hospitals around the world (Table 4). place outside the institution by children living on this task.

Provision of requirements for managing different The task of transfer of health-care wastes from some
stages of HCWM is the most important requirements to institutions to others which do have incinerators is not
achieve sound and proper management that is to say from regular and carry some hazards since they are beyond the
providing bags of different colors to segregate hazardous capacity of incinerators so some are neglected or being
HCW down to big containers for storage and transportation burned locally by firing them inside non-working
to areas of treatment or dumping site. incinerators or in barrels which carry the risk of air
pollution in addition to misuse of wastes which fall around.
Mean generated health Lack of training of HCWM personnel necessitate a
Health Institute wastes Kg continuous training and educating program to all hospital
Monthly Annually staff concerned with HCWM. In addition, the shortage of
Official hospitals 500 6000 HCWM personnel should be managed by motivation or by
Private hospitals 167 2004 contracting with private companies concerned with
HCWM.
Primary health centers 83 996
Total 750 9000 HCWM in hospital and PHC centers is incompetent
Table 3:- The Mean Monthly and Annually Generated and lack fixed responsibility and accordingly improperly
Health Wastes in Different Health Institutions monitored and managed. However, it needs several

IJISRT19MY670 www.ijisrt.com 863

Volume 4, Issue 5, May– 2019 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
measures be more controlled such as monitoring, and training option. J Ayub Med Coll
coordinative and collaborative task and responsibility of Abbottabad. 2010;22(4):101-5.
HCWM, the cooperation of infection control committee in [7]. World Health Organization. Standard Precautions in
each hospital with the public health department, supplying Healthcare, 2017.
proper equipment of locally managed medical wastes and [8]. Ali, Z.H.; Al-Hiyaly, S.A.K and Rashid, G.Y.
implementing a water waste disposal treatment unit in Environmental Impact Assessment of Medical Wastes
every health institute. Shredding Machine in Al-Hila Teaching Hospital-
Babylon Province, IRAQ. Under Press, 2019.
To handle proper health care waste management, two [9]. Lee, BK; Ellenbecker, MJ and Moure-Ersaso, R.
obvious actions may be recommended in short and medium Alternatives for treatment and disposal cost reduction
terms where: of regulated medical wastes. Waste Management,
2004; 24(2), 143-161.
 Short Term Actions Consist of the Following: [10]. World Health Organization. National healthcare
waste management plan. Guidance Manual; 2002.
 Providing new suitable incinerators to cover all health [11]. Amin R, Gul R, Mehrab A. Hospital waste
institutes. management; practices in different hospitals of Distt.
 Securing a safe transportation of hazardous health-care Peshawar. Professional Med J 2013;20(6): 988-994.
solid wastes from hospital and PHCs. [12]. Chaerul, M, Tanaka, M. shexdar, AV. A system
 Minimizing misdischarging by proper waste separation dynamic approach for hospital waste management.
and waste audit. (17) Waste many,2008, Vol. 28(2), 442.449.
 Minimizing wastes generating. (18) [13]. Berwick, D.M hackbarth, A.D. Eliminating waste in
U.S healthcare. JAMA, 2012, Vol. 307(M),1513-
 Medium Term Should Cover the Following Actions (19): 1513.
[14]. Gupta, S., and Boojh, R. Report on biomedical waste
 Strengthen the cooperation, integration between management practices at Balrampur hospital,
concerned institution at governorate and strict levels. Lucknow, India. Waste Manag. Res., 2006, Vol.
 Implementing waste-water treatment plants at hospitals 24,584-591.
and PHCs. [15]. Muduli, K. and Bare, A: Barriers to green practice in
 Finding laws and regulations in coordination with the health care waste sector: An Indian perspective. I nt.
J. Environ. Sci. 2012, Vol. 3(4), 393-399.
ministry of environment.
[16]. Abdulla, F.; Qdais, H.A. and Rabi, A.
 Carrying studies to assess the HCWM and strengthen
Site.investigation on medical waste management
research work in different aspects of the subject.
practice in northern Jorden. Waste money, 2008, Vol.
 Proper handling hazardous liquid wastes prior to their 28(2),450-458.
drainage into the public sewage system, with special [17]. Conrardy, J.; Hillanbrand, M..; Myers, S. and
priority to hospital draining liquid wastes directly to the
Nussbaum, G.F. Reducing medical waste. AORN
river.
J.2010 Vol. 91(6).711-21.
 Minimizing health care wastes by reducing generating [18]. Momeni, H.; Tabatbagel, F.SF.; Arefinejad, A.;
sources, recycling wastes either on-site or off-site, Afzali, A.; Talebi, F. and Rahmanpour, S.E.
Following clear management instructions and finally Composition, Production Rate and Management of
segregating such wastes to control hazardous materials. Dental Solid Waste in 2017 in Birjand. Iran. Int J
Occup Environment Med. 2018 Vol. 9(1) 52-60.
REFERENCES [19]. Abah, SO and Ohimain, EL. Healthcare waste
management in Nigeria. Acase study. J. Public Health
[1]. Reinhardt, Peter A., and Judith G. Gordon. Infections Epidemiology 2011, Vol.3(3).99-110.
and medical waste management. Chelsea, Michelins
publisher, 1991.
[2]. The Public Health Implications of Medical Waste. A
report to congress. Atlanta: U.S department of health
and human services. Public health services, 1990;
document no. PB 100271
[3]. USA Department. National research council
recommendations concerning chemical hygiene
laboratories. 2013
[4]. Environment Protection Agency Guidance on closed
containers, 2013
[5]. World Health Organization. Safe management
&health for waste, 1999.
[6]. Kumar, R.; Khan, EA; Ahmed, J.; Khan, Z.; Magan,
M.; Nousheen, M. and Mughal, MI. Healthcare waste
management (HCWN) in Pakistan current situation

IJISRT19MY670 www.ijisrt.com 864