Pediatric Head Trauma: A Review and Update: Practice Gaps
Pediatric Head Trauma: A Review and Update: Practice Gaps
Rose N. Gelineau-Morel, MD,* Timothy P. Zinkus, MD,† Jean-Baptiste Le Pichon, MD, PhD*
*Division of Neurology and †Division of Radiology, Children’s Mercy Hospital, Kansas City, MO
Practice Gaps
There is still a considerable amount of confusion when it comes
to managing concussions. An excessive number of head computed
tomographic scans are being obtained for concussions, resulting
in unnecessary exposure to ionizing radiation. Clinicians should be
aware of the most recent guidelines for the management of
concussion, including the need for imaging, and should be able
to differentiate mild from moderate and severe traumatic brain
injury.
C Cognitive function Memory impairment, decreased attention and Neuropsychological testing (in person or computer-
concentration, slowed processing speed based, such as ImPACT testing)
O Oculomotor Convergence insufficiency, blurred vision, abnormal Visual acuity testing
dysfunction saccades and/or smooth pursuit, photophobia King-Devick test (assess saccadic eye movements)
A Affective disturbances Fatigue, sadness, irritability, sleep disturbance, poor Depression screen
concentration, emotionality
C Cervical spine disorders Neck pain, headaches, dizziness, balance difficulty Neck range of motion
Palpation of bones and muscles of the neck
H Headaches Migrainous, tension-type, or cervicogenic headaches –
C Cardiovascular Exercise intolerance, heart rate variability or elevation, Orthostatic vital signs
anomaly postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, autonomic Exercise stress test
dysfunction Tilt table testing
V Vestibular dysfunction Dizziness, vertigo, balance difficulties Romberg test
Tandem gait
Vestibulo-ocular reflex
Balance Error Scoring System (see the Child Sport
Concussion Assessment Tool)
This table includes the common clinical phenotypes of concussion that patients may endorse on a symptom scale. Listed are the corresponding symptoms
of each phenotype, as well as further testing that can be considered to assess each symptom. See Craton et al. (12)
testing at the time of injury and repeated testing throughout evidence of skull fracture, or signs of clinical deterioration.
recovery to track changes in individual and total symptom (6) The Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Net-
scores. If symptoms in any 1 or more of the tested clinical work (PECARN) has established criteria that can be used in
domains are present, this suggests a diagnosis of concus- decision making for children presenting after a TBI. The
sion. (13) clinical criteria for children 2 years and older include
If further delineation of symptoms is required, additional normal mental status, no loss of consciousness, no vomit-
testing, either in the office or via a referral to the appropriate ing, nonsevere injury mechanism, no signs of basilar skull
provider, can be considered. Some toolkits, such as the Child fracture, and no severe headache. If all of these criteria are
SCAT5, include further testing that can be performed by the met, they demonstrate a negative predictive value of
provider to screen for certain concussion phenotypes. These 99.95% for clinically important TBI. Conversely, the pres-
include the Balance Error Scoring System, which assesses ence of any 1 of these predictors has sensitivity of 96.8%
postural stability, and the Sensory Organization Test, which in identifying clinically important TBI and indicates that
assesses the patient’s equilibrium with altering visual and further assessment with head CT is required. Criteria
somatosensory inputs. However, these methods are not as for children younger than 2 years are also included in
sensitive at concussion diagnosis as the previously men- the study. (18) Unfortunately, unnecessary head CT in
tioned Likert rating scales. (6) Other targeted testing could children remains a common concern, and further education
include visual acuity for oculomotor dysfunction, orthostatic of community providers can help reduce this unneeded
vital signs of cardiovascular dysfunction, or a detailed spinal radiation exposure. (19)
neuromuscular examination to evaluate for cervical spine Although clinical discretion is still required to make a
abnormalities (Table 1). (7) concussion diagnosis, the previously mentioned tools can
Of note, computed tomography (CT) cannot be used to help identify symptoms and track recovery, aiding the
diagnose concussion and should generally be avoided to clinician in decisions regarding return to play and when
prevent unnecessary ionizing radiation exposure, although to pursue referral or further testing. With the typical natural
it may be used to rule out a more severe TBI, especially in history of concussion, an athlete’s symptoms should return
patients with loss of consciousness, posttraumatic amnesia, to baseline in 2 weeks for adults and in 4 weeks for children.
persistent altered mental status, focal neurologic deficit, (20)
The table is adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Heads Up guidelines and the Child Sport Concussion Assessment Tool for
returning to play. Each step should take a minimum of 24 hours. During the above progression, the child, family, and health-care provider should pay
special attention to any new or worsening symptoms. If any symptoms worsen while exercising, the child should return to the previous step.
Spontaneously Spontaneously 4
To shout To verbal command 3
To pain To pain 2
No response No response 1
Spontaneous Obeys 6
Localizes pain Localizes pain 5
Flexion withdrawal Flexion withdrawal 4
Decorticate Decorticate 3
Decerebrate Decerebrate 2
No response No response 1
0–23 mo 2–5 y >5 y
Verbal response
Information from Teasdale G, Jennett B. Assessment of coma and impaired consciousness: a practical scale. Lancet. 1974;304:81–84.
Epidural Hematoma. Epidural hematomas tend to be the filled with cerebrospinal fluid (Fig 1). These bleeds are ex-
result of arterial bleeds associated with skull fractures. tremely common in the context of TBI and frequently cause
These bleeds result from the accumulation of blood in seizures because blood is an irritant to the cerebral cortex. CT
the potential space formed by the junction of the dura mater scans of an acute subarachnoid hemorrhage show hyperdense
and the skull (Fig 1). The classic example is a middle layering along the convexities of the cerebral cortex extending
meningeal artery tear in the context of a temporal or parietal into the sulci and often the basilar cisterns (Fig 2).
bone fracture. In this context, epidural bleeds can be cata-
strophic. Given the arterial nature of these bleeds they can Space-Occupying Lesions: Contusion and DAI
lead to a very rapid mass effect with resulting herniation of Contusions occur as a result of mechanical compression
the cerebral contents. However, it is important to recognize of the brain tissue, such as often occurs after a very rapid
that epidural bleeds in children are usually much more acceleration, and tend to have the greatest impact to the
forgiving than those in adults. (44) It is not completely clear orbital frontal region. These types of injuries frequently cause
why this might be, although in the study just cited smaller a corresponding injury in the diametrically opposite side of
clots tended to be more frequent in younger children. Acute the brain, likely a result of a low-pressure area of injury.
epidural bleeds are characterized by a hyperdense lens- These types of injuries are frequently referred to as coup
shaped lesion on CT (Fig 2). and contrecoup injuries (Fig 2). Interestingly, the contrecoup
Subdural Hematoma. Subdural hematomas result from injury is often more severe than the coup injury. (46)
the accumulation of blood in the potential space between the DAIs are deep white matter track injuries typically caused
dura mater and the arachnoid layers (Fig 1). These bleeds are by rapid rotational acceleration of the brain content. These
usually caused by the rupture of bridging veins that traverse injuries result in axonal damage and often axonopathy (axon
this space. They are quite frequent in infants, especially in disconnection). Technically, DAI can be diagnosed postmor-
the context of abuse. (45) They are also frequently caused by tem only. However, a patient presenting with a closed head
other forms of rapid shearing injuries to the brain, such as injury caused by a high-velocity impact and found to have a
motor vehicle accidents. Subdural bleeds typically layer in a GCS score less than 9 is highly likely to have sustained DAI.
crescentic shape that, when acute, appears hyperdense on (47) These lesions can have devastating morbidities, espe-
the CT scan of the brain (Fig 2). cially when they affect white matter tracts arising from the
Subarachnoid Hemorrhage. Subarachnoid hemorrhages frontal lobes and connecting to the limbic system. The frontal
result from the accumulation of blood in the subarachnoid lobes are the seat of important higher cognitive functions,
space. As opposed to the 2 previous types of bleeds, subarach- including premotor planning, executive function, motiva-
noid hemorrhages occur in an anatomical space normally tional states, and social behaviors. (48) It has been well
established that subcortical injures in these regions can result Transtentorial Herniation
in significant neuropsychiatric impairments, including lack Transtentorial herniation is probably the most common herni-
of motivation, depression, disinhibition, aggressivity, and ation in the context of TBI. It occurs as a result of a mass effect
cognitive impairments, especially in the area of motor plan- in the supratentorial (above the tentorium cerebelli) region.
ning. Intraparenchymal hemorrhages as a result of head Transtentorial herniation can be unilateral (uncal herniation)
trauma also occur frequently in the context of DAI, either or bilateral (central herniation) (many authors refer to a bilat-
as microbleeds or as much larger hemorrhagic lesions (Fig 2). eral tentorial herniation as transtentorial).
Unilateral (Uncal) Herniation. If there is a unilateral
Herniation Syndromes compression from a bleed or hemispheric edema, there is
Herniation syndromes occur as a result of a rapidly grow- a risk of uncal herniation. In this case, the space-occupying
ing space-occupying lesion (over hours to days), such as a lesion forces a displacement toward the opposite side to the
hemorrhage or developing edema. Herniation of the brain lesion, resulting in compression of several critical structures
contents can occur around any of the major fixed intracra- below the tentorial incisura (ridge formed by the tentorium
nial structures, including the tentorium cerebelli (trans- cerebelli). Critical structures compromised in this syndrome
tentorial or uncal herniation), the falx cerebri (cingulate include the oculomotor nerve (CNIII) and the main motor
or subfalcine herniation), and the foramen magnum (ton- pathways (pyramidal tracts). As a result, one will observe a
sillar herniation). Each of these herniation syndromes has unilateral mydriasis that will be ipsilateral to the herniation
clinically distinct presentations (Fig 1 schematically illus- (compression of cranial nerve III) but contralateral to the lesion
trates each type of cerebral herniation; see also Table 4). It is and a hemiparesis that will be contralateral to the herniation
important to emphasize that the herniation itself is a con- (compression of the pyramidal tracts before the decussation of
sequence, not the cause, of the clinical symptoms observed. the pyramids) but ipsilateral to the lesion. A classic pathologic
The cause of the syndrome is in fact the downward pressure finding that has been described in this context is the Kernohan
on the individual anatomical structures of the cingulate notch, caused by compression of the cerebral peduncle against
gyrus, midbrain, and medulla. (49) the tentorium opposite to the side of the space-occupying
lesion. It is important to recognize that anisocoria caused by toward the cortex, while decerebrate posturing is generally
transtentorial herniation is almost always accompanied by loss caused by injury below the red nucleus and the arms are
of consciousness as a result of a compression of the midbrain extended and pointing away from the cortex). The pupils will
(including the periaqueductal gray and other structures essen- initially be dilated and reactive. As the syndrome progresses
tial for maintaining consciousness). they will become fixed and upward eye movement will be
Bilateral (Central) Herniation. If there is diffuse cerebral compromised (resulting in a “sunsetting appearance”).
edema or a large bleed as a result of bilateral and severe
cerebral injury, transtentorial herniation may be bilateral, Cingulate Herniation
resulting from a downward compression force (aka central Cingulate herniation (or subfalcine herniation) occurs as a
herniation). In this case the patient will first develop decor- result of the brain contents being displaced under the falx
ticate posturing (arms flexed and legs extended) as a result of cerebri. This most often affects the frontal lobes as a result of a
midbrain compression, and as the herniation worsens, lateral rapidly growing mass lesion. The clinical signs of
decerebrate posturing (arms and legs extended) with exten- cingulate herniation are not as typical as those of the other
sion downward of the compression (a simple mnemonic is herniation syndromes. Because the cingulate gyrus is com-
to remember decorticate posturing is caused by injury above pressed under the falx, the anterior cerebral artery may become
the red nucleus and with the arms flexed and pointing compromised, with resultant ischemia of the medial motor
Cingulate Symptoms secondary to anterior cerebral artery compression Cerebral lateral compressive mass such as epidural or
and stroke include contralateral foot paresis and subdural bleed.
numbness, abulia, and urinary incontinence. As the
syndrome progresses, uncal herniation may occur.
Uncal Ipsilateral pupillary dilation (cranial nerve III), contralateral Cerebral lateral compressive mass such as epidural or
hemiparesis (cerebral peduncles). Note that the mass subdural bleed compressing the cerebral peduncle
compressing the brain will often be contralateral to the against the tentorium toward the side opposite the mass
herniation. Always associated with altered consciousness. (will result in a Kernohan notch).
Central Initially bilateral fixed pupils, impaired upward eye Bilateral cerebral compressive mass such as diffuse TBI with
movements (sunsetting appearance), decorticate followed associated edema and/or ischemia resulting in
by decerebrate posturing as the syndrome progresses. downward compression of the midbrain.
Tonsillar Neck stiffness, cranial neuropathies, Cushing triad Rare in the context of TBI, brainstem mass.
(hypertension, bradycardia, and irregular breathing).
cortex, leading to weakness of the contralateral lower extremity. absence of seizure activity, evidence of loss of consciousness
However, compression of the foramen of Monro will eventu- at the time of impact, or change in the level of consciousness
ally lead to increased intracranial pressure, and the patient will will all help guide the management of these children. In
develop symptoms typically associated with uncal herniation. addition, any child presenting with a decreased level of
consciousness or complaining of neck pain should immedi-
Tonsillar Herniation ately undergo cervical spine injury precautions with immo-
Tonsillar herniation is the least common type of herniation bilization of the spine. If the GCS score is less than 9 or if the
seen in the context of TBI (because the brain stem is much less child’s mental status is fluctuating, an airway should be
frequently involved in TBIs). Tonsillar herniation results from secured. The imaging modality of choice is CT because it
mass effect in the brain stem. As a result of the mass effect, the is ideal to show both bone fractures and hemorrhage. How-
cerebral contents will shift downward, forcing the cerebellar ever, DAI and contusion will not show as well on CT.
tonsils and the medulla through the foramen magnum. Ini-
tially the patient may complain of neck stiffness. On exami- MRI versus CT
nation cranial neuropathies may be evident. As the syndrome CT of the head is readily available in almost all emergency
progresses the children will often develop the Cushing triad: departments; it is a rapid study and is ideal to look for skull
hypertension, bradycardia, and slow and irregular breathing fractures or acute hemorrhages (acute hemorrhages will
from compression of the medulla oblongata. appear hyperdense on CT). In addition, if necessary, a CT of
the C-spine can be added to evaluate for spinal fractures. The
Evaluation of the Child with Moderate to Severe TBI CT will also reveal areas of edema as evidenced by hypo-
Evaluation of the child presenting with TBI depends largely dense lesions, although these changes can take some time to
on the initial assessment. The management will be radically become evident. It follows that a negative CT scan may
different depending on whether the child arrives with an require follow-up with MRI to fully characterize the lesion
mTBI (GCS score >13) or a moderate or severe TBI as depending on the clinical presentation. However, CT is a
evidenced by a GCS score less than 13 (for further details on poor study to evaluate for contusion or evidence of DAI.
the management of the child with an mTBI refer to the Furthermore, CT is associated with a significant amount of
Recognizing Concussion subsection). The child with a ionizing radiation. Note that the dose reduction techniques
decreased level of consciousness should be rapidly evaluated now commonly in use have resulted in significantly less
for symptoms of herniation while ensuring that airway, dose exposure (refer to the Recognizing Concussion sub-
breathing, and circulation measures are addressed. The section for further discussion of imaging in mTBI).
history in this case needs to be gathered rapidly but remains MRI offers a better evaluation of hemorrhage. T1, T2, and
essential. A description of the trauma, the presence or T2 fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) series are
Summary
• Traumatic brain injuries are the leading cause of death or severe To view teaching slides that accompany this article,
disability in children older than 1 year, and the incidence is visit http://pedsinreview.aappublications.org/
continuing to increase, making this topic especially relevant for content/40/8/468.supplemental.
the pediatrician.
• Based on a well-designed prospective cohort study, it
is not recommended that all children presenting with
head trauma obtain a head computed tomographic
scan. (18) Rather, this decision should be based on the
mechanism of injury and the signs and symptoms of the
patient.
• Based on multiple cohort studies and expert opinion, concussion
symptom checklists, such as the Child Sport Concussion
Assessment Tool, the Postconcussion Symptom Scale, or the
Graded Symptom Checklist, can be used to aid in concussion
diagnosis and tracking symptom resolution in determining
graduated return to play. (6)(11)(13)
• Children with moderate or severe traumatic brain injury
are at high risk for elevated intracranial pressure; this References for this article are at http://pedsinreview.aappub-
lications.org/content/40/9/468.
REQUIREMENTS: Learners
1. A 6-year-old girl is seen in the office after falling from her bicycle and striking her can take Pediatrics in Review
unhelmeted head yesterday. She did not lose consciousness at the time of injury, but ever quizzes and claim credit
since she has complained of headache and her mother feels that she is “not acting herself.” online only at: http://
An evaluation for the presumed diagnosis of mild traumatic brain injury, also known as pedsinreview.org.
concussion, is begun. Which one of the following is part of the COACH CV mnemonic for To successfully complete
diagnosis of concussion? 2019 Pediatrics in Review
A. Cardiovascular anomalies. articles for AMA PRA
B. Head imaging normal. Category 1 CreditTM, learners
C. Loss of Consciousness. must demonstrate a minimum
D. Orbital injury. performance level of 60% or
E. Vomiting. higher on this assessment.
2. You are participating as a sideline medical staff for an elite youth soccer team. A 14-year- If you score less than 60%
old girl collided with another player and her head struck the other player’s knee. She on the assessment, you
believes she lost consciousness for a few seconds, but she is verbally responsive when you will be given additional
evaluate her on the field. She complains of headache but is alert and oriented, with no opportunities to answer
neurologic deficits on your sideline physical examination. You pull her from the game, but questions until an overall 60%
she asks when she can return to her workouts. Which one of the following is the best or greater score is achieved.
guidance for the time she must be on complete rest, after which she can return to This journal-based CME
noncompetitive physical activity? activity is available through
A. Immediate return to activity. Dec. 31, 2021, however, credit
B. 2 days. will be recorded in the year in
C. 5 days. which the learner completes
D. 7 days. the quiz.
E. 10 days.
3. A 7-year-old boy is brought to the office for follow-up after he was seen in the emergency
department for a concussion 1 week earlier. He was discharged with a standardized
symptom assessment checklist, which his mother has been performing daily. His mother is
concerned that he complains of headaches and seems “out of it” and short-tempered. She
wants to know if this is going to be a prolonged recovery. Which one of the following is a 2019 Pediatrics in Review
risk factor for postconcussive syndrome? now is approved for a total
of 30 Maintenance of
A. Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder or learning disabilities.
Certification (MOC) Part 2
B. History of supraventricular tachycardia.
credits by the American
C. Male sex.
Board of Pediatrics through
D. Nonsport mechanism of injury.
the AAP MOC Portfolio
E. Preadolescent age.
Program. Complete the first
4. An 11-year-old boy is being seen for routine well-child care. His mother is concerned that 10 issues or a total of 30
he has had 2 concussions in early childhood and is reluctant about letting him participate quizzes of journal CME
in sports. Which one of the following sports would you advise her that he plays because of credits, achieve a 60%
its lowest risk of concussion? passing score on each, and
A. Biking. start claiming MOC credits
B. Football. as early as October 2019. To
C. Skiing. learn how to claim MOC
D. Soccer. points, go to: http://
E. Volleyball. www.aappublications.org/
content/moc-credit.
Updated Information & including high resolution figures, can be found at:
Services http://pedsinreview.aappublications.org/content/40/9/468
Supplementary Material Supplementary material can be found at:
http://pedsinreview.aappublications.org/content/suppl/2019/08/28/40
.9.468.DC1
References This article cites 52 articles, 12 of which you can access for free at:
http://pedsinreview.aappublications.org/content/40/9/468.full#ref-list
-1
Subspecialty Collections This article, along with others on similar topics, appears in the
following collection(s):
Emergency Medicine
http://classic.pedsinreview.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/emerge
ncy_medicine_sub
Trauma
http://classic.pedsinreview.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/trauma
_sub
Sports Medicine/Physical Fitness
http://classic.pedsinreview.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/sports_
medicine:physical_fitness_sub
Concussion
http://classic.pedsinreview.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/concus
sion_sub
Head and Neck Injuries
http://classic.pedsinreview.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/head_n
eck_injuries_sub
Traumatic Brain Injury
http://classic.pedsinreview.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/trauma
tic_brain_injury_sub
Permissions & Licensing Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or
in its entirety can be found online at:
https://shop.aap.org/licensing-permissions/
Reprints Information about ordering reprints can be found online:
http://classic.pedsinreview.aappublications.org/content/reprints
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is
located on the World Wide Web at:
http://pedsinreview.aappublications.org/content/40/9/468
Pediatrics in Review is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly
publication, it has been published continuously since 1979. Pediatrics in Review is owned,
published, and trademarked by the American Academy of Pediatrics, 345 Park Avenue, Itasca,
Illinois, 60143. Copyright © 2019 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved.
Print ISSN: 0191-9601.