The Properties of Cobalt Oxide Catalyst For Ammonia Oxidation Szalowki Et Al. Appl. Catal. 1998
The Properties of Cobalt Oxide Catalyst For Ammonia Oxidation Szalowki Et Al. Appl. Catal. 1998
The Properties of Cobalt Oxide Catalyst For Ammonia Oxidation Szalowki Et Al. Appl. Catal. 1998
Received 17 March 1998; received in revised form 9 June 1998; accepted 12 June 1998
Abstract
A cobalt oxide catalyst for ammonia oxidation of high and stable activity and selectivity has been obtained and tested in a
¯uidized bed laboratory reactor. Its active component is Co3O4. It has been found that much less nitrous oxide is produced in
ammonia oxidation on this catalyst than on platinum. The macrostructure of the cobalt catalysts, and especially the presence
of mesopores of diameter <0.1 mm have an essential effect on their activity and selectivity and on the stability of these
properties. In the macrostructure of selective and stable catalysts the share of the mesopores <0.1 mm is extremely low, while
the total pore volume amounts from some tens to a hundred and some tens of mm3/g. A hypothetical model has been presented
to explain the effect of the catalyst's macrostructure on its properties. # 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Ammonia oxidation; Cobalt catalyst; Co3O4; Reagent interaction; CoO formation; Macrostructure of granules;
Selectivity; Deactivation mechanism
0926-860X/98/$ ± see front matter # 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S0926-860X(98)00206-3
148 K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157
other parts of the bed. Since these transformations are composition of the reagent mixture: 10 vol% of
reversible, the catalyst does not lose its initial activity. ammonia and 90 vol% of air;
It has also been found that the cobalt oxide catalyst can atmospheric pressure;
be successfully applied in a stationary bed as a second total flow rate: 400 Nl/h;
layer of a two-stage reactor. In such systems, platinum bed temperature: 720±8008C;
gauzes are used as the ®rst stage but their number is diameter of the ball-shaped catalyst granules: 0.8±
much smaller than in the common commercial reac- 1.8 mm;
tors. The activity and selectivity of the cobalt catalyst height of the immobile catalyst bed: 60 mm.
may be stable for a long time because of low ammonia The conversion of ammonia to nitrogen oxide was
concentration in the bed. It should be added that due to calculated from the ammonia content in the reagent
the last years' progress, more stable cobalt catalysts gas mixture at the inlet and from the NO content in the
were obtained of a quality satisfactory for commercial outlet of the reactor both determined by the gravime-
use. trical-titration method. The content of ammonia in the
The aim of this work was to investigate the relation gas, entering the reactor was determined in gas mix-
between the macrostructure of cobalt oxide catalysts ture samples taken to a previously weighed ¯ask, in
(formed by heat treatment) and their activity and which the pressure was kept at about 100 hPa. The
selectivity in the ammonia oxidation. The composition ¯ask contained some amount of 0.1 N H2SO4. The
of these catalysts under the conditions of ammonia ¯ask was weighed again and the contents were titrated
oxidation and the process of their deactivation were with an alkali. Similarly, NO was determined in the
also studied. outlet gas, the samples being taken to a ¯ask contain-
ing H2O2 and some gaseous oxygen was let in. The
2. Studies on composition, macrostructure, and content was titrated. The analyses were repeated to
selectivity of the catalyst obtain results differing by less than 0.1%. The content
of nitrous oxide was determined chromatographically
2.1. Experimental and the Nessler method was used for spectrophoto-
metric determination of ammonia [7].
The method applied for preparation of the cobalt Average composition of the granules and the com-
catalyst consists in granulating Co3O4 with aqueous position of their outer layer were determined grav-
solution of a binder and calcination of the granulated imetrically by reduction with hydrogen to metallic
product. The catalyst exhibits high mechanical cobalt [9], and the main components were identi®ed
strength and can be used in a ¯uidized bed. Tricobalt with the use of a Siemens X-ray diffractometer type D-
tetraoxide of appropriate purity was used as the start- 500.
ing material [6] (Fe ± 3.410ÿ2, Mg ± 8.010ÿ3, Mn The measurements of the pore size were performed
± 5.010ÿ2, Ni ± 5.010ÿ2, Pb ± 1.010ÿ2, Cu ± using a mercury Porosimeter AutoPore II 9220 of
5.710ÿ3, V ± below 0.02, Na ± 2.210ÿ3, K ± 0.7 Micrometrics. The true density of the catalysts was
10ÿ3, Ca ± 2.810ÿ3 wt%). It was granulated in a measured by means of a helium pycnometer AccuPyc
rotary granulator with aqueous solution of an organic 1330 of Micrometrics, and the apparent density was
binder and dried at room temperature for 48 h. After determined by the pycnometric method. The macro-
drying, the granules (containing ca. 96% Co3O4 and structure of the catalyst granules was observed using a
4% of the binder) were calcined in a vertical tubular Zeiss DSM 942 scanning microscope.
furnace for 5 h in air at a constant temperature of
10008C to 12508C. The temperature was then 2.2. Cobalt catalyst in the ammonia oxidation
decreased to 8008C and the catalysts were heated at
this temperature for 24 h, also in air. 2.2.1. Composition of the catalyst during the
The activity and the selectivity of the catalysts ammonia oxidation
in ammonia oxidation was tested in an isothermal Four samples of the catalyst, calcined in different
¯uidized bed in a quartz-glass reactor (17 mm in temperatures (1000±12508C) and divided in two
diameter) under the following conditions [5,7,8]: groups, were chosen for investigation. Group I
K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157 149
Table 1
Properties of catalysts: A ± catalyst before the activity measurement in the ammonia oxidation process, B ± after the activity measurement, K ±
catalyst for pilot plant studies
Average composition of the O/Co granules (mol/mol) A 1.31 1.31 1.25 1.23 1.26
B 1.31 1.31 1.29 1.31 1.31
Composition of the external layer (about 1% of the total mass) A 1.38 ± ± ± 1.37
O/Co (mol/mol)
B 1.47 1.40 ± 1.43 1.45
Porosity (%) (from porosimetric measurements) A 45.3 36.6 17.6 15.2 15.2
B 44.1 33.5 17.5 15.3 15.3
Total porosity (mm3/g) (from porosimetric measurements) A 138.1 96.0 35.9 30.0 27.8
B 132.9 85.0 35.0 30.3 24.7
contained two catalysts calcined at 10008C and The catalysts were tested in a ¯uidized bed reactor
10508C. Their average composition (determined by (Section 2.1). They worked in an ammonia oxidation
reduction with hydrogen) was close to that of stoichio- gas mixture at temperature 720±8008C for at least
metric Co3O4 (O/Co1.33). These samples are fea- 13 h, and after a series of measurements they were
tured by a ®ne-grained macrostructure (Fig. 1), cooled in closed reactor in an atmosphere of the gas
considerable porosity and small apparent density reactants (NOx, N2, O2). On the basis of reduction with
(Table 1). Group II comprised catalysts calcined at hydrogen it was found that the average composition of
a much higher temperature: 12008C or 12508C. These all the samples used (both from Group I and II) was
catalysts contained less oxygen with respect to stoi- almost identical, close to stoichiometric value of
chiometric Co3O4. Their macrostructure was coarse- Co3O4 (Table 1). Thus, the catalysts of Group II,
grained, their porosity was low, and their apparent which contained considerable amounts of CoO due
density high. X-ray analysis showed that in Group II to the thermal treatment, were reoxidized under the
also CoO is present besides to Co3O4. action of the reactant gas mixture. However, X-ray
150 K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157
Fig. 1. Structure of the surface and interior of catalyst particles calcined at 10008C (Group I) and 12008C (Group II): 1,2 ± Surface layer of
catalyst calcined at 10008C before and after the activity measurements, respectively; 3,4 ± Surface layer of catalyst calcined at 12008C before
and after the activity measurements, respectively; 5,6 ± Structure of the interior of catalyst granules calcined at 10008C before and after the
activity measurements, respectively; 7,8 ± Structure of the interior of catalyst granules calcined at 12008C before and after the activity
measurements, respectively.
K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157 151
Table 2
Measurements of the catalyst selectivity in ammonia oxidation
The measurement of ammonia conversion indexes were deactivated starting from the ®rst hours of the
X1 and X2 showed an essential difference between measurements. During a 13 h work, X1 decreased by
Group I catalysts (PA-100 and PA-105) calcined at 4%, and at the same time X2 increased considerably.
10008C and 10508C, and those from Group II (PA-120 As mentioned above, the deactivation of cobalt
and PA-125) calcined at 12008C and 12508C (Fig. 2, catalysts in the course of ammonia oxidation may
Table 2). Group I is characterised by a favourable be due to reduction of active Co3O4 to relatively
selectivity which is evidenced by the high conversion inactive CoO [3,4]. Probably this process is not
to NO (X1 92±94%), and a low conversion to N2O effected throughout the whole granule volume, but
(X20.2±0.9%). No deactivation of these catalysts is limited to the surface layer, where most of the gas
was found during the series of measurements carried reactants participate in the reaction. However in our
out over two or three days (ca. 13 h of operating time). experiments, another phenomenon was observed. Cat-
The selectivity of Group II catalysts was much lower: alysts that lost rapidly their activity, featured a
X187±92%; X21±2%. Moreover, these catalysts strongly oxidized surface layer with over-stoichio-
K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157 153
metric contents of oxygen. The fact is not easy for oxidation conditions resulting in a considerable grain
interpretation because the true composition of the growth.
catalyst in the working bed is not known (especially The results of porosimetric study of catalysts from
in the bottom zone, where the ammonia concentration the two groups (Figs. 3 and 4) also showed some
is maximum). It should be taken into account that the essential differences. Porosimetric measurements of
rate of the catalyst's conversion in the surface layer of other cobalt catalysts were also performed: catalyst K,
the granules may be very high. Thus it cannot be produced from the same material as Groups I and II
excluded that in the bottom zone of the bed the surface (for semi-industrial experiment), and two industrial
layer of the granules was really reduced, whereas the catalysts named here K1 and K2. All the results are
samples used for the analysis were taken from the discussed in Section 3.
upper zone, where a reoxidation proceeded due to the
low ammonia concentration.
3. Discussion
2.2.3. Macrostructure of the catalyst
The difference between the macrostructures of cat- 3.1. Relationships between the macrostructure and
alysts from Groups I and II was evident (Fig. 1). It is the selectivity of the catalyst
worth noting that the ®ne-grained macrostructure of
Group I catalysts did not undergo essential transfor- The newly prepared catalysts in both Groups I and
mation within the time of their work (overall ca. 13 h) II were different in composition and macrostructure of
under conditions of ammonia oxidation. Group II the granules. However, the composition of the gran-
catalysts behaved differently. Their initial coarse- ules, attained under the conditions of ammonia oxida-
grained macrostructure formed as a result of calcina- tion, was similar in both groups. On the other hand,
tion, underwent transformation under the ammonia considerable differences were noted in the macro-
Fig. 3. Pore volumes of catalysts after activity measurements. The overall porosity and distribution of pore volumes in the Group I and II
catalysts calcined at 1000±12508C. Pore diameters are shown in the diagram.
154 K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157
Fig. 4. Pore volumes of catalysts after activity measurements. Group I (PB-100, PB-105) and II (PB-120, PB-125) catalysts calcined at 1000±
12508C, and three other catalysts characterized by high selectivity: K, K1 and K2. Data are presented in Table 1.
structure of the granules, both in new catalysts and in KII (Section 3 and Figs. 3 and 4). They can be sum-
that taken from the used bed. It might be concluded, marised as follows:
therefore, that the main and primary reason of differ- 1. The total volume of pores of selective catalysts of
ences in catalytic properties of these groups was Group I is much higher than that of Group II
connected with their macrostructure. The ®ne-grained catalysts.
macrostructure of Group I catalysts was stable under 2. A peculiar feature of Group I (of high and stable
ammonia oxidation conditions and their selectivity selectivity) consists in the absence of mesopores of
was also stable. The observed drop in selectivity in diameter <0.1 mm.
Group II was associated with transformation of their 3. With rising calcination temperature the volume of
macrostructure. It should be noted, however, that this the macropores >0.1 mm decreases, and at the same
is not a suf®cient proof of a causal-result connection time the volume of the mesopores <0.1 mm
between these phenomena. For example, the studies of increases. Therefore, in catalysts from Group II
Morozow et al. [12] on heat treatment of the catalyst the share of mesopores is significant. That group is
from pure Co3O4 at ca. 10008C showed that the characterised by a low selectivity and it undergoes
recrystallization occurring under these conditions deactivation under the conditions of ammonia oxi-
led to an essential decrease in its speci®c surface, dation.
i.e. a change in macrostructure of the granules took 4. Another cobalt catalyst K (produced from the same
place. No effect, however, was found of this phenom- material as Group I and II catalysts) exhibits a high
enon on the catalytic activity of thus treated sample. selectivity, as in Group I, despite of the small total
Some conclusions concerning the relation between pore volume which is close to that of low-selec-
the catalysts' macrostructure and their selectivity tivity Group II catalysts. However, like in Group I,
result from porosimetric studies of Groups I and II, nearly all this volume consists of macropores
including also some other catalysts named K, KI and (>0.1 mm) with a negligible share of mesopores.
K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157 155
3.2. A model of the catalyst's macrostructure Fig. 5. Scheme of the model macrostructures I and II: (- - - -)
active surface of the catalyst grains; (!) diffusion of the reactants.
its concentration will be higher than in the case of content is higher than in stoichiometric Co3O4. The
macrostructure I. Since the external surface of these model presented here does not touch this phenom-
granules is not well developed, the rate of ammonia enon.
oxidation related to a unit of their geometrical surface
is lower than that in the macrostructure I, and despite
of the diffusion resistance the ammonia concentration 4. Conclusions
can increase at the solid surface in the external layer of
the granule. Under the action of such a reagent mixture 1. A catalyst of high and stable activity and
Co3O4 may be reduced, initially in the external layer, selectivity in ammonia oxidation to NO, generat-
and the process of the catalyst's deactivation begins. ing minimum quantity of N2O, was prepared from
The catalytic reaction rate decreases and the ammonia pure cobalt oxide Co3O4. It may be used in a
concentration increases still more. Thus the reduction ¯uidized bed reactor.
and deactivation zone may expand into the bulk of the 2. The macrostructure of cobalt catalysts (especially
granule. the presence of mesopores <0.1 mm) has an essen-
Moreover, it should be noticed that irrespective of tial effect on their activity and selectivity, as well as
the Co3O4 reduction, the macrostructure II can exhibit on the stability of these properties. It has been
a smaller selectivity of ammonia oxidation to NO than found that the share of such mesopores in the
the macrostructure I. If high ammonia concentrations structure of stable selective catalysts is extremely
occur at the surface of granules, then NH3 can easily small while the total pore volume amounts from
penetrate inside the mesopores. In such a case, parasite some tens to more than a hundred mm3/g.
reactions will proceed in the mesopores, e.g. between 3. One of the possible reasons for the deactivation of
ammonia and nitrogen oxide to form nitrogen. The the cobalt catalyst (containing pure Co3O4 in the
catalytic action of the developed surface of mesopores initial state) under the conditions of ammonia
can favour those reactions, resulting in a decrease of oxidation is the reduction of Co3O4 which results
the ammonia conversion to NO. in the formation of CoO in the external layer of the
When the conversion of ammonia in the bulk of the catalyst. However, some of our experiments sug-
gas stream is high, its concentration at the catalyst gest that another deactivation mechanism is also
surface is low, even at the most external parts. Under possible causing a decrease of the catalyst activity
such conditions, the reduction of Co3O4 does not and selectivity, when the oxygen content in the
proceed and the catalyst is not deactivated. Thus, external layer of cobalt oxide is not smaller (and
the catalyst of macrostructure II could be used for sometimes even much higher) than in stoichio-
industrial purposes, but only as the second stage of the metric Co3O4. The study of the latter effect will
ammonia oxidation reactor. be continued.
To end the discussion it is worth noting that if the
model adopted describes correctly at least the main References
phenomena occurring during the ammonia oxidation,
then the most favourable catalyst may be such as that [1] S.P.S. Andrew, G.C. Chinchen, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 6
presented by variant I-B (Fig. 5).This is a catalyst with (1980) 141.
developed external surface due to the presence of [2] L.E. James, R.L. Crescentini, W.B. Fisher, US Patent
4 389 339 (1983).
macropores between the grains, but the single grains
[3] T. Popowa, D. Stawrakiewa, I. Zrncziew, Chimia and
of the macrostructure are monolithic and do not con- Industria 56 (1984) 164.
tain mesopores. It should be noted, however, that the [4] M.C. Goromonzi, S.K. Raman, B.D. Padalia et al., React.
model presented is of a hypothetical character and Kinet. Catal. Lett. 15 (1980) 131.
requires further studies for con®rmation. One of the [5] J. Petryk, K. Krawczyk, Przem. Chem. 67 (1988) 272.
[6] J. Petryk, K. Krawczyk, PL Patent 149619 (1990).
questions still left unanswered is that of the mechan-
[7] K. Krawczyk, Ph.D. Thesis, Warsaw University of Technol-
ism of catalyst deactivation under conditions, when its ogy, Warsaw, 1995.
surface layer is not reduced, but on the contrary ± it [8] K. Krawczyk, J. Petryk, K. Schmidt-Szaøowski, Stud. Surf.
becomes additionally oxidised so that the oxygen Sci. Catal. 91 (1995) 683.
K. Schmidt-Szaøowski et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 175 (1998) 147±157 157
[9] K. Schmidt-Szaøowski, J. Petryk, K. Krawczyk, Przem. [11] è.A. Isupowa, W.J. Alieksandrow, W.W Popowski et al., Izw.
Chem. 73 (1994) 423. Sibirskowo Otdielienia AN SSSR 1 (1989) 39.
[10] I.D. Bieøowa, J.E. Roginska, J.N. Wieniewciew, ZÇurn. Nieorg. [12] N.N. Morozow, è.I. èukianowa, M.I. Tiemkin, Kinet. Katal. 7
Chimii 28 (1983) 3009. (1966) 172.