Strengthening of Shear Deficient Reinforced Concrete Beams Retrofitted With Cement-Based Composites
Strengthening of Shear Deficient Reinforced Concrete Beams Retrofitted With Cement-Based Composites
Strengthening of Shear Deficient Reinforced Concrete Beams Retrofitted With Cement-Based Composites
1, 2015
ABSTRACT
The restoration of strength and stiffness of damaged reinforced concrete beams with deficient reinforcements,
through retrofitting, was experimentally and numerically studied. Retrofitting is carried out by wrapping glass
fiber strips using cement-based composite binders. Six beams of size 1500mm (length) x100mm (width) x
150mm (depth) have been tested in four-point bending. Three beams are used as reference beams, whereas
the other three are cast as shear deficient beams and loaded up to first few cracks.The damaged beams were
repaired, cured and retrofitted. Flexure test is carried out to find the average ultimate load, maximum
deflection, maximum moment, stiffness, energy absorption and crack pattern of reference and preloaded
retrofitted beams. Numerical analysis is carried out for the similar shear deficient beams. It is concluded that
the ultimate load and moment carrying capacity were restored in preloaded retrofitted beams. The stiffness
and energy absorption are improved in preloaded wrapped beams with deflection at ultimate load being
reduced.
KEYWORDS: Experimental analysis, Numerical analysis, Shear deficient beams, Glass fiber strips,
Cement-based composites.
by (Badanoiu and Holmgren, 2003). The mechanism to finite element model and validated the experimental
prepare precast carbon fiber strips to strengthen and results of the behavior of strengthened sulfate damaged
rehabilitate damaged reinforced concrete beams is reinforced concrete beams. They concluded that glass
discussed by (Alace and Kaihaloo, 2003). Blanksvard strips provided at an angle of 45º are effective in
(2007) mentioned the significance of cementitious strengthening the beams in the shear región.
binders in strengthening techniques. Finite elements analysis helps understand the
A new term, mineral-based composites, has been behavior of retrofitted beam members effectively and
introduced by (Taljsten and Blanksvard, 2007). They economically. Many studies were carried out to
concluded that slab strengthened with carbon fibers justify the validity of modelling and analysis of
using epoxy binders showed brittle failure mode, structural members using ANSYS. Wolanski (2004)
whereas ductile failure mode was noted for slabs with concluded that deflection and stress at the center line
mineral-based binders. Sundaraja and Rajamohan compared well with experimental data obtained for
(2009) concluded that GFRP inclined strips using reinforced concrete beams. Initial and successive
epoxy as binder restricted the development of diagonal cracking of the finite element model were noted as
cracks and prevented brittle failure of the beam well. Santhakumar et al. (2004) presented the load-
strengthened in the shear region. Ludovico et al. (2010) deflection behavior and crack pattern for control and
studied the use of cement mortar as binder along with shear retrofitted beams. Ibrahim and Mahmod (2009)
basalt sheets to provide a good solution to enhance the concluded that the numerical solution could be
compressive strength and ductility of concrete adopted to study the ultimate shear strength of
members and to overcome the limitations of epoxy- concrete beams reinforced with FRP laminates. They
based FRP laminates. also found that the numerical method adopted is a
Past study by (Wu et al., 2010) showed that quick and effective way compared to full-scale
cement-based composite sheets for in situ structural experimental test.
retrofit are possible with excellent bonding and without Majeed (2012) concluded that effective 3D
delamination using carbon fiber sheets. Obaidat et al. modelling and non-linear analysis of steel fiber
(2011) found that increasing the CFRP plate length in reinforced concrete deep beams are possible using
the flexural region, beyond the middle one third length ANSYS. The stress-strain plot along the depth of a
of the beam, enhances the flexural and shear behavior deep beam for various L/D ratios is effectively
of preloaded beams. analyzed through ANSYS by (Patil et al., 2012).
Low-density glass fiber sheets with clear spacing The above studies concluded that glass fiber
between individual rovings allow effective sheet bonded with cement-based composites could
impregnation of cement mortar as was confirmed by be effectively used to strengthen the beam in shear at
(Francisco et al., 2012). supports. It was also confirmed that ANSYS could
Beylergil et al. (2013) found that even the damaged be used to model retrofitted reinforced concrete
wooden beams could be successfully retrofitted and beam members to study effectively the load–
enhanced in load carrying capacity. Haddad et al. deflection behavior, stress distribution, strain
(2013) compared the effectiveness of carbon and glass distribution and crack patterns. The results could be
fiber sheets and strips, for enhancing the properties of validated through experimental works. The aim of
shear deficient beams damaged by sulfate attack. this study is to investigate the restoration of strength
Experimental results were validated through an and stiffness in shear damaged beams through
analytical model. retrofitting.
Al-Rousan and Haddad (2013) created a non-linear
- 60 -
Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 9, No. 1, 2015
Solid 46 179000 6900 6900 0.26 0.26 0.3 1400 1700 2550
Glenium B233 admixture used in this work is based width, 150 mm height and 1500 mm length. Reference
on polycarboxylic ether. This super plasticizer is free beams (RB) were cast with two 10 mm bars, both at
of chloride and compatible with all types of cements. top and bottom along with stirrups at 100 mm c/c.
The specific gravity is 1.08 with pH > 6. Glenium Shear deficient (SD) beams were cast with reduced
stream 2 is a premier ready-to-use, liquid, organic, stirrups to obtain inclined shear cracks by increasing
viscosity-modifying admixture, specially developed for the spacing to 400 mm.
producing concrete with enhanced viscosity and
controlled rheological properties. The specific gravity Testing of Specimens
is 1.01. The design of concrete mix is according to IS
10262-1982 to achieve a characteristic compressive Testing of Cubes and Cylinders
strength of 30MPa with a w/c ratio of 0.37 and a slump All the cubes and cylinders were tested in saturated
of 60 mm. The concrete mix proportion is 1:0.96:2.33. condition, after wiping out the surface moisture at 28
days of curing using compression testing machine of
Casting of Specimens 3000 kN capacity. The tests were carried out at a
Concrete cubes (150 mm x 150 mm x 150 mm) and uniform stress of 10 kg/cm2/minute after the specimen
cylinders (height of 150 mm and diameter of 300 mm) has been centred in the testing machine.
were cast to confirm the characteristic compressive
strength of the design mix. Reinforced concrete beam Testing of Beams
with four-point bending was considered for analysis to Reference Beams
achieve uniform moment between load points. The The reference beams were tested in four-point
beams have a rectangular cross-section of 100 mm bending. The span between the supports was 1200 mm,
- 61 -
ng of Shear…
Strengthenin P. Bhuv
vaneshwari an
nd K. Saravana
a Raja Mohan
Figure (1):
( Preparatioon of cement based composites Figure (2): Wrappiing with glass ffiber strips and
d cement
based composites
c
Testing of Retrofitted
R Beeams al., 2009):
RSD beaams were loadded such thatt the glass sheet = . (1)
was not loadded directly. Testing
T patternn was similarr to
that of RB. After
A the conccrete starts to crack, the glaass Shear carrieed by concrete at support is expressedd
sheet compoosite starts too take additioonal load up to by
y:
failure of thee beam. = . (2)
Shear forrce at the suppports of the beeam is shared by
each componnent of the beeam as follow ws (Sundarrajaa et Strength of shear reinforccement is:
- 62 -
Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 9, No. 1, 2015
. . ∝ ∝
= . (3) = . (4)
Figure (3): Crack pattern in RB with sufficient flexure and shear reinforcements
- 63 -
Strengthening of Shear… P. Bhuvaneshwari and K. Saravana Raja Mohan
section; fy is the yield stress in steel; Asv is the area of Elements for Meshing and Boundary Conditions
stirrup bar; sv is the spacing of stirrups; Af is the area of The elements used were solid65 to model concrete
one strip of fiber sheet; ff is the effective tensile stress and binder, link8 for reinforcement, solid45 for steel
in the fiber sheet; sf is the spacing of fiber sheets; α is plates and layered solid46 for glass sheet composites.
the angle of inclination of fiber sheet with longitudinal The solid65 element has eight nodes with three degrees
axis of the beam; tM is the total thickness of mineral- of freedom at each node – translation in the nodal x-, y-
based composites; he is the effective height of the and z-directions. This element is capable of plastic
mineral-based composites in bearing the shear; fM is the deformation, cracking in three orthogonal directions
tensile strength of mineral-based mortar. and crushing. Link8 element was used to model steel
reinforcement. It is a 3D spar element having two
Numerical Investigation nodes with three degrees of freedom as translation in
Numerical Model the nodal x-, y- and z-directions and also has the
Symmetry of the beam was utilized to model only capacity of plastic deformation. Solid45 element has
one half of the beam. Displacement in the right end of eight nodes with three degrees of freedom at each
the model was applied zero to simulate symmetry node– translation in the nodal x-, y- and z- directions.
boundary condition.To avoid stress concentration, Layered solid46 elements were used to model fiber
square steel plates of size 100 mm× 100 mm x 5 mm sheet. Supports were hinged and load was applied at
were provided at point of loading and supports. the corresponding nodes. Numerical model for RB
Keypoints, lines, areas and volumes were used to along with boundary conditions is shown in Fig.7.
create the model of concrete, steel reinforcement, steel Model of RSD along with wrapping is shown in Fig. 8.
plates and glass sheet as wrapping.
- 64 -
Jordan Journ
nal of Civil Eng
ngineering, Vollume 9, No. 1, 2015
2
Figu
ure (7): Numerrical model witth boundary coonditions Figure (8): Numerical moodel with wrap
pping
- 65 -
Strengthening of Shear… P. Bhuvaneshwari and K. Saravana Raja Mohan
stiffness matrix of the model was modified to reflect Load-Deflection Behavior of Beams
nonlinear changes in structural stiffness. Newton- The load deflection behavior was recorded for the
Raphson equilibrium iterations are used for RB. Widening of flexural cracks occurred at the mid
convergence within tolerance limits. span along with limited shear cracks as shown in Fig.3.
The RB, being under reinforced section, undergoes
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION large deflection before failure with an average ultimate
load of 38.01kN and an average ultimate moment of
Beams were cast and tested. Results from both 7.62kNm. Preloading of the SD beam initiated the
experiments and numerical analysis are tabulated and shear cracks as shown in Fig.4, even at low load
compared. values. Repaired and retrofitted SD beam was loaded
up to ultimate load. Strengthening of SD beams in the
Compressive Strength of Concrete shear region allowed for flexural cracks to appear
The average characteristic compressive strength of initially, instead of shear cracks as shown in Fig.5.
concrete through cube test amounted to 38 MPa. The Loading up to failure leads to ductile flexure failure as
average compressive strength of cylinders was 32 MPa. shown in Fig.6. Results are compared with that of RB.
The stress-strain plot for concrete cylinders was Analyses of the similar beams were carried out in
utilized in numerical modelling. ANSYS. Restoration of stiffness and energy absorbing
capacity are compared in Table 2.
Figure (9) :Bilinear stress-strain curve for steel Figure (10) : Multilinear stress-strain curve for concrete
- 66 -
Jordan Journ
nal of Civil Eng
ngineering, Vollume 9, No. 1, 2015
2
50
45
40
35 RB
B-
Load (KN)
)
30 Expperimental
(
25 RSDD-
20 Expperimental
15
10 RB
B-ANSYS
5
0 RSD
D-ANSYS
0 5 10 15 20
0
Deflection (mm)
Figure (13)
( :Crack an
nd crush plot in
n RSD Figure (14
4) : Comparisoon of load-defleection behaviorr
- 67 -
Strengthening of Shear… P. Bhuvaneshwari and K. Saravana Raja Mohan
in the shear region reduces the shear stress in the Fig.16, respectively. The percentage decrease in shear
concrete. Variation of shear stress and shear strain stress and shear strain for RSD is 29.46% and 24.2%,
across the depth of the beams are plotted in Fig.15 and respectively, compared to RB.
160 160
140 140
120 120
Depth (mm)
Depth (mm)
100 100
80 80
60 RB 60 RB
40 RSD 40 RSD
20 20
0 0
0 5 10 0 5 10
Shear Stress x 10 -1(N/mm²) Shear Strain x 10-3
Figure (15) :Comparison of shear stress distribution Figure (16) : Comparison of shear strain distribution
- 68 -
Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering, Volume 9, No. 1, 2015
concrete starts to crack, the glass sheet composite glass strips and cement-based binders. The results
starts to take further load without any delamination. are validated through numerical analysis.
Restoration of strength and stiffness of beams, Utilization of symmetry made the model stiffer
damaged due to insufficient shear reinforcement, compared to real beam.
was achieved through retrofitting with inclined
- 69 -
Strengthening of Shear… P. Bhuvaneshwari and K. Saravana Raja Mohan
Marco Di Ludovico, Andrea Prota, and Gaetano Manfredi. Stephen Kurtz, and Balaguru, P. (2001). “Comparison of
(2010). “Structural upgrade using basalt fibers for inorganic and organic matrices for strengthening of RC
concrete confinement”. J. of Composites for beams with carbon sheets”. J. of Structural
Construction, ASCE, 14 (5), 541-552. Engineering, 127 (1), 35-42.
Ohama, Y. (1998). “Polymer-based admixtures”. Cement Sundarraja, M.C., and Rajamohan, S. (2009).
Concrete Composites, 20 (2), 189-212. “Strengthening of RC beams in shear using GFRP
Patil, S.S., Shaikh, A.N., and Niranjan, B.R. (2012). inclined strips – an experimental study”. Construction
“Nonlinear finite element method of analysis of and Building Materials, 23, 856-864.
reinforced concrete deep beam”. I.J. of Modern Thomas Blansksvärd, Bjorn Täljsten, and Anders Carolin.
Engineering Research, 2 (6), 4622-4628. (2009). “Shear strengthening of concrete structures
Santhakumar, R., Chandrasekaran, E., and Dhanaraj, R. with the use of mineral-based composites”. J. of
(2004). “Analysis of retrofitted reinforced concrete Composites for Construction, 13 (1), 25- 34.
shear beams using carbon fiber composites”. Electronic Yasmeen Taleb Obaidat, Susanne Heyden, Ola Dahlblom,
J. of Structural Engrg., 4, 66-74. Ghazi Abu-Farsakh, and Yahia Abdel-Jawad. (2011).
“Retrofitting of reinforced concrete beams using
composite laminates”. Construction and Building
Materials, 25, 591-597.
- 70 -