Category: Behind The Firewall
Category: Behind The Firewall
Category: Behind The Firewall
CATEGORY:
1 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
DIVISION: CORPORATE
CATEGORY: BEHIND THE FIREWALL
NOVARTIS ONCOLOGY
To help Novartis Oncology meet its business objectives and grow its existing talent base, a
plan was created to launch an internal communications campaign—the Open Employee
Generation campaign—that incorporated breakthrough, out of the box creative concepts that
could later be shared with the external community and potential hires.
SOLUTION/TOOLS USED/RESULTS
•Create a consistent internal culture that celebrates the unique stories taking shape at Novartis
Oncology locations around the world, uniting employees in the fight to help cancer patients
live longer, better lives.
•Drive business objectives by helping Novartis Oncology create an internal campaign that
could evolve into an external program aimed at meeting the company’s ambitious hiring goals:
to recruit hundreds of new employees worldwide by year end.
•Novartis Oncology employees are extremely busy individuals working with a very important
and noble business and personal objective: improving and extending the lives of cancer
patients around the world. Our challenge was to gain participation in the campaign from this
crowd of very passionate and focused individuals—an act that would require that they take
time away from their demanding schedules. To gain interest and participation from Novartis
Oncology employees from around the word, we positioned the campaign for its ability to:
•Enhance employees’ commitment to growing with the company and referring top talent.--The
campaign’s target audience was 5,000 employees operating in more than 50 countries around
the world.--Phase I: Capture
2 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
•Reaffirm the Organization’s Key Brand Characteristics through the Accumulation of
Employee Generated Media
In phase one of the campaign, we developed and designed tools (including online/offline tools)
to generate excitement among employees to share their stories and participate in a voting
campaign to select the best stories. The program objectives were to:
•Showcase the diversity of associates and the wide range of their cultures, styles, and
backgrounds.
•Communicate the special aspect of working at Novartis Oncology -- the great purpose of the
work on behalf of patients -- as a way to further attract talent to the company.
Adapt the Current Novartis Oncology Career Website to Generate Candidate Interest and
Employee Engagement
•Create branded employee communications materials and messages. The campaign invited
Novartis Oncology employees around the world to submit personal video testimonials that
expressed what it means to be a part of Novartis Oncology.
•125 Flip cameras were distributed to Novartis Oncology locations around the world—from
Canada to Australia and Argentina to Russia—with a simple ask: “Tell us why you work
here!”
An internal campaign microsite was developed as the hub of the campaign—where employees
could not only submit their videos, but view, comment and vote on the submissions of their
peers--The deployment of the campaign was supported through a network of employee
“ambassadors” and “directors.” Open Employee Generation Ambassadors and Directors were
located in Novartis Oncology locations across the globe. The ambassadors were key
influencers who actively promoted the campaign to employees in different units across the
Oncology business. Ambassadors encouraged employees to create videos and upload them to
the internal Website. Directors provided logistical support on the ground in offices around the
world by ensuring all employees who wanted to participate knew how to do so (through the
distribution of campaign literature) and had the equipment required to do so (Flip Cameras and
instructions). To prepare these individuals to support the campaign, we provided toolkits of
3 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
campaign resources available to help spread word in their locations and conducted webinars
with each group to train them on campaign objectives and how to use the tools available to
them.
Internal communications materials, including HTML emails, CEO blogs posts, fliers, posters,
brochures and more were distributed throughout the various phases of the campaign to
encourage employees to participate and notify them of key campaign updates. All of these
materials drove employees to the unofficial hub of the campaign -- the campaign Website,
which was updated frequently to inform employees about the rules/keys to participation in
various phases of the program, including the Campaign Launch, Video Collection “How-
Top’s" Voting Phase, and the Announcement of the Winning Video.
—Shortly before launching the campaign we learned that a significant assumption on which
the campaign was based was no longer accurate. We had built the campaign microsite with the
understanding that a certain level of Flash was installed for all Novartis Oncology employees.
Only days before launch, we learned that employees in many of the largest office locations
were unable to view test videos available on the site in Flash, because they did not have an
updated version of the application that our video player required. We were not using the most
recent version of Flash, but one that had a very high market share amongst users and was
supposed to be a base level for all systems across the Novartis Oncology network.
Simply updating to a new version of Flash was not an option since there were employees
working in remote regions as well as tight IT security standards on the client’s end based on
the nature of Novartis Oncology’s work. Because the success of the campaign rested on the
employees’ ability to view and share video stories, we knew we had to develop a solution—
and fast. We learned through testing of a variety of video formats that .wmv files appeared to
be viewable by employees, so with only a few days left until launch, we developed a system
for converting submitted videos upon upload into .wmv format. For those employees who
could not view the Flash Video Uploader tool, we also set up an alternate video upload method
on the Novartis Oncology intranet where employees could upload their videos.
Another obstacle was that we wanted the site only available to users in the Novartis Oncology
network. With users logging in from around the world, we needed to make sure that the site
was available to only these users and not require them to log in to see the site. The solution was
to develop an IP blocker that would not allow users outside the IPs provided by Novartis
Oncology to access the site. This proved to work well and only Novartis Oncology employees
were able to see the site.
—Mino HD Flip cameras (125 total) distributed across the organization for video development.
The development of the campaign Website included working with the vendor, Kaltura. Kaltura
is an open source video platform that allows for customizable solutions for rich media
Websites. The campaign Website was developed using Kaltura to manage the video
functionality including video searching, uploading, importing and the video player used for the
site.
4 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
—The Open Employee Generation campaign was fully integrated and incorporated individuals
representing a variety of areas of expertise, including Internal Communications, Creative
Design, Web Design and Online Communications. The Open Employee Generation campaign
succeeded on many fronts, including:
•Uniting Novartis Oncology’s global community—allowing employees from across the globe
to connect with one another around their common goal: helping improve and extend the lives
of cancer patients around the world.
•Energizing and empowering global associates who were valued and recognized as trusted
ambassadors of the Novartis Oncology brand.
•Securing widespread and enthusiastic participation by employees from around the world.
From Novartis Oncology’s employee base of 5,000 worldwide, we saw:
•Providing compelling content for the integration of employee generated stories into external
recruiting communications. These video stories already appear on Novartis Oncology’s Careers
Website and will be used in an employee referral campaign in the coming weeks. As stated
above, a primary goal of the campaign was to CAPTURE employee stories that reaffirmed the
Novartis brand. The employee-generated stories did that and more. Videos talked about some
of the key characteristics that Novartis Oncology prides itself in, including diversity, passion
for helping cancer patients, work life balance, great teamwork and more.
•Online Editorial Outreach—communication with bloggers who cover relevant issues -- from
pharmaceutical and healthcare news to recruiting and marketing techniques).
Science
5 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
North America
http://sncr.org/awards_2008_uploads/147-NovartisOncology_SNCR_Materials.zip
Emilie Moghadam
Managing Supervisor
Fleishman-Hillard
1615 L St. NW, Suite 1000, Washington, DC 20007
(202) 441-6620
[email protected]
6 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
DIVISION: CORPORATE
CATEGORY: BEHIND THE FIREWALL
Good enough stopped being good enough a long time ago in employee communications.
Today, given our unstable times, employee communications need to be great. Communications
need to help drive rational and emotional commitment among employees. But how do we take
the measurement of employee communications from good enough to great? How does a leader
know if his or her communications are achieving relevance and impact among employees?
How does a corporate communicator use results to refine strategy and optimize messages?
SOLUTION/TOOLS USED/RESULTS
This robust methodology created a virtuous cycle of testing, learning, and improvement for
American Express. The potential significance and application of this methodology goes beyond
employee communications. It provides important insights on tracking, analyzing, and
improving online dialogue for all areas of public relations.
The American Express Company is organized into two distinct customer-focused groups: the
Global Business-to-Business Group (B2B) and the Global Consumer Group. Our target
audience was the Global Business-to-Business Group. Four businesses comprise the global
B2B group: the global merchant business, the network services business, the commercial card
business, and business travel. Collectively, these businesses generate 31% of the company’s
total Net Revenue and 55% of the company’s Net Income as most recently reported. More than
21,000 employees in 140 countries work in these businesses and ultimately report to Mr.
Gilligan. The majority of these employees work in sales or client management roles, and more
than 10% work virtually or in alternative work arrangements. The majority of the B2B
employee population (69%) is Generation X or Generation Y. Most employees are in their
early to mid careers. They are often self-reliant, anti-institution, and family-centric. They are
plugged-in and parallel thinkers. Knowing these demographics and their characteristics were
7 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
imperative to designing an experience-based communications platform and creating a non-
traditional, authentic tone for Ed Gilligan.
• Retention: Are employees remembering what they are reading in Ed’s Blog?
Step 1 - Identify Audience Readiness: The first step in our methodology was to
complete a comprehensive segmentation of the employee base. We augmented our
segmentation with results from a comprehensive research program, including an aided
awareness and usage study, periodic one-to-one employee interviews, key word
linguistic analyses, and weekly online measurement tracking.
Step 2 - Create the Tone: The second step was to share best-in-class linguistic insights
with Ed Gilligan to inform the tone of his writing. We focused on helping Ed to tap into
his unique and authentic voice. Particularly, we kept three principles top of mind:
• Most public behavior, including language, is becoming less formal. Meaning that
informality is becoming the norm, even in written business language, and officialese
sounds increasingly old-fashioned.
8 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
• Webness changed the rules for how we expect information to be given to us. People
interact (and expect to interact) with information differently now -- even complex
information is ˜chunked’ and ˜layered.’ We recognized that there are multiple paths or
employee journeys to the same information.
Step 3 - Develop the Experience and Implement: Finally, we built a creative and engaging
internal communications platform on our corporate intranet using flash, video, and graphics.
This platform included executions such as new media tactics including: employee-generated
videos and flash-based executions, an intranet video game, an April Fool’s backwards blog,
and Easter eggs undocumented features available by finding hidden links within Ed’s various
blogs.
The team faced three challenges: introduce a new platform of communications, prove the
business case for this new communications platform, and prove its relevance during difficult
times.
Challenge #1
Introduce the New Platform: Ed’s Blog was the first intranet-based blog introduced at
American Express. Given this, we needed to set clear expectations for what Ed’s Blog would
be and would it would not. Ed described it in this way: Let me start off by saying a little more
about what my blog is, and what it is not. Apparently there are more than 107 million blogs in
the world and they’re updated all the time. Now, I don’t know what these people do for a living
and I certainly hope they don’t work for us. I know that I won’t be updating my blog that often,
9 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
nor should I. What I want to do is occasionally share with you my thoughts about our B2B
world.
Challenge #2
Prove the Business Case: The key challenge facing the team was to identify metrics to prove
the business case for this new communication strategy and required the investment to execute
against it. To meet this challenge, the team developed a four-part framework for measurement
based on insights from marketing, advertising, and customer servicing.
Challenge #3
Prove Relevance during Difficult Times: As the economy worsened in Q3 and Q4 2008, we
needed to assess the employee population’s experience and readiness for layoffs and major
reengineering actions. The majority of employees (55%) had NOT previously experienced an
economic downturn (notably the recessions of 1990-91 and/or 2001). We used 1-on-1
conversations and key word analyses to track responses over time and adjust messages
accordingly. Given these insights, we were able to dial up messaging from Ed Gilligan focused
on care, direction, and trust.
This communications platform required a staff of two full-time employees a vice president of
communications to focus on strategy and message creation and a specialist in communications
to focus on segmentation, intranet programming, and measurement.
Our measurement methodology needed to answer four basic questions to prove impact.
• Retention: Are employees remembering what they are reading in Ed’s Blog?
10 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
To do so, we adapted best practices and insights from brand advertising, customer servicing,
linguistics, and social media to identify and track key metrics for each question. This
methodology also enabled us to set baselines and measure improvement over time.
Message Engagement: Given that Ed’s Blog is built within American Express’s corporate
intranet, we are able to use click-thru rates to determine how many employees actually went
online to read Ed’s Blog. Gone are the days of sending a broadcast corporate memo and
wondering how many employees actually ever read it. Now, we could measure readership of
an individual blog and track adoption of the blog as a new communication strategy over time.
We were also able to analyze click-thru rates by geography, business unit, and job level to help
us improve our segmentation and targeting efforts. Moreover, by comparing our click-thru
rates to external benchmarks, we were able to assess our relative performance. For the first
time, we were able to tell a senior executive how his communications stacked up against
industry peers.
Message Retention: In advertising, unaided and aided awareness levels are well-established
measurements to assess how likely an individual is to recall a brand or product. We adapted
this methodology to assess employee awareness of Ed’s Blog and their retention of its key
messages. We periodically measured unaided and aided awareness through employee surveys.
The results enabled us to know which messages were achieving break-thru for employees and
where we needed to focus additional efforts to increase recall of key corporate messages. But
as we know, awareness doesn’t always mean action. We also went a step further. Similar to
purchase intent in advertising, we created a metric for willingness to act to gauge the likelihood
that an employee would do, say, or try something different because they were aware of a key
message from Ed. Through employee surveys, interviews, and focus groups, we were able to
measure what percent of the employee base changed their goals, their customer actions, and
other behaviors to drive business performance. We were then able to correlate this willingness
to act to actual business unit performance and customer feedback metrics.
Message Satisfaction: It’s a widely accepted industry practice to use a 5-point Likert scale to
assess customer satisfaction. Ed was very familiar with this methodology and challenged us to
use a similar approach to understand how satisfied employees were with his blog. By
comparing overall satisfaction, top 2-box and bottom 2-box scores collected from periodic
surveys, we were able to identify areas for improvement. For example, if we saw a drop in
satisfaction among employees in marketing, then we were able to advise Ed to dial-up or
change his messaging to resonate more strongly with and for that employee segment.
Message Relevance: It’s a given that the more relevant a message is to its audience, the more
impact it will have. We measured relevance for Ed’s Blog through word and theme resonance
and circles of influence. In linguistics, word and theme resonance is a method of converting a
body of text into a network of key words to help uncover themes, emotional states, and
cognitive associations. Simply said, we first used Microsoft Excel, and then later, programmed
subroutines, to complete two analyses after every blog. First, we analyzed the words and
themes that Ed wrote in that single blog and compared it to all of his blogs to date. Doing so
helped Ed’s words to become a reflection of his own thinking and emotionality. This became
11 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
an important tool to help persuade Ed to change messages over time. Second, we aggregated
and analyzed the employee emails sent to Ed after a blog. This gave us insight into the tone and
depth of what employees were thinking and feeling. We calculated the ratio of negative to
positive emotions so that we could assess how employee sentiment was changing over time.
For example, we were able to compare employee sentiments at several critical points in time:
October 2008 (the height of the financial crisis) and March 2009 (the second wave of company
reengineering efforts).
These analyses enabled us to detect clues for message enhancements, to identify emerging
employee needs, and to help Ed tap into emotional hooks that would spur future response and
dialogue. From the burgeoning field of social media, we know that connectivity (the number of
connections an individual has within and across an online community) and social influence
(respect and position within an online community) are two important metrics to understand the
impact of word-of-mouth in a communications program. For Ed’s Blog, we established a circle
of influence metric to assess the overall impact of one-to-one email communications between
Ed and employees. Particularly, our circles of influence metric calculated the leadership
distance between Ed and the employee (e.g., band levels in reporting hierarchy) and the
number of peers for the employee. We used this to measure the number of incremental word-
of-mouth conversations and leadership impressions among employees about Ed’s Blog.
Our engagement and retention measures specifically mapped to our goal to create a non-
traditional communications platform.
Message Engagement: Ed’s Blog has an average click-thru rate of 44% (an increase of 12%
since launch.) On a relative basis, Ed’s Blog far exceeds available external benchmarks of 21%
and 15% for intranet-based blogs at Northwestern Mutual and a global advertising firm
respectively.
Message Retention: Unaided awareness and aided awareness levels were also high — with
30% of employees naming Ed’s Blog as a primary channel of communication on an unaided
basis and 86% on an aided awareness basis. Key messages on average have 16% unaided
awareness and 68% aided awareness. Again, on a relative basis when compared to a new
product or brand launch, these awareness results are impressive. In terms of willingness to act,
we found that 65% of employees intended to take a different course of action (e.g., customer
action, different goal, leadership action) based on their new awareness of a key message from
Ed and 28% of those employees had already taken that action. This helped to prove the
efficacy of our communications to Ed and his senior management team.
We were able to measure our success to increase the frequency and quality of employee
dialogue with the vice chairman through our satisfaction and relevance measures.
Message Satisfaction: 82% of employees were satisfied with Ed’s Blog -- with 16% of
employees expressing that they were extremely or very satisfied with Ed’s Blog. Only 2% were
detractors -- expressing their concern or dissatisfaction with Ed’s Blog. We were also able to
determine satisfaction by functional group (sales, marketing, operations), geography, band
12 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
level, and gender. This segmentation of the results helped us to identify opportunities to
increase satisfaction among some employee segments and to tap into other segments as highly
satisfied advocates.
Message Relevance: By far the most outstanding result of Ed’s Blog was the dialogue it
created. On average per blog, a hundred employees sent Ed a direct email to which Ed
responded personally. Our word and theme resonance of responses showed an average ratio of
70% positive emotions to 20% negative emotions among employees. This analysis also showed
the depth of employee sentiments. By comparing the occurrence of negative emotions
expressed by employees in October 2008 to March 2009, we saw a decrease from 27% to 23%.
This helped us to understand how Ed’s messages were helping to restore employee positivism.
Particularly, the analysis showed that although positivism was improving, some of the key
words and trends were more intense and required more direct messaging from Ed in his blog.
For example, between October 2008 and March 2009, we saw feedback trends evolve from
bad, challenging times to worst; difficult times and financial uncertainty evolve into personal
financial loss. Measuring this type of pulse on employee sentiment enabled Ed to speak more
directly to employee concerns and improve the relevance of his messages. As for our results in
measuring circles of influence, we identified that on average Ed’s email exchanges about his
blogs were with employees who were five or more levels lower in band level than Ed and have
12 or more peers. Our measurement showed that employees were likely to mention an email
exchange with Ed to at least 50% of their peers. This means that almost 12,000 employees to
date have participated in a word-of-mouth conversation about Ed’s Blog and his willingness to
communicate directly with employees. These conversations have translated into employees
maintaining a high degree of trust in the company’s leadership during unprecedented business
conditions.
And overall, our measurement methodology helped to achieve our third objective to measure
the holistic impact of our employee communications. Particularly, we think that our progress in
how to measure the relevance of social media in corporate environments, such as internal
blogs, can help further innovation in the field of employee communications.
13 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
DIVISION: CORPORATE
CATEGORY: BEHIND THE FIREWALL
MANHEIM
In 2009, as the auto industry faced its biggest changes in decades, Manheim, the world’s
leading provider of used vehicle services with 135 locations, also began to undergo significant
change. We began reviewing every process in an effort to simplify our company and create
efficiencies across locations. At the same time, we were implementing a new financial system
infrastructure and working with customers who were gravely affected by the changing
automotive industry.
To help employees understand how these changes affected our company and their role, we
knew we needed to communicate well. We needed to efficiently bring together employees and
their expertise and foster a collaborative approach to help managers understand our strategy,
adopt changes and be able to communicate messages to their staff. This is challenging at
Manheim because:
With travel significantly reduced, managers have fewer opportunities to share ideas and
best practices in person with their counterparts at our 85 North American locations.
When employees join Manheim, transfer or leave, we face challenges keeping their
profile current. When titles and departments aren’t correct in the company directory,
employees cannot easily find decision-makers, thought-leaders or the go-to person they
need.
We need to communicate frequently and quickly using a small staff. On our current
intranet, it takes an average of 89 minutes to post new requests for content, creating a
two-week message bottleneck.
Lots of corporate messages compete for our managers’ attention. Only 30% of our
employees are active on the current intranet. To make significant changes using the
intranet to communicate, we will need more employees visiting the site regularly.
TOOLS USED
Given these challenges, Manheim decided to use social media tools (i.e., blogs, wikis,
communities, RSS, “friending,” etc.,) to transform our intranet into the first place for
employees to look to answer their questions and get information they need to handle their
employees' questions. To do this, we needed to make the site a dynamic, relevant, collaborative
space where employees could connect and find experts. However, we're not a technology
company, and many of our executives were only vaguely aware of the current intranet, what it
was used for and who used it. So, convincing them of the benefits of a “social intranet” was
going to be the hardest challenge of all. We decided to create a pilot intranet to demonstrate
how a transformed intranet can help us achieve our change management messaging goals.
14 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
The audience for the pilot was 600 employees representing four key manager groups and
totaling four percent of our total intranet population:
SOLUTION
Our primary goal for the pilot was to demonstrate to senior management the business benefits
of a "social intranet" and how it will be crucial in helping us meet our change communications
needs. Our primary project objective was to receive funding from the executive committee to
purchase the full suite of licenses for the entire employee population of 15,000. We decided to
build a pilot to do this.
First, we chose work groups within each key executive's organization that had the most to gain
from online communities. We planned the following communities:
15 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
Ran in Pilot: 138 days
Business Goal: Generate business discussions amongst AGMs related to company strategy and
operational changes occurring
Trained over 15 business managers to manage their communities and use the
community blog as their group news instead of using inefficient group emails and easy-
to-use wikis to present key community content.
Added a personalized aggregation of general corporate news + the user's targeted
community news using RSS technology
Our biggest project constraint was losing our IT project manager, who also played the business
analyst role, just as the pilots were being planned. Due to tight budgets, IT did not replace her.
This put the burden of vendor and user management on the communications intranet team,
something we were not staffed to handle.
16 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
We selected Jive SBS as our social business software. Gartner positioned Jive as leading
visionaries in their 2008 Magic Quadrant for Social Software, and Forester cited Jive as a
market leader in Community Platforms in 2009. We chose it for its collaboration, community
and social capabilities: a flexible widget framework, tagging/tag clouds, community news
blogs, community discussion forums, wiki documents with flexible collaboration options, A/V
capabilities, all content tied to its author(s) and robust company directory. We also liked that
content development happens right where the content lives, making it much more efficient to
manage.
The following roles and responsibilities were put in place to support the pilot project:
Product Manager
Developed vision for the social intranet
Defined business requirements for IT
Sold vision to intranet stakeholders
Project Manager
Drove timelines for each community plan, design and launch
Trained community managers
Managed users and memberships
2 Communication Liaisons
Acted as consultants to the community managers for messaging and communication best
practices
RESULTS
The results were overwhelmingly positive and showed Manheim employees were ready to
adopt online collaboration and business managers were eager to embrace the new site as a key
method for change communications.
The new platform is giving business managers quantitative results of their communications that
they never had using group emails. Executives who previously didn't know who accessed or
for what reasons they accessed the previous intranet platform, now are advocates of
communicating business critical information on the new intranet. As a result, we received
funding to purchase 4,500 licenses for the remainder of the year and our maximum 15,000
licenses by Jan. 2010. The total funding commitment for the licenses, hardware, system
integration and operational support was for $1.8 million!"
COMMUNITY BUILDING
17 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
In 138 days, four vibrant online business communities came alive, bringing geographically
dispersed managers together to discuss the changes happening and get answers immediately:
1) Discussions
a) 134 Total Discussions Posted - averaging one discussion post for every four users.
b) 5,056 Total Views to Discussions
c) 390 replies -- averaging one reply for every two users
2) Word about the communities’ successes is spreading and now there is a high demand for
more communities —12 more are under development
3) Sample Success Story: Community members found two customers who were abusing our
Arbitration system at several locations —103 views /13 replies
CONNECTING EMPLOYEES
Employees gravitated to the people connecting tools available in the new pilot platform by
searching/browsing the new company directory, taking ownership of their online identities and
finding valuable colleagues to connect with:
1) 55% users updated their profile on the pilot platform in 138 days, compared to 10%
who've submitted a request on the current site over a 2-year period
2) 34% users uploaded a profile picture on pilot platform in 138 days, compared to 3%
who’ve submitted a request on the current site over a 2-year period
3) 9,975 Employee Profile Views (17 views/user), compared to 3,025 views (0.25
views/user) on the current site during the same time period
4) Colleague Connections (not promoted at all, completely organic)
a) 330 Total Users using this feature (i.e. have at least one colleague connection), 55%
of users
b) 1,735 Total Colleague Connections
c) 3 Average Connections/User
With the new pilot platform, every employee's user experience is tailored to his/her business
information needs and personal communication preferences:
1) 15 appointed and trained captains are managing live communities and generating
relevant community news: 1 messenger to every 40 users, compared to 2.5 people who
are qualified to update the current site: 1 messenger to every 6,000 users
2) My Manheim News aggregates a user's targeted community news & company news
into one location on the home page
3) Users can turn on/off e-mail notifications per community news, document, &
discussion
4) 287 users subscribed to content they care about, 48% of users
18 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
MORE DYNAMIC SITE
In addition to having more trained content contributors, each author is able to contribute to the
site faster, resulting in a more dynamic site. The process of developing content is 2.5Xs faster
on the pilot platform compared to the current site: 35 minutes per average page of content vs.
89 minutes.
By creating a highly personalized, dynamic site where employees can easily connect with
experts and like-minded colleagues, we drove views to the intranet, meaning we have relatively
more eyeballs on our messages:
1) 15,337 average monthly views to the pilot site. With a user population of 600, that is
averaging over 25 views/user. (Compare this to the current site's monthly page views of
70,000-user population of 15,000, which only gets 4.6 views/user)
2) 50-55% of community members have visited their new communities. (Compared to 25-
30% of users who visit the current Main Street at least once a month)
The new platform is giving business managers quantitative results of their communications that
they never had using group emails. Executives who previously didn’t know who accessed or
for what reasons they accessed the previous intranet platform, now are advocates of
communicating business critical information on the new intranet. As a result, we received
funding to purchase 4,500 licenses for the remainder of the year and our maximum 15,000
licenses by Jan. 2010. The total funding commitment for the licenses, hardware, system
integration and operational support were for $1.8 million!
Industry: Wholesale
Region: North America
Supporting document: http://sncr.org/awards_2008_uploads/84-Microsoft Word –SNCR -
Corporate Award Entry - Behind the Firewall Visuals.pdf
Contact: Jennifer Bouani
Manager of Interactive Communications
Manheim
6205 Peachtree Dunwoody Rd.; Atlanta, GA 30328
(678) 645-2261
[email protected]
19 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
DIVISION: CORPORATE
CATEGORY: BEHIND THE FIREWALL
SPRINT
Following a series of significant changes to our business, including leadership changes, layoffs
and economic pressure, Sprint (www.sprint.com) seeks to positively impact its reputation
among employees and (re) build brand ambassadors from the inside out.
The 2009 Clarius Research study that Sprint commissioned to measure its reputation indicated
that it significantly trails both Verizon and AT&T with customers, businesses executives and
thought leaders. Word of mouth from a friend/relative was the key driver of negative brand
perception. The study also found that Sprint has a high level of satisfaction among its
customers - but the lowest among providers.
Since employees are also customers, shareholders and thought leaders, our challenge is to
positively impact employee attitudes and leverage their significant word of mouth influence.
We also had data from Sprint’s Employee Experience Survey and the Edelman Trust
Barometer that indicated that employees were more likely to trust information coming from
their peers and direct managers than the corporate executive institution. Year-over-year
employees ranked quality of direct management high but their commitment to the company
low. They also claim that their opinions and expertise are not valued to a large degree.
After a successful launch of the social media platform Sprint Space in May 2008, we looked
for ways to fully implement a strategy to drive a culture of open communications and provide
intelligence about our business to key decision makers.
SOLUTION/TOOLS USED/RESULTS
In 2009, The Communications and PR team, leaders, subject matter experts and
general employees have leveraged the platform to:
20 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
Community-based sites that support special interest groups are also advancing
critical business initiatives such as Sprint’s political action committee, diversity and
inclusion organizations, sustainability, and performance coaching.
Additionally, we have enjoyed an added depth to our internal news coverage by embracing
employee "journalists" who rebuff the traditional approval process of formal employee
communications and deliver an honest accounting of everyday life in our Retail stores, our call
centers and offices complete with pictures, videos, polls and comments in real time.
While Sprint Space is open to all 49,000 employees nationwide, the biggest adoption has come
from employees in customer-facing roles in our retail-store and customer-service operations.
Employees in retail stores, customer-care call centers and sales functions generate 80 percent
of all posts to Sprint Space today. The average age of Sprint Retail employees is 22 years. That
makes them part of the digital generation, whose members blog, friend and tweet just as they
eat, drink, and sleep. In other words, they have grown up using social media. The next largest
groups of employees to embrace social media are in information technology and other highly
technical positions, such as telecommunications network engineering.
The Retail, Care, Sales, IT, and Sprint Network employees comprise approximately 75 percent
of the total employee population. Active participation, which is defined as having an active
profile, individual blog or publishing comments on postings, is lower among corporate support
functions. However, we have significant passive participation (no profile, just reading the
content, which is also known as lurking). In addition, several key leaders including those in
Human Resources and Corporate Strategy are active, regular participants in Sprint Space.
The goal behind our employee social networking and blogging community, Sprint
Space—is to equip employees with the necessary knowledge to explain the why behind
company decisions and to answer customer questions. Sprint Space allows us to
facilitate open, two-way dialogue among employees at all levels and across all
geographies.
Sprint's chief goals are to build its brand, protect the company’s reputation and to
deliver an exceptional service to customers. We believe that Sprint Space contributes to
these goals by driving a culture of openness, increasing transparency about business
initiatives and spotlighting accountability among leaders who chose to contribute.
Blur lines between Sprint Space (social media site) and i-Connect (company-wide
intranet), ratchet up activity to drive authenticity and engage key employee influencers.
Decrease communications clutter and reach employees in ways they've embraced
outside of work.
Today, we have integrated the social media channel into our overall internal
communications capabilities. Our role as communicators has moved from
disseminating information to being the stewards of open communication and active
21 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
contributors to the dialogue. We are also responsible for measuring the effectiveness of
the channel and monitoring its use for policy violations. Our corporate communicators
are encouraged to consider the following in their approach to communications counsel:
Shine a light on real business issues and be a catalyst to help solve them
Offer a perspective on key issues and influence perceptions about our company
Activate our brand from the inside out
Deliver the "why" behind decision making in a two-way conversation
With these principles in mind, we look for opportunities to leverage the channel to further the
communications goals of our internal clients. We listen to the conversations started by
employees to take intelligence back to our business partners. We develop opportunities to
advance transparency in the communication style and demonstrate accountability of our
leaders. One notable example is the use of real time chats with key decision makers. When
Sprint announced a partnership with Ericsson to provide maintenance of our networks,
resulting in the transfer of approximately 6000 employees to that company, we hosted a live
Webcast to the desktop to Network employees followed by a one-hour chat in Sprint Space for
all employees with key executives and decision makers. The result was increased
understanding of the new business model and a direct dialogue with the leaders who were
accountable for the partnership.
Prior to 2008, there were a variety of small instances of blogging platforms being used in
various tech-savvy work groups, most were homegrown solutions and none could meet our
enterprise requirements. In 2008, we found a work group using Jive Clearspace, and with their
help, we deployed it for use by the entire organization. We named the platform Sprint Space
and linked key discussions and blog posts to the regular internal news coverage on our intranet,
i-Connect. We did very little to promote the site internally as we wanted to give our early
adopters and social media-savvy employees a chance to own it. We did not want to stifle
grassroots discussion by being too heavy handed with the corporate influence or signal that this
was just another corporate tool.
22 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
We continued to develop our policies and guidelines working with HR and Legal and bench
marked best practices of other companies. For a month or so, we monitored the space and
when the opportunity to confront a major issue with broad relevance to our employees
presented itself, we jumped on it. The response was great. We had thousands of employees
read the discussion and nearly 500 comments in a thread that lasted for several months.
About a month after we tackled the first big issue, it was clear that Sprint Space was quickly
being adopted as a trusted channel. Feeling that the channel had taken hold, we created a
portlet on the homepage of our intranet and selected blogs to feature each day. We began a
News blog for all major employee news stories and prominently feature those in our internal
media.
Sprint Space accommodates both public and private spaces where, in addition to blogging,
users can pick and choose tools for project management, polls, calendar, and discussions. All
new public blog posts appear on the homepage of the site in chronological order. All
employees are required to log in to post or participate in discussions. There is no anonymity in
order to foster a culture of accountability.
Employees can choose to follow specific content sets and receive e-mail notifications when
new content is added to the spaces or discussions they are following. We (Corporate
Communications' editorial team) choose blog posts or discussions that are of the broadest
interest or have specific business relevance to feature on the home page of our Corporate
Intranet. Employees navigate between the intranet and Sprint Space using the same login ID
and password and can remain logged into Sprint Space for up to two weeks.
Employee word-of-mouth helps promote the site and we integrate the channel in our regular
communication counsel to executives and business groups who are our internal clients.
Increasingly, we are finding links to blogs and discussions in executive memos, newsletters
and other work group communications.
23 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
look closely at the time spent on each blog to help understand the level of engagement with the
channel as well as with each topic.
We also are addressing connectivity issues with our vendor-partners. As our business evolves
and we partner with other companies for things like network maintenance and call center
services, the size of audience that can reach the channel and participate in conversations behind
the firewall seems to be ever-changing.
Like most of the companies we have bench marked, we are continually educating employees in
how to engage with the channel, how to use the technology platform and the value in time
spent building a community and communicating using new media resources.
At present, we are launching a company-wide initiative to identify, educate and support brand
ambassadors who would like to participate in both internal and external social media forums on
behalf of Sprint. In the context of this initiative, we are addressing challenges of resources,
training, and labor law as well as revising the policies to support our efforts.
The larger Social Media team in Corporate Communications is primarily focused on external
social media outreach and includes:
To date in 2009, 23,073 page titles were viewed a total of 1,935,788 times in Sprint Space.
Average time on all pages is 1:41. Traffic is steady with unique views averaging 14,000 -
15,000 each week (~ 60,000 per month) and view times between 3-5 minutes consistently.
Reputation: The PR team has been able to influence the tone of conversations on a number of
occasions. For example, when employees posted a media report on executive compensation,
24 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
the PR manager jumped in to help clear up misinformation about executive perks and provide a
counter perspective—the comments moved from mostly negative to neutral. The Money blog
titled "Sprint's report on executive compensation" received 3,172 views with 3:27 time on site.
Transparency and accountability: When the employee discount for monthly service was
discontinued in one key market, the manager of the program joined the conversation,
tempering the tone by educating employees about the business drivers. Comments indicated
appreciation that someone was listening and willing to address it. The News blog titled
"Setting the record straight - so what do you want to know" addressed rumors about several
potential business deals and layoffs. It received 4,952 views with a view time of 3:13. The head
of Corporate Strategy's blog titled "Why are we doing what we're doing?" received 2,011 views
with 4:06 view time.
Employee culture: Sprint’s culture was sighted as a key problem for the company following its
merger with Nextel and several other key business changes. The most read blog post so far this
year titled "read the news today (oh boy)" was written by Jennifer Sniderman in conjunction
with the Jan. 2009 labor reduction. The blog post was viewed 7,957 times with 5:16 avg. time
on site.
Second most read blog this year; "You might just be a Sprint employee." was viewed 6, 170
times with 2:06 average view time. This one is a thread of one-liners started by a Retail store
employee. Most are positive comments on the quirks and perks of everyday life at Sprint.
Window into the customer experience: During the launch of the Palm Pre this year, the
"official" Sprint Space for the device was one of the most trafficked spaces with 5,114 views
and 2:26 avg. view time. There were more than 20 other individual blogs and discussions
sharing key features of the device as well as surfacing drivers of in-store returns and pricing
questions. Issues uncovered included cracked LCDs or the eligibility of discounting and
rebates. We provided daily buzz reports during the launch and passed along several customer
service issues to the Retail and Customer Care "war rooms" in the initial weeks after the
consumer launch of the device.
Sprint’s corporate goals are to build its brand, protect the company’s reputation and to deliver
an exceptional service to customers. By educating employees about the decisions we are
making as a company, our products and services they are better equipped to speak
knowledgeably about the company in their natural social networks. Providing a forum that
spotlights accountability of key decisions makers gives us unprecedented ability to influence
the tenor of the dialogue. By connecting people, we can share best practices and solve real
business and customer issues in real time. The free exchange of information and personal
aspects of the social media tool has allowed frontline employees to give us a rare window into
the experiences of our customers in their unedited and unfiltered words. The natural freedom of
expression intrinsic in the design of the medium drives a culture of openness and camaraderie
that is infinitely larger in the online mobile workforce. The volume of traffic and level of
engagement (both through passive and active participation) provides significant opportunity to
25 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
turn the virtual water cooler into a productive intelligence-gathering tool that can deliver real
value to our business. "
26 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
DIVISION: CORPORATE
CATEGORY: BEHIND THE FIREWALL
NETAPP
Business challenge
NetApp is a global company with over 100 offices worldwide and 8,000 employees. The
company was struggling to effectively leverage information about products and customers
within geographically dispersed teams and across functions. It was not able to host global
discussions about the company, its leadership, new products and partners, events, etc.., nor to
effectively listen to its audience and process appropriate feedback.
Rapid growth led to functional silos of information; multiple collaboration initiatives and
platforms were created without consideration of a global web strategy.
The root cause was our legacy culture of over-reliance on email, tribal knowledge. NetApp was
thinking about communication the same way it did ten years earlier.
The opportunity was to identify and utilize a common communication platform to increase
productivity, reduce waste, and enable NetApp-wide leveraging of information as well as with
strengthening external relationships with partners, customers. This communication platform
was also identified as part of our global web strategy.
Cultural challenge
NetApp has been recognized as one of the 100 best places to work in the US for the past 7
years (being ranked # 1 by FORTUNE Magazine at the beginning of this year) as well as
garnering similar recognition around the world. The open communications environment and
accessibility of our execs have regularly contributed to this recognition. As NetApp has grown
to a company of over ,8000 employees the challenge was to grow the internal communications
infrastructure to keep pace with growth of company and global expansion of company, to over
100 offices worldwide.
We survey our employees annually about our internal communications and in 2006 learned that
employees wanted to have greater opportunities for online dialogue. Culturally, we needed to
unite all the internal discussions under a single platform where information could be shared
across the company.
27 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
We also wanted to ensure that we had buy-in and support from teams across the company in
the initial development of this idea as well as throughout the RFP, planning and deployment so
that we could grow the solution with cross-functional support and not in a silo.
The annual internal communications survey indicated that employees working outside of
headquarters and in the field needed “equal access” and a unified platform for learning about
key corporate initiatives. These same employees also needed a place to be heard and share their
thoughts and feedback with their peers and key leaders within the company. Bottom line, email
was not an effective way to communicate corporate initiatives. Our employees already get
enough email. One team estimated hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of lost productivity
just in glancing and deleting emails from distribution lists.
In brief we realized that we needed to make it easy for employees across functions and
geographies to share information with each other. To do this we needed to find integrated
community software that could be launched quickly and would be easy for users to use.
In addition to the business and communication challenges outlined above, the planning for the
NetApp Live initiative coincided with the planning for the launch of our brand. We realized
that the increased functionality of online community would provide both employees and
customers with a richer experience that would begin to deliver on our brand promise of “Go
further, faster.” We decided that including the launch of online dialogue/ online community as
part of our brand launch was the best way to kick-start employee use of community and to
align the concept of community with a critical corporate initiative.
NetApp employees are primarily knowledge workers, well educated, articulate and intelligent
who are committed to providing our customers with an outstanding experience and helping our
customers solve their business problems. A large percentage of NetApp employees have
engineering and technical backgrounds. They are enthusiastic, engaged, and innovative as well
as open about sharing their ideas. These employees and their leaders have created a workplace
that has been recognized around the world as a great place to work and they are committed to
keeping that vibrant and dynamic community. NetApp employees like to work as part of a
team and many of our teams span the globe.
Approximately 8,000 employees and 1,000+ contractors worldwide with access to the intranet.
All NetApp employees have computer access. Many in the field rely primarily on smart phones
to stay in touch.
English is the business language for NetApp, although not 100% of the employees are fluent in
English. We wanted to provide them with a platform that would scale to accommodate local
language just as email accommodates local language conversation.
SOLUTION/TOOLS USED/RESULTS
VISION
28 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
Have a space to transcend time zones, geographic locations and functional silos.
NetApp Live is named for the overarching internal online community that would leverage
community infrastructure (comprised of multiple sub communities) to push out executive
messaging and internal communications while at the same time enlarging the feedback pipe to
increase employee-driven dialogue and engagement forums around the globe, across functions,
between employees and leaders.
This community is exclusively an internal community and does not include external parties
such as partners, customers, and prospects.
The plan was to build an internal online community that would allow employees to:
Due to resource constraints, we planned to pilot internal community with a brand community
dedicated to providing information and answering questions about our multi-year branding
initiative simultaneous with our worldwide brand launch in March of 2008.
Hire a community manager to support the growth of community including technical support,
internal marketing and development of roadmap.
29 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
In the next fiscal year, with resources in place to support NetApp Live, the more robust internal
community that we had envisioned during the RFP process. The initial brand community
would then become a sub-community of NetApp Live.
Employ Social Media strategies that tap into people’s need to connect at work.
Enlist executive support and involvement including being hosts for communities, responding to
employee questions as well as directing their teams to use NetApp Live. Our CEO asked to be
the host for the Words From the Helm community.
Update the plan every 6-12 months to respond to evolving user interest.
The launch of NetApp Live was to be a zero-defect launch. The Internal Communications site,
linkages with other sites, template for community site layout, tools for community owners,
process and workflow etc., were to be built out and tested prior to the launch to the employee
population.
Structure
Grow organically
Documentation
•Less anonymity
•Continual need for new and timely content for all communities
31 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
•Evolution of communities
Various members of the cross-functional team that was part of the extensive RFP evaluation
process have been involved with the growth of NetApp Live over the past 18 months.
The vision was to have a hybrid of community and conversation that would give employees
greater voice and allow for increased conversation between employees and executives as well
as pushing out important corporate news. (See screen shots in accompanying PPT deck.)
We implemented a best practice in online design page layout by having certain core elements
in the same place on all pages. Included in these standard elements were welcome messages,
boxes for highlighting key corporate news found in Words From the Helm (messages from our
executives) and Roving Reporter (a weekly news program that includes written, audio and
video messages) and the actions that users can take. (See screen shot on PPT page 2.)
We learned that building community requires a tremendous and ongoing investment of time in
working with community owners to launch and sustain their communities as well as employing
creative and engaging opportunities for employees to use a new medium in a work context.
In order to effectively link the NetApp Live community to our intranet we created a box in the
upper right corner that highlights new content on NetApp Live. This box typically includes
listings of the question of the week, new Roving Reporter coverage and key executive
messages. Additionally, when an executive responds to employee posts we would highlight it,
or we would post the name of the employees and description of their submissions to the
NetApp Champions Contest (see description below). (See screen shot on PPT page 3.)
Introduction of pulse polls: We created an editorial calendar for questions and plan at least one
question asked per week. Answering polls provides an easy way for users to participate. We’ve
found that including an element of irreverence in the answers increases the participation. (See
screen shot on PPT page 4.)
Becoming part of the internal communications mix: When the Internal Communications team
consults on how a companywide initiative could be communicated to employees we normally
explore how different communication tools including elements of NetApp Live community
32 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
could be leveraged. For example, is there a need for a dedicated community such as Green
Inside for our Green Initiative? In other cases, it might be a pulse poll or a conversation prompt
in the “Speak Out” Community where any employee can raise any topic.
NetApp Champions Contest: The Internal Communications team partnered with the Brand
team to develop and implement a companywide contest. Since we wanted to ensure that
everyone around the world could participate, we realized that an online contest was the way to
go and that NetApp Live would be the perfect medium. Imagine an online version of
“American Idol.” The categories for competition were poetry, photography and video. Our
CEO and CMO introduced the contest during a Special Edition All Hands as well as by email.
Contest results are discussed below in the Results Section. Employees understood that this was
a beta environment and didn’t complain about our leveraging an employee’s photo album to
serve as the photo album for the contest. (See screen shots on PPT page 6, 7.)
Engaging a broader group of executive advocates: We invited three VPs to be judges of the
NetApp Champions Contest. Evaluation of the submissions necessitated that they view the
submissions on NetApp Live. One of those VPs became so impressed with the functionality
and platform that he has since become a huge advocate and led his team to create communities
on NetApp Live. He also saw how employee participation outside of the US picked up once
employees outside of the US won in the monthly competitions.
Alternative to intranet site: Because the platform is so user-friendly, we have been able to
launch communities for team that weren’t able to build out an intranet site. NetApp Live
allowed them to leapfrog into the web 2.0 experience: both post their content and provide
interactivity.
We decided to prominently display “Beta” on the banner for NetApp Live so that employees
would be reminded that this is a new deployment of technology. (See screen shots on PPT page
2) As we are a technology company, our employees are familiar with what it means to be in
beta-mode and have given us feedback that we have acted on. (For examples, see the “The
tools involved” section below.)
Initially, we needed to get support across functions throughout the company so that people
would align around one approach to community rather than pursuing unrelated pilot programs
within their own silos. Our CEO included a request that employees who were interested in
online community contact the Senior Manager of Internal Communications in the same email
in which he reported back the high-level results of the employee internal communications
survey to the employee population. The Senior Manager contacted each individual who
expressed interest in supporting this initiative and after having individual meetings with each
one started to have team meetings. In addition to team meetings she provided periodic email
33 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
updates to the team so that the team stayed aligned during the year in which they scoped and
implemented the vendor selection process.
When others asked to join the team, they were welcomed in and asked to share their expertise
whether it was technical expertise in evaluating an RFP response or insights into how a
particular executive liked to see information or in reporting back and advocating with their
team for support of NetApp Live. The result was a sense of common ownership and
collaboration that finally led to the selection of Jive Software to support both internal and
external community for NetApp.
We needed IT support during a time when our IT organization was taxed with a number of
higher priority projects. And we finally got it with the understanding that we would utilize
external hosting and thus be less demanding of IT resources at the same time we provided
additional value to customers and employees.
We had originally envisioned that employees would be able to view the site without having to
log-on, but our initial IT infrastructure prevented that. We have been working for months to
change this and expect this to change within weeks of this submission. As with other aspects of
this deployment, relentless, dogged persistence and patience are bringing more and more
aspects of the vision into reality.
HR and legal concerns about potential liability due to the content of discussions (political,
religious, gender, etc.,) in some of the social groups. We realized that we needed to update
social media guidelines. We responded by drafting a comprehensive social media guide in
partnership with those responsible for externally facing social media for both internal and
external usage which was approved by both HR and legal. (See attached abridged Social Media
Guidelines focusing on NetApp Live.)
Funding: Once we could prove how the launch of online community would provide instant
increased functionality for both internal and external audiences and thus be an initial proof
point for our brand promise “Go further, faster” we were able to secure funding for both
communities for a companywide implementation.
Getting video player functionality. While the external Jive platform allows YouTube and
similar access, being behind the firewall, that isn’t an option for the NetApp Live Community.
Yet our original vision always included having corporate and employee user produced video as
part of the content mix. We store our videos on our internal media server. To further improve
the user experience, we created code to allow us to embed a video player into a community
page or a document.
Starting with the out-of-the-box ClearSpace software from Jive and an externally hosted
implementation, we began by requiring people to login to use the communities. To enable that
IT and Jive IT integrated the implementation with our Single Sign On system using the
information from our internal databases to identify the person as an employee. We then worked
with internal IT and with Jive IT to wrap the system in a VPN which enables us to treat it as an
internal machine. Based on feedback from our community owners, we worked with the Jive
Professional Services to customize the product. We had them adapt and install a Photo Album
capability, which allows anyone to create an album and upload photos (similar to an internal
version of Flickr). (See screen shots on PPT page 8.)
At the same time we introduced the improved Photo Album capability, we changed the default
statement on the creation screen to remind people of our social media guidelines about adding
items onto a company system. We noticed a poor user experience with reporting activity on a
poll. The system was modified to not report that a person voted in a poll until after 10 votes
were submitted, protecting anonymity. One community implemented moderation on content
and asked to have the default language changed to provide information about the process used
by that team. To improve metrics reporting, we worked with the Jive Professional Services and
our Omniture team to create code on each document, which collects the tags used on that
document. This allows us to sort and view usage based on the tags.
Using the internal window media server as a host, we created links to the window media video
file. The initial version, using just the link to the file, caused the video file to download onto
the user’s computer and open a window media player. To improve this, we created code, which
allows us to embed the player onto the page. This plays the video without having to wait.
Looking forward, we started work to support Flash video. Currently we are developing a
prototype Flash media server, obtained code to transform other video formats into Flash, and
have developed code to create a Flash media player, which we can embed in the page.
Hired our first community manager whose initial responsibility was to bring up external
communities and one internal brand community by our brand launch in March 2008 (he had
approximately 2 months to do this). He now supports our external community. (John Summers)
Engaged part-time brand contractors whose responsibilities included posting content to the
internal brand community and answering employee questions re: brand launch.
35 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
We brought on a second community manager to support internal communities who
responsibility was to re-launch community on a broader basis than we had done with the initial
brand community. This internal community manager is an integral member of the Internal
Communications team. Responsibilities include:
Lead the development and oversee the design, production, and integration of the
community with the corporate site
Coordinate the development and delivery of content for the community site
Monitor and maintain the site on a daily basis including online forums
Notify appropriate staff about online discussions or inquiries that should receive a
response from the organization.
Provide ongoing support to and share best practices with community owners
Maintain network and data security including controlling user access, monitoring
performance, data backups, Internet firewall configuration and virus and worm
prevention and elimination.
(Mike Crocker)
Community owners are responsible for putting together a preliminary business plan for each
community, which comprises the larger NetApp Live Internal Community. This business plan
must include a statement of purpose and how the community engagement will be initiated and
sustained. Our 26 community owners work with the internal community manager to build out
their communities and to share best practices with their peers.
Executive sponsors of NetApp Live: Initially, Elisa Steele who was the SVP of Corporate
Marketing. Today, Jay Kidd, SVP and CMO (Chief Marketing Officer).
Community executive sponsors are required to start all communities. This ensures that there is
support for the communities and that a clear business purpose has been identified before a new
community is built. We currently have 25 executive sponsors for communities on NetApp
Live. (See attached Community Request Form.)
36 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
Program manager, Internal Communications, (including Roving Reporter and N-reporter) who
partners closely with the internal community manager. (Erik Stromberg)
We rely on metrics, employee comments on NetApp Live, anecdotal comments, survey results
to measure our progress. We continue to explore new ways of measuring progress and success
and we share this information with community owners on a weekly basis so that we are
continuously learning from each other.
Metrics Summary
Launched pilot brand community in March 2008. Added 24 communities in 11 months from
September 2008 through August 2009 taking us to a total of 25 communities at the end of
August 2009.
Registered users from zero (in March 2008) to 1,068 for initial single-focus brand community.
Registered users grew from 1058 (on September 10, 2008) to 8,468 by the end of August 2009.
Total Interactions grew from 131 total interactions for September 2008 to a total of 1848 at the
end of August 2009 (Interactions defined as new messages and documents measured for a
period of slightly less than 12 months).
Page views grew from 11,397 (in September 2008) to 42,532 for the month of August 2009
and a total of 346,595 for the period September 10, 2008 to August 31, 2009)
Monthly unique visitors grew from 2,124 (in September 2008) to 5,112 by the end of August
2009.
Speed of Growth
The initial objective was to create internal community. The work that the cross-functional team
did in defining a comprehensive RFP process, which resulted in the selection of Jive Software
allowed us to introduce
One of our objectives was to bring up this technology quickly. We were able to bring up the
initial internal community, the brand community in two months. We launched the NetApp Live
internal community within 3 months of our internal community manager joining us.
37 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
Ongoing nurturing of community is essential to its growth. Our community manager has/is
worked with teams to explore the development of 76 potential sub-communities within NetApp
Live. He encouraged 8 of those teams to launch their communities as part of our NetApp
external community so that conversations could include partners, customers and/or prospects. 6
of the communities have been retired. We currently have 25 communities accessible to
employees (Only two of these internal communities have business reasons for having restricted
access.) Another 8 communities are in the active staging and development area.
Grew from one community to 25 communities in 18 months: Started with one pilot community
in March 2008. We launched NetApp Live in September 2008 and have 25 communities at the
end of August 2008.
Growth in registered users to include most employees and contractors in less than a year after
launch of NetApp Live.
Our original plan was to nurture the communities slowly and to have the registered user base
grow as additional communities were added and became active. We thought that this would be
a way to leverage lessons learned and to discover the best ways to sustain engagement. We did
not anticipate the extent of the effect of executive support of our CEO and President including
references to NetApp Live in their emails to employees and the rapidity of growth of registered
users exceeded all of our expectations.
When we moved the Roving Reporter stories from our intranet to NetApp Live we were
concerned that we might experience a decline in viewership due to the fact that employees had
to sign on to read rather than just click to another page. This decline did not occur.
Consequently, we also moved our executive messaging on Words From the Helm to NetApp
Live as well.
In fact, because of the real-time metrics that we can get from the Jive Software we can watch
the increase in hits real-time rather than having to wait until the next day as we had to with
postings on our intranet site. With our intranet site only a static number at the end of the day is
available.
Additionally, we have more employees asking to have news stories on topics of interest to
them and we have introduced a new program, N-reporter to accommodate those who want to
38 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
share regional stories that don’t meet the requirements for being included in the Roving
Reporter program. Employees are not only posting news they are also putting together
guidelines. An employee in Germany has put together a video on how your profile and has
offered to create more “how to” videos for fellow employees. (See attached N-reporter posting
guidelines)
NetApp employees are used to honesty and directness in executive communications. NetApp
Live provides a global platform for these discussions. One doesn’t have to be in the same time
zone as an executive to ask a question. An example of this is a question raised by one of our
employees after a bidding war for an acquisition, “What does NetApp do with the 57 Million
Consolation Prize?” Our CMO responded to this question. The thread including this question
had 1541 views by the end of August. These metrics are typical of online activity: there are
exponentially more readers or observers than active participants. (See PPT page 9)
It is now a norm for emails from executives to all employees to ask them for their comments
on NetApp Live.
The Brand Team with whom we launched our online community initiative has been so
impressed with the visibility that NetApp Live has provided and the ease of posting materials
that they continue to be internal advocates for use of the community in their communications
with and outreach to employees.
Global participation
We definitely have global participation in the NetApp Live community and it has provided a
flat playing field for employee participation. We are able to track international usage through
the network nodes as shown below. Activity in an office that is a node in our infrastructure
such as the Netherlands could represent either activity from an employee in the Netherlands or
in a country that connects to our network through the Netherlands. (See screen shots on PPT
page 14)
The very first employee comment came from an employee based in Singapore.
VPs outside of the US were the first VPs after the SVPs in Marketing (who were
Executive Sponsors for this initiative) to ask for communities to be built:
•NetApp Live UK
39 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
We had a contest asking employees to share their expression of the NetApp brand
called NetApp Champions. Out of the 67 submissions, 42 came from the US, 21 of the
submissions came from our office in Bangalore and 3 came from EMEA. We asked employees
to share creative work in a way that had never been done before at NetApp. There were a total
of 10 poems submitted, 46 photos and 12 employee created videos. Employees also
commented freely on the submissions of their colleagues with a total of 19 video comments on
the videos; 20 comments on poems and; 94 comments on the photos. There were a total of
12,323 page views of contest entries and pages from March 30 to 27 July 2009 when the
contest ended. The grand finalist of this contest will have at least one video posted on YouTube
by NetApp’s Social Media team. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VlqAr9o5pw8 (See screen
shots on PPT page 15) This is an incredible example of employee engagement with brand
leading to an external expression- and our internal community made this possible.
40 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
DIVISION: CORPORATE
CATEGORY: BEHIND THE FIREWALL
ALLYIS
An additional challenge was that the site supported two audiences; client-facing employees
who primarily used the site as a resource for communications and locating information on co-
workers, and the internal support teams who used the site to publish information for employees
and to host their SharePoint based team sites.
—With a widely dispersed workforce, there was a need for a centralized Web-based
location for employees to receive announcements, locate forms, people and knowledge
within the organization. The company wanted to provide a one-stop shop for those
components of the company that employees need to access and connect with.
—The audience is Allyis employees, a geographically dispersed group; some who are
client-facing and working in very different environments and some who are work on
internal support teams and work in the Allyis office or from home.--To solve the
challenges with the Allyis intranet that included inefficient knowledge extraction,
collaboration, and surfacing of colleagues’ knowledge and expertise.
—To solve the challenges with the intranet, Allyis partnered three of their internal
teams, HR/Employee Experience, Project Services, and IT to develop a new solution
that achieved the following goals: build a more stable server environment, create a site
architecture that allowed for future growth, increase information discoverability,
improve communication channels, and support Allyis’ company culture through clear
communications and user generated content. We began by implementing user
41 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
experience interviews to gain a deeper awareness of how Allyis employees currently
engage with the company intranet. The information gathered from these user
experience studies drove many of the proposed site changes. The ability to surface
employee contact information, particularly in a dispersed workforce, surfaced as a key
component, and drove an enhanced Employee Finder tool that allows for employees to
search across the population using a variety of filters. Since many end users are less
familiar with some of the features of out-of-the-box SharePoint functionality, including
Alerts and Bookmarks, a “dashboard” area was integrated to make them more easily
accessible.
SOLUTION/TOOLS USED/RESULTS
—The internal communications team worked to hype the new site and develop
excitement around its launch in advance of the launch date. They unveiled the site in a
brown bag luncheon for employees, showing them some of its features and sparking
their interest in exploring the site. The executive vice president sent a global email out
to all employees to announce the official launch.
The development does not end with the initial deployment. Team sites—areas dedicated to
housing content, discussions, blogs, and other resources around specific teams or projects—are
being developed within the My Allyis environment. This will allow for teams to collaborate
remotely in a secure environment, and eventually allow for a greater personalization of the My
42 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
Allyis experience by allowing team members to surface team-specific content for a more
relevant user experience. And ongoing user testing continues, ensuring that the focus of future
site development is meeting and exceeding the expectations of Allyis’ employee population.
Challenges that we came up against: 1) Delay in receiving hardware ordered to support the
environment in addition to the hardware vendor sending the wrong equipment at first and then
not being available for installation/support for weeks afterward. 2) Balancing billable work
with this large internal project. Billable work is the priority so there were times when this
affected the project timeline and forced the internal team to operate very lean to complete
deliverables. 3) Implementation challenges for features leveraging C# customizations since
they were built from scratch unlike OOB features that have been heavily used in the past and
functionality is familiar. 4) Multiple iterations (more than planned) of graphic design due to the
desire to really land on a user tested look/feel that resonated with the end user. 5) Scope creep
was also a challenge as we ultimately had a large employee base and leadership team that we
were aiming to please, so we had to be very cognizant about managing scope.
Microsoft SharePoint was used both to create the site and project manage the process. The
Allyis team provided end-to-end support, including:
•Project management
•Technical implementation
•We used a 6-phase project approach for this that included the following phases:
1) Envisioning, 2) Planning, 3) Technical & Design Specification, 4) Development &
Build, 5) Implementation & Stabilization, 6) Project Review.
43 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
•Provide high-level project oversight
•Provide guidance and consultative advice to project team and client regarding site
concept, design and functionality
•Work with client users and stakeholders to perform user testing at the onset of project
through field studies
•Work with project manager throughout the lifecycle of the project to ensure that
direction/design fulfill business requirements
•Work with usability lead and project manager in developing visual design concept
•Performance of unit testing and quality assurance testing as site features are completed
•Responsible for resolution for development and application of applicable bug fixes
•90% of Allyis employees have used the My.Allyis.com extranet since launch
—Employees are connecting on blogs: 15% of our employees have created blogs, with 78
posts and 111 comments.
—The results, while in their infancy due to a recent launch, map directly back to Allyis’
objective. The goal is to have employees finding the information they need and finding each
other so that they can effectively extract knowledge, collaborate and serve their clients even
more effectively.
Technology
North America
Karen Dawson
Principal
Dawson Communications Group
24011 SE 281st St., Maple Valley, WA 98038
(425) 442-4931
[email protected]
Rochelle Hill Executive Vice President
Allyis
10210 NE Points Drive, Suite 200, Kirkland, WA 98033
(425) 691-5822
[email protected]
45 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009
DIVISION: GOVERNMENT
CATEGORY: BEHIND THE FIREWALL
DEPARTMENT OF STATE/JWT
Through qualitative and quantitative research (surveys and on-line focus groups), JWT and the
Department learned that current and former Department of State interns often felt disconnected
from the greater Department of State community. To address these findings and the goal
outlined by the Department, JWT recommended creation of a social/professional-networking
platform for the Department’s former, current and future interns.
—JWT was asked to address the problem of the disconnect between Department of
State interns and the greater Department of State community. JWT was asked to
address this problem, in which we found that this generation of students often relies on
social networking platforms such as Facebook and LinkedIn to keep in touch with their
professional and personal contacts.
SOLUTION/TOOLS USED/RESULTS
—JWT proposed the integration of social media into the Department of State’s internal
and external strategy. We wanted to create a platform for the Department Interns
(former, current and future) to engage with one another and Department of State
peers/staff.
—We developed and hosted several on-line focus groups, following a survey
completed by the Department, which sought to identify influential factors in students’
decision to pursue career opportunities elsewhere after their internships with the
Department. The findings indicated that interns wanted to feel more connected to the
Department and its’ employees prior, during and following their internship, thus JWT
INSIDE designed, created and launched an internal social networking platform entitled,
“INTERNational Connections.
Jennifer Perhacs (Account Executive)
Patricia Miller (Senior Copywriter)
Svetlana Raynes (Creative Director/Designer) former employee of JWT
—To date, the site has grown to include over 600 members as we continue to work with key
Department of State personnel to identify strategies and methods to evolve and further grow
this initiative.
Currently we are developing a place on the site for interaction with Diplomats in Residence
(DiRs), who are retired Foreign Service Officers placed at college campuses nationwide, as
well as integration of former interns into the user database.
•Upload personal documents & pictures from intern travels and posts
The objective was to integrate engagement between interns and past/present Department of
State employees. The growing number of members and functionality of the site show the
proven effectiveness of this social networking tool.
Government
North America
http://sncr.org/awards_2008_uploads/102-SNCR Award Submission 2009.doc
Megan McGovern
Creative Services Freelance JWT INSIDE
2425 Olympic Blvd Suite 2200-W Santa Monica, CA 90404
(310) 309-8297
[email protected]
Olga Zimonjic Account Supervisor
JWT INSIDE
607 14th Street, NW Suite 300 Washington, DC 20005
202-628-2076 x 110
[email protected]
47 | P a g e (c) Copyright SNCR Press 2009