Topic: Fatalism and Its Impact On Two Victorian Novels:: Great Expectations and Wuthering Heights
Topic: Fatalism and Its Impact On Two Victorian Novels:: Great Expectations and Wuthering Heights
Topic: Fatalism and Its Impact On Two Victorian Novels:: Great Expectations and Wuthering Heights
Submitted By:
Fahim Al Kawser
ID: ENG 052-06-940
Session: Summer 2013
Submitted For:
Sharmin Siddique
Assistant Professor
Department of English
Disclaimer
The work contained in this dissertation has not been previously submitted to meet requirements
for an award at this or any other higher education institution. To the best of my knowledge and
belief, the thesis contains no material previously published or written by another person except
Name: ………………………………………….
Signature: ………………………………………….
Signature: ………………………………………….
3
Acknowledgement
paper with good and sound health. I am thankful to have the blessing of my parents who always
guided me with love and also fortunate enough to have such a supportive parents.
I would like to acknowledge to my honorable supervisor Ms. Sharmin Siddique. She provided
Finally, I would like to thank all of those who have directly or indirectly help me in any respect
Abstract
Fatalism refers to a philosophy which expresses human being is bound to fate; whatever he or
she may try to do, however the effort is, fate or someone beyond the control of human beings and
everything will decide the outcome of the effort. In Great Expectations and Wuthering Heights
most of the major characters are affected by the cruelty of fatalism as they tried to be proved in
this paper that the major characters were just helpless to nature. Thomas Hardy can be
considered a great advocate of fatalism and he portrayed the philosophy in his major works like
Tess of the D’Urbervilles where the helplessness of Tess is depicted though she took all the
conscious and possible steps to be saved from the cruelty of her fate. In the lives of major
characters of Great Expectations and Wuthering Heights the helplessness of them is portrayed.
Some critics may try to blame themselves as the main personalities who triggered their
destruction but this paper will try to prove that they made their best efforts which was possible
for them but fate did not allow them what they wanted.
Table of Contents
Disclaimer………………………………………………………………………. 02
Acknowledgement………….……………………….…………………………. 03
Abstract………………………….……………………………………………... 04
Table of Contents……………………………………………………………….. 05
Chapter 1: Introduction…................................................................………….. 06
Background…………………………..………………………………………... 07
Definition of Fatalism…………………………………………………………. 08
Hardy’s Fatalism………………………………………………………………... 09
Chapter 3: Methodology………………………………………………………. 12
Qualitative Research……………………………………………………………. 13
Quantitative Research…………………………………………………………. 15
Chapter 5 : Conclusion……………….……………………………………….. 23
Chapter 1
Introduction
Fate is the ultimate truth of our life. Fate plays an important role to play in our life. Fate
is the thing which occurs accidentally, which is happening not out of our carefulness, not out of
our willingness, but is just situational. No one can change one’s destiny. What is destined is
going to happen, whether it is good or bad, we have to go through it. However, the choice is
Each historical period features a different treatment to represent the role of fate in
peoples’ life. For example, for the Greeks and Romans, man is predestined to lead either a good
life or a bad life, no matter how hard he tries to change his fate. These people blindly believe in
fate. In The Middle Ages, however, fate takes a different form. Fate of people is controlled by
the church. In the Renaissance, man is the architect of his life. Man can be either happy or sad on
account of his actions and behavior. In the Victorian Age, society plays the role of fate. In the
Modern Age, man's fate is his own and no one or nothing can be blamed for man's fall down but
man himself.
In the 19th century literature, Fate plays an important role in the novels. In both the
novels Great Expectations and Wuthering Heights fate has lots of effects on the life of the
characters. Charles Dickens and Emily Bronte represent the theme of fate very effectively in
these novels. Fate plays a dominant role which controls all the incidents, activities of the
characters in the Victorian novels Great Expectaions and Wuthering Heights. The article intends
Background
In Great Expectations Pip was from a lower class family where his fatherly figure,
brother-in-law Joe used to nourish him. Suddenly Pip dreamed to be a gentleman and he passed a
long time as a gentleman. Later he returned to his nearly old condition. Magwitch in his life
made some big deeds which were wrong, he glorified his life by helping Pip to be a gentleman.
Estella started a life about which she was totally unaware and she could judge the previous life
later. Miss Havisham, Joe, Biddy, Compeyson they all went through different sorts of path
through their life. Wuthering Heights introduce a different picture but quite similar to the picture
of Great Expectations Heathcliff an orphan boy came from a background which is unknown.
Mr.Eranshaw raise him like his own child. Through different abusive treatment made him reach
to the peak of worldly torment. Then the humiliation and rejection from Catherine made him
leave Wuthering Heights. Till the last moment of his life the torment did not let him alone but, he
did not let anyone who was responsible for his pain or who was related to the heart of those
people. At last, Heathcliff became rich but, he was more empty then previous time. Hindley,
Hareton, Edgar, Catherine, Isbella; everyone was destroyed in different way with different
unfulfilled expectations, but Nelly Dean could not help herself without just being a watcher. No
one could settle their lives with their own will, rather they moved with will of someone else
beyond them.
8
Chapter 2
Literature Review
Human being takes steps in various actions in life. Sometimes it occurs as he or she
planned, sometimes it is partially similar and sometimes it is not favourable at all. What a man
will do in future or will be in a man's life is determined by the fact which is beyond human
control. This fact cannot be denied. This helplessness faces human being though all sorts of
efforts are taken. This matter of Fatalism which explains human being is helpless to fate or some
Definitions of Fatalism:
“Fatalism is the view that whatever is going to happen, is going to happen, no matter
what we do. Determinism alone does not imply such a consequence. What we decide and what
we do would make a difference in how things turn out -- often an enormous difference-- even if
As reported in Cliff notes “Fatalism being that view of life which says that all action is
controlled by the nature of things or by fate which is a great, impersonal, primitive force existing
through all eternity, absolutely independent of human wills and superior to any god created by
man” (Force,1966,p.8)
9
Merriam-Webster Dictionary states about Fatalism that “a doctrine that events are fixed in
advance so that human beings are powerless to change them; also : a belief in or attitude
determined by this doctrine fatalism that regards social problems as simply inevitable”(Merriam-
It is defined in Oxford Learners Dictionary as “the belief that events are decided by fate and that
you cannot control them; the fact of accepting that you cannot prevent something from
Hardy's Fatalism:
Fatalism is the philosophy which explains that whatever a human tries to do he or she can
never change anything if the fate does not favor him or her. Here human being is powerless.
Hardy had a deep emotional attachment to the ancient civilization and hated industrial
civilization because he thought that the people had been destructed by industrial civilization.
Hardy lived in a time when United Kingdom was running a free capitalism over the period of
imperialism. During that event many farmers became in occupation because of free capitalism in
the society. Hardy saw how the capitalist invaded the rural areas and how farmers became
bankrupts. So, he gave all the blame to destiny for that. After seeing all these events it can be
said that Hardy’s social conditions are limited by his fate. Hardy could save the ancient
civilization if the fate favored him. Nothing can be done as something is beyond our control.
Fatalism may take the view that, if all our actions are dominated by forces beyond our control,
Hardy had a philosophy that we are limited by destiny or fate and used to blame the
destiny or fate in various places in his writings. In his work Tess of the D'Urbervilles, he
explained the matter of destructive destiny 'Justice' was done, and the president of the Immortals,
Æschylean phrase, had ended his sport with Tess ”. He blamed the fate for her unexpected
tragedy of whole life. In this novel Tess was presented 'a pure woman' and Hardy portrayed her
in such way that she was just innocent and she did not do anything wrong rather destiny played
with her such way that she could not save herself from the misery.
Though Great Expectations and Wuthering Heights were written by different novelists
other than Hardy, the philosophy of Hardy's fatalism is reflected in the same way. In Great
Expectations Pip, Estella, Miss Havisham had their own background which made them to suffer
and be motivated to the way they choose. But, they had to stop though various ways like physical
disability, economic or mental or situation disability which made them to denounce their own
ways. On the other hand, Magwitch tried to escape the whole way to be saved from something,
but he met the same thing which he was running from. Compeyson, Mr and Mrs Joe, Biddy they
all had to move according to will of the power which was in charge of controlling the situation.
In Wuthering Heights, various characters took steps to according to their own will and plan. But,
most of them failed and they had no way to get out of their sufferings. Heathcliff was an orphan
boy who was tortured from the beginning severely, later started to take revenge on Hindley,
Hareton, Catherine, Isabella, Edgar and Nelly was just like a pillar though she had many wishes
to save them. Every single action was controlled by someone or something who or what was
beyond them.
This paper is going to discuss about the fatalism of Thomas Hardy and the reflection of
the fatalism in novels like Greats Expectations and Wuthering Heights. The idea of being
11
helpless in accordance with Hardy's fatalism is reflected there in almost all the main characters.
In this paper these main characters like Pip, Estella, Miss Havisham, Magwitch, Compeyson, Mr.
Joe and Biddy from Great Expectations and Heathcliff, Mr. Earnshaw, Catherine and her
daughter Catherine, Hindley, Hareton, Edgar, Isabella, Nelly are the characters who are from
Wuthering Heights. Hardy's fatalism is going to be reflected and proved through the characters in
Chapter 3
Methodology
I am using methodology and in the methods section have described the rationale for the
application of specific procedures or techniques used to identify, select, and analyze information
applied to understanding the research problem, thereby, allowing the reader to critically evaluate
a study’s overall validity and reliability. The writing I used was direct and precise and everything
was written in the past tense. From the famous writer Kallet, Richard H. "How to Write the
Importance of a Good Methodology Section I must explain how I obtained and analyzed his
results for the following reasons. In my methodology you need to know how the data was
obtained because the method I choose affects the findings and, by extension, how i likely
interpreted them. Methodology is crucial for any branch of scholarship because an unreliable
interpretations of the findings. In most cases, there are a variety of different methods I could
articulates the reasons why I choose a particular procedure or technique. The method had be
appropriate to fulfilling the overall aims of my study. For example, I need to ensure that I have a
large enough sample size to be able to generalize and make recommendations based upon the
findings. I gave importance to provide sufficient information to allow other researchers to adopt
or explicate my methodology. This information is particularly important when a new method has
about both the ways in which the research is carried out its structure and process, as well as with
Qualitative Research is concerned with opinions, feelings and experiences describes social
phenomena as they occur naturally - no attempt is made to manipulate the situation - just
rather than looking at a set of variables qualitative research data is used to help us to develop
concepts and theories that help us to understand the social world - which is an inductive
approach to the development of theory, rather than a deductive approach that quantitative
research takes - i.e. Testing theories that have already been proposed. Qualitative data is
collected through direct encounters i.e. through interview or observation and is rather time
consuming.
1. Unstructured: The interviewer may frame the interview questions based on the
interviewee and his/her previous response. This allows the discussion to cover areas in
great detail. They involve the researcher wanting to know or find out more about a
14
encourage the interviewee if they are looking for more information or find what they are
saying interesting. This method gives the researcher the freedom to probe the interviewee
saying. Work best when the interviewed has a number of areas he/she wants to be sure to
be addressing.
3. Structured: The interviewed asks the respondent the same questions in the same way. A
tightly structured schedule is used. The questions may be phrased in order that a limited
range of responses may be given - i.e. 'Do you rate our services as very good, good or
more appropriate.
B. Observation: Observation involves may take place in natural settings and involve the
researcher taking lengthy and descriptive notes of what is happening. It is argued that there are
limits to the situations that can be observed in their 'natural' settings and that the presence of the
study written by a person who was part of the study. The methods vary on how
15
researchers run an experiment or study, but it typically follows the scientific method. One
way you can think of primary research is that it is typically original research.
research that is relevant to a writing topic and interpret what the primary research found.
For instance, secondary research often takes the form of the results from two or more
primary research articles and explains what the two separate findings are telling us. Or,
the author may have a specific topic to write about and will find many pieces of primary
research and use them as information in their next article or textbook chapter.
Quantitative research is used to quantify the problem by way of generating numerical data or
data that can be transformed into usable statistics. It is used to quantify attitudes, opinions,
behaviors, and other defined variables and generalize results from a larger sample population.
Quantitative Research uses measurable data to formulate facts and uncover patterns in research.
Quantitative data collection methods are much more structured than Qualitative data collection
methods. Quantitative data collection methods include various forms of surveys – online surveys,
paper surveys, mobile surveys and kiosk surveys, face-to-face interviews, telephone interviews,
longitudinal studies, website interceptors, online polls, and systematic observations. Used to find
out how much, how many, how often, to what extent. Aims to be objective and scientific in its
theories. Aims to assess and measure. Is regarded as a way to get to the truth, to understand the
16
world well enough so that we might predict and control it through identifying cause and effect
In this research, I have used qualitative method. It is a secondary data collection process.
The sources of secondary data collection process were publications, research studies and
journals. My literature review also includes my own opinion, feelings and social phenomenon.
However there are certain limitations in my research. Many readers may differ and say that
fatalism did not dominate the fate of characters of the novel, Great Expectations and Wuthering
Heights. Even before my research many other researchers have explained about the role of fate in
Greek tragedies and various works in general. I however have specifically focused on the
fatalism in Great Expectaions by Charles Dickens and Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte.
17
Chapter 4
Pip ,an orphan boy lived with his sister and brother –in-law in a village .Staying near the
tombstone he met with a escaped convict grab him and asked him for food and file to protect his
leg .Pip helps him taking the blame of theft on his shoulders. Later, in his regular days of life he
got a chance to visit Satis House, Miss Havisham was the owner of it .He met with Estella and a
hope to get her rose in his mind and he wished to be a gentleman. Unfortunately, he got a chance
to stay there as a laborer and he was informed later that he was given a large fortune and it was
from a secret benefactor. He thought the benefactor was Miss Havisham who did it to marry him
with Estella. He began to develop himself as a gentleman in London and he met again with the
former man who was the escaped convict and he revealed the truth that he was the secret
benefactor of his fortune. Pip also became grateful to him as well as considered he has an
obligation to Magwitch the benefactor. One day he helped Magwitch to escape while police and
Compeyon, the criminal and betrayer who made suffer Miss Havisham. That day Compeyson
died but, Magwitch was caught by police and he was sentenced to death and Pip lost his fortune.
He returned to his village where Joe, his brother-in-low marred to Biddy and he began to live
there .Before the event Miss Havisham was severely afflicted by fireplace and she begged
pardon from Pip .Estella also married to someone else. When Pip began to live with his brother-
in-low suddenly he decided to work in other city and he left the village .One day he met Estella
18
in a barren garden in Satis House where he found a new Estella who went through a
metamorphosis. He and Estella left the garden holding hands of each other. (Sparknotes)
Pip was taken to Satis House to fulfill the plot of revenge of Miss Havisham. Miss Havisham did
not possess an evil heart. But the betrayal of Compeyson made her a different Havisham. She
decided to break the hearts of many men. For this reason she raised Estella as her tool break the
hearts. She was quite successful in developing the mind set of Estella. She began to use her to
play with the heart of Pip. On the other hand, Pip was in hope to be raised as a gentleman and
marry Estella. Moreover he began to take his lessons on the matter and was developing himself.
Once Miss Havisham got her previous rational mind after she got burnt beside fireplace. Estella
was married to someone else. Miss Havisham begged pardon from Pip. .In her last days she
repented about what she did with Pip and Estella. Miss Havisham expressed her helplessness to
“So unchanging was the dull old house, the yellow light in the darkened room, the faded
specter in the chair by the dressing-table glass, that I felt as if the stopping of the clocks
had stopped Time in that mysterious place, and, while I and everything else outside it
Miss Havisham died. Pip had no hope to get Estella, however he lost his fortune. He did remorse
saying that
“I did really cry in good earnest when I went to bed, to think that my expectations had
Furthermore, he had failed to marry Biddy as she was married to Joe. Pip and Estella started their
journey together which was unexpected for both of them thought they were pleased with that.
19
Miss Havisham took every single attempt to fulfill her purpose through Pip and Estella when she
had the physical ability. At last that happened about which they lose their hope and they did not
When the novel started Magwitch was trying to survive; he tried to escape death. He was
saved by Pip at first. Later, he expressed his gratitude through giving the fortune to Pip. For the
obligation from heart Pip helped Magwitch to escape again. Unfortunately Magwitch was caught
by police which resulted the sentence of death of him. From beginning of the novel to the end
Magwitch tried to survive, to escape death but he could not escape the exact same death he was
running from.
Compeyson did a crime along with Magwitch. He betrayed him by throwing Magwitch in
a trap of death. On the contrary, he betrayed Miss Havisham by not marrying her which resulted
the ruin of her heart as well as her rationality. Afterwards, he lure the police behind Magwitch.
But he died. He was plotting against Magwitch later the plot became his own trap of death which
Orlick was working in the forge of Joe. His evil nature made him to harm the wife of his
master. Orlick did not hope to get a job in Satis House, but he got. After taking attempts to kill
Pip and making harassment to Biddy he survived though he was sent to jail later. After doing
such crimes he was not captured in jail, but at last could not save himself.
Orphan boy Heathcliff was taken to be raised in Wuthering Heights. Mr. Earnshaw
accepted him as own son, even his compassion increased more after the death of his wife.
20
Catherine developed a very good relationship with him, however Hindley could not tolerate him
at all neither he let him keep away from his physical and psychological torment. Mr. Earnshaw
did not have any way to save Heathcliff without sending Hindley to college and he did so. After
the death of Mr. Earnshaw, Hindley and Frances, his wife got the ownership of Wuthering
Heights and Hindley began to take revenge of previous rage and it became more severe after the
death of Frances. Heathcliff left Wuthering Heights for the words of Catherine which humiliated
him in the matter of marrying Edgar. Three years passed and Heathcliff returned with a largest
amount of wealth but no one knows the source of it. Heathcliff started to entrap everyone except
Catherine. He used the policy to make Hindley bankrupt and gained the ownership of Wuthering
Heights. He began intense torture upon Hareton, son of Hindley and trapped Catherine, daughter
of Catherine and Edgar where he did not hesitate to use his own son as a toll of the plot. Later his
son died and he began to be ill with the memories of Catherine and he used to talk with the spirit
to Catherine. The whole story was described by Nelly to Lockwood who came to visit
Thrashcross Grange and noted the story in his notebook. Later Heathcliff died and Lockwood
Heathcliff was an orphan boy who had no chance to get fatherly love from anyone so easily as he
got from Mr. Earnshaw. Mr. Earnshaw loved him too much from the beginning, on the contrary
Catherine and Hindley did not accepted him though Catherine accepted him later. Mr. Earnshaw
loved Heathcliff in such a way that he sent his own son Hindley to college to save Heathcliff
from the severe torture to him. It was really something unexpected for Heathcliff to have such
support from Mr. Earnshaw. Even the death of Mrs. Earnshaw triggered the compassion of Mr.
Earnshaw to Heathcliff.
21
Catherine began to be raised with Heathcliff and they became inseparable. Catherine did not
accept Heathcliff as her beloved neither she thought to marry him. In the mindset of Catherine,
Heathcliff was the orphan boy when she was talking with Nelly about Edgar, she knew that she
herself as Heathcliff, on the other hand she was not ready to marry him which was expressed as
she told that she did not want to lower herself by marrying Heathcliff.
“It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff now; so he shall never know how I love him:
and that, not because he's handsome, Nelly, but because he's more myself than I am.
Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same; and Linton's is as different as
She was not ready to love him but she unwilling loved Healthcliff as her own existence. When
Heathcliff returned, Catherine felt the intense pain of depriving herself from the presence of
Heathcliff. Though she was not ready to accept Heathcliff as her husband and not as her beloved,
it was out of her control to stop the love she had for him.
When Hindley returned with Frances, his wife after the death of his father, he took attempts to
take the revenge on Heathcliff. Still the death of Frances, he continued the oppression on
Heathcliff as the owner of Wuthering Heights. After the death of Frances, Hindley began
drinking and the torture upon Heathcliff became more severe as Heathcliff had to work in the
fields as a laborer. When Heathcliff returned, he lent money to Hindley which resulted the
bankruptcy of him and leaded the fortune to Heathcliff. Hindley died and the new owner of
22
Wuthering Heights, Heathcliff started torment on Hareton, the son of Hindley. Hindley tried his
best to torture Heathcliff from the beginning till end. But he was unable to save his progeny from
Heathcliff torture. On the other hand, Heathcliff took all attempts to entrap Hareton and junior
Catherine even he did not let his own son to be a part of the plot. After all, the ownership went to
Edgar as well as Isabella experienced the lovely side of life before their marriage. Though they
were possessing the innocent sort of mindset but their fate made their life to turn in such a
terrible way what they never imagined. Getting the chance of nourishing the children of
Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange, Nelly tried to advise them to keep away from the
disasters, but she could not save them nor change anything. Fate did not allow her to be a witness
Approval of Fatalism:
Fatalism refers to the view which prompts that all the actions are controlled by a superior
existence; nature or fate who or which is independent from human wills. In both Great
Expectations and Wuthering Heights the reflection of fatalism is prominent. Pip, Estella, Miss
Hindley, Hareton, Edgar, Nelly, Isabella all of them were victims of fate. They tried to make
their life and go on through the path of life in their own ways. But, they had to bow down before
will of someone or something who or which is beyond them. At last they had to compromise
their will with the supreme. With these evidences this paper is going to approve the reflection of
Chapter 5
Conclusion
In the way of life we wish to get many things. We make various sorts of efforts.
Sometimes we get what we wished or worked for, sometimes we do not get the chance of
drawing near the thing. Sometimes the thing comes to us without any efforts rather just wish is
enough for it. Something or someone controls the matter of our life which is reflected in Great
Expectations and Wuthering Heights as well. This is the reflection of fatalism. Fatalism reveals
his various colors of face in various lives. Someone may find the matter so favourable to him,
someone gets the cruelty. Like the lives of major characters of these novels, fatalism is faced by
Works Cited
"What Is Fatalism? How Does It Differ from Determinism?" Maverick Philosopher. N.p.,
n.d.
2017.<http://maverickphilosopher.typepad.com/maverick_philosopher/2011/11/what-is-
fatalism-how-does-it-differ-from-determinism.html>
Dickens, Charles. Great Expectaions. Dhaka: Friends Book Corner, n.d. Print.